Project Narrative

City of Glendale — Regular Meeting (2021-12-09)

View PDF Item b Meeting page

Extracted text (via pymupdf) 27225 characters
1 
 
CITIZEN’S PARTICIPATION PLAN FOR 
“Villas at 45th” 
 
 
Located in Glendale, Arizona. 
  
 
 
 
 
 
Prepared By: 
 
 
BFH GROUP, LLC 
3707 E. Southern Avenue 
Glendale, AZ  85206 
 
Ph:  480.734.1446 
 
Email: davidb@thebfhgroup.com 
Attn: David M. Bohn, P.E.  
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
SR21-0060 
 
 
November 16,
2021.

2 
 
CITIZEN’S PARTICIPATION PLAN 
FOR “VILLAS AT 45TH” 
 
TABLE OF CONTENTS                                                               PAGE 
 
1. PURPOSE OF REQUEST  
 
 
 
 
1 
2. FINDINGS FOR VARIANCE 
 
 
 
 
1 
3. NOTIFICATION FOR PROCEDURE 
 
 
 
6 
4. AFFECTED PARTIES 
 
 
 
 
 
6 
5. CITIZEN PARTICIPATION SCHEDULE 
 
 
 
7 
 
 
APPENDIX A: ATTACHMENTS 
PARCEL MAP 
DEED 
FLOOR PLAN 
SITE PLAN 
NOTIFICATION LETTER 
NOTIFICATION AREA MAP 
NOTIFICATION LIST 
ZOOM MEETING NOTES 
FINAL SUMMARY AND REPORT

3 
 
1. PURPOSE OF REQUEST 
BFH Group is delighted to present to the City of Glendale this application with corresponding 
narrative and exhibits for variance review and approval. Per request by the applicant, the 
purpose of the narrative is to request for a variance to the current setback requirement for the 
City of Glendale Overlay District from 30’ to 5’ on the proposed 3.01-acre townhome-style 
residential development located at 7127 N 45th Avenue, Glendale, AZ 85301, more specifically 
APN: 147-08-003, -009B. The proposed development is intended to be 60 townhome style units 
with a proposed gross density of 19.93 du/ac. It is intended by the developer that these units 
will be for rent under one ownership.  The property is not intended to be platted, but the two 
parcels shall be combined to one. 
2. BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT FINDINGS FOR VARIANCE. 
As shown in the above standards table, the developer is respectfully requesting as part of this 
variance request solely a reduction to the perimeter setbacks from 30’ to 5’.  Considering the 
parcel dimensions, constraints of the surrounding area and in-fill nature of the site, and the 
standards and guidelines constituted in the City of Glendale Municipal Code Development 
Standards, it is a challenge to make the City of Glendale Centerline Overlay setbacks function for 
development.   
Several factors affect this parcel and thus require the need for variance from this standard.   
1. There are special circumstances or conditions applicable to the property including its 
size, shape, topography, location, or surroundings which were not self-imposed by the 
owner:  The main challenge is the parcels’ shape being very long and narrow.  At the 
narrowest section, the property is approximately 132’.  When implementing a 30’ 
setback in this area (on both the north (30’ BSL) and south side (30’ BSL) = 60 ft total 
lost) on this portion, it would take away nearly half of the developable section of land.   
Overall, the area outside of the perimeter building setbacks which structures may be 
place would be reduced by nearly 40%.   When bearing in mind that this site is only 
approximately 3 acres total, this translates to over an acre of space that cannot be used 
for residential development. 
Also, it is important to highlight the infill nature of this property where all parcels 
adjacent have been fully developed.  This limits or eliminates the ability of the 
developer to coordinate future efforts with adjacent land owners, get more creative 
with his circulation plan internally, or propose many viable solutions when there’s

