Extracted text (via pymupdf)
531104 characters
City of Glendale
Planning ● 5850 West Glendale Avenue, Suite 212 ● Glendale, AZ 85301-2599 ● Phone (623) 930-2800
Planning
Memorandum
DATE:
August 3, 2023
TO:
Planning Commission
THRU:
Tabitha Perry, Planning Manager
FROM:
Matthew Taylor, Senior Planner
SUBJECT:
CUP23-04 (Modern Stay – StayAPT)
On April 28, 2023, the Planning Division began receiving emails regarding this
Conditional Use Permit application. To date, staff has received more than 50
messages regarding this case.
There are frequent misconceptions as to the nature of the proposed extended stay
hotel, suggesting it to be a budget hotel. Other misconceptions include the type of use
itself, some citizens believing a multi-family residential project is proposed for the
property. Some citizens are concerned the project will extend 73rd Avenue through
Secluded Estates and Secluded Acres, which is not the case.
Citizens have voiced common land use concerns regarding building heights, increased
traffic, and the size of the property. However, many concerns involve broader social
issues not considered in routine land use planning analysis, including transiency, drug
activity, and human trafficking. Staff’s analysis of the CUP application falls under the
five Conditional Use Permit findings identified in Section 3.904 of the zoning ordinance.
You don't often get email from steveneldridge2@gmail.com. Learn why this is important
From:
Steven Eldridge
To:
Taylor, Matthew
Subject:
Re: CUP 23-04
Date:
Friday, April 28, 2023 8:43:28 AM
Thank you for the information Matthew. I think thats all I had for concerns. I'm on 73rd and
libby up the street so connecting the road was my main concern. Thank you again - Steve
On Fri, Apr 28, 2023, 8:34 AM Taylor, Matthew <MTaylor@glendaleaz.com> wrote:
Good morning,
The proposed height of the hotel is 3-stories with a roofline of about 30’ (roughly 32’ with
parapets), which is slightly less than the 35’ allowed by the approved Arrowhead PAD. 73rd
Avenue is not proposed to extend from Camino San Xavier to Angela Drive.
Feel free to contact me directly at 623.930.2805 if you have additional questions and/or
would like the applicant’s contact information.
Thank you.
From: Steven <steveneldridge2@gmail.com>
Sent: Thursday, April 27, 2023 11:30 AM
To: Taylor, Matthew <MTaylor@GLENDALEAZ.com>
Subject: CUP 23-04
Good Morning Matthew,
I just got wind of the StayApt project going in at 73rd and Camino San Xavier. I was
wondering how many stories tall is it planned to be and if any portion of the project will
connect 73rd Ave to Union Hills? Thank you for the help -Steve Eldridge 602-330-6790
From:
Chase •
To:
Taylor, Matthew
Subject:
Keep Human Trafficking Away from Secluded Acres
Date:
Saturday, May 20, 2023 1:16:55 PM
You don't often get email from chasecrandall3083@gmail.com. Learn why this is important
Mr. Taylor, I am a resident of secluded acres, a short walk away from where the new APT
Suites extended stay hotel is planned to be built. This type of building has been known to
swell with dangerous individuals constantly from homeless drug addicts to sex traffickers and
drug dealers. This apartment is not only a short distance from Arrowhead Elementary school
but also on bell road which is already dealing with increasingly aggressive pan handling.
Building this "hotel" would be a great way to turn this nice area of arizona into the next slum.
As a tax paying resident of the area I am expressing my opposition to this hotel and citing is as
a main source of my possible leaving of the area, which would no doubt replace one working
middle class citizen with Human Traffickers, pan handlers, and violent drug addicts. Like a
Californian Hydra.
You don't often get email from jillteaches@yahoo.com. Learn why this is important
From:
Perry, Tabitha
To:
jill waldrip; rmalnar@glendalAZ.com; Mehta, Jamsheed; Huggins Jr, Randy; notostayapt@gmail.com
Cc:
Taylor, Matthew
Subject:
RE: Extended Stay at 7300 W Camino San Xavier, Glendale, AZ
Date:
Tuesday, May 23, 2023 1:13:34 PM
Hello Jill,
I hope your day is going well.
Thanks for expressing your concerns regarding the proposed Modern Stay (stay apt
suites) development. This proposed development brand's competitors are Marriott
(Residence Inn) and Hiton (Home2 Suites).
The applicant must make every reasonable effort to address citizens' concerns as
part of the citizen participation process. I encourage you to speak with the applicant
also, as he may be able to provide you with some clarity based on some of the
assumptions made on the proposal.
The development proposal requires a Conditional Use Permit Approval by the
Planning Commission that is tentatively scheduled for June 22nd but subject to
change. Planning staff will conduct a sound planning analysis of the proposal and
provide a recommendation to Planning Commission.
Matt Taylor, Senior Planner, is the project manager. Thus, I have forwarded your
email to him to incorporate into his working file for future reference.
Thanks, again, for taking the time to share your thoughts and concerns.
Tabitha
From: jill waldrip <jillteaches@yahoo.com>
Sent: Tuesday, May 23, 2023 12:59 PM
To: rmalnar@glendalAZ.com; Mehta, Jamsheed <JMehta@GLENDALEAZ.com>; Huggins Jr, Randy
<RHuggins@GLENDALEAZ.com>; Perry, Tabitha <TPerry@GLENDALEAZ.com>;
notostayapt@gmail.com
Subject: Extended Stay at 7300 W Camino San Xavier, Glendale, AZ
Recently, I found out that the City of Glendale was planning to put an Extended Stay Type Hotel at the
end of 73 Ave where I live in the same area. This is a very nice quiet neighborhood where lots of families
with little children and a lot of elderly people live. These are million dollar homes and the crime is low.
We are able to go for walks, feel safe, go to the mall, and not worry about drug dealers or being mugged.
This new development would change all of this. The Arrowhead mall is a nice place to go shopping
without worrying about the type of people you will run into, all of this would change. It is also, one of the
only malls left that is a safe place for people to go shopping. Please keep our neighborhood safe!!! Don't
let this happen!
Jill Waldrip
7202 W Grovers Ave
Glendale, AZ
You don't often get email from jillteaches@yahoo.com. Learn why this is important
From:
Huggins Jr, Randy
To:
Perry, Tabitha; Taylor, Matthew
Subject:
FW: Extended Stay at 7300 W Camino San Xavier, Glendale, AZ
Date:
Tuesday, May 23, 2023 5:03:57 PM
From: St John, Richard <RSTJohn@GLENDALEAZ.com>
Sent: Tuesday, May 23, 2023 3:44 PM
To: Pederson, Jessi <JPederson@GLENDALEAZ.COM>; Huggins Jr, Randy
<RHuggins@GLENDALEAZ.com>; Briggs, Christopher <CBriggs@GLENDALEAZ.com>; Freeburg, Ryan
<RFreeburg@GLENDALEAZ.com>
Subject: FW: Extended Stay at 7300 W Camino San Xavier, Glendale, AZ
Another message from the Waldrip family on this project.
From: jill waldrip <jillteaches@yahoo.com>
Sent: Tuesday, May 23, 2023 12:51 PM
To: St John, Richard <RSTJohn@GLENDALEAZ.com>
Subject: Extended Stay at 7300 W Camino San Xavier, Glendale, AZ
Recently, I found out that the City of Glendale was planning to put an Extended Stay Type Hotel at the
end of 73 Ave where I live in the same area. This is a very nice quiet neighborhood where lots of families
with little children and a lot of elderly people live. These are million dollar homes and the crime is low.
We are able to go for walks, feel safe, go to the mall, and not worry about drug dealers or being mugged.
This new development would change all of this. The Arrowhead mall is a nice place to go shopping
without worrying about the type of people you will run into, all of this would change. It is also, one of the
only malls left that is a safe place for people to go shopping. Please keep our neighborhood safe!!! Don't
let this happen!
Jill Waldrip
7202 W Grovers Ave
Glendale, AZ
You don't often get email from kelley@acmeconfidential.com. Learn why this is important
From:
Huggins Jr, Randy
To:
Taylor, Matthew; Perry, Tabitha
Subject:
FW: Extended-Stay Development
Date:
Wednesday, May 24, 2023 11:08:18 AM
From: St John, Richard <RSTJohn@GLENDALEAZ.com>
Sent: Tuesday, May 23, 2023 10:55 AM
To: Briggs, Christopher <CBriggs@GLENDALEAZ.com>; Pederson, Jessi <JPederson@GLENDALEAZ.COM>; Huggins Jr, Randy <RHuggins@GLENDALEAZ.com>;
Freeburg, Ryan <RFreeburg@GLENDALEAZ.com>
Subject: FW: Extended-Stay Development
Just fyi…I have no idea who this person is claiming to be a former Glendale officer.
From: Kelley Waldrip <kelley@acmeconfidential.com>
Sent: Tuesday, May 23, 2023 10:47 AM
To: St John, Richard <RSTJohn@GLENDALEAZ.com>; bhoopeer@glendaleAZ.com
Subject: Extended-Stay Development
To whom this may concern,
I am a former Glendale Police officer and city resident and was considering returning to Glendale: until I learned of an
extended-stay hotel being planned for 7300 W. Camino San Xavier. Having spent my entire life in law enforcement, much of
it enforcing narcotics laws, I was greatly alarmed about this development.
My own experience with facilities like that being planned tells me that Glendale’s city administration is completely oblivious
to the hazards of such a development – especially in that area. The Arrowhead Mall and other booming commercial
enterprises will be negatively affected by the placement of an extended-stay facility and will, over time, reduce tax revenue
as the area begins to decline.
One need only look at what happened with Metro Center after similar high-occupancy and extended-stay facilities were
constructed around it. If this project proceeds, I predict that the Glendale Police and Fire Departments will require additional
resources to address the increased crime and calls-for-service that will no doubt be generated in that area. Diverting tax
dollars from further community improvement to addressing increased criminal behavior.
I recently moved from Los Angeles and was looking forward to reestablishing my residence in the very area of the planned
extended-stay facility. Unfortunately, I am now reconsidering my decision to return to Glendale and will encourage my many
friends and family in that area to do likewise ahead of the certain impact on that area’s property values.
Sincerely,
Some people who received this message don't often get email from notostayapt@gmail.com. Learn why this is
important
From:
Taylor, Matthew
To:
NoTo StayApt; Perry, Tabitha; rmalnar@glendalaz.com; Huggins Jr, Randy; Mehta, Jamsheed; St John, Richard
Cc:
jillteaches@yahoo.com
Subject:
RE: Extended Stay at 7300 W Camino San Xavier, Glendale, AZ
Date:
Thursday, May 25, 2023 8:56:00 AM
Attachments:
image001.png
Good morning,
I am the case manager for this application. The Modern Stay – StayAPT conditional use permit (CUP)
application is tentatively scheduled for a Planning Commission public hearing on June 22, 2023.
Planning Commission public hearings are held at 6:00pm in City Council chambers at 5850 W
Glendale Avenue on the date scheduled.
Should this CUP application not move forward to Planning Commission on June 22nd, I will notify you
via this email address.
My direct contact information is below – feel free to reach out with additional questions.
Thank you.
From: NoTo StayApt <notostayapt@gmail.com>
Sent: Thursday, May 25, 2023 6:50 AM
To: Taylor, Matthew <MTaylor@GLENDALEAZ.com>; Perry, Tabitha <TPerry@GLENDALEAZ.com>;
rmalnar@glendalaz.com; Huggins Jr, Randy <RHuggins@GLENDALEAZ.com>; Mehta, Jamsheed
<JMehta@GLENDALEAZ.com>; St John, Richard <RSTJohn@GLENDALEAZ.com>
Cc: jillteaches@yahoo.com
Subject: Fwd: Extended Stay at 7300 W Camino San Xavier, Glendale, AZ
Thank you for your reply.
June 22, but "subject to change". How much notice is the City required to give the public when/if it
is changed? How are citizens notified? What time? Where is the meeting held?
You don't often get email from jillteaches@yahoo.com. Learn why this is important
---------- Forwarded message ---------
From: Perry, Tabitha <TPerry@glendaleaz.com>
Date: Tue, May 23, 2023 at 1:13 PM
Subject: RE: Extended Stay at 7300 W Camino San Xavier, Glendale, AZ
To: jill waldrip <jillteaches@yahoo.com>, rmalnar@glendalAZ.com <rmalnar@glendalaz.com>,
Mehta, Jamsheed <JMehta@glendaleaz.com>, Huggins Jr, Randy <RHuggins@glendaleaz.com>,
notostayapt@gmail.com <notostayapt@gmail.com>
Cc: Taylor, Matthew <MTaylor@glendaleaz.com>
Hello Jill,
I hope your day is going well.
Thanks for expressing your concerns regarding the proposed Modern Stay (stay apt
suites) development. This proposed development brand's competitors are Marriott
(Residence Inn) and Hiton (Home2 Suites).
The applicant must make every reasonable effort to address citizens' concerns as
part of the citizen participation process. I encourage you to speak with the applicant
also, as he may be able to provide you with some clarity based on some of the
assumptions made on the proposal.
The development proposal requires a Conditional Use Permit Approval by the
Planning Commission that is tentatively scheduled for June 22nd but subject to
change. Planning staff will conduct a sound planning analysis of the proposal and
provide a recommendation to Planning Commission.
Matt Taylor, Senior Planner, is the project manager. Thus, I have forwarded your
email to him to incorporate into his working file for future reference.
Thanks, again, for taking the time to share your thoughts and concerns.
Tabitha
From: jill waldrip <jillteaches@yahoo.com>
Sent: Tuesday, May 23, 2023 12:59 PM
To: rmalnar@glendalAZ.com; Mehta, Jamsheed <JMehta@GLENDALEAZ.com>; Huggins Jr, Randy
<RHuggins@GLENDALEAZ.com>; Perry, Tabitha <TPerry@GLENDALEAZ.com>;
notostayapt@gmail.com
Subject: Extended Stay at 7300 W Camino San Xavier, Glendale, AZ
Recently, I found out that the City of Glendale was planning to put an Extended Stay Type Hotel at the
end of 73 Ave where I live in the same area. This is a very nice quiet neighborhood where lots of families
with little children and a lot of elderly people live. These are million dollar homes and the crime is low.
We are able to go for walks, feel safe, go to the mall, and not worry about drug dealers or being mugged.
This new development would change all of this. The Arrowhead mall is a nice place to go shopping
without worrying about the type of people you will run into, all of this would change. It is also, one of the
only malls left that is a safe place for people to go shopping. Please keep our neighborhood safe!!! Don't
let this happen!
Jill Waldrip
7202 W Grovers Ave
Glendale, AZ
CITY CONTACTS:
Councilman - Sahuaro District, Ray Malnar rmalnar@glendaleAZ.com
Assistant City Manager, Jamsheed Mehta, JMehta@glendaleaz.com
Deputy City Manager of Emergency Management, Rick St. John, rstjohn@glendaleaz.com
Development Services Department Director, Randy Huggins, RHuggins@GLENDALEAZ.com
Planning Manager – Tabita Perry, tperry@glendaleaz.com
Planning Commission – Sahuaro District, Bryan Hoopeer, bhoopeer@glendaleaz.com
StayApt and The City of Glendale are planning to build a 3-story EXTENDED STAY
TYPE HOTEL at 7300 W. Camino San Xavier (vacant lot south of IRS building).
What does this mean to you?
This poses an incredible safety hazard for our families and our properties as extended stay type hotels are
notorious for crime including but not limited to drugs, sex trafficking, and prostitution. This “hotel” will
bring 24-hour activity less than 300 feet from our doors.
What can you do?
Please join your neighbors by opposing this business by contacting any/all of the people listed below.
Email us at NoToStayApt@gmail.com to stay informed and to volunteer!
This Photo by Unknown Author is licensed under CC BY-NC
From:
Jeff Swanson
To:
Erin Cole
Cc:
Mike Homco
Subject:
RE: Petition link attached
Date:
Thursday, June 8, 2023 10:00:17 AM
Attachments:
image001.png
flyer1.pptx
Hi Erin,
Thanks for including us on this…
Unfortunately we have a zero solicitation policy in our contract with DES/DDD, and this potential
project doesn’t affect services provided to our participants, so we can’t simply send this out to
families and staff…I did see a couple days ago that the city posted the public meeting scheduled for
6/22…that seems like a great platform to meet with leadership.
I will share with you that I did in fact meet with several staff within City of Glendale regarding
potential concerns several weeks ago that I could foresee, one of which was based solely on access
points to entry/egress and the current traffic on Camino…
My recommendation to you would be to base your comments at the meeting on very specific
zoning/permitting issues you see, NOT based on the pieces on the flyer (attached) circulated or the
comments regarding drugs, crime, etc. While I might agree with you on the very distant “potential”
to those things, its NOT what the City will base their zoning/permitting decisions on…
Hope this helps…
Jeff
Jeff Swanson
Executive Director of Administration
C: 602-768-3868 | O: 623-215-2449
9299 W. Olive Ave. | Suite 311 | Peoria, AZ 85345
OSBI.org
Unless expressly specified otherwise, this email and its contents, attached, referenced, or otherwise, ("Contents") do NOT contain legal,
financial, or tax advice; and rather, represent the (business) opinions of the author only. We are a 501(c) 3 non-profit organization (EIN:
86-1036448, QCO 20638) EST. 2003, One Step Beyond, Inc. provides unique and empowering programs and services to individuals who
have Intellectual Disabilities and their families by creating unique opportunities and promoting community inclusion. This message and
the Contents are intended solely for the person(s) to whom they are directly and intentionally sent, and may contain privileged,
protected, and/or confidential information. If you receive this message by mistake or otherwise and/or are a non-intended recipient,
please destroy this message and Contents immediately. Thank you.
From: Erin Cole <erinscole@gmail.com>
Sent: Wednesday, June 7, 2023 8:55 PM
To: Jeff Swanson <jeffswanson@osbi.org>; Mike Homco <mikehomco@osbi.org>
Subject: Fwd: Petition link attached
Gentlemen,
I wanted to forward this email from my personal account, as perhaps the "NoToStayApt" was
marked as spam through OSBI.
We have exceeded my original goal of 100 signatures, and need as many more as possible before
the CUP Meeting 6/22 @ 6pm.
Please let me know what I can do to get your staff, members, and parents/guardians engaged.
Very respectfully,
Erin Cole
602.770.9799
erinscole@gmail.com
---------- Forwarded message ---------
From: NoTo StayApt <notostayapt@gmail.com>
Date: Sat, Jun 3, 2023 at 8:48 AM
Subject: Petition link attached
To: bkhutton@cox.net <bkhutton@cox.net>, bpray@cox.net <bpray@cox.net>, crabbyaz
<crabbyaz@q.com>, D Adams <azchrome@yahoo.com>, Dan Mareska <danmareska@q.com>, Don
Robertson <don.c.robertson@gmail.com>, erinscole@gmail.com <erinscole@gmail.com>, George
Gaspar <georgesgaspar@yahoo.com>, gregacole@gmail.com <gregacole@gmail.com>,
jeffswanson@osbi.org <jeffswanson@osbi.org>, jgatt@cox.net <jgatt@cox.net>,
jillteaches@yahoo.com <jillteaches@yahoo.com>, Larry Alexander <aprilmoon821@gmail.com>,
littl918@yahoo.com <littl918@yahoo.com>, Littlmrs7243@gmail.com <Littlmrs7243@gmail.com>,
mikehomco@osbi.org <mikehomco@osbi.org>, saranne1211@gmail.com
<saranne1211@gmail.com>, skipcrandall@hotmail.com <skipcrandall@hotmail.com>,
sss510@cox.net <sss510@cox.net>, <Paul.Carver@dvusd.org>, <Ann.Ordway@dvusd.org>
Hi all,
Please see attached petition, sign, and forward.
This is my first time making a petition, and first time on this website. I am open to suggestions...
Jeff and Mike: Is there a way we can get this forwarded to your staff and guardians of your
members, please? Say the word, and you know I will do whatever I can.
Ann and Paul: What do I need to do to get this on DVUSD Board's next agenda? Parents need to be
notified immediately. Say the word, and I will do anything in my power.
Reminder: CUP Meeting is 6/22/23 at 6pm at City Council, 5850 W. Glendale Ave. We need as
many signatures as possible before the meeting. Please plan to attend. We need to have a
presence!
Lastly, I don't have a Facebook account, and perhaps I should make one...? In any case, please share
to yours, if you have one.
https://www.ipetitions.com/petition/no-to-stayapt-extended-stay
Thank you all!
Erin
You don't often get email from sjpeters03@yahoo.com. Learn why this is important
From:
Huggins Jr, Randy
To:
Scott and Julie Peters; Taylor, Matthew
Cc:
Malnar, Raymond; Mehta, Jamsheed; St John, Richard; Perry, Tabitha
Subject:
RE: NO to Extended Stay
Date:
Monday, June 12, 2023 1:30:23 PM
Attachments:
image001.png
Good afternoon Julie,
Thank you for sending your comments and feedback in the email below. I have forwarded this email
to Matt Taylor, our Senior Planner that is managing this process so he can add it to the file.
Have a great day.
From: Scott and Julie Peters <sjpeters03@yahoo.com>
Sent: Sunday, June 11, 2023 8:49 AM
To: Malnar, Raymond <RMalnar@GLENDALEAZ.COM>; Mehta, Jamsheed
<JMehta@GLENDALEAZ.com>; St John, Richard <RSTJohn@GLENDALEAZ.com>; Huggins Jr, Randy
<RHuggins@GLENDALEAZ.com>; Perry, Tabitha <TPerry@GLENDALEAZ.com>
Subject: NO to Extended Stay
Good Morning,
My name is Julie Peters and I am a mom, wife, and local REALTOR in Glendale, AZ. I live
in the neighborhood where they are proposing property for the Extended Stay at 73rd and
Camino San Xavier. This property is not zoned for a hotel and there is not enough room there
for a hotel or that many vehicles. This extended stay hotel would bring too much crime to our
neighborhood as these hotels are known for crime including drugs, sex trafficking, and
prostitution - among other things. As a MOM I would ask that you would please NOT
ALLOW this hotel to be built on this property as our crime rate will increase in the
neighborhood and (as a REALTOR) our home values will decrease! Please consider those of
us who live in this neighborhood and our safety and quality of life here in North Glendale.
Thank you for your consideration and we'll see you at the meeting on June 22nd.
Sincerely,
Julie Peters
MOM
REALTOR
DeLex Realty, Glendale, AZ
623-606-9105
From:
Taylor, Matthew
To:
NoTo StayApt
Subject:
RE: Extended Stay at 7300 W Camino San Xavier, Glendale, AZ
Date:
Monday, June 12, 2023 8:45:00 AM
Attachments:
image001.png
Good morning,
Thank you for your message regarding #CUP23-04. Per your questions below:
1. Why does the sign say "n/a" for City Council? Should not you and Mr. Malnar be the point of
contact for the citizens of Glendale instead of the proposed buyer's attorney?
The Planning Commission approves Conditional Use Permits (CUP) during a public
hearing based on required findings. CUP applications do not appear before City Council.
2. Is it common practice to place the sign hidden in foliage, unable to be seen from the
intersection, and unable to be seen by westbound traffic? You'll notice the rest of the lot has
far less vegetation, and faces a 3-way stop sign.
Public notice signs must be placed along each property frontage, parallel to the
road, and be visible from the street. The subject property has a single frontage (W
Camino San Xavier).
3. Please provide proof of posting on June 2, as the sign states. We walk and bike these trails
daily, and perhaps I missed it prior to June 10. It is quite hidden.
Our office received a notarized affidavit of posting from the applicant. The
affidavit attests to posting on June 2, 2023 and a date/time stamped photograph
of the sign after posting is included with the affidavit.
Please reach out to me directly with any additional questions or concerns you may have regarding
this application.
Thank you again for your message.
From: NoTo StayApt <notostayapt@gmail.com>
Sent: Sunday, June 11, 2023 11:33 AM
To: Taylor, Matthew <MTaylor@GLENDALEAZ.com>
Subject: Re: Extended Stay at 7300 W Camino San Xavier, Glendale, AZ
Mr. Taylor,
Please see attached photos:
Last night on my evening walk, I noticed the City placed a CUP Meeting Notice sign in the lot at 7300
W. Camino San Xavier.
In an effort to be efficient and organized, please answer the following questions:
1. Why does the sign say "n/a" for City Council? Should not you and Mr. Malnar be the point of
contact for the citizens of Glendale instead of the proposed buyer's attorney?
2. Is it common practice to place the sign hidden in foliage, unable to be seen from the intersection,
and unable to be seen by westbound traffic? You'll notice the rest of the lot has far less vegetation,
and faces a 3-way stop sign.
3. Please provide proof of posting on June 2, as the sign states. We walk and bike these trails daily,
and perhaps I missed it prior to June 10. It is quite hidden.
We look forward to your response.
IMG-8935.jpg
IMG-8936.jpg
IMG-8938.jpg
IMG-8939.jpg
IMG-8940.jpg
IMG-8947.jpg
On Thu, May 25, 2023 at 8:56 AM Taylor, Matthew <MTaylor@glendaleaz.com> wrote:
Good morning,
I am the case manager for this application. The Modern Stay – StayAPT conditional use permit
(CUP) application is tentatively scheduled for a Planning Commission public hearing on June 22,
2023. Planning Commission public hearings are held at 6:00pm in City Council chambers at 5850
Some people who received this message don't often get email from notostayapt@gmail.com. Learn why this is
important
W Glendale Avenue on the date scheduled.
Should this CUP application not move forward to Planning Commission on June 22nd, I will notify
you via this email address.
My direct contact information is below – feel free to reach out with additional questions.
Thank you.
From: NoTo StayApt <notostayapt@gmail.com>
Sent: Thursday, May 25, 2023 6:50 AM
To: Taylor, Matthew <MTaylor@GLENDALEAZ.com>; Perry, Tabitha <TPerry@GLENDALEAZ.com>;
rmalnar@glendalaz.com; Huggins Jr, Randy <RHuggins@GLENDALEAZ.com>; Mehta, Jamsheed
<JMehta@GLENDALEAZ.com>; St John, Richard <RSTJohn@GLENDALEAZ.com>
Cc: jillteaches@yahoo.com
Subject: Fwd: Extended Stay at 7300 W Camino San Xavier, Glendale, AZ
Thank you for your reply.
June 22, but "subject to change". How much notice is the City required to give the public when/if
it is changed? How are citizens notified? What time? Where is the meeting held?
---------- Forwarded message ---------
From: Perry, Tabitha <TPerry@glendaleaz.com>
Date: Tue, May 23, 2023 at 1:13 PM
Subject: RE: Extended Stay at 7300 W Camino San Xavier, Glendale, AZ
To: jill waldrip <jillteaches@yahoo.com>, rmalnar@glendalAZ.com <rmalnar@glendalaz.com>,
Mehta, Jamsheed <JMehta@glendaleaz.com>, Huggins Jr, Randy <RHuggins@glendaleaz.com>,
notostayapt@gmail.com <notostayapt@gmail.com>
Cc: Taylor, Matthew <MTaylor@glendaleaz.com>
You don't often get email from jillteaches@yahoo.com. Learn why this is important
Hello Jill,
I hope your day is going well.
Thanks for expressing your concerns regarding the proposed Modern Stay (stay
apt suites) development. This proposed development brand's competitors are
Marriott (Residence Inn) and Hiton (Home2 Suites).
The applicant must make every reasonable effort to address citizens' concerns as
part of the citizen participation process. I encourage you to speak with the applicant
also, as he may be able to provide you with some clarity based on some of the
assumptions made on the proposal.
The development proposal requires a Conditional Use Permit Approval by the
Planning Commission that is tentatively scheduled for June 22nd but subject to
change. Planning staff will conduct a sound planning analysis of the proposal and
provide a recommendation to Planning Commission.
Matt Taylor, Senior Planner, is the project manager. Thus, I have forwarded your
email to him to incorporate into his working file for future reference.
Thanks, again, for taking the time to share your thoughts and concerns.
Tabitha
From: jill waldrip <jillteaches@yahoo.com>
Sent: Tuesday, May 23, 2023 12:59 PM
To: rmalnar@glendalAZ.com; Mehta, Jamsheed <JMehta@GLENDALEAZ.com>; Huggins Jr, Randy
<RHuggins@GLENDALEAZ.com>; Perry, Tabitha <TPerry@GLENDALEAZ.com>;
notostayapt@gmail.com
Subject: Extended Stay at 7300 W Camino San Xavier, Glendale, AZ
Recently, I found out that the City of Glendale was planning to put an Extended Stay Type Hotel at the
end of 73 Ave where I live in the same area. This is a very nice quiet neighborhood where lots of
families with little children and a lot of elderly people live. These are million dollar homes and the crime
is low. We are able to go for walks, feel safe, go to the mall, and not worry about drug dealers or being
mugged. This new development would change all of this. The Arrowhead mall is a nice place to go
shopping without worrying about the type of people you will run into, all of this would change. It is also,
one of the only malls left that is a safe place for people to go shopping. Please keep our neighborhood
safe!!! Don't let this happen!
Jill Waldrip
7202 W Grovers Ave
Glendale, AZ
From:
NoTo StayApt
To:
Taylor, Matthew
Subject:
Re: Extended Stay at 7300 W Camino San Xavier, Glendale, AZ
Date:
Monday, June 12, 2023 9:02:09 PM
Attachments:
image001.png
Thank you so much!
As evidenced by the photos, the sign is only visible by eastbound traffic, on a blind curve in
the road, where no driver could possibly see it as he/she would be navigating his/her vehicle.
It is very much hidden from public view. Please consider this email request to relocate the
sign, and post it in plain sight. Further, I would argue that the alleged June 2 posting is
insufficient as it is hidden in foliage. How does one contest this notice date? It appears this
sign has been hidden intentionally. Is it common practice for the City to post a notice behind
foliage when the rest of the lot is cleared?
Lastly, regarding the meeting: When citizens come to speak, are they timed in the same
fashion as City Council, or is there a Q&A portion with the City?
Thanks again!
On Mon, Jun 12, 2023 at 8:44 AM Taylor, Matthew <MTaylor@glendaleaz.com> wrote:
Good morning,
Thank you for your message regarding #CUP23-04. Per your questions below:
1. Why does the sign say "n/a" for City Council? Should not you and Mr. Malnar be the
point of contact for the citizens of Glendale instead of the proposed buyer's attorney?
The Planning Commission approves Conditional Use Permits (CUP) during a
public hearing based on required findings. CUP applications do not appear before City
Council.
2. Is it common practice to place the sign hidden in foliage, unable to be seen from the
intersection, and unable to be seen by westbound traffic? You'll notice the rest of the
lot has far less vegetation, and faces a 3-way stop sign.
Public notice signs must be placed along each property frontage, parallel
to the road, and be visible from the street. The subject property has a
single frontage (W Camino San Xavier).
3. Please provide proof of posting on June 2, as the sign states. We walk and bike these
trails daily, and perhaps I missed it prior to June 10. It is quite hidden.
Our office received a notarized affidavit of posting from the applicant.
The affidavit attests to posting on June 2, 2023 and a date/time stamped
photograph of the sign after posting is included with the affidavit.
Please reach out to me directly with any additional questions or concerns you may have
regarding this application.
Thank you again for your message.
From: NoTo StayApt <notostayapt@gmail.com>
Sent: Sunday, June 11, 2023 11:33 AM
To: Taylor, Matthew <MTaylor@GLENDALEAZ.com>
Subject: Re: Extended Stay at 7300 W Camino San Xavier, Glendale, AZ
Mr. Taylor,
Please see attached photos:
Last night on my evening walk, I noticed the City placed a CUP Meeting Notice sign in the
lot at 7300 W. Camino San Xavier.
In an effort to be efficient and organized, please answer the following questions:
1. Why does the sign say "n/a" for City Council? Should not you and Mr. Malnar be the
point of contact for the citizens of Glendale instead of the proposed buyer's attorney?
2. Is it common practice to place the sign hidden in foliage, unable to be seen from the
intersection, and unable to be seen by westbound traffic? You'll notice the rest of the lot has
far less vegetation, and faces a 3-way stop sign.
3. Please provide proof of posting on June 2, as the sign states. We walk and bike these
trails daily, and perhaps I missed it prior to June 10. It is quite hidden.
We look forward to your response.
IMG-8935.jpg
IMG-8936.jpg
IMG-8938.jpg
IMG-8939.jpg
IMG-8940.jpg
IMG-8947.jpg
On Thu, May 25, 2023 at 8:56 AM Taylor, Matthew <MTaylor@glendaleaz.com> wrote:
Good morning,
Some people who received this message don't often get email from notostayapt@gmail.com. Learn why this is
I am the case manager for this application. The Modern Stay – StayAPT conditional use
permit (CUP) application is tentatively scheduled for a Planning Commission public
hearing on June 22, 2023. Planning Commission public hearings are held at 6:00pm in
City Council chambers at 5850 W Glendale Avenue on the date scheduled.
Should this CUP application not move forward to Planning Commission on June 22nd, I
will notify you via this email address.
My direct contact information is below – feel free to reach out with additional questions.
Thank you.
From: NoTo StayApt <notostayapt@gmail.com>
Sent: Thursday, May 25, 2023 6:50 AM
To: Taylor, Matthew <MTaylor@GLENDALEAZ.com>; Perry, Tabitha
<TPerry@GLENDALEAZ.com>; rmalnar@glendalaz.com; Huggins Jr, Randy
<RHuggins@GLENDALEAZ.com>; Mehta, Jamsheed
<JMehta@GLENDALEAZ.com>; St John, Richard <RSTJohn@GLENDALEAZ.com>
Cc: jillteaches@yahoo.com
Subject: Fwd: Extended Stay at 7300 W Camino San Xavier, Glendale, AZ
important
Thank you for your reply.
June 22, but "subject to change". How much notice is the City required to give the public
when/if it is changed? How are citizens notified? What time? Where is the
meeting held?
---------- Forwarded message ---------
From: Perry, Tabitha <TPerry@glendaleaz.com>
Date: Tue, May 23, 2023 at 1:13 PM
Subject: RE: Extended Stay at 7300 W Camino San Xavier, Glendale, AZ
To: jill waldrip <jillteaches@yahoo.com>, rmalnar@glendalAZ.com
<rmalnar@glendalaz.com>, Mehta, Jamsheed <JMehta@glendaleaz.com>, Huggins Jr,
Randy <RHuggins@glendaleaz.com>, notostayapt@gmail.com
<notostayapt@gmail.com>
Cc: Taylor, Matthew <MTaylor@glendaleaz.com>
Hello Jill,
I hope your day is going well.
Thanks for expressing your concerns regarding the proposed Modern Stay (stay
apt suites) development. This proposed development brand's competitors are
Marriott (Residence Inn) and Hiton (Home2 Suites).
The applicant must make every reasonable effort to address citizens' concerns as
part of the citizen participation process. I encourage you to speak with the
applicant also, as he may be able to provide you with some clarity based on some
of the assumptions made on the proposal.
The development proposal requires a Conditional Use Permit Approval by the
Planning Commission that is tentatively scheduled for June 22nd but subject to
change. Planning staff will conduct a sound planning analysis of the proposal and
provide a recommendation to Planning Commission.
Matt Taylor, Senior Planner, is the project manager. Thus, I have forwarded your
email to him to incorporate into his working file for future reference.
You don't often get email from jillteaches@yahoo.com. Learn why this is important
Thanks, again, for taking the time to share your thoughts and concerns.
Tabitha
From: jill waldrip <jillteaches@yahoo.com>
Sent: Tuesday, May 23, 2023 12:59 PM
To: rmalnar@glendalAZ.com; Mehta, Jamsheed <JMehta@GLENDALEAZ.com>;
Huggins Jr, Randy <RHuggins@GLENDALEAZ.com>; Perry, Tabitha
<TPerry@GLENDALEAZ.com>; notostayapt@gmail.com
Subject: Extended Stay at 7300 W Camino San Xavier, Glendale, AZ
Recently, I found out that the City of Glendale was planning to put an Extended Stay Type Hotel at
the end of 73 Ave where I live in the same area. This is a very nice quiet neighborhood where lots of
families with little children and a lot of elderly people live. These are million dollar homes and the
crime is low. We are able to go for walks, feel safe, go to the mall, and not worry about drug dealers
or being mugged. This new development would change all of this. The Arrowhead mall is a nice
place to go shopping without worrying about the type of people you will run into, all of this would
change. It is also, one of the only malls left that is a safe place for people to go shopping. Please
keep our neighborhood safe!!! Don't let this happen!
Jill Waldrip
7202 W Grovers Ave
Glendale, AZ
You don't often get email from sjpeters03@yahoo.com. Learn why this is important
From:
Huggins Jr, Randy
To:
Scott and Julie Peters; Taylor, Matthew
Cc:
Malnar, Raymond; Mehta, Jamsheed; St John, Richard; Perry, Tabitha
Subject:
RE: NO to Extended Stay
Date:
Monday, June 12, 2023 1:30:23 PM
Attachments:
image001.png
Good afternoon Julie,
Thank you for sending your comments and feedback in the email below. I have forwarded this email
to Matt Taylor, our Senior Planner that is managing this process so he can add it to the file.
Have a great day.
From: Scott and Julie Peters <sjpeters03@yahoo.com>
Sent: Sunday, June 11, 2023 8:49 AM
To: Malnar, Raymond <RMalnar@GLENDALEAZ.COM>; Mehta, Jamsheed
<JMehta@GLENDALEAZ.com>; St John, Richard <RSTJohn@GLENDALEAZ.com>; Huggins Jr, Randy
<RHuggins@GLENDALEAZ.com>; Perry, Tabitha <TPerry@GLENDALEAZ.com>
Subject: NO to Extended Stay
Good Morning,
My name is Julie Peters and I am a mom, wife, and local REALTOR in Glendale, AZ. I live
in the neighborhood where they are proposing property for the Extended Stay at 73rd and
Camino San Xavier. This property is not zoned for a hotel and there is not enough room there
for a hotel or that many vehicles. This extended stay hotel would bring too much crime to our
neighborhood as these hotels are known for crime including drugs, sex trafficking, and
prostitution - among other things. As a MOM I would ask that you would please NOT
ALLOW this hotel to be built on this property as our crime rate will increase in the
neighborhood and (as a REALTOR) our home values will decrease! Please consider those of
us who live in this neighborhood and our safety and quality of life here in North Glendale.
Thank you for your consideration and we'll see you at the meeting on June 22nd.
Sincerely,
Julie Peters
MOM
REALTOR
DeLex Realty, Glendale, AZ
623-606-9105
From:
Huggins Jr, Randy
To:
lsullivan0711@gmail.com; Taylor, Matthew
Cc:
Perry, Tabitha
Subject:
FW: Extended Stay
Date:
Monday, June 12, 2023 10:14:48 AM
Attachments:
image001.png
Good Morning Linda,
Thank you for sending your comments and feedback in the email below. I have forwarded this email
to Matt Taylor, our Senior Planner that is managing this process so he can add it to the file.
Have a great day.
-----Original Message-----
From: L Sully <lsullivan0711@gmail.com>
Sent: Sunday, June 11, 2023 9:58 PM
To: Huggins Jr, Randy <RHuggins@GLENDALEAZ.com>
Subject: Extended Stay
[You don't often get email from lsullivan0711@gmail.com. Learn why this is important at
https://aka.ms/LearnAboutSenderIdentification ]
Please do not allow the extended stay to be built off of Union Hills and 73rd avenue. Our
neighborhood is already going downhill with all of the rentals. An extended stay will bring in a lot of
criminal activity. All you would need to do is visit an extended stay property to see it for yourself
Allow a decent Glendale neighborhood to remain so, please.
Linda Sullivan
7939 W Taro Lane
Glendale, AZ 85308
623 332-9920
Sent from my iPhone
Sent from my iPhone
You don't often get email from cmfairbairn@gmail.com. Learn why this is important
From:
Huggins Jr, Randy
To:
Cassie Fairbairn
Cc:
Taylor, Matthew; Perry, Tabitha
Subject:
RE: Opposition to Extended Stay 7300 W Camino San Xavier
Date:
Wednesday, June 14, 2023 11:25:47 AM
Attachments:
image001.png
Good afternoon Cassie,
Thank you for sending your comments and feedback in the email below. I have forwarded this email
to Matt Taylor, our Senior Planner that is managing this process so he can add it to the file.
Have a great day.
From: Cassie Fairbairn <cmfairbairn@gmail.com>
Sent: Tuesday, June 13, 2023 6:42 PM
To: Huggins Jr, Randy <RHuggins@GLENDALEAZ.com>
Subject: Opposition to Extended Stay 7300 W Camino San Xavier
Dear arandy Huggins,
We hope this letter finds you well. We are writing to express our unwavering and strong opposition to the proposed
building of the Stay Apt extended stay hotel at 7300 W. Camino San Xavier. We have grave concerns about the
potential detrimental impact this project may have on our community, including the severe decline of property
values and an alarming increase in crime rates.
Constructing an extended stay hotel in close proximity to residential homes raises valid and deeply concerning
issues regarding the potential adverse effects on property values. Homeowners in the immediate vicinity of the
proposed Stay Apt at 7300 W. Camino San Xavier would likely suffer a substantial decrease in property values,
severely hindering their ability to sell their homes or secure favorable financing options. Such a decline in property
values would have far-reaching consequences, profoundly affecting the entire community's well-being and stability.
Moreover, the proximity of an extended stay hotel to residential areas raises legitimate concerns regarding the
potential surge in crime. Extended stay hotels frequently attract a transient population and often become hotspots
for criminal activities. The proposed Stay Apt at 7300 W. Camino San Xavier could compromise the safety and
security of residents in the surrounding area, jeopardizing the peace of mind and quality of life of the community
members. It is crucial to prioritize the safety and well-being of the residents, and approving this project would
introduce unnecessary risks and potentially lead to an increase in criminal incidents.
Considering the gravity of these concerns, we strongly urge the City of Glendale to reassess and outright reject the
approval of the Stay Apt extended stay hotel project at 7300 W. Camino San Xavier. We implore the city authorities
to explore alternative locations that genuinely address the concerns of the residents and ensure the safety and
security of the community.
Thank you for dedicating the time and consideration needed to review our resolute opposition. We firmly believe
that city officials must take into account the potentially devastating impact of the proposed Stay Apt on the
Secluded Acres Neighborhood and community.
Yours sincerely,
Cassie & Ryan Burnley
Secluded Acres
From:
Taylor, Matthew
To:
NoTo StayApt
Subject:
RE: Extended Stay at 7300 W Camino San Xavier, Glendale, AZ
Date:
Wednesday, June 14, 2023 5:19:00 PM
Attachments:
image001.png
Good afternoon,
We provide the same guidance for posting – one sign along each property frontage that is visible
from the street. It appears the applicant has met this requirement.
Citizen comments during the Planning Commission is like that of City Council. Comments are subject
to time limit and, depending on the number of citizens present, the Commission Chair may suggest a
designated speaker to represent the concerns of those in attendance. Dialogue is through the
Commission Chair.
CUP23-04 is the first item on the agenda next Thursday, June 22nd, with two other public hearings to
follow. This item will not be heard before 6:00pm.
We strongly encourage participation in the public hearing process and look forward to seeing you
next Thursday. As always, available for your questions or comments regarding this application.
Thank you.
From: NoTo StayApt <notostayapt@gmail.com>
Sent: Monday, June 12, 2023 9:02 PM
To: Taylor, Matthew <MTaylor@GLENDALEAZ.com>
Subject: Re: Extended Stay at 7300 W Camino San Xavier, Glendale, AZ
Thank you so much!
As evidenced by the photos, the sign is only visible by eastbound traffic, on a blind curve in the road,
where no driver could possibly see it as he/she would be navigating his/her vehicle. It is very much
hidden from public view. Please consider this email request to relocate the sign, and post it in plain
sight. Further, I would argue that the alleged June 2 posting is insufficient as it is hidden in foliage.
How does one contest this notice date? It appears this sign has been hidden intentionally. Is it
common practice for the City to post a notice behind foliage when the rest of the lot is cleared?
Lastly, regarding the meeting: When citizens come to speak, are they timed in the same fashion as
City Council, or is there a Q&A portion with the City?
Thanks again!
On Mon, Jun 12, 2023 at 8:44 AM Taylor, Matthew <MTaylor@glendaleaz.com> wrote:
Good morning,
Thank you for your message regarding #CUP23-04. Per your questions below:
1. Why does the sign say "n/a" for City Council? Should not you and Mr. Malnar be the point
of contact for the citizens of Glendale instead of the proposed buyer's attorney?
The Planning Commission approves Conditional Use Permits (CUP) during a
public hearing based on required findings. CUP applications do not appear before
City Council.
2. Is it common practice to place the sign hidden in foliage, unable to be seen from the
intersection, and unable to be seen by westbound traffic? You'll notice the rest of the lot
has far less vegetation, and faces a 3-way stop sign.
Public notice signs must be placed along each property frontage, parallel to the
road, and be visible from the street. The subject property has a single frontage
(W Camino San Xavier).
3. Please provide proof of posting on June 2, as the sign states. We walk and bike these trails
daily, and perhaps I missed it prior to June 10. It is quite hidden.
Our office received a notarized affidavit of posting from the applicant.
The affidavit attests to posting on June 2, 2023 and a date/time stamped
photograph of the sign after posting is included with the affidavit.
Please reach out to me directly with any additional questions or concerns you may have regarding
this application.
Thank you again for your message.
From: NoTo StayApt <notostayapt@gmail.com>
Sent: Sunday, June 11, 2023 11:33 AM
To: Taylor, Matthew <MTaylor@GLENDALEAZ.com>
Subject: Re: Extended Stay at 7300 W Camino San Xavier, Glendale, AZ
Mr. Taylor,
Please see attached photos:
Last night on my evening walk, I noticed the City placed a CUP Meeting Notice sign in the lot at
7300 W. Camino San Xavier.
In an effort to be efficient and organized, please answer the following questions:
1. Why does the sign say "n/a" for City Council? Should not you and Mr. Malnar be the point of
contact for the citizens of Glendale instead of the proposed buyer's attorney?
2. Is it common practice to place the sign hidden in foliage, unable to be seen from the
intersection, and unable to be seen by westbound traffic? You'll notice the rest of the lot has far
less vegetation, and faces a 3-way stop sign.
3. Please provide proof of posting on June 2, as the sign states. We walk and bike these trails
daily, and perhaps I missed it prior to June 10. It is quite hidden.
We look forward to your response.
IMG-8935.jpg
IMG-8936.jpg
IMG-8938.jpg
IMG-8939.jpg
Some people who received this message don't often get email from notostayapt@gmail.com. Learn why this is
important
IMG-8940.jpg
IMG-8947.jpg
On Thu, May 25, 2023 at 8:56 AM Taylor, Matthew <MTaylor@glendaleaz.com> wrote:
Good morning,
I am the case manager for this application. The Modern Stay – StayAPT conditional use permit
(CUP) application is tentatively scheduled for a Planning Commission public hearing on June 22,
2023. Planning Commission public hearings are held at 6:00pm in City Council chambers at
5850 W Glendale Avenue on the date scheduled.
Should this CUP application not move forward to Planning Commission on June 22nd, I will
notify you via this email address.
My direct contact information is below – feel free to reach out with additional questions.
Thank you.
From: NoTo StayApt <notostayapt@gmail.com>
Sent: Thursday, May 25, 2023 6:50 AM
To: Taylor, Matthew <MTaylor@GLENDALEAZ.com>; Perry, Tabitha
<TPerry@GLENDALEAZ.com>; rmalnar@glendalaz.com; Huggins Jr, Randy
<RHuggins@GLENDALEAZ.com>; Mehta, Jamsheed <JMehta@GLENDALEAZ.com>; St John,
Richard <RSTJohn@GLENDALEAZ.com>
Cc: jillteaches@yahoo.com
Subject: Fwd: Extended Stay at 7300 W Camino San Xavier, Glendale, AZ
Thank you for your reply.
June 22, but "subject to change". How much notice is the City required to give the public
when/if it is changed? How are citizens notified? What time? Where is the meeting held?
---------- Forwarded message ---------
From: Perry, Tabitha <TPerry@glendaleaz.com>
Date: Tue, May 23, 2023 at 1:13 PM
Subject: RE: Extended Stay at 7300 W Camino San Xavier, Glendale, AZ
To: jill waldrip <jillteaches@yahoo.com>, rmalnar@glendalAZ.com <rmalnar@glendalaz.com>,
Mehta, Jamsheed <JMehta@glendaleaz.com>, Huggins Jr, Randy <RHuggins@glendaleaz.com>,
notostayapt@gmail.com <notostayapt@gmail.com>
Cc: Taylor, Matthew <MTaylor@glendaleaz.com>
Hello Jill,
I hope your day is going well.
Thanks for expressing your concerns regarding the proposed Modern Stay (stay
apt suites) development. This proposed development brand's competitors are
Marriott (Residence Inn) and Hiton (Home2 Suites).
The applicant must make every reasonable effort to address citizens' concerns as
part of the citizen participation process. I encourage you to speak with the
applicant also, as he may be able to provide you with some clarity based on
some of the assumptions made on the proposal.
The development proposal requires a Conditional Use Permit Approval by the
Planning Commission that is tentatively scheduled for June 22nd but subject to
change. Planning staff will conduct a sound planning analysis of the proposal
and provide a recommendation to Planning Commission.
Matt Taylor, Senior Planner, is the project manager. Thus, I have forwarded your
email to him to incorporate into his working file for future reference.
Thanks, again, for taking the time to share your thoughts and concerns.
Tabitha
From: jill waldrip <jillteaches@yahoo.com>
Sent: Tuesday, May 23, 2023 12:59 PM
To: rmalnar@glendalAZ.com; Mehta, Jamsheed <JMehta@GLENDALEAZ.com>; Huggins Jr,
Randy <RHuggins@GLENDALEAZ.com>; Perry, Tabitha <TPerry@GLENDALEAZ.com>;
notostayapt@gmail.com
Subject: Extended Stay at 7300 W Camino San Xavier, Glendale, AZ
You don't often get email from jillteaches@yahoo.com. Learn why this is important
Recently, I found out that the City of Glendale was planning to put an Extended Stay Type Hotel at
the end of 73 Ave where I live in the same area. This is a very nice quiet neighborhood where lots
of families with little children and a lot of elderly people live. These are million dollar homes and the
crime is low. We are able to go for walks, feel safe, go to the mall, and not worry about drug dealers
or being mugged. This new development would change all of this. The Arrowhead mall is a nice
place to go shopping without worrying about the type of people you will run into, all of this would
change. It is also, one of the only malls left that is a safe place for people to go shopping. Please
keep our neighborhood safe!!! Don't let this happen!
Jill Waldrip
7202 W Grovers Ave
Glendale, AZ
From:
NoTo StayApt
To:
Taylor, Matthew
Subject:
Re: Extended Stay at 7300 W Camino San Xavier, Glendale, AZ
Date:
Thursday, June 15, 2023 5:33:26 PM
Attachments:
image001.png
Thank you for all your replies.
I hope you have a great 3-day weekend!
On Thu, Jun 15, 2023 at 5:13 PM Taylor, Matthew <MTaylor@glendaleaz.com> wrote:
FYI – The applicant has indicated they will request a continuance at next week’s Planning
Commission public hearing. The agenda will reflect this when it’s posted, possibly as early
as tomorrow – it will be viewable at Public Meetings & Notices - City of Glendale
(glendaleaz.com).
I will be out of the office tomorrow.
From: NoTo StayApt <notostayapt@gmail.com>
Sent: Thursday, June 15, 2023 5:04 PM
To: Taylor, Matthew <MTaylor@GLENDALEAZ.com>
Subject: Re: Extended Stay at 7300 W Camino San Xavier, Glendale, AZ
Noted, thanks.
When will the Planning Commission agenda be posted? And when is it legally required to
be posted?
Thanks!
On Thu, Jun 15, 2023 at 10:29 AM Taylor, Matthew <MTaylor@glendaleaz.com> wrote:
Good morning,
Speaker time allotment generally mirrors that of City Council, about 3 minutes. However,
this is at the discretion of the Commission Chair. As stated previously, the Chair may
suggest a representative to speak on behalf of citizens in opposition to an application
during a public hearing.
We will have legal counsel present during the public hearing. I recommend voicing all
your concerns, including notification sign posting, at that time.
Thank you.
From: NoTo StayApt <notostayapt@gmail.com>
Sent: Thursday, June 15, 2023 6:50 AM
To: Taylor, Matthew <MTaylor@GLENDALEAZ.com>
Subject: Re: Extended Stay at 7300 W Camino San Xavier, Glendale, AZ
Thank you.
The sign is not in public view. I invite you to drive to the subject property and see for
yourself. It "appears" the sign is hidden in the one overgrown tree on the lot. We are
contesting the notice date of June 2 as the sign is invisible from all vehicle, foot traffic,
and even the neighboring business. Please provide steps to officially contest the "public
notice".
Secondly, and in an effort to be prepared, what is the "time limit" per speaker?
Thanks.
On Wed, Jun 14, 2023 at 5:19 PM Taylor, Matthew <MTaylor@glendaleaz.com> wrote:
Good afternoon,
We provide the same guidance for posting – one sign along each property frontage that
is visible from the street. It appears the applicant has met this requirement.
Citizen comments during the Planning Commission is like that of City Council.
Comments are subject to time limit and, depending on the number of citizens present,
the Commission Chair may suggest a designated speaker to represent the concerns of
those in attendance. Dialogue is through the Commission Chair.
CUP23-04 is the first item on the agenda next Thursday, June 22nd, with two other
public hearings to follow. This item will not be heard before 6:00pm.
We strongly encourage participation in the public hearing process and look forward to
seeing you next Thursday. As always, available for your questions or comments
regarding this application.
Thank you.
From: NoTo StayApt <notostayapt@gmail.com>
Sent: Monday, June 12, 2023 9:02 PM
To: Taylor, Matthew <MTaylor@GLENDALEAZ.com>
Subject: Re: Extended Stay at 7300 W Camino San Xavier, Glendale, AZ
Thank you so much!
As evidenced by the photos, the sign is only visible by eastbound traffic, on a blind
curve in the road, where no driver could possibly see it as he/she would be navigating
his/her vehicle. It is very much hidden from public view. Please consider this email
request to relocate the sign, and post it in plain sight. Further, I would argue that the
alleged June 2 posting is insufficient as it is hidden in foliage. How does one contest
this notice date? It appears this sign has been hidden intentionally. Is it
common practice for the City to post a notice behind foliage when the rest of the lot is
cleared?
Lastly, regarding the meeting: When citizens come to speak, are they timed in the same
fashion as City Council, or is there a Q&A portion with the City?
Thanks again!
On Mon, Jun 12, 2023 at 8:44 AM Taylor, Matthew <MTaylor@glendaleaz.com>
wrote:
Good morning,
Thank you for your message regarding #CUP23-04. Per your questions below:
1. Why does the sign say "n/a" for City Council? Should not you and Mr. Malnar
be the point of contact for the citizens of Glendale instead of the proposed
buyer's attorney?
The Planning Commission approves Conditional Use Permits (CUP)
during a public hearing based on required findings. CUP applications do not
appear before City Council.
2. Is it common practice to place the sign hidden in foliage, unable to be seen
from the intersection, and unable to be seen by westbound traffic? You'll
notice the rest of the lot has far less vegetation, and faces a 3-way stop sign.
Public notice signs must be placed along each property frontage,
parallel to the road, and be visible from the street. The subject
property has a single frontage (W Camino San Xavier).
3. Please provide proof of posting on June 2, as the sign states. We walk and bike
these trails daily, and perhaps I missed it prior to June 10. It is quite hidden.
Our office received a notarized affidavit of posting from the
applicant. The affidavit attests to posting on June 2, 2023 and a
date/time stamped photograph of the sign after posting is included
with the affidavit.
Please reach out to me directly with any additional questions or concerns you may
have regarding this application.
Thank you again for your message.
From: NoTo StayApt <notostayapt@gmail.com>
Sent: Sunday, June 11, 2023 11:33 AM
To: Taylor, Matthew <MTaylor@GLENDALEAZ.com>
Subject: Re: Extended Stay at 7300 W Camino San Xavier, Glendale, AZ
Mr. Taylor,
Please see attached photos:
Last night on my evening walk, I noticed the City placed a CUP Meeting Notice sign
in the lot at 7300 W. Camino San Xavier.
In an effort to be efficient and organized, please answer the following questions:
1. Why does the sign say "n/a" for City Council? Should not you and Mr. Malnar be
the point of contact for the citizens of Glendale instead of the proposed buyer's
attorney?
2. Is it common practice to place the sign hidden in foliage, unable to be seen from
the intersection, and unable to be seen by westbound traffic? You'll notice the rest of
the lot has far less vegetation, and faces a 3-way stop sign.
3. Please provide proof of posting on June 2, as the sign states. We walk and bike
these trails daily, and perhaps I missed it prior to June 10. It is quite hidden.
We look forward to your response.
IMG-8935.jpg
IMG-8936.jpg
IMG-8938.jpg
IMG-8939.jpg
IMG-8940.jpg
IMG-8947.jpg
On Thu, May 25, 2023 at 8:56 AM Taylor, Matthew <MTaylor@glendaleaz.com>
wrote:
Good morning,
I am the case manager for this application. The Modern Stay – StayAPT
conditional use permit (CUP) application is tentatively scheduled for a Planning
Commission public hearing on June 22, 2023. Planning Commission public
hearings are held at 6:00pm in City Council chambers at 5850 W Glendale Avenue
on the date scheduled.