4 
 
limited available space.  Unfortunately, there was no planning on any of the adjacent 
developments to take into consideration the future improvements of the subject 
property.    
2. Due to the special circumstances, the strict application of the Zoning Ordinance would 
deprive the property of privileges enjoyed by other properties in the same classification 
in same zoning district:  Due to the special circumstances illustrated above which 
include, but are not limited to, the property’s size, shape, location / surroundings, none 
of which were imposed by the owner, the property is now significantly deprived of 
privileges that the City of Glendale Centerline Overlay District was envisioned to 
provide: 
The Glendale Centerline will become a vibrant, premiere location of choice for 
progressive private development, which encourages a diverse mix of retail, office, 
mixed-use, and residential projects. The Centerline area will maintain its hometown 
ambiance and character and will strive to be a clean, safe, well maintained pedestrian 
area that takes pride in its history and historic landmarks. 
Specifically, the Midtown District development concept includes: 
The character would be moderate intensity, with a floor area ratio of 2.0, and density up 
to 50 dwelling units per acre. Buildings would be up to six stories (70 feet), stair-
stepped back in height from the “set to line” (property line) 43rd and Glendale avenues. 
A maximum FAR (Floor Area Ratio) of 4.0 can be achieved through performance 
incentives given for the following amenities; public art, open space, Leadership in Energy 
and Environmental Design (LEED) certified buildings, and shared parking at the rate of 
.50 additional FAR for each amenity Glendale Centerline Overlay District June 14, 2011 
Page 4 provided.  The district has no setback requirements, except adjacent to 
residential zoning districts and residential uses. 
The intent of the residential developments within the Midtown District would be to 
allow for structures up to 6 stories and a maximum density of 50 units to the acre.  
When considering the location of this property which is adjacent to only two story 
buildings (maximum), to propose the allowable 6 stories and 50 du/ac would not appear 
to be as congruent to the area as the currently proposed Villas at 45th development of 
(60) two story townhomes.  It should also be noted that the Overlay District standard 
allows for zero building setbacks throughout, except for when adjacent to residential

5 
 
development (30 ft setback current standard), which appears to be inconsistent to the 
intent of the Centerline Overlay vision and goals for this area. 
3. The variance is the minimum necessary to alleviate the property hardship:  This variance 
is the only standard the developer is requesting deviation.  As demonstrated previously 
in the standards table, if granted this variance, the proposed development is offering an 
increase in not only the private open space from 100 SF to 120 SF, but also an increase 
in the overall open space, which based on this plan, would be close to double the 
required open space.  The increase in private and common open space will absolutely 
have a positive impact on not only the residents that occupy the units, but also will 
improve the ambience of the existing neighborhood.  Although a small development, 
Villas at 45th will be considered an innovative implementation of residential 
development within the Centerline Overlay District.  
4. Granting the variance will not have a detrimental effect on the property, adjoining 
property, the surrounding neighborhood, or the City in general:  It is important to discuss 
the current state of the property, which has been vacant land for well over 20 years 
allowing for transients, trash / debris dumping, and potentially dangerous circumstances 
and situations for local residents.  Property values in the area are hurt by leaving this 
land vacant.   As mentioned in this narrative, the property cannot be developed 
adequately under the current zoning R1-6, but when granted this minor variance under 
the Centerline Overlay District, it can be a thriving, sought-out community that will 
improve the surrounding area and City not only aesthetically, but also economically.   
The townhome product type will bring a fresh and modern look to the area, which 
would personify the intent of the Centerline Overlay District.  The variance will not 
negatively impact the surrounding community or the City, but it is believed that it will 
actually do quite the opposite. 
 
Finally, the circumstances applicable to this variance are not self-imposed by the owner, but 
they were inherited.  This is a very challenging site to develop considering the shape, size and 
infill nature.  This hardship has not been intentionally, knowingly, or recklessly created by the 
owner.  The owner has considered several alternatives in lieu of this variance and has found the 
proposed development to be the most beneficial to the City.  The setback constraints make 
other townhome-style product developments extremely ineffective and dysfunctional due to

6 
 
not only inefficient circulation, but also for parking requirements and inadequate usable open 
space.   Another option considered was apartments, however in order to comply with the 
standards, that proposed site plan transformed into a large parking lot, minimal open space for 
the residents, and a lesser-desired home environment.  The proposed townhome plan 
associated with this variance is far superior on many levels and will improve the neighborhood 
as well as the Midtown area. 
3. NOTIFICATION AND PROCEDURE 
BFH Group intends to follow the notification procedure outlined by the City of Glendale variance 
process.  All variance documents shall be submitted to the assigned City of Glendale planning 
staff.  Per this Citizen’s Participation Plan and upon administrative approval from City of 
Glendale planning staff, BFH Group will notify all property owners within 300’ of the subject 
property of the intention to propose a variance to the perimeter setback requirement.  A 
neighborhood meeting will be held (on Zoom) that will allow adjacent residents and other 
interested parties the opportunity to ask questions and provide opinions on what the proposed 
variance will be.  BFH Group will consolidate this correspondence as well as any other 
communication received and prepare a final report summarizing the community’s inputs.  This 
will be delivered to the corresponding planning staff for review and ultimately to the Board of 
Adjustment for review and approval. 
Attached in this appendix are all pertinent documents and notification forms as required by this 
variance and Citizen Participation Plan. 
 
4. AFFECTED PARTIES QUESTIONS AND COMMUNICATION 
It is understood by the applicant that there is potential for members of the surrounding 
neighborhood as well as other “interested parties” that may be concerned about an adverse 
effect that modifying the setback minimum would create.  One of the concerns the applicant 
anticipates were he an adjacent property owner could be that reducing the setbacks would 
place the townhome units too close to the property line, allowing new residents to see into the 
backyards of the existing homes.  This would impact only three homes along the north side of 
the property.  All other existing developments adjacent to the site are apartments or 
townhomes along the east and the south and the structures are an additional 24 feet from the 
property line allowing ample distance.

7 
 
The developer anticipates potential for concerns and welcomes the questions that the 
neighbors would have.  Individuals affected by this variance would have the ability to call or 
email the applicant directly as well as have the opportunity to share during the neighborhood 
meeting.  The applicant would be happy to meet with them on an individual basis or continue 
the conversation over the phone or email.  If there are any significant changes to the Site Plan, 
the applicant is willing to have another neighborhood meeting as necessary to ensure all 
concerns and suggestions have been considered and/or addressed. 
Correspondence with interested individuals will be documented in the final report and any 
concerns will be relayed to the Planning department staff member overseeing the variance 
process. 
 
5. CITIZEN PARTICIPATION PLAN SCHEDULE 
Below is an anticipated approximate schedule for the Citizen’s Participation Plan: 
 
a. Citizen Participation Plan (CPP) Submittal  
 
09/23/2021 
b. CPP Implementation Date 
 
 
 
10/06/2021 
c. Time allocated for Citizen inputs 
 
 
11/03/2021 
d. Final CPP Submittal Date 
 
 
 
11/17/2021 
 
 
Your consideration in this matter is very much appreciated and we look forward to continuing a 
successful development.

8 
 
 
 
 
APPENDIX A 
PARCEL MAP 
DEED 
FLOOR PLAN 
SITE PLAN 
NOTIFICATION LETTER 
NOTIFICATION AREA MAP 
NOTIFICATION LIST 
ZOOM MEETING NOTES 
FINAL SUMMARY AND REPORT

	


		





 
!"#
$ % $
##%
 
%
$%&
' '
()*
 
!"#
 %
+# %
!$
#,%
#
$
(-*
!"#
 '
 
 $!
#',%
).
!"#
 
 %
+# %
!$
 #%
$% &
(-
 
!"#
 %
+# %
!$
$ % $
##%
 
%
/0112342546758
905:4;<4=1>?@21>

	

	














 
!"
#$%&
'()"
*+,
'-).)-
#,,.
)"#
.(
-./
!0)""0
#$123
')"
*+,
').#
4,).#
*#"-
,5.
,!
"-
#$163
'*+,
#)0
)"
')""-*
,05."
#$27
'*+,
)"
').#
4,).#
*#"-
)",.
-.)/
#$16&
')"
*+,
').#
4,).#
*#"-
'-).)-
#,,.
)"#
.(
89::;<=;>=?@>A
B9>C=DE=F:GHI;:G

	
	

















 !"#
$%&
'()
$*&+&*
 ))+
& 
+%
*+,
-&-
 !./0
$&
'()
$&+ 
1)&+ 
' *
)2+
)
*
 !.30
$'()
 &-
&
$&*'
)-2+
 !/4
$'()
&
$&+ 
1)&+ 
' *
&)+
*+&,
 !.3#
$&
'()
$&+ 
1)&+ 
' *
$*&+&*
 ))+
& 
+%
567789:8;:<=;>
?6;@:AB:C7DEF87D