Some people who received this message don't often get email from notostayapt@gmail.com. Learn why
this is important
Should this CUP application not move forward to Planning Commission on June
22nd, I will notify you via this email address.
My direct contact information is below – feel free to reach out with additional
questions.
Thank you.
From: NoTo StayApt <notostayapt@gmail.com>
Sent: Thursday, May 25, 2023 6:50 AM
To: Taylor, Matthew <MTaylor@GLENDALEAZ.com>; Perry, Tabitha
<TPerry@GLENDALEAZ.com>; rmalnar@glendalaz.com; Huggins Jr, Randy
<RHuggins@GLENDALEAZ.com>; Mehta, Jamsheed
<JMehta@GLENDALEAZ.com>; St John, Richard
<RSTJohn@GLENDALEAZ.com>
Cc: jillteaches@yahoo.com
Subject: Fwd: Extended Stay at 7300 W Camino San Xavier, Glendale, AZ
Thank you for your reply.
June 22, but "subject to change". How much notice is the City required to give the
public when/if it is changed? How are citizens notified? What time? Where is the
meeting held?
---------- Forwarded message ---------
From: Perry, Tabitha <TPerry@glendaleaz.com>
Date: Tue, May 23, 2023 at 1:13 PM
Subject: RE: Extended Stay at 7300 W Camino San Xavier, Glendale, AZ
To: jill waldrip <jillteaches@yahoo.com>, rmalnar@glendalAZ.com
<rmalnar@glendalaz.com>, Mehta, Jamsheed <JMehta@glendaleaz.com>,
Huggins Jr, Randy <RHuggins@glendaleaz.com>, notostayapt@gmail.com
<notostayapt@gmail.com>
Cc: Taylor, Matthew <MTaylor@glendaleaz.com>
Hello Jill,
I hope your day is going well.
Thanks for expressing your concerns regarding the proposed Modern Stay
(stay apt suites) development. This proposed development brand's
competitors are Marriott (Residence Inn) and Hiton (Home2 Suites).
The applicant must make every reasonable effort to address citizens'
concerns as part of the citizen participation process. I encourage you to
speak with the applicant also, as he may be able to provide you with some
clarity based on some of the assumptions made on the proposal.
The development proposal requires a Conditional Use Permit Approval by
the Planning Commission that is tentatively scheduled for June 22nd but
subject to change. Planning staff will conduct a sound planning analysis of
the proposal and provide a recommendation to Planning Commission.
Matt Taylor, Senior Planner, is the project manager. Thus, I have forwarded
your email to him to incorporate into his working file for future reference.
Thanks, again, for taking the time to share your thoughts and concerns.
You don't often get email from jillteaches@yahoo.com. Learn why this is important
Tabitha
From: jill waldrip <jillteaches@yahoo.com>
Sent: Tuesday, May 23, 2023 12:59 PM
To: rmalnar@glendalAZ.com; Mehta, Jamsheed
<JMehta@GLENDALEAZ.com>; Huggins Jr, Randy
<RHuggins@GLENDALEAZ.com>; Perry, Tabitha
<TPerry@GLENDALEAZ.com>; notostayapt@gmail.com
Subject: Extended Stay at 7300 W Camino San Xavier, Glendale, AZ
Recently, I found out that the City of Glendale was planning to put an Extended Stay Type
Hotel at the end of 73 Ave where I live in the same area. This is a very nice quiet
neighborhood where lots of families with little children and a lot of elderly people live. These
are million dollar homes and the crime is low. We are able to go for walks, feel safe, go to
the mall, and not worry about drug dealers or being mugged. This new development would
change all of this. The Arrowhead mall is a nice place to go shopping without worrying about
the type of people you will run into, all of this would change. It is also, one of the only malls
left that is a safe place for people to go shopping. Please keep our neighborhood safe!!!
Don't let this happen!
Jill Waldrip
7202 W Grovers Ave
Glendale, AZ
From:
NoTo StayApt
To:
Taylor, Matthew
Subject:
Re: Extended Stay at 7300 W Camino San Xavier, Glendale, AZ
Date:
Thursday, June 15, 2023 6:50:00 AM
Attachments:
image001.png
Thank you.
The sign is not in public view. I invite you to drive to the subject property and see for
yourself. It "appears" the sign is hidden in the one overgrown tree on the lot. We are
contesting the notice date of June 2 as the sign is invisible from all vehicle, foot traffic, and
even the neighboring business. Please provide steps to officially contest the "public notice".
Secondly, and in an effort to be prepared, what is the "time limit" per speaker?
Thanks.
On Wed, Jun 14, 2023 at 5:19 PM Taylor, Matthew <MTaylor@glendaleaz.com> wrote:
Good afternoon,
We provide the same guidance for posting – one sign along each property frontage that is
visible from the street. It appears the applicant has met this requirement.
Citizen comments during the Planning Commission is like that of City Council. Comments
are subject to time limit and, depending on the number of citizens present, the Commission
Chair may suggest a designated speaker to represent the concerns of those in attendance.
Dialogue is through the Commission Chair.
CUP23-04 is the first item on the agenda next Thursday, June 22nd, with two other public
hearings to follow. This item will not be heard before 6:00pm.
We strongly encourage participation in the public hearing process and look forward to
seeing you next Thursday. As always, available for your questions or comments regarding
this application.
Thank you.
From: NoTo StayApt <notostayapt@gmail.com>
Sent: Monday, June 12, 2023 9:02 PM
To: Taylor, Matthew <MTaylor@GLENDALEAZ.com>
Subject: Re: Extended Stay at 7300 W Camino San Xavier, Glendale, AZ
Thank you so much!
As evidenced by the photos, the sign is only visible by eastbound traffic, on a blind curve in
the road, where no driver could possibly see it as he/she would be navigating his/her
vehicle. It is very much hidden from public view. Please consider this email request to
relocate the sign, and post it in plain sight. Further, I would argue that the alleged June 2
posting is insufficient as it is hidden in foliage. How does one contest this notice date? It
appears this sign has been hidden intentionally. Is it common practice for the City to post a
notice behind foliage when the rest of the lot is cleared?
Lastly, regarding the meeting: When citizens come to speak, are they timed in the same
fashion as City Council, or is there a Q&A portion with the City?
Thanks again!
On Mon, Jun 12, 2023 at 8:44 AM Taylor, Matthew <MTaylor@glendaleaz.com> wrote:
Good morning,
Thank you for your message regarding #CUP23-04. Per your questions below:
1. Why does the sign say "n/a" for City Council? Should not you and Mr. Malnar be
the point of contact for the citizens of Glendale instead of the proposed buyer's
attorney?
The Planning Commission approves Conditional Use Permits (CUP) during a
public hearing based on required findings. CUP applications do not appear before
City Council.
2. Is it common practice to place the sign hidden in foliage, unable to be seen from the
intersection, and unable to be seen by westbound traffic? You'll notice the rest of
the lot has far less vegetation, and faces a 3-way stop sign.
Public notice signs must be placed along each property frontage,
parallel to the road, and be visible from the street. The subject
property has a single frontage (W Camino San Xavier).
3. Please provide proof of posting on June 2, as the sign states. We walk and bike
these trails daily, and perhaps I missed it prior to June 10. It is quite hidden.
Our office received a notarized affidavit of posting from the applicant.
The affidavit attests to posting on June 2, 2023 and a date/time
stamped photograph of the sign after posting is included with the
affidavit.
Please reach out to me directly with any additional questions or concerns you may have
regarding this application.
Thank you again for your message.
From: NoTo StayApt <notostayapt@gmail.com>
Sent: Sunday, June 11, 2023 11:33 AM
To: Taylor, Matthew <MTaylor@GLENDALEAZ.com>
Subject: Re: Extended Stay at 7300 W Camino San Xavier, Glendale, AZ
Mr. Taylor,
Please see attached photos:
Last night on my evening walk, I noticed the City placed a CUP Meeting Notice sign in
the lot at 7300 W. Camino San Xavier.
In an effort to be efficient and organized, please answer the following questions:
1. Why does the sign say "n/a" for City Council? Should not you and Mr. Malnar be the
point of contact for the citizens of Glendale instead of the proposed buyer's attorney?
2. Is it common practice to place the sign hidden in foliage, unable to be seen from the
intersection, and unable to be seen by westbound traffic? You'll notice the rest of the lot
has far less vegetation, and faces a 3-way stop sign.
3. Please provide proof of posting on June 2, as the sign states. We walk and bike these
trails daily, and perhaps I missed it prior to June 10. It is quite hidden.
We look forward to your response.
IMG-8935.jpg
IMG-8936.jpg
IMG-8938.jpg
IMG-8939.jpg
IMG-8940.jpg
IMG-8947.jpg
On Thu, May 25, 2023 at 8:56 AM Taylor, Matthew <MTaylor@glendaleaz.com> wrote:
Good morning,
I am the case manager for this application. The Modern Stay – StayAPT conditional use
permit (CUP) application is tentatively scheduled for a Planning Commission public
hearing on June 22, 2023. Planning Commission public hearings are held at 6:00pm in
City Council chambers at 5850 W Glendale Avenue on the date scheduled.
Should this CUP application not move forward to Planning Commission on June 22nd, I
will notify you via this email address.
My direct contact information is below – feel free to reach out with additional
questions.
Thank you.
Some people who received this message don't often get email from notostayapt@gmail.com. Learn why this is
important
From: NoTo StayApt <notostayapt@gmail.com>
Sent: Thursday, May 25, 2023 6:50 AM
To: Taylor, Matthew <MTaylor@GLENDALEAZ.com>; Perry, Tabitha
<TPerry@GLENDALEAZ.com>; rmalnar@glendalaz.com; Huggins Jr, Randy
<RHuggins@GLENDALEAZ.com>; Mehta, Jamsheed
<JMehta@GLENDALEAZ.com>; St John, Richard
<RSTJohn@GLENDALEAZ.com>
Cc: jillteaches@yahoo.com
Subject: Fwd: Extended Stay at 7300 W Camino San Xavier, Glendale, AZ
Thank you for your reply.
June 22, but "subject to change". How much notice is the City required to give the
public when/if it is changed? How are citizens notified? What time? Where is the
meeting held?
---------- Forwarded message ---------
From: Perry, Tabitha <TPerry@glendaleaz.com>
Date: Tue, May 23, 2023 at 1:13 PM
Subject: RE: Extended Stay at 7300 W Camino San Xavier, Glendale, AZ
To: jill waldrip <jillteaches@yahoo.com>, rmalnar@glendalAZ.com
<rmalnar@glendalaz.com>, Mehta, Jamsheed <JMehta@glendaleaz.com>, Huggins Jr,
Randy <RHuggins@glendaleaz.com>, notostayapt@gmail.com
<notostayapt@gmail.com>
Cc: Taylor, Matthew <MTaylor@glendaleaz.com>
Hello Jill,
I hope your day is going well.
Thanks for expressing your concerns regarding the proposed Modern Stay
(stay apt suites) development. This proposed development brand's competitors
You don't often get email from jillteaches@yahoo.com. Learn why this is important
are Marriott (Residence Inn) and Hiton (Home2 Suites).
The applicant must make every reasonable effort to address citizens' concerns
as part of the citizen participation process. I encourage you to speak with the
applicant also, as he may be able to provide you with some clarity based on
some of the assumptions made on the proposal.
The development proposal requires a Conditional Use Permit Approval by the
Planning Commission that is tentatively scheduled for June 22nd but subject to
change. Planning staff will conduct a sound planning analysis of the proposal
and provide a recommendation to Planning Commission.
Matt Taylor, Senior Planner, is the project manager. Thus, I have forwarded
your email to him to incorporate into his working file for future reference.
Thanks, again, for taking the time to share your thoughts and concerns.
Tabitha
From: jill waldrip <jillteaches@yahoo.com>
Sent: Tuesday, May 23, 2023 12:59 PM
To: rmalnar@glendalAZ.com; Mehta, Jamsheed <JMehta@GLENDALEAZ.com>;
Huggins Jr, Randy <RHuggins@GLENDALEAZ.com>; Perry, Tabitha
<TPerry@GLENDALEAZ.com>; notostayapt@gmail.com
Subject: Extended Stay at 7300 W Camino San Xavier, Glendale, AZ
Recently, I found out that the City of Glendale was planning to put an Extended Stay Type Hotel
at the end of 73 Ave where I live in the same area. This is a very nice quiet neighborhood where
lots of families with little children and a lot of elderly people live. These are million dollar homes
and the crime is low. We are able to go for walks, feel safe, go to the mall, and not worry about
drug dealers or being mugged. This new development would change all of this. The Arrowhead
mall is a nice place to go shopping without worrying about the type of people you will run into, all
of this would change. It is also, one of the only malls left that is a safe place for people to go
shopping. Please keep our neighborhood safe!!! Don't let this happen!
Jill Waldrip
7202 W Grovers Ave
Glendale, AZ
From:
Jeff Swanson
To:
Erin Cole
Cc:
Mike Homco
Subject:
RE: Petition link attached
Date:
Thursday, June 15, 2023 3:42:58 PM
Attachments:
image001.png
Ms. Cole,
I received a call from an individual this afternoon that saw your neighborhood posting specific to the
project we discussed several weeks ago in my office at One Step Beyond, and they sent me the
attached photo.
I’d ask that you remove/change the verbiage ASAP…as we discussed, One Step Beyond provides
programming for ADULTS who have intellectual disabilities (not challenged), we serve ZERO
children/youth as is clearly depicted on the flyer…and this is misleading/not appropriate to many
residents, many of whom support us financially and through volunteer efforts and know the quality
of our programs and those we serve.
Please reply that you received this and the action taken. I sent you a pretty detailed message last
week (below) with the recommendations on the proper ways to address the project (specific to
zoning/permitting) with the City of Glendale.
Jeff
Jeff Swanson
Executive Director of Administration
C: 602-768-3868 | O: 623-215-2449
9299 W. Olive Ave. | Suite 311 | Peoria, AZ 85345
OSBI.org
Unless expressly specified otherwise, this email and its contents, attached, referenced, or otherwise, ("Contents") do NOT contain legal,
financial, or tax advice; and rather, represent the (business) opinions of the author only. We are a 501(c) 3 non-profit organization (EIN:
86-1036448, QCO 20638) EST. 2003, One Step Beyond, Inc. provides unique and empowering programs and services to individuals who
have Intellectual Disabilities and their families by creating unique opportunities and promoting community inclusion. This message and
the Contents are intended solely for the person(s) to whom they are directly and intentionally sent, and may contain privileged,
protected, and/or confidential information. If you receive this message by mistake or otherwise and/or are a non-intended recipient,
please destroy this message and Contents immediately. Thank you.
From: Erin Cole <erinscole@gmail.com>
Sent: Friday, June 9, 2023 6:17 AM
To: Jeff Swanson <jeffswanson@osbi.org>
Subject: Re: Petition link attached
Thanks, Jeff.
-Erin
On Thu, Jun 8, 2023 at 10:00 AM Jeff Swanson <jeffswanson@osbi.org> wrote:
Hi Erin,
Thanks for including us on this…
Unfortunately we have a zero solicitation policy in our contract with DES/DDD, and this potential
project doesn’t affect services provided to our participants, so we can’t simply send this out to
families and staff…I did see a couple days ago that the city posted the public meeting scheduled
for 6/22…that seems like a great platform to meet with leadership.
I will share with you that I did in fact meet with several staff within City of Glendale regarding
potential concerns several weeks ago that I could foresee, one of which was based solely on
access points to entry/egress and the current traffic on Camino…
My recommendation to you would be to base your comments at the meeting on very specific
zoning/permitting issues you see, NOT based on the pieces on the flyer (attached) circulated or
the comments regarding drugs, crime, etc. While I might agree with you on the very distant
“potential” to those things, its NOT what the City will base their zoning/permitting decisions on…
Hope this helps…
Jeff
Jeff Swanson
Executive Director of Administration
C: 602-768-3868 | O: 623-215-2449
9299 W. Olive Ave. | Suite 311 | Peoria, AZ 85345
OSBI.org
Unless expressly specified otherwise, this email and its contents, attached, referenced, or otherwise, ("Contents") do NOT contain
legal, financial, or tax advice; and rather, represent the (business) opinions of the author only. We are a 501(c) 3 non-profit
organization (EIN: 86-1036448, QCO 20638) EST. 2003, One Step Beyond, Inc. provides unique and empowering programs and
services to individuals who have Intellectual Disabilities and their families by creating unique opportunities and promoting community
inclusion. This message and the Contents are intended solely for the person(s) to whom they are directly and intentionally sent, and
may contain privileged, protected, and/or confidential information. If you receive this message by mistake or otherwise and/or are a
non-intended recipient, please destroy this message and Contents immediately. Thank you.
From: Erin Cole <erinscole@gmail.com>
Sent: Wednesday, June 7, 2023 8:55 PM
To: Jeff Swanson <jeffswanson@osbi.org>; Mike Homco <mikehomco@osbi.org>
Subject: Fwd: Petition link attached
Gentlemen,
I wanted to forward this email from my personal account, as perhaps the "NoToStayApt" was
marked as spam through OSBI.
We have exceeded my original goal of 100 signatures, and need as many more as possible before
the CUP Meeting 6/22 @ 6pm.
Please let me know what I can do to get your staff, members, and parents/guardians engaged.
Very respectfully,
Erin Cole
602.770.9799
erinscole@gmail.com
---------- Forwarded message ---------
From: NoTo StayApt <notostayapt@gmail.com>
Date: Sat, Jun 3, 2023 at 8:48 AM
Subject: Petition link attached
To: bkhutton@cox.net <bkhutton@cox.net>, bpray@cox.net <bpray@cox.net>, crabbyaz
<crabbyaz@q.com>, D Adams <azchrome@yahoo.com>, Dan Mareska <danmareska@q.com>,
Don Robertson <don.c.robertson@gmail.com>, erinscole@gmail.com <erinscole@gmail.com>,
George Gaspar <georgesgaspar@yahoo.com>, gregacole@gmail.com <gregacole@gmail.com>,
jeffswanson@osbi.org <jeffswanson@osbi.org>, jgatt@cox.net <jgatt@cox.net>,
jillteaches@yahoo.com <jillteaches@yahoo.com>, Larry Alexander <aprilmoon821@gmail.com>,
littl918@yahoo.com <littl918@yahoo.com>, Littlmrs7243@gmail.com
<Littlmrs7243@gmail.com>, mikehomco@osbi.org <mikehomco@osbi.org>,
saranne1211@gmail.com <saranne1211@gmail.com>, skipcrandall@hotmail.com
<skipcrandall@hotmail.com>, sss510@cox.net <sss510@cox.net>, <Paul.Carver@dvusd.org>,
<Ann.Ordway@dvusd.org>
Hi all,
Please see attached petition, sign, and forward.
This is my first time making a petition, and first time on this website. I am open to suggestions...
Jeff and Mike: Is there a way we can get this forwarded to your staff and guardians of your
members, please? Say the word, and you know I will do whatever I can.
Ann and Paul: What do I need to do to get this on DVUSD Board's next agenda? Parents need to
be notified immediately. Say the word, and I will do anything in my power.
Reminder: CUP Meeting is 6/22/23 at 6pm at City Council, 5850 W. Glendale Ave. We need as
many signatures as possible before the meeting. Please plan to attend. We need to have a
presence!
Lastly, I don't have a Facebook account, and perhaps I should make one...? In any case, please
share to yours, if you have one.
https://www.ipetitions.com/petition/no-to-stayapt-extended-stay
Thank you all!
Erin
From:
crabbyaz
To:
Taylor, Matthew
Subject:
Secluded Acres/Estates
Date:
Saturday, June 17, 2023 1:51:15 PM
You don't often get email from crabbyaz@q.com. Learn why this is important
Mr. Malnar,
As a resident on St.John Rd since 1988 and have seen the area grow in a somewhat controlled
manner, I want to state my total opposition to the StayApt project being proposed!
Long term this is not in the best interest of your constituents or city tax base. One issue that
may not have been addressed is water, sewer, infrastructure and power needs for this project.
Beyond all the currently stated objections it appears growth and water usage should be a
primary focus rather than tax base income. As you are aware there is a downturn in growth
and a decline in revenues of existing business.
Please consider areas of better geography and resident approval.
Regards, Ken Crabtree
Sent from my Verizon, Samsung Galaxy smartphone
From:
Cox52
To:
Taylor, Matthew
Subject:
Opposition to Stay Apartments Bell Road and 73rd Avenue
Date:
Saturday, June 17, 2023 2:17:08 PM
[You don't often get email from elr52@cox.net. Learn why this is important at
https://aka.ms/LearnAboutSenderIdentification ]
Dear Mr Taylor,
I am writing to express my opposition to the building and opening of the Stay Apts. Just north of this site is
designated horse property that borders the equine trails through this area. Equine lovers that purchased surrounding
property with the excited anticipation of enjoying these trails with their horses will encounter an increased number
of people that could endanger equines and their riders. More people and unaccompanied children on bicycles,
skateboards, motorbikes (which already occurs), ATV’s, will further prevent the peaceful enjoyment of these equine
trails.
I request that you oppose this Stay Apts which will only add to the desecration of these trails.
Sincerely,
Eileen and Ron Gregg
Sent from my iPhone
From:
Diana Leuschner
To:
Taylor, Matthew
Subject:
NO to 23-04, StayApt at 7300 W. Camino San Xavier
Date:
Saturday, June 17, 2023 6:22:43 PM
You don't often get email from dpleuschner@gmail.com. Learn why this is important
Dear Mr. Taylor,
We are Ben and Diana Leuschner. Our family has lived in Secluded Acres for 5 years.
We are writing to express our opposition to CUP 23-04, StayApt at 7300 W. Camino San
Xavier.
We moved here because it is a quiet, and safe neighborhood. We do not need 24-hour activity
in the business lots neighboring our home. The City correctly did not zone this area for this
type of business, most likely because of these well-established and peaceful neighborhoods
that have been here for decades. Please do not change the zoning now to accommodate one
business. They can go somewhere else, we can't.
Respectfully,
Ben and Diana Leuschner
For the best experience, open this PDF portfolio in
Acrobat X or Adobe Reader X, or later.
Get Adobe Reader Now!
From:
Jackie
To:
Taylor, Matthew
Cc:
Robin Giordano
Subject:
OPPOSITION OF STAYAPT!!!
Date:
Saturday, June 17, 2023 3:28:08 PM
You don't often get email from jackie.rosenecker@gmail.com. Learn why this is important
To whom it may concern:
I am writing this letter to express my strong opposition to allowing StayApt to be built in our
neighborhood.
First of all, as a resident/property owner to the north of 73rd Avenue and W. Camino San
Xavier, it came as quite a surprise to my family and extended family/neighbors to recently
hear that the end of our street is the proposed site for the StayApt. The proposed would
devalue our homes, open streets to more traffic, bring in more crime, sex trafficking and
vagrancy. This area is already overly congested (ie, arrowhead mall, numerous restaurants,
banks, apartments, venues, etc.) Allowing this to be built would further congest the area.
A primary concern is the amount of traffic this will bring to our quiet “Secluded Acres”. The
area in question is NOT ZONED for a hotel OR residential housing.
Therefore for safety reasons they would have to open the area and create a byway right down
73rd Avenue. This is an area I walk frequently with my children and grandchildren. We love
to walk the quiet neighborhood to see all the animals. In fact there are homes right on 73rd
Avenue that have horses that we love to visit! If this were allowed to happen, these animals
would be in grave danger from the pollution and noise as well. Therefore creating an issue that
doesn’t seem to be adequately considered…traffic, noise, pedestrian and animal danger.
Our small area was not structured to implement such a business, with houses so close to the
proposed site and a valley where noise travels freely. The noise and dangers would be
unacceptable for this community.
Finally, what is the environmental impact of an StayApt in the proposed area? We have yet to
see an Environmental Impact Study from the city for the proposed site. If any information is
available, our community should have a right to review the results of such studies.
Should all of these things not be fully vetted out BEFORE making a proposal??? This
proposal seems in direct conflict with the City of Glendales own mission statement “... We
improve the lives of the people we serve every day” … i believe allowing this property to be
built would do just the opposite!
It seems to me that someone who is not familiar with the area or the people should not have
the right to infringe such a place on us residents.
I am a resident of Glendale, AZ in Maricopa County. I live in Secluded Acres. I strongly
oppose allowing this property to be built.
Please vote against this horrid encroachment of our homes.
Thank you for your consideration.
Respectfully
Jackie Rosenecker
From:
Skip Crandall
To:
Taylor, Matthew
Subject:
StayApt 73rd Ave and San Xavier
Date:
Sunday, June 18, 2023 9:23:18 AM
[You don't often get email from skipcrandall@hotmail.com. Learn why this is important at
https://aka.ms/LearnAboutSenderIdentification ]
Matthew,
I am one of the three residents officially notified of the planned extended stay hotel on 73rd Avenue and Camino
San Xavier. This lot is not zoned residential (hence the need for the CUP). I’m 100% against this being built. It is
the wrong land use. Fortunately the CUP requires community involvement and you will be hearing from our
neighborhood in force. This low cost extended stay hotel would literally be a 30 second walk from the trailhead
accessed by the neighborhood at the end of 73rd Ave (there are only nine ball signs there). It would also be in plain
view from several residents front and back yards. We appreciate your support in sharing our concerns. There will
be a large presence at any community meetings and public meetings (most recent one delayed by Councilman
Malnar based on community concerns). Thank you for a acknowledgement of this this email and sharing as
required.
Ronald Crandall
7331 W Angela Drive
Glendale, AZ 85308
623-687-6684
From:
Glenda Dunshee
To:
Taylor, Matthew
Subject:
StayApt Extended Stay proposal
Date:
Sunday, June 18, 2023 7:07:57 PM
[You don't often get email from g.dunshee@yahoo.com. Learn why this is important at
https://aka.ms/LearnAboutSenderIdentification ]
We do not want the StayApt Extended Stay hotel built in our area. We have great concern about the increased crime
that this will bring into our neighborhood. This is a quiet neighborhood where families with children and elderly
people can enjoy living. We do not want to have to worry about the the elements this type of transient housing
brings. And our home values will go down since they will have no pride in keeping our community clean and safe.
So again we say NO to StayApt Extended Stay!!!
Sent from my iPhone
From:
bkhutton@cox.net
To:
Taylor, Matthew
Subject:
FW: Proposed StayApt concerns
Date:
Sunday, June 18, 2023 12:39:19 PM
You don't often get email from bkhutton@cox.net. Learn why this is important
Hello Mr. Taylor –
I’ve been informed we need to send our citizen feedback to you; so it
can be shared with the Planning Committee.
Please refer to the following; which I sent to Mr. Malnar on 5/28.
Thanks very much for your help in getting our voices heard,
Brenda Hutton
(an extremely concerned resident of Secluded Acres)
From: bkhutton@cox.net <bkhutton@cox.net>
Sent: Tuesday, May 23, 2023 8:59 AM
To: 'rmalnar@glendaleAZ.com' <rmalnar@glendaleAZ.com>
Subject: Proposed StayApt concerns
Hello Mr. Malnar –
Thank you for representing our district so well. Your efforts are tremendously appreciated.
I’m writing because I just learned of the proposed temporary stay hotel (in the vacant lot
behind Michaels).
As a resident of the Secluded Acres subdivision; upon learning of this proposal; the
following concerns come to mind:
1. Franchisee is out of state
2. Franchisee likely has no experience with AZ (or truly cares about AZ lifestyle)
3. The height of the building (3 stories) will further block views and increase the heat
island
4. Volume of rooms (76 is what I understand) – multiply that times several individuals
staying in one room and it’s like a mini-city of humans
5. Limited parking requirements – where will the extra vehicles end up parking?
6. Extended stay type hotels are conducive to many types of criminal activity as well as
transient populations
7. Law enforcement is already stretched extremely thin – there are no additional
provisions for monitoring this facility
8. At this point, my largest concerns are this will introduce more criminal activity and 24
hour activity to what is typically a quiet neighborhood.
Please let me know what I can do to help prevent this proposal from becoming a reality.
Thank you,
Brenda Hutton
From:
Christella Cruz
To:
Taylor, Matthew
Subject:
Opposition StayApt
Date:
Monday, June 19, 2023 9:45:59 AM
You don't often get email from christella7312@yahoo.com. Learn why this is important
Mr. Taylor,
My name is Judith. My family and I have lived in Secluded Acres for a little over a year.
I am writing this letter to express my strong opposition to allowing StayApt to be built in our
neighborhood.
Sir, our primary concern is the amount of traffic this will bring to our quiet Secluded Acres
neighborhood. We moved here specifically for the tranquil neighborhood. The area in
question is NOT ZONED for a hotel OR residential housing. Please do not change the zoning
now to accommodate StayApt.
Best regards,
Judith Christella Cruz
7401 W. Villa Rita Dr.
Sent from Yahoo Mail on Android
From:
Crystal Viglietta
To:
Taylor, Matthew
Subject:
Opposition to Stay Apt
Date:
Monday, June 19, 2023 4:23:43 PM
You don't often get email from crystalmviglietta@gmail.com. Learn why this is important
Dear Mr. Taylor,
We hope this letter finds you well. We are writing to express our strong opposition to the
proposed building of the Stay Apt, proposed to be built at 7300 W. Camino San Xavier. This
proposed extended-stay hotel is in an area not zoned for such a development and in close
proximity to residential homes. We have significant concerns about the potential negative
impact this project may have on our community and specifically the Secluded Acres
Neighborhood, including the decline of property values and an increase in crime rates.
Firstly, constructing an extended-stay hotel in an area not designated for such purposes goes
against established zoning regulations. These regulations are put in place to ensure the
harmonious development and protection of residential neighborhoods. Allowing the
construction of Stay Apt in this area sets a concerning precedent that could lead to further
disregarding of zoning laws, ultimately affecting the character and integrity of our community.
Moreover, the close proximity of the proposed Stay Apt hotel to residential homes raises valid
concerns about the potential adverse effects on property values. Research has consistently
shown that the presence of commercial establishments, such as hotels, in residential areas can
have a detrimental impact on property values. Homeowners in the vicinity of the hotel would
likely experience a decrease in property values, making it more challenging for them to sell
their properties or obtain favorable financing options. This decline in property values could
have far-reaching consequences for the entire community.
Furthermore, the potential increase in crime associated with an extended-stay hotel is a
significant concern. Extended-stay hotels often attract a transient population and can become
hotspots for criminal activities. As a result, the safety and security of residents in the
surrounding area may be compromised. This issue should be taken seriously, as the well-being
of the community should always be a top priority.
Considering these points, we kindly request that the City of Glendale carefully reconsider the
approval and deny the Stay Apt extended stay hotel project in its current proposed location.
While we understand the importance of development and progress, it is crucial to prioritize
our community's long-term well-being and stability. We urge the city authorities to explore
alternative locations that are more suitable for an extended-stay hotel, keeping in mind the
established zoning regulations and the concerns of the residents.
Thank you for taking the time to review our concerns. We trust that the city officials will give
due consideration to the potential negative impact of the Stay Apt extended stay hotel on the
community and make a decision that reflects the best interests of the surrounding
neighborhood.
Yours sincerely,
Ben & Crystal Viglietta
Secluded Acres Residents
7301 W Union Hills Drive
Glendale, AZ 85308
crystalmviglietta@gmail.com
623-341-3984
Emails sent and received shall not create a binding contract or acceptance of an offer until the written contract is signed by all parties. If
your property is currently listed with a Realtor, please disregard this, it is not our intention to solicit the offerings of other Brokers. We are
happy to work with them and cooperate fully.
From:
Monica Manning
To:
Taylor, Matthew
Cc:
Chris Manning
Subject:
Opposed to the Extended Stay on Camino San Xavier
Date:
Tuesday, June 20, 2023 1:59:22 PM
Attachments:
image001.png
You don't often get email from monica@themanningregroup.com. Learn why this is important
Mr. Taylor,
My name is Monica Manning. I am writing to you to oppose CUP 23-04 for StayApt at 7300 W.
Camino San Xavier.
My husband and I have 3 children and have in Secluded Acres for 11 years. This is a safe, quiet
neighborhood. We chose this location after my husband and I researched many areas in town. I am
a real estate broker, and pride myself in neighborhood research for clients - more importantly for my
family.
Adding an extended stay with direct access to our neighborhood is an incredible safety concern.
Further, I would not have purchased my home, nor advocated for my clients to buy in this
neighborhood had the extended stay already been built. They are notorious for illegal activity.
As a real estate broker, I can assure you this establishment will drastically reduce the value of the
homes in this area. The City will then become directly liable.
We vehemently oppose this establishment, and any other 24 hour business at 7300 W. Camino San
Xavier.
Regards,
Chris and Monica Manning
photo
Monica Manning, Associate Broker
Manning RE Group, EPIC Home Realty
Call/Text 602-321-9304
www.themanningregroup.com
9059 W. Lake Pleasant pkwy G700
Peoria, Az 85382
From:
NoTo StayApt
To:
Rosemary Chambers
Cc:
Taylor, Matthew
Subject:
Re: Extended stay apartments
Date:
Tuesday, June 20, 2023 3:30:03 PM
Thanks, Rosemary! I added Mr. Taylor to the email.
On Tue, Jun 20, 2023 at 2:31 PM Rosemary Chambers <rc85308@yahoo.com> wrote:
To whom this may concern, we are totally against this project going in our area. Thank you
very much.
Sent from my iPhone
From:
MaryAnn
To:
Taylor, Matthew
Subject:
StayApt “hotel”
Date:
Wednesday, June 21, 2023 7:49:27 AM
Dear Mr Taylor,
My family, friends, and I are very concerned about the building of the StayApt “hotel”, at 7300 W Camino San
Xavier, Glendale, AZ. We are wondering who is going to be staying there. Is it going to be a government funded
for low income people? A halfway house? A rehab facility? A facility for immigrants? We are as a community
who live close to this want to know this information. We are looking forward to hearing from you or Mr Malnar as
the purpose of this facility.
Thank you, Mary Ann Brown
18203 N 69th Dr
Glendale, AZ 85308
Sent from my iPad
From:
Debbie Carlston
To:
Taylor, Matthew; Debbie Carlston
Subject:
Stay Apt. 73rd / Union Hills / 75th in Glendale, AZ 85308
Date:
Wednesday, June 21, 2023 9:38:00 PM
You don't often get email from 2vettenut@gmail.com. Learn why this is important
Dear Matthew Taylor,
My name is Debbie Carlston and I live on West Villa Theresa Dr. off of Union Hills and 73rd.
(7116 ). I am very much opposed for Stay Apt.s to goin and house people in our area, that is
proposed.
I am very concerned for Safety reasons.
There is an elementary school close and I feel it will not be safe for those who chose to walk
and ride bikes.
I walk the neighborhood and ride my bicycle and with the housing proposed I will not feel
safe....Which is why I live here.
We have a daughter who I will be extremely concerned for her safety.
Garbage and litter issues.....noise.
This is a quiet and safe neighborhood, I feel it would damage our neighborhoods safety, and
more.
I understand that everyone deserves a home or a place to live. This is not the neighborhood
for this housing.
Please take this into strong consideration.....We do not want to feel unsafe and that is exactly
how we will feel.
Thank you....concerned,
Debbie Carlston
7116 West Villa Theresa Dr
Glendale, AZ 85308
From:
Robin Giordano
To:
Taylor, Matthew
Subject:
STAY APT
Date:
Wednesday, June 21, 2023 2:33:31 PM
You don't often get email from robin.giordano@gmail.com. Learn why this is important
To whom it may concern :
I am NOT in favor of this STAY APT in MY neighborhood !
I have been in Secluded Acres for over 20 yr. & live right off 73rd Ave.
I know the Fire Marshall will make 73rd be opened for safety reasons. If this 3 story complex
is built. That means TRAFFIC which is hazardous for our children. 73rd Ave has school Bus
Stops for our children to go back & forth to school & home. This is a BIG concern for our
children's safety, not to mention this is an Equestrian neighborhood with Horses properties
right on 73rd, the traffic will also have an effect on them.
The area in question as I understand it is NOT ZONED for hotel or residential housing. I feel
this kind of business will bring in more crime,sex trafficking and drugs to our areas as I follow
the news and these properties are used this way.
This area has many retail shops & restaurants. What environmental impact will this have on
these businesses ? Not to mention our neighborhood.
My daughter works over in that area & has walked to & from work. It is so close but with
having something like this between our house & her job I would make her drive for her own
safety. Bringing her an extra expense She is a single parent of 2 young children. Our
grandchildren & daughter are our biggest concern as she is trying to get back on her feet .
This is our neighborhood. People should not have the right to infringe on something like this
in our neighborhood where we live. I don't think you would want something like this in your
neighborhood where your family walks & waits for the school bus. These are High school &
Elementary age children.
I would appreciate it if you could take some consideration in voting against this.
Sincerely
Robin Giordano
From:
declinedit@yahoo.com
To:
Taylor, Matthew
Subject:
STAYAPT application for transient lodging at 7300 W.Camino San Xavier
Date:
Wednesday, June 21, 2023 3:53:03 PM
[You don't often get email from declinedit@yahoo.com. Learn why this is important at
https://aka.ms/LearnAboutSenderIdentification ]
Dear Mr. Taylor,
This email is directed to your attention to protest any approval by the City of Glendale for transient lodging, hotels,
or apartments, on the parcel located at 7300 W. Camino San Xavier. This location is not zoned for, and is not
suitable for, such business.
Thank you,
Edward Igoe
From:
Lisa Lund
To:
Taylor, Matthew
Cc:
Matt Oliver
Subject:
Extended Stay at 7300 W Camino San Xavier Glendale, AZ 85308
Date:
Wednesday, June 21, 2023 4:44:05 PM
Attachments:
image001.png
You don't often get email from lisal@lundmortgage.com. Learn why this is important
Mr. Taylor,
My name is Lisa Lund. I am also the owner and operator of 2 businesses in the area of 7300 W.
Camino San Xavier. Both Matt Oliver and I own 2 buildings and run two businesses out of them.
It has come to my attention that StayApt, an extended stay hotel, has applied for a Conditional Use
Permit.
Not only are extended stay type hotels notorious for criminal activity, but our zone is also not
permitted to have any 24-hour activity.
My business partners and I vehemently oppose this type of business in the area.
Please consider this a letter of opposition for CUP 23-04.
Regards,
Matt Oliver
623-606-6515 Cell
Lisa Lund
Broker/Owner
623.875.9940
623-606-6515
lisal@lundmortgage.com
lundmortgageteam.com
7170 W Camino San Xavier, Ste A104
Glendale, AZ 85308
***Due to the ongoing impact of COVID-19 we are requesting that you please inform our office
immediately if: You have been laid off, been furloughed, had reduction in pay, or are thinking
about loan forgivenss/forebearance options. ***
From:
Matt Oliver
To:
Taylor, Matthew
Subject:
Extended Stay at 7300 W Camino San Xavier, Glendale, AZ
Date:
Wednesday, June 21, 2023 4:38:07 PM
You don't often get email from matto@lundmortgage.com. Learn why this is important
Mr. Taylor,
My name is Matt Oliver. I am the owner and operator of 2 businesses in the area of 7300 W. Camino
San Xavier.
It has come to my attention that StayApt, an extended stay hotel, has applied for a Conditional Use
Permit.
Not only are extended stay type hotels notorious for criminal activity, but our zone is also not
permitted to have any 24-hour activity.
My business partners and I vehemently oppose this type of business in the area.
Please consider this a letter of opposition for CUP 23-04.
Regards,
Matt Oliver
602 628 4010 – Cell
You don't often get email from declinedit@yahoo.com. Learn why this is important
From:
Taylor, Matthew
To:
declinedit@yahoo.com
Subject:
RE: STAYAPT application for transient lodging at 7300 W.Camino San Xavier
Date:
Thursday, June 22, 2023 1:16:00 PM
Attachments:
image001.png
Good afternoon Mr. Igoe,
Thank you for your inquiry regarding CUP23-04.
The applicant is requesting a continuance. The exact date will be stated at the Planning Commission
public hearing, but it is anticipated the continuance will be to August 24, 2023.
The applicant and city have met all public notification requirements for today’s public hearing, so re-
notification for the August 24, 2023, public hearing is not required. We will have the applicant
change the hearing date on the sign currently posted on the property.
You have my contact information – feel free to reach out at any time for updates on this application.
Thank you.
From: declinedit@yahoo.com <declinedit@yahoo.com>
Sent: Thursday, June 22, 2023 1:03 PM
To: Taylor, Matthew <MTaylor@GLENDALEAZ.com>
Subject: Re: STAYAPT application for transient lodging at 7300 W.Camino San Xavier
Dear Mr. Taylor,
It has come to my attention that the noticed hearing on this matter has been postponed. May I
presume that the City will officially re-notice the new scheduled date by correspondence and posted
signage?
Thank you,
Edward Igoe
On Wednesday, June 21, 2023 at 03:52:52 PM PDT, <declinedit@yahoo.com> wrote:
Dear Mr. Taylor,
This email is directed to your attention to protest any approval by the City of Glendale for transient
lodging, hotels, or apartments, on the parcel located at 7300 W. Camino San Xavier. This location is
not zoned for, and is not suitable for, such business.
Thank you,
Edward Igoe
From:
Matt Oliver
To:
Taylor, Matthew
Cc:
Lisa Lund
Subject:
RE: Extended Stay at 7300 W Camino San Xavier, Glendale, AZ
Date:
Thursday, June 22, 2023 10:21:53 AM
You don't often get email from matto@lundmortgage.com. Learn why this is important
Mr Taylor,
I wanted to add that we own a building at the 7100 block of Camino San Xavier – It’s a salon suite
building that has anywhere from 35 – 42 small business owners that do hair, nails, etc. They have a
lot of clients that come in and out of that building on a daily basis.
We’re now being told that if this Modern Stay / StayApt project does get put in, that our tenants will
be looking to move their businesses elsewhere. This would be a huge blow to our business, our
building, etc.
We pay quarterly taxes to the City of Glendale and that would also be gone as well as the value of
the building decreasing.
This is why we’re VEHEMENTLY against the Modern Stay / StayApt project.
We DO NOT WANT these types of businesses in the surrounding area!!!
Thank you,
Matt Oliver
602 628 4010
From: Matt Oliver
Sent: Wednesday, June 21, 2023 4:38 PM
To: 'mtaylor@glendaleaz.com' <mtaylor@glendaleaz.com>
Subject: Extended Stay at 7300 W Camino San Xavier, Glendale, AZ
Mr. Taylor,
My name is Matt Oliver. I am the owner and operator of 2 businesses in the area of 7300 W. Camino
San Xavier.
It has come to my attention that StayApt, an extended stay hotel, has applied for a Conditional Use
Permit.
Not only are extended stay type hotels notorious for criminal activity, but our zone is also not
permitted to have any 24-hour activity.
My business partners and I vehemently oppose this type of business in the area.
Please consider this a letter of opposition for CUP 23-04.
Regards,
Matt Oliver
602 628 4010 – Cell
From:
NoTo StayApt
To:
Lori Gray
Cc:
Taylor, Matthew; rmalnar@glendalaz.com
Subject:
Re: No apartments in our neighborhood.
Date:
Monday, June 26, 2023 6:38:54 AM
Hi Lori,
Thanks for your email!
I have passed it on to Matthew Taylor, Senior Planner for City of Glendale, and Ray Malnar,
Councilman.
Thanks again!
On Sat, Jun 24, 2023 at 6:40 PM Lori Gray <lorigray1959@icloud.com> wrote:
Sent from my iPhone
From:
Gary Carlston
To:
Taylor, Matthew
Cc:
Gary Carlston
Subject:
Opposition to StayApt
Date:
Sunday, June 25, 2023 1:57:08 PM
[You don't often get email from 1vettenut@gmail.com. Learn why this is important at
https://aka.ms/LearnAboutSenderIdentification ]
Dear Matthew Taylor,
My name is Gary Carlston and I live on West Villa Theresa Dr. off of
Union Hills and 73rd Ave. I am very much opposed to the proposed
StayApt going in and house people in our area.
I am very concerned for Safety reasons.
There is an elementary school close and I feel it will not be safe for
those who choose to walk and ride bikes in our neighborhood.
I walk the neighborhood and ride my bicycle but with the housing
proposed I will not feel safe....One of the reasons why I live here.
We have a daughter whom I will be extremely concerned for her safety.
Garbage and litter issues in addition to noise.
This is a quiet and safe neighborhood, I feel it would damage our
neighborhoods safety, and more.
I understand that everyone deserves a home or a place to live. This is
not the neighborhood for this housing.
Lastly, I feel this will negatively impact the property values in our
neighborhood.
Please take my concerns into strong consideration.....We do not want
StayApt in our neighborhood.
Thank you. A very concerned Glendale resident.
Gary Carlston
7116 W. Villa Theresa Dr.
Glendale, AZ 85308
From:
Taylor, Matthew
To:
Erin Cole
Cc:
Shaine T. Alleman; Perry, Tabitha; Huggins Jr, Randy
Subject:
RE: CUP 23-04 - 7300 W. Camino San Xavier - StayApt
Date:
Wednesday, June 28, 2023 4:32:00 PM
Attachments:
image001.png
Erin,
Staff’s recommendation for approval follows these findings sequentially and is contained in the staff
report (which you’ve seen). Attempting a detailed discussion of the findings via email will be
impractical.
If you have homeowners and business owners contacting you directly about the findings, please
inform them they can also contact me with their questions about the required findings. Of course,
specific questions about the project itself can be directed to the applicant.
I am available to discuss the staff report with you via phone call or virtual meeting. Feel free to
continue reaching out with questions as we approach the August 7th neighborhood meeting and
August 24th Planning Commission public hearing.
Thank you.
From: Erin Cole <erinscole@gmail.com>
Sent: Wednesday, June 28, 2023 2:01 PM
To: Taylor, Matthew <MTaylor@GLENDALEAZ.com>
Cc: Shaine T. Alleman <sta@tblaw.com>; Perry, Tabitha <TPerry@GLENDALEAZ.com>; Huggins Jr,
Randy <RHuggins@GLENDALEAZ.com>
Subject: Re: CUP 23-04 - 7300 W. Camino San Xavier - StayApt
STOP, THINK, READ.
This email contains keywords that are known to link to malicious content.
Use caution when clicking on links as they could open malicious sites. DO NOT enter City credentials or
provide personal data if you are unsure of the website.
- City of Glendale IT ServiceDesk
Wonderful, thank you!
In addition, numerous concerned homeowners and business owners are asking what the criteria are
for the City to recommend approval vs. rejection for each of the required findings. I am unsure, and
hope your expertise could speak to that. I will gladly pass along any information as soon as you're
able to respond.
Thanks,
Erin
On Wed, Jun 28, 2023 at 12:38 PM Taylor, Matthew <MTaylor@glendaleaz.com> wrote:
Good afternoon,
Following up on my voicemail from this morning-
As the case manager of this land use application, you can continue to direct your questions to me.
Your original message stated you wished to have written responses to your questions prior to the
August neighborhood meeting – I understand you are now looking for a more immediate
response. Your questions with written responses below:
Question #1: “Regarding the April 10 notice, who is an "interested party", and how did he/she
become "interested"? To whom were postcards sent? How do I obtain receipts?”
Response: Per Section 3.900 of the zoning ordinance, applicants notify
owners of properties located within 300’ as measured from property line to
property line. Additionally, we provide a list of interested parties to the applicant
and these individuals are also notified. Interested parties are individuals who have
signed up to be notified of land development activities within their respective
council districts. Individuals may also request to be added to all interested party
lists.
The city sent notification postcards to owners of property within 300’ in
accordance with Section 3.806 of the zoning ordinance as well as individuals
identified on the council district interested parties list. You can request digital
copies of these lists by filing a public records request through the City Clerk’s
office at City Clerk - City of Glendale (glendaleaz.com). The city utilizes a third-
party vendor for mailings. We do not receive receipts, but we do receive vendor
confirmation that the applicant paid these fees and the specific fulfillment date
postcards will be mailed.
Question #2: “Please provide a copy of the published notice in the Arizona
Republic from May 31. In my searching, I cannot seem to find it for my records.
Below are the two links I used in an attempt to locate the notice. Perhaps you
have a better way...”
Response: We have a publisher proof confirming the legal ad ran on May 31,
2023. You can request a digital copy of this proof by submitting a public records
request through the City Clerk’s office at City Clerk - City of Glendale
(glendaleaz.com).
Question #3: “Regarding the May 26 notice, to whom were postcards sent? I
would assume I would qualify as an "interested party" after providing my contact
information to Mr. Alleman. I have never received a postcard, nor any
communication from him, his client, nor his firm.”
Response: The city sent postcards to owners of property within 300’ in
accordance with Section 3.806 of the zoning ordinance as well as individuals
identified on the council district interested parties list. You can request digital
copies of these lists by filing a public records request through the City Clerk’s
office at City Clerk - City of Glendale (glendaleaz.com).
Postcards were mailed May 31, 2023. This city mailing was 22-days prior to the
June 22nd Planning Commission public hearing, meeting the 15-day mailing in
advance of the public hearing requirement of the zoning ordinance. The actual
mailing date will be read into the record during the public hearing. You can
request digital copies of the postcards and vendor confirmation by filing a public
records request through the City Clerk’s office at City Clerk - City of Glendale
(glendaleaz.com).
Question #4: “The posted sign in the subject lot states it was posted June 2.
The report states June 7. I did not see the sign until June 10. Granted, it is all but
invisible as it is conveniently tucked next to the only overgrown foliage on the lot.
Thus, what is the actual posted notice date?”
Response: The applicant posted the sign on June 2nd, 20-days prior to the
scheduled June 22nd Planning Commission public hearing, meeting the 15-day
property posting in advance of the public hearing requirement of the zoning
ordinance. The actual posting date will be read into the record during the public
hearing.
The applicant provided the required affidavit of posting along with a photo of the
posted sign. You can request digital copies of these files by filing a public records
request through the City Clerk’s office at City Clerk - City of Glendale
(glendaleaz.com).
Question #5: “According to the North Valley Specific Area Plan, 24-hour activity
is not permitted for any businesses in the vicinity. Further, zero activity is
permitted from 2200-0600. This, in and of itself, is reason to find a better suitable
business for this lot, and to assist Mr. Alleman in finding one for his "professionals,
medical staff, military, and leisure travelers".”
Response: The subject property is zoned PAD (Planned Area Development)
pursuant to zoning application Z-89-09. The purpose of this zoning case was to
Some people who received this message don't often get email from erinscole@gmail.com. Learn why this is
important
implement the North Valley Specific Area Plan (GP89-04); therefore, the approved
zoning is in conformance with the land uses and densities established by the
General Plan and later amended by the North Valley Specific Area Plan. General
plans are adopted by resolution; zoning ordinances are adopted by ordinance,
superseding the plan.
The approved PAD authorizes uses allowed in C-2 (General Commercial) for the
subject property – the PAD does not identify hotels as a prohibited use. Per
Section 5.754.H of the zoning ordinance, “Hotels and motels” are allowed in C-2
with the approval of a Conditional Use Permit (CUP), requiring a public hearing
before the Planning Commission with approval subject to 5 findings (analysis of
these findings is contained in the staff report). The public hearing, continued to
August 24, 2023, provides citizens the opportunity to express concerns before
the Commission prior to a vote to approve or deny an application.
If you wish to be added to the interested parties list, please provide your complete mailing
address and specify if you want to be placed specifically on the Sahuaro District list or if you want
to be added to all 5 council district lists.
Should these responses not fully answer your questions, please contact me.
Thank you.
From: Erin Cole <erinscole@gmail.com>
Sent: Tuesday, June 27, 2023 8:58 PM
To: Shaine T. Alleman <sta@tblaw.com>; Taylor, Matthew <MTaylor@GLENDALEAZ.com>; Perry,
Tabitha <TPerry@GLENDALEAZ.com>
Subject: Re: CUP 23-04 - 7300 W. Camino San Xavier - StayApt
Mr. Alleman,
Thank you for your reply. I'll pass along your message.
Mr. Taylor,
Is there another member of the City with whom I should be directing questions? Kindly reply to
the line items requested.
We look forward to an honest, and productive meeting.
Erin Cole
602.770.9799
erinscole@gmail.com
From:
Erin Cole
To:
Taylor, Matthew
Cc:
Shaine T. Alleman; Perry, Tabitha; Huggins Jr, Randy
Subject:
Re: CUP 23-04 - 7300 W. Camino San Xavier - StayApt
Date:
Thursday, June 29, 2023 8:50:02 AM
Attachments:
image001.png
Thanks, Mr. Taylor,
For the record, and to add to the Commission's Packet - Mr. Alleman is refusing to answer
specific questions about the project (as evidenced by email), and has refused to redact/correct
his false statements therein. It is impossible to receive information from the applicant as he is
failing to provide it as of this writing. If another party wants to speak on his behalf, kindly
direct me.
Thanks,
Erin
On Wed, Jun 28, 2023 at 4:32 PM Taylor, Matthew <MTaylor@glendaleaz.com> wrote:
Erin,
Staff’s recommendation for approval follows these findings sequentially and is contained in
the staff report (which you’ve seen). Attempting a detailed discussion of the findings via
email will be impractical.
If you have homeowners and business owners contacting you directly about the findings,
please inform them they can also contact me with their questions about the required
findings. Of course, specific questions about the project itself can be directed to the
applicant.
I am available to discuss the staff report with you via phone call or virtual meeting. Feel free
to continue reaching out with questions as we approach the August 7th neighborhood
meeting and August 24th Planning Commission public hearing.
Thank you.
From: Erin Cole <erinscole@gmail.com>
Sent: Wednesday, June 28, 2023 2:01 PM
To: Taylor, Matthew <MTaylor@GLENDALEAZ.com>
Cc: Shaine T. Alleman <sta@tblaw.com>; Perry, Tabitha <TPerry@GLENDALEAZ.com>;
Huggins Jr, Randy <RHuggins@GLENDALEAZ.com>
Subject: Re: CUP 23-04 - 7300 W. Camino San Xavier - StayApt
STOP, THINK, READ.
This email contains keywords that are known to link to malicious content.
Use caution when clicking on links as they could open malicious sites. DO NOT enter City credentials
or provide personal data if you are unsure of the website.
- City of Glendale IT ServiceDesk
Wonderful, thank you!
In addition, numerous concerned homeowners and business owners are asking what the
criteria are for the City to recommend approval vs. rejection for each of the required
findings. I am unsure, and hope your expertise could speak to that. I will gladly pass along
any information as soon as you're able to respond.
Thanks,
Erin
On Wed, Jun 28, 2023 at 12:38 PM Taylor, Matthew <MTaylor@glendaleaz.com> wrote:
Good afternoon,
Following up on my voicemail from this morning-
As the case manager of this land use application, you can continue to direct your
questions to me. Your original message stated you wished to have written responses to
your questions prior to the August neighborhood meeting – I understand you are now
looking for a more immediate response. Your questions with written responses below:
Question #1: “Regarding the April 10 notice, who is an "interested party", and how did
he/she become "interested"? To whom were postcards sent? How do I obtain receipts?”
Response: Per Section 3.900 of the zoning ordinance, applicants
notify owners of properties located within 300’ as measured from property
line to property line. Additionally, we provide a list of interested parties to
the applicant and these individuals are also notified. Interested parties are
individuals who have signed up to be notified of land development
activities within their respective council districts. Individuals may also
request to be added to all interested party lists.
The city sent notification postcards to owners of property within 300’ in
accordance with Section 3.806 of the zoning ordinance as well as
individuals identified on the council district interested parties list. You can
request digital copies of these lists by filing a public records request
through the City Clerk’s office at City Clerk - City of Glendale
(glendaleaz.com). The city utilizes a third-party vendor for mailings. We
do not receive receipts, but we do receive vendor confirmation that the
applicant paid these fees and the specific fulfillment date postcards will be
mailed.
Question #2: “Please provide a copy of the published notice in the
Arizona Republic from May 31. In my searching, I cannot seem to find it
for my records. Below are the two links I used in an attempt to locate
the notice. Perhaps you have a better way...”
Response: We have a publisher proof confirming the legal ad ran on
May 31, 2023. You can request a digital copy of this proof by submitting a
public records request through the City Clerk’s office at City Clerk - City
of Glendale (glendaleaz.com).
Question #3: “Regarding the May 26 notice, to whom were postcards
sent? I would assume I would qualify as an "interested party" after
providing my contact information to Mr. Alleman. I have never received a
postcard, nor any communication from him, his client, nor his firm.”
Response: The city sent postcards to owners of property within 300’
in accordance with Section 3.806 of the zoning ordinance as well as
individuals identified on the council district interested parties list. You can
request digital copies of these lists by filing a public records request
through the City Clerk’s office at City Clerk - City of Glendale
(glendaleaz.com).
Postcards were mailed May 31, 2023. This city mailing was 22-days prior
to the June 22nd Planning Commission public hearing, meeting the 15-day
mailing in advance of the public hearing requirement of the zoning
ordinance. The actual mailing date will be read into the record during the
public hearing. You can request digital copies of the postcards and vendor
confirmation by filing a public records request through the City Clerk’s
office at City Clerk - City of Glendale (glendaleaz.com).
Question #4: “The posted sign in the subject lot states it was posted
June 2. The report states June 7. I did not see the sign until June 10.