	

	




 !""#$%&#'( #)' *
++++,++-+
.
/0112345617
8494542:3;<=
/4213=><5
?@A
>1B156
84>></3<23CD20
15B4511A
6181>@=1A
E.FE353CD203<81GH3B>156<>1H3<A4I@5<H3JDKL.
M</4/3@?3M1<A45B
M1590;<AN
N1:3;<=
=A@O192361/9A4=24@5
>1B<>361/9A4=24@5
/4213/P;;<A:
LLFLFL.LLQL


	



	




 
	


	


	


	





	

 

	
	



	


 

	



	

 






	

 !

"	








#
# $ #

 #%#

&&##"
 !

"
# #"
	"

'%
'&(%%!
)&!
&&!
&&!
(!
)	&!

	

!
	
 !
*

!
*
	
	

&&%!
*
!
!
	

 ++&


"

 ++

,-


"

 ++


,
,

"

 ++
-
.
'


 ++$




 ++

/
'


 ++&
	


"'
'
'
&(%%!
)&!
(!
)	
&&!
&(%%!
)!
(!
)	
!
&(%!
%)!
 !

	
"'

	

	

	

	

	

	

	

	
	
	
	
	
	




!
!
!
!
%%!
%!
	
!
%!
*
&!
*
!
*
!
*
%!
!
*
%!
%!
%!
 !
*
%!
%!
$
"










!
%!
*
!
!
!






!
!



&



&
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
%!
!
!
%!
	
%!
	
%!
	
%!
%!
!
%%!
%!
!
!


 !
 !






&&!





 '

#
"
""
	

' !
"$
&(&!
)	"$
%&!
"$
.




"


	


 !
"$
(!
)	"$


%%&!
"$!
 
'.






01213456736897:4;<35=4<94
>:8<4?3@A2B10@BC@@D

E465F35;GH8<5F3AIJ2D

'
&





KLLM
NOPQL

September 21, 2021 
 
BFH GROUP 
3707 E. Southern Avenue 
Mesa, AZ  85206 
davidb@thebfhgroup.com 
 
Subject:  Setback Variance Application for Villas at 45th 
 
Dear Neighbor: 
 
This letter is to inform you that I am applying for a Variance application with the City of 
Glendale.  The property is located at 7127 N. 45th Avenue in the Cactus District. 
 
The development will include 60 new modern townhome-style residences at this location.  
Each unit will be approximately 1250 square feet (3) bedrooms and (2) bathrooms. The 
property has been vacant land for well over 20 years and sits within existing residential 
homes, apartments and townhomes adjacent to it. The developer is employing the City 
of Glendale Centerline Overlay “Midtown District” and is requesting a slight variance for 
the perimeter setbacks from 30’ to 5’.  Considering the location, lot size, and shape it is 
imperative to reduce the setback to allow development of these parcels. 
 
I have included a site plan with this letter for your review.  A neighborhood meeting will 
take place (date, time, on zoom).  Comments and questions will be accepted at this time.  
If you are unable to attend, please write, email, or call me at the contact information 
above.  You may also contact Edward Vigil  with the City of Glendale at (623) 930-3071.   
 
Sincerely, 
 
 
David Bohn 
 
Encl: Site Plan 
 
Aerial Map

NOTIFICATION AREA MAP

PROPERTY OWNERS
Mailing Address
CITY
STATE
ZIP
MAR-MHP-ROYAL GLEN LLC
PO BOX 27671 SCORRSDALE AZ 85255
SCORRSDALE
AZ
85255
RIMULA FRANK ANTHONY JR
4442 W MYRTLE AVE GLENDALE AZ 85301
GLENDALE
AZ
85301
REED RONALD B/STELLA M
4436 W MYRTLE AVE GLENDALE AZ 85301
GLENDALE
AZ
85301
SANTIAGO SERGIO V GOMEZ/GOMEZ DORA ELIA
4430 W MYRTLE AVE GLENDALE AZ 85301
GLENDALE
AZ
85301
ROJAS CARMEN/BETANCOURT MARIA M
4424 W MYRTLE AVE GLENDALE AZ 85301
GLENDALE
AZ
85301
VELAZQUEZ LORENZO R/GUTIERREZ CELIA VALLEZ
4418 W MYRTLE AVE GLENDALE AZ 85301
GLENDALE
AZ
85301
ROBINSON SCOTT/SUZ
PO BOX 5099 GLENDALE AZ 85312
GLENDALE
AZ
85312
HALL ABRAHAM/PAMELA
4406 W MYRTLE AVE GLENDALE AZ 85301
GLENDALE
AZ
85301
GIERCZYNSKI PAUL
7223 N 44TH AVE GLENDALE AZ 85301
GLENDALE
AZ
85301
HAYWOOD LARRY/WIMBISH EUPHENIA
7215 N 44TH AVE GLENDALE AZ 85301
GLENDALE
AZ
85301
BFH HOLDINGS LLC
2621 E CARMEL CIR MESA AZ 85204
MESA
AZ
85204
AZ SOLANO VISTA LLC
1240 E 2100 STE 300 SALT LAKE CITY UT 84106
SALT LAKE CITY
UT
84106
RAMOS ISRAEL/JUANITA
7149 N 45TH AVE GLENDALE AZ 85301
GLENDALE
AZ
85301
GALINDO LOUIE R/CONSUELO
4403 W MYRTLE AVE GLENDALE AZ 85301
GLENDALE
AZ
85301
PHAN HA/TU ANH/NGUYEN MINH P T
4001 W GLENN DR PHOENIX AZ 85051
PHOENIX
AZ
85051
VARELA JACQUELINE O
4413 W MYRTLE AVE GLENDALE AZ 85301
GLENDALE
AZ
85301
PROCTOR ADAM
7135 N 45TH AVE GLENDALE AZ 85301
GLENDALE
AZ
85301
BFH HOLDINGS LLC
2621 E CARMEL CIR MESA AZ 85204
MESA
AZ
85204
LPNIVASI LLC
3549 E HELENA DR PHOENIX AZ USA 85032
PHOENIX
AZ
85032
SFREDDO PATRICK M
7123 N 45TH AVE GLENDALE AZ 85301
GLENDALE
AZ
85301
QUINTERO JOSE ANTONIO/DIANA P
7121 N 45TH AVE GLENDALE AZ 85301
GLENDALE
AZ
85301
SFREDDO JEAN E
7119 N 45TH AVE GLENDALE AZ 85301
GLENDALE
AZ
85301
RICE STEVEN J
23806 N 40TH LN GLENDALE AZ 85310
GLENDALE
AZ
85310
ROMERO ERIC CHRISTOPHER
7107 N 45TH AVE GLENDALE AZ 85301
GLENDALE
AZ
85301
LEANOS-ORTIZ SILVINA
7105 N 45TH AVE GLENDALE AZ 85301
GLENDALE
AZ
85301
CHAVEZ ASHLEY K
7103 N 45TH AVE GLENDALE AZ 85301
GLENDALE
AZ
85301
DAWNIT ENTERPRISES LLC
4484 W PALMAIRE AVE GLENDALE AZ 85301
GLENDALE
AZ
85301
PONATH PATRICE A
4482 W PALMAIRE AVE GLENDALE AZ 85301
GLENDALE
AZ
85301
ABED OMAR
4480 W PALMAIRE AVE GLENDALE AZ 85301
GLENDALE
AZ
85301
BENITEZ NEREIDA G
4478 W PALMAIRE AVE GLENDALE AZ 85301
GLENDALE
AZ
85301
ANTHONY J ROSSETTI TRUST
3120 N 19TH AVE SUITE 200 PHOENIX AZ 85015
PHOENIX
AZ
85015
BROWN BLAND
4474 W PALMAIRE AVE GLENDALE AZ 85301
GLENDALE
AZ
85301
JEWELL CHRISTINE LESLIE
2302 E PIESTEWA PEAK DR PHOENIX AZ 85016
PHOENIX
AZ
85016
WILSON TAZESHA
4458 W PALMAIRE AVE GLENDALE AZ 85301
GLENDALE
AZ
85301