Granted, it is all but invisible as it is conveniently tucked next to the only
overgrown foliage on the lot. Thus, what is the actual posted notice date?”
Response: The applicant posted the sign on June 2nd, 20-days prior
to the scheduled June 22nd Planning Commission public hearing, meeting
the 15-day property posting in advance of the public hearing requirement
of the zoning ordinance. The actual posting date will be read into the
record during the public hearing.
The applicant provided the required affidavit of posting along with a photo
of the posted sign. You can request digital copies of these files by filing a
public records request through the City Clerk’s office at City Clerk - City
of Glendale (glendaleaz.com).
Question #5: “According to the North Valley Specific Area Plan, 24-
hour activity is not permitted for any businesses in the vicinity. Further,
zero activity is permitted from 2200-0600. This, in and of itself, is reason
to find a better suitable business for this lot, and to assist Mr. Alleman in
finding one for his "professionals, medical staff, military, and leisure
travelers".”
Response: The subject property is zoned PAD (Planned Area
Development) pursuant to zoning application Z-89-09. The purpose of this
zoning case was to implement the North Valley Specific Area Plan (GP89-
04); therefore, the approved zoning is in conformance with the land uses
and densities established by the General Plan and later amended by the
North Valley Specific Area Plan. General plans are adopted by resolution;
zoning ordinances are adopted by ordinance, superseding the plan.
The approved PAD authorizes uses allowed in C-2 (General Commercial)
for the subject property – the PAD does not identify hotels as a prohibited
use. Per Section 5.754.H of the zoning ordinance, “Hotels and motels” are
allowed in C-2 with the approval of a Conditional Use Permit (CUP),
requiring a public hearing before the Planning Commission with approval
subject to 5 findings (analysis of these findings is contained in the staff
report). The public hearing, continued to August 24, 2023, provides
citizens the opportunity to express concerns before the Commission prior
to a vote to approve or deny an application.
If you wish to be added to the interested parties list, please provide your complete mailing
address and specify if you want to be placed specifically on the Sahuaro District list or if
you want to be added to all 5 council district lists.
Should these responses not fully answer your questions, please contact me.
Thank you.
Some people who received this message don't often get email from erinscole@gmail.com. Learn why this is
important
From: Erin Cole <erinscole@gmail.com>
Sent: Tuesday, June 27, 2023 8:58 PM
To: Shaine T. Alleman <sta@tblaw.com>; Taylor, Matthew
<MTaylor@GLENDALEAZ.com>; Perry, Tabitha <TPerry@GLENDALEAZ.com>
Subject: Re: CUP 23-04 - 7300 W. Camino San Xavier - StayApt
Mr. Alleman,
Thank you for your reply. I'll pass along your message.
Mr. Taylor,
Is there another member of the City with whom I should be directing questions? Kindly
reply to the line items requested.
We look forward to an honest, and productive meeting.
Erin Cole
602.770.9799
erinscole@gmail.com
From:
Todd VanDriel
To:
jameshoaz@gmail.com; Taylor, Matthew
Cc:
Stacy Van Driel; Stacy Van Driel; notostayapt@gmail.com
Subject:
No to CUP 23-04
Date:
Thursday, June 29, 2023 12:15:17 PM
You don't often get email from azfirecapt63@gmail.com. Learn why this is important
Mr. Taylor and Mr. Ho,
My name is Todd. I am a resident of Secluded Acres and Estates. I am writing to you both in
opposition of CUP 23-04, StayApt.
I am a retired Firefighter and paramedic, serving our community for over 28 years. Next
month, I am retiring from the US Navy after 20 years. That said, I have years of experience
with medical and fire calls from extended stays in our community, most of which do not end
well.
Extended stays are hubs for crime - drugs, prostitution, sex trafficking, just to name a few.
And while this company states they will not market to transients, since they have the same
price point as the extended stay across the street, they will attract the same clientele. It is
simple business math.
Mr. Ho - as a retired firefighter, I am concerned about access to the proposed building for
rescue vehicles. Is there data to show that an engine can access the 3-story building? Do we
have photos or video to show that an engine, an ambulance, a Battalion chief, and civilian
vehicles can navigate Camino San Xavier east bound from 75th Ave?
Mr. Taylor, I can only assume you would not discount my expertise, and proceed with
approval of such a danger and detriment to our community. Please assist this franchisee with
a lot that is far from a residential area, and more conducive to 24-hour activity.
Respectfully,
HMCS Van Driel, Todd
Regional LCPO (Central) NR NMRTC San Diego
Navy Medicine Readiness and Training Command San Diego Headquarters
todd.vandriel@navy.mil
azfirecapt63@gmail.com
C: 480-703-8665
From:
Webb, Stacy
To:
Taylor, Matthew; JamesHoAZ@gmail.com
Cc:
Stacy Webb; Webb, Stacy; Todd VanDriel
Subject:
Opposition to CUP 23-04
Date:
Thursday, June 29, 2023 9:37:18 AM
You don't often get email from stacywebb@ltic.com. Learn why this is important
This message was sent securely using Zix®
Mr. Taylor and Mr. Ho,
My name is Stacy. My husband and I are both AZ Natives, and have been in the Valley for decades.
My family and I live in Secluded Acres and Estates, and I work just over a mile from the area. While
my family and I moved here just under 5 years ago, this area has been a desired location for me for
more than 30 years. We chose this neighborhood because of its quiet, peaceful, safe, secluded feel.
We knew it would be a great place for our family.
I am asking you to reject the CUP 23-04 based on the introduction of 24-hour activity to our
neighborhood and increase in traffic (pedestrian and vehicle).
Many people use our neighborhood to bypass the intersection of 75th Ave and Union Hills. We do
not need increased traffic coming in and out of our residential streets for people looking for a short
cut to their extended stay. We do not need people attempting to pass through the end of 73rd
Avenue. We do not need overflow parking into our residential streets as the proposed parking lot
hardly accommodates the amount of apartments, and staff. I have encouraged surrounding
businesses to reach out to you both with concerns of parking and traffic.
Have either of you driven from 75th Ave to the subject lot? I would be interested to see if two
vehicles can even maneuver that curve at the same time.
Do you know about the equestrian/biking/walking trail at the end of 73rd Avenue? That is less than
a 90 second walk from the proposed site to a school bus stop.
Mr. Taylor, this business is not conducive to family life, and the quiet neighborhood in which we live.
I am asking you to change your recommendation to reject CUP 23-04, and propose a more
appropriate site for an extended stay hotel.
Mr. Ho, please consider this email as a "transportation concern", and forward as appropriate. I know
you are out of the office, and I will hear from you upon your return.
Thank you both,
Stacy Van Driel
623-399-2975
StacyWebb07@gmail.com
StacyWebb@LTIC.com
Thank you,
Our office will be closed on Tuesday July 4, 2023 in observance of
Independence Day.
Stacy Webb - Van Driel
Lawyers Title of Arizona, Inc.
17100 N. 67th Avenue Building 2, Suite 200
Glendale, AZ 85308
direct line: 623-435-4262
main office ph. 623-979-6060
fax 623-334-4900
stacywebb@ltic.com
NOTICE: The information contained in this message is proprietary and/or confidential and
may be privileged. If you are not the intended recipient of this communication, you are hereby
notified to: (i) delete the message and all copies; (ii) do not disclose, distribute or use the
message in any manner; and (iii) notify the sender immediately.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------
This message was secured by Zix®.
From:
James Ho
To:
bkhutton@cox.net
Cc:
Taylor, Matthew
Subject:
Re: Proposed StayApt concerns - transportation concerns (CUP23-04 Conditional Use Permit (CUP) StayApt
[Hotel] at 73rd Avenue and Camino San Xavier)
Date:
Friday, June 30, 2023 6:54:27 AM
You don't often get email from jameshoaz@gmail.com. Learn why this is important
Ms. Hutton,
Thank you for sharing your transportation concerns and questions regarding CUP 23-04
Conditional Use Permit StayApt Hotel. Your public input is invaluable to the decision-making
process and I will be attaching your email to a letter that I will be sending to the Planning
Commission and City staff in August. That letter will summarize all of the public feedback
that I have received through my CTOC capacity and will request that the City and Applicant
address these concerns to the satisfaction of all parties.
As you may know, I will be out of the office from July 1 - 30, but I expect to continue
receiving public input on transportation matters, including this CUP 23-04 case, throughout
that period. I will provide responses to all those who send me feedback when I return in
August.
Thank you again for your active participation in this process.
Commissioner James Ho
jameshoaz@gmail.com
On Thu, Jun 29, 2023 at 9:49 AM <bkhutton@cox.net> wrote:
Dear Ms. Ho -
I’ve been informed we need to send our citizen feedback to you
regarding transportation concerns.
As a resident of Secluded Acres – Here are my concerns (limited
strictly to transportation):
1. Parking concerns - The volume of rooms vs the parking slots
designated for this new business – where will the overflow
parking occur? (in the surround businesses? In the dirt lots? On
the already small street? In the residential neighborhood?)
2. Blind curve concerns – I frequently drive there (W. Camino San
Xavier) from our neighborhood to the surrounding businesses. It
is always dicey to go around the blind curve; people drive too fast
or drive down the middle of the street. Increased traffic will only
magnify that situation with potential deadly outcomes).
3. Traffic impediment concerns - Increased traffic around Arrowhead
Mall – we already have a lot of congestion in/out of the mall area.
Additional vehicles will add to that; possibly impeding traffic flow
and potentially contributing to more accidents.
4. Increased noise and pollution concerns – additional vehicles will
increase noise levels and pollution (assuming some (or all) of the
vehicles will be gasoline or diesel fueled). In our neighbhorhood,
we already hear loud vehicles traveling on 75th Avenue, Bell
Road and Union Hills Road - the addition of more vehicles will
only add to that unwanted load.
5. Additional traffic in the surrounding neighborhoods concerns –
Since Secluded Acres is due north of the proposed development;
it’s very conceivable that individuals residing at the StayApt will
filter thru the Secluded Acres neighborhood (potential reason#1:
looking for an easier access to StayApt potential reason #2:
unsure of how to arrive at StayApt for their first stay). This will
cause unwanted traffic our residential neighborhood and potential
safety issues – there are many folks in the Seclude Acres
neighborhood who walk, jog, ride bike daily as well as some
horse back riders.
6. Trail head issues (73rd Avenue) the southern end of 73rd Avenue
(in our Secluded Acres residential neighborhood) begins a City of
Glendale trail head that flows into Skunk Creek. This is an often
used trailhead by walkers, hikers, bikers, joggers (pedestrian
traffic) both coming from and going to the Skunk Creek trails.
This trail head is quite close (easy walking distance) from the
proposed site. If individuals park their overflow vehicles at the
end of 73rd Avenue, the trail head will be clogged and difficult to
navigate).
Overall, my largest concern is one of safety for the existing residential
neighborhoods as well as existing surrounding businesses (their
rights) and public safety regarding the additional traffic and blind curve
on Camino San Xavier (which has ALREADY proven to be a hazard
with the current volume of traffic).
Thank you for your time and consideration. Please know, it is
appreciated.
Brenda Hutton
Secluded Acres Resident
From:
James Ho
To:
Todd VanDriel
Cc:
Taylor, Matthew; Stacy Van Driel; Stacy Van Driel; notostayapt@gmail.com
Subject:
Re: No to CUP 23-04
Date:
Friday, June 30, 2023 6:56:00 AM
You don't often get email from jameshoaz@gmail.com. Learn why this is important
Mr. Van Driel,
Thank you for sharing your transportation concerns and questions regarding CUP 23-04
Conditional Use Permit StayApt Hotel. Your public input is invaluable to the decision-making
process and I will be attaching your email to a letter that I will be sending to the Planning
Commission and City staff in August. That letter will summarize all of the public feedback
that I have received through my CTOC capacity and will request that the City and Applicant
address these concerns to the satisfaction of all parties.
As you may know, I will be out of the office from July 1 - 30, but I expect to continue
receiving public input on transportation matters, including this CUP 23-04 case, throughout
that period. I will provide responses to all those who send me feedback when I return in
August.
Thank you again for your active participation in this process.
Commissioner James Ho
jameshoaz@gmail.com
On Thu, Jun 29, 2023 at 12:14 PM Todd VanDriel <azfirecapt63@gmail.com> wrote:
Mr. Taylor and Mr. Ho,
My name is Todd. I am a resident of Secluded Acres and Estates. I am writing to you both
in opposition of CUP 23-04, StayApt.
I am a retired Firefighter and paramedic, serving our community for over 28 years. Next
month, I am retiring from the US Navy after 20 years. That said, I have years of experience
with medical and fire calls from extended stays in our community, most of which do not end
well.
Extended stays are hubs for crime - drugs, prostitution, sex trafficking, just to name a few.
And while this company states they will not market to transients, since they have the same
price point as the extended stay across the street, they will attract the same clientele. It is
simple business math.
Mr. Ho - as a retired firefighter, I am concerned about access to the proposed building for
rescue vehicles. Is there data to show that an engine can access the 3-story building? Do we
have photos or video to show that an engine, an ambulance, a Battalion chief, and civilian
vehicles can navigate Camino San Xavier east bound from 75th Ave?
Mr. Taylor, I can only assume you would not discount my expertise, and proceed with
approval of such a danger and detriment to our community. Please assist this franchisee
with a lot that is far from a residential area, and more conducive to 24-hour activity.
Respectfully,
HMCS Van Driel, Todd
Regional LCPO (Central) NR NMRTC San Diego
Navy Medicine Readiness and Training Command San Diego Headquarters
todd.vandriel@navy.mil
azfirecapt63@gmail.com
C: 480-703-8665
From:
James Ho
To:
Webb, Stacy
Cc:
Taylor, Matthew; Stacy Webb; Todd VanDriel
Subject:
Re: Opposition to CUP 23-04
Date:
Friday, June 30, 2023 6:51:59 AM
You don't often get email from jameshoaz@gmail.com. Learn why this is important
Mrs. Webb-Van Driel,
Thank you for sharing your transportation concerns and questions regarding CUP 23-04
Conditional Use Permit StayApt Hotel. Your public input is invaluable to the decision-making
process and I will be attaching your email to a letter that I will be sending to the Planning
Commission and City staff in August. That letter will summarize all of the public feedback
that I have received through my CTOC capacity and will request that the City and Applicant
address these concerns to the satisfaction of all parties.
As you may know, I will be out of the office from July 1 - 30, but I expect to continue
receiving public input on transportation matters, including this CUP 23-04 case, throughout
that period. I will provide responses to all those who send me feedback when I return in
August.
Thank you again for your active participation in this process.
Commissioner James Ho
jameshoaz@gmail.com
On Thu, Jun 29, 2023 at 9:37 AM Webb, Stacy <StacyWebb@ltic.com> wrote:
This message was sent securely using Zix®
Mr. Taylor and Mr. Ho,
My name is Stacy. My husband and I are both AZ Natives, and have been in the Valley for
decades. My family and I live in Secluded Acres and Estates, and I work just over a mile
from the area. While my family and I moved here just under 5 years ago, this area has been
a desired location for me for more than 30 years. We chose this neighborhood because of its
quiet, peaceful, safe, secluded feel. We knew it would be a great place for our family.
I am asking you to reject the CUP 23-04 based on the introduction of 24-hour activity
to our neighborhood and increase in traffic (pedestrian and vehicle).
Many people use our neighborhood to bypass the intersection of 75th Ave and Union Hills.
We do not need increased traffic coming in and out of our residential streets for people
looking for a short cut to their extended stay. We do not need people attempting to pass
through the end of 73rd Avenue. We do not need overflow parking into our residential
streets as the proposed parking lot hardly accommodates the amount of apartments, and
staff. I have encouraged surrounding businesses to reach out to you both with concerns of
parking and traffic.
Have either of you driven from 75th Ave to the subject lot? I would be interested to see if
two vehicles can even maneuver that curve at the same time.
Do you know about the equestrian/biking/walking trail at the end of 73rd Avenue? That is
less than a 90 second walk from the proposed site to a school bus stop.
Mr. Taylor, this business is not conducive to family life, and the quiet neighborhood in
which we live. I am asking you to change your recommendation to reject CUP 23-04, and
propose a more appropriate site for an extended stay hotel.
Mr. Ho, please consider this email as a "transportation concern", and forward as
appropriate. I know you are out of the office, and I will hear from you upon your return.
Thank you both,
Stacy Van Driel
623-399-2975
StacyWebb07@gmail.com
StacyWebb@LTIC.com
Thank you,
Our office will be closed on Tuesday July 4, 2023 in observance of
Independence Day.
Stacy Webb - Van Driel
Lawyers Title of Arizona, Inc.
17100 N. 67th Avenue Building 2, Suite 200
Glendale, AZ 85308
direct line: 623-435-4262
main office ph. 623-979-6060
fax 623-334-4900
stacywebb@ltic.com
NOTICE: The information contained in this message is proprietary and/or confidential and
may be privileged. If you are not the intended recipient of this communication, you are
hereby notified to: (i) delete the message and all copies; (ii) do not disclose, distribute or use
the message in any manner; and (iii) notify the sender immediately.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------
This message was secured by Zix®.
From:
bpray
To:
Taylor, Matthew
Cc:
sss510@cox.net; Erin Cole; skipcrandall@hotmail.com; Malnar, Raymond
Subject:
CUP 23-04 7300 W Camino San Xavier - StayApt
Date:
Sunday, July 2, 2023 5:29:25 PM
Attachments:
Mathew Taylor aptstay 07022023.docx
[Some people who received this message don't often get email from bpray@cox.net. Learn why this is important at
https://aka.ms/LearnAboutSenderIdentification ]
Mr. Taylor,
We are the Ray Family with a home directly north of the proposed extended stay hotel - StayApt on 73rd and West
Camino San Xaiver.
Our home and privacy will be greatly impacted if the proposed hotel is approved. We have attached a document
regarding reports issued and why we are opposed to the proposed hotel.
We are totally in support of the City’s desire to have the property developed, however the proposed hotel doesn’t
seem like a good fit for the area. It provides only a few jobs and will be a greater demand and negative impact on
energy, water, and infrastructure for the City.
More importantly it will completely invade our privacy as well as others in the neighborhood. At a minimum we
don’t feel sufficient stipulations and conditions are being placed on the design and use to protect us neighbors.
We apologize for the lengthy document but we felt it is imperative to provide you with what we have read and our
interpretations that have led us to why the CUP should not be approved. We have also provided our request of
stipulations should the City approve the CUP.
We look forward to hearing back from you and addressing our concerns. If you would prefer to meet with us or
have a phone call, just let us know.
Thank you for your time,
The Rays
bpray@cox.net
623-498-7595
From:
Crystal Viglietta
To:
Taylor, Matthew
Subject:
Re: Opposition to Stay Apt
Date:
Monday, July 10, 2023 5:26:48 PM
You don't often get email from crystalmviglietta@gmail.com. Learn why this is important
Hello Mr. Taylor,
I was reviewing the public meeting notes and see a postcard went out to the neighborhood.
How many postcards were sent out? What constitutes affected neighbors? We were not one of
the people who received a postcard. I have been campaigning to stop this project and haven't
found but two people who received notice. I saw "A Notice of Public Hearing was published
in The Arizona Republic on May 31, 2023. Notification postcards of the public hearing were
mailed to adjacent property owners and interested parties on May 26, 2023. The property was
posted on June 7, 2023." I search for the publication on May 31, 2023 and was unable to find
it on https://www.azcentral.com/public-notices for the Arizona Republic. Could you please
forward me the link to the publication?
Thank you
Crystal Viglietta
Secluded Acres
Emails sent and received shall not create a binding contract or acceptance of an offer until the written contract is signed by all parties. If
your property is currently listed with a Realtor, please disregard this, it is not our intention to solicit the offerings of other Brokers. We are
happy to work with them and cooperate fully.
On Mon, Jun 19, 2023 at 4:23 PM Crystal Viglietta <crystalmviglietta@gmail.com> wrote:
Dear Mr. Taylor,
We hope this letter finds you well. We are writing to express our strong opposition to the
proposed building of the Stay Apt, proposed to be built at 7300 W. Camino San Xavier.
This proposed extended-stay hotel is in an area not zoned for such a development and in
close proximity to residential homes. We have significant concerns about the potential
negative impact this project may have on our community and specifically the Secluded
Acres Neighborhood, including the decline of property values and an increase in crime rates.
Firstly, constructing an extended-stay hotel in an area not designated for such purposes goes
against established zoning regulations. These regulations are put in place to ensure the
harmonious development and protection of residential neighborhoods. Allowing the
construction of Stay Apt in this area sets a concerning precedent that could lead to further
disregarding of zoning laws, ultimately affecting the character and integrity of our
community.
Moreover, the close proximity of the proposed Stay Apt hotel to residential homes raises
valid concerns about the potential adverse effects on property values. Research has
consistently shown that the presence of commercial establishments, such as hotels, in
residential areas can have a detrimental impact on property values. Homeowners in the
vicinity of the hotel would likely experience a decrease in property values, making it more
challenging for them to sell their properties or obtain favorable financing options. This
decline in property values could have far-reaching consequences for the entire community.
Furthermore, the potential increase in crime associated with an extended-stay hotel is a
significant concern. Extended-stay hotels often attract a transient population and can become
hotspots for criminal activities. As a result, the safety and security of residents in the
surrounding area may be compromised. This issue should be taken seriously, as the well-
being of the community should always be a top priority.
Considering these points, we kindly request that the City of Glendale carefully reconsider
the approval and deny the Stay Apt extended stay hotel project in its current proposed
location. While we understand the importance of development and progress, it is crucial to
prioritize our community's long-term well-being and stability. We urge the city authorities to
explore alternative locations that are more suitable for an extended-stay hotel, keeping in
mind the established zoning regulations and the concerns of the residents.
Thank you for taking the time to review our concerns. We trust that the city officials will
give due consideration to the potential negative impact of the Stay Apt extended stay hotel
on the community and make a decision that reflects the best interests of the surrounding
neighborhood.
Yours sincerely,
Ben & Crystal Viglietta
Secluded Acres Residents
7301 W Union Hills Drive
Glendale, AZ 85308
crystalmviglietta@gmail.com
623-341-3984
Emails sent and received shall not create a binding contract or acceptance of an offer until the written contract is signed by all
parties. If your property is currently listed with a Realtor, please disregard this, it is not our intention to solicit the offerings of other
Brokers. We are happy to work with them and cooperate fully.
From:
Stephanie Marston
To:
Taylor, Matthew
Subject:
StayApt at 7300 W. Camino San Xavier
Date:
Tuesday, July 11, 2023 9:19:04 AM
You don't often get email from marston@pobox.com. Learn why this is important
Dear Mr. Taylor,
I am writing you about the proposed StayApt at 7300 W. Camino San Xavier in Glendale,
85308.
I do not support the City allowing a conditional permit for this building or proceeding with the
build for all the questionable reasons outlined in the online petition (link below).
Our neighborhood is already maxed out with all the businesses, hotels, and the Sports
Complex. Adding a facility that encourages crime right next to our neighborhood walking path
and schools is never going to be ok.
Thanks for your time,
Stephanie Marston
Neighborhood-Secluded Acres
Petition NO TO STAYAPT EXTENDED STAY
ipetitions.com
From:
James Ho
To:
crabbyaz
Cc:
Taylor, Matthew
Subject:
Re: Extd Stay
Date:
Wednesday, July 12, 2023 12:00:50 PM
You don't often get email from jameshoaz@gmail.com. Learn why this is important
Mr. Crabtree,
Thank you for sharing your transportation concerns and questions regarding CUP 23-04
Conditional Use Permit StayApt Hotel. Your public input is invaluable to the decision-making
process and I will be attaching your email to a letter that I will be sending to the Planning
Commission and City staff in August. That letter will summarize all of the public feedback
that I have received through my CTOC capacity and will request that the City and Applicant
address these concerns to the satisfaction of all parties.
As you may know, I will be out of the office from July 1 - 30, but I expect to continue
receiving public input on transportation matters, including this CUP 23-04 case, throughout
that period. I will provide responses to all those who send me feedback when I return in
August.
Thank you again for your active participation in this process.
Commissioner James Ho
jameshoaz@gmail.com
From: crabbyaz <crabbyaz@q.com>
Sent: Tuesday, July 11, 2023 6:47 AM
To: jameshoaz@gmail.com <jameshoaz@gmail.com>
Subject: Extd Stay
Mr. Ho,
I have previously voiced my opposition to the proposed project near Arrowhead Secluded
Estates and Secluded Acres but recently was told of your impact on the outcome.
I've been here at 7232 W. SAINT John Rd since early 1988 and witnessed many changes,
most of which have been agreeable and amenable for the neighborhood and city, but I strongly
recommend not pursuing this venture that seems to be loosely designed and definitely not a
"good neighbor" partner.
I wrote to Mr Malnar voicing concerns about the impact to our neighborhood. Water,
electricity, traffic, sewage and the human impact all are not clearly defined by the project
managers. The area currently is on the decline for a tax base for one. Closed businesses,
declined road/foot traffic and the absence of adequate real estate sufficient for the project
represent a primary factor on another location.
The residents of the neighborhood have not been in favor for similar concerns and having been
in rezoning hearings going back to the days of the Arrowhead Mall and even the 101 loop, the
impacted residents should be considered greater than a short term tax base that probably won't
benefit us or the City of Glendale long term. I have been a resident of Glendale, Peoria, and
Phx since the mid 50s and have been through rezoning, city annexation and differing Post
Office usage and having only three homes.
The residents expect you and the city leaders to do what is right and best for them as well as
maintaining and growing responsibly.
I encourage you to NOT build another eye sore to the horizon that in effect can look into the
neighbors backyard and windows and not benefit the city long term.
Respectfully, Ken Crabtree
Retired, USMC Vet, 60 year AZ resident.
Sent from my Verizon, Samsung Galaxy smartphone
From:
Chris Zukowski
To:
Taylor, Matthew
Subject:
Extended Stay: Build it!
Date:
Wednesday, July 12, 2023 2:32:38 PM
You don't often get email from iamchriszukowski@gmail.com. Learn why this is important
A facebook group said I should email you regarding the Extended stay hotel on 7300 W.
Camino San Xavier. So I am emailing you to tell you to go ahead and approve it.
Who cares? We live in a free country where everyone should be allowed to build whatever
they want. We shouldn't be regulating what a business does. Approve it.
Also reduce the parking requirements. Glendale way over builds parking.
From:
James Ho
To:
MaryAnn
Cc:
Taylor, Matthew
Subject:
Re: Extended stay facility
Date:
Saturday, July 15, 2023 4:33:36 PM
You don't often get email from jameshoaz@gmail.com. Learn why this is important
Mr. and Mrs. Brown,
Thank you for sharing your transportation concerns regarding CUP 23-04 Conditional Use
Permit StayApt Hotel. Your public input is invaluable to the decision-making process and I
will be attaching your email to a letter that I will be sending to the Planning Commission and
City staff in August. That letter will summarize all of the public feedback that I have received
through my CTOC capacity and will request that the City and Applicant address these
concerns to the satisfaction of all parties.
As you may know, I will be out of the office from July 1 - 30, but I expect to continue
receiving public input on transportation matters, including this CUP 23-04 case, throughout
that period. I will provide responses to all those who send me feedback when I return in
August.
Thank you again for your active participation in this process.
Commissioner James Ho
jameshoaz@gmail.com
From: MaryAnn <mab1119@cox.net>
Sent: Saturday, July 15, 2023 10:09 AM
To: jameshoaz@gmail.com <jameshoaz@gmail.com>
Subject: Extended stay facility
Dear Sir,
My husband and I are very concerned about the traffic issues that may be caused by the building of
this extended stay apartments in Glendale, Az. There’s enough foot traffic and homelessness already
starting in our neighborhood. We do not need anymore. Thx,
Mr & Mrs C Brown
Arrowhead estates
Sent from my iPhone
From:
Sherri Gatterdam
To:
Taylor, Matthew
Subject:
Opposition to CUP 23-04
Date:
Saturday, July 29, 2023 4:29:06 PM
You don't often get email from jgatt@cox.net. Learn why this is important
Mr. Taylor,
My name is Sherri Gatterdam. My family and I have lived in Secluded Acres and
Estates for 28 years. We originally chose this neighborhood due to its quiet
location, and we continue to live here for the same reason.
The purpose of my writing is to oppose CUP 23-04, and for this correspondence to
be included in the Planning Commission's packet.
Introducing 24 hour activity to our neighborhood would be a danger and detriment
to our community. As a grandmother, I am very concerned about the children
waiting at bus stops being confronted by transients residing in temporary housing.
The trailhead at the end of 73rd Avenue would give direct access to our homes, our
children, our elderly - our most vulnerable populations.
24 hour activity is not permitted in that zoning, and for good reason. We are an
established neighborhood. The City does not have the right to change zoning as it
sees fit. This will cause an imminent danger to our community. And all
ramifications of this build will be owned by the City.
Any increase in crime, devaluation of properties, images shared of
properties/children/homes online would be directly related to this build, and the
City would be liable. Please consider this letter opposition to CUP 23-04.
Signed,
Sherri Gatterdam
From:
Don Abel
To:
Taylor, Matthew; jameshoaz@gmail.com
Subject:
Opposition to Extended Stay Hotel
Date:
Monday, July 31, 2023 10:40:32 AM
You don't often get email from donap2hoa@gmail.com. Learn why this is important
Mr. Taylor,
I'm writing to you regarding the proposed Extended Stay Hotel (CUP23-04)
I do not believe the proposed location is a good choice for a few reasons.
1. The tiny little road, West Camino San Xavier, cannot possibly accommodate the anticipated
traffic this hotel would create. There are already many businesses that utilize this street. There
is the non-profit organization One Step Beyond with many vans transporting mentally
challenged people that use that road constantly.
2. Everyone knows Bell Road is a main artery for homeless and transient people. The hotel
being located behind the shopping center, almost hidden, is just too big an invitation for these
people to congregate.
3. There is a neighborhood, Secluded Acres and Estates, on the north side of this property. All
the other commercial buildings in this immediate area between Bell Rd. and Camino San
Xavier are single and 2-story buildings. To put such a large building on the proposed site
would not be harmonious to this area.
Thank you,
Don Abel
Vice President/
Architectural Committee Chair
Arrowhead Ranch Phase II
From:
penbo penbo
To:
Taylor, Matthew
Cc:
jameshoaz@gmail.com
Subject:
stayAPT RE-ZONING REQUEST
Date:
Monday, July 31, 2023 9:19:12 AM
You don't often get email from penbo@cox.net. Learn why this is important
July 31, 2023
Matthew Taylor
Glendale City Planner
RE: stayAPT re-zoning hearing
Dear Mr. Taylor,
There is much concern regarding the re-zoning of the empty lot on West
Camino San Xavier to allow a stayAPT long term extended stay
hotel/apartments.
First, the fact that it being considered on a street that is not really a road at that
location but a cut through behind the local businesses off of Bell Road and the
amount of traffic which will be added to the already congested area since it is
not a through street but a small internal street leading only to the small business
occupying the area currently. I see accidents being a frequent problem.
My second concern is how close it will be to the Non-Profit Organization ONE
STEP BEYOND which is a day center for individuals with intellectual
disabilities. What kind of individuals will be staying at this hotel/apartment and
since the building would be hidden between the many local businesses, what
type of nefarious activities this might bring to the area. I consider this a major
concern and not something to be glossed over.
My third concern is as to whether this will be a Section 8 establishment? We
are currently suffering from an overflow of people in our city with border
crossers and a large amount of people relocating here. Also, a large number of
homeless people are taking up camp in every available location.
I am against this large three story hotel moving into the backyard of the
community and next door to One Step Beyond. This may fill your coffers with
tax money but it won’t make this community better off.
I am asking you to vote against the stayAPT Hotel.
Sincerely,
Penny Abel
19827 N. 78th Ln
Glendale, AZ 85308
From:
James Ho
To:
Walker-Hall, Tawanda; Perry, Tabitha
Cc:
Taylor, Matthew; Sage, Patrick
Subject:
Transportation Public Comments for CUP23-04 StayApt Hotel - Letter to Planning Commission
Date:
Tuesday, August 1, 2023 6:01:13 AM
Attachments:
CUP23-04 JH Letter to Planning Commission.pdf
Ms. Walker-Hall and Ms. Perry,
Please distribute the attached letter to the members of the Planning Commission regarding
transportation-related public comments for the Conditional Use Permit case CUP23-
04 StayApt Hotel.
I received these public comments in my capacity as a member of the CTOC and am
transmitting them to the Planning Commission to be addressed by the Applicant and/or City to
the satisfaction of all parties.
Commissioner James Ho
602-420-3765
jameshoaz@gmail.com
From:
James Ho
To:
Walker-Hall, Tawanda; Perry, Tabitha
Cc:
Taylor, Matthew; Sage, Patrick
Subject:
Transportation Public Comments for CUP23-04 StayApt Hotel - Letter to Planning Commission
Date:
Tuesday, August 1, 2023 6:01:13 AM
Attachments:
CUP23-04 JH Letter to Planning Commission.pdf
Ms. Walker-Hall and Ms. Perry,
Please distribute the attached letter to the members of the Planning Commission regarding
transportation-related public comments for the Conditional Use Permit case CUP23-
04 StayApt Hotel.
I received these public comments in my capacity as a member of the CTOC and am
transmitting them to the Planning Commission to be addressed by the Applicant and/or City to
the satisfaction of all parties.
Commissioner James Ho
602-420-3765
jameshoaz@gmail.com
From:
D Adams
To:
Malnar, Raymond; Taylor, Matthew
Cc:
Erin Cole
Subject:
stayAPT Suites 8/7 meeting
Date:
Monday, August 7, 2023 12:10:03 PM
You don't often get email from azchrome@yahoo.com. Learn why this is important
Hello, Ray Malnar
My wife and I have rsvp’d for the meetings today. We will do our best to attend but we are juggling our 4
kids meet the teacher night (5:30 - 7p).
Looking at the agenda the meeting will be ~65 minutes, so hoping we make the Q&A.
Just in case we are late or cannot make it tonight, I wanted to send you this note with our initial thoughts
so that our attendance is virtually counted.
Is there any way the developers presentation can be shared post the meeting?
Also the city presentation please?
1. We are very interested to hear the City of Glendale vision for this wonderful area (Arrowhead) and how
this project fits in the future growth of Glendale. Because based on the comprehensive parks and
recreation study that Glendale published and approved, we thought Glendale had aspirations for growing
Glendale so not to fall forth behind other cities. And it is not clear how this re-zoning and allowing the
build of a startup motel chain, furthers or supports those goals and objective.
Also it is not clear what this developers plans for success are. It looks like stayAPT have a location
planned on Central and Washington St (downtown Phoenix), which is definitely a much different area
than Arrowhead.
This just seems like an odd location to build an extended stay motel. Is there a comprehensive business
plan from the developers with targets and forecast. Personally I feel there are much better options on the
main road, not a hidden lot with only a view of business dumpster to the south and a poorly lite
neighborhood to the north, because the City of Glendale has YET to invest in street lights, sidewalks or
updating the historic walking path/trail (to match the path near the police/fire station on Union Hills), so
that any potential visitors have a place to walk their pets.
We feel that the success of this project should be the top priority for the City of Glendale and not just
selling the land. As the failure of this project will solely be City of Glendale and the neighboring residence
issue, which is the concern of all the constituencies that have vocalized.
Is the upcoming zoning hearing a community vote or unilateral decision by the city staff?
If the City of Glendale have broader development plans coming to the area I would love to see those
ideas and plans and how this motel supports? We, and I bet everyone as well, do not want this beautiful
area to become like Metro Center or 27th Ave and Yorkshire.
Thank you in advance for the community support,
Diwan and Rebecca Adams
Planning Received
August 7, 2023
From:
Erin Cole
To:
Malnar, Raymond
Cc:
Taylor, Matthew; Walker-Hall, Tawanda; Perry, Tabitha; Lerma, Alex
Subject:
Re: August 7th Meeting Follow Up From Council Member Malnar
Date:
Wednesday, August 9, 2023 8:21:38 PM
Hi Ray,
Thank you for your email. And thank you, again, for hosting the meeting.
I trust that the countless emails that Mr. Taylor has already received will be included in P&Z
Commission's packet, and that the linked email addresses will be supplementing what has
already been sent? Perhaps City staff can confirm that... ?
In addition, this is my third request to City staff asking the ramifications of an applicant
providing false information on their submitted report. Please advise if the P&Z Commission
was notified of the erroneous report, the penalties thereof, and how the City will ensure that
the next report is accurate.
Thanks to you all!
Erin Cole
602.770.9799
erinscole@gmail.com
On Wed, Aug 9, 2023 at 1:32 PM Malnar, Raymond <RMalnar@glendaleaz.com> wrote:
Dear Resident,
I would like to begin by thanking you for attending Monday’s meeting at the Foothills
Recreation and Aquatics Center. My goal in having this informational meeting was to give
more residents an opportunity to hear directly from the developer and ask questions and
express concerns.
Many of you expressed an interest in sending letters to the Planning Commission prior to the
request being heard at their meeting on August 24th at 6:00pm to be located at Glendale
Civic Center, 5750 W Glenn Dr, Glendale, AZ 85301 . Please submit your letters to the
following city staff: twalker@glendaleaz.com , tperry@glendaleaz.com , and
alerma@glendaleaz.com .
If you plan on speaking, you will need to fill out a speaker card at the meeting. We
recommend that you prepare a statement prior to the meeting as you will be limited to 3
minutes speaking time.
Additionally, my office confirmed with the City Clerk’s office that the agenda will be posted
by August 22nd. Once it’s posted, you can click HERE to review it.
Once again, thank you for attending this important meeting- should you have any questions,
please feel free to reach out.
Thank you,
Council Member Ray Malnar
Sahuaro District
From:
Deborah Catania
To:
Walker-Hall, Tawanda
Subject:
Re: Drug hotel
Date:
Wednesday, August 9, 2023 3:44:28 PM
You don't often get email from catani3@outlook.com. Learn why this is important
In what city do you all live ?
Get Outlook for iOS
From: Deborah Catania
Sent: Wednesday, August 9, 2023 3:37:19 PM
To: twalker@glendaleaz.com <twalker@glendaleaz.com>
Subject: Drug hotel
To whom it may concern ,
If you try to act like this hotel would be a good addition to the neighborhood spare me the
money hungry tax money your looking for from such a hotel !
This is not a Marriott or Hilton it is a low rate pile of crap hotel and how dare all of you spin it
like it's a great addition to the neighborhood ! It is NOT.
Get Outlook for iOS
From:
MaryAnn
To:
Walker-Hall, Tawanda
Subject:
Next committee meeting
Date:
Wednesday, August 9, 2023 5:05:25 PM
[You don't often get email from mab1119@cox.net. Learn why this is important at
https://aka.ms/LearnAboutSenderIdentification ]
I received the communication from Ray Malnar concerning the next committee meeting.
I am against the building of this Stay Apt extended stay facility on Camino San Xavier in Glendale, Az. There are
too many concerns, stated by many residents at the Aug 7 meeting with the developer. First being safety of the
nearby neighborhood residents, cameras were mention. Cameras can can document crimes, not stop crimes. It’s
supposed to be a non smoking facility, no where on the grounds, where are the residents going to smoke cigarettes
or marijuana. Perhaps in the neighborhood near by in back of facility. We do not want that in our area.
The price that the developers quoted to stay was $166.00 a night. There was some confusion on the price, we had
$3500.00 a month. Some of our speakers spoke on the subject of price. There is an apartment complex nearby
where people are paying more than that. So it’s a no brainer the Stay Apt will rent faster. Who’s going to be
renting there? As one of the police officer said at the meeting, homeless people all have cell phones, and receive
credit cards from the government for assistance. They also know how to manipulate to get cards. They then can
leave their doors open to bring others in, only God knows who. A huge concern. Police knows it’s hard to evict
them.
The people’s homes that back up to the facility will not have privacy, since it is so close to their homes. The
developers offered to plant trees on their property, trees that tall would cost $10,000.00 and the owners would bear
the cost of water to keep them alive. Also we are worried about the numbers of parking spaces that they want to
provide, and if there are going to be charging stations for EV’s. The access for fire trucks is also questionable,
doesn’t seem like there’s wide enough access.
The homes have also depreciated $10,000.00, after the IRS building was built. The owners don’t want their
properties depreciated any more. There plenty of vacant land to the north in Peoria.
In 5 or 10 years, if the franchise runs into financial difficulty, there is no guarantee who’s going to take over.
Perhaps a homeless shelter, or put immigrants there. No telling.
Also is this committee meeting going to be televised on the Glendale station or the internet? What is the time and
location of the next meeting. Thx, Mary Ann Brown
Sent from my iPad
From:
Leeanne Hayward
To:
Taylor, Matthew; Perry, Tabitha
Subject:
CUP 23-04
Date:
Friday, August 11, 2023 12:32:03 PM
Some people who received this message don't often get email from leeannehay79@gmail.com. Learn why this is
important
Dear Planning Commission,
My name is Leeanne Hayward and I am a former resident of Glendale for 50+ years and a
current Peoria, Az. resident. Although I am a resident of another city, I am a frequent shopper
and visitor of the Glendale area. I am writing to oppose the CUP 23-04 - Modern Stay near
Arrowhead Mall.
Our key concerns are for the safety of those who live and shop in the area. As you know
Phoenix is the kidnapping capital of America and human/sex trafficking is a huge problem. This
hotel will only draw into this. This hotel is less than 500 ft from a school bus stop and less than
a mile from an elementary school. This 3-story hotel would overlook some of Glendale
resident's backyards and a straight view into their home.
I am writing in opposition to the Modern StayApt and am asking you to vote "NO" for the CUP
23-04.
Thank you,
Leeanne & Jim Hayward
14851 N 88th Avenue
Peoria AZ
85381
From:
Connie Kiser
To:
Taylor, Matthew; Perry, Tabitha
Subject:
P&Z packet for StayAPT project
Date:
Friday, August 11, 2023 9:26:34 PM
Some people who received this message don't often get email from conkiser@msn.com. Learn why this is
important
Dear Mr. Taylor and Ms. Perry:
Would you please see that the following letter is included in the P & Z Commissioners' packet
for the 8/24/23 P&Z meeting where the StayAPT application is going to be considered. I am
totally against this project.
8/11/2023
Dear: Members of the Glendale Planning & Zoning Commission
P & Z Staff: Matt Taylor and Tabitha Perry
First, thank you Mr. Taylor and Ms. Perry for attending the informational meeting held at the
Foothills Aquatic Center on August 7th. As you know from that meeting residents from Secluded
Acres and also Hidden Manor and Arrowhead Ranch are adamantly against approval of the StayAPT
application now pending to be built in our neighborhood.
Some of my thoughts taken from the meeting:
1. The diagram of what the proposed facility will be appears to be more like a prison. Each of
the apartments open onto a courtyard, with no outside access other than through one main
door leading into the entire building. The code for that door could be changed at any time to
facilitate a rental program for residents that cannot leave, such as housing for a half-way
house or temporary housing for migrants – such as was done in Scottsdale.
2. The developer sold this as catering to high-end executives who need to stay in the area for
work. Who in their right might would choose to rent in a location that is built along a two-
lane alley that backs up to the rear of numerous retail stores where garbage and other
delivery truck services are taking place. I believe the developer is not being totally honest
about his intentions with the City of Glendale on what the ultimate use for this facility is going
to be. Something just doesn’t smell right about this project – including the fact that the
developer keeps changing his answers depending on who he is trying to sway, including how
much the apartments are going to rent for nightly. During the meeting it became apparent
that this project is going to end up negatively impacting all of the nearby residents who have
invested hard-earned money into their homes, including not only Secluded Acres, but also
Hidden Manor and Arrowhead Ranch.
3. This project is less than 300’ from the backyards of residents in Secluded Acres which will
totally destroy their privacy and create noise and other issues that you wouldn't want in your
own backyard - so why allow it is ours.
4. Over the years we have already seen crime increase in the Arrowhead mall area and this
proposed StayAPT facility would create a window of opportunity for increased crime and
traffic along Camino San Xavier.
I urge you to DENY the application for the StayAPT three-story building to be located at
73rd Ave. and Camino San Xavier. It is not beneficial to anyone but the developer for
such a project to be tucked into our otherwise quiet neighborhoods.
Thank you.
Connie Kiser
Hidden Manor Resident
7644 W. Michigan Ave.
Glendale, AZ 85308
Some people who received this message don't often get email from 1vettenut@gmail.com. Learn why this is
important
From:
Walker-Hall, Tawanda
To:
Gary Carlston
Cc:
Perry, Tabitha; Lerma, Alex; Taylor, Matthew
Subject:
RE: stayAPT proposal
Date:
Monday, August 14, 2023 8:48:03 AM
Greetings, Mr. Carlston –
Your concerns have been received and will be shared with the Planning Commission.
Thank you,
We are moving…
Glendale City Hall is being remodeled. Effective Monday, August 21, 2023, Development Services Department -
Building Safety/ Planning will be located at 5754 W Glenn Drive formerly known as The Bead Museum. All
department emails and phone numbers will remain the same.
From: Gary Carlston <1vettenut@gmail.com>
Sent: Sunday, August 13, 2023 4:08 PM
To: Walker-Hall, Tawanda <TWalker@GLENDALEAZ.com>; Perry, Tabitha
<TPerry@GLENDALEAZ.com>; Lerma, Alex <alerma@GLENDALEAZ.com>
Subject: stayAPT proposal
Dear Planning Commission Members,
I am a resident of Secluded Acres neighborhood located just north of a proposed stayAPT
Suites building site.
I am totally opposed to the building of any extended stay, hotel, motel or other short term
living facility for a number of reasons.
First, the proposed facility is planned as a three story structure. This would allow the rooms on
the second and third floors on the north side of the facility to look into the backyards of the
homes located on the south side of our neighborhood. Compromising these homes privacy.
Second, I feel that the security of our neighborhood would be severely compromised. StayApt
officials claim that because they cater to a higher standard clientele (i.e. professional medical,
military, sports enthusiasts, etc.) there would be no chance of criminal activity. The stayAPT
officials did not consider that drug pushers, sex traffickers and child traffickers, etc. have the
means to rent these type of facilities as well and likely would. Of course, it would attract these
type of people. Please understand that we have a lot of families in our neighborhood who have
children and those children travel to an elementary school by foot and bicycle located just
across Union Hills Drive to the north of Secluded Acres. Also, we have quite a few people
who walk and ride bicycles on the streets of our neighborhood. Their safety would be
compromised by any criminal activity resulting from stayAPT, not to mention our properties
as well.
Third, it's a given that our property values will decrease. When extended stays, hotels, motels
and any other short term living facility is located nearby or adjacent to a housing development,
property values are almost certainly to be affected.
Please do not approve stayAPT's request to build on this property. Thank You.
Gary Carlston
7116 W. Villa Theresa Dr.
Glendale, AZ 95308
Phone: 602-547-2110
From:
Arlene Duston
To:
Taylor, Matthew
Cc:
Malnar, Raymond
Subject:
Plans for stayAPT Suites Motel
Date:
Sunday, August 13, 2023 4:25:01 PM
Some people who received this message don't often get email from duston2001@email.com. Learn why this is
important
Dear Mr. Matt Taylor and members of the Glendale Planning Commission:
I request the Glendale Planning Commission decline authorization of the CUP for the
Extended stayAPT Suites Hotel. I have the following concerns.
1. Safety concern: Experience shows that hospitals see increased prostitution and
drug cases when an extended stay is near the hospital. Arrowhead Abrazo
Hospital is only a mile away and Secluded Acres is in the middle. People
engaging in prostitution and drug use need money to continue their habits and
will break into nearby homes/yards to steal money or anything to sell for
money. Residents are concerned about break-ins. Glendale police will need to
be called more often.
2. Traffic concern: Traffic will increase in Secluded Acres down 73rd Avenue with
Extended stayAPT Motel customers trying to drive to the building only to find
they are blocked by the signs and trails. Drivers will then wind around various
streets looking for a way out of the neighborhood. This impacts children and
parents riding bikes to or from school and people walking. By design, there are
no sidewalks in Secluded Acres.
3. Location: The location for Extended stayAPT hotel is not a good location for
clients who will have a hard time finding it. Driving there during busy times of
the day is difficult because the street is curved and narrow. There is a greater
chance of car wrecks. Glendale police will have more calls.
4. Lighting: Secluded Acres is a low- light area. We have few street lights. I
remember when they first put in street lights – what a change for street corners!
The additional lighting at the motel will impact homes nearby making it hard to
sleep and decreasing privacy. Planners will have a challenge regarding
directional lighting.
5. Increased Noise: Additional vehicles increase noise for Secluded Acres
residents. Trucks make more noise. Extended stayAPT motel clients will be
driving cars and trucks all times of the day and night coming and going. Utility
trucks will come particularly in the early morning to dump trash. Air
conditioners, if outside of the building, make noise.
An office building would be a better choice for this property.
Sincerely,
Arlene Duston, 602-938-2886
Duston2001@email.com
Cc: Ray Malnar, City Councilman
1
Lerma, Alex
From:
Taylor, Matthew
Sent:
Tuesday, August 15, 2023 7:18 AM
To:
Lerma, Alex
Cc:
Walker-Hall, Tawanda
Subject:
FW: Appreciated your presentation for the Stay APT project
Applicant-forwarded email re: CUP23-04.
From: Shaine T. Alleman <sta@tblaw.com>
Sent: Monday, August 14, 2023 2:49 PM
To: Perry, Tabitha <TPerry@GLENDALEAZ.com>; Taylor, Matthew <MTaylor@GLENDALEAZ.com>
Subject: FW: Appreciated your presentation for the Stay APT project
Tabitha and Matthew,
Please see support email received from a nearby residential neighbor. We also included this in the revised Citizen
Participation Report that I will send you shortly.
Thank you,
Shaine T. Alleman | Shareholder | 602.452.2712
TIFFANY & BOSCO, P.A.
Seventh Floor Camelback Esplanade II | 2525 E Camelback Road | Phoenix, AZ 85016
P 602.255.6000 | F 602.255.0103
sta@tblaw.com | Bio | vCard | Website | Practice Areas
Offices: Arizona | California | Nevada | New Mexico
From: Randy Huston <Yellowstoneta@yellowstoneta.com>
Sent: Monday, August 14, 2023 10:07 AM
To: Shaine T. Alleman <sta@tblaw.com>
Subject: Appreciated your presentation for the Stay APT project
Hi Shane,
I was at the meeting at the Foothill Aquatic Center last Monday for the presentation and questions for your
client for the Stay APT project.
I was shocked at how rude and disrespectful most of the attendees were to you, Mike and the others who
were part of the presentation. You all impressed me that you always took the high road on every question
with Michael most of the time saying “that was a very thoughtful question”. You all were very professional,
gracious and courteous even though the people on the other side were far from that. I am sure you had to
bite your tongue many times when the same unfounded statements were repeated. Most people were
obviously not there to hear your side of the discussion.
Your group did a great job of explaining how your project is not the typical Extended Stay hotel. Your price
point is higher, you have the on-site manager to keep things under control as well as explaining why your
2
clientele is mostly a working during the day group of clients and not the type of patron who could possibly be
a threat to the neighborhood.
I live in the Hidden Manor neighborhood on the west side of 75th Ave. I am an owner of Yellowstone Trust
Administration and know what it means to start your own business with the needed capital and time to put
into it to make it successful. I attended to see what the project is and to see if it was possibly the type of
Extended Stay hotel that would be all the problems that some people were inferring about your project. I was
totally convinced that this is a good project and an asset to the neighborhood. I can’t imagine that a vacant lot
with no lighting is a better option than an expensive Hotel that attracts upper middle class clients. I hope that
the Planning commission approves your project and look forward to having relatives and business associates
stay at your nice Hotel.
Best Regards,
Randy Huston, CFP®
Yellowstone Trust Administration, Inc.
Randy Huston's direct lines:
Phone: 800-572-6394
Fax: 602-926-2584
2070 Overland Ave., Suite 104
Billings, MT 59102
Website: www.yellowstoneta.com
Email: yellowstoneta@yellowstoneta.com
Note: Unless otherwise specifically noted in this e-mail letter, the author is not engaged in rendering legal, accounting, tax or other professional services with the
dissemination of information in this e-mail letter. The opinions expressed in this e-mail, while intended to be accurate, are for general educational and
informational purposes only.
From:
caralee mcruff.com
To:
Taylor, Matthew
Subject:
Opposition to StayApt CUP 23-04
Date:
Monday, August 14, 2023 8:52:27 PM
You don't often get email from caralee@mcruff.com. Learn why this is important
Dear Mr. Taylor,
I hope this email finds you well. I am writing to express my strong opposition to CUP 23-04. As a
concerned citizen, I believe it is crucial to address the potential dangers that this proposal may
bring to our community, particularly to hotels and extended stay establishments.
One of the primary concerns I have is the potential increase in criminal activities associated with
such establishments. Crime, drugs, and sex trafficking are unfortunate realities that can thrive in
environments where transient populations are prevalent. It is essential to consider the safety and
well-being of both residents and visitors when evaluating this proposal.
Furthermore, I would like to draw attention to the potential impact on traffic congestion. The
influx of guests and visitors to these establishments may lead to increased traffic in the
surrounding areas. This could not only inconvenience local residents but also pose potential
safety hazards.
In conclusion, I urge you to carefully reconsider the implications of CUP 23-04. The safety and
security of our community should be our utmost priority. I appreciate your attention to this
matter and look forward to hearing your thoughts on the subject.
Thank you for your time and consideration.
Sincerely,
Caralee Ruff
Secluded Acres Resident
Ray Family Impacts
OPPOSITION TO APPROVAL OF Stay Apt CUP 23 04
The Ray Family
7305 W Angela Drive
Live Directly North (260’) of the Proposed StayApt Hotel
Opposition to Approval of StayApt CUP 23 04
•Hotels are inherently a 24 hour operation to accommodate various arrival & departure needs
• Standard hours may allude to restricted access but there are NO hour restrictions
•The proposed hotel is NOT a low-intensity, commercial use & will have negative impacts to our long established quiet
neighborhood
• The parcel zoning may have changed to C-2, however it is off main streets in an area that is primarily business park and
only 260 feet from a well established quiet neighborhood
• There are many uses for the site that would not have 24 hour operations such as retail, office, enclosed manufacturing or
storage facility, etc.
•Surrounding buildings and businesses do not have operations beyond 10 pm
•The 24 hours will increase traffic, noise, and foot traffic in the neighborhood
•The size of the building is out of character for the area and will overshadow the IRS building behind it
• The IRS building is already difficult for people to find and has increased neighborhood traffic for those looking for it, this
problem will only increase traffic issues
•Perimeter fencing is not planned, which would help prevent crime and decrease neighborhood foot traffic
•The hotel will have lighting that will be on at all hours of the night and create light trespassing onto our property at night from
the illumination and glare of the lights
Due to Use and Hours of Operation
Opposition to Approval of StayApt CUP 23 04
•The building height and location does not promote a functional relationship to the buildings
surrounding the site nor the surrounding neighborhood
•The tall architecture and proposed colors are not in harmony to the neighboring environment
•The proposed structure will create an intrusion of our privacy and reduce our quality of life
• A person 5’ tall will have an eye level view at about 15 ft on the 2nd floor and an eye level view at
about 25 ft on the 3rd floor
•A 3 story hotel of 35 feet high with windows looking into our home and neighborhood backyards will
negatively impact our and our neighbors’ privacy
• This is in direct opposition to the guidelines for approval under zoning code 3.605
•Commercial properties not FULLY screened from homes reduces property values
•The use and structure is in opposition to the City Envision Glendale General Plan, more specifically,
infill development policy CRR 2.5 which states the City should protect established areas/
neighborhoods by promoting context ‐ appropriate infill development
Due to Use and Hours of Operation
Opposition to Approval of StayApt CUP 23 04
•We had a meeting with the City of Glendale Planning Department on 7/19 to discuss our concerns and were
told:
• Citizen Participation Reports are not updated or corrected
• The planning department informed us on 8/15 they will be updated for this case to include Councilman
Malnar's Community Meeting held on 8/7/23
• Suggest changes and stipulations to the planning commission
• Our concerns are reasonable, understandable and valuable
• They can impact your quality of life
• Hold firm with our concerns, bring them up at the planning commission
•When deciding your vote we kindly ask you to consider the city CUP guidelines and infill development
policies in place to protect existing established neighborhoods
• Is a 3 story hotel with unrestricted hours of operation, increased foot traffic, unrestricted views into
neighboring homes and backyards that decreases property values, a good use for the parcel and meets
the city guidelines of not having a negative impact to the surrounding neighborhood?
Concerns
Opposition to Approval of StayApt CUP 23 04
•We attended the planning commission workshop on 8/10/23 the planning department reminded us a parcel may be
zoned to allow for a desired development but conditional use permits are used for PAD development to ensure the use is
compatible with existing uses and the surrounding neighborhood
•Does it fit with existing uses?
• The hours of operation don’t fit with existing business uses
• A hotel use is much more intense than existing surrounding uses
• A 3 story hotel does not fit in with existing 2 story buildings and will overshadow one behind it
• The proposed colors do not fit in with the existing buildings and will be an eye sore to neighbors
• The building barely fits on the lot
• The lot is not large enough for the applicant to plant trees that can address neighborhood privacy and property
valuation concerns
•We hope the commission weighs the rights of neighbors regarding privacy and property values
• A 3 story building without will allow guest to see into neighboring homes and yards which will intrude upon
residential privacy
• Not being fully screened from existing homes will reduce the homes property values
DOES IT FIT?
CUP Approval Restrictions
•Approve a 2 story building only
• A 2 story building will reduce the amount of property devaluation experienced by everyone since it won’t be as viewable from neighboring yards
• A 2 story building will not overshadow the IRS building behind it
• A 2 story building will greatly reduce the visibility into neighboring homes and yards
•Require the building colors to conform to the surrounding buildings in the business park and at best allow a muted blue and no yellows
•At a minimum, require shutters or some type of exterior window treatment that prevents viewing into our’s and neighboring homes and yards to
ensure our privacy is maintained
•Require an exterior surveillance system
•Require perimeter fencing to increase security features and help mitigate neighborhood foot traffic
•Limit stays not to exceed 6 months
•Please note in an effort to work with the developer
• We had initially requested larger trees as a stipulation and the owner said he would agree to this stipulation however they won’t solve the issue
and his solution places the ongoing watering and maintenance on us
• Trees will cost approximately $40,000, and be a large water drain
• Tree placement along our back yard is in direct conflict with the APS Right Tree Right Place guidelines as there are overhead power poles and
lines along our back fence
• Trees in our yard do not solve the privacy issues for many years to come and will solve the privacy issue our neighbors will also be facing
If a hotel use is approved we request the following Stipulations
Possible Window Treatments
•Shutters should be placed on any windows with
views into neighboring yards in order to provide
neighbors with privacy
•Shutters will provide privacy immediately
•Shutters will allow light into the room
•Shutters would be cheaper that trees
•Shutters won’t require water resources like trees will
From:
bpray
To:
Taylor, Matthew
Cc:
Walker-Hall, Tawanda; Perry, Tabitha; Lerma, Alex; Malnar, Raymond
Subject:
CUP 23 04
Date:
Wednesday, August 16, 2023 11:44:29 AM
Attachments:
Stay Apt Opposision Slides.pdf
Some people who received this message don't often get email from bpray@cox.net. Learn why this is important
Good Morning Matthew,
Attached is a document I prepared outlining why we believe the CUP 23 04 should be denied
according to city guidelines. It also includes stipulations we suggest if for some reason the use
is approved.
Thank You
Pam Ray
623-498-7595
bpray@cox.net
Ray Family Impacts
OPPOSITION TO APPROVAL OF Stay Apt CUP 23 04
The Ray Family
7305 W Angela Drive
Live Directly North (260’) of the Proposed StayApt Hotel
Opposition to Approval of StayApt CUP 23 04
•Hotels are inherently a 24 hour operation to accommodate various arrival & departure needs
• Standard hours may allude to restricted access but there are NO hour restrictions
•The proposed hotel is NOT a low-intensity, commercial use & will have negative impacts to our long established quiet
neighborhood
• The parcel zoning may have changed to C-2, however it is off main streets in an area that is primarily business park and
only 260 feet from a well established quiet neighborhood
• There are many uses for the site that would not have 24 hour operations such as retail, office, enclosed manufacturing or
storage facility, etc.
•Surrounding buildings and businesses do not have operations beyond 10 pm
•The 24 hours will increase traffic, noise, and foot traffic in the neighborhood
•The size of the building is out of character for the area and will overshadow the IRS building behind it
• The IRS building is already difficult for people to find and has increased neighborhood traffic for those looking for it, this
problem will only increase traffic issues
•Perimeter fencing is not planned, which would help prevent crime and decrease neighborhood foot traffic
•The hotel will have lighting that will be on at all hours of the night and create light trespassing onto our property at night from
the illumination and glare of the lights
Due to Use and Hours of Operation
Opposition to Approval of StayApt CUP 23 04
•The building height and location does not promote a functional relationship to the buildings
surrounding the site nor the surrounding neighborhood
•The tall architecture and proposed colors are not in harmony to the neighboring environment
•The proposed structure will create an intrusion of our privacy and reduce our quality of life
• A person 5’ tall will have an eye level view at about 15 ft on the 2nd floor and an eye level view at
about 25 ft on the 3rd floor
•A 3 story hotel of 35 feet high with windows looking into our home and neighborhood backyards will
negatively impact our and our neighbors’ privacy
• This is in direct opposition to the guidelines for approval under zoning code 3.605
•Commercial properties not FULLY screened from homes reduces property values
•The use and structure is in opposition to the City Envision Glendale General Plan, more specifically,
infill development policy CRR 2.5 which states the City should protect established areas/
neighborhoods by promoting context ‐ appropriate infill development
Due to Use and Hours of Operation
Opposition to Approval of StayApt CUP 23 04
•We had a meeting with the City of Glendale Planning Department on 7/19 to discuss our concerns and were
told:
• Citizen Participation Reports are not updated or corrected
• The planning department informed us on 8/15 they will be updated for this case to include Councilman
Malnar's Community Meeting held on 8/7/23
• Suggest changes and stipulations to the planning commission
• Our concerns are reasonable, understandable and valuable
• They can impact your quality of life
• Hold firm with our concerns, bring them up at the planning commission
•When deciding your vote we kindly ask you to consider the city CUP guidelines and infill development
policies in place to protect existing established neighborhoods
• Is a 3 story hotel with unrestricted hours of operation, increased foot traffic, unrestricted views into
neighboring homes and backyards that decreases property values, a good use for the parcel and meets
the city guidelines of not having a negative impact to the surrounding neighborhood?
Concerns
Opposition to Approval of StayApt CUP 23 04
•We attended the planning commission workshop on 8/10/23 the planning department reminded us a parcel may be
zoned to allow for a desired development but conditional use permits are used for PAD development to ensure the use is
compatible with existing uses and the surrounding neighborhood
•Does it fit with existing uses?
• The hours of operation don’t fit with existing business uses
• A hotel use is much more intense than existing surrounding uses
• A 3 story hotel does not fit in with existing 2 story buildings and will overshadow one behind it
• The proposed colors do not fit in with the existing buildings and will be an eye sore to neighbors
• The building barely fits on the lot
• The lot is not large enough for the applicant to plant trees that can address neighborhood privacy and property
valuation concerns
•We hope the commission weighs the rights of neighbors regarding privacy and property values
• A 3 story building without will allow guest to see into neighboring homes and yards which will intrude upon
residential privacy
• Not being fully screened from existing homes will reduce the homes property values
DOES IT FIT?
CUP Approval Restrictions
•Approve a 2 story building only
• A 2 story building will reduce the amount of property devaluation experienced by everyone since it won’t be as viewable from neighboring yards
• A 2 story building will not overshadow the IRS building behind it
• A 2 story building will greatly reduce the visibility into neighboring homes and yards
•Require the building colors to conform to the surrounding buildings in the business park and at best allow a muted blue and no yellows
•At a minimum, require shutters or some type of exterior window treatment that prevents viewing into our’s and neighboring homes and yards to
ensure our privacy is maintained
•Require an exterior surveillance system
•Require perimeter fencing to increase security features and help mitigate neighborhood foot traffic
•Limit stays not to exceed 6 months
•Please note in an effort to work with the developer
• We had initially requested larger trees as a stipulation and the owner said he would agree to this stipulation however they won’t solve the issue
and his solution places the ongoing watering and maintenance on us
• Trees will cost approximately $40,000, and be a large water drain
• Tree placement along our back yard is in direct conflict with the APS Right Tree Right Place guidelines as there are overhead power poles and
lines along our back fence
• Trees in our yard do not solve the privacy issues for many years to come and will solve the privacy issue our neighbors will also be facing
If a hotel use is approved we request the following Stipulations
Possible Window Treatments
•Shutters should be placed on any windows with
views into neighboring yards in order to provide
neighbors with privacy
•Shutters will provide privacy immediately
•Shutters will allow light into the room
•Shutters would be cheaper that trees
•Shutters won’t require water resources like trees will
From:
Erin Cole
To:
Taylor, Matthew; Walker-Hall, Tawanda; Perry, Tabitha; Lerma, Alex
Cc:
Malnar, Raymond
Subject:
CUP 23-04 Community Feedback
Date:
Wednesday, August 16, 2023 10:53:17 AM
Attachments:
Community Feedback CUP 23-04 (1).pdf
Good day, all,
Please see attached citizen summary from Councilman Malnar's Community Meeting August
7, 2023.
As Ms. Perry advised, pertinent documents received today would be included in the
Commissioners' packets for the August 24, 2023 hearing.
Kindly reply with confirmation of receipt, and confirmation of inclusion into the packets.
Thank you,
Erin Cole
602.770.9799
erinscole@gmail.com
SUMMARY OF COMMUNITY FEEDBACK
CUP 23-04, STAYAPT, 7300 W. CAMINO SAN XAVIER
AUGUST 16, 2023
Below is a summary of questions and comments posed to StayAPT’s developer, legal counsel,
and City Staff/administration from Councilman Malnar’s Community Meeting at Foothills
Recreation and Aquatic Center, Monday, August 7, 2023.
Support for project - residential and commercial neighbors: 0
Petition against project: Over 640 signatures
Attendees to oppose: Over 150 citizens, business owners, community stakeholders
Statements provided by StayAPT:
●
Inconsistent rate claims (Weinstein, 2021).
●
No ID requirements for reservation nor check-in (screenshots provided, Kelly).
●
False statements alleging zero negative feedback from neighbors (Adgie, 2022).
●
Area chosen as it is “quiet” for guests, with no regard for homeowners (Dymski).
●
North side 14’ buffer cannot accommodate landscaping to mitigate privacy intrusions to
residences (Dymski).
●
Offer to plant trees in Rays’ yard, as they have admitted sight line issues (Dymski).
●
Public admission of improper notification regarding the hidden signage on subject lot
(Dymski)
Media coverage of StayAPT:
Adgie, 2022., Dobrosielski, 2020., Stockmar, 2023a., Stockmar, 2023b., Weinstein, 2020.
Comments from community members
●
Immeasurable devaluation of residential properties as stated by realtors, brokers, and
appraisers (Manning, Ray, Viglietta, et al).
●
Gross invasion of privacy from north, east, and west windows of property with zero plan
to cover windows, inability to provide landscaping (Cole, Crandall, Ray).
●
Safety concerns with 24-hour activity into our neighborhood.
●
Traffic concerns (75th Ave, blind curve in Camino San Xavier, lost travelers into
neighborhood (Cole, McRuff, Prather et al).
●
No sidewalks on Camino San Xavier for guests to frequent mall, businesses (Prather)
●
Emergency response vehicle concerns - accessibility (VanDriel)
●
90 second walk into neighborhood (Crandall)
●
<400 feet to junior high/high school bus stop (Cole, Crandall)
●
No streetlights, no sidewalks in Secluded Acres (Prather)
●
Congestion/misuse/abuse of equestrian/biking/hiking trail (Mareska)
●
Limited notice to community and businesses, hidden sign (Leuschner)
●
Tax deferment packages (Viglietta)
●
Greenbriar Park proximity - walking distance to children (Fowler)
●
Overflow parking destination when the parking lot is full (McRuff)
●
Parking for full-sized vehicles, construction vehicles, military vehicles (Cole, Kelly)
●
No vetting of tenants - temporary housing for transient workers (DeWalt)
●
49 potential sites provided to build
●
The community is not against StayAPT in Glendale - we are against it in our backyards
(150 attendees)
Statistical crime data:
●
Peer-reviewed published analyses attached hereto, “References”.
Questions posed to StayApt and its speakers and that remain unanswered:
●
Where is the contract for service with the US military, as alleged in each meeting (Cole)?
●
Where are the contracts for service with traveling nurse agencies, as named in each
meeting (Cole)?
●
Where are the contracts for service with displayed local brands of hospitals, and other
businesses (Cole)?
●
Why do some campuses answer the phone with a different name other than “StayAPT”
(Cole)?
●
What happened to the new properties to change brands so quickly (Cole)?
●
StayAPT was unable to describe security other than a live in manager, and a key card
access to the property. StayAPT is unsure if they will install exterior security cameras
(Cole, Kelly, Young).
●
Where will tenants be permitted to smoke? There is no smoking on property (Kelly).
●
Where is the pet area? It is omitted from the site plan (Kelly).
●
What is the security plan and eviction enforcement with Glendale PD (Young)?
●
What are the lumens of the lights on the exterior of the facility (Kelly)?
Questions posed to and unanswered by City Staff:
●
Was the P&Z Commission notified that the April document provided by Mr. Alleman
was incorrect/misleading (Cole)?
●
What are the ramifications for an applicant falsifying a report provided to City Staff after
a neighborhood meeting notice (Cole)?
●
When will the amended report be prepared and public record (Cole)?
●
How many additional police officers is the City hiring to mitigate illegal activity in this
area (Crawford, Young)?
●
Who will be liable for devaluation of property values (Manning, Ray, Viglietta, et al)?
●
Who will be liable for privacy issues (photos from apartments into our homes and yards)
(Cole, Crandall, Prather, et al)?
●
Why were the surrounding businesses in the 300’ zone NOT noticed (Cole)?
References
Adgie, J. (2022, March 21). Neighborhood angry over proposed extended-stay hotel.
Times-Herald.com.
https://www.times-herald.com/news/local/neighborhood-angry-over-proposed-extended-stay-hot
el/article_46063d60-b770-5825-8481-9a58921d4f0d.html
AllSides. (2023, August 10). Massachusetts lt. gov tells residents to ‘consider hosting’ illegal
immigrant families in their homes.
https://www.allsides.com/news/2023-08-10-1024/general-news-massachusetts-lt-gov-tells-reside
nts-consider-hosting-illegal
Binns, C. A., & Kempf, R. J. (2020). Introduction to safety and security in hotels and home
sharing. In (Ed.), Springerbriefs in criminology (pp. 1–9).
https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-59306-3_1
Bowen, D. A., Anthony, K. M., & Sumner, S. A. (2022). Business and property types
experiencing excess violent crime: A micro-spatial analysis. Journal of injury & violence
research, 14(1), 1–10. https://doi.org/10.5249/jivr.v14i1.1566
Clark, L. (2023, July 30). Service dog stolen from tempe hotel room found, returned to owner.
FOX 10 Phoenix.
https://www.fox10phoenix.com/news/20k-reward-offered-for-service-dog-stolen-from-tempe-hot
el-room?utm_campaign=trueanthem_manual%26utm_medium=trueAnthem&utm_source=instag
ram
Dobrosielski, C. (2020, January 23). New stayAPT Suites extended-stay brand plots rapid
growth. HotelManagement.net.
https://www.hotelmanagement.net/development/new-long-term-lodging-brand-stayapt-suites-plo
ts-rapid-growth
EIN News. (2023, February 21). Sexual assault attorneys create safety checklist for travelers
amid surge of hotel attacks.
https://www.einnews.com/pr_news/618259535/sexual-assault-attorneys-create-safety-checklist-f
or-travelers-amid-surge-of-hotel-attacks
Ho, T., Zhao, J., & Brown, M. P. (2008). Examining hotel crimes from police crime reports.
Crime Prevention and Community Safety, 11(1), 21–33. https://doi.org/10.1057/cpcs.2008.17
Meyers, C. (2023, January 5). Rights of Renters in Extended Stay Hotels. findlaw.com.
https://www.findlaw.com/realestate/landlord-tenant-law/rights-of-renters-in-extended-stay-hotels
.html
Schmerler, K. (2005). US Department of Justice - Office of Community Policing. Disorder at
Budget Motels, 30.
https://doi.org/chrome-extension://efaidnbmnnnibpcajpcglclefindmkaj/https://popcenter.asu.edu/
sites/default/files/disorder_at_budget_motels.pdf
Shapiro, L. R. (2021). Corporate Liability of Hotels: Criminal Sanctions for Online Sex
Trafficking. Journal of Internet Law, 24(5), 3–10.
Stockmar, S. (2023a, June 28). Potential extended-stay hotel draws ire of glendale residents - the
daily independent at yourvalley.net. The Daily Independent at YourValley.net.
https://www.yourvalley.net/stories/potential-extended-stay-hotel-draws-ire-from-glendale-reside
nts,406986
Stockmar, S. (2023b, August 9). Glendale residents, developers square off over hotel location -
the daily independent at yourvalley.net. The Daily Independent at YourValley.net.
https://www.yourvalley.net/stories/glendale-residents-developers-square-off-over-hotel-location,
416378
U.S. Census Bureau. (2011). People who live in hotels: An exploratory overview [PDF].
https://www.census.gov/content/dam/Census/library/working-papers/2006/adrm/ssm2006-03.pdf
Weinstein, J. (2021, April 9). Stayapt suites off to aggressive start in us - hotelsmag.com.
HOTELSMag.com. https://hotelsmag.com/news/stayapt-suites-off-to-aggressive-start-in-us/
Zarkowski, P., & Avery, D. (2006). Hotel room suicide. Suicide and Life-Threatening Behavior,
36(5), 578–581. https://doi.org/10.1521/suli.2006.36.5.578
From:
Taylor, Matthew
To:
Lerma, Alex
Cc:
Walker-Hall, Tawanda
Subject:
FW: Appreciated your presentation for the Stay APT project
Date:
Tuesday, August 15, 2023 7:18:24 AM
Attachments:
image001.jpg
Applicant-forwarded email re: CUP23-04.
From: Shaine T. Alleman <sta@tblaw.com>
Sent: Monday, August 14, 2023 2:49 PM
To: Perry, Tabitha <TPerry@GLENDALEAZ.com>; Taylor, Matthew <MTaylor@GLENDALEAZ.com>
Subject: FW: Appreciated your presentation for the Stay APT project
Tabitha and Matthew,
Please see support email received from a nearby residential neighbor. We also included this in the
revised Citizen Participation Report that I will send you shortly.
Thank you,
Shaine T. Alleman | Shareholder | 602.452.2712
TIFFANY & BOSCO, P.A.
Seventh Floor Camelback Esplanade II | 2525 E Camelback Road | Phoenix, AZ 85016
P 602.255.6000 | F 602.255.0103
sta@tblaw.com | Bio | vCard | Website | Practice Areas
Offices: Arizona | California | Nevada | New Mexico
From: Randy Huston <Yellowstoneta@yellowstoneta.com>
Sent: Monday, August 14, 2023 10:07 AM
To: Shaine T. Alleman <sta@tblaw.com>
Subject: Appreciated your presentation for the Stay APT project
Hi Shane,
I was at the meeting at the Foothill Aquatic Center last Monday for the presentation and
questions for your client for the Stay APT project.
I was shocked at how rude and disrespectful most of the attendees were to you, Mike and the
others who were part of the presentation. You all impressed me that you always took the high
road on every question with Michael most of the time saying “that was a very thoughtful
question”. You all were very professional, gracious and courteous even though the people on
the other side were far from that. I am sure you had to bite your tongue many times when
the same unfounded statements were repeated. Most people were obviously not there to
hear your side of the discussion.
Your group did a great job of explaining how your project is not the typical Extended Stay
hotel. Your price point is higher, you have the on-site manager to keep things under control
as well as explaining why your clientele is mostly a working during the day group of clients and
not the type of patron who could possibly be a threat to the neighborhood.
I live in the Hidden Manor neighborhood on the west side of 75th Ave. I am an owner of
Yellowstone Trust Administration and know what it means to start your own business with the
needed capital and time to put into it to make it successful. I attended to see what the project
is and to see if it was possibly the type of Extended Stay hotel that would be all the problems
that some people were inferring about your project. I was totally convinced that this is a good
project and an asset to the neighborhood. I can’t imagine that a vacant lot with no lighting is a
better option than an expensive Hotel that attracts upper middle class clients. I hope that the
Planning commission approves your project and look forward to having relatives and business
associates stay at your nice Hotel.
Best Regards,
Randy Huston, CFP®
Yellowstone Trust Administration, Inc.
Randy Huston's direct lines:
Phone: 800-572-6394
Fax: 602-926-2584
2070 Overland Ave., Suite 104
Billings, MT 59102
Website: www.yellowstoneta.com
Email: yellowstoneta@yellowstoneta.com
Note: Unless otherwise specifically noted in this e-mail letter, the author is not engaged in rendering legal, accounting, tax or other
professional services with the dissemination of information in this e-mail letter. The opinions expressed in this e-mail, while intended to
be accurate, are for general educational and informational purposes only.
From:
Mary Park
To:
Taylor, Matthew
Subject:
Opposing CUP 23-04
Date:
Wednesday, August 16, 2023 10:08:19 AM
You don't often get email from mbpark814@gmail.com. Learn why this is important
Dear Planning Commission, Mr. Taylor
My name is Mary Park and I am a resident of Buckeye. Although I am a resident of
another city, I am a frequent shopper and visitor of the Glendale area and belong to
organizations that gather in Glendale often. I am writing to oppose the CUP 23-04 -
Modern Stay near Arrowhead Mall.
The Hotel’s location would be too close to a School and also it takes away the privacy of
the neighbors from the upper floors. With the Phoenix area so close it would expand the
safety issue of children because of the criminals for Human Trafficking, Kidnapping not
to mention the additional traffic.
I sincerely hope you consider opposing the Modern StayApt and am asking you to vote
NO for the CUP 23-04.
Thank you,
Mary Park
mbpark814@gmail.com
City of Glendale
Planning ● 5850 West Glendale Avenue, Suite 212 ● Glendale, AZ 85301-2599 ● Phone (623) 930-2800
www.glendaleaz.com
August 23, 2023
The City of Glendale, Development Service Department – Planning, has amended the
Planning Commission agenda for the public hearing on August 24, 2023. The Citizen
Comments for agenda item 5.1 CUP23-04 MODERN STAY – STAY APT have been
updated.
City staff received 200+ emails (pages) and made great efforts to provide the Public and
Planning Commissioners with additional and/or missed correspondences that we
received between from August 1 – 22, 2023; before the start of the public hearing. Any
correspondences received after noon; August 22nd will be given to the Commissioners
at the public hearing.
Thank you for your patience.
The City of Glendale
Development Service Department - Planning
From:
James Ho
To:
Walker-Hall, Tawanda; Perry, Tabitha
Cc:
Taylor, Matthew; Sage, Patrick
Subject:
Transportation Public Comments for CUP23-04 StayApt Hotel - Letter to Planning Commission
Date:
Tuesday, August 1, 2023 6:01:13 AM
Attachments:
CUP23-04 JH Letter to Planning Commission.pdf
Ms. Walker-Hall and Ms. Perry,
Please distribute the attached letter to the members of the Planning Commission regarding
transportation-related public comments for the Conditional Use Permit case CUP23-
04 StayApt Hotel.
I received these public comments in my capacity as a member of the CTOC and am
transmitting them to the Planning Commission to be addressed by the Applicant and/or City to
the satisfaction of all parties.
Commissioner James Ho
602-420-3765
jameshoaz@gmail.com
From:
D Adams
To:
Malnar, Raymond; Taylor, Matthew
Cc:
Erin Cole
Subject:
stayAPT Suites 8/7 meeting
Date:
Monday, August 7, 2023 12:10:03 PM
You don't often get email from azchrome@yahoo.com. Learn why this is important
Hello, Ray Malnar
My wife and I have rsvp’d for the meetings today. We will do our best to attend but we are juggling our 4
kids meet the teacher night (5:30 - 7p).
Looking at the agenda the meeting will be ~65 minutes, so hoping we make the Q&A.
Just in case we are late or cannot make it tonight, I wanted to send you this note with our initial thoughts
so that our attendance is virtually counted.
Is there any way the developers presentation can be shared post the meeting?
Also the city presentation please?
1. We are very interested to hear the City of Glendale vision for this wonderful area (Arrowhead) and how
this project fits in the future growth of Glendale. Because based on the comprehensive parks and
recreation study that Glendale published and approved, we thought Glendale had aspirations for growing
Glendale so not to fall forth behind other cities. And it is not clear how this re-zoning and allowing the
build of a startup motel chain, furthers or supports those goals and objective.
Also it is not clear what this developers plans for success are. It looks like stayAPT have a location
planned on Central and Washington St (downtown Phoenix), which is definitely a much different area
than Arrowhead.
This just seems like an odd location to build an extended stay motel. Is there a comprehensive business
plan from the developers with targets and forecast. Personally I feel there are much better options on the
main road, not a hidden lot with only a view of business dumpster to the south and a poorly lite
neighborhood to the north, because the City of Glendale has YET to invest in street lights, sidewalks or
updating the historic walking path/trail (to match the path near the police/fire station on Union Hills), so
that any potential visitors have a place to walk their pets.
We feel that the success of this project should be the top priority for the City of Glendale and not just
selling the land. As the failure of this project will solely be City of Glendale and the neighboring residence
issue, which is the concern of all the constituencies that have vocalized.
Is the upcoming zoning hearing a community vote or unilateral decision by the city staff?
If the City of Glendale have broader development plans coming to the area I would love to see those
ideas and plans and how this motel supports? We, and I bet everyone as well, do not want this beautiful
area to become like Metro Center or 27th Ave and Yorkshire.
Thank you in advance for the community support,
Diwan and Rebecca Adams
Planning Received
August 7, 2023
From:
Erin Cole
To:
Malnar, Raymond
Cc:
Taylor, Matthew; Walker-Hall, Tawanda; Perry, Tabitha; Lerma, Alex
Subject:
Re: August 7th Meeting Follow Up From Council Member Malnar
Date:
Wednesday, August 9, 2023 8:21:38 PM
Hi Ray,
Thank you for your email. And thank you, again, for hosting the meeting.
I trust that the countless emails that Mr. Taylor has already received will be included in P&Z
Commission's packet, and that the linked email addresses will be supplementing what has
already been sent? Perhaps City staff can confirm that... ?
In addition, this is my third request to City staff asking the ramifications of an applicant
providing false information on their submitted report. Please advise if the P&Z Commission
was notified of the erroneous report, the penalties thereof, and how the City will ensure that
the next report is accurate.
Thanks to you all!
Erin Cole
602.770.9799
erinscole@gmail.com
On Wed, Aug 9, 2023 at 1:32 PM Malnar, Raymond <RMalnar@glendaleaz.com> wrote:
Dear Resident,
I would like to begin by thanking you for attending Monday’s meeting at the Foothills
Recreation and Aquatics Center. My goal in having this informational meeting was to give
more residents an opportunity to hear directly from the developer and ask questions and
express concerns.
Many of you expressed an interest in sending letters to the Planning Commission prior to the
request being heard at their meeting on August 24th at 6:00pm to be located at Glendale
Civic Center, 5750 W Glenn Dr, Glendale, AZ 85301 . Please submit your letters to the
following city staff: twalker@glendaleaz.com , tperry@glendaleaz.com , and
alerma@glendaleaz.com .
If you plan on speaking, you will need to fill out a speaker card at the meeting. We
recommend that you prepare a statement prior to the meeting as you will be limited to 3
minutes speaking time.
Additionally, my office confirmed with the City Clerk’s office that the agenda will be posted
by August 22nd. Once it’s posted, you can click HERE to review it.
Once again, thank you for attending this important meeting- should you have any questions,
please feel free to reach out.
Thank you,
Council Member Ray Malnar
Sahuaro District
From:
Deborah Catania
To:
Walker-Hall, Tawanda
Subject:
Re: Drug hotel
Date:
Wednesday, August 9, 2023 3:44:28 PM
You don't often get email from catani3@outlook.com. Learn why this is important
In what city do you all live ?
Get Outlook for iOS
From: Deborah Catania
Sent: Wednesday, August 9, 2023 3:37:19 PM
To: twalker@glendaleaz.com <twalker@glendaleaz.com>
Subject: Drug hotel
To whom it may concern ,
If you try to act like this hotel would be a good addition to the neighborhood spare me the
money hungry tax money your looking for from such a hotel !
This is not a Marriott or Hilton it is a low rate pile of crap hotel and how dare all of you spin it
like it's a great addition to the neighborhood ! It is NOT.
Get Outlook for iOS
From:
MaryAnn
To:
Walker-Hall, Tawanda
Subject:
Next committee meeting
Date:
Wednesday, August 9, 2023 5:05:25 PM
[You don't often get email from mab1119@cox.net. Learn why this is important at
https://aka.ms/LearnAboutSenderIdentification ]
I received the communication from Ray Malnar concerning the next committee meeting.
I am against the building of this Stay Apt extended stay facility on Camino San Xavier in Glendale, Az. There are
too many concerns, stated by many residents at the Aug 7 meeting with the developer. First being safety of the
nearby neighborhood residents, cameras were mention. Cameras can can document crimes, not stop crimes. It’s
supposed to be a non smoking facility, no where on the grounds, where are the residents going to smoke cigarettes
or marijuana. Perhaps in the neighborhood near by in back of facility. We do not want that in our area.
The price that the developers quoted to stay was $166.00 a night. There was some confusion on the price, we had
$3500.00 a month. Some of our speakers spoke on the subject of price. There is an apartment complex nearby
where people are paying more than that. So it’s a no brainer the Stay Apt will rent faster. Who’s going to be
renting there? As one of the police officer said at the meeting, homeless people all have cell phones, and receive
credit cards from the government for assistance. They also know how to manipulate to get cards. They then can
leave their doors open to bring others in, only God knows who. A huge concern. Police knows it’s hard to evict
them.
The people’s homes that back up to the facility will not have privacy, since it is so close to their homes. The
developers offered to plant trees on their property, trees that tall would cost $10,000.00 and the owners would bear
the cost of water to keep them alive. Also we are worried about the numbers of parking spaces that they want to
provide, and if there are going to be charging stations for EV’s. The access for fire trucks is also questionable,
doesn’t seem like there’s wide enough access.
The homes have also depreciated $10,000.00, after the IRS building was built. The owners don’t want their
properties depreciated any more. There plenty of vacant land to the north in Peoria.
In 5 or 10 years, if the franchise runs into financial difficulty, there is no guarantee who’s going to take over.
Perhaps a homeless shelter, or put immigrants there. No telling.
Also is this committee meeting going to be televised on the Glendale station or the internet? What is the time and
location of the next meeting. Thx, Mary Ann Brown
Sent from my iPad
From:
Leeanne Hayward
To:
Taylor, Matthew; Perry, Tabitha
Subject:
CUP 23-04
Date:
Friday, August 11, 2023 12:32:03 PM
Some people who received this message don't often get email from leeannehay79@gmail.com. Learn why this is
important
Dear Planning Commission,
My name is Leeanne Hayward and I am a former resident of Glendale for 50+ years and a
current Peoria, Az. resident. Although I am a resident of another city, I am a frequent shopper
and visitor of the Glendale area. I am writing to oppose the CUP 23-04 - Modern Stay near
Arrowhead Mall.
Our key concerns are for the safety of those who live and shop in the area. As you know
Phoenix is the kidnapping capital of America and human/sex trafficking is a huge problem. This
hotel will only draw into this. This hotel is less than 500 ft from a school bus stop and less than
a mile from an elementary school. This 3-story hotel would overlook some of Glendale
resident's backyards and a straight view into their home.
I am writing in opposition to the Modern StayApt and am asking you to vote "NO" for the CUP
23-04.
Thank you,
Leeanne & Jim Hayward
14851 N 88th Avenue
Peoria AZ
85381
From:
Connie Kiser
To:
Taylor, Matthew; Perry, Tabitha
Subject:
P&Z packet for StayAPT project
Date:
Friday, August 11, 2023 9:26:34 PM
Some people who received this message don't often get email from conkiser@msn.com. Learn why this is
important
Dear Mr. Taylor and Ms. Perry:
Would you please see that the following letter is included in the P & Z Commissioners' packet
for the 8/24/23 P&Z meeting where the StayAPT application is going to be considered. I am
totally against this project.
8/11/2023
Dear: Members of the Glendale Planning & Zoning Commission
P & Z Staff: Matt Taylor and Tabitha Perry
First, thank you Mr. Taylor and Ms. Perry for attending the informational meeting held at the
Foothills Aquatic Center on August 7th. As you know from that meeting residents from Secluded
Acres and also Hidden Manor and Arrowhead Ranch are adamantly against approval of the StayAPT
application now pending to be built in our neighborhood.
Some of my thoughts taken from the meeting:
1. The diagram of what the proposed facility will be appears to be more like a prison. Each of
the apartments open onto a courtyard, with no outside access other than through one main
door leading into the entire building. The code for that door could be changed at any time to
facilitate a rental program for residents that cannot leave, such as housing for a half-way
house or temporary housing for migrants – such as was done in Scottsdale.
2. The developer sold this as catering to high-end executives who need to stay in the area for
work. Who in their right might would choose to rent in a location that is built along a two-
lane alley that backs up to the rear of numerous retail stores where garbage and other
delivery truck services are taking place. I believe the developer is not being totally honest
about his intentions with the City of Glendale on what the ultimate use for this facility is going
to be. Something just doesn’t smell right about this project – including the fact that the
developer keeps changing his answers depending on who he is trying to sway, including how
much the apartments are going to rent for nightly. During the meeting it became apparent
that this project is going to end up negatively impacting all of the nearby residents who have
invested hard-earned money into their homes, including not only Secluded Acres, but also
Hidden Manor and Arrowhead Ranch.
3. This project is less than 300’ from the backyards of residents in Secluded Acres which will
totally destroy their privacy and create noise and other issues that you wouldn't want in your
own backyard - so why allow it is ours.
4. Over the years we have already seen crime increase in the Arrowhead mall area and this
proposed StayAPT facility would create a window of opportunity for increased crime and
traffic along Camino San Xavier.
I urge you to DENY the application for the StayAPT three-story building to be located at
73rd Ave. and Camino San Xavier. It is not beneficial to anyone but the developer for
such a project to be tucked into our otherwise quiet neighborhoods.
Thank you.
Connie Kiser
Hidden Manor Resident
7644 W. Michigan Ave.
Glendale, AZ 85308
Some people who received this message don't often get email from 1vettenut@gmail.com. Learn why this is
important
From:
Walker-Hall, Tawanda
To:
Gary Carlston
Cc:
Perry, Tabitha; Lerma, Alex; Taylor, Matthew
Subject:
RE: stayAPT proposal
Date:
Monday, August 14, 2023 8:48:03 AM
Greetings, Mr. Carlston –
Your concerns have been received and will be shared with the Planning Commission.
Thank you,
We are moving…
Glendale City Hall is being remodeled. Effective Monday, August 21, 2023, Development Services Department -
Building Safety/ Planning will be located at 5754 W Glenn Drive formerly known as The Bead Museum. All
department emails and phone numbers will remain the same.
From: Gary Carlston <1vettenut@gmail.com>
Sent: Sunday, August 13, 2023 4:08 PM
To: Walker-Hall, Tawanda <TWalker@GLENDALEAZ.com>; Perry, Tabitha
<TPerry@GLENDALEAZ.com>; Lerma, Alex <alerma@GLENDALEAZ.com>
Subject: stayAPT proposal
Dear Planning Commission Members,
I am a resident of Secluded Acres neighborhood located just north of a proposed stayAPT
Suites building site.
I am totally opposed to the building of any extended stay, hotel, motel or other short term
living facility for a number of reasons.
First, the proposed facility is planned as a three story structure. This would allow the rooms on
the second and third floors on the north side of the facility to look into the backyards of the
homes located on the south side of our neighborhood. Compromising these homes privacy.
Second, I feel that the security of our neighborhood would be severely compromised. StayApt
officials claim that because they cater to a higher standard clientele (i.e. professional medical,
military, sports enthusiasts, etc.) there would be no chance of criminal activity. The stayAPT
officials did not consider that drug pushers, sex traffickers and child traffickers, etc. have the
means to rent these type of facilities as well and likely would. Of course, it would attract these
type of people. Please understand that we have a lot of families in our neighborhood who have
children and those children travel to an elementary school by foot and bicycle located just
across Union Hills Drive to the north of Secluded Acres. Also, we have quite a few people
who walk and ride bicycles on the streets of our neighborhood. Their safety would be
compromised by any criminal activity resulting from stayAPT, not to mention our properties
as well.
Third, it's a given that our property values will decrease. When extended stays, hotels, motels
and any other short term living facility is located nearby or adjacent to a housing development,
property values are almost certainly to be affected.
Please do not approve stayAPT's request to build on this property. Thank You.
Gary Carlston
7116 W. Villa Theresa Dr.
Glendale, AZ 95308
Phone: 602-547-2110
From:
Arlene Duston
To:
Taylor, Matthew
Cc:
Malnar, Raymond
Subject:
Plans for stayAPT Suites Motel
Date:
Sunday, August 13, 2023 4:25:01 PM
Some people who received this message don't often get email from duston2001@email.com. Learn why this is
important
Dear Mr. Matt Taylor and members of the Glendale Planning Commission:
I request the Glendale Planning Commission decline authorization of the CUP for the
Extended stayAPT Suites Hotel. I have the following concerns.
1. Safety concern: Experience shows that hospitals see increased prostitution and
drug cases when an extended stay is near the hospital. Arrowhead Abrazo
Hospital is only a mile away and Secluded Acres is in the middle. People
engaging in prostitution and drug use need money to continue their habits and
will break into nearby homes/yards to steal money or anything to sell for
money. Residents are concerned about break-ins. Glendale police will need to
be called more often.
2. Traffic concern: Traffic will increase in Secluded Acres down 73rd Avenue with
Extended stayAPT Motel customers trying to drive to the building only to find
they are blocked by the signs and trails. Drivers will then wind around various
streets looking for a way out of the neighborhood. This impacts children and
parents riding bikes to or from school and people walking. By design, there are
no sidewalks in Secluded Acres.
3. Location: The location for Extended stayAPT hotel is not a good location for
clients who will have a hard time finding it. Driving there during busy times of
the day is difficult because the street is curved and narrow. There is a greater
chance of car wrecks. Glendale police will have more calls.
4. Lighting: Secluded Acres is a low- light area. We have few street lights. I
remember when they first put in street lights – what a change for street corners!
The additional lighting at the motel will impact homes nearby making it hard to
sleep and decreasing privacy. Planners will have a challenge regarding
directional lighting.
5. Increased Noise: Additional vehicles increase noise for Secluded Acres
residents. Trucks make more noise. Extended stayAPT motel clients will be
driving cars and trucks all times of the day and night coming and going. Utility
trucks will come particularly in the early morning to dump trash. Air
conditioners, if outside of the building, make noise.
An office building would be a better choice for this property.
Sincerely,
Arlene Duston, 602-938-2886
Duston2001@email.com
Cc: Ray Malnar, City Councilman
1
Lerma, Alex
From:
Taylor, Matthew
Sent:
Tuesday, August 15, 2023 7:18 AM
To:
Lerma, Alex
Cc:
Walker-Hall, Tawanda
Subject:
FW: Appreciated your presentation for the Stay APT project
Applicant-forwarded email re: CUP23-04.
From: Shaine T. Alleman <sta@tblaw.com>
Sent: Monday, August 14, 2023 2:49 PM
To: Perry, Tabitha <TPerry@GLENDALEAZ.com>; Taylor, Matthew <MTaylor@GLENDALEAZ.com>
Subject: FW: Appreciated your presentation for the Stay APT project
Tabitha and Matthew,
Please see support email received from a nearby residential neighbor. We also included this in the revised Citizen
Participation Report that I will send you shortly.
Thank you,
Shaine T. Alleman | Shareholder | 602.452.2712
TIFFANY & BOSCO, P.A.
Seventh Floor Camelback Esplanade II | 2525 E Camelback Road | Phoenix, AZ 85016
P 602.255.6000 | F 602.255.0103
sta@tblaw.com | Bio | vCard | Website | Practice Areas
Offices: Arizona | California | Nevada | New Mexico
From: Randy Huston <Yellowstoneta@yellowstoneta.com>
Sent: Monday, August 14, 2023 10:07 AM
To: Shaine T. Alleman <sta@tblaw.com>
Subject: Appreciated your presentation for the Stay APT project
Hi Shane,
I was at the meeting at the Foothill Aquatic Center last Monday for the presentation and questions for your
client for the Stay APT project.
I was shocked at how rude and disrespectful most of the attendees were to you, Mike and the others who
were part of the presentation. You all impressed me that you always took the high road on every question
with Michael most of the time saying “that was a very thoughtful question”. You all were very professional,
gracious and courteous even though the people on the other side were far from that. I am sure you had to
bite your tongue many times when the same unfounded statements were repeated. Most people were
obviously not there to hear your side of the discussion.
Your group did a great job of explaining how your project is not the typical Extended Stay hotel. Your price
point is higher, you have the on-site manager to keep things under control as well as explaining why your
2
clientele is mostly a working during the day group of clients and not the type of patron who could possibly be
a threat to the neighborhood.
I live in the Hidden Manor neighborhood on the west side of 75th Ave. I am an owner of Yellowstone Trust
Administration and know what it means to start your own business with the needed capital and time to put
into it to make it successful. I attended to see what the project is and to see if it was possibly the type of
Extended Stay hotel that would be all the problems that some people were inferring about your project. I was
totally convinced that this is a good project and an asset to the neighborhood. I can’t imagine that a vacant lot
with no lighting is a better option than an expensive Hotel that attracts upper middle class clients. I hope that
the Planning commission approves your project and look forward to having relatives and business associates
stay at your nice Hotel.
Best Regards,
Randy Huston, CFP®
Yellowstone Trust Administration, Inc.
Randy Huston's direct lines:
Phone: 800-572-6394
Fax: 602-926-2584
2070 Overland Ave., Suite 104
Billings, MT 59102
Website: www.yellowstoneta.com
Email: yellowstoneta@yellowstoneta.com
Note: Unless otherwise specifically noted in this e-mail letter, the author is not engaged in rendering legal, accounting, tax or other professional services with the
dissemination of information in this e-mail letter. The opinions expressed in this e-mail, while intended to be accurate, are for general educational and
informational purposes only.
From:
caralee mcruff.com
To:
Taylor, Matthew
Subject:
Opposition to StayApt CUP 23-04
Date:
Monday, August 14, 2023 8:52:27 PM
You don't often get email from caralee@mcruff.com. Learn why this is important
Dear Mr. Taylor,
I hope this email finds you well. I am writing to express my strong opposition to CUP 23-04. As a
concerned citizen, I believe it is crucial to address the potential dangers that this proposal may
bring to our community, particularly to hotels and extended stay establishments.
One of the primary concerns I have is the potential increase in criminal activities associated with
such establishments. Crime, drugs, and sex trafficking are unfortunate realities that can thrive in
environments where transient populations are prevalent. It is essential to consider the safety and
well-being of both residents and visitors when evaluating this proposal.
Furthermore, I would like to draw attention to the potential impact on traffic congestion. The
influx of guests and visitors to these establishments may lead to increased traffic in the
surrounding areas. This could not only inconvenience local residents but also pose potential
safety hazards.
In conclusion, I urge you to carefully reconsider the implications of CUP 23-04. The safety and
security of our community should be our utmost priority. I appreciate your attention to this
matter and look forward to hearing your thoughts on the subject.
Thank you for your time and consideration.
Sincerely,
Caralee Ruff
Secluded Acres Resident
Ray Family Impacts
OPPOSITION TO APPROVAL OF Stay Apt CUP 23 04
The Ray Family
7305 W Angela Drive
Live Directly North (260’) of the Proposed StayApt Hotel
Opposition to Approval of StayApt CUP 23 04
•Hotels are inherently a 24 hour operation to accommodate various arrival & departure needs
• Standard hours may allude to restricted access but there are NO hour restrictions
•The proposed hotel is NOT a low-intensity, commercial use & will have negative impacts to our long established quiet
neighborhood
• The parcel zoning may have changed to C-2, however it is off main streets in an area that is primarily business park and
only 260 feet from a well established quiet neighborhood
• There are many uses for the site that would not have 24 hour operations such as retail, office, enclosed manufacturing or
storage facility, etc.
•Surrounding buildings and businesses do not have operations beyond 10 pm
•The 24 hours will increase traffic, noise, and foot traffic in the neighborhood
•The size of the building is out of character for the area and will overshadow the IRS building behind it
• The IRS building is already difficult for people to find and has increased neighborhood traffic for those looking for it, this
problem will only increase traffic issues
•Perimeter fencing is not planned, which would help prevent crime and decrease neighborhood foot traffic
•The hotel will have lighting that will be on at all hours of the night and create light trespassing onto our property at night from
the illumination and glare of the lights
Due to Use and Hours of Operation
Opposition to Approval of StayApt CUP 23 04
•The building height and location does not promote a functional relationship to the buildings
surrounding the site nor the surrounding neighborhood
•The tall architecture and proposed colors are not in harmony to the neighboring environment
•The proposed structure will create an intrusion of our privacy and reduce our quality of life
• A person 5’ tall will have an eye level view at about 15 ft on the 2nd floor and an eye level view at
about 25 ft on the 3rd floor
•A 3 story hotel of 35 feet high with windows looking into our home and neighborhood backyards will
negatively impact our and our neighbors’ privacy
• This is in direct opposition to the guidelines for approval under zoning code 3.605
•Commercial properties not FULLY screened from homes reduces property values
•The use and structure is in opposition to the City Envision Glendale General Plan, more specifically,
infill development policy CRR 2.5 which states the City should protect established areas/
neighborhoods by promoting context ‐ appropriate infill development
Due to Use and Hours of Operation
Opposition to Approval of StayApt CUP 23 04
•We had a meeting with the City of Glendale Planning Department on 7/19 to discuss our concerns and were
told:
• Citizen Participation Reports are not updated or corrected
• The planning department informed us on 8/15 they will be updated for this case to include Councilman
Malnar's Community Meeting held on 8/7/23
• Suggest changes and stipulations to the planning commission
• Our concerns are reasonable, understandable and valuable
• They can impact your quality of life
• Hold firm with our concerns, bring them up at the planning commission
•When deciding your vote we kindly ask you to consider the city CUP guidelines and infill development
policies in place to protect existing established neighborhoods
• Is a 3 story hotel with unrestricted hours of operation, increased foot traffic, unrestricted views into
neighboring homes and backyards that decreases property values, a good use for the parcel and meets
the city guidelines of not having a negative impact to the surrounding neighborhood?
Concerns
Opposition to Approval of StayApt CUP 23 04
•We attended the planning commission workshop on 8/10/23 the planning department reminded us a parcel may be
zoned to allow for a desired development but conditional use permits are used for PAD development to ensure the use is
compatible with existing uses and the surrounding neighborhood
•Does it fit with existing uses?
• The hours of operation don’t fit with existing business uses
• A hotel use is much more intense than existing surrounding uses
• A 3 story hotel does not fit in with existing 2 story buildings and will overshadow one behind it
• The proposed colors do not fit in with the existing buildings and will be an eye sore to neighbors
• The building barely fits on the lot
• The lot is not large enough for the applicant to plant trees that can address neighborhood privacy and property
valuation concerns
•We hope the commission weighs the rights of neighbors regarding privacy and property values
• A 3 story building without will allow guest to see into neighboring homes and yards which will intrude upon
residential privacy
• Not being fully screened from existing homes will reduce the homes property values
DOES IT FIT?
CUP Approval Restrictions
•Approve a 2 story building only
• A 2 story building will reduce the amount of property devaluation experienced by everyone since it won’t be as viewable from neighboring yards
• A 2 story building will not overshadow the IRS building behind it
• A 2 story building will greatly reduce the visibility into neighboring homes and yards
•Require the building colors to conform to the surrounding buildings in the business park and at best allow a muted blue and no yellows
•At a minimum, require shutters or some type of exterior window treatment that prevents viewing into our’s and neighboring homes and yards to
ensure our privacy is maintained
•Require an exterior surveillance system
•Require perimeter fencing to increase security features and help mitigate neighborhood foot traffic
•Limit stays not to exceed 6 months
•Please note in an effort to work with the developer
• We had initially requested larger trees as a stipulation and the owner said he would agree to this stipulation however they won’t solve the issue
and his solution places the ongoing watering and maintenance on us
• Trees will cost approximately $40,000, and be a large water drain
• Tree placement along our back yard is in direct conflict with the APS Right Tree Right Place guidelines as there are overhead power poles and
lines along our back fence
• Trees in our yard do not solve the privacy issues for many years to come and will solve the privacy issue our neighbors will also be facing
If a hotel use is approved we request the following Stipulations
Possible Window Treatments
•Shutters should be placed on any windows with
views into neighboring yards in order to provide
neighbors with privacy
•Shutters will provide privacy immediately
•Shutters will allow light into the room
•Shutters would be cheaper that trees
•Shutters won’t require water resources like trees will
From:
Erin Cole
To:
Taylor, Matthew; Walker-Hall, Tawanda; Perry, Tabitha; Lerma, Alex
Cc:
Malnar, Raymond
Subject:
CUP 23-04 Community Feedback
Date:
Wednesday, August 16, 2023 10:53:17 AM
Attachments:
Community Feedback CUP 23-04 (1).pdf
Good day, all,
Please see attached citizen summary from Councilman Malnar's Community Meeting August
7, 2023.
As Ms. Perry advised, pertinent documents received today would be included in the
Commissioners' packets for the August 24, 2023 hearing.
Kindly reply with confirmation of receipt, and confirmation of inclusion into the packets.
Thank you,
Erin Cole
602.770.9799
erinscole@gmail.com
SUMMARY OF COMMUNITY FEEDBACK
CUP 23-04, STAYAPT, 7300 W. CAMINO SAN XAVIER
AUGUST 16, 2023
Below is a summary of questions and comments posed to StayAPT’s developer, legal counsel,
and City Staff/administration from Councilman Malnar’s Community Meeting at Foothills
Recreation and Aquatic Center, Monday, August 7, 2023.
Support for project - residential and commercial neighbors: 0
Petition against project: Over 640 signatures
Attendees to oppose: Over 150 citizens, business owners, community stakeholders
Statements provided by StayAPT:
●
Inconsistent rate claims (Weinstein, 2021).
●
No ID requirements for reservation nor check-in (screenshots provided, Kelly).
●
False statements alleging zero negative feedback from neighbors (Adgie, 2022).
●
Area chosen as it is “quiet” for guests, with no regard for homeowners (Dymski).
●
North side 14’ buffer cannot accommodate landscaping to mitigate privacy intrusions to
residences (Dymski).
●
Offer to plant trees in Rays’ yard, as they have admitted sight line issues (Dymski).
●
Public admission of improper notification regarding the hidden signage on subject lot
(Dymski)
Media coverage of StayAPT:
Adgie, 2022., Dobrosielski, 2020., Stockmar, 2023a., Stockmar, 2023b., Weinstein, 2020.
Comments from community members
●
Immeasurable devaluation of residential properties as stated by realtors, brokers, and
appraisers (Manning, Ray, Viglietta, et al).
●
Gross invasion of privacy from north, east, and west windows of property with zero plan
to cover windows, inability to provide landscaping (Cole, Crandall, Ray).
●
Safety concerns with 24-hour activity into our neighborhood.
●
Traffic concerns (75th Ave, blind curve in Camino San Xavier, lost travelers into
neighborhood (Cole, McRuff, Prather et al).
●
No sidewalks on Camino San Xavier for guests to frequent mall, businesses (Prather)
●
Emergency response vehicle concerns - accessibility (VanDriel)
●
90 second walk into neighborhood (Crandall)
●
<400 feet to junior high/high school bus stop (Cole, Crandall)
●
No streetlights, no sidewalks in Secluded Acres (Prather)
●
Congestion/misuse/abuse of equestrian/biking/hiking trail (Mareska)
●
Limited notice to community and businesses, hidden sign (Leuschner)
●
Tax deferment packages (Viglietta)
●
Greenbriar Park proximity - walking distance to children (Fowler)
●
Overflow parking destination when the parking lot is full (McRuff)
●
Parking for full-sized vehicles, construction vehicles, military vehicles (Cole, Kelly)
●
No vetting of tenants - temporary housing for transient workers (DeWalt)
●
49 potential sites provided to build
●
The community is not against StayAPT in Glendale - we are against it in our backyards
(150 attendees)
Statistical crime data:
●
Peer-reviewed published analyses attached hereto, “References”.
Questions posed to StayApt and its speakers and that remain unanswered:
●
Where is the contract for service with the US military, as alleged in each meeting (Cole)?
●
Where are the contracts for service with traveling nurse agencies, as named in each
meeting (Cole)?
●
Where are the contracts for service with displayed local brands of hospitals, and other
businesses (Cole)?
●
Why do some campuses answer the phone with a different name other than “StayAPT”
(Cole)?
●
What happened to the new properties to change brands so quickly (Cole)?
●
StayAPT was unable to describe security other than a live in manager, and a key card
access to the property. StayAPT is unsure if they will install exterior security cameras
(Cole, Kelly, Young).
●
Where will tenants be permitted to smoke? There is no smoking on property (Kelly).
●
Where is the pet area? It is omitted from the site plan (Kelly).
●
What is the security plan and eviction enforcement with Glendale PD (Young)?
●
What are the lumens of the lights on the exterior of the facility (Kelly)?
Questions posed to and unanswered by City Staff:
●
Was the P&Z Commission notified that the April document provided by Mr. Alleman
was incorrect/misleading (Cole)?
●
What are the ramifications for an applicant falsifying a report provided to City Staff after
a neighborhood meeting notice (Cole)?
●
When will the amended report be prepared and public record (Cole)?
●
How many additional police officers is the City hiring to mitigate illegal activity in this
area (Crawford, Young)?
●
Who will be liable for devaluation of property values (Manning, Ray, Viglietta, et al)?
●
Who will be liable for privacy issues (photos from apartments into our homes and yards)
(Cole, Crandall, Prather, et al)?
●
Why were the surrounding businesses in the 300’ zone NOT noticed (Cole)?
References
Adgie, J. (2022, March 21). Neighborhood angry over proposed extended-stay hotel.
Times-Herald.com.
https://www.times-herald.com/news/local/neighborhood-angry-over-proposed-extended-stay-hot
el/article_46063d60-b770-5825-8481-9a58921d4f0d.html
AllSides. (2023, August 10). Massachusetts lt. gov tells residents to ‘consider hosting’ illegal
immigrant families in their homes.
https://www.allsides.com/news/2023-08-10-1024/general-news-massachusetts-lt-gov-tells-reside
nts-consider-hosting-illegal
Binns, C. A., & Kempf, R. J. (2020). Introduction to safety and security in hotels and home
sharing. In (Ed.), Springerbriefs in criminology (pp. 1–9).
https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-59306-3_1
Bowen, D. A., Anthony, K. M., & Sumner, S. A. (2022). Business and property types
experiencing excess violent crime: A micro-spatial analysis. Journal of injury & violence
research, 14(1), 1–10. https://doi.org/10.5249/jivr.v14i1.1566
Clark, L. (2023, July 30). Service dog stolen from tempe hotel room found, returned to owner.
FOX 10 Phoenix.
https://www.fox10phoenix.com/news/20k-reward-offered-for-service-dog-stolen-from-tempe-hot
el-room?utm_campaign=trueanthem_manual%26utm_medium=trueAnthem&utm_source=instag
ram
Dobrosielski, C. (2020, January 23). New stayAPT Suites extended-stay brand plots rapid
growth. HotelManagement.net.
https://www.hotelmanagement.net/development/new-long-term-lodging-brand-stayapt-suites-plo
ts-rapid-growth
EIN News. (2023, February 21). Sexual assault attorneys create safety checklist for travelers
amid surge of hotel attacks.
https://www.einnews.com/pr_news/618259535/sexual-assault-attorneys-create-safety-checklist-f
or-travelers-amid-surge-of-hotel-attacks
Ho, T., Zhao, J., & Brown, M. P. (2008). Examining hotel crimes from police crime reports.
Crime Prevention and Community Safety, 11(1), 21–33. https://doi.org/10.1057/cpcs.2008.17
Meyers, C. (2023, January 5). Rights of Renters in Extended Stay Hotels. findlaw.com.
https://www.findlaw.com/realestate/landlord-tenant-law/rights-of-renters-in-extended-stay-hotels
.html
Schmerler, K. (2005). US Department of Justice - Office of Community Policing. Disorder at
Budget Motels, 30.
https://doi.org/chrome-extension://efaidnbmnnnibpcajpcglclefindmkaj/https://popcenter.asu.edu/
sites/default/files/disorder_at_budget_motels.pdf
Shapiro, L. R. (2021). Corporate Liability of Hotels: Criminal Sanctions for Online Sex
Trafficking. Journal of Internet Law, 24(5), 3–10.
Stockmar, S. (2023a, June 28). Potential extended-stay hotel draws ire of glendale residents - the
daily independent at yourvalley.net. The Daily Independent at YourValley.net.
https://www.yourvalley.net/stories/potential-extended-stay-hotel-draws-ire-from-glendale-reside
nts,406986
Stockmar, S. (2023b, August 9). Glendale residents, developers square off over hotel location -
the daily independent at yourvalley.net. The Daily Independent at YourValley.net.
https://www.yourvalley.net/stories/glendale-residents-developers-square-off-over-hotel-location,
416378
U.S. Census Bureau. (2011). People who live in hotels: An exploratory overview [PDF].
https://www.census.gov/content/dam/Census/library/working-papers/2006/adrm/ssm2006-03.pdf
Weinstein, J. (2021, April 9). Stayapt suites off to aggressive start in us - hotelsmag.com.