DUHAIME MICHAEL/OLIVARES DOLORES M
4456 W PALMAIRE AVE GLENDALE AZ 85301
GLENDALE
AZ
85301
DAUGHERTY LESLIE A
4454 W PALMAIRE AVE GLENDALE AZ 85301
GLENDALE
AZ
85301
JONES STEPHANEE
4452 W PALMAIRE AVE GLENDALE AZ 85301
GLENDALE
AZ
85301
VANDERCOOK PELC LIVING TRUST
4433 N 59TH DR PHOENIX AZ 85033
PHOENIX
AZ
85033
DORIS AND GEORGE TRAVERS TRUST
4742 W ROSE LN GLENDALE AZ 85301
GLENDALE
AZ
85301
MORGART THERESA
4428 W PALMAIRE AVE GLENDALE AZ 85301
GLENDALE
AZ
85301
CRUZ CARMEN C
4430 W PALMAIRE AVE GLENDALE AZ 85301
GLENDALE
AZ
85301
BRADEEN STELLA J
4432 W PALMAIRE AVE GLENDALE AZ 85301
GLENDALE
AZ
85301
BOYD KELLY
4424 W PALMAIRE AVE GLENDALE AZ 85301
GLENDALE
AZ
85301
GARCIA CYNTHIA K
4422 W PALMAIRE AVE GLENDALE AZ 85301
GLENDALE
AZ
85301
AGSAULIO GLENN J
4420 W PALMAIRE AVE GLENDALE AZ 85301
GLENDALE
AZ
85301
SUNKIN LILY/DON TR
32096 RANCHO CIELO TRABUCO CANYON CA 92679
TRABUCO CANYON
CA
92679
SPENCERZACH 1 LLC
8776 E SHEA BLVD UNIT 106-173 SCOTTSDALE AZ 85260
SCOTTSDALE
AZ
85260
AHMED MOHAMED
4414 W PALMAIRE AVE GLENDALE AZ 85301
GLENDALE
AZ
85301
BROWN JEANNA
4412 W PALMAIRE AVE GLENDALE AZ 85301
GLENDALE
AZ
85301
CURETON LEE/ROGER J
4410 W PALMAIRE AVE GLENDALE AZ 85301
GLENDALE
AZ
85301
UPSHAW TREVA A
4408 W PALMAIRE AVE GLENDALE AZ 85301
GLENDALE
AZ
85301
SWEENEY MARJORIE
4406 W PALMAIRE AVE GLENDALE AZ 85301-2831
GLENDALE
AZ
85301-2831
GARCIA JUAN P
3348 W WILLOW AVE PHOENIX AZ 85029
PHOENIX
AZ
85029
DAVIS JAMES H TR
4402 W PALMAIRE AVE GLENDALE AZ 85301
GLENDALE
AZ
85301
SQUIRE MITCHELL LLC
4150 W NORTHERN AVE SUITE 170 PHOENIX AZ 85051
PHOENIX
AZ
85051
LOWERY WENDELL
4436 W PALMAIRE AVE GLENDALE AZ 85301
GLENDALE
AZ
85301
EGGIMAN TAMARA K
4438 W PALMAIRE AVE GLENDALE AZ 85301
GLENDALE
AZ
85301
ANNE WICKS REVOCABLE LIVING TRUST
2705 VIA CARDEL CARLSBAD CA 92010
CARLSBAD
CA
92010
GALLUP FAMILY TRUST/GALLUP BAILEY MARIE
4442 W PALMAIRE AVE GLENDALE AZ 85301
GLENDALE
AZ
85301
ALCOCER DANIEL L
4444 W PALMAIRE AVE GLENDALE AZ 85301-2801
GLENDALE
AZ
85301-2801
NEAL TYDERYON
4446 W PALMAIRE AVE GLENDALE AZ 85301
GLENDALE
AZ
85301
CRUSTITLA JOSE J/BAHA-ALCHESAY BAILEY A
4448 W PALMAIRE AVE GLENDALE AZ 85301
GLENDALE
AZ
85301
MEIER SUSAN J
4462 W PALMAIRE AVE GLENDALE AZ 85301
GLENDALE
AZ
85301
THOMAS AYESHAH
4464 W PALMAIRE AVE GLENDALE AZ 85301
GLENDALE
AZ
85301
GANDOLFO KRISTIN MICHELE/JONATHAN JAMES
1937 JITNEY DR SPARKS NV 89434
SPARKS
NV
89434
CELNIK JOSHUA
4468 W PALMAIRE AVE GLENDALE AZ 85301
GLENDALE
AZ
85301
HUMPHREY MELVIN
4470 W PALMAIRE AVE GLENDALE AZ 85301
GLENDALE
AZ
85301
AZ WHOLESALE INVESTMENTS LLC
3202 HONOLULU AVE GLENDALE CA 91214
GLENDALE
CA
91214
BLAKE W HEFFELFINGER TRUST
14300 N 83RD AVE #1031 PEORIA AZ 85381
PEORIA
AZ
85381