HOTELSMag.com. https://hotelsmag.com/news/stayapt-suites-off-to-aggressive-start-in-us/
Zarkowski, P., & Avery, D. (2006). Hotel room suicide. Suicide and Life-Threatening Behavior,
36(5), 578–581. https://doi.org/10.1521/suli.2006.36.5.578
From:
Taylor, Matthew
To:
Lerma, Alex
Cc:
Walker-Hall, Tawanda
Subject:
FW: Appreciated your presentation for the Stay APT project
Date:
Tuesday, August 15, 2023 7:18:24 AM
Attachments:
image001.jpg
Applicant-forwarded email re: CUP23-04.
From: Shaine T. Alleman <sta@tblaw.com>
Sent: Monday, August 14, 2023 2:49 PM
To: Perry, Tabitha <TPerry@GLENDALEAZ.com>; Taylor, Matthew <MTaylor@GLENDALEAZ.com>
Subject: FW: Appreciated your presentation for the Stay APT project
Tabitha and Matthew,
Please see support email received from a nearby residential neighbor. We also included this in the
revised Citizen Participation Report that I will send you shortly.
Thank you,
Shaine T. Alleman | Shareholder | 602.452.2712
TIFFANY & BOSCO, P.A.
Seventh Floor Camelback Esplanade II | 2525 E Camelback Road | Phoenix, AZ 85016
P 602.255.6000 | F 602.255.0103
sta@tblaw.com | Bio | vCard | Website | Practice Areas
Offices: Arizona | California | Nevada | New Mexico
From: Randy Huston <Yellowstoneta@yellowstoneta.com>
Sent: Monday, August 14, 2023 10:07 AM
To: Shaine T. Alleman <sta@tblaw.com>
Subject: Appreciated your presentation for the Stay APT project
Hi Shane,
I was at the meeting at the Foothill Aquatic Center last Monday for the presentation and
questions for your client for the Stay APT project.
I was shocked at how rude and disrespectful most of the attendees were to you, Mike and the
others who were part of the presentation. You all impressed me that you always took the high
road on every question with Michael most of the time saying “that was a very thoughtful
question”. You all were very professional, gracious and courteous even though the people on
the other side were far from that. I am sure you had to bite your tongue many times when
the same unfounded statements were repeated. Most people were obviously not there to
hear your side of the discussion.
Your group did a great job of explaining how your project is not the typical Extended Stay
hotel. Your price point is higher, you have the on-site manager to keep things under control
as well as explaining why your clientele is mostly a working during the day group of clients and
not the type of patron who could possibly be a threat to the neighborhood.
I live in the Hidden Manor neighborhood on the west side of 75th Ave. I am an owner of
Yellowstone Trust Administration and know what it means to start your own business with the
needed capital and time to put into it to make it successful. I attended to see what the project
is and to see if it was possibly the type of Extended Stay hotel that would be all the problems
that some people were inferring about your project. I was totally convinced that this is a good
project and an asset to the neighborhood. I can’t imagine that a vacant lot with no lighting is a
better option than an expensive Hotel that attracts upper middle class clients. I hope that the
Planning commission approves your project and look forward to having relatives and business
associates stay at your nice Hotel.
Best Regards,
Randy Huston, CFP®
Yellowstone Trust Administration, Inc.
Randy Huston's direct lines:
Phone: 800-572-6394
Fax: 602-926-2584
2070 Overland Ave., Suite 104
Billings, MT 59102
Website: www.yellowstoneta.com
Email: yellowstoneta@yellowstoneta.com
Note: Unless otherwise specifically noted in this e-mail letter, the author is not engaged in rendering legal, accounting, tax or other
professional services with the dissemination of information in this e-mail letter. The opinions expressed in this e-mail, while intended to
be accurate, are for general educational and informational purposes only.
From:
bpray
To:
Taylor, Matthew
Cc:
Walker-Hall, Tawanda; Perry, Tabitha; Lerma, Alex; Malnar, Raymond
Subject:
CUP 23 04
Date:
Wednesday, August 16, 2023 11:44:29 AM
Attachments:
Stay Apt Opposision Slides.pdf
Some people who received this message don't often get email from bpray@cox.net. Learn why this is important
Good Morning Matthew,
Attached is a document I prepared outlining why we believe the CUP 23 04 should be denied
according to city guidelines. It also includes stipulations we suggest if for some reason the use
is approved.
Thank You
Pam Ray
623-498-7595
bpray@cox.net
Ray Family Impacts
OPPOSITION TO APPROVAL OF Stay Apt CUP 23 04
The Ray Family
7305 W Angela Drive
Live Directly North (260’) of the Proposed StayApt Hotel
Opposition to Approval of StayApt CUP 23 04
•Hotels are inherently a 24 hour operation to accommodate various arrival & departure needs
• Standard hours may allude to restricted access but there are NO hour restrictions
•The proposed hotel is NOT a low-intensity, commercial use & will have negative impacts to our long established quiet
neighborhood
• The parcel zoning may have changed to C-2, however it is off main streets in an area that is primarily business park and
only 260 feet from a well established quiet neighborhood
• There are many uses for the site that would not have 24 hour operations such as retail, office, enclosed manufacturing or
storage facility, etc.
•Surrounding buildings and businesses do not have operations beyond 10 pm
•The 24 hours will increase traffic, noise, and foot traffic in the neighborhood
•The size of the building is out of character for the area and will overshadow the IRS building behind it
• The IRS building is already difficult for people to find and has increased neighborhood traffic for those looking for it, this
problem will only increase traffic issues
•Perimeter fencing is not planned, which would help prevent crime and decrease neighborhood foot traffic
•The hotel will have lighting that will be on at all hours of the night and create light trespassing onto our property at night from
the illumination and glare of the lights
Due to Use and Hours of Operation
Opposition to Approval of StayApt CUP 23 04
•The building height and location does not promote a functional relationship to the buildings
surrounding the site nor the surrounding neighborhood
•The tall architecture and proposed colors are not in harmony to the neighboring environment
•The proposed structure will create an intrusion of our privacy and reduce our quality of life
• A person 5’ tall will have an eye level view at about 15 ft on the 2nd floor and an eye level view at
about 25 ft on the 3rd floor
•A 3 story hotel of 35 feet high with windows looking into our home and neighborhood backyards will
negatively impact our and our neighbors’ privacy
• This is in direct opposition to the guidelines for approval under zoning code 3.605
•Commercial properties not FULLY screened from homes reduces property values
•The use and structure is in opposition to the City Envision Glendale General Plan, more specifically,
infill development policy CRR 2.5 which states the City should protect established areas/
neighborhoods by promoting context ‐ appropriate infill development
Due to Use and Hours of Operation
Opposition to Approval of StayApt CUP 23 04
•We had a meeting with the City of Glendale Planning Department on 7/19 to discuss our concerns and were
told:
• Citizen Participation Reports are not updated or corrected
• The planning department informed us on 8/15 they will be updated for this case to include Councilman
Malnar's Community Meeting held on 8/7/23
• Suggest changes and stipulations to the planning commission
• Our concerns are reasonable, understandable and valuable
• They can impact your quality of life
• Hold firm with our concerns, bring them up at the planning commission
•When deciding your vote we kindly ask you to consider the city CUP guidelines and infill development
policies in place to protect existing established neighborhoods
• Is a 3 story hotel with unrestricted hours of operation, increased foot traffic, unrestricted views into
neighboring homes and backyards that decreases property values, a good use for the parcel and meets
the city guidelines of not having a negative impact to the surrounding neighborhood?
Concerns
Opposition to Approval of StayApt CUP 23 04
•We attended the planning commission workshop on 8/10/23 the planning department reminded us a parcel may be
zoned to allow for a desired development but conditional use permits are used for PAD development to ensure the use is
compatible with existing uses and the surrounding neighborhood
•Does it fit with existing uses?
• The hours of operation don’t fit with existing business uses
• A hotel use is much more intense than existing surrounding uses
• A 3 story hotel does not fit in with existing 2 story buildings and will overshadow one behind it
• The proposed colors do not fit in with the existing buildings and will be an eye sore to neighbors
• The building barely fits on the lot
• The lot is not large enough for the applicant to plant trees that can address neighborhood privacy and property
valuation concerns
•We hope the commission weighs the rights of neighbors regarding privacy and property values
• A 3 story building without will allow guest to see into neighboring homes and yards which will intrude upon
residential privacy
• Not being fully screened from existing homes will reduce the homes property values
DOES IT FIT?
CUP Approval Restrictions
•Approve a 2 story building only
• A 2 story building will reduce the amount of property devaluation experienced by everyone since it won’t be as viewable from neighboring yards
• A 2 story building will not overshadow the IRS building behind it
• A 2 story building will greatly reduce the visibility into neighboring homes and yards
•Require the building colors to conform to the surrounding buildings in the business park and at best allow a muted blue and no yellows
•At a minimum, require shutters or some type of exterior window treatment that prevents viewing into our’s and neighboring homes and yards to
ensure our privacy is maintained
•Require an exterior surveillance system
•Require perimeter fencing to increase security features and help mitigate neighborhood foot traffic
•Limit stays not to exceed 6 months
•Please note in an effort to work with the developer
• We had initially requested larger trees as a stipulation and the owner said he would agree to this stipulation however they won’t solve the issue
and his solution places the ongoing watering and maintenance on us
• Trees will cost approximately $40,000, and be a large water drain
• Tree placement along our back yard is in direct conflict with the APS Right Tree Right Place guidelines as there are overhead power poles and
lines along our back fence
• Trees in our yard do not solve the privacy issues for many years to come and will solve the privacy issue our neighbors will also be facing
If a hotel use is approved we request the following Stipulations
Possible Window Treatments
•Shutters should be placed on any windows with
views into neighboring yards in order to provide
neighbors with privacy
•Shutters will provide privacy immediately
•Shutters will allow light into the room
•Shutters would be cheaper that trees
•Shutters won’t require water resources like trees will
1
Lerma, Alex
From:
Glenda <G.Dunshee@yahoo.com>
Sent:
Thursday, August 17, 2023 1:34 PM
To:
Lerma, Alex
Subject:
Proposed StayApt Extended Stay Hotel
[You don't often get email from g.dunshee@yahoo.com. Learn why this is important at
https://aka.ms/LearnAboutSenderIdentification ]
We are requesting that the Planning Committee disapprove the StayApts’s request to allow an Extended Stay Hotel to be
built in the Secluded Acre area. We have concerns about the increase in traffic and crime that it will bring into our
neighborhood. This is a quiet, friendly neighborhood for families with children and the elderly like ourselves and that is
why we live here. We do not want to have to worry about the elements this type of transient housing brings. They will
have no pride in our community since they are temporary and that can affect our home values. So we request the
Planning Commission say “NO” to StayApt Extended Stay Hotel!!
Frank and Glenda Dunshee
7304 W. Villa Rita Drive
Secluded Acres
Sent from my iPad
From:
Perry, Tabitha
To:
Walker-Hall, Tawanda
Subject:
FW: Opposing CU 23-04 - Modern Stay
Date:
Friday, August 18, 2023 9:14:20 AM
Attachments:
Jamie"s Letter.pdf
Do you have this one to be handed at the meeting.
From: jamie notallheroes.org <jamie@notallheroes.org>
Sent: Thursday, August 17, 2023 3:17 PM
To: Perry, Tabitha <TPerry@GLENDALEAZ.com>; Taylor, Matthew <MTaylor@GLENDALEAZ.com>
Subject: Opposing CU 23-04 - Modern Stay
Dear Mr. Taylor and Ms. Perry,
Attache you will find a PDF of my opposition to the CUP 23-04. I am requesting the entire packet be included in the Planning
Commissioners packet for next week.
Thank you,
Jamie
August 10, 2023
City of Glendale Planning Commission
5850 W. Glendale Avenue
Glendale, AZ 85301
RE: OBJECTION to CUP23-04 - Modern StayApt
Dear Commissioners,
My name is Jamie Kelly. I am a lifelong resident born and raised in Glendale and have called the neighborhood of Secluded
Acres my home since 2017. I am writing to request that the Planning Commission understands how CUP 23-04 Modern
StayApt would be detrimental to the health, safety, and general welfare of those who live and work near the proposed site.
Between the nature of this proposed hotel plus the types of criminal behavior, dangerous activities like human and
sex trafficking, and additional traffic as well as concerns about the builder's honesty which is detailed in this report,
please vote no on CUP 23-04 - Modern StayApt located at 73rd Avenue and West Camino San Xavier which is just south
of my neighborhood.
I am a wife, mother, and grandmother who absolutely loves and adores my family, neighborhood, community, and country.
When my husband and I made the decision to move into the quiet neighborhood of Secluded Acres, I believe it was the best
decision for our family. Now my husband and I have invested our time and energy into our community. My husband served
for 23 years in the City of Glendale as a Police Officer. I have been active with non-profit community organizations and
served on a Glendale commission and an Arizona state board.
In the following pages, you will read my research and insight on why I am asking you to vote NO on the CUP 23-04 - Modern
StayApt. A hotel in this lot does not make sense for the builder, the community, and Glendale. My concerns about this
Modern StayApt include criminal activity such as human and sex trafficking, drugs, kidnapping, rape, and murder as property
crimes like vehicle theft, burglary, and retail theft. In reviewing the data, it is very clear that these types of hotel venues do
not provide a service to the community but rather a burden on the community, law enforcement, and fire service and create a
negative influence of crime in a community. Please read through the research and statements I have collected to show you
how the Modern StayApt will be destructive to our community.
The idea of a hotel that does not provide security or validate those who are renting a room provides significant concerns for
safety to those who live and shop near this proposed site. This hotel would be less than a 1/2 mile from a program that
provides services to individuals with physical and mental disabilities as well as a rehabilitation center. I am asking you to
think of the potential risks of having a hotel that does not verify the identification of guests and would open the door for
criminals like registered sex offenders to have easy access to a school bus stop, an organization for those with disabilities,
and near a mall and shopping centers.
I appreciate your time and consideration. Again, I am asking you to vote NO to the CUP 23-04 - Modern StayApt. Please
help me protect my family and community from the criminal activity brought on by extended stay-type hotels.
Respectfully,
Jamie Kelly
August 10, 2023
City of Glendale Planning Commission
5850 W. Glendale Avenue
Glendale, AZ 85301
RE: OBJECTION to CUP23-04 - Modern StayApt
Dear Commissioners,
My name is Jamie Kelly. I am a lifelong resident born and raised in Glendale and have called the
neighborhood of Secluded Acres my home since 2017. I am writing to request that the Planning
Commission understands how CUP 23-04 Modern StayApt would be detrimental to the health, safety,
and general welfare of those who live and work near the proposed site. Between the nature of this
proposed hotel plus the types of criminal behavior, dangerous activities like human and sex
trafficking, and additional traffic as well as concerns about the builder's honesty which is
detailed in this report, please vote no on CUP 23-04 - Modern StayApt located at 73rd Avenue and
West Camino San Xavier which is just south of my neighborhood.
I am a wife, mother, and grandmother who absolutely loves and adores my family, neighborhood,
community, and country. When my husband and I made the decision to move into the quiet
neighborhood of Secluded Acres, I believe it was the best decision for our family. Now my husband and
I have invested our time and energy into our community. My husband served for 23 years in the City of
Glendale as a Police Officer. I have been active with non-profit community organizations and served on
a Glendale commission and an Arizona state board.
In the following pages, you will read my research and insight on why I am asking you to vote NO on the
CUP 23-04 - Modern StayApt. A hotel in this lot does not make sense for the builder, the community,
and Glendale. My concerns about this Modern StayApt include criminal activity such as human and sex
trafficking, drugs, kidnapping, rape, and murder as property crimes like vehicle theft, burglary, and retail
theft. In reviewing the data, it is very clear that these types of hotel venues do not provide a service to
the community but rather a burden on the community, law enforcement, and fire service and create a
negative influence of crime in a community. Please read through the research and statements I have
collected to show you how the Modern StayApt will be destructive to our community.
The idea of a hotel that does not provide security or validate those who are renting a room provides
significant concerns for safety to those who live and shop near this proposed site. This hotel would be
less than a 1/2 mile from a program that provides services to individuals with physical and mental
disabilities as well as a rehabilitation center. I am asking you to think of the potential risks of having a
hotel that does not verify the identification of guests and would open the door for criminals like
registered sex offenders to have easy access to a school bus stop, an organization for those with
disabilities, and near a mall and shopping centers.
I appreciate your time and consideration. Again, I am asking you to vote NO to the CUP 23-04 - Modern
StayApt. Please help me protect my family and community from the criminal activity brought on
by extended stay-type hotels.
Respectfully,
Jamie Kelly
Page of
1
40
In this document, you will see my research, the connection, and truth about the proposed
StayApt, and requested stipulations if you do decide to vote yes. Again, my request is that you
vote no on CUP 23-04 Modern Stay Apt.
Safety & Security
Since we moved into our forever home in 2017, we have had a few incidents that brought concerns
about safety. One night while my husband was on duty with the Glendale Police Department a man
tried the front door of my home while I was home alone. He tried the door handle, kicking the door and
hitting the windows. Thankfully Glendale Police Department arrived and ensured my safety. However,
the man was never located. Another early morning after my husband finished his shift and parked his
police motorcycle in our garage, a man entered our garage and attempted to steal from us. These types
of crimes are only on the rise with the increase of homeless and drug addicts who are utilizing the wash
that runs between our neighborhood and the neighborhood to the east.
My number one concern is that this type of hotel will bring additional unwanted criminal behavior. I do
understand that the hotel will have a secure facility with key cards and restricted access inside the
venue however that does not protect the community. I reviewed the website for StayApt and booked a
reservation at another location. Never once in the process was my state-issued identification required. I
would be provided with a digital key and would not be required to interact with a staff member
to confirm my identification or check-in. This provides significant concern that the venue would not
have knowledge of who is actually on their property.
A 2016 article written by DolanDobrinsky Rosenbaum Bluestein, LLP titled “Hotel Security and Crime”
stated that annually there are more than 53,000 crimes that happen at hotels. In this article, they
1
stated that insufficient security surveillance and personnel to properly monitor the hotel activity is when
the crime occurs. This proposed StayApt has clearly stated they will not have security personnel on the
property and will depend on the Glendale Police Department for response to their criminal activity.
** Requested Stipulation: Require the StayApt to provide 24-hour staffing that would mandate
the employee must be awake during their work hours. Not just a general manager who lives on-
site but rather employees who are awake and working.
** Additional Requested Stipulation: Required StayApt to provide security staff who will be on-
site to conduct property walks to reduce criminal behavior and monitor the security cameras.
AND/OR
** Additional Requested Stipulation: Required StayApt to hire a security company that will
provide security checks of the property at least every four hours.
As you may know, human and sex trafficking is one of the top dangers in Arizona. The Phoenix area
including Glendale is the capital of kidnapping in America and only second in the world to Mexico City.
According to Former Attorney General Mark Brnovich in the Human Trafficking: Not Buying It
publication, the average age of entry into the sex trade in Arizona is 14 years old. Law enforcement has
Hotel security and crime, accessed August 10, 2023, https://www.ddrlawyers.com/blog/hotel-
1
security-and-crime/
Page of
2
40
seen girls as young as 9 sold for sex. In the article “In Harm’s Way: How Systems Fail Human
2
Trafficking Survivors”, one survivor stated,
“My debit card was frequently used to purchase hotel rooms in my name. My pimp/ trafficker
would send me the funds that I earned that he was keeping through Cash App. I used a fake ID
with my real name to buy the rooms alongside the debit card. (Since hotels require you to be 21
and I was only 19, he gave me fake IDs to use). He put it in my name to maintain his privacy
from any potential law enforcement situations at the hotel.”3
According to a 2018 Polaris Survivor Survey, more than 60% of sex-trafficking victims were forced to
sell sex from hotels. In the 2021 Federal Human Trafficking Report, 80% of the sex trafficking acts took
4
place at a hotel. In the 2022 Federal Human Trafficking Report, of the 178 new federal criminal cases,
5
20% of new federal trafficking cases involved a completed sex act that occurred in a hotel. Of these
6
cases, the following hotels were reported:
2 Case - Hampton Inn
2 Cases - Days Inn
1 Case - Comfort Inn Suites
1 Case - Budget Suites
1 Case - Springhill Suites
1 Case - Homewood Inn and Suites
1 Case - Extended Stay America
In the community presentation on August 7,
2023, the builder of the proposed StayApt
compared themselves to several hotels
including Homewood Suites and Comfort Inn
Suites. Below is a photo from their
presentation. If StayApt is comparable by
their definitions to two of these hotels that
have been reported to have human and sex
trafficking, then what kind of criminal
activity will StayApt attract to our quiet
community?
Human Trafficking; Not Buying It, accessed August 10, 2023, https://www.azag.gov/sites/default/
2
files/publications/2018-06/Human_Trafficking_Not_Buying_It.pdf
In Harms Way: How Systems Fail Human Trafficking Survivors, accessed August 10, 2023, https://
3
polarisproject.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/07/In-Harms-Way-How-Systems-Fail-Human-Trafficking-
Survivors-by-Polaris-modifed-June-2023.pdf.
Should Hotel Chains Be Held Liable for Human Trafficking?, accessed August 10, 2023, https://
4
www.newyorker.com/news/a-reporter-at-large/should-hotel-chains-be-held-liable-for-human-
trafficking.
What happened to the woman in the hotel room next door?, accessed August 10, 2023, https://
5
www.nytimes.com/2023/03/17/travel/hotels-sex-trafficking-violence-crime.html
2022 Federal Human Trafficking Report, accessed August 10, 2023, https://traffickinginstitute.org/
6
wp-content/uploads/2023/06/2022-Federal-Human-Trafficking-Report-WEB-
Spreads_compressed.pdf
Page of
3
40
In Ohio, more than 40 lawsuits were filed by human trafficking victims against hotels including
Wyndham Hotels, Choices Hotels, and Red Roof Inns. In Georgia, on July 27, 2023, a hotel clerk was
7
convicted and sentenced to 15 years in prison for facilitating the human trafficking of a juvenile victim.
8
In 2022, a multiple-agency operation arrested 29
suspects in a human and sex trafficking ring. This
operation was led by the Phoenix Police Department
Human Exploitation and Trafficking unit along with Mesa,
Chandler, Scottsdale, Glendale, and Surprise Police
Departments along with the Arizona Department of
Public Safety, FBI, and the Arizona Attorney General’s
office.9
In May 2023, a man was arrested in Phoenix at a local
hotel for child sex trafficking and kidnapping.10
According to the A Roadmap for Systems and Industries
to Prevent and Disrupt Human Trafficking report dated
July 2018,
“Since the beginning of the National Human
Trafficking Hotline in December 2007 through
December 31, 2017, the Hotline has recorded 3,596
cases of human trafficking involving a hotel or motel.
Furthermore, 75 percent of survivors in the Polaris
survey reported coming into contact with hotels at
some point during their trafficking situation. This
means traffickers in all 50 states are taking
advantage of unwitting hotel franchisees and relying
on them to help facilitate their illicit businesses.”11
According to Former Attorney General Mark Brnovich,
the safety of our children begins at home in their own
neighborhoods. He encouraged parents and neighbors to
work collectively to make sure their children are safe.
This is the call to help us protect our children and
More than 40 human trafficking lawsuits filed against hotel companies, accessed August 10, 2023,
7
https://www.10tv.com/article/news/local/more-than-40-human-trafficking-lawsuits-filed-hotel-
companies/530-b0c54a7c-6fe0-4d5d-800f-a3e8a89d3bba
Carr: Hotel Clerk, Convicted, Sentenced to 15 years in Prison for Facilitating Human Trafficking,
8
accessed August 11, 2023, https://law.georgia.gov/press-releases/2023-07-27/carr-hotel-clerk-
convicted-sentenced-15-years-prison-facilitating-human
29 arrested in HSI Phoenix, multiagency operation targeting alleged child sex and human traffickers,
9
accessed August 10, 2023, https://www.ice.gov/news/releases/29-arrested-hsi-phoenix-multiagency-
operation-targeting-alleged-child-sex-and-human
Man arrested after possible kidnapping at Phoenix hotel, accessed August 11, 2023, https://
10
www.12news.com/article/news/crime/kidnapping-phoenix-hotel-man-arrested/
75-84f31c00-087b-4f69-9572-cd23c63ea06e
A Roadmap for Systems and Industries to Prevent and Disrupt Human Trafficking, accessed August
11
9, 2023, https://polarisproject.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/08/A-Roadmap-for-Systems-and-
Industries-to-Prevent-and-Disrupt-Human-Trafficking-Hotels-and-Motels.pdf
Page of
4
40
grandchildren from human trafficking by saying no to the StayApt CPU.
Many hotel chains and franchises require their staff to complete an initial new hire training and then
annual refresher training on human trafficking related to victim identification, warning signs, and
reporting procedures. At this time StayApt does not demonstrate on their website that they require nor
provide any training on human trafficking.
The applicant has expressed that they will not put up fencing around the property nor will they provide
fencing to prevent direct access into the neighborhood. This fence would reduce access to the middle
school bus stop at 73rd Avenue just north of the proposed hotel. This would create a barrier to reduce
the risk of kidnapping or sexual assault of those who live or shop near the hotel.
**Requested Stipulation: Require the builder to conduct new hires and annual training on
human trafficking.
In June 2023, the City of Scottsdale approved a grant of $940,000 to house homeless and illegal
immigrants at hotels located in Scottsdale. Although the details of the hotel location are confidential,
12
two of the area hotels include Staybridge Suites and Comfort Inn Suites. StayApt compared themselves
to Comfort Suites and Staybridge Suites in their community presentation. The idea that within 300 ft of
my neighborhood could potential housing be provided to homeless and illegal immigrants through a
grant program is troublesome. Compassion is incredible however there are other options. The concern
is if StayApt does not have the occupancy they need to pay their bills would they seek relief options like
a grant from the State of Arizona to provide housing?
Tobacco & Drugs
At the community meeting, I asked the builder where the guests will be permitted to smoke either
tobacco or marijuana as Arizona is a recreational marijuana state. The builder stated that they are a
non-smoking facility which means guests will be required to walk off the property to smoke either
tobacco or marijuana. The options then become to walk into the neighborhood, walk on the walking
path containing natural landscaping that is highly flammable, or onto the property of the other business
owners. This provides significant concerns to the homeowners as the concerns of smelling the smoke,
a fire starting due to tossing cigarettes, and the trash of tossed cigarettes or other products.
** Requested Stipulation: Require the builder to modify their plans to include a smoking area
with proper disposal containers for smoking trash to protect the environment and reduce the
risk of fire or other issues.
Drug activity is already increasing in the area due to the homeless and addicts. In 2020, at a North
Phoenix hotel, a man was arrested for possession of 77 lbs of meth that was packaged for sale along
with $8,000 in cash. In October 2022, a minor was hospitalized after becoming unresponsive due to
13
Scottsdale expands housing for migrants, homeless from ‘The Zone’, accessed August 10, 2023,
12
https://www.azfamily.com/2023/07/04/scottsdale-expands-housing-migrants-homeless-zone/
PD: Drug mule arrested at north PHX hotel with $100,000 of meth, accessed August 14, 2023,
13
https://www.abc15.com/news/crime/pd-drug-mule-arrested-at-north-phx-hotel-with-100-000-of-meth
Page of
5
40
drugs in a hotel room in Surprise. In March 2022, a Prescott Valley man was arrested on drug
14
charges at a local hotel that offers a similar rate to StayApt.15
Criminal Activity
Extended stay-type hotels bring additional criminal activity to their communities. As we in Secluded
Acres have watched the criminal activity increase, the idea of a hotel that targets a transient population
creates additional burdens on us as homeowners and visitors in our area like Arrowhead Mall and the
shopping centers near the hotel. My husband refers to them as crimes of convenience but to most, they
are known as vehicle or home break-ins and/or theft. This hotel will be a draw for more of these crimes
of convenience.
I have included the criminal activity of another StayApt location in TN to demonstrate how similar the
activity is to that of other extended stay-type venues. I have also included the criminal activity of other
extended stay venues in the Phoenix metro area. This information demonstrates the following:
• There will be an increase in criminal activity from this venue that will be detrimental to the
health, safety, and general welfare of the community including the residents of Secluded Acres
and other neighborhoods nearby as well as the businesses.
•Regardless of the proposed safety features of the StayApt, they do not provide adequate
security for their clients, neighborhood residents, and business owners.
•This venue will provide a substantial burden on the Glendale Police Department with an
increase in calls for service, investigations, and arrests.
•This venue will provide a substantial burden on the Glendale Judicial System with an increase
in case prosecution.
In an article on eHotelier, they highlight eight key elements to determine if a hotel will be a hot spot for
criminal activity and the proposed StayApt location will be a hot spot for criminal activity.
16
1. The residential and activity locations are predisposed offender populations.
2. The residential and activity locations of vulnerable populations.
3. The spatial and temporal distribution of different forms of security and guardianship.
4. The broader residential and activity structure of the city.
5. The mix of activity types and land uses.
6. The modes of transport and structure of the transport network.
7. The actual transportation flows of people through the city’s infrastructure.
8. The timescape we are living in.
It should be noted that often times drug and human traffickers will move their business from their
homes and vehicles into hotel rooms because of the offender’s asset forfeiture and seizure laws.
17
Arizona law enforcement is already burdened with the increase in human and drug trafficking that is
Minor hospitalized, woman arrested after police find drugs in Surprise hotel room, accessed August
14
14, 2023, https://www.abc15.com/news/region-west-valley/surprise/minor-hospitalized-woman-
arrested-after-police-find-drugs-in-surprise-hotel-room
Prescott Valley man arrested on drug charges at an area hotel, accessed August 14, 2023https://
15
gcmaz.com/kaff_news/prescott-valley-man-arrested-on-drug-charges-at-an-area-hotel/
Understanding crime patterns and hotspots in context of hotel security, accessed August 10, 2023,
16
https://insights.ehotelier.com/insights/2021/02/19/understanding-crime-patterns-and-hotspots-in-the-
context-of-hotel-security-design/
Hotel Motel Interdiction, accessed August 8, 2023, https://hampton.gov/757/Hotel-Motel-
17
Interdiction
Page of
6
40
occurring due to the border, cartels, and more. The increase in crime due to the proposed StayApt will
place an undo burden and would be detrimental to the health, safety, and welfare of those living and
working near the proposed location.
Privacy
When the applicant presented to the community on Monday, August 7, 2023, they stated in their
presentation that the neighborhood was over a half mile away. (Photograph is below of their
presentation.) This is an incorrect statement as the closest home is only 260 feet away and a half
mile is 2,640 feet. The hotel would be less than 500 feet from a middle school bus stop and less than a
mile from an elementary school.
The 2nd/3rd-floor rooms would have a direct line of sight into the backyards and homes that are less
than 300 feet away. For myself, the idea that some random person staying in a hotel would have a clear
line of sight into my house or backyard where my children and grandchildren play creates a very
uncomfortable sense of fear for safety in my own home. The applicant has offered to pay for trees to be
purchased by the homeowners for their privacy. This would require a future expense for homeowners of
water and maintenance that could be extremely costly to the homeowner. In addition, there are
overhead power lines that would restrict the approved height these trees could grow to and create
additional problems for the homeowner. There are also concerns about the roots of the trees causing
issues with the homeowners’ fencing and pools. The solution of trees for privacy in the homeowners’
property is just not acceptable for these homeowners.
Requested Stipulation: Require the builder during initial construction to install proper exterior
window coverings to ensure the privacy of the backyards or homes located in Secluded Acres.
The justification for this modification is based on the visibility of young children and women from the
view of the hotel rooms. As we know sex assault crimes are committed by men and women of all ages
in all industries and professions. The modification to the window coverings would provide additional
security and safety for those staying in the hotel and living near the property.
Page of
7
40
Hotel Security & Staff
In researching StayApt, according to their LinkedIn jobs page as well as other job pages, they do not
mention a requirement to pass a background check or sex offender registry check. This provides
significant concerns that they will not properly screen staff to ensure protection from criminals working
and/or living at the hotel. From the jobs posted the consistent rate of pay is listed at $14 per hour for
most staff and the Assistant General Manager is at $16 per hour. These hourly rates are consistent with
what Extended Stay and Budget Suites
pays their employees.
During the Community Meeting, the
builder expressed that they will have
minimal staff with a general manager
who lives on-site and housekeeping
staff. In preparation for my letter to the
City, I called multiple StayApt locations
to speak to someone at the front desk.
The calls were placed at various hours
(9 am, 2 pm, 6 pm, and 11 pm) to a
variety of locations, and with each call
regardless of the time of day, no one
answered the phone, several voicemails
were full and no one returned my calls.
As a potential consumer of the StayApt
locations and a resident who lives within a 1/2 mile of the proposed location, the lack of accessibility to
the staff creates significant concern.
Page of
8
40
The builder expressed that they will have security cameras however without 24/7 monitoring these
cameras will only record criminal behavior but will not prevent crimes.
Requested Stipulation: StayApt is required to provide access to the City of Glendale Police
Department for the StayApt camera system to be connected with the Real Time Crime Center.
However, again this places the burden of safety and security on the Glendale Police Department and
not StayApt.
Pricing
It is important to note that trafficking and crime are not limited to budget hotels, but rather venues that
are understaffed and often distracted. The applicant presented that the room rate would be $166 a
night. However, in reviewing the StayApt website to review the other 14 StayApt hotel locations in the
United States, the average room rate for August 10th was $120.79 per night. The concern as a
community member is that the builder is demonstrating their lack of honesty on the pricing
structure and will be a lower-priced hotel similar to the extended stay or budget-type facility. For
these other locations, it is currently their peak season like we will have around the holidays and into the
spring. This creates a significant concern that the slow season rates will be below $100 a night and
some nights may even drop to below $80 a night. This creates a comparable rate to an Extended Stay
or Budget Suite type hotel. A table is below to show the room takes for the StayApt locations and then
the pricing of other hotels near the proposed site.
The screenshot below is from the StayApt website showing pricing for their San Antonio-Lackland
location to show you the pricing from their other locations.
StayApt Rates
Room Rates for August 10, 2023 to August 11, 2023
Hotel Name
Address
Room Rate
per Night
StayApt - San Antonio-Randolph 7645 N Loop 1604 E., Live Oak, Texas 78233
$99.00
Page of
9
40
StayApt - San Antonio-Lackland
9923 Ingram Road, San Antonio, Texas 78245
$134.00
StayApt - Rock Hill
840 Patriot Parkway, Rock Hill, South Carolina 29730
$109.00
StayApt - Greenville/Greer
1455 Hwy 101 South, Greer, South Carolina 29651
$139.00
StayApt - Alexandria
8849 Richmond Hwy, Alexandria, Virginia 22309
$154.00
StayApt - Houston
1566 Live Oak Street, Webster, Texas 77598
$109.00
StayApt - Chattanooga-
Oolte ah
6046 Relocation Way, Ooltewah, Tennessee 37363
$119.00
StayApt - Greenville/Haywood
85 Mall Connector Road, Greenville, South Carolina
29607
$124.00
StayApt - Columbia
851 Columbiana Drive, Irmo, South Carolina 29063
$104.00
stayAPT - Raleigh-Durham
1009 Lower Shiloh Way, Morrisville, North Carolina
27560
$114.00
StayApt - Goldsboro
1001 Sunburst Drive, Goldsboro, North Carolina
27534
$124.00
StayApt - Montgomery
5000 Woodmere Blvd, Montgomery, Alabama 36106
$104.00
StayApt - Huntsville
210 West Park Loop NW, Huntsville, Alabama 35806
$144.00
StayApt - Dothan
259 Hospitality Lane, Dothan, Alabama 36303
$114.00
Other Similar Hotels
Residence Inn - Peoria
8435 West Paradise Lane, Peoria, Arizona 85382 USA
$156.00
Springhill Suites - Peoria
7810 West Bell Road, Glendale, Arizona 85308 USA
$126.00
Hampton Inn - Peoria
8408 W Paradise Ln, Peoria, AZ 85382
$103.00
Holiday Inn Express - Peoria
16771 N. 84th Ave., Peoria, AZ
$99.00
Comfort Suites
8473 West Paradise Ln., Peoria, AZ, 85382
$86.00
Page
of
10
40
StayApt - TN, 6046 Relocation Way, Ooltewah, Tennessee 37363
Date_Incident
Incident_Description
Incident_Ty
pe
Case_Num
ber
Case_Status_Descri
ption
05/15/2023 10:20:00
PM
Miscellaneous Information
23-051373
Pending/Possible
Leads
04/17/2023 3:06:00
PM
Property Lost
23-039894
Pending/Possible
Leads
04/17/2023 10:31:00
AM
Miscellaneous Information
23-039770
Pending/Possible
Leads
04/14/2023 11:25:00
AM
False Pretense/Swindle/Confidence
Game
Part 1
Crimes
23-040991
Pending/Possible
Leads
04/13/2023 6:10:00
PM
Serving Warrant
23-038438
Cleared by Arrest
04/13/2023 6:00:00
PM
Miscellaneous Information
23-038415
Pending/Possible
Leads
04/13/2023 1:15:00
PM
Suspicious Activity
23-038313
Pending/Possible
Leads
04/03/2023 3:00:00
PM
Damaged Property Accidental
23-034765
Pending/Possible
Leads
04/01/2023 12:00:00
AM
Property Lost
23-052952
Pending/Possible
Leads
02/28/2023 12:00:00
PM
Worthless Checks
Part 2
Crimes
23-031877
Pending/Possible
Leads
01/30/2023 1:31:00
PM
Field Interview
23-010517
Pending/Possible
Leads
01/27/2023 9:35:00
PM
All Other Offenses
Part 2
Crimes
23-009617
Cleared by Arrest
01/25/2023 4:19:00
PM
Embezzlement
Part 1
Crimes
23-030682
Cleared by Arrest
01/23/2023 3:59:00
PM
Field Interview
23-008081
Pending/Possible
Leads
01/22/2023 12:00:00
PM
Miscellaneous Information
23-007689
Pending/Possible
Leads
01/11/2023 12:00:00
PM
Impersonation
Part 1
Crimes
23-020832
Pending/Possible
Leads
12/30/2022 12:00:00
AM
Destructive/Damage/Vandalism Of
Property
Part 1
Crimes
22-140114
Pending/Possible
Leads
12/15/2022 1:00:00
PM
Shoplifting
Part 1
Crimes
22-135026
Pending/Possible
Leads
12/12/2022 7:00:00
PM
Embezzlement
Part 1
Crimes
22-134077
Cleared by Arrest
12/04/2022 10:22:00
AM
Theft From Buildings
Part 1
Crimes
22-130858
Pending/Possible
Leads
11/19/2022 10:41:00
AM
Fraud Credit Card/Automated Teller
Machines
Part 1
Crimes
22-131995
Pending/Possible
Leads
11/15/2022 2:00:00
PM
Property Found
22-124136
Pending/Possible
Leads
Page
of
11
40
10/29/2022 2:35:00
PM
Damaged Property Accidental
22-117833
Pending/Possible
Leads
10/23/2022 11:00:00
AM
Property Found
22-115745
Pending/Possible
Leads
10/18/2022 4:00:00
PM
All Other Offenses
Part 2
Crimes
22-113709
Pending/Possible
Leads
10/13/2022 1:15:00
PM
Miscellaneous Information
22-111769
Pending/Possible
Leads
10/11/2022 11:26:00
PM
Miscellaneous Information
22-111219
Pending/Possible
Leads
10/08/2022 11:53:00
AM
False Pretense/Swindle/Confidence
Game
Part 1
Crimes
22-109945
Pending/Possible
Leads
10/03/2022 1:08:00
PM
All Other Larceny
Part 1
Crimes
22-106160
Pending/Possible
Leads
09/23/2022 5:15:00
PM
Drunkenness
Part 2
Crimes
22-104159
Cleared by Arrest
09/23/2022 5:15:00
PM
Disorderly Conduct
Part 2
Crimes
22-104159
Cleared by Arrest
09/23/2022 5:15:00
PM
Trespass Of Real Property
Part 2
Crimes
22-104159
Cleared by Arrest
08/05/2022 6:55:00
PM
Destructive/Damage/Vandalism Of
Property
Part 1
Crimes
22-084497
Pending/Possible
Leads
08/05/2022 3:15:00
PM
All Other Larceny
Part 1
Crimes
22-084351
Pending/Possible
Leads
07/19/2022 11:30:00
AM
Aggravated Assault
Part 1
Crimes
22-077131
Cleared by Arrest
07/14/2022 6:00:00
PM
All Other Offenses
Part 2
Crimes
22-075403
Pending/Possible
Leads
07/14/2022 7:22:00
AM
All Other Larceny
Part 1
Crimes
22-076283
Pending/Possible
Leads
06/22/2022 7:31:00
PM
Shoplifting
Part 1
Crimes
22-066178
Cleared by Arrest
05/27/2022 6:18:00
PM
Damaged Property Accidental
22-055607
Pending/Possible
Leads
05/08/2022 11:00:00
PM
Miscellaneous Information
22-047940
Pending/Possible
Leads
04/30/2022 5:12:00
PM
Miscellaneous Information
1704190001 Pending/Possible
Leads
04/30/2022 11:10:00
AM
Miscellaneous Information
22-044477
Pending/Possible
Leads
04/12/2022 7:15:00
PM
Simple Assault
Part 1
Crimes
22-037598
Pending/Possible
Leads
03/24/2022 1:07:00
PM
Drug/Narcotic Violations
Part 1
Crimes
22-030304
Pending/Possible
Leads
03/24/2022 1:07:00
PM
Drug Equipment Violations
Part 1
Crimes
22-030304
Pending/Possible
Leads
03/24/2022 1:07:00
PM
Misc Report
Other
Incidents
22-030304
Pending/Possible
Leads
Page
of
12
40
03/21/2022 4:30:00
PM
Trespass Of Real Property
Part 2
Crimes
22-029205
Cleared by Arrest
03/17/2022 11:23:00
AM
All Other Larceny
Part 1
Crimes
22-027571
Pending/Possible
Leads
03/16/2022 2:19:00
PM
Misc Report
Other
Incidents
22-027224
Pending/Possible
Leads
03/16/2022 2:19:00
PM
Drug/Narcotic Violations
Part 1
Crimes
22-027224
Pending/Possible
Leads
03/04/2022 8:21:00
PM
Miscellaneous Information
22-022866
Pending/Possible
Leads
02/25/2022 1:00:00
PM
Wire/Computer/Other Electronic
Manipulation
Part 1
Crimes
22-021326
Inactive/Suspended
02/21/2022 6:45:00
PM
Shoplifting
Part 1
Crimes
22-018638
Pending/Possible
Leads
02/21/2022 4:40:00
PM
Shoplifting
Part 1
Crimes
22-018586
Cleared by Arrest
02/16/2022 2:18:00
PM
Shoplifting
Part 1
Crimes
22-016642
Cleared by Arrest
02/16/2022 2:18:00
PM
Drug Equipment Violations
Part 1
Crimes
22-016642
Cleared by Arrest
02/15/2022 7:00:00
PM
Shoplifting
Part 1
Crimes
22-016338
Cleared by Arrest
02/15/2022 6:02:00
PM
Shoplifting
Part 1
Crimes
22-016618
Pending/Possible
Leads
01/11/2022 10:07:00
AM
Trespass Of Real Property
Part 2
Crimes
22-003526
Pending/Possible
Leads
01/10/2022 12:56:00
AM
Miscellaneous Information
22-003089
Pending/Possible
Leads
Page
of
13
40
Budget Suites of America, 2702 W. Yorkshire Drive, Phoenix, AZ 85027
Inc. Number
Type
Co
de
Description
Date/Time
Location
202300000955 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
1/1/2023
3:06:36
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300000955 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
1/1/2023
3:06:36
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300003336 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
41
5B
CRIMINAL DAMAGE
1/1/2023
15:28:02
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300003336 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
41
5B
CRIMINAL DAMAGE
1/1/2023
15:28:02
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300007917 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
651 LOOSE ANIMALS
1/2/2023
15:35:01
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300007917 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
651 LOOSE ANIMALS
1/2/2023
15:35:01
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300015989 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
1/4/2023
8:09:31
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300015989 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
1/4/2023
8:09:31
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300016331 INTERACTION
239 FIGHT
1/4/2023
9:37:52
196XX N 27TH
AVE
202300016861 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
1/4/2023
11:44:37
196XX N 27TH
AVE
202300017157 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
240 ASSAULT
1/4/2023
13:01:02
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300017157 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
240 ASSAULT
1/4/2023
13:01:02
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300019809 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
1/4/2023
21:52:43
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300019809 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
1/4/2023
21:52:43
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300022066 NO ACTION REQUIRED
917 ABANDONED VEHICLE
1/5/2023
11:43:41
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300022066 NO ACTION REQUIRED
917 ABANDONED VEHICLE
1/5/2023
11:43:41
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300029906 INTERACTION
31
5D
THEFT OF CREDIT
CARD
1/6/2023
20:48:10
196XX N 27TH
AVE
202300040590 NO ACTION REQUIRED
900 CHECK WELFARE
1/9/2023
2:59:55
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300040590 NO ACTION REQUIRED
900 CHECK WELFARE
1/9/2023
2:59:55
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300045228 INTERACTION
601 MISSING PERSON
1/9/2023
22:24:02
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300045228 INTERACTION
601 MISSING PERSON
1/9/2023
22:24:02
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300051746 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
1/11/2023
9:06:44
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
Page
of
14
40
202300051746 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
1/11/2023
9:06:44
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300052230 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
240 ASSAULT
1/11/2023
11:06:26
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300052230 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
240 ASSAULT
1/11/2023
11:06:26
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300054803 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
239 FIGHT
1/11/2023
19:34:52
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300054803 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
239 FIGHT
1/11/2023
19:34:52
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300055894 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
239 FIGHT
1/12/2023
0:46:18
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300055894 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
239 FIGHT
1/12/2023
0:46:18
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300066006 NO ACTION REQUIRED
41
8O
1/13/2023
21:37:31
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300066006 NO ACTION REQUIRED
41
8O
1/13/2023
21:37:31
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300066659 INTERACTION
239 FIGHT
1/14/2023
0:55:36
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300066659 INTERACTION
239 FIGHT
1/14/2023
0:55:36
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300069002 INTERACTION
41
8O
1/14/2023
15:10:34
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300069002 INTERACTION
41
8O
1/14/2023
15:10:34
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300073166 NO ACTION REQUIRED
418 CIVIL MATTER/STANDBY
1/15/2023
13:14:46
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300073166 NO ACTION REQUIRED
418 CIVIL MATTER/STANDBY
1/15/2023
13:14:46
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300076929 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
41
5F
DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
1/16/2023
9:50:08
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300076929 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
41
5F
DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
1/16/2023
9:50:08
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300085245 OTHER (SUPP/FALSE
ALARM/FI/LOUD PARTY)
45
9A
BURGLARY ALARM
1/17/2023
22:17:44
196XX N 27TH
AVE
202300085442 OTHER (SUPP/FALSE
ALARM/FI/LOUD PARTY)
45
9A
BURGLARY ALARM
1/17/2023
23:22:47
196XX N 27TH
AVE
202300092474 NO ACTION REQUIRED
41
8O
1/19/2023
10:14:37
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300092474 NO ACTION REQUIRED
41
8O
1/19/2023
10:14:37
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300096554 NO ACTION REQUIRED
64
7V
SUSPICIOUS PERSON
IN VEHICLE
1/20/2023
0:35:09
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300096554 NO ACTION REQUIRED
64
7V
SUSPICIOUS PERSON
IN VEHICLE
1/20/2023
0:35:09
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300099396 NO ACTION REQUIRED
211
A
ARMED ROBBERY
ALARM
1/20/2023
14:43:05
196XX N 27TH
AVE
Page
of
15
40
202300103617 NO ACTION REQUIRED
647 SUSPICIOUS PERSON
1/21/2023
11:16:35
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300103617 NO ACTION REQUIRED
647 SUSPICIOUS PERSON
1/21/2023
11:16:35
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300115479 INTERACTION
48
7V
STOLEN VEHICLE
1/23/2023
17:37:29
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300115479 INTERACTION
48
7V
STOLEN VEHICLE
1/23/2023
17:37:29
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300124993 INTERACTION
239 FIGHT
1/25/2023
15:07:54
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300124993 INTERACTION
239 FIGHT
1/25/2023
15:07:54
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300125867 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
1/25/2023
17:12:06
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300125867 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
1/25/2023
17:12:06
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300128593 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
90
1H
DEAD BODY
1/26/2023
9:17:29
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300128593 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
90
1H
DEAD BODY
1/26/2023
9:17:29
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300146888 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
1/29/2023
18:08:27
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300146888 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
1/29/2023
18:08:27
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300154061 NO ACTION REQUIRED
41
5F
DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
1/31/2023
6:37:57
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300154061 NO ACTION REQUIRED
41
5F
DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
1/31/2023
6:37:57
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300158192 INTERACTION
41
8T
TRESPASSING
1/31/2023
20:40:12
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300158192 INTERACTION
41
8T
TRESPASSING
1/31/2023
20:40:12
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300169973 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
2/3/2023
3:44:28
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300169973 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
2/3/2023
3:44:28
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300171503 INTERACTION
601 MISSING PERSON
2/3/2023
11:55:32
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300171503 INTERACTION
601 MISSING PERSON
2/3/2023
11:55:32
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300177191 INTERACTION
647 SUSPICIOUS PERSON
2/4/2023
11:46:07
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300177191 INTERACTION
647 SUSPICIOUS PERSON
2/4/2023
11:46:07
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300177244 INTERACTION
239 FIGHT
2/4/2023
11:53:16
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300177244 INTERACTION
239 FIGHT
2/4/2023
11:53:16
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
Page
of
16
40
202300177406 OTHER (SUPP/FALSE
ALARM/FI/LOUD PARTY)
45
9A
BURGLARY ALARM
2/4/2023
12:26:29
196XX N 27TH
AVE
202300186016 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
601 MISSING PERSON
2/6/2023
1:27:11
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300186016 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
601 MISSING PERSON
2/6/2023
1:27:11
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300202769 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
418 CIVIL MATTER/STANDBY
2/9/2023
7:27:25
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300202769 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
418 CIVIL MATTER/STANDBY
2/9/2023
7:27:25
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300207227 NO ACTION REQUIRED
41
5E
LOUD NOISE
DISTURBANCE
2/9/2023
22:23:18
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300207227 NO ACTION REQUIRED
41
5E
LOUD NOISE
DISTURBANCE
2/9/2023
22:23:18
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300212075 NO ACTION REQUIRED
239 FIGHT
2/10/2023
19:04:05
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300212075 NO ACTION REQUIRED
239 FIGHT
2/10/2023
19:04:05
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300213024 INTERACTION
45
9R
BURGLARY
RESIDENTIAL
2/10/2023
21:58:39
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300213024 INTERACTION
45
9R
BURGLARY
RESIDENTIAL
2/10/2023
21:58:39
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300218226 INTERACTION
65
1A
INJURED ANIMALS
2/11/2023
20:48:15
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300218226 INTERACTION
65
1A
INJURED ANIMALS
2/11/2023
20:48:15
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300223795 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
245 AGGRAVATED ASSAULT
2/12/2023
22:25:37
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300223795 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
245 AGGRAVATED ASSAULT
2/12/2023
22:25:37
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300230283 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
45
9C
BURGLARY
COMMERCIAL
2/14/2023
7:56:02
196XX N 27TH
AVE
202300232994 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
310 MOLESTING
2/14/2023
17:27:37
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300232994 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
310 MOLESTING
2/14/2023
17:27:37
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300251841 INTERACTION
96
1H
HIT & RUN ACCIDENT
NO INJURY
2/18/2023
9:04:54
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300251841 INTERACTION
96
1H
HIT & RUN ACCIDENT
NO INJURY
2/18/2023
9:04:54
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300255586 NO ACTION REQUIRED
45
9A
BURGLARY ALARM
2/18/2023
22:26:12
196XX N 27TH
AVE
202300256823 INTERACTION
41
5F
DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
2/19/2023
5:23:28
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300256823 INTERACTION
41
5F
DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
2/19/2023
5:23:28
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300267802 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
2/21/2023
10:39:20
196XX N 27TH
AVE
Page
of
17
40
202300280777 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
60
1J
MISSING JUVENILE
2/23/2023
17:24:44
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300280777 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
60
1J
MISSING JUVENILE
2/23/2023
17:24:44
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300288734 INTERACTION
239 FIGHT
2/25/2023
3:40:44
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300288734 INTERACTION
239 FIGHT
2/25/2023
3:40:44
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300293103 NO ACTION REQUIRED
239 FIGHT
2/25/2023
22:12:02
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300293103 NO ACTION REQUIRED
239 FIGHT
2/25/2023
22:12:02
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300297251 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
240 ASSAULT
2/26/2023
18:24:35
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300297251 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
240 ASSAULT
2/26/2023
18:24:35
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300304259 INTERACTION
911
H
9-1-1 HANG-UP CALL
2/28/2023
7:21:21
196XX N 27TH
AVE
202300318801 INTERACTION
41
5I
INCORRIGIBLE
JUVENILE
3/2/2023
18:52:20
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300318801 INTERACTION
41
5I
INCORRIGIBLE
JUVENILE
3/2/2023
18:52:20
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300318817 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
239 FIGHT
3/2/2023
19:00:01
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300318817 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
239 FIGHT
3/2/2023
19:00:01
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300323728 NO ACTION REQUIRED
911
H
9-1-1 HANG-UP CALL
3/3/2023
18:38:04
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300323728 NO ACTION REQUIRED
911
H
9-1-1 HANG-UP CALL
3/3/2023
18:38:04
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300337618 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
1051FELONY WARRANT
OUTSTANDING
3/6/2023
13:29:51
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300337618 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
1051FELONY WARRANT
OUTSTANDING
3/6/2023
13:29:51
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300339089 INTERACTION
41
8G
UNWANTED GUEST
3/6/2023
17:13:34
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300339089 INTERACTION
41
8G
UNWANTED GUEST
3/6/2023
17:13:34
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300352900 NO ACTION REQUIRED
900 CHECK WELFARE
3/9/2023
6:10:07
196XX N 27TH
AVE
202300359898 INTERACTION
65
1A
INJURED ANIMALS
3/10/2023
11:46:19
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300359898 INTERACTION
65
1A
INJURED ANIMALS
3/10/2023
11:46:19
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300367649 INTERACTION
236 THREAT
3/11/2023
18:40:35
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300367649 INTERACTION
236 THREAT
3/11/2023
18:40:35
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
Page
of
18
40
202300377076 NO ACTION REQUIRED
1076NOTIFY OWNER OF
VEHICLE RECOVERY
3/13/2023
14:19:45
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300377076 NO ACTION REQUIRED
1076NOTIFY OWNER OF
VEHICLE RECOVERY
3/13/2023
14:19:45
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300381364 INTERACTION
647 SUSPICIOUS PERSON
3/14/2023
9:55:44
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300381364 INTERACTION
647 SUSPICIOUS PERSON
3/14/2023
9:55:44
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300385837 NO ACTION REQUIRED
64
7V
SUSPICIOUS PERSON
IN VEHICLE
3/15/2023
3:47:40
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300385837 NO ACTION REQUIRED
64
7V
SUSPICIOUS PERSON
IN VEHICLE
3/15/2023
3:47:40
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300386005 NO ACTION REQUIRED
647 SUSPICIOUS PERSON
3/15/2023
5:46:20
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300386005 NO ACTION REQUIRED
647 SUSPICIOUS PERSON
3/15/2023
5:46:20
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300393703 NO ACTION REQUIRED
26
0J
SEXUAL ABUSE OF
JUVENILE
3/16/2023
13:47:37
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300393703 NO ACTION REQUIRED
26
0J
SEXUAL ABUSE OF
JUVENILE
3/16/2023
13:47:37
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300394243 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
26
0J
SEXUAL ABUSE OF
JUVENILE
3/16/2023
15:28:29
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300394243 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
26
0J
SEXUAL ABUSE OF
JUVENILE
3/16/2023
15:28:29
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300396153 INTERACTION
239 FIGHT
3/16/2023
21:31:42
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300396153 INTERACTION
239 FIGHT
3/16/2023
21:31:42
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300421082 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
3/21/2023
13:32:36
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300421082 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
3/21/2023
13:32:36
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300432668 INTERACTION
911
H
9-1-1 HANG-UP CALL
3/23/2023
14:16:27
196XX N 27TH
AVE
202300434835 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
3/23/2023
20:22:16
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300434835 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
3/23/2023
20:22:16
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300435759 NO ACTION REQUIRED
907 BACK-UP
3/24/2023
1:27:28
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300435759 NO ACTION REQUIRED
907 BACK-UP
3/24/2023
1:27:28
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300442884 INTERACTION
41
8T
TRESPASSING
3/25/2023
9:59:45
196XX N 27TH
AVE
202300446566 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
647 SUSPICIOUS PERSON
3/25/2023
23:33:51
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300446566 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
647 SUSPICIOUS PERSON
3/25/2023
23:33:51
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
Page
of
19
40
202300448727 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
3/26/2023
12:00:24
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300448727 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
3/26/2023
12:00:24
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300452230 INTERACTION
236 THREAT
3/27/2023
3:41:10
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300452230 INTERACTION
236 THREAT
3/27/2023
3:41:10
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300457150 INTERACTION
41
5F
DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
3/27/2023
22:37:09
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300457150 INTERACTION
41
5F
DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
3/27/2023
22:37:09
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300462912 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
48
7V
STOLEN VEHICLE
3/28/2023
20:56:54
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300462912 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
48
7V
STOLEN VEHICLE
3/28/2023
20:56:54
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300464455 NO ACTION REQUIRED
48
8V
RECOVERY OF VEHICLE
3/29/2023
6:42:47
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300464455 NO ACTION REQUIRED
48
8V
RECOVERY OF VEHICLE
3/29/2023
6:42:47
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300469638 NO ACTION REQUIRED
239 FIGHT
3/29/2023
23:20:30
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300469638 NO ACTION REQUIRED
239 FIGHT
3/29/2023
23:20:30
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300473129 NO ACTION REQUIRED
65
1A
INJURED ANIMALS
3/30/2023
15:17:15
196XX N 27TH
AVE
202300475385 INTERACTION
647 SUSPICIOUS PERSON
3/30/2023
22:07:49
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300475385 INTERACTION
647 SUSPICIOUS PERSON
3/30/2023
22:07:49
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300476354 NO ACTION REQUIRED
647 SUSPICIOUS PERSON
3/31/2023
5:14:07
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300476354 NO ACTION REQUIRED
647 SUSPICIOUS PERSON
3/31/2023
5:14:07
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300481546 NO ACTION REQUIRED
647 SUSPICIOUS PERSON
3/31/2023
23:20:53
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300481546 NO ACTION REQUIRED
647 SUSPICIOUS PERSON
3/31/2023
23:20:53
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300488471 NO ACTION REQUIRED
236 THREAT
4/2/2023
7:35:38
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300488471 NO ACTION REQUIRED
236 THREAT
4/2/2023
7:35:38
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300503822 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
4/4/2023
23:21:05
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300503822 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
4/4/2023
23:21:05
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300509982 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
4/6/2023
1:30:47
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
Page
of
20
40
202300509982 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
4/6/2023
1:30:47
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300524336 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
900 CHECK WELFARE
4/8/2023
13:15:04
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300524336 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
900 CHECK WELFARE
4/8/2023
13:15:04
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300532010 NO ACTION REQUIRED
647 SUSPICIOUS PERSON
4/9/2023
22:58:19
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300532010 NO ACTION REQUIRED
647 SUSPICIOUS PERSON
4/9/2023
22:58:19
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300533161 OTHER (SUPP/FALSE
ALARM/FI/LOUD PARTY)
45
9A
BURGLARY ALARM
4/10/2023
7:15:08
196XX N 27TH
AVE
202300533634 NO ACTION REQUIRED
1091ASSIST MOTORIST
4/10/2023
9:01:39
196XX N 27TH
AVE
202300546498 INTERACTION
961 ACCIDENT NO INJURIES
4/12/2023
10:17:15
196XX N 27TH
AVE
202300554143 NO ACTION REQUIRED
211
A
ARMED ROBBERY
ALARM
4/13/2023
15:33:07
196XX N 27TH
AVE
202300561359 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
4/14/2023
21:50:06
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300561359 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
4/14/2023
21:50:06
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300571444 INTERACTION
240 ASSAULT
4/16/2023
19:16:19
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300571444 INTERACTION
240 ASSAULT
4/16/2023
19:16:19
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300581640 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
239 FIGHT
4/18/2023
15:26:56
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300581640 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
239 FIGHT
4/18/2023
15:26:56
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300589665 INTERACTION
239 FIGHT
4/19/2023
22:29:59
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300589665 INTERACTION
239 FIGHT
4/19/2023
22:29:59
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300592541 NO ACTION REQUIRED
60
1F
FOUND MISSING
PERSON
4/20/2023
13:13:59
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300592541 NO ACTION REQUIRED
60
1F
FOUND MISSING
PERSON
4/20/2023
13:13:59
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300618633 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
41
5B
CRIMINAL DAMAGE
4/25/2023
7:42:43
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300618633 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
41
5B
CRIMINAL DAMAGE
4/25/2023
7:42:43
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300624268 INTERACTION
418 CIVIL MATTER/STANDBY
4/26/2023
6:11:58
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300624268 INTERACTION
418 CIVIL MATTER/STANDBY
4/26/2023
6:11:58
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300626637 INTERACTION
418 CIVIL MATTER/STANDBY
4/26/2023
14:31:28
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
Page
of
21
40
202300626637 INTERACTION
418 CIVIL MATTER/STANDBY
4/26/2023
14:31:28
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300632824 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
31
5I
IDENTITY THEFT
4/27/2023
14:40:59
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300632824 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
31
5I
IDENTITY THEFT
4/27/2023
14:40:59
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300642952 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
240 ASSAULT
4/29/2023
6:35:48
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300642952 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
240 ASSAULT
4/29/2023
6:35:48
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300643179 ACCIDENT REPORT
961 ACCIDENT NO INJURIES
4/29/2023
7:58:47
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300643179 ACCIDENT REPORT
961 ACCIDENT NO INJURIES
4/29/2023
7:58:47
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300676693 OTHER (SUPP/FALSE
ALARM/FI/LOUD PARTY)
45
9A
BURGLARY ALARM
5/5/2023
5:26:39
196XX N 27TH
AVE
202300686843 INTERACTION
41
5E
LOUD NOISE
DISTURBANCE
5/6/2023
22:33:02
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300686843 INTERACTION
41
5E
LOUD NOISE
DISTURBANCE
5/6/2023
22:33:02
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300687333 NO ACTION REQUIRED
239 FIGHT
5/7/2023
0:33:59
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300687333 NO ACTION REQUIRED
239 FIGHT
5/7/2023
0:33:59
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300693976 OTHER (SUPP/FALSE
ALARM/FI/LOUD PARTY)
45
9A
BURGLARY ALARM
5/8/2023
9:23:39
196XX N 27TH
AVE
202300697649 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
240 ASSAULT
5/8/2023
21:26:44
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300697649 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
240 ASSAULT
5/8/2023
21:26:44
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300698249 INTERACTION
23
7D
DANGEROUS DRUGS
5/9/2023
0:25:46
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300698249 INTERACTION
23
7D
DANGEROUS DRUGS
5/9/2023
0:25:46
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300699965 INTERACTION
239 FIGHT
5/9/2023
9:59:15
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300699965 INTERACTION
239 FIGHT
5/9/2023
9:59:15
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300700359 INTERACTION
41
8O
5/9/2023
11:06:34
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300700359 INTERACTION
41
8O
5/9/2023
11:06:34
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300702441 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
5/9/2023
16:58:51
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300702441 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
5/9/2023
16:58:51
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300704123 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
5/9/2023
23:40:01
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
Page
of
22
40
202300704123 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
5/9/2023
23:40:01
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300705035 INTERACTION
41
8B
NEIGHBOR DISPUTE
5/10/2023
6:38:04
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300705035 INTERACTION
41
8B
NEIGHBOR DISPUTE
5/10/2023
6:38:04
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300706120 INTERACTION
918 INSANE PERSON
5/10/2023
10:32:53
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300706120 INTERACTION
918 INSANE PERSON
5/10/2023
10:32:53
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300708318 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
5/10/2023
16:35:03
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300708318 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
5/10/2023
16:35:03
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300722761 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
64
7V
SUSPICIOUS PERSON
IN VEHICLE
5/13/2023
5:29:08
196XX N 27TH
AVE
202300737750 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
900 CHECK WELFARE
5/16/2023
0:17:39
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300737750 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
900 CHECK WELFARE
5/16/2023
0:17:39
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300738149 NO ACTION REQUIRED
41
8T
TRESPASSING
5/16/2023
4:19:24
196XX N 27TH
AVE
202300746524 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
5/17/2023
12:38:16
196XX N 27TH
AVE
202300759687 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
5/19/2023
15:18:51
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300759687 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
5/19/2023
15:18:51
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300767835 INTERACTION
927 UNKNOWN TROUBLE
5/21/2023
0:27:27
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300767835 INTERACTION
927 UNKNOWN TROUBLE
5/21/2023
0:27:27
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300769399 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
961 ACCIDENT NO INJURIES
5/21/2023
9:42:09
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300769399 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
961 ACCIDENT NO INJURIES
5/21/2023
9:42:09
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300774511 NO ACTION REQUIRED
911
H
9-1-1 HANG-UP CALL
5/22/2023
8:22:20
196XX N 27TH
AVE
202300774956 NO ACTION REQUIRED
900 CHECK WELFARE
5/22/2023
9:47:30
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300774956 NO ACTION REQUIRED
900 CHECK WELFARE
5/22/2023
9:47:30
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300812665 INTERACTION
239 FIGHT
5/28/2023
19:09:17
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300812665 INTERACTION
239 FIGHT
5/28/2023
19:09:17
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300818482 NO ACTION REQUIRED
236 THREAT
5/29/2023
20:20:31
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
Page
of
23
40
202300818482 NO ACTION REQUIRED
236 THREAT
5/29/2023
20:20:31
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300828285 NO ACTION REQUIRED
901 INJURED/SICK PERSON
5/31/2023
13:53:55
196XX N 27TH
AVE
202300828821 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
41
5F
DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
5/31/2023
15:16:23
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300828821 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
41
5F
DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
5/31/2023
15:16:23
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300833201 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
900 CHECK WELFARE
6/1/2023
11:23:42
196XX N 27TH
AVE
202300837554 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
6/2/2023
4:53:42
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300837554 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
6/2/2023
4:53:42
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300852239 INTERACTION
487 THEFT
6/4/2023
20:29:48
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300852239 INTERACTION
487 THEFT
6/4/2023
20:29:48
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300858092 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
41
5F
DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
6/5/2023
20:30:50
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300858092 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
41
5F
DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
6/5/2023
20:30:50
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300858807 INTERACTION
23
7D
DANGEROUS DRUGS
6/5/2023
23:38:36
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300858807 INTERACTION
23
7D
DANGEROUS DRUGS
6/5/2023
23:38:36
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300858868 OTHER (SUPP/FALSE
ALARM/FI/LOUD PARTY)
45
9A
BURGLARY ALARM
6/6/2023
0:10:41
196XX N 27TH
AVE
202300873153 INTERACTION
911
H
9-1-1 HANG-UP CALL
6/8/2023
12:33:32
196XX N 27TH
AVE
202300896411 NO ACTION REQUIRED
318 THEFT BY FRAUD
6/12/2023
15:24:38
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300896411 NO ACTION REQUIRED
318 THEFT BY FRAUD
6/12/2023
15:24:38
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300904313 NO ACTION REQUIRED
31
5C
MONEY LAUNDERING
6/13/2023
22:07:50
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300904313 NO ACTION REQUIRED
31
5C
MONEY LAUNDERING
6/13/2023
22:07:50
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300911246 NO ACTION REQUIRED
41
8T
TRESPASSING
6/15/2023
5:33:32
196XX N 27TH
AVE
202300911361 INTERACTION
901 INJURED/SICK PERSON
6/15/2023
6:15:43
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300911361 INTERACTION
901 INJURED/SICK PERSON
6/15/2023
6:15:43
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300911724 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
96
1H
HIT & RUN ACCIDENT
NO INJURY
6/15/2023
8:09:12
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300911724 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
96
1H
HIT & RUN ACCIDENT
NO INJURY
6/15/2023
8:09:12
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
Page
of
24
40
202300912846 NO ACTION REQUIRED
96
1H
S
HIT & RUN ACCIDENT
NO INJURIES SUPP
6/15/2023
12:28:23
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300912846 NO ACTION REQUIRED
96
1H
S
HIT & RUN ACCIDENT
NO INJURIES SUPP
6/15/2023
12:28:23
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300913023 INTERACTION
96
1H
S
HIT & RUN ACCIDENT
NO INJURIES SUPP
6/15/2023
13:04:20
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300913023 INTERACTION
96
1H
S
HIT & RUN ACCIDENT
NO INJURIES SUPP
6/15/2023
13:04:20
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300914020 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
91
8T
MENTALLY ILL SUBJECT
TRANSPORT
6/15/2023
16:06:03
196XX N 27TH
AVE
202300917562 NO ACTION REQUIRED
900 CHECK WELFARE
6/16/2023
9:17:13
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300917562 NO ACTION REQUIRED
900 CHECK WELFARE
6/16/2023
9:17:13
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300918811 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
45
9R
BURGLARY
RESIDENTIAL
6/16/2023
13:16:00
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300918811 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
45
9R
BURGLARY
RESIDENTIAL
6/16/2023
13:16:00
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300931864 INTERACTION
647 SUSPICIOUS PERSON
6/18/2023
23:41:01
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300931864 INTERACTION
647 SUSPICIOUS PERSON
6/18/2023
23:41:01
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300933937 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
6/19/2023
11:10:18
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300933937 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
6/19/2023
11:10:18
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300943446 NO ACTION REQUIRED
45
9F
BURGLARY FROM
VEHICLE
6/21/2023
1:06:01
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300943446 NO ACTION REQUIRED
45
9F
BURGLARY FROM
VEHICLE
6/21/2023
1:06:01
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300955271 INTERACTION
239 FIGHT
6/23/2023
1:19:39
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300955271 INTERACTION
239 FIGHT
6/23/2023
1:19:39
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300955479 NO ACTION REQUIRED
900 CHECK WELFARE
6/23/2023
3:06:08
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300955479 NO ACTION REQUIRED
900 CHECK WELFARE
6/23/2023
3:06:08
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300961908 OTHER (SUPP/FALSE
ALARM/FI/LOUD PARTY)
45
9A
BURGLARY ALARM
6/24/2023
6:49:31
196XX N 27TH
AVE
202300965567 INTERACTION
41
8B
NEIGHBOR DISPUTE
6/24/2023
21:00:52
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300965567 INTERACTION
41
8B
NEIGHBOR DISPUTE
6/24/2023
21:00:52
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
Page
of
25
40
202301026322 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
7/5/2023
17:54:45
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202301026322 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
7/5/2023
17:54:45
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202301032332 INTERACTION
239 FIGHT
7/6/2023
20:13:23
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202301032332 INTERACTION
239 FIGHT
7/6/2023
20:13:23
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202301037164 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
240 ASSAULT
7/7/2023
17:53:53
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202301037164 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
240 ASSAULT
7/7/2023
17:53:53
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202301044309 INTERACTION
41
5B
CRIMINAL DAMAGE
7/9/2023
2:40:19
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202301044309 INTERACTION
41
5B
CRIMINAL DAMAGE
7/9/2023
2:40:19
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202301048784 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
23
7D
DANGEROUS DRUGS
7/10/2023
0:48:06
196XX N 27TH
AVE
202301058004 NO ACTION REQUIRED
45
9R
BURGLARY
RESIDENTIAL
7/11/2023
18:59:33
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202301058004 NO ACTION REQUIRED
45
9R
BURGLARY
RESIDENTIAL
7/11/2023
18:59:33
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202301059445 NO ACTION REQUIRED
586 ILLEGAL PARKING
7/12/2023
2:07:59
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202301059445 NO ACTION REQUIRED
586 ILLEGAL PARKING
7/12/2023
2:07:59
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202301060434 INTERACTION
250 HARASSMENT
7/12/2023
8:30:34
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202301060434 INTERACTION
250 HARASSMENT
7/12/2023
8:30:34
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202301087966 INTERACTION
48
7V
STOLEN VEHICLE
7/17/2023
11:38:59
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202301087966 INTERACTION
48
7V
STOLEN VEHICLE
7/17/2023
11:38:59
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202301089723 INTERACTION
45
9F
BURGLARY FROM
VEHICLE
7/17/2023
17:34:26
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202301089723 INTERACTION
45
9F
BURGLARY FROM
VEHICLE
7/17/2023
17:34:26
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
Budget Suites of America, 611 W. Indian School Road, Phoenix, AZ 85013
Inc. Number
Type
Co
de
Description
Date/Time
Location
202300013832 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
41
5F
DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
1/3/2023
6:25:03 PM
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
Page
of
26
40
202300026197 NO ACTION REQUIRED
1091ASSIST MOTORIST
1/6/2023
7:54:49 AM
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300032302 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
900 CHECK WELFARE
1/7/2023
11:33:20 AM
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300032603 NO ACTION REQUIRED
900 CHECK WELFARE
1/7/2023
12:35:19 PM
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300033221 NO ACTION REQUIRED
90
1X
SUICIDE ATTEMPT
1/7/2023
2:47:00 PM
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300049805 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
49
1C
ACCESS
INTERFERENCE
1/10/2023
8:08:06 PM
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300054475 INTERACTION
41
8T
TRESPASSING
1/11/2023
6:18:23 PM
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300058498 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
48
7V
STOLEN VEHICLE
1/12/2023
2:46:39 PM
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300059778 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
90
1C
CUTTING/STABBING
1/12/2023
6:44:57 PM
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300059922 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
487 THEFT
1/12/2023
7:12:35 PM
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300060526 INTERACTION
41
5F
DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
1/12/2023
9:33:38 PM
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300060619 INTERACTION
239 FIGHT
1/12/2023
9:59:16 PM
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300065772 INTERACTION
647 SUSPICIOUS PERSON
1/13/2023
8:40:22 PM
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300067001 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
49
1C
ACCESS
INTERFERENCE
1/14/2023
3:06:28 AM
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300069629 INTERACTION
41
8T
TRESPASSING
1/14/2023
5:58:49 PM
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300070208 INTERACTION
390 DRUNK DISTURBING/
DOWN/CAR
1/14/2023
8:24:41 PM
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300091048 INTERACTION
239 FIGHT
1/19/2023
12:04:26 AM
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300093414 INTERACTION
41
8G
UNWANTED GUEST
1/19/2023
1:20:02 PM
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300094228 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
239 FIGHT
1/19/2023
3:41:45 PM
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300094992 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
928 FOUND PROPERTY
1/19/2023
5:49:49 PM
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300099139 ACCIDENT REPORT
961 ACCIDENT NO INJURIES
1/20/2023
2:00:02 PM
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300101813 NO ACTION REQUIRED
900 CHECK WELFARE
1/20/2023
11:13:31 PM
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300104541 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
90
1H
DEAD BODY
1/21/2023
2:55:44 PM
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300107168 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
1/22/2023
12:31:22 AM
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300112549 INTERACTION
41
8T
TRESPASSING
1/23/2023
6:31:41 AM
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
Page
of
27
40
202300117437 NO ACTION REQUIRED
647 SUSPICIOUS PERSON
1/24/2023
6:30:09 AM
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300119275 INTERACTION
41
8T
TRESPASSING
1/24/2023
1:37:44 PM
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300121050 NO ACTION REQUIRED
41
8T
TRESPASSING
1/24/2023
6:59:00 PM
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300121834 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
41
8B
NEIGHBOR DISPUTE
1/24/2023
10:27:54 PM
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300128171 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
41
5B
CRIMINAL DAMAGE
1/26/2023
7:28:32
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300138229 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
1/27/2023
23:38:28
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300144419 NO ACTION REQUIRED
41
5F
DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
1/29/2023
6:32:59
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300144445 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
240 ASSAULT
1/29/2023
6:35:52
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300150865 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
236 THREAT
1/30/2023
14:17:02
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300154674 INTERACTION
487 THEFT
1/31/2023
9:27:13
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300161513 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
60
1J
MISSING JUVENILE
2/1/2023
14:27:41
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300168181 NO ACTION REQUIRED
41
5F
DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
2/2/2023
18:28:43
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300168463 INTERACTION
487 THEFT
2/2/2023
19:24:52
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300169970 NO ACTION REQUIRED
927 UNKNOWN TROUBLE
2/3/2023
3:38:13
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300170894 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
41
5F
DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
2/3/2023
9:35:27
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300172069 OTHER (SUPP/FALSE
ALARM/FI/LOUD PARTY)
418 CIVIL MATTER/STANDBY
2/3/2023
13:38:59
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300173755 NO ACTION REQUIRED
900 CHECK WELFARE
2/3/2023
18:55:54
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300175355 INTERACTION
239 FIGHT
2/4/2023
0:49:55
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300177933 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
312 CHILD NEGLECT
2/4/2023
14:08:01
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300188681 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
918 INSANE PERSON
2/6/2023
15:03:21
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300195518 INTERACTION
961 ACCIDENT NO INJURIES
2/7/2023
19:40:03
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300205170 NO ACTION REQUIRED
900 CHECK WELFARE
2/9/2023
15:34:02
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300211091 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
60
1F
FOUND MISSING
PERSON
2/10/2023
16:16:31
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300213261 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
41
5F
DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
2/10/2023
22:48:49
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
Page
of
28
40
202300225213 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
48
7V
STOLEN VEHICLE
2/13/2023
7:49:29
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300239929 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
41
8T
TRESPASSING
2/16/2023
0:58:18
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300240157 NO ACTION REQUIRED
900 CHECK WELFARE
2/16/2023
3:35:01
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300244524 NO ACTION REQUIRED
41
5G
SHOTS FIRED
2/16/2023
20:52:12
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300251690 NO ACTION REQUIRED
41
5F
DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
2/18/2023
8:13:37
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300261022 INTERACTION
239 FIGHT
2/20/2023
0:41:49
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300261174 INTERACTION
239 FIGHT
2/20/2023
1:45:00
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300264887 NO ACTION REQUIRED
900 CHECK WELFARE
2/20/2023
18:40:47
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300270422 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
41
5F
DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
2/21/2023
18:54:49
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300272805 INTERACTION
41
5F
DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
2/22/2023
8:02:19
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300277318 INTERACTION
901 INJURED/SICK PERSON
2/23/2023
0:55:28
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300281608 NO ACTION REQUIRED
41
8O
2/23/2023
19:48:15
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300286153 NO ACTION REQUIRED
41
8O
2/24/2023
16:37:14
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300300912 INTERACTION
45
9A
BURGLARY ALARM
2/27/2023
13:29:25
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300307864 INTERACTION
239 FIGHT
2/28/2023
19:02:18
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300311520 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
48
7V
STOLEN VEHICLE
3/1/2023
13:17:19
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300319036 NO ACTION REQUIRED
647 SUSPICIOUS PERSON
3/2/2023
19:49:10
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300324690 NO ACTION REQUIRED
45
9R
BURGLARY
RESIDENTIAL
3/3/2023
22:20:07
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300328354 INTERACTION
250 HARASSMENT
3/4/2023
16:35:52
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300331885 NO ACTION REQUIRED
239 FIGHT
3/5/2023
10:34:13
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300342013 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
240 ASSAULT
3/7/2023
9:15:50
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300343700 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
239 FIGHT
3/7/2023
14:33:37
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300344305 NO ACTION REQUIRED
900 CHECK WELFARE
3/7/2023
16:09:01
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300344847 NO ACTION REQUIRED
23
9S
FIGHT SUPPLEMENT
3/7/2023
17:41:15
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
Page
of
29
40
202300345309 NO ACTION REQUIRED
1021CALL BY PHONE
3/7/2023
19:06:41
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300366059 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
41
5B
CRIMINAL DAMAGE
3/11/2023
13:18:15
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300367439 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
41
5F
DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
3/11/2023
17:47:18
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300374213 NO ACTION REQUIRED
41
5F
DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
3/13/2023
1:11:02
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300383236 NO ACTION REQUIRED
41
8T
TRESPASSING
3/14/2023
15:40:02
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300384484 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
239 FIGHT
3/14/2023
19:43:08
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300388971 NO ACTION REQUIRED
487 THEFT
3/15/2023
15:59:20
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300394949 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
3/16/2023
17:19:41
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300399546 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
487 THEFT
3/17/2023
14:22:50
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300401960 NO ACTION REQUIRED
41
5F
DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
3/17/2023
22:16:38
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300403187 NO ACTION REQUIRED
91
8T
MENTALLY ILL SUBJECT
TRANSPORT
3/18/2023
5:34:35
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300404435 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
3/18/2023
11:46:54
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300404916 NO ACTION REQUIRED
91
8T
MENTALLY ILL SUBJECT
TRANSPORT
3/18/2023
13:32:35
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300409870 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
91
8T
MENTALLY ILL SUBJECT
TRANSPORT
3/19/2023
11:48:24
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300417173 INTERACTION
239 FIGHT
3/20/2023
18:09:37
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300430654 NO ACTION REQUIRED
239 FIGHT
3/23/2023
7:36:22
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300463786 NO ACTION REQUIRED
911
H
9-1-1 HANG-UP CALL
3/29/2023
0:59:02
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300467800 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
487 THEFT
3/29/2023
16:50:25
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300470942 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
3/30/2023
8:59:29
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300494047 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
901 INJURED/SICK PERSON
4/3/2023
9:21:21
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300495183 NO ACTION REQUIRED
500 GENERIC
4/3/2023
13:03:59
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300506204 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
90
1H
DEAD BODY
4/5/2023
12:16:34
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300511243 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
918 INSANE PERSON
4/6/2023
9:43:28
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300521494 NO ACTION REQUIRED
239 FIGHT
4/7/2023
22:55:43
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
Page
of
30
40
202300523913 NO ACTION REQUIRED
239 FIGHT
4/8/2023
11:51:07
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300531499 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
4/9/2023
20:48:52
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300538772 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
4/11/2023
5:13:17
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300544494 NO ACTION REQUIRED
418 CIVIL MATTER/STANDBY
4/11/2023
22:40:44
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300545066 NO ACTION REQUIRED
41
5B
CRIMINAL DAMAGE
4/12/2023
2:48:19
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300551216 NO ACTION REQUIRED
41
5F
DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
4/13/2023
3:50:18
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300554396 INTERACTION
647 SUSPICIOUS PERSON
4/13/2023
16:11:40
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300571923 INTERACTION
239 FIGHT
4/16/2023
21:10:33
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300574112 NO ACTION REQUIRED
41
8T
TRESPASSING
4/17/2023
10:10:49
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300584425 INTERACTION
41
5F
DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
4/19/2023
3:31:30
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300591671 NO ACTION REQUIRED
23
7D
DANGEROUS DRUGS
4/20/2023
10:16:06
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300600270 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
240 ASSAULT
4/21/2023
19:42:56
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300601389 INTERACTION
927 UNKNOWN TROUBLE
4/22/2023
0:18:33
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300605705 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
4/22/2023
20:50:26
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300605938 NO ACTION REQUIRED
45
9R
BURGLARY
RESIDENTIAL
4/22/2023
21:39:41
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300607369 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
60
1J
MISSING JUVENILE
4/23/2023
5:26:05
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300624040 NO ACTION REQUIRED
239 FIGHT
4/26/2023
4:10:31
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300637632 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
45
9F
BURGLARY FROM
VEHICLE
4/28/2023
10:47:56
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300640369 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
245 AGGRAVATED ASSAULT
4/28/2023
17:58:07
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300640653 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
41
5F
DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
4/28/2023
18:46:46
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300642592 NO ACTION REQUIRED
911
H
9-1-1 HANG-UP CALL
4/29/2023
3:38:04
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300652226 INTERACTION
390 DRUNK DISTURBING/
DOWN/CAR
4/30/2023
20:37:03
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300656884 INTERACTION
1076NOTIFY OWNER OF
VEHICLE RECOVERY
5/1/2023
17:11:02
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300666621 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
45
9R
BURGLARY
RESIDENTIAL
5/3/2023
11:17:12
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
Page
of
31
40
202300672079 NO ACTION REQUIRED
311 INDECENT EXPOSURE
5/4/2023
10:02:30
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300723770 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
41
5B
CRIMINAL DAMAGE
5/13/2023
10:47:12
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300725685 ACCIDENT REPORT
961 ACCIDENT NO INJURIES
5/13/2023
17:21:38
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300727796 INTERACTION
647 SUSPICIOUS PERSON
5/14/2023
1:52:29
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300738163 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
5/16/2023
4:06:47
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300744927 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
918 INSANE PERSON
5/17/2023
7:43:14
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300750249 NO ACTION REQUIRED
647 SUSPICIOUS PERSON
5/18/2023
0:03:24
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300755421 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
31
5M
COUNTERFEIT
CURRENCY
5/18/2023
19:56:45
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300767330 NO ACTION REQUIRED
41
5E
LOUD NOISE
DISTURBANCE
5/20/2023
22:30:53
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300772836 INTERACTION
601 MISSING PERSON
5/21/2023
22:05:48
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300773226 NO ACTION REQUIRED
41
5E
LOUD NOISE
DISTURBANCE
5/21/2023
23:51:11
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300782069 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
928 FOUND PROPERTY
5/23/2023
13:09:41
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300785225 NO ACTION REQUIRED
41
5E
LOUD NOISE
DISTURBANCE
5/23/2023
23:26:17
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300798160 NO ACTION REQUIRED
41
5F
DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
5/26/2023
7:21:39
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300808292 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
5/27/2023
22:19:25
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300815882 INTERACTION
239 FIGHT
5/29/2023
11:22:28
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300836446 INTERACTION
210 STRONG ARMED
ROBBERY
6/1/2023
21:13:30
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300839196 NO ACTION REQUIRED
647 SUSPICIOUS PERSON
6/2/2023
12:15:18
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300842880 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
240 ASSAULT
6/3/2023
1:10:21
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300843368 INTERACTION
41
5F
DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
6/3/2023
4:57:10
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300853499 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
23
7D
DANGEROUS DRUGS
6/5/2023
4:07:22
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300857020 NO ACTION REQUIRED
48
7V
STOLEN VEHICLE
6/5/2023
16:48:59
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300858987 NO ACTION REQUIRED
41
5F
DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
6/6/2023
1:09:58
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300871112 NO ACTION REQUIRED
239 FIGHT
6/8/2023
2:01:09
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
Page
of
32
40
202300883302 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
41
5B
CRIMINAL DAMAGE
6/10/2023
5:35:29
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300890818 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
48
7V
STOLEN VEHICLE
6/11/2023
14:30:34
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300895741 NO ACTION REQUIRED
41
8O
6/12/2023
13:27:46
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300901847 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
41
5F
DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
6/13/2023
14:38:34
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300913866 NO ACTION REQUIRED
48
7V
S
STOLEN VEHICLE
SUPPLEMENT
6/15/2023
15:37:58
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300918427 INTERACTION
41
8T
TRESPASSING
6/16/2023
12:09:52
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300920230 NO ACTION REQUIRED
48
7F
THEFT FROM VEHICLE
6/16/2023
17:22:29
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300929232 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
318 THEFT BY FRAUD
6/18/2023
11:51:26
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300939734 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
41
8T
TRESPASSING
6/20/2023
12:12:51
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300945616 NO ACTION REQUIRED
900 CHECK WELFARE
6/21/2023
11:50:21
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300945864 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
45
9C
BURGLARY
COMMERCIAL
6/21/2023
12:39:42
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300956048 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
502 JUDICIAL
INTERFERENCE
6/23/2023
7:14:01
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300967437 NO ACTION REQUIRED
41
5I
INCORRIGIBLE
JUVENILE
6/25/2023
6:08:48
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300968318 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
245 AGGRAVATED ASSAULT
6/25/2023
11:37:30
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300976825 INTERACTION
240 ASSAULT
6/26/2023
23:09:27
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300979551 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
48
8V
RECOVERY OF VEHICLE
6/27/2023
13:38:04
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300980221 INTERACTION
240 ASSAULT
6/27/2023
15:42:52
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300982448 INTERACTION
459 BURGLARY
6/27/2023
23:42:05
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300982580 NO ACTION REQUIRED
239 FIGHT
6/28/2023
0:27:26
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300982645 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
41
5B
CRIMINAL DAMAGE
6/28/2023
0:51:48
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300983238 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
48
7V
STOLEN VEHICLE
6/28/2023
6:00:38
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300994167 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
211 ARMED ROBBERY
6/30/2023
1:14:15
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300996261 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
311 INDECENT EXPOSURE
6/30/2023
12:41:30
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
Page
of
33
40
202301006580 NO ACTION REQUIRED
45
9C
BURGLARY
COMMERCIAL
7/2/2023
8:22:19
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202301007213 INTERACTION
918 INSANE PERSON
7/2/2023
11:16:35
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202301010583 NO ACTION REQUIRED
927 UNKNOWN TROUBLE
7/3/2023
1:31:20
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202301022832 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
240 ASSAULT
7/5/2023
2:39:10
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202301022964 NO ACTION REQUIRED
900 CHECK WELFARE
7/5/2023
3:50:55
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202301025130 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
45
9R
BURGLARY
RESIDENTIAL
7/5/2023
13:55:44
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202301047313 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
487 THEFT
7/9/2023
18:27:34
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202301051367 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
7/10/2023
14:22:37
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202301055795 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
7/11/2023
10:45:21
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202301069800 NO ACTION REQUIRED
41
8T
TRESPASSING
7/13/2023
21:32:12
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202301085975 INTERACTION
41
5F
DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
7/16/2023
23:46:32
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202301086149 OTHER (SUPP/FALSE
ALARM/FI/LOUD PARTY)
900 CHECK WELFARE
7/17/2023
0:51:56
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202301086192 OTHER (SUPP/FALSE
ALARM/FI/LOUD PARTY)
45
9A
BURGLARY ALARM
7/17/2023
1:11:17
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202301086305 NO ACTION REQUIRED
900 CHECK WELFARE
7/17/2023
2:16:10
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202301087164 OTHER (SUPP/FALSE
ALARM/FI/LOUD PARTY)
45
9A
BURGLARY ALARM
7/17/2023
8:24:31
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
Extended Stay, 1360 N 43rd Ave, Phoenix, AZ 85009
202300009794 INTERACTION
41
5F
DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
1/2/2023
23:33:10
13XX N 43RD
AVE
202300032745 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
236 THREAT
1/7/2023
13:13:18
13XX N 43RD
AVE
202300062326 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
1/13/2023
9:50:33
13XX N 43RD
AVE
202300071191 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
1/15/2023
0:23:45
13XX N 43RD
AVE
202300072847 NO ACTION REQUIRED
90
0V
1/15/2023
11:43:02
13XX N 43RD
AVE
202300086698 NO ACTION REQUIRED
41
8T
TRESPASSING
1/18/2023
8:46:41
13XX N 43RD
AVE
202300087160 INTERACTION
41
8G
UNWANTED GUEST
1/18/2023
10:31:03
13XX N 43RD
AVE
Page
of
34
40
202300101332 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
41
5F
DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
1/20/2023
21:08:20
13XX N 43RD
AVE
202300103169 INTERACTION
41
8G
UNWANTED GUEST
1/21/2023
9:07:49
13XX N 43RD
AVE
202300116056 INTERACTION
41
8T
TRESPASSING
1/23/2023
20:10:08
13XX N 43RD
AVE
202300146869 INTERACTION
1091ASSIST MOTORIST
1/29/2023
18:07:22
13XX N 43RD
AVE
202300151529 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
1/30/2023
16:05:14
13XX N 43RD
AVE
202300151894 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
1/30/2023
17:15:58
13XX N 43RD
AVE
202300189824 NO ACTION REQUIRED
41
8T
TRESPASSING
2/6/2023
18:51:14
13XX N 43RD
AVE
202300211929 NO ACTION REQUIRED
41
8T
TRESPASSING
2/10/2023
18:36:34
13XX N 43RD
AVE
202300221294 NO ACTION REQUIRED
239 FIGHT
2/12/2023
13:31:18
13XX N 43RD
AVE
202300235749 INTERACTION
239 FIGHT
2/15/2023
9:15:11
13XX N 43RD
AVE
202300245788 NO ACTION REQUIRED
239 FIGHT
2/17/2023
6:00:38
13XX N 43RD
AVE
202300260804 NO ACTION REQUIRED
927 UNKNOWN TROUBLE
2/19/2023
23:27:30
13XX N 43RD
AVE
202300271266 NO ACTION REQUIRED
41
5F
DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
2/21/2023
22:39:35
13XX N 43RD
AVE
202300289582 NO ACTION REQUIRED
41
8T
TRESPASSING
2/25/2023
9:37:36
13XX N 43RD
AVE
202300319806 INTERACTION
65
1A
INJURED ANIMALS
3/2/2023
23:43:55
13XX N 43RD
AVE
202300368871 NO ACTION REQUIRED
41
5F
DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
3/11/2023
23:17:18
13XX N 43RD
AVE
202300371713 INTERACTION
41
8T
TRESPASSING
3/12/2023
14:58:18
13XX N 43RD
AVE
202300372604 NO ACTION REQUIRED
647 SUSPICIOUS PERSON
3/12/2023
18:27:19
13XX N 43RD
AVE
202300403217 NO ACTION REQUIRED
239 FIGHT
3/18/2023
5:49:24
13XX N 43RD
AVE
202300515301 NO ACTION REQUIRED
911
H
9-1-1 HANG-UP CALL
4/6/2023
22:03:32
13XX N 43RD
AVE
202300520876 NO ACTION REQUIRED
239 FIGHT
4/7/2023
20:36:42
13XX N 43RD
AVE
202300537791 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
41
8T
TRESPASSING
4/10/2023
21:33:45
13XX N 43RD
AVE
202300538269 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
928 FOUND PROPERTY
4/11/2023
0:16:46
13XX N 43RD
AVE
202300571390 INTERACTION
48
7I
STOLEN BICYCLE
4/16/2023
19:01:51
13XX N 43RD
AVE
Page
of
35
40
202300594419 NO ACTION REQUIRED
900 CHECK WELFARE
4/20/2023
18:46:36
13XX N 43RD
AVE
202300597832 NO ACTION REQUIRED
41
5F
DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
4/21/2023
12:28:03
13XX N 43RD
AVE
202300603235 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
90
1H
DEAD BODY
4/22/2023
11:29:10
13XX N 43RD
AVE
202300636345 INTERACTION
41
8T
TRESPASSING
4/28/2023
5:21:30
13XX N 43RD
AVE
202300707680 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
90
1X
SUICIDE ATTEMPT
5/10/2023
14:55:50
13XX N 43RD
AVE
202300723446 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
48
7V
STOLEN VEHICLE
5/13/2023
9:30:19
13XX N 43RD
AVE
202300723793 INTERACTION
41
8T
TRESPASSING
5/13/2023
10:52:46
13XX N 43RD
AVE
202300825276 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
45
9F
BURGLARY FROM
VEHICLE
5/30/2023
22:56:16
13XX N 43RD
AVE
202300825534 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
41
5F
DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
5/31/2023
0:22:15
13XX N 43RD
AVE
202300877260 NO ACTION REQUIRED
41
5F
DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
6/9/2023
4:02:53
13XX N 43RD
AVE
202300879207 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
48
7V
STOLEN VEHICLE
6/9/2023
12:49:39
13XX N 43RD
AVE
202300905160 NO ACTION REQUIRED
45
9F
BURGLARY FROM
VEHICLE
6/14/2023
4:51:33
13XX N 43RD
AVE
202300912361 NO ACTION REQUIRED
48
7V
STOLEN VEHICLE
6/15/2023
10:44:42
13XX N 43RD
AVE
202300950235 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
900 CHECK WELFARE
6/22/2023
7:24:00
13XX N 43RD
AVE
202300975011 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
48
7V
STOLEN VEHICLE
6/26/2023
16:36:03
13XX N 43RD
AVE
202300975091 NO ACTION REQUIRED
48
7V
S
STOLEN VEHICLE
SUPPLEMENT
6/26/2023
16:53:45
13XX N 43RD
AVE
202300997240 NO ACTION REQUIRED
41
5F
DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
6/30/2023
15:30:35
13XX N 43RD
AVE
202301024470 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
711
C
7/5/2023
11:29:06
13XX N 43RD
AVE
202301034694 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
900 CHECK WELFARE
7/7/2023
9:37:08
13XX N 43RD
AVE
202301036039 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
601 MISSING PERSON
7/7/2023
14:13:16
13XX N 43RD
AVE
Extended Stay, 8808 N Black Cyn Hwy, Phoenix, AZ 85051
202300001210 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
211 ARMED ROBBERY
1/1/2023
4:39:35
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300010494 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
418 CIVIL MATTER/STANDBY
1/3/2023
5:44:40
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
Page
of
36
40
202300015604 NO ACTION REQUIRED
647 SUSPICIOUS PERSON
1/4/2023
6:00:33
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300016312 NO ACTION REQUIRED
601 MISSING PERSON
1/4/2023
9:33:36
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300021212 NO ACTION REQUIRED
64
7V
SUSPICIOUS PERSON
IN VEHICLE
1/5/2023
8:36:49
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300022548 INTERACTION
502 JUDICIAL
INTERFERENCE
1/5/2023
13:28:53
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300039347 INTERACTION
647 SUSPICIOUS PERSON
1/8/2023
19:42:11
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300042127 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
41
5B
CRIMINAL DAMAGE
1/9/2023
11:36:49
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300044899 NO ACTION REQUIRED
41
8T
TRESPASSING
1/9/2023
21:03:22
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300052522 ACCIDENT REPORT
961 ACCIDENT NO INJURIES
1/11/2023
12:10:25
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300060622 NO ACTION REQUIRED
647 SUSPICIOUS PERSON
1/12/2023
21:58:53
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300063627 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
49
1A
CUSTODIAL
INTERFERENCE
1/13/2023
14:09:10
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300070615 NO ACTION REQUIRED
647 SUSPICIOUS PERSON
1/14/2023
21:57:29
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300071415 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
240 ASSAULT
1/15/2023
1:30:24
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300091652 NO ACTION REQUIRED
41
8T
TRESPASSING
1/19/2023
6:36:38
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300101149 INTERACTION
41
8T
TRESPASSING
1/20/2023
20:21:40
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300104352 INTERACTION
41
8T
TRESPASSING
1/21/2023
14:01:22
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300116198 INTERACTION
418 CIVIL MATTER/STANDBY
1/23/2023
20:43:31
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300135395 INTERACTION
239 FIGHT
1/27/2023
13:48:59
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300137283 NO ACTION REQUIRED
41
8T
TRESPASSING
1/27/2023
19:44:24
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300155158 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
48
7Y
THEFT OF METAL
1/31/2023
11:20:37
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300155706 NO ACTION REQUIRED
900 CHECK WELFARE
1/31/2023
13:05:41
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300163037 NO ACTION REQUIRED
41
8T
TRESPASSING
2/1/2023
19:12:34
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300164373 NO ACTION REQUIRED
647 SUSPICIOUS PERSON
2/2/2023
2:34:15
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300169120 NO ACTION REQUIRED
60
1F
FOUND MISSING
PERSON
2/2/2023
21:48:58
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300169476 OTHER (SUPP/FALSE
ALARM/FI/LOUD PARTY)
45
9A
BURGLARY ALARM
2/2/2023
23:31:31
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
Page
of
37
40
202300172129 INTERACTION
41
8T
TRESPASSING
2/3/2023
13:49:53
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300173999 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
41
5B
CRIMINAL DAMAGE
2/3/2023
19:37:47
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300177694 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
487 THEFT
2/4/2023
13:21:15
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300181319 INTERACTION
64
7V
SUSPICIOUS PERSON
IN VEHICLE
2/5/2023
3:54:23
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300189828 NO ACTION REQUIRED
487 THEFT
2/6/2023
18:50:39
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300191389 INTERACTION
41
8T
TRESPASSING
2/7/2023
2:49:46
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300202185 NO ACTION REQUIRED
64
7V
SUSPICIOUS PERSON
IN VEHICLE
2/9/2023
1:59:07
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300202819 NO ACTION REQUIRED
41
8T
TRESPASSING
2/9/2023
7:46:01
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300247657 NO ACTION REQUIRED
961 ACCIDENT NO INJURIES
2/17/2023
13:51:04
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300249723 INTERACTION
41
8G
UNWANTED GUEST
2/17/2023
20:10:38
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300262547 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
60
1J
MISSING JUVENILE
2/20/2023
10:42:30
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300262787 INTERACTION
240 ASSAULT
2/20/2023
11:31:12
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300265482 INTERACTION
60
1F
FOUND MISSING
PERSON
2/20/2023
20:53:20
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300269176 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
48
7V
STOLEN VEHICLE
2/21/2023
15:05:59
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300273596 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
45
9C
BURGLARY
COMMERCIAL
2/22/2023
10:31:05
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300275114 NO ACTION REQUIRED
45
9C
S
BURGLARY
COMMERCIAL
SUPPLEMENT
2/22/2023
15:23:10
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300276586 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
2/22/2023
20:37:49
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300277305 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
2/23/2023
0:46:07
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300287599 NO ACTION REQUIRED
65
1A
INJURED ANIMALS
2/24/2023
21:16:42
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300290290 INTERACTION
41
7G
SUBJECT WITH A GUN
2/25/2023
12:23:51
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300326018 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
240 ASSAULT
3/4/2023
7:37:19
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300348370 ACCIDENT REPORT
961 ACCIDENT NO INJURIES
3/8/2023
10:59:12
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300384460 INTERACTION
41
8T
TRESPASSING
3/14/2023
19:38:02
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
Page
of
38
40
202300404796 NO ACTION REQUIRED
41
8T
TRESPASSING
3/18/2023
13:07:14
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300408466 NO ACTION REQUIRED
45
9A
BURGLARY ALARM
3/19/2023
3:42:53
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300421454 NO ACTION REQUIRED
45
9C
S
BURGLARY
COMMERCIAL
SUPPLEMENT
3/21/2023
14:48:05
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300436004 NO ACTION REQUIRED
239 FIGHT
3/24/2023
3:52:25
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300487319 NO ACTION REQUIRED
900 CHECK WELFARE
4/1/2023
23:33:11
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300500780 NO ACTION REQUIRED
647 SUSPICIOUS PERSON
4/4/2023
13:08:10
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300512917 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
41
8G
UNWANTED GUEST
4/6/2023
14:49:55
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300557113 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
901 INJURED/SICK PERSON
4/14/2023
6:08:28
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300621552 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
487 THEFT
4/25/2023
16:37:33
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300644388 INTERACTION
45
9R
BURGLARY
RESIDENTIAL
4/29/2023
12:40:03
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300644853 INTERACTION
41
8G
UNWANTED GUEST
4/29/2023
14:18:38
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300692052 NO ACTION REQUIRED
41
5F
DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
5/7/2023
21:18:53
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300694049 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
45
9C
BURGLARY
COMMERCIAL
5/8/2023
9:34:26
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300706345 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
5/10/2023
11:12:11
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300721512 NO ACTION REQUIRED
64
7V
SUSPICIOUS PERSON
IN VEHICLE
5/12/2023
21:46:42
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300750313 INTERACTION
418 CIVIL MATTER/STANDBY
5/18/2023
0:25:28
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300753063 INTERACTION
1052MISDEMEANOR
WARRANT
OUTSTANDING
5/18/2023
13:07:29
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300758041 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
41
5F
DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
5/19/2023
10:13:23
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300773532 NO ACTION REQUIRED
41
5F
DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
5/22/2023
2:01:34
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300775936 INTERACTION
41
8T
TRESPASSING
5/22/2023
12:57:15
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300778215 INTERACTION
41
8T
TRESPASSING
5/22/2023
19:47:17
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300798059 NO ACTION REQUIRED
647 SUSPICIOUS PERSON
5/26/2023
6:51:28
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300819275 NO ACTION REQUIRED
601 MISSING PERSON
5/29/2023
23:47:21
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
Page
of
39
40
202300825527 NO ACTION REQUIRED
1076NOTIFY OWNER OF
VEHICLE RECOVERY
5/31/2023
0:15:56
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300841582 NO ACTION REQUIRED
41
8T
TRESPASSING
6/2/2023
20:00:55
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300888964 NO ACTION REQUIRED
647 SUSPICIOUS PERSON
6/11/2023
5:28:19
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300895050 INTERACTION
418 CIVIL MATTER/STANDBY
6/12/2023
10:47:26
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300929934 INTERACTION
911
H
9-1-1 HANG-UP CALL
6/18/2023
15:10:06
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300962549 NO ACTION REQUIRED
41
8T
TRESPASSING
6/24/2023
10:11:49
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300966703 INTERACTION
239 FIGHT
6/25/2023
0:59:42
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300972288 NO ACTION REQUIRED
647 SUSPICIOUS PERSON
6/26/2023
6:19:25
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300975943 NO ACTION REQUIRED
64
7V
SUSPICIOUS PERSON
IN VEHICLE
6/26/2023
19:48:34
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300992336 ACCIDENT REPORT
961 ACCIDENT NO INJURIES
6/29/2023
17:49:59
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202301011963 NO ACTION REQUIRED
41
8G
UNWANTED GUEST
7/3/2023
9:59:06
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202301013854 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
900 CHECK WELFARE
7/3/2023
16:17:57
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202301019804 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
91
8T
MENTALLY ILL SUBJECT
TRANSPORT
7/4/2023
17:39:57
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202301031516 INTERACTION
647 SUSPICIOUS PERSON
7/6/2023
17:21:49
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202301035017 NO ACTION REQUIRED
96
1H
HIT & RUN ACCIDENT
NO INJURY
7/7/2023
10:45:58
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202301048186 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
7/9/2023
21:45:00
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202301050716 NO ACTION REQUIRED
900 CHECK WELFARE
7/10/2023
12:14:07
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202301082386 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
647 SUSPICIOUS PERSON
7/16/2023
9:12:23
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
Page
of
40
40
From:
jamie notallheroes.org
To:
Taylor, Matthew; Perry, Tabitha
Subject:
Fw: My Unanswered Questions
Date:
Thursday, August 17, 2023 3:20:39 PM
Attachments:
image001.png
Good Afternoon,
In addition to my previously submitted email, I am requesting the email communication
below be included in the Planning Commissioner packet.
Thank you,
Jamie
From: Taylor, Matthew <MTaylor@GLENDALEAZ.com>
Sent: Monday, August 14, 2023 10:58 AM
To: jamie notallheroes.org <jamie@notallheroes.org>
Cc: Perry, Tabitha <TPerry@GLENDALEAZ.com>
Subject: RE: My Unanswered Questions
Good morning Jamie,
All the questions posed in your message were asked during the August 7, 2023, public meeting
facilitated by Councilmember Malnar’s office – answers to these questions regarding the Modern
Stay-StayAPT project are integrated into your original email message of August 8, 2023 (see below in
red italics). As stated during the meeting, all ground-up projects go through a major design review
application process by the city’s project team.
Feel free to reach out with additional questions.
Thank you.
From: jamie notallheroes.org <jamie@notallheroes.org>
Sent: Thursday, August 10, 2023 12:17 PM
To: Taylor, Matthew <MTaylor@GLENDALEAZ.com>
Cc: Perry, Tabitha <TPerry@GLENDALEAZ.com>
Subject: Re: My Unanswered Questions
Good Afternoon Mr. Taylor,
I would appreciate an email response so I have the answers in writing. If that is not an
option, then please let me know why.
Thanks,
Jamie
From: Taylor, Matthew <MTaylor@GLENDALEAZ.com>
Sent: Wednesday, August 9, 2023 3:13 PM
To: jamie notallheroes.org <jamie@notallheroes.org>
Cc: Perry, Tabitha <TPerry@GLENDALEAZ.com>
Subject: RE: My Unanswered Questions
Good afternoon,
We are glad to discuss your concerns via phone call, as this would be a more efficient use of time
than addressing each topic in a series of email messages. Please give me a call at your convenience
(direct line below) or I can call you at 623.326.8219 if that is a good number.
Thank you.
From: jamie notallheroes.org <jamie@notallheroes.org>
Sent: Tuesday, August 8, 2023 10:12 AM
To: Taylor, Matthew <MTaylor@GLENDALEAZ.com>; Perry, Tabitha <TPerry@GLENDALEAZ.com>
Subject: My Unanswered Questions
Good Morning Mr. Taylor and Ms. Perry,
Again, thank you for your time last night. I do have multiple questions that we
unanswered last night that I would appreciate answers from the business owner. If I
need to reach out to someone else, please let me know.
1. Will StayApt have lighted signage such as a backlit logo on the building or a
separate standing sign? If yes, how tall will this be? If yes, what is the lumens of
this logo or signage?
Signs and lighting are evaluated during the design review application process for compliance
with city requirements.
2. Will there be fencing around the StayApt parking lot?
The applicant has not identified perimeter fencing on the conceptual site plan. Site fencing
will be evaluated during the design review application process.
3. Will they install a privacy fence to reduce down on noise into the neighborhood?
Perimeter fencing will be evaluated during the design review process for compliance with city
requirements.
4. I asked for the Franchise Disclosure Documents, can you please have it sent to me
by the builder?
Please direct this question to the applicant: Tiffany & Bosco, PA, Attn: Shaine Alleman,
sta@tblaw.com / 602.255.6000.
5. How will StayApt ensure the privacy of the homeowners whose backyards are
within view of the guest rooms? Will they provide privacy shutters in their building?
Please direct this question to the applicant: Tiffany & Bosco, PA, Attn: Shaine Alleman,
sta@tblaw.com / 602.255.6000.
6. What will the average room rate be during our slow season? What will the average
room rate be during our business season?
Please direct this question to the applicant: Tiffany & Bosco, PA, Attn: Shaine Alleman,
sta@tblaw.com / 602.255.6000.
7. What type of security beyond key cards and a camera system will StayApt provide
for the community against potential criminal activity?
Please direct this question to the applicant: Tiffany & Bosco, PA, Attn: Shaine Alleman,
sta@tblaw.com / 602.255.6000.
8. Where will the garbage dumpsters be located on the property? What will be done
to reduce the potential noise of dumping the garbage? How many dumpsters will
the client have and how often will they be dumped?
Currently, dumpster placement is proposed at the west side of the building. Dumpster
location and enclosure will be evaluated during the design review process for compliance
with city requirements.
9. How does StayApt plan on conserving water?
Please direct this question to the applicant: Tiffany & Bosco, PA, Attn: Shaine Alleman,
sta@tblaw.com / 602.255.6000.
10. Will StayApt have electric vehicle parking? How will the charging occur? A
generator? Will this take a regular parking spot? How will they reduce the noise
from the diesel fuel generator?
Please direct this question to the applicant: Tiffany & Bosco, PA, Attn: Shaine Alleman,
sta@tblaw.com / 602.255.6000. If provided, vehicle charging areas, along with required on-
site vehicle parking, will be evaluated during the design review process for compliance with
city requirements.
11. Does StayApt have contracts with our local hospitals for housing with their staff? If
yes, what is the contract nightly rate?
Please direct this question to the applicant: Tiffany & Bosco, PA, Attn: Shaine Alleman,
sta@tblaw.com / 602.255.6000.
12. Does StayApt have a government/military contract to provide housing for our
military that is stationed at Luke Air Force Base which is over 15 miles away?
Please direct this question to the applicant: Tiffany & Bosco, PA, Attn: Shaine Alleman,
sta@tblaw.com / 602.255.6000.
13. Currently, businesses do not have enough parking, and street parking if often
utilized. Where will additional vehicle park if the StayApt parking lot is full?
On-site parking is required for this project. Street parking along San Camino Xavier will not be
permitted.
14. Where will semis and trucks with trailers park as they may not be able to turn
around in the proposed lot?
On-site parking is required for this project. Street parking along San Camino Xavier will not be
permitted.
15. Is there an environmental impact study available on how dangerous this building
will be for our local wildlife such as our coyotes, owls, snakes, etc?
The city does not have an EIS requirement for this project.
16. What are the mitigations of the stormwater? Our neighborhood often floods during
intensive storms. Will the flood plan push the water into our neighborhood or the
surrounding businesses?
Stormwater mitigation will be evaluated during the design review application process for
compliance with city requirements.
17. We heard loud and clear that the building is secure with keys and cameras. As a
neighbor of this building, my concern is the safety of my children and
grandchildren from this building. What safety will be in place to protect the
community members?
Please direct this question to the applicant: Tiffany & Bosco, PA, Attn: Shaine Alleman,
sta@tblaw.com / 602.255.6000. Nothing suggests hazardous conditions warrant additional
safety measures for this project.
18. Will the builder decrease the number of rooms to provide the allowance on the
property for installing the proper size trees to provide security and privacy to the
neighbors? The neighbors are not able to fund the maintenance of the trees and it
is unfair to require the homeowners to pay for privacy!
Landscaping will be evaluated during the design review application process for compliance
with city requirements.
19. What landscaping lights will be included? What are the lumens of these lights?
Landscaping and lighting are evaluated during the design review application process for
compliance with city requirements.
20. Will there be backlighting on the extended stay hotel? What are the lumens of
these lights?
Signs and lighting are evaluated during the design review application process for compliance
with city requirements.
My questions for the City of Glendale are the following...
1. How will the City of Glendale address the additional traffic turning off 75th Avenue
onto Camino San Xavier? My concern is that if there are more than 3 vehicles
turning off 75th Avenue then they will block a lane of southbound travel. If most of
the traffic returns to the hotel around 5 pm or 6 pm with at least 50 vehicles that is
a significant increase of traffic coming off 75th avenue.
The applicant provided a traffic statement to the city. Based on trip counts, street
improvements are not required for this project.
2. Will the City of Glendale provide additional signage in the Secluded Acres
neighborhood at the entrance saying "Not a Thru Street" to reduce the potential
lost travelers who may attempt to utilize the 73rd Avene roadway to gain access?
73rd Avenue will not extend north into Secluded Estates/Secluded Acres.
3. Will the City of Glendale install ADA approved sidewalks on Camino San Xavier to
reduce the risk of accidents with walkers?
Sidewalks and ADA accessible curbs are required for this project.
4. Will the City of Glendale re-do Camino San Xavier to remove the potholes and
install additional lighting and signage for the extended stay apt?
You can submit a Glendale One service request regarding improvements to Camino San
Xavier: Request for Service - GlendaleOne.
5. Will the City of Glendale be increasing the number of police officers to
accommodate the extended stay apt reports and crimes?
Nothing suggests hazardous conditions warrant elevated safety measures for this project.
I appreciate your time and assistance.