AWAD SAMY S/AUDETTE
8915 W SALTER DR PEORIA AZ 85382
PEORIA
AZ
85382
NOLEN WILLIAM T/HEINZELMANN ADELHEID TR
7115 N 45TH AVE GLENDALE AZ 85301
GLENDALE
AZ
85301
WISE SHIRLEY
8641 JELLISON ST ARVADO CO 80005
ARVADO
CO
80005
BRUNNEMER SHIRLEY J
11795 W COLUMBINE DR EL MIRAGE AZ 85335
EL MIRAGE
AZ
85335
CAFFREY MICHAEL
4488 W PALMAIRE AVE GLENDALE AZ 85301
GLENDALE
AZ
85301
AL SAEDI OMAR/SABAH
4490 W PALMAIRE AVE GLENDALE AZ USA 85301
GLENDALE
AZ
85301
JIRON GABRIEL ISAAC
4492 W PALMAIRE AVE GLENDALE AZ 85301
GLENDALE
AZ
85301
JOHNSON BRIAN
4494 W PALMAIRE AVE GLENDALE AZ 85301
GLENDALE
AZ
85301
BURRELL HERBERT L
4496 W PALMAIRE AVE GLENDALE AZ 85301
GLENDALE
AZ
85301
GLENCOURT ONE TOWNHOUSE ASSN
PO BOX 188 SCOTTSDALE AZ 85252
SCOTTSDALE
AZ
85252
GLENCOURT ONE TOWNHOUSE ASSN
PO BOX 188 SCOTTSDALE AZ 85252
SCOTTSDALE
AZ
85252
GLENCOURT ONE TOWNHOUSE ASSN
PO BOX 188 SCOTTSDALE AZ 85252
SCOTTSDALE
AZ
85252
GLENCOURT ONE TOWNHOUSE ASSN
PO BOX 188 SCOTTSDALE AZ 85252
SCOTTSDALE
AZ
85252
TANNER TERRACE INC
2150 E BROADWAY PHOENIX AZ 85040
PHOENIX
AZ
85040
REDEEMER INVESTMENTS LLC/SOUTHWEST INVEST LLC
7102 N 45TH AVE GLENDALE AZ 85301
GLENDALE
AZ
85301
THORNTON THOMAS C
7110 N 45TH AVE GLENDALE AZ 85301
GLENDALE
AZ
85301
VASQUEZ FRANCISCO BECERRA/GARCIA YNES MEJIAS
4529 W PALMAIRE AVE GLENDALE AZ 85301
GLENDALE
AZ
85301
WB PROPERTY VENTURES LLC
2610 S ZURICH COURT DENVER CO 80219
DENVER
CO
80219
SIMS KEVIN SHAWN
7208 N 45TH AVE GLENDALE AZ 85301
GLENDALE
AZ
85301
MOHAMMED AEAD/THABET MAZEN
7202 N 45TH AVE GLENDALE AZ 85301
GLENDALE
AZ
85301
SERRANO GEORGE JR
4511 W MYRTLE AVE GLENDALE AZ 85301
GLENDALE
AZ
85301
ARMENTA DULCE PATRICIA LUQUE
4515 W MYRTLE AVE GLENDALE AZ 85301
GLENDALE
AZ
85301