Thank you,
Jamie
August 10, 2023
City of Glendale Planning Commission
5850 W. Glendale Avenue
Glendale, AZ 85301
RE: OBJECTION to CUP23-04 - Modern StayApt
Dear Commissioners,
My name is Jamie Kelly. I am a lifelong resident born and raised in Glendale and have called the
neighborhood of Secluded Acres my home since 2017. I am writing to request that the Planning
Commission understands how CUP 23-04 Modern StayApt would be detrimental to the health, safety,
and general welfare of those who live and work near the proposed site. Between the nature of this
proposed hotel plus the types of criminal behavior, dangerous activities like human and sex
trafficking, and additional traffic as well as concerns about the builder's honesty which is
detailed in this report, please vote no on CUP 23-04 - Modern StayApt located at 73rd Avenue and
West Camino San Xavier which is just south of my neighborhood.
I am a wife, mother, and grandmother who absolutely loves and adores my family, neighborhood,
community, and country. When my husband and I made the decision to move into the quiet
neighborhood of Secluded Acres, I believe it was the best decision for our family. Now my husband and
I have invested our time and energy into our community. My husband served for 23 years in the City of
Glendale as a Police Officer. I have been active with non-profit community organizations and served on
a Glendale commission and an Arizona state board.
In the following pages, you will read my research and insight on why I am asking you to vote NO on the
CUP 23-04 - Modern StayApt. A hotel in this lot does not make sense for the builder, the community,
and Glendale. My concerns about this Modern StayApt include criminal activity such as human and sex
trafficking, drugs, kidnapping, rape, and murder as property crimes like vehicle theft, burglary, and retail
theft. In reviewing the data, it is very clear that these types of hotel venues do not provide a service to
the community but rather a burden on the community, law enforcement, and fire service and create a
negative influence of crime in a community. Please read through the research and statements I have
collected to show you how the Modern StayApt will be destructive to our community.
The idea of a hotel that does not provide security or validate those who are renting a room provides
significant concerns for safety to those who live and shop near this proposed site. This hotel would be
less than a 1/2 mile from a program that provides services to individuals with physical and mental
disabilities as well as a rehabilitation center. I am asking you to think of the potential risks of having a
hotel that does not verify the identification of guests and would open the door for criminals like
registered sex offenders to have easy access to a school bus stop, an organization for those with
disabilities, and near a mall and shopping centers.
I appreciate your time and consideration. Again, I am asking you to vote NO to the CUP 23-04 - Modern
StayApt. Please help me protect my family and community from the criminal activity brought on
by extended stay-type hotels.
Respectfully,
Jamie Kelly
Page of
1
40
In this document, you will see my research, the connection, and truth about the proposed
StayApt, and requested stipulations if you do decide to vote yes. Again, my request is that you
vote no on CUP 23-04 Modern Stay Apt.
Safety & Security
Since we moved into our forever home in 2017, we have had a few incidents that brought concerns
about safety. One night while my husband was on duty with the Glendale Police Department a man
tried the front door of my home while I was home alone. He tried the door handle, kicking the door and
hitting the windows. Thankfully Glendale Police Department arrived and ensured my safety. However,
the man was never located. Another early morning after my husband finished his shift and parked his
police motorcycle in our garage, a man entered our garage and attempted to steal from us. These types
of crimes are only on the rise with the increase of homeless and drug addicts who are utilizing the wash
that runs between our neighborhood and the neighborhood to the east.
My number one concern is that this type of hotel will bring additional unwanted criminal behavior. I do
understand that the hotel will have a secure facility with key cards and restricted access inside the
venue however that does not protect the community. I reviewed the website for StayApt and booked a
reservation at another location. Never once in the process was my state-issued identification required. I
would be provided with a digital key and would not be required to interact with a staff member
to confirm my identification or check-in. This provides significant concern that the venue would not
have knowledge of who is actually on their property.
A 2016 article written by DolanDobrinsky Rosenbaum Bluestein, LLP titled “Hotel Security and Crime”
stated that annually there are more than 53,000 crimes that happen at hotels. In this article, they
1
stated that insufficient security surveillance and personnel to properly monitor the hotel activity is when
the crime occurs. This proposed StayApt has clearly stated they will not have security personnel on the
property and will depend on the Glendale Police Department for response to their criminal activity.
** Requested Stipulation: Require the StayApt to provide 24-hour staffing that would mandate
the employee must be awake during their work hours. Not just a general manager who lives on-
site but rather employees who are awake and working.
** Additional Requested Stipulation: Required StayApt to provide security staff who will be on-
site to conduct property walks to reduce criminal behavior and monitor the security cameras.
AND/OR
** Additional Requested Stipulation: Required StayApt to hire a security company that will
provide security checks of the property at least every four hours.
As you may know, human and sex trafficking is one of the top dangers in Arizona. The Phoenix area
including Glendale is the capital of kidnapping in America and only second in the world to Mexico City.
According to Former Attorney General Mark Brnovich in the Human Trafficking: Not Buying It
publication, the average age of entry into the sex trade in Arizona is 14 years old. Law enforcement has
Hotel security and crime, accessed August 10, 2023, https://www.ddrlawyers.com/blog/hotel-
1
security-and-crime/
Page of
2
40
seen girls as young as 9 sold for sex. In the article “In Harm’s Way: How Systems Fail Human
2
Trafficking Survivors”, one survivor stated,
“My debit card was frequently used to purchase hotel rooms in my name. My pimp/ trafficker
would send me the funds that I earned that he was keeping through Cash App. I used a fake ID
with my real name to buy the rooms alongside the debit card. (Since hotels require you to be 21
and I was only 19, he gave me fake IDs to use). He put it in my name to maintain his privacy
from any potential law enforcement situations at the hotel.”3
According to a 2018 Polaris Survivor Survey, more than 60% of sex-trafficking victims were forced to
sell sex from hotels. In the 2021 Federal Human Trafficking Report, 80% of the sex trafficking acts took
4
place at a hotel. In the 2022 Federal Human Trafficking Report, of the 178 new federal criminal cases,
5
20% of new federal trafficking cases involved a completed sex act that occurred in a hotel. Of these
6
cases, the following hotels were reported:
2 Case - Hampton Inn
2 Cases - Days Inn
1 Case - Comfort Inn Suites
1 Case - Budget Suites
1 Case - Springhill Suites
1 Case - Homewood Inn and Suites
1 Case - Extended Stay America
In the community presentation on August 7,
2023, the builder of the proposed StayApt
compared themselves to several hotels
including Homewood Suites and Comfort Inn
Suites. Below is a photo from their
presentation. If StayApt is comparable by
their definitions to two of these hotels that
have been reported to have human and sex
trafficking, then what kind of criminal
activity will StayApt attract to our quiet
community?
Human Trafficking; Not Buying It, accessed August 10, 2023, https://www.azag.gov/sites/default/
2
files/publications/2018-06/Human_Trafficking_Not_Buying_It.pdf
In Harms Way: How Systems Fail Human Trafficking Survivors, accessed August 10, 2023, https://
3
polarisproject.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/07/In-Harms-Way-How-Systems-Fail-Human-Trafficking-
Survivors-by-Polaris-modifed-June-2023.pdf.
Should Hotel Chains Be Held Liable for Human Trafficking?, accessed August 10, 2023, https://
4
www.newyorker.com/news/a-reporter-at-large/should-hotel-chains-be-held-liable-for-human-
trafficking.
What happened to the woman in the hotel room next door?, accessed August 10, 2023, https://
5
www.nytimes.com/2023/03/17/travel/hotels-sex-trafficking-violence-crime.html
2022 Federal Human Trafficking Report, accessed August 10, 2023, https://traffickinginstitute.org/
6
wp-content/uploads/2023/06/2022-Federal-Human-Trafficking-Report-WEB-
Spreads_compressed.pdf
Page of
3
40
In Ohio, more than 40 lawsuits were filed by human trafficking victims against hotels including
Wyndham Hotels, Choices Hotels, and Red Roof Inns. In Georgia, on July 27, 2023, a hotel clerk was
7
convicted and sentenced to 15 years in prison for facilitating the human trafficking of a juvenile victim.
8
In 2022, a multiple-agency operation arrested 29
suspects in a human and sex trafficking ring. This
operation was led by the Phoenix Police Department
Human Exploitation and Trafficking unit along with Mesa,
Chandler, Scottsdale, Glendale, and Surprise Police
Departments along with the Arizona Department of
Public Safety, FBI, and the Arizona Attorney General’s
office.9
In May 2023, a man was arrested in Phoenix at a local
hotel for child sex trafficking and kidnapping.10
According to the A Roadmap for Systems and Industries
to Prevent and Disrupt Human Trafficking report dated
July 2018,
“Since the beginning of the National Human
Trafficking Hotline in December 2007 through
December 31, 2017, the Hotline has recorded 3,596
cases of human trafficking involving a hotel or motel.
Furthermore, 75 percent of survivors in the Polaris
survey reported coming into contact with hotels at
some point during their trafficking situation. This
means traffickers in all 50 states are taking
advantage of unwitting hotel franchisees and relying
on them to help facilitate their illicit businesses.”11
According to Former Attorney General Mark Brnovich,
the safety of our children begins at home in their own
neighborhoods. He encouraged parents and neighbors to
work collectively to make sure their children are safe.
This is the call to help us protect our children and
More than 40 human trafficking lawsuits filed against hotel companies, accessed August 10, 2023,
7
https://www.10tv.com/article/news/local/more-than-40-human-trafficking-lawsuits-filed-hotel-
companies/530-b0c54a7c-6fe0-4d5d-800f-a3e8a89d3bba
Carr: Hotel Clerk, Convicted, Sentenced to 15 years in Prison for Facilitating Human Trafficking,
8
accessed August 11, 2023, https://law.georgia.gov/press-releases/2023-07-27/carr-hotel-clerk-
convicted-sentenced-15-years-prison-facilitating-human
29 arrested in HSI Phoenix, multiagency operation targeting alleged child sex and human traffickers,
9
accessed August 10, 2023, https://www.ice.gov/news/releases/29-arrested-hsi-phoenix-multiagency-
operation-targeting-alleged-child-sex-and-human
Man arrested after possible kidnapping at Phoenix hotel, accessed August 11, 2023, https://
10
www.12news.com/article/news/crime/kidnapping-phoenix-hotel-man-arrested/
75-84f31c00-087b-4f69-9572-cd23c63ea06e
A Roadmap for Systems and Industries to Prevent and Disrupt Human Trafficking, accessed August
11
9, 2023, https://polarisproject.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/08/A-Roadmap-for-Systems-and-
Industries-to-Prevent-and-Disrupt-Human-Trafficking-Hotels-and-Motels.pdf
Page of
4
40
grandchildren from human trafficking by saying no to the StayApt CPU.
Many hotel chains and franchises require their staff to complete an initial new hire training and then
annual refresher training on human trafficking related to victim identification, warning signs, and
reporting procedures. At this time StayApt does not demonstrate on their website that they require nor
provide any training on human trafficking.
The applicant has expressed that they will not put up fencing around the property nor will they provide
fencing to prevent direct access into the neighborhood. This fence would reduce access to the middle
school bus stop at 73rd Avenue just north of the proposed hotel. This would create a barrier to reduce
the risk of kidnapping or sexual assault of those who live or shop near the hotel.
**Requested Stipulation: Require the builder to conduct new hires and annual training on
human trafficking.
In June 2023, the City of Scottsdale approved a grant of $940,000 to house homeless and illegal
immigrants at hotels located in Scottsdale. Although the details of the hotel location are confidential,
12
two of the area hotels include Staybridge Suites and Comfort Inn Suites. StayApt compared themselves
to Comfort Suites and Staybridge Suites in their community presentation. The idea that within 300 ft of
my neighborhood could potential housing be provided to homeless and illegal immigrants through a
grant program is troublesome. Compassion is incredible however there are other options. The concern
is if StayApt does not have the occupancy they need to pay their bills would they seek relief options like
a grant from the State of Arizona to provide housing?
Tobacco & Drugs
At the community meeting, I asked the builder where the guests will be permitted to smoke either
tobacco or marijuana as Arizona is a recreational marijuana state. The builder stated that they are a
non-smoking facility which means guests will be required to walk off the property to smoke either
tobacco or marijuana. The options then become to walk into the neighborhood, walk on the walking
path containing natural landscaping that is highly flammable, or onto the property of the other business
owners. This provides significant concerns to the homeowners as the concerns of smelling the smoke,
a fire starting due to tossing cigarettes, and the trash of tossed cigarettes or other products.
** Requested Stipulation: Require the builder to modify their plans to include a smoking area
with proper disposal containers for smoking trash to protect the environment and reduce the
risk of fire or other issues.
Drug activity is already increasing in the area due to the homeless and addicts. In 2020, at a North
Phoenix hotel, a man was arrested for possession of 77 lbs of meth that was packaged for sale along
with $8,000 in cash. In October 2022, a minor was hospitalized after becoming unresponsive due to
13
Scottsdale expands housing for migrants, homeless from ‘The Zone’, accessed August 10, 2023,
12
https://www.azfamily.com/2023/07/04/scottsdale-expands-housing-migrants-homeless-zone/
PD: Drug mule arrested at north PHX hotel with $100,000 of meth, accessed August 14, 2023,
13
https://www.abc15.com/news/crime/pd-drug-mule-arrested-at-north-phx-hotel-with-100-000-of-meth
Page of
5
40
drugs in a hotel room in Surprise. In March 2022, a Prescott Valley man was arrested on drug
14
charges at a local hotel that offers a similar rate to StayApt.15
Criminal Activity
Extended stay-type hotels bring additional criminal activity to their communities. As we in Secluded
Acres have watched the criminal activity increase, the idea of a hotel that targets a transient population
creates additional burdens on us as homeowners and visitors in our area like Arrowhead Mall and the
shopping centers near the hotel. My husband refers to them as crimes of convenience but to most, they
are known as vehicle or home break-ins and/or theft. This hotel will be a draw for more of these crimes
of convenience.
I have included the criminal activity of another StayApt location in TN to demonstrate how similar the
activity is to that of other extended stay-type venues. I have also included the criminal activity of other
extended stay venues in the Phoenix metro area. This information demonstrates the following:
• There will be an increase in criminal activity from this venue that will be detrimental to the
health, safety, and general welfare of the community including the residents of Secluded Acres
and other neighborhoods nearby as well as the businesses.
•Regardless of the proposed safety features of the StayApt, they do not provide adequate
security for their clients, neighborhood residents, and business owners.
•This venue will provide a substantial burden on the Glendale Police Department with an
increase in calls for service, investigations, and arrests.
•This venue will provide a substantial burden on the Glendale Judicial System with an increase
in case prosecution.
In an article on eHotelier, they highlight eight key elements to determine if a hotel will be a hot spot for
criminal activity and the proposed StayApt location will be a hot spot for criminal activity.
16
1. The residential and activity locations are predisposed offender populations.
2. The residential and activity locations of vulnerable populations.
3. The spatial and temporal distribution of different forms of security and guardianship.
4. The broader residential and activity structure of the city.
5. The mix of activity types and land uses.
6. The modes of transport and structure of the transport network.
7. The actual transportation flows of people through the city’s infrastructure.
8. The timescape we are living in.
It should be noted that often times drug and human traffickers will move their business from their
homes and vehicles into hotel rooms because of the offender’s asset forfeiture and seizure laws.
17
Arizona law enforcement is already burdened with the increase in human and drug trafficking that is
Minor hospitalized, woman arrested after police find drugs in Surprise hotel room, accessed August
14
14, 2023, https://www.abc15.com/news/region-west-valley/surprise/minor-hospitalized-woman-
arrested-after-police-find-drugs-in-surprise-hotel-room
Prescott Valley man arrested on drug charges at an area hotel, accessed August 14, 2023https://
15
gcmaz.com/kaff_news/prescott-valley-man-arrested-on-drug-charges-at-an-area-hotel/
Understanding crime patterns and hotspots in context of hotel security, accessed August 10, 2023,
16
https://insights.ehotelier.com/insights/2021/02/19/understanding-crime-patterns-and-hotspots-in-the-
context-of-hotel-security-design/
Hotel Motel Interdiction, accessed August 8, 2023, https://hampton.gov/757/Hotel-Motel-
17
Interdiction
Page of
6
40
occurring due to the border, cartels, and more. The increase in crime due to the proposed StayApt will
place an undo burden and would be detrimental to the health, safety, and welfare of those living and
working near the proposed location.
Privacy
When the applicant presented to the community on Monday, August 7, 2023, they stated in their
presentation that the neighborhood was over a half mile away. (Photograph is below of their
presentation.) This is an incorrect statement as the closest home is only 260 feet away and a half
mile is 2,640 feet. The hotel would be less than 500 feet from a middle school bus stop and less than a
mile from an elementary school.
The 2nd/3rd-floor rooms would have a direct line of sight into the backyards and homes that are less
than 300 feet away. For myself, the idea that some random person staying in a hotel would have a clear
line of sight into my house or backyard where my children and grandchildren play creates a very
uncomfortable sense of fear for safety in my own home. The applicant has offered to pay for trees to be
purchased by the homeowners for their privacy. This would require a future expense for homeowners of
water and maintenance that could be extremely costly to the homeowner. In addition, there are
overhead power lines that would restrict the approved height these trees could grow to and create
additional problems for the homeowner. There are also concerns about the roots of the trees causing
issues with the homeowners’ fencing and pools. The solution of trees for privacy in the homeowners’
property is just not acceptable for these homeowners.
Requested Stipulation: Require the builder during initial construction to install proper exterior
window coverings to ensure the privacy of the backyards or homes located in Secluded Acres.
The justification for this modification is based on the visibility of young children and women from the
view of the hotel rooms. As we know sex assault crimes are committed by men and women of all ages
in all industries and professions. The modification to the window coverings would provide additional
security and safety for those staying in the hotel and living near the property.
Page of
7
40
Hotel Security & Staff
In researching StayApt, according to their LinkedIn jobs page as well as other job pages, they do not
mention a requirement to pass a background check or sex offender registry check. This provides
significant concerns that they will not properly screen staff to ensure protection from criminals working
and/or living at the hotel. From the jobs posted the consistent rate of pay is listed at $14 per hour for
most staff and the Assistant General Manager is at $16 per hour. These hourly rates are consistent with
what Extended Stay and Budget Suites
pays their employees.
During the Community Meeting, the
builder expressed that they will have
minimal staff with a general manager
who lives on-site and housekeeping
staff. In preparation for my letter to the
City, I called multiple StayApt locations
to speak to someone at the front desk.
The calls were placed at various hours
(9 am, 2 pm, 6 pm, and 11 pm) to a
variety of locations, and with each call
regardless of the time of day, no one
answered the phone, several voicemails
were full and no one returned my calls.
As a potential consumer of the StayApt
locations and a resident who lives within a 1/2 mile of the proposed location, the lack of accessibility to
the staff creates significant concern.
Page of
8
40
The builder expressed that they will have security cameras however without 24/7 monitoring these
cameras will only record criminal behavior but will not prevent crimes.
Requested Stipulation: StayApt is required to provide access to the City of Glendale Police
Department for the StayApt camera system to be connected with the Real Time Crime Center.
However, again this places the burden of safety and security on the Glendale Police Department and
not StayApt.
Pricing
It is important to note that trafficking and crime are not limited to budget hotels, but rather venues that
are understaffed and often distracted. The applicant presented that the room rate would be $166 a
night. However, in reviewing the StayApt website to review the other 14 StayApt hotel locations in the
United States, the average room rate for August 10th was $120.79 per night. The concern as a
community member is that the builder is demonstrating their lack of honesty on the pricing
structure and will be a lower-priced hotel similar to the extended stay or budget-type facility. For
these other locations, it is currently their peak season like we will have around the holidays and into the
spring. This creates a significant concern that the slow season rates will be below $100 a night and
some nights may even drop to below $80 a night. This creates a comparable rate to an Extended Stay
or Budget Suite type hotel. A table is below to show the room takes for the StayApt locations and then
the pricing of other hotels near the proposed site.
The screenshot below is from the StayApt website showing pricing for their San Antonio-Lackland
location to show you the pricing from their other locations.
StayApt Rates
Room Rates for August 10, 2023 to August 11, 2023
Hotel Name
Address
Room Rate
per Night
StayApt - San Antonio-Randolph 7645 N Loop 1604 E., Live Oak, Texas 78233
$99.00
Page of
9
40
StayApt - San Antonio-Lackland
9923 Ingram Road, San Antonio, Texas 78245
$134.00
StayApt - Rock Hill
840 Patriot Parkway, Rock Hill, South Carolina 29730
$109.00
StayApt - Greenville/Greer
1455 Hwy 101 South, Greer, South Carolina 29651
$139.00
StayApt - Alexandria
8849 Richmond Hwy, Alexandria, Virginia 22309
$154.00
StayApt - Houston
1566 Live Oak Street, Webster, Texas 77598
$109.00
StayApt - Chattanooga-
Oolte ah
6046 Relocation Way, Ooltewah, Tennessee 37363
$119.00
StayApt - Greenville/Haywood
85 Mall Connector Road, Greenville, South Carolina
29607
$124.00
StayApt - Columbia
851 Columbiana Drive, Irmo, South Carolina 29063
$104.00
stayAPT - Raleigh-Durham
1009 Lower Shiloh Way, Morrisville, North Carolina
27560
$114.00
StayApt - Goldsboro
1001 Sunburst Drive, Goldsboro, North Carolina
27534
$124.00
StayApt - Montgomery
5000 Woodmere Blvd, Montgomery, Alabama 36106
$104.00
StayApt - Huntsville
210 West Park Loop NW, Huntsville, Alabama 35806
$144.00
StayApt - Dothan
259 Hospitality Lane, Dothan, Alabama 36303
$114.00
Other Similar Hotels
Residence Inn - Peoria
8435 West Paradise Lane, Peoria, Arizona 85382 USA
$156.00
Springhill Suites - Peoria
7810 West Bell Road, Glendale, Arizona 85308 USA
$126.00
Hampton Inn - Peoria
8408 W Paradise Ln, Peoria, AZ 85382
$103.00
Holiday Inn Express - Peoria
16771 N. 84th Ave., Peoria, AZ
$99.00
Comfort Suites
8473 West Paradise Ln., Peoria, AZ, 85382
$86.00
Page
of
10
40
StayApt - TN, 6046 Relocation Way, Ooltewah, Tennessee 37363
Date_Incident
Incident_Description
Incident_Ty
pe
Case_Num
ber
Case_Status_Descri
ption
05/15/2023 10:20:00
PM
Miscellaneous Information
23-051373
Pending/Possible
Leads
04/17/2023 3:06:00
PM
Property Lost
23-039894
Pending/Possible
Leads
04/17/2023 10:31:00
AM
Miscellaneous Information
23-039770
Pending/Possible
Leads
04/14/2023 11:25:00
AM
False Pretense/Swindle/Confidence
Game
Part 1
Crimes
23-040991
Pending/Possible
Leads
04/13/2023 6:10:00
PM
Serving Warrant
23-038438
Cleared by Arrest
04/13/2023 6:00:00
PM
Miscellaneous Information
23-038415
Pending/Possible
Leads
04/13/2023 1:15:00
PM
Suspicious Activity
23-038313
Pending/Possible
Leads
04/03/2023 3:00:00
PM
Damaged Property Accidental
23-034765
Pending/Possible
Leads
04/01/2023 12:00:00
AM
Property Lost
23-052952
Pending/Possible
Leads
02/28/2023 12:00:00
PM
Worthless Checks
Part 2
Crimes
23-031877
Pending/Possible
Leads
01/30/2023 1:31:00
PM
Field Interview
23-010517
Pending/Possible
Leads
01/27/2023 9:35:00
PM
All Other Offenses
Part 2
Crimes
23-009617
Cleared by Arrest
01/25/2023 4:19:00
PM
Embezzlement
Part 1
Crimes
23-030682
Cleared by Arrest
01/23/2023 3:59:00
PM
Field Interview
23-008081
Pending/Possible
Leads
01/22/2023 12:00:00
PM
Miscellaneous Information
23-007689
Pending/Possible
Leads
01/11/2023 12:00:00
PM
Impersonation
Part 1
Crimes
23-020832
Pending/Possible
Leads
12/30/2022 12:00:00
AM
Destructive/Damage/Vandalism Of
Property
Part 1
Crimes
22-140114
Pending/Possible
Leads
12/15/2022 1:00:00
PM
Shoplifting
Part 1
Crimes
22-135026
Pending/Possible
Leads
12/12/2022 7:00:00
PM
Embezzlement
Part 1
Crimes
22-134077
Cleared by Arrest
12/04/2022 10:22:00
AM
Theft From Buildings
Part 1
Crimes
22-130858
Pending/Possible
Leads
11/19/2022 10:41:00
AM
Fraud Credit Card/Automated Teller
Machines
Part 1
Crimes
22-131995
Pending/Possible
Leads
11/15/2022 2:00:00
PM
Property Found
22-124136
Pending/Possible
Leads
Page
of
11
40
10/29/2022 2:35:00
PM
Damaged Property Accidental
22-117833
Pending/Possible
Leads
10/23/2022 11:00:00
AM
Property Found
22-115745
Pending/Possible
Leads
10/18/2022 4:00:00
PM
All Other Offenses
Part 2
Crimes
22-113709
Pending/Possible
Leads
10/13/2022 1:15:00
PM
Miscellaneous Information
22-111769
Pending/Possible
Leads
10/11/2022 11:26:00
PM
Miscellaneous Information
22-111219
Pending/Possible
Leads
10/08/2022 11:53:00
AM
False Pretense/Swindle/Confidence
Game
Part 1
Crimes
22-109945
Pending/Possible
Leads
10/03/2022 1:08:00
PM
All Other Larceny
Part 1
Crimes
22-106160
Pending/Possible
Leads
09/23/2022 5:15:00
PM
Drunkenness
Part 2
Crimes
22-104159
Cleared by Arrest
09/23/2022 5:15:00
PM
Disorderly Conduct
Part 2
Crimes
22-104159
Cleared by Arrest
09/23/2022 5:15:00
PM
Trespass Of Real Property
Part 2
Crimes
22-104159
Cleared by Arrest
08/05/2022 6:55:00
PM
Destructive/Damage/Vandalism Of
Property
Part 1
Crimes
22-084497
Pending/Possible
Leads
08/05/2022 3:15:00
PM
All Other Larceny
Part 1
Crimes
22-084351
Pending/Possible
Leads
07/19/2022 11:30:00
AM
Aggravated Assault
Part 1
Crimes
22-077131
Cleared by Arrest
07/14/2022 6:00:00
PM
All Other Offenses
Part 2
Crimes
22-075403
Pending/Possible
Leads
07/14/2022 7:22:00
AM
All Other Larceny
Part 1
Crimes
22-076283
Pending/Possible
Leads
06/22/2022 7:31:00
PM
Shoplifting
Part 1
Crimes
22-066178
Cleared by Arrest
05/27/2022 6:18:00
PM
Damaged Property Accidental
22-055607
Pending/Possible
Leads
05/08/2022 11:00:00
PM
Miscellaneous Information
22-047940
Pending/Possible
Leads
04/30/2022 5:12:00
PM
Miscellaneous Information
1704190001 Pending/Possible
Leads
04/30/2022 11:10:00
AM
Miscellaneous Information
22-044477
Pending/Possible
Leads
04/12/2022 7:15:00
PM
Simple Assault
Part 1
Crimes
22-037598
Pending/Possible
Leads
03/24/2022 1:07:00
PM
Drug/Narcotic Violations
Part 1
Crimes
22-030304
Pending/Possible
Leads
03/24/2022 1:07:00
PM
Drug Equipment Violations
Part 1
Crimes
22-030304
Pending/Possible
Leads
03/24/2022 1:07:00
PM
Misc Report
Other
Incidents
22-030304
Pending/Possible
Leads
Page
of
12
40
03/21/2022 4:30:00
PM
Trespass Of Real Property
Part 2
Crimes
22-029205
Cleared by Arrest
03/17/2022 11:23:00
AM
All Other Larceny
Part 1
Crimes
22-027571
Pending/Possible
Leads
03/16/2022 2:19:00
PM
Misc Report
Other
Incidents
22-027224
Pending/Possible
Leads
03/16/2022 2:19:00
PM
Drug/Narcotic Violations
Part 1
Crimes
22-027224
Pending/Possible
Leads
03/04/2022 8:21:00
PM
Miscellaneous Information
22-022866
Pending/Possible
Leads
02/25/2022 1:00:00
PM
Wire/Computer/Other Electronic
Manipulation
Part 1
Crimes
22-021326
Inactive/Suspended
02/21/2022 6:45:00
PM
Shoplifting
Part 1
Crimes
22-018638
Pending/Possible
Leads
02/21/2022 4:40:00
PM
Shoplifting
Part 1
Crimes
22-018586
Cleared by Arrest
02/16/2022 2:18:00
PM
Shoplifting
Part 1
Crimes
22-016642
Cleared by Arrest
02/16/2022 2:18:00
PM
Drug Equipment Violations
Part 1
Crimes
22-016642
Cleared by Arrest
02/15/2022 7:00:00
PM
Shoplifting
Part 1
Crimes
22-016338
Cleared by Arrest
02/15/2022 6:02:00
PM
Shoplifting
Part 1
Crimes
22-016618
Pending/Possible
Leads
01/11/2022 10:07:00
AM
Trespass Of Real Property
Part 2
Crimes
22-003526
Pending/Possible
Leads
01/10/2022 12:56:00
AM
Miscellaneous Information
22-003089
Pending/Possible
Leads
Page
of
13
40
Budget Suites of America, 2702 W. Yorkshire Drive, Phoenix, AZ 85027
Inc. Number
Type
Co
de
Description
Date/Time
Location
202300000955 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
1/1/2023
3:06:36
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300000955 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
1/1/2023
3:06:36
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300003336 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
41
5B
CRIMINAL DAMAGE
1/1/2023
15:28:02
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300003336 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
41
5B
CRIMINAL DAMAGE
1/1/2023
15:28:02
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300007917 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
651 LOOSE ANIMALS
1/2/2023
15:35:01
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300007917 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
651 LOOSE ANIMALS
1/2/2023
15:35:01
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300015989 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
1/4/2023
8:09:31
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300015989 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
1/4/2023
8:09:31
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300016331 INTERACTION
239 FIGHT
1/4/2023
9:37:52
196XX N 27TH
AVE
202300016861 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
1/4/2023
11:44:37
196XX N 27TH
AVE
202300017157 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
240 ASSAULT
1/4/2023
13:01:02
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300017157 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
240 ASSAULT
1/4/2023
13:01:02
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300019809 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
1/4/2023
21:52:43
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300019809 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
1/4/2023
21:52:43
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300022066 NO ACTION REQUIRED
917 ABANDONED VEHICLE
1/5/2023
11:43:41
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300022066 NO ACTION REQUIRED
917 ABANDONED VEHICLE
1/5/2023
11:43:41
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300029906 INTERACTION
31
5D
THEFT OF CREDIT
CARD
1/6/2023
20:48:10
196XX N 27TH
AVE
202300040590 NO ACTION REQUIRED
900 CHECK WELFARE
1/9/2023
2:59:55
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300040590 NO ACTION REQUIRED
900 CHECK WELFARE
1/9/2023
2:59:55
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300045228 INTERACTION
601 MISSING PERSON
1/9/2023
22:24:02
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300045228 INTERACTION
601 MISSING PERSON
1/9/2023
22:24:02
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300051746 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
1/11/2023
9:06:44
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
Page
of
14
40
202300051746 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
1/11/2023
9:06:44
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300052230 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
240 ASSAULT
1/11/2023
11:06:26
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300052230 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
240 ASSAULT
1/11/2023
11:06:26
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300054803 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
239 FIGHT
1/11/2023
19:34:52
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300054803 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
239 FIGHT
1/11/2023
19:34:52
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300055894 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
239 FIGHT
1/12/2023
0:46:18
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300055894 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
239 FIGHT
1/12/2023
0:46:18
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300066006 NO ACTION REQUIRED
41
8O
1/13/2023
21:37:31
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300066006 NO ACTION REQUIRED
41
8O
1/13/2023
21:37:31
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300066659 INTERACTION
239 FIGHT
1/14/2023
0:55:36
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300066659 INTERACTION
239 FIGHT
1/14/2023
0:55:36
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300069002 INTERACTION
41
8O
1/14/2023
15:10:34
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300069002 INTERACTION
41
8O
1/14/2023
15:10:34
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300073166 NO ACTION REQUIRED
418 CIVIL MATTER/STANDBY
1/15/2023
13:14:46
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300073166 NO ACTION REQUIRED
418 CIVIL MATTER/STANDBY
1/15/2023
13:14:46
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300076929 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
41
5F
DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
1/16/2023
9:50:08
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300076929 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
41
5F
DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
1/16/2023
9:50:08
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300085245 OTHER (SUPP/FALSE
ALARM/FI/LOUD PARTY)
45
9A
BURGLARY ALARM
1/17/2023
22:17:44
196XX N 27TH
AVE
202300085442 OTHER (SUPP/FALSE
ALARM/FI/LOUD PARTY)
45
9A
BURGLARY ALARM
1/17/2023
23:22:47
196XX N 27TH
AVE
202300092474 NO ACTION REQUIRED
41
8O
1/19/2023
10:14:37
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300092474 NO ACTION REQUIRED
41
8O
1/19/2023
10:14:37
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300096554 NO ACTION REQUIRED
64
7V
SUSPICIOUS PERSON
IN VEHICLE
1/20/2023
0:35:09
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300096554 NO ACTION REQUIRED
64
7V
SUSPICIOUS PERSON
IN VEHICLE
1/20/2023
0:35:09
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300099396 NO ACTION REQUIRED
211
A
ARMED ROBBERY
ALARM
1/20/2023
14:43:05
196XX N 27TH
AVE
Page
of
15
40
202300103617 NO ACTION REQUIRED
647 SUSPICIOUS PERSON
1/21/2023
11:16:35
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300103617 NO ACTION REQUIRED
647 SUSPICIOUS PERSON
1/21/2023
11:16:35
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300115479 INTERACTION
48
7V
STOLEN VEHICLE
1/23/2023
17:37:29
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300115479 INTERACTION
48
7V
STOLEN VEHICLE
1/23/2023
17:37:29
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300124993 INTERACTION
239 FIGHT
1/25/2023
15:07:54
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300124993 INTERACTION
239 FIGHT
1/25/2023
15:07:54
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300125867 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
1/25/2023
17:12:06
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300125867 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
1/25/2023
17:12:06
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300128593 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
90
1H
DEAD BODY
1/26/2023
9:17:29
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300128593 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
90
1H
DEAD BODY
1/26/2023
9:17:29
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300146888 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
1/29/2023
18:08:27
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300146888 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
1/29/2023
18:08:27
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300154061 NO ACTION REQUIRED
41
5F
DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
1/31/2023
6:37:57
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300154061 NO ACTION REQUIRED
41
5F
DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
1/31/2023
6:37:57
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300158192 INTERACTION
41
8T
TRESPASSING
1/31/2023
20:40:12
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300158192 INTERACTION
41
8T
TRESPASSING
1/31/2023
20:40:12
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300169973 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
2/3/2023
3:44:28
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300169973 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
2/3/2023
3:44:28
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300171503 INTERACTION
601 MISSING PERSON
2/3/2023
11:55:32
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300171503 INTERACTION
601 MISSING PERSON
2/3/2023
11:55:32
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300177191 INTERACTION
647 SUSPICIOUS PERSON
2/4/2023
11:46:07
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300177191 INTERACTION
647 SUSPICIOUS PERSON
2/4/2023
11:46:07
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300177244 INTERACTION
239 FIGHT
2/4/2023
11:53:16
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300177244 INTERACTION
239 FIGHT
2/4/2023
11:53:16
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
Page
of
16
40
202300177406 OTHER (SUPP/FALSE
ALARM/FI/LOUD PARTY)
45
9A
BURGLARY ALARM
2/4/2023
12:26:29
196XX N 27TH
AVE
202300186016 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
601 MISSING PERSON
2/6/2023
1:27:11
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300186016 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
601 MISSING PERSON
2/6/2023
1:27:11
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300202769 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
418 CIVIL MATTER/STANDBY
2/9/2023
7:27:25
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300202769 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
418 CIVIL MATTER/STANDBY
2/9/2023
7:27:25
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300207227 NO ACTION REQUIRED
41
5E
LOUD NOISE
DISTURBANCE
2/9/2023
22:23:18
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300207227 NO ACTION REQUIRED
41
5E
LOUD NOISE
DISTURBANCE
2/9/2023
22:23:18
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300212075 NO ACTION REQUIRED
239 FIGHT
2/10/2023
19:04:05
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300212075 NO ACTION REQUIRED
239 FIGHT
2/10/2023
19:04:05
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300213024 INTERACTION
45
9R
BURGLARY
RESIDENTIAL
2/10/2023
21:58:39
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300213024 INTERACTION
45
9R
BURGLARY
RESIDENTIAL
2/10/2023
21:58:39
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300218226 INTERACTION
65
1A
INJURED ANIMALS
2/11/2023
20:48:15
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300218226 INTERACTION
65
1A
INJURED ANIMALS
2/11/2023
20:48:15
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300223795 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
245 AGGRAVATED ASSAULT
2/12/2023
22:25:37
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300223795 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
245 AGGRAVATED ASSAULT
2/12/2023
22:25:37
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300230283 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
45
9C
BURGLARY
COMMERCIAL
2/14/2023
7:56:02
196XX N 27TH
AVE
202300232994 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
310 MOLESTING
2/14/2023
17:27:37
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300232994 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
310 MOLESTING
2/14/2023
17:27:37
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300251841 INTERACTION
96
1H
HIT & RUN ACCIDENT
NO INJURY
2/18/2023
9:04:54
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300251841 INTERACTION
96
1H
HIT & RUN ACCIDENT
NO INJURY
2/18/2023
9:04:54
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300255586 NO ACTION REQUIRED
45
9A
BURGLARY ALARM
2/18/2023
22:26:12
196XX N 27TH
AVE
202300256823 INTERACTION
41
5F
DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
2/19/2023
5:23:28
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300256823 INTERACTION
41
5F
DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
2/19/2023
5:23:28
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300267802 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
2/21/2023
10:39:20
196XX N 27TH
AVE
Page
of
17
40
202300280777 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
60
1J
MISSING JUVENILE
2/23/2023
17:24:44
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300280777 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
60
1J
MISSING JUVENILE
2/23/2023
17:24:44
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300288734 INTERACTION
239 FIGHT
2/25/2023
3:40:44
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300288734 INTERACTION
239 FIGHT
2/25/2023
3:40:44
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300293103 NO ACTION REQUIRED
239 FIGHT
2/25/2023
22:12:02
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300293103 NO ACTION REQUIRED
239 FIGHT
2/25/2023
22:12:02
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300297251 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
240 ASSAULT
2/26/2023
18:24:35
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300297251 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
240 ASSAULT
2/26/2023
18:24:35
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300304259 INTERACTION
911
H
9-1-1 HANG-UP CALL
2/28/2023
7:21:21
196XX N 27TH
AVE
202300318801 INTERACTION
41
5I
INCORRIGIBLE
JUVENILE
3/2/2023
18:52:20
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300318801 INTERACTION
41
5I
INCORRIGIBLE
JUVENILE
3/2/2023
18:52:20
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300318817 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
239 FIGHT
3/2/2023
19:00:01
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300318817 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
239 FIGHT
3/2/2023
19:00:01
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300323728 NO ACTION REQUIRED
911
H
9-1-1 HANG-UP CALL
3/3/2023
18:38:04
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300323728 NO ACTION REQUIRED
911
H
9-1-1 HANG-UP CALL
3/3/2023
18:38:04
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300337618 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
1051FELONY WARRANT
OUTSTANDING
3/6/2023
13:29:51
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300337618 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
1051FELONY WARRANT
OUTSTANDING
3/6/2023
13:29:51
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300339089 INTERACTION
41
8G
UNWANTED GUEST
3/6/2023
17:13:34
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300339089 INTERACTION
41
8G
UNWANTED GUEST
3/6/2023
17:13:34
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300352900 NO ACTION REQUIRED
900 CHECK WELFARE
3/9/2023
6:10:07
196XX N 27TH
AVE
202300359898 INTERACTION
65
1A
INJURED ANIMALS
3/10/2023
11:46:19
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300359898 INTERACTION
65
1A
INJURED ANIMALS
3/10/2023
11:46:19
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300367649 INTERACTION
236 THREAT
3/11/2023
18:40:35
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300367649 INTERACTION
236 THREAT
3/11/2023
18:40:35
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
Page
of
18
40
202300377076 NO ACTION REQUIRED
1076NOTIFY OWNER OF
VEHICLE RECOVERY
3/13/2023
14:19:45
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300377076 NO ACTION REQUIRED
1076NOTIFY OWNER OF
VEHICLE RECOVERY
3/13/2023
14:19:45
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300381364 INTERACTION
647 SUSPICIOUS PERSON
3/14/2023
9:55:44
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300381364 INTERACTION
647 SUSPICIOUS PERSON
3/14/2023
9:55:44
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300385837 NO ACTION REQUIRED
64
7V
SUSPICIOUS PERSON
IN VEHICLE
3/15/2023
3:47:40
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300385837 NO ACTION REQUIRED
64
7V
SUSPICIOUS PERSON
IN VEHICLE
3/15/2023
3:47:40
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300386005 NO ACTION REQUIRED
647 SUSPICIOUS PERSON
3/15/2023
5:46:20
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300386005 NO ACTION REQUIRED
647 SUSPICIOUS PERSON
3/15/2023
5:46:20
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300393703 NO ACTION REQUIRED
26
0J
SEXUAL ABUSE OF
JUVENILE
3/16/2023
13:47:37
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300393703 NO ACTION REQUIRED
26
0J
SEXUAL ABUSE OF
JUVENILE
3/16/2023
13:47:37
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300394243 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
26
0J
SEXUAL ABUSE OF
JUVENILE
3/16/2023
15:28:29
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300394243 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
26
0J
SEXUAL ABUSE OF
JUVENILE
3/16/2023
15:28:29
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300396153 INTERACTION
239 FIGHT
3/16/2023
21:31:42
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300396153 INTERACTION
239 FIGHT
3/16/2023
21:31:42
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300421082 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
3/21/2023
13:32:36
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300421082 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
3/21/2023
13:32:36
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300432668 INTERACTION
911
H
9-1-1 HANG-UP CALL
3/23/2023
14:16:27
196XX N 27TH
AVE
202300434835 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
3/23/2023
20:22:16
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300434835 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
3/23/2023
20:22:16
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300435759 NO ACTION REQUIRED
907 BACK-UP
3/24/2023
1:27:28
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300435759 NO ACTION REQUIRED
907 BACK-UP
3/24/2023
1:27:28
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300442884 INTERACTION
41
8T
TRESPASSING
3/25/2023
9:59:45
196XX N 27TH
AVE
202300446566 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
647 SUSPICIOUS PERSON
3/25/2023
23:33:51
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300446566 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
647 SUSPICIOUS PERSON
3/25/2023
23:33:51
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
Page
of
19
40
202300448727 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
3/26/2023
12:00:24
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300448727 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
3/26/2023
12:00:24
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300452230 INTERACTION
236 THREAT
3/27/2023
3:41:10
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300452230 INTERACTION
236 THREAT
3/27/2023
3:41:10
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300457150 INTERACTION
41
5F
DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
3/27/2023
22:37:09
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300457150 INTERACTION
41
5F
DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
3/27/2023
22:37:09
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300462912 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
48
7V
STOLEN VEHICLE
3/28/2023
20:56:54
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300462912 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
48
7V
STOLEN VEHICLE
3/28/2023
20:56:54
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300464455 NO ACTION REQUIRED
48
8V
RECOVERY OF VEHICLE
3/29/2023
6:42:47
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300464455 NO ACTION REQUIRED
48
8V
RECOVERY OF VEHICLE
3/29/2023
6:42:47
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300469638 NO ACTION REQUIRED
239 FIGHT
3/29/2023
23:20:30
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300469638 NO ACTION REQUIRED
239 FIGHT
3/29/2023
23:20:30
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300473129 NO ACTION REQUIRED
65
1A
INJURED ANIMALS
3/30/2023
15:17:15
196XX N 27TH
AVE
202300475385 INTERACTION
647 SUSPICIOUS PERSON
3/30/2023
22:07:49
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300475385 INTERACTION
647 SUSPICIOUS PERSON
3/30/2023
22:07:49
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300476354 NO ACTION REQUIRED
647 SUSPICIOUS PERSON
3/31/2023
5:14:07
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300476354 NO ACTION REQUIRED
647 SUSPICIOUS PERSON
3/31/2023
5:14:07
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300481546 NO ACTION REQUIRED
647 SUSPICIOUS PERSON
3/31/2023
23:20:53
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300481546 NO ACTION REQUIRED
647 SUSPICIOUS PERSON
3/31/2023
23:20:53
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300488471 NO ACTION REQUIRED
236 THREAT
4/2/2023
7:35:38
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300488471 NO ACTION REQUIRED
236 THREAT
4/2/2023
7:35:38
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300503822 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
4/4/2023
23:21:05
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300503822 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
4/4/2023
23:21:05
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300509982 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
4/6/2023
1:30:47
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
Page
of
20
40
202300509982 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
4/6/2023
1:30:47
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300524336 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
900 CHECK WELFARE
4/8/2023
13:15:04
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300524336 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
900 CHECK WELFARE
4/8/2023
13:15:04
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300532010 NO ACTION REQUIRED
647 SUSPICIOUS PERSON
4/9/2023
22:58:19
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300532010 NO ACTION REQUIRED
647 SUSPICIOUS PERSON
4/9/2023
22:58:19
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300533161 OTHER (SUPP/FALSE
ALARM/FI/LOUD PARTY)
45
9A
BURGLARY ALARM
4/10/2023
7:15:08
196XX N 27TH
AVE
202300533634 NO ACTION REQUIRED
1091ASSIST MOTORIST
4/10/2023
9:01:39
196XX N 27TH
AVE
202300546498 INTERACTION
961 ACCIDENT NO INJURIES
4/12/2023
10:17:15
196XX N 27TH
AVE
202300554143 NO ACTION REQUIRED
211
A
ARMED ROBBERY
ALARM
4/13/2023
15:33:07
196XX N 27TH
AVE
202300561359 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
4/14/2023
21:50:06
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300561359 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
4/14/2023
21:50:06
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300571444 INTERACTION
240 ASSAULT
4/16/2023
19:16:19
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300571444 INTERACTION
240 ASSAULT
4/16/2023
19:16:19
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300581640 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
239 FIGHT
4/18/2023
15:26:56
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300581640 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
239 FIGHT
4/18/2023
15:26:56
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300589665 INTERACTION
239 FIGHT
4/19/2023
22:29:59
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300589665 INTERACTION
239 FIGHT
4/19/2023
22:29:59
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300592541 NO ACTION REQUIRED
60
1F
FOUND MISSING
PERSON
4/20/2023
13:13:59
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300592541 NO ACTION REQUIRED
60
1F
FOUND MISSING
PERSON
4/20/2023
13:13:59
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300618633 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
41
5B
CRIMINAL DAMAGE
4/25/2023
7:42:43
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300618633 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
41
5B
CRIMINAL DAMAGE
4/25/2023
7:42:43
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300624268 INTERACTION
418 CIVIL MATTER/STANDBY
4/26/2023
6:11:58
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300624268 INTERACTION
418 CIVIL MATTER/STANDBY
4/26/2023
6:11:58
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300626637 INTERACTION
418 CIVIL MATTER/STANDBY
4/26/2023
14:31:28
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
Page
of
21
40
202300626637 INTERACTION
418 CIVIL MATTER/STANDBY
4/26/2023
14:31:28
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300632824 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
31
5I
IDENTITY THEFT
4/27/2023
14:40:59
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300632824 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
31
5I
IDENTITY THEFT
4/27/2023
14:40:59
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300642952 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
240 ASSAULT
4/29/2023
6:35:48
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300642952 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
240 ASSAULT
4/29/2023
6:35:48
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300643179 ACCIDENT REPORT
961 ACCIDENT NO INJURIES
4/29/2023
7:58:47
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300643179 ACCIDENT REPORT
961 ACCIDENT NO INJURIES
4/29/2023
7:58:47
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300676693 OTHER (SUPP/FALSE
ALARM/FI/LOUD PARTY)
45
9A
BURGLARY ALARM
5/5/2023
5:26:39
196XX N 27TH
AVE
202300686843 INTERACTION
41
5E
LOUD NOISE
DISTURBANCE
5/6/2023
22:33:02
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300686843 INTERACTION
41
5E
LOUD NOISE
DISTURBANCE
5/6/2023
22:33:02
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300687333 NO ACTION REQUIRED
239 FIGHT
5/7/2023
0:33:59
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300687333 NO ACTION REQUIRED
239 FIGHT
5/7/2023
0:33:59
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300693976 OTHER (SUPP/FALSE
ALARM/FI/LOUD PARTY)
45
9A
BURGLARY ALARM
5/8/2023
9:23:39
196XX N 27TH
AVE
202300697649 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
240 ASSAULT
5/8/2023
21:26:44
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300697649 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
240 ASSAULT
5/8/2023
21:26:44
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300698249 INTERACTION
23
7D
DANGEROUS DRUGS
5/9/2023
0:25:46
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300698249 INTERACTION
23
7D
DANGEROUS DRUGS
5/9/2023
0:25:46
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300699965 INTERACTION
239 FIGHT
5/9/2023
9:59:15
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300699965 INTERACTION
239 FIGHT
5/9/2023
9:59:15
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300700359 INTERACTION
41
8O
5/9/2023
11:06:34
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300700359 INTERACTION
41
8O
5/9/2023
11:06:34
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300702441 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
5/9/2023
16:58:51
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300702441 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
5/9/2023
16:58:51
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300704123 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
5/9/2023
23:40:01
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
Page
of
22
40
202300704123 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
5/9/2023
23:40:01
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300705035 INTERACTION
41
8B
NEIGHBOR DISPUTE
5/10/2023
6:38:04
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300705035 INTERACTION
41
8B
NEIGHBOR DISPUTE
5/10/2023
6:38:04
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300706120 INTERACTION
918 INSANE PERSON
5/10/2023
10:32:53
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300706120 INTERACTION
918 INSANE PERSON
5/10/2023
10:32:53
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300708318 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
5/10/2023
16:35:03
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300708318 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
5/10/2023
16:35:03
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300722761 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
64
7V
SUSPICIOUS PERSON
IN VEHICLE
5/13/2023
5:29:08
196XX N 27TH
AVE
202300737750 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
900 CHECK WELFARE
5/16/2023
0:17:39
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300737750 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
900 CHECK WELFARE
5/16/2023
0:17:39
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300738149 NO ACTION REQUIRED
41
8T
TRESPASSING
5/16/2023
4:19:24
196XX N 27TH
AVE
202300746524 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
5/17/2023
12:38:16
196XX N 27TH
AVE
202300759687 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
5/19/2023
15:18:51
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300759687 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
5/19/2023
15:18:51
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300767835 INTERACTION
927 UNKNOWN TROUBLE
5/21/2023
0:27:27
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300767835 INTERACTION
927 UNKNOWN TROUBLE
5/21/2023
0:27:27
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300769399 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
961 ACCIDENT NO INJURIES
5/21/2023
9:42:09
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300769399 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
961 ACCIDENT NO INJURIES
5/21/2023
9:42:09
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300774511 NO ACTION REQUIRED
911
H
9-1-1 HANG-UP CALL
5/22/2023
8:22:20
196XX N 27TH
AVE
202300774956 NO ACTION REQUIRED
900 CHECK WELFARE
5/22/2023
9:47:30
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300774956 NO ACTION REQUIRED
900 CHECK WELFARE
5/22/2023
9:47:30
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300812665 INTERACTION
239 FIGHT
5/28/2023
19:09:17
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300812665 INTERACTION
239 FIGHT
5/28/2023
19:09:17
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300818482 NO ACTION REQUIRED
236 THREAT
5/29/2023
20:20:31
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
Page
of
23
40
202300818482 NO ACTION REQUIRED
236 THREAT
5/29/2023
20:20:31
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300828285 NO ACTION REQUIRED
901 INJURED/SICK PERSON
5/31/2023
13:53:55
196XX N 27TH
AVE
202300828821 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
41
5F
DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
5/31/2023
15:16:23
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300828821 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
41
5F
DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
5/31/2023
15:16:23
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300833201 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
900 CHECK WELFARE
6/1/2023
11:23:42
196XX N 27TH
AVE
202300837554 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
6/2/2023
4:53:42
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300837554 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
6/2/2023
4:53:42
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300852239 INTERACTION
487 THEFT
6/4/2023
20:29:48
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300852239 INTERACTION
487 THEFT
6/4/2023
20:29:48
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300858092 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
41
5F
DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
6/5/2023
20:30:50
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300858092 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
41
5F
DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
6/5/2023
20:30:50
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300858807 INTERACTION
23
7D
DANGEROUS DRUGS
6/5/2023
23:38:36
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300858807 INTERACTION
23
7D
DANGEROUS DRUGS
6/5/2023
23:38:36
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300858868 OTHER (SUPP/FALSE
ALARM/FI/LOUD PARTY)
45
9A
BURGLARY ALARM
6/6/2023
0:10:41
196XX N 27TH
AVE
202300873153 INTERACTION
911
H
9-1-1 HANG-UP CALL
6/8/2023
12:33:32
196XX N 27TH
AVE
202300896411 NO ACTION REQUIRED
318 THEFT BY FRAUD
6/12/2023
15:24:38
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300896411 NO ACTION REQUIRED
318 THEFT BY FRAUD
6/12/2023
15:24:38
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300904313 NO ACTION REQUIRED
31
5C
MONEY LAUNDERING
6/13/2023
22:07:50
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300904313 NO ACTION REQUIRED
31
5C
MONEY LAUNDERING
6/13/2023
22:07:50
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300911246 NO ACTION REQUIRED
41
8T
TRESPASSING
6/15/2023
5:33:32
196XX N 27TH
AVE
202300911361 INTERACTION
901 INJURED/SICK PERSON
6/15/2023
6:15:43
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300911361 INTERACTION
901 INJURED/SICK PERSON
6/15/2023
6:15:43
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300911724 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
96
1H
HIT & RUN ACCIDENT
NO INJURY
6/15/2023
8:09:12
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300911724 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
96
1H
HIT & RUN ACCIDENT
NO INJURY
6/15/2023
8:09:12
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
Page
of
24
40
202300912846 NO ACTION REQUIRED
96
1H
S
HIT & RUN ACCIDENT
NO INJURIES SUPP
6/15/2023
12:28:23
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300912846 NO ACTION REQUIRED
96
1H
S
HIT & RUN ACCIDENT
NO INJURIES SUPP
6/15/2023
12:28:23
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300913023 INTERACTION
96
1H
S
HIT & RUN ACCIDENT
NO INJURIES SUPP
6/15/2023
13:04:20
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300913023 INTERACTION
96
1H
S
HIT & RUN ACCIDENT
NO INJURIES SUPP
6/15/2023
13:04:20
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300914020 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
91
8T
MENTALLY ILL SUBJECT
TRANSPORT
6/15/2023
16:06:03
196XX N 27TH
AVE
202300917562 NO ACTION REQUIRED
900 CHECK WELFARE
6/16/2023
9:17:13
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300917562 NO ACTION REQUIRED
900 CHECK WELFARE
6/16/2023
9:17:13
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300918811 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
45
9R
BURGLARY
RESIDENTIAL
6/16/2023
13:16:00
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300918811 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
45
9R
BURGLARY
RESIDENTIAL
6/16/2023
13:16:00
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300931864 INTERACTION
647 SUSPICIOUS PERSON
6/18/2023
23:41:01
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300931864 INTERACTION
647 SUSPICIOUS PERSON
6/18/2023
23:41:01
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300933937 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
6/19/2023
11:10:18
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300933937 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
6/19/2023
11:10:18
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300943446 NO ACTION REQUIRED
45
9F
BURGLARY FROM
VEHICLE
6/21/2023
1:06:01
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300943446 NO ACTION REQUIRED
45
9F
BURGLARY FROM
VEHICLE
6/21/2023
1:06:01
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300955271 INTERACTION
239 FIGHT
6/23/2023
1:19:39
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300955271 INTERACTION
239 FIGHT
6/23/2023
1:19:39
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300955479 NO ACTION REQUIRED
900 CHECK WELFARE
6/23/2023
3:06:08
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300955479 NO ACTION REQUIRED
900 CHECK WELFARE
6/23/2023
3:06:08
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300961908 OTHER (SUPP/FALSE
ALARM/FI/LOUD PARTY)
45
9A
BURGLARY ALARM
6/24/2023
6:49:31
196XX N 27TH
AVE
202300965567 INTERACTION
41
8B
NEIGHBOR DISPUTE
6/24/2023
21:00:52
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202300965567 INTERACTION
41
8B
NEIGHBOR DISPUTE
6/24/2023
21:00:52
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
Page
of
25
40
202301026322 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
7/5/2023
17:54:45
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202301026322 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
7/5/2023
17:54:45
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202301032332 INTERACTION
239 FIGHT
7/6/2023
20:13:23
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202301032332 INTERACTION
239 FIGHT
7/6/2023
20:13:23
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202301037164 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
240 ASSAULT
7/7/2023
17:53:53
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202301037164 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
240 ASSAULT
7/7/2023
17:53:53
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202301044309 INTERACTION
41
5B
CRIMINAL DAMAGE
7/9/2023
2:40:19
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202301044309 INTERACTION
41
5B
CRIMINAL DAMAGE
7/9/2023
2:40:19
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202301048784 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
23
7D
DANGEROUS DRUGS
7/10/2023
0:48:06
196XX N 27TH
AVE
202301058004 NO ACTION REQUIRED
45
9R
BURGLARY
RESIDENTIAL
7/11/2023
18:59:33
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202301058004 NO ACTION REQUIRED
45
9R
BURGLARY
RESIDENTIAL