NAME
OR CURRENT RESIDENT
ADDRESS
City, State Zipcode 
KAREN ABORNE
7318 W GRIFFIN AVENUE
GLENDALE AZ  85303
JOYCE CLARK
8628 W CAVALIER DR
GLENDALE AZ  85305
GARY HIRSCH
4520 WEST ECHO LANE
GLENDALE, AZ 85302
DIANE ESTERLY
4801 WEST CHERYL DRIVE
GLENDALE, AZ 85302
STEVEN FRATE
PO BOX 6265
GLENDALE, AZ 85312
JAMES LAVIGNE
10227 NORTH 52ND AVE
GLENDALE, AZ 85302
AL LENOX
5130 W EL CAMINITO DR
GLENDALE. AZ 85302
DENNIS GERHARD
10613 N 48TH AVE
GLENDALE AZ  85304
RICK HARPER
5335 W BLOOMFIELD RD
GLENDALE AZ 85304
JACK MARTINO
7407 NORTH 75TH DRIVE
GLENDALE, AZ  85303
JOHN AND SUE JONES
18658 NORTH 78TH DR
GLENDALE AZ  85308
JOHN KOLODZIEJ
6258 NORTH 88TH LANE
GLENDALE AZ  85305
WENDY DAVY/ PEORIA UNI SCH DIST
6330 W THUNDERBIRD RD
GLENDALE, AZ 85306
MICKEY LUND
5708 W ROYAL PALM RD
GLENDALE AZ  85302
MANNY MARTINEZ
19107 NORTH 73rd LANE
GLENDALE, AZ  85308
MARY SMITH
8968 WEST CITRUS WAY
GLENDALE AZ  89305
DAVID MORENO
8387 West Denton LAnE
GLENDALE AZ 85305
DAVID PENILLA
5760 W LARKSPUR DR
GLENDALE AZ  85304
DANIEL STREYLE/ VERMILION IDG
7333 E DOUBLETREE RANCH RD. #D220
SCOTTSDALE, AZ 85258
WILLIAM RAY
7305 WEST ANGELA DR
GLENDALE AZ  85308
ELAINE SCRUGGS
21656 NORTH 58TH DRIVE
GLENDALE AZ 85308
MEL SMITH
24654 N LAKE PLESANT 103-329
PEORIA, AZ 85383
MICHAEL SOCACIU
8574 W BERRIDGE LN
GLENDALE, AZ 85305
TOM TRAW
6024 N 83RD AVE
GLENDALE, AZ 85303
MARIE SCILLIERI
5124 W EL CAMINITO DR
GLENDALE, AZ 85308
ED NYBERG
6987 W POTTER DR
GLENDALE, AZ 85308
WARREN WILFONG
5001 N 62ND DR
GLENDALE, AZ 85301
VERN CROW
6343 W REDFIELD RD
GLENDALE, AZ 85306
M NOWAKOWSKI
6116 N 85TH DR
GLENDALE, AZ 85305
ARNOLD DOYSCHEN
7578 W TRAILS DRIVE
GLENDALE, AZ 85308
JAMIE ALDAMA
7329 NORTH 68TH DRIVE
GLENDALE, AZ 85303
MAYOR WEIERS
CITY OF GLENDALE
5850 W GLENDALE AVE 4TH FLOOR
GLENDALE, AZ 85301
COUNCIL MEMBER HUGH
CITY OF GLENDALE
5850 W GLENDALE AVE 4TH FLOOR
GLENDALE, AZ 85301
DIANA FIGUEROA
CITY OF GLENDALE
5850 W GLENDALE AVE 2ND FLOOR
GLENDALE, AZ 85301
TOM COLE
5705 W LOMA LANE
GLENDALE, AZ 85302

COMPLETION OF THE FOLLOWING IS NECESSARY FOR FINAL REPORT APPROVAL 
 
SUMMARY / FINAL REPORT 
Total individuals notified: 
Total Participants: 
CONCERNS, ISSUES, PROBLEMS EXPRESSED 
 
 
 
HOW CONCERNS WILL BE ADDRESSED? 
 
 
 
CONCERNS APPLICANT IS UNWILLING TO ADDRESS 
 
 
 
CITIZEN PARTICIPATION FINAL 
REPORT

HOW THE PROPOSAL HAS BEEN REVISED TO ADDRESS CONCERNS 
 
 
 
APPLICANT SIGNATURE AND DATE