7/11/2023
18:59:33
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202301059445 NO ACTION REQUIRED
586 ILLEGAL PARKING
7/12/2023
2:07:59
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202301059445 NO ACTION REQUIRED
586 ILLEGAL PARKING
7/12/2023
2:07:59
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202301060434 INTERACTION
250 HARASSMENT
7/12/2023
8:30:34
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202301060434 INTERACTION
250 HARASSMENT
7/12/2023
8:30:34
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202301087966 INTERACTION
48
7V
STOLEN VEHICLE
7/17/2023
11:38:59
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202301087966 INTERACTION
48
7V
STOLEN VEHICLE
7/17/2023
11:38:59
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202301089723 INTERACTION
45
9F
BURGLARY FROM
VEHICLE
7/17/2023
17:34:26
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
202301089723 INTERACTION
45
9F
BURGLARY FROM
VEHICLE
7/17/2023
17:34:26
27XX W
YORKSHIRE DR
Budget Suites of America, 611 W. Indian School Road, Phoenix, AZ 85013
Inc. Number
Type
Co
de
Description
Date/Time
Location
202300013832 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
41
5F
DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
1/3/2023
6:25:03 PM
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
Page
of
26
40
202300026197 NO ACTION REQUIRED
1091ASSIST MOTORIST
1/6/2023
7:54:49 AM
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300032302 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
900 CHECK WELFARE
1/7/2023
11:33:20 AM
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300032603 NO ACTION REQUIRED
900 CHECK WELFARE
1/7/2023
12:35:19 PM
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300033221 NO ACTION REQUIRED
90
1X
SUICIDE ATTEMPT
1/7/2023
2:47:00 PM
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300049805 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
49
1C
ACCESS
INTERFERENCE
1/10/2023
8:08:06 PM
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300054475 INTERACTION
41
8T
TRESPASSING
1/11/2023
6:18:23 PM
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300058498 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
48
7V
STOLEN VEHICLE
1/12/2023
2:46:39 PM
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300059778 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
90
1C
CUTTING/STABBING
1/12/2023
6:44:57 PM
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300059922 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
487 THEFT
1/12/2023
7:12:35 PM
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300060526 INTERACTION
41
5F
DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
1/12/2023
9:33:38 PM
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300060619 INTERACTION
239 FIGHT
1/12/2023
9:59:16 PM
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300065772 INTERACTION
647 SUSPICIOUS PERSON
1/13/2023
8:40:22 PM
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300067001 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
49
1C
ACCESS
INTERFERENCE
1/14/2023
3:06:28 AM
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300069629 INTERACTION
41
8T
TRESPASSING
1/14/2023
5:58:49 PM
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300070208 INTERACTION
390 DRUNK DISTURBING/
DOWN/CAR
1/14/2023
8:24:41 PM
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300091048 INTERACTION
239 FIGHT
1/19/2023
12:04:26 AM
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300093414 INTERACTION
41
8G
UNWANTED GUEST
1/19/2023
1:20:02 PM
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300094228 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
239 FIGHT
1/19/2023
3:41:45 PM
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300094992 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
928 FOUND PROPERTY
1/19/2023
5:49:49 PM
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300099139 ACCIDENT REPORT
961 ACCIDENT NO INJURIES
1/20/2023
2:00:02 PM
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300101813 NO ACTION REQUIRED
900 CHECK WELFARE
1/20/2023
11:13:31 PM
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300104541 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
90
1H
DEAD BODY
1/21/2023
2:55:44 PM
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300107168 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
1/22/2023
12:31:22 AM
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300112549 INTERACTION
41
8T
TRESPASSING
1/23/2023
6:31:41 AM
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
Page
of
27
40
202300117437 NO ACTION REQUIRED
647 SUSPICIOUS PERSON
1/24/2023
6:30:09 AM
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300119275 INTERACTION
41
8T
TRESPASSING
1/24/2023
1:37:44 PM
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300121050 NO ACTION REQUIRED
41
8T
TRESPASSING
1/24/2023
6:59:00 PM
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300121834 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
41
8B
NEIGHBOR DISPUTE
1/24/2023
10:27:54 PM
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300128171 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
41
5B
CRIMINAL DAMAGE
1/26/2023
7:28:32
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300138229 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
1/27/2023
23:38:28
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300144419 NO ACTION REQUIRED
41
5F
DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
1/29/2023
6:32:59
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300144445 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
240 ASSAULT
1/29/2023
6:35:52
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300150865 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
236 THREAT
1/30/2023
14:17:02
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300154674 INTERACTION
487 THEFT
1/31/2023
9:27:13
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300161513 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
60
1J
MISSING JUVENILE
2/1/2023
14:27:41
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300168181 NO ACTION REQUIRED
41
5F
DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
2/2/2023
18:28:43
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300168463 INTERACTION
487 THEFT
2/2/2023
19:24:52
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300169970 NO ACTION REQUIRED
927 UNKNOWN TROUBLE
2/3/2023
3:38:13
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300170894 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
41
5F
DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
2/3/2023
9:35:27
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300172069 OTHER (SUPP/FALSE
ALARM/FI/LOUD PARTY)
418 CIVIL MATTER/STANDBY
2/3/2023
13:38:59
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300173755 NO ACTION REQUIRED
900 CHECK WELFARE
2/3/2023
18:55:54
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300175355 INTERACTION
239 FIGHT
2/4/2023
0:49:55
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300177933 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
312 CHILD NEGLECT
2/4/2023
14:08:01
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300188681 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
918 INSANE PERSON
2/6/2023
15:03:21
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300195518 INTERACTION
961 ACCIDENT NO INJURIES
2/7/2023
19:40:03
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300205170 NO ACTION REQUIRED
900 CHECK WELFARE
2/9/2023
15:34:02
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300211091 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
60
1F
FOUND MISSING
PERSON
2/10/2023
16:16:31
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300213261 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
41
5F
DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
2/10/2023
22:48:49
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
Page
of
28
40
202300225213 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
48
7V
STOLEN VEHICLE
2/13/2023
7:49:29
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300239929 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
41
8T
TRESPASSING
2/16/2023
0:58:18
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300240157 NO ACTION REQUIRED
900 CHECK WELFARE
2/16/2023
3:35:01
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300244524 NO ACTION REQUIRED
41
5G
SHOTS FIRED
2/16/2023
20:52:12
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300251690 NO ACTION REQUIRED
41
5F
DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
2/18/2023
8:13:37
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300261022 INTERACTION
239 FIGHT
2/20/2023
0:41:49
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300261174 INTERACTION
239 FIGHT
2/20/2023
1:45:00
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300264887 NO ACTION REQUIRED
900 CHECK WELFARE
2/20/2023
18:40:47
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300270422 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
41
5F
DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
2/21/2023
18:54:49
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300272805 INTERACTION
41
5F
DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
2/22/2023
8:02:19
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300277318 INTERACTION
901 INJURED/SICK PERSON
2/23/2023
0:55:28
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300281608 NO ACTION REQUIRED
41
8O
2/23/2023
19:48:15
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300286153 NO ACTION REQUIRED
41
8O
2/24/2023
16:37:14
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300300912 INTERACTION
45
9A
BURGLARY ALARM
2/27/2023
13:29:25
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300307864 INTERACTION
239 FIGHT
2/28/2023
19:02:18
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300311520 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
48
7V
STOLEN VEHICLE
3/1/2023
13:17:19
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300319036 NO ACTION REQUIRED
647 SUSPICIOUS PERSON
3/2/2023
19:49:10
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300324690 NO ACTION REQUIRED
45
9R
BURGLARY
RESIDENTIAL
3/3/2023
22:20:07
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300328354 INTERACTION
250 HARASSMENT
3/4/2023
16:35:52
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300331885 NO ACTION REQUIRED
239 FIGHT
3/5/2023
10:34:13
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300342013 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
240 ASSAULT
3/7/2023
9:15:50
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300343700 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
239 FIGHT
3/7/2023
14:33:37
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300344305 NO ACTION REQUIRED
900 CHECK WELFARE
3/7/2023
16:09:01
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300344847 NO ACTION REQUIRED
23
9S
FIGHT SUPPLEMENT
3/7/2023
17:41:15
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
Page
of
29
40
202300345309 NO ACTION REQUIRED
1021CALL BY PHONE
3/7/2023
19:06:41
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300366059 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
41
5B
CRIMINAL DAMAGE
3/11/2023
13:18:15
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300367439 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
41
5F
DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
3/11/2023
17:47:18
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300374213 NO ACTION REQUIRED
41
5F
DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
3/13/2023
1:11:02
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300383236 NO ACTION REQUIRED
41
8T
TRESPASSING
3/14/2023
15:40:02
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300384484 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
239 FIGHT
3/14/2023
19:43:08
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300388971 NO ACTION REQUIRED
487 THEFT
3/15/2023
15:59:20
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300394949 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
3/16/2023
17:19:41
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300399546 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
487 THEFT
3/17/2023
14:22:50
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300401960 NO ACTION REQUIRED
41
5F
DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
3/17/2023
22:16:38
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300403187 NO ACTION REQUIRED
91
8T
MENTALLY ILL SUBJECT
TRANSPORT
3/18/2023
5:34:35
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300404435 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
3/18/2023
11:46:54
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300404916 NO ACTION REQUIRED
91
8T
MENTALLY ILL SUBJECT
TRANSPORT
3/18/2023
13:32:35
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300409870 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
91
8T
MENTALLY ILL SUBJECT
TRANSPORT
3/19/2023
11:48:24
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300417173 INTERACTION
239 FIGHT
3/20/2023
18:09:37
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300430654 NO ACTION REQUIRED
239 FIGHT
3/23/2023
7:36:22
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300463786 NO ACTION REQUIRED
911
H
9-1-1 HANG-UP CALL
3/29/2023
0:59:02
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300467800 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
487 THEFT
3/29/2023
16:50:25
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300470942 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
3/30/2023
8:59:29
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300494047 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
901 INJURED/SICK PERSON
4/3/2023
9:21:21
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300495183 NO ACTION REQUIRED
500 GENERIC
4/3/2023
13:03:59
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300506204 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
90
1H
DEAD BODY
4/5/2023
12:16:34
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300511243 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
918 INSANE PERSON
4/6/2023
9:43:28
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300521494 NO ACTION REQUIRED
239 FIGHT
4/7/2023
22:55:43
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
Page
of
30
40
202300523913 NO ACTION REQUIRED
239 FIGHT
4/8/2023
11:51:07
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300531499 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
4/9/2023
20:48:52
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300538772 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
4/11/2023
5:13:17
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300544494 NO ACTION REQUIRED
418 CIVIL MATTER/STANDBY
4/11/2023
22:40:44
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300545066 NO ACTION REQUIRED
41
5B
CRIMINAL DAMAGE
4/12/2023
2:48:19
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300551216 NO ACTION REQUIRED
41
5F
DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
4/13/2023
3:50:18
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300554396 INTERACTION
647 SUSPICIOUS PERSON
4/13/2023
16:11:40
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300571923 INTERACTION
239 FIGHT
4/16/2023
21:10:33
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300574112 NO ACTION REQUIRED
41
8T
TRESPASSING
4/17/2023
10:10:49
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300584425 INTERACTION
41
5F
DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
4/19/2023
3:31:30
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300591671 NO ACTION REQUIRED
23
7D
DANGEROUS DRUGS
4/20/2023
10:16:06
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300600270 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
240 ASSAULT
4/21/2023
19:42:56
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300601389 INTERACTION
927 UNKNOWN TROUBLE
4/22/2023
0:18:33
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300605705 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
4/22/2023
20:50:26
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300605938 NO ACTION REQUIRED
45
9R
BURGLARY
RESIDENTIAL
4/22/2023
21:39:41
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300607369 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
60
1J
MISSING JUVENILE
4/23/2023
5:26:05
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300624040 NO ACTION REQUIRED
239 FIGHT
4/26/2023
4:10:31
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300637632 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
45
9F
BURGLARY FROM
VEHICLE
4/28/2023
10:47:56
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300640369 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
245 AGGRAVATED ASSAULT
4/28/2023
17:58:07
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300640653 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
41
5F
DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
4/28/2023
18:46:46
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300642592 NO ACTION REQUIRED
911
H
9-1-1 HANG-UP CALL
4/29/2023
3:38:04
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300652226 INTERACTION
390 DRUNK DISTURBING/
DOWN/CAR
4/30/2023
20:37:03
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300656884 INTERACTION
1076NOTIFY OWNER OF
VEHICLE RECOVERY
5/1/2023
17:11:02
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300666621 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
45
9R
BURGLARY
RESIDENTIAL
5/3/2023
11:17:12
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
Page
of
31
40
202300672079 NO ACTION REQUIRED
311 INDECENT EXPOSURE
5/4/2023
10:02:30
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300723770 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
41
5B
CRIMINAL DAMAGE
5/13/2023
10:47:12
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300725685 ACCIDENT REPORT
961 ACCIDENT NO INJURIES
5/13/2023
17:21:38
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300727796 INTERACTION
647 SUSPICIOUS PERSON
5/14/2023
1:52:29
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300738163 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
5/16/2023
4:06:47
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300744927 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
918 INSANE PERSON
5/17/2023
7:43:14
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300750249 NO ACTION REQUIRED
647 SUSPICIOUS PERSON
5/18/2023
0:03:24
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300755421 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
31
5M
COUNTERFEIT
CURRENCY
5/18/2023
19:56:45
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300767330 NO ACTION REQUIRED
41
5E
LOUD NOISE
DISTURBANCE
5/20/2023
22:30:53
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300772836 INTERACTION
601 MISSING PERSON
5/21/2023
22:05:48
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300773226 NO ACTION REQUIRED
41
5E
LOUD NOISE
DISTURBANCE
5/21/2023
23:51:11
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300782069 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
928 FOUND PROPERTY
5/23/2023
13:09:41
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300785225 NO ACTION REQUIRED
41
5E
LOUD NOISE
DISTURBANCE
5/23/2023
23:26:17
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300798160 NO ACTION REQUIRED
41
5F
DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
5/26/2023
7:21:39
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300808292 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
5/27/2023
22:19:25
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300815882 INTERACTION
239 FIGHT
5/29/2023
11:22:28
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300836446 INTERACTION
210 STRONG ARMED
ROBBERY
6/1/2023
21:13:30
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300839196 NO ACTION REQUIRED
647 SUSPICIOUS PERSON
6/2/2023
12:15:18
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300842880 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
240 ASSAULT
6/3/2023
1:10:21
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300843368 INTERACTION
41
5F
DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
6/3/2023
4:57:10
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300853499 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
23
7D
DANGEROUS DRUGS
6/5/2023
4:07:22
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300857020 NO ACTION REQUIRED
48
7V
STOLEN VEHICLE
6/5/2023
16:48:59
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300858987 NO ACTION REQUIRED
41
5F
DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
6/6/2023
1:09:58
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300871112 NO ACTION REQUIRED
239 FIGHT
6/8/2023
2:01:09
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
Page
of
32
40
202300883302 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
41
5B
CRIMINAL DAMAGE
6/10/2023
5:35:29
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300890818 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
48
7V
STOLEN VEHICLE
6/11/2023
14:30:34
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300895741 NO ACTION REQUIRED
41
8O
6/12/2023
13:27:46
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300901847 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
41
5F
DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
6/13/2023
14:38:34
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300913866 NO ACTION REQUIRED
48
7V
S
STOLEN VEHICLE
SUPPLEMENT
6/15/2023
15:37:58
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300918427 INTERACTION
41
8T
TRESPASSING
6/16/2023
12:09:52
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300920230 NO ACTION REQUIRED
48
7F
THEFT FROM VEHICLE
6/16/2023
17:22:29
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300929232 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
318 THEFT BY FRAUD
6/18/2023
11:51:26
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300939734 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
41
8T
TRESPASSING
6/20/2023
12:12:51
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300945616 NO ACTION REQUIRED
900 CHECK WELFARE
6/21/2023
11:50:21
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300945864 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
45
9C
BURGLARY
COMMERCIAL
6/21/2023
12:39:42
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300956048 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
502 JUDICIAL
INTERFERENCE
6/23/2023
7:14:01
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300967437 NO ACTION REQUIRED
41
5I
INCORRIGIBLE
JUVENILE
6/25/2023
6:08:48
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300968318 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
245 AGGRAVATED ASSAULT
6/25/2023
11:37:30
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300976825 INTERACTION
240 ASSAULT
6/26/2023
23:09:27
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300979551 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
48
8V
RECOVERY OF VEHICLE
6/27/2023
13:38:04
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300980221 INTERACTION
240 ASSAULT
6/27/2023
15:42:52
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300982448 INTERACTION
459 BURGLARY
6/27/2023
23:42:05
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300982580 NO ACTION REQUIRED
239 FIGHT
6/28/2023
0:27:26
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300982645 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
41
5B
CRIMINAL DAMAGE
6/28/2023
0:51:48
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300983238 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
48
7V
STOLEN VEHICLE
6/28/2023
6:00:38
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300994167 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
211 ARMED ROBBERY
6/30/2023
1:14:15
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202300996261 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
311 INDECENT EXPOSURE
6/30/2023
12:41:30
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
Page
of
33
40
202301006580 NO ACTION REQUIRED
45
9C
BURGLARY
COMMERCIAL
7/2/2023
8:22:19
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202301007213 INTERACTION
918 INSANE PERSON
7/2/2023
11:16:35
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202301010583 NO ACTION REQUIRED
927 UNKNOWN TROUBLE
7/3/2023
1:31:20
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202301022832 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
240 ASSAULT
7/5/2023
2:39:10
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202301022964 NO ACTION REQUIRED
900 CHECK WELFARE
7/5/2023
3:50:55
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202301025130 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
45
9R
BURGLARY
RESIDENTIAL
7/5/2023
13:55:44
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202301047313 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
487 THEFT
7/9/2023
18:27:34
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202301051367 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
7/10/2023
14:22:37
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202301055795 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
7/11/2023
10:45:21
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202301069800 NO ACTION REQUIRED
41
8T
TRESPASSING
7/13/2023
21:32:12
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202301085975 INTERACTION
41
5F
DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
7/16/2023
23:46:32
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202301086149 OTHER (SUPP/FALSE
ALARM/FI/LOUD PARTY)
900 CHECK WELFARE
7/17/2023
0:51:56
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202301086192 OTHER (SUPP/FALSE
ALARM/FI/LOUD PARTY)
45
9A
BURGLARY ALARM
7/17/2023
1:11:17
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202301086305 NO ACTION REQUIRED
900 CHECK WELFARE
7/17/2023
2:16:10
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
202301087164 OTHER (SUPP/FALSE
ALARM/FI/LOUD PARTY)
45
9A
BURGLARY ALARM
7/17/2023
8:24:31
6XX W INDIAN
SCHOOL RD
Extended Stay, 1360 N 43rd Ave, Phoenix, AZ 85009
202300009794 INTERACTION
41
5F
DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
1/2/2023
23:33:10
13XX N 43RD
AVE
202300032745 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
236 THREAT
1/7/2023
13:13:18
13XX N 43RD
AVE
202300062326 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
1/13/2023
9:50:33
13XX N 43RD
AVE
202300071191 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
1/15/2023
0:23:45
13XX N 43RD
AVE
202300072847 NO ACTION REQUIRED
90
0V
1/15/2023
11:43:02
13XX N 43RD
AVE
202300086698 NO ACTION REQUIRED
41
8T
TRESPASSING
1/18/2023
8:46:41
13XX N 43RD
AVE
202300087160 INTERACTION
41
8G
UNWANTED GUEST
1/18/2023
10:31:03
13XX N 43RD
AVE
Page
of
34
40
202300101332 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
41
5F
DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
1/20/2023
21:08:20
13XX N 43RD
AVE
202300103169 INTERACTION
41
8G
UNWANTED GUEST
1/21/2023
9:07:49
13XX N 43RD
AVE
202300116056 INTERACTION
41
8T
TRESPASSING
1/23/2023
20:10:08
13XX N 43RD
AVE
202300146869 INTERACTION
1091ASSIST MOTORIST
1/29/2023
18:07:22
13XX N 43RD
AVE
202300151529 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
1/30/2023
16:05:14
13XX N 43RD
AVE
202300151894 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
1/30/2023
17:15:58
13XX N 43RD
AVE
202300189824 NO ACTION REQUIRED
41
8T
TRESPASSING
2/6/2023
18:51:14
13XX N 43RD
AVE
202300211929 NO ACTION REQUIRED
41
8T
TRESPASSING
2/10/2023
18:36:34
13XX N 43RD
AVE
202300221294 NO ACTION REQUIRED
239 FIGHT
2/12/2023
13:31:18
13XX N 43RD
AVE
202300235749 INTERACTION
239 FIGHT
2/15/2023
9:15:11
13XX N 43RD
AVE
202300245788 NO ACTION REQUIRED
239 FIGHT
2/17/2023
6:00:38
13XX N 43RD
AVE
202300260804 NO ACTION REQUIRED
927 UNKNOWN TROUBLE
2/19/2023
23:27:30
13XX N 43RD
AVE
202300271266 NO ACTION REQUIRED
41
5F
DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
2/21/2023
22:39:35
13XX N 43RD
AVE
202300289582 NO ACTION REQUIRED
41
8T
TRESPASSING
2/25/2023
9:37:36
13XX N 43RD
AVE
202300319806 INTERACTION
65
1A
INJURED ANIMALS
3/2/2023
23:43:55
13XX N 43RD
AVE
202300368871 NO ACTION REQUIRED
41
5F
DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
3/11/2023
23:17:18
13XX N 43RD
AVE
202300371713 INTERACTION
41
8T
TRESPASSING
3/12/2023
14:58:18
13XX N 43RD
AVE
202300372604 NO ACTION REQUIRED
647 SUSPICIOUS PERSON
3/12/2023
18:27:19
13XX N 43RD
AVE
202300403217 NO ACTION REQUIRED
239 FIGHT
3/18/2023
5:49:24
13XX N 43RD
AVE
202300515301 NO ACTION REQUIRED
911
H
9-1-1 HANG-UP CALL
4/6/2023
22:03:32
13XX N 43RD
AVE
202300520876 NO ACTION REQUIRED
239 FIGHT
4/7/2023
20:36:42
13XX N 43RD
AVE
202300537791 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
41
8T
TRESPASSING
4/10/2023
21:33:45
13XX N 43RD
AVE
202300538269 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
928 FOUND PROPERTY
4/11/2023
0:16:46
13XX N 43RD
AVE
202300571390 INTERACTION
48
7I
STOLEN BICYCLE
4/16/2023
19:01:51
13XX N 43RD
AVE
Page
of
35
40
202300594419 NO ACTION REQUIRED
900 CHECK WELFARE
4/20/2023
18:46:36
13XX N 43RD
AVE
202300597832 NO ACTION REQUIRED
41
5F
DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
4/21/2023
12:28:03
13XX N 43RD
AVE
202300603235 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
90
1H
DEAD BODY
4/22/2023
11:29:10
13XX N 43RD
AVE
202300636345 INTERACTION
41
8T
TRESPASSING
4/28/2023
5:21:30
13XX N 43RD
AVE
202300707680 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
90
1X
SUICIDE ATTEMPT
5/10/2023
14:55:50
13XX N 43RD
AVE
202300723446 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
48
7V
STOLEN VEHICLE
5/13/2023
9:30:19
13XX N 43RD
AVE
202300723793 INTERACTION
41
8T
TRESPASSING
5/13/2023
10:52:46
13XX N 43RD
AVE
202300825276 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
45
9F
BURGLARY FROM
VEHICLE
5/30/2023
22:56:16
13XX N 43RD
AVE
202300825534 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
41
5F
DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
5/31/2023
0:22:15
13XX N 43RD
AVE
202300877260 NO ACTION REQUIRED
41
5F
DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
6/9/2023
4:02:53
13XX N 43RD
AVE
202300879207 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
48
7V
STOLEN VEHICLE
6/9/2023
12:49:39
13XX N 43RD
AVE
202300905160 NO ACTION REQUIRED
45
9F
BURGLARY FROM
VEHICLE
6/14/2023
4:51:33
13XX N 43RD
AVE
202300912361 NO ACTION REQUIRED
48
7V
STOLEN VEHICLE
6/15/2023
10:44:42
13XX N 43RD
AVE
202300950235 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
900 CHECK WELFARE
6/22/2023
7:24:00
13XX N 43RD
AVE
202300975011 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
48
7V
STOLEN VEHICLE
6/26/2023
16:36:03
13XX N 43RD
AVE
202300975091 NO ACTION REQUIRED
48
7V
S
STOLEN VEHICLE
SUPPLEMENT
6/26/2023
16:53:45
13XX N 43RD
AVE
202300997240 NO ACTION REQUIRED
41
5F
DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
6/30/2023
15:30:35
13XX N 43RD
AVE
202301024470 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
711
C
7/5/2023
11:29:06
13XX N 43RD
AVE
202301034694 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
900 CHECK WELFARE
7/7/2023
9:37:08
13XX N 43RD
AVE
202301036039 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
601 MISSING PERSON
7/7/2023
14:13:16
13XX N 43RD
AVE
Extended Stay, 8808 N Black Cyn Hwy, Phoenix, AZ 85051
202300001210 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
211 ARMED ROBBERY
1/1/2023
4:39:35
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300010494 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
418 CIVIL MATTER/STANDBY
1/3/2023
5:44:40
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
Page
of
36
40
202300015604 NO ACTION REQUIRED
647 SUSPICIOUS PERSON
1/4/2023
6:00:33
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300016312 NO ACTION REQUIRED
601 MISSING PERSON
1/4/2023
9:33:36
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300021212 NO ACTION REQUIRED
64
7V
SUSPICIOUS PERSON
IN VEHICLE
1/5/2023
8:36:49
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300022548 INTERACTION
502 JUDICIAL
INTERFERENCE
1/5/2023
13:28:53
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300039347 INTERACTION
647 SUSPICIOUS PERSON
1/8/2023
19:42:11
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300042127 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
41
5B
CRIMINAL DAMAGE
1/9/2023
11:36:49
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300044899 NO ACTION REQUIRED
41
8T
TRESPASSING
1/9/2023
21:03:22
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300052522 ACCIDENT REPORT
961 ACCIDENT NO INJURIES
1/11/2023
12:10:25
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300060622 NO ACTION REQUIRED
647 SUSPICIOUS PERSON
1/12/2023
21:58:53
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300063627 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
49
1A
CUSTODIAL
INTERFERENCE
1/13/2023
14:09:10
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300070615 NO ACTION REQUIRED
647 SUSPICIOUS PERSON
1/14/2023
21:57:29
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300071415 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
240 ASSAULT
1/15/2023
1:30:24
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300091652 NO ACTION REQUIRED
41
8T
TRESPASSING
1/19/2023
6:36:38
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300101149 INTERACTION
41
8T
TRESPASSING
1/20/2023
20:21:40
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300104352 INTERACTION
41
8T
TRESPASSING
1/21/2023
14:01:22
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300116198 INTERACTION
418 CIVIL MATTER/STANDBY
1/23/2023
20:43:31
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300135395 INTERACTION
239 FIGHT
1/27/2023
13:48:59
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300137283 NO ACTION REQUIRED
41
8T
TRESPASSING
1/27/2023
19:44:24
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300155158 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
48
7Y
THEFT OF METAL
1/31/2023
11:20:37
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300155706 NO ACTION REQUIRED
900 CHECK WELFARE
1/31/2023
13:05:41
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300163037 NO ACTION REQUIRED
41
8T
TRESPASSING
2/1/2023
19:12:34
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300164373 NO ACTION REQUIRED
647 SUSPICIOUS PERSON
2/2/2023
2:34:15
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300169120 NO ACTION REQUIRED
60
1F
FOUND MISSING
PERSON
2/2/2023
21:48:58
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300169476 OTHER (SUPP/FALSE
ALARM/FI/LOUD PARTY)
45
9A
BURGLARY ALARM
2/2/2023
23:31:31
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
Page
of
37
40
202300172129 INTERACTION
41
8T
TRESPASSING
2/3/2023
13:49:53
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300173999 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
41
5B
CRIMINAL DAMAGE
2/3/2023
19:37:47
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300177694 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
487 THEFT
2/4/2023
13:21:15
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300181319 INTERACTION
64
7V
SUSPICIOUS PERSON
IN VEHICLE
2/5/2023
3:54:23
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300189828 NO ACTION REQUIRED
487 THEFT
2/6/2023
18:50:39
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300191389 INTERACTION
41
8T
TRESPASSING
2/7/2023
2:49:46
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300202185 NO ACTION REQUIRED
64
7V
SUSPICIOUS PERSON
IN VEHICLE
2/9/2023
1:59:07
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300202819 NO ACTION REQUIRED
41
8T
TRESPASSING
2/9/2023
7:46:01
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300247657 NO ACTION REQUIRED
961 ACCIDENT NO INJURIES
2/17/2023
13:51:04
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300249723 INTERACTION
41
8G
UNWANTED GUEST
2/17/2023
20:10:38
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300262547 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
60
1J
MISSING JUVENILE
2/20/2023
10:42:30
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300262787 INTERACTION
240 ASSAULT
2/20/2023
11:31:12
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300265482 INTERACTION
60
1F
FOUND MISSING
PERSON
2/20/2023
20:53:20
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300269176 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
48
7V
STOLEN VEHICLE
2/21/2023
15:05:59
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300273596 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
45
9C
BURGLARY
COMMERCIAL
2/22/2023
10:31:05
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300275114 NO ACTION REQUIRED
45
9C
S
BURGLARY
COMMERCIAL
SUPPLEMENT
2/22/2023
15:23:10
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300276586 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
2/22/2023
20:37:49
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300277305 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
2/23/2023
0:46:07
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300287599 NO ACTION REQUIRED
65
1A
INJURED ANIMALS
2/24/2023
21:16:42
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300290290 INTERACTION
41
7G
SUBJECT WITH A GUN
2/25/2023
12:23:51
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300326018 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
240 ASSAULT
3/4/2023
7:37:19
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300348370 ACCIDENT REPORT
961 ACCIDENT NO INJURIES
3/8/2023
10:59:12
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300384460 INTERACTION
41
8T
TRESPASSING
3/14/2023
19:38:02
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
Page
of
38
40
202300404796 NO ACTION REQUIRED
41
8T
TRESPASSING
3/18/2023
13:07:14
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300408466 NO ACTION REQUIRED
45
9A
BURGLARY ALARM
3/19/2023
3:42:53
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300421454 NO ACTION REQUIRED
45
9C
S
BURGLARY
COMMERCIAL
SUPPLEMENT
3/21/2023
14:48:05
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300436004 NO ACTION REQUIRED
239 FIGHT
3/24/2023
3:52:25
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300487319 NO ACTION REQUIRED
900 CHECK WELFARE
4/1/2023
23:33:11
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300500780 NO ACTION REQUIRED
647 SUSPICIOUS PERSON
4/4/2023
13:08:10
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300512917 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
41
8G
UNWANTED GUEST
4/6/2023
14:49:55
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300557113 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
901 INJURED/SICK PERSON
4/14/2023
6:08:28
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300621552 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
487 THEFT
4/25/2023
16:37:33
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300644388 INTERACTION
45
9R
BURGLARY
RESIDENTIAL
4/29/2023
12:40:03
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300644853 INTERACTION
41
8G
UNWANTED GUEST
4/29/2023
14:18:38
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300692052 NO ACTION REQUIRED
41
5F
DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
5/7/2023
21:18:53
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300694049 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
45
9C
BURGLARY
COMMERCIAL
5/8/2023
9:34:26
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300706345 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
5/10/2023
11:12:11
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300721512 NO ACTION REQUIRED
64
7V
SUSPICIOUS PERSON
IN VEHICLE
5/12/2023
21:46:42
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300750313 INTERACTION
418 CIVIL MATTER/STANDBY
5/18/2023
0:25:28
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300753063 INTERACTION
1052MISDEMEANOR
WARRANT
OUTSTANDING
5/18/2023
13:07:29
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300758041 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
41
5F
DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
5/19/2023
10:13:23
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300773532 NO ACTION REQUIRED
41
5F
DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
5/22/2023
2:01:34
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300775936 INTERACTION
41
8T
TRESPASSING
5/22/2023
12:57:15
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300778215 INTERACTION
41
8T
TRESPASSING
5/22/2023
19:47:17
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300798059 NO ACTION REQUIRED
647 SUSPICIOUS PERSON
5/26/2023
6:51:28
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300819275 NO ACTION REQUIRED
601 MISSING PERSON
5/29/2023
23:47:21
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
Page
of
39
40
202300825527 NO ACTION REQUIRED
1076NOTIFY OWNER OF
VEHICLE RECOVERY
5/31/2023
0:15:56
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300841582 NO ACTION REQUIRED
41
8T
TRESPASSING
6/2/2023
20:00:55
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300888964 NO ACTION REQUIRED
647 SUSPICIOUS PERSON
6/11/2023
5:28:19
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300895050 INTERACTION
418 CIVIL MATTER/STANDBY
6/12/2023
10:47:26
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300929934 INTERACTION
911
H
9-1-1 HANG-UP CALL
6/18/2023
15:10:06
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300962549 NO ACTION REQUIRED
41
8T
TRESPASSING
6/24/2023
10:11:49
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300966703 INTERACTION
239 FIGHT
6/25/2023
0:59:42
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300972288 NO ACTION REQUIRED
647 SUSPICIOUS PERSON
6/26/2023
6:19:25
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300975943 NO ACTION REQUIRED
64
7V
SUSPICIOUS PERSON
IN VEHICLE
6/26/2023
19:48:34
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202300992336 ACCIDENT REPORT
961 ACCIDENT NO INJURIES
6/29/2023
17:49:59
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202301011963 NO ACTION REQUIRED
41
8G
UNWANTED GUEST
7/3/2023
9:59:06
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202301013854 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
900 CHECK WELFARE
7/3/2023
16:17:57
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202301019804 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
91
8T
MENTALLY ILL SUBJECT
TRANSPORT
7/4/2023
17:39:57
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202301031516 INTERACTION
647 SUSPICIOUS PERSON
7/6/2023
17:21:49
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202301035017 NO ACTION REQUIRED
96
1H
HIT & RUN ACCIDENT
NO INJURY
7/7/2023
10:45:58
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202301048186 INTERACTION
900 CHECK WELFARE
7/9/2023
21:45:00
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202301050716 NO ACTION REQUIRED
900 CHECK WELFARE
7/10/2023
12:14:07
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
202301082386 DEPARTMENTAL
REPORT
647 SUSPICIOUS PERSON
7/16/2023
9:12:23
88XX N BLACK
CANYON AC
Page
of
40
40
From:
jamie notallheroes.org
To:
Perry, Tabitha; Taylor, Matthew
Subject:
Opposing CU 23-04 - Modern Stay
Date:
Thursday, August 17, 2023 3:17:35 PM
Attachments:
Jamie"s Letter.pdf
Dear Mr. Taylor and Ms. Perry,
Attache you will find a PDF of my opposition to the CUP 23-04. I am requesting the entire packet be included in the Planning
Commissioners packet for next week.
Thank you,
Jamie
August 10, 2023
City of Glendale Planning Commission
5850 W. Glendale Avenue
Glendale, AZ 85301
RE: OBJECTION to CUP23-04 - Modern StayApt
Dear Commissioners,
My name is Jamie Kelly. I am a lifelong resident born and raised in Glendale and have called the neighborhood of Secluded
Acres my home since 2017. I am writing to request that the Planning Commission understands how CUP 23-04 Modern
StayApt would be detrimental to the health, safety, and general welfare of those who live and work near the proposed site.
Between the nature of this proposed hotel plus the types of criminal behavior, dangerous activities like human and
sex trafficking, and additional traffic as well as concerns about the builder's honesty which is detailed in this report,
please vote no on CUP 23-04 - Modern StayApt located at 73rd Avenue and West Camino San Xavier which is just south
of my neighborhood.
I am a wife, mother, and grandmother who absolutely loves and adores my family, neighborhood, community, and country.
When my husband and I made the decision to move into the quiet neighborhood of Secluded Acres, I believe it was the best
decision for our family. Now my husband and I have invested our time and energy into our community. My husband served
for 23 years in the City of Glendale as a Police Officer. I have been active with non-profit community organizations and
served on a Glendale commission and an Arizona state board.
In the following pages, you will read my research and insight on why I am asking you to vote NO on the CUP 23-04 - Modern
StayApt. A hotel in this lot does not make sense for the builder, the community, and Glendale. My concerns about this
Modern StayApt include criminal activity such as human and sex trafficking, drugs, kidnapping, rape, and murder as property
crimes like vehicle theft, burglary, and retail theft. In reviewing the data, it is very clear that these types of hotel venues do
not provide a service to the community but rather a burden on the community, law enforcement, and fire service and create a
negative influence of crime in a community. Please read through the research and statements I have collected to show you
how the Modern StayApt will be destructive to our community.
The idea of a hotel that does not provide security or validate those who are renting a room provides significant concerns for
safety to those who live and shop near this proposed site. This hotel would be less than a 1/2 mile from a program that
provides services to individuals with physical and mental disabilities as well as a rehabilitation center. I am asking you to
think of the potential risks of having a hotel that does not verify the identification of guests and would open the door for
criminals like registered sex offenders to have easy access to a school bus stop, an organization for those with disabilities,
and near a mall and shopping centers.
I appreciate your time and consideration. Again, I am asking you to vote NO to the CUP 23-04 - Modern StayApt. Please
help me protect my family and community from the criminal activity brought on by extended stay-type hotels.
Respectfully,
Jamie Kelly
From:
Erin Cole
To:
Taylor, Matthew; Lerma, Alex; Perry, Tabitha; Walker-Hall, Tawanda
Cc:
Skip Crandall; Jamie Kelly; Malnar, Raymond
Subject:
Access to Media for 8/24 - CUP 23-04
Date:
Friday, August 18, 2023 10:49:20 AM
Hi all,
Will the residents in opposition to this project be granted access to media, similar to what the
applicant is permitted to use?
Thanks,
Erin Cole
602.770.9799
erinscole@gmail.com
From:
jamie notallheroes.org
To:
Taylor, Matthew; Perry, Tabitha; Malnar, Raymond
Cc:
Walker-Hall, Tawanda; Lerma, Alex
Subject:
Re: My Unanswered Questions
Date:
Friday, August 18, 2023 9:41:34 AM
Attachments:
image001.png
Good Morning,
I am reaching out because I scrolled through the 200 plus pages of citizens comments to see
that none of my emails, questions or oppositions were included.
I am requesting that the packet be updated to include ALL of the items and that I am able to
view the packet provided to the commissioners to ensure my comments were included.
I do know mistakes do happen but I am very disappointed.
Thank you,
Jamie
From: Taylor, Matthew <MTaylor@GLENDALEAZ.com>
Sent: Friday, August 18, 2023 7:26:07 AM
To: jamie notallheroes.org <jamie@notallheroes.org>; Perry, Tabitha <TPerry@GLENDALEAZ.com>
Cc: Walker-Hall, Tawanda <TWalker@GLENDALEAZ.com>; Lerma, Alex <alerma@GLENDALEAZ.com>
Subject: RE: My Unanswered Questions
Good morning Jamie,
Your messages and letter have been compiled into the public input received for CUP23-04.
Please direct future messages regarding this August 24, 2023, public hearing item to Tabitha Perry,
Tawanda Walker-Hall, and Alex Lerma (copied).
Thank you.
From: jamie notallheroes.org <jamie@notallheroes.org>
Sent: Thursday, August 17, 2023 3:20 PM
To: Taylor, Matthew <MTaylor@GLENDALEAZ.com>; Perry, Tabitha <TPerry@GLENDALEAZ.com>
Subject: Fw: My Unanswered Questions
Good Afternoon,
In addition to my previously submitted email, I am requesting the email communication
below be included in the Planning Commissioner packet.
Thank you,
Jamie
From: Taylor, Matthew <MTaylor@GLENDALEAZ.com>
Sent: Monday, August 14, 2023 10:58 AM
To: jamie notallheroes.org <jamie@notallheroes.org>
Cc: Perry, Tabitha <TPerry@GLENDALEAZ.com>
Subject: RE: My Unanswered Questions
Good morning Jamie,
All the questions posed in your message were asked during the August 7, 2023, public meeting
facilitated by Councilmember Malnar’s office – answers to these questions regarding the Modern
Stay-StayAPT project are integrated into your original email message of August 8, 2023 (see below in
red italics). As stated during the meeting, all ground-up projects go through a major design review
application process by the city’s project team.
Feel free to reach out with additional questions.
Thank you.
From: jamie notallheroes.org <jamie@notallheroes.org>
Sent: Thursday, August 10, 2023 12:17 PM
To: Taylor, Matthew <MTaylor@GLENDALEAZ.com>
Cc: Perry, Tabitha <TPerry@GLENDALEAZ.com>
Subject: Re: My Unanswered Questions
Good Afternoon Mr. Taylor,
I would appreciate an email response so I have the answers in writing. If that is not an
option, then please let me know why.
Thanks,
Jamie
From: Taylor, Matthew <MTaylor@GLENDALEAZ.com>
Sent: Wednesday, August 9, 2023 3:13 PM
To: jamie notallheroes.org <jamie@notallheroes.org>
Cc: Perry, Tabitha <TPerry@GLENDALEAZ.com>
Subject: RE: My Unanswered Questions
Good afternoon,
We are glad to discuss your concerns via phone call, as this would be a more efficient use of time
than addressing each topic in a series of email messages. Please give me a call at your convenience
(direct line below) or I can call you at 623.326.8219 if that is a good number.
Thank you.
From: jamie notallheroes.org <jamie@notallheroes.org>
Sent: Tuesday, August 8, 2023 10:12 AM
To: Taylor, Matthew <MTaylor@GLENDALEAZ.com>; Perry, Tabitha <TPerry@GLENDALEAZ.com>
Subject: My Unanswered Questions
Good Morning Mr. Taylor and Ms. Perry,
Again, thank you for your time last night. I do have multiple questions that we
unanswered last night that I would appreciate answers from the business owner. If I
need to reach out to someone else, please let me know.
1. Will StayApt have lighted signage such as a backlit logo on the building or a
separate standing sign? If yes, how tall will this be? If yes, what is the lumens of
this logo or signage?
Signs and lighting are evaluated during the design review application process for compliance
with city requirements.
2. Will there be fencing around the StayApt parking lot?
The applicant has not identified perimeter fencing on the conceptual site plan. Site fencing
will be evaluated during the design review application process.
3. Will they install a privacy fence to reduce down on noise into the neighborhood?
Perimeter fencing will be evaluated during the design review process for compliance with city
requirements.
4. I asked for the Franchise Disclosure Documents, can you please have it sent to me
by the builder?
Please direct this question to the applicant: Tiffany & Bosco, PA, Attn: Shaine Alleman,
sta@tblaw.com / 602.255.6000.
5. How will StayApt ensure the privacy of the homeowners whose backyards are
within view of the guest rooms? Will they provide privacy shutters in their building?
Please direct this question to the applicant: Tiffany & Bosco, PA, Attn: Shaine Alleman,
sta@tblaw.com / 602.255.6000.
6. What will the average room rate be during our slow season? What will the average
room rate be during our business season?
Please direct this question to the applicant: Tiffany & Bosco, PA, Attn: Shaine Alleman,
sta@tblaw.com / 602.255.6000.
7. What type of security beyond key cards and a camera system will StayApt provide
for the community against potential criminal activity?
Please direct this question to the applicant: Tiffany & Bosco, PA, Attn: Shaine Alleman,
sta@tblaw.com / 602.255.6000.
8. Where will the garbage dumpsters be located on the property? What will be done
to reduce the potential noise of dumping the garbage? How many dumpsters will
the client have and how often will they be dumped?
Currently, dumpster placement is proposed at the west side of the building. Dumpster
location and enclosure will be evaluated during the design review process for compliance
with city requirements.
9. How does StayApt plan on conserving water?
Please direct this question to the applicant: Tiffany & Bosco, PA, Attn: Shaine Alleman,
sta@tblaw.com / 602.255.6000.
10. Will StayApt have electric vehicle parking? How will the charging occur? A
generator? Will this take a regular parking spot? How will they reduce the noise
from the diesel fuel generator?
Please direct this question to the applicant: Tiffany & Bosco, PA, Attn: Shaine Alleman,
sta@tblaw.com / 602.255.6000. If provided, vehicle charging areas, along with required on-
site vehicle parking, will be evaluated during the design review process for compliance with
city requirements.
11. Does StayApt have contracts with our local hospitals for housing with their staff? If
yes, what is the contract nightly rate?
Please direct this question to the applicant: Tiffany & Bosco, PA, Attn: Shaine Alleman,
sta@tblaw.com / 602.255.6000.
12. Does StayApt have a government/military contract to provide housing for our
military that is stationed at Luke Air Force Base which is over 15 miles away?
Please direct this question to the applicant: Tiffany & Bosco, PA, Attn: Shaine Alleman,
sta@tblaw.com / 602.255.6000.
13. Currently, businesses do not have enough parking, and street parking if often
utilized. Where will additional vehicle park if the StayApt parking lot is full?
On-site parking is required for this project. Street parking along San Camino Xavier will not be
permitted.
14. Where will semis and trucks with trailers park as they may not be able to turn
around in the proposed lot?
On-site parking is required for this project. Street parking along San Camino Xavier will not be
permitted.
15. Is there an environmental impact study available on how dangerous this building
will be for our local wildlife such as our coyotes, owls, snakes, etc?
The city does not have an EIS requirement for this project.
16. What are the mitigations of the stormwater? Our neighborhood often floods during
intensive storms. Will the flood plan push the water into our neighborhood or the
surrounding businesses?
Stormwater mitigation will be evaluated during the design review application process for
compliance with city requirements.
17. We heard loud and clear that the building is secure with keys and cameras. As a
neighbor of this building, my concern is the safety of my children and
grandchildren from this building. What safety will be in place to protect the
community members?
Please direct this question to the applicant: Tiffany & Bosco, PA, Attn: Shaine Alleman,
sta@tblaw.com / 602.255.6000. Nothing suggests hazardous conditions warrant additional
safety measures for this project.
18. Will the builder decrease the number of rooms to provide the allowance on the
property for installing the proper size trees to provide security and privacy to the
neighbors? The neighbors are not able to fund the maintenance of the trees and it
is unfair to require the homeowners to pay for privacy!
Landscaping will be evaluated during the design review application process for compliance
with city requirements.
19. What landscaping lights will be included? What are the lumens of these lights?
Landscaping and lighting are evaluated during the design review application process for
compliance with city requirements.
20. Will there be backlighting on the extended stay hotel? What are the lumens of
these lights?
Signs and lighting are evaluated during the design review application process for compliance
with city requirements.
My questions for the City of Glendale are the following...
1. How will the City of Glendale address the additional traffic turning off 75th Avenue
onto Camino San Xavier? My concern is that if there are more than 3 vehicles
turning off 75th Avenue then they will block a lane of southbound travel. If most of
the traffic returns to the hotel around 5 pm or 6 pm with at least 50 vehicles that is
a significant increase of traffic coming off 75th avenue.
The applicant provided a traffic statement to the city. Based on trip counts, street
improvements are not required for this project.
2. Will the City of Glendale provide additional signage in the Secluded Acres
neighborhood at the entrance saying "Not a Thru Street" to reduce the potential
lost travelers who may attempt to utilize the 73rd Avene roadway to gain access?
73rd Avenue will not extend north into Secluded Estates/Secluded Acres.
3. Will the City of Glendale install ADA approved sidewalks on Camino San Xavier to
reduce the risk of accidents with walkers?
Sidewalks and ADA accessible curbs are required for this project.
4. Will the City of Glendale re-do Camino San Xavier to remove the potholes and
install additional lighting and signage for the extended stay apt?
You can submit a Glendale One service request regarding improvements to Camino San
Xavier: Request for Service - GlendaleOne.
5. Will the City of Glendale be increasing the number of police officers to
accommodate the extended stay apt reports and crimes?
Nothing suggests hazardous conditions warrant elevated safety measures for this project.
I appreciate your time and assistance.
Thank you,
Jamie
1
Lerma, Alex
From:
MaryAnn <mab1119@cox.net>
Sent:
Thursday, August 17, 2023 6:49 PM
To:
Lerma, Alex
Subject:
Extended stay APT
[You don't often get email from mab1119@cox.net. Learn why this is important at
https://aka.ms/LearnAboutSenderIdentification ]
I’m writing to let you know my husband and I oppose the building of the extended stay apt complex on Camino San
Xavier in Glendale, on the lot behind Micheals. The property values of the neighboring communities has depreciated
after the IRS went in on that street. Told to us by a realtor. The prices for the apartments seen to be unclear, is it
$133.00 a night? Is there a discount for multiple months? There are people who have evictions on their records, who
have vouchers, are they going to be able to move in there? A police officer spoke on the subject of more crime in the
area, there was a mention of cameras. Cameras document crimes not prevent them. Another officer said he gets
called all the time to another facility close by on Bell Rd, and not so easy to get the offenders out of the rooms. The
builders said that these apartments are high end, must of repeated this info 3 or 4 times during the discussion at
foothills recreation meeting. There are apartment just north of Home Deport that charge more rent. These extended
stay will rent fast if they are less expensive.
A lot of people have credit cards from the government, and they all have cell phone, cards are easily manipulated. Is
they’re going to be a security guard on the premises 24/7? We we also told that the whole complex, parking lots and all
are non smoking. Where are these residents going to go smoke, vape, or use marijuana? The neighborhood right
behind it. A quiet neighborhood, no smokers, or extra traffic wanted .
Seems that the powers that be have already approved this build. So are we the people opposing this just spinning our
wheels? We would like to have answers to these questions, and our other concerns. Thx, MaryAnn & Charles Brown
Sent from my iPad
From:
sss510@cox.net
To:
Taylor, Matthew
Cc:
Walker-Hall, Tawanda; Perry, Tabitha; Lerma, Alex; Malnar, Raymond; Mehta, Jamsheed;
rstjohn@glendalaz.com; Perry, Tabitha; bhoopeer@glrndaleaz.com; rhuggins@glendalaz.com
Subject:
Stay APT Suites hotel
Date:
Friday, August 18, 2023 11:52:28 AM
Attachments:
cub.PNG
curb1.PNG
curb2.PNG
curb3.PNG
curb4.PNG
curb5.PNG
Some people who received this message don't often get email from sss510@cox.net. Learn why this is important
Dear Mr. Taylor:
This letter is in response to the conditional use permit for the Stay APT Hotel at 73rd Ave. I am
opposed to this project. A conditional use permit is to be put into place when a type of building is
not approved in the current zoning for the property. This building is not in line with the other
buildings and businesses in the area and will have a negative impact to the surrounding area.
This hotel is not going to provide food and beverage services on site. These units do have kitchens
reducing the need for such services. One issue mentioned at the meeting is the number of parking
spaces not meeting the needs of the 9 employees and the 76 guests at the hotel. If every room and
employee was utilizing a parking space that would come to 85 parking spaces. The hotel is only going
to have 79. Stay APT has stated that they have never experienced a 100% fill rate on the parking lot,
even with 100% occupancy. That being the case then some of the guests are not going to have cars.
The hotel is going to be required to have a sidewalk on Camino San Xavier (CSX in future
references). As I had mentioned at the meeting there will be no sidewalks or lighting on CSX west of
the hotel. This will result in people desiring to travel west on foot to walk on the road surface. CSX
has a sharp turn in the area just west of the hotel where there is poor lighting and no sidewalks. This
section of the curb on the north side of CSX (same side of the hotel) is shattered in over 40 sections
due to tire strikes. I fear that this sharp curve with no provisions for sidewalks or lighting will result in
vehicle/pedestrian accidents.
Situation: A guest at the hotel does not have a car. They look online and see that there are
considerably more businesses west of the hotel than east of the hotel. These include Mimi’s Café,
Mod Pizza, Pita Jungle, Barrio Queen, Wildflower, Ajo Al’s, Café Zupas, Taco Bell, Jimmy Jims, Trader
Joes, Total Wine and more, Portillos and Arrowhead Mall. All these locations are within walking
distance of the hotel and on the same side of Bell Road as the hotel. Let’s say the guest has a per
diem of $x and they can have a nicer meal just by walking for a few minutes. Without having to pay
for an Uber. You know they are going to do this, I would. Without knowing that walk may be your
last walk as you get struck by a car.
I feel that my concern was trivialized by Ray Malnar stated this is a City of Glendale issue not a
hotel issue. That just goes to show that even the city did not plan for this property to be used for this
purpose. The conditional use permit should not be allowed for the lack of a safe infrastructure for all
guests at the hotel. How many lives is a hotel worth? Hopefully not one. My uncle (Robert Culp) was
struck by a car in Phoenix and die from his injuries. The accident was a hit and run and no one has
ever been charged in his death. Please review the attached photos displaying the condition of the
curb on this road from tire strikes.
An additional concern is once VAI resort opens the Glendale area will be gaining 1200 hotel
rooms. With this increase supply in hotel rooms, I believe will pull demand for hotel rooms in the
area surrounding the location of the Stay APT suites hotel. This loss of demand will result in the hotel
needing to reduce rates to gain customers. Resulting in a lower quality customer. Stay APT is not
going to be high end compared to the VAI. Currently people are overpaying at hotels in the area like,
Extended stay America for events like baseball spring training, Phoenix Open, and Cardinals football.
Many of these customers staying at hotels in the Bell and 75th Ave area are going to stay at the VAI
resort. This reduction in demand is going to have a negative impact on hotels resulting in reduced
rates resulting in reduced returns for the investors in these hotels. Resulting in Stay APT declining to
take over the option of first refusal of the franchisee decides they want out. The first right to refusal
is not a guarantee that Stay APT corporation will buy the hotel. If Stay APT does not exercise the first
right to purchase the hotel there is a fear the hotel will be sold at a discount price. If there is a
change in ownership there is no knowing what will happen at the hotel.
Stay APT has very little experience in this industry having only opened their first hotel on October
1st, 2020. They also misrepresent themselves as having 100 hotels but in fact they only have 14
hotels operating. The remaining only hotels in the fact that these are paid for franchise agreements
sold. This also brings up the statistics they produce about their ratings and low crime are for a very
small number of hotels for a very short time. It appears that Stay APT is going through a non-
controlled rate of growth. Uncontrolled growth is considered a very risky way to operate. There is no
long term history to understand what is Hotel Chains is actually going to be in 5-10 years.
Thank you for your time.
Barry Prather
1
Lerma, Alex
From:
Randy Huston <Yellowstoneta@yellowstoneta.com>
Sent:
Saturday, August 19, 2023 1:47 PM
To:
Walker-Hall, Tawanda; Perry, Tabitha; Lerma, Alex
Subject:
Planning Commission meeting comments for August 24th meeting
Attachments:
Stay APT project comments.docx
To whom it may concern:
Here is my comments for the Planning Commission meeting on August 24th. Please submit this opinion page
to the Commissioners.
Best Regards,
Randy Huston, CFP®
Yellowstone Trust Administration, Inc.
Randy Huston's direct lines:
Phone: 800-572-6394
Fax: 602-926-2584
2070 Overland Ave., Suite 104
Billings, MT 59102
Website: www.yellowstoneta.com
Email: yellowstoneta@yellowstoneta.com
Note: Unless otherwise specifically noted in this e-mail letter, the author is not engaged in rendering legal, accounting, tax or other professional services with the
dissemination of information in this e-mail letter. The opinions expressed in this e-mail, while intended to be accurate, are for general educational and
informational purposes only.
Some people who received this message don't often get email from yellowstoneta@yellowstoneta.com. Learn why this is important
Planning Commission Hearing for Stay APT project
To whom it may concern:
I was at the meeting at the Foothill Aquatic Center on Monday, August 7th for the presentation
and questions for the Stay APT project.
The developer group did a great job of explaining how the project is not the typical Extended
Stay hotel. They clearly explained that the price point is higher than typical Extended Stay
Hotels, that they have the on-site manager to keep things under control as well as explaining
why the clientele is mostly a working during the day group of clients and not the type of patron
who would likely be a threat to the neighborhood.
I live in the Hidden Manor neighborhood on the west side of 75th Ave and go to the food
establishments often near the project property.
I am an owner of Yellowstone Trust Administration and know what it means to start your own
business with the needed capital and time to put into it to make it successful. This appears to
be a major personal commitment by the Developer who has a lot at stake to be a good
neighbor at this site. I attended the meeting to see what the project is and to see if it was
possibly the type of Extended Stay hotel that would be all the problems that some people were
inferring about the project. I was totally convinced that this is a good project and an asset to
the neighborhood.
At the meeting, the opposing points were very directly refuted, even though the same
misinformed points were repeated over and over by audience members:
Problems with the typical ESH – this is not a typical ESH (fewer police calls, better security, on
site manager, little traffic access to the neighborhood
Line of site problems – there is already a line of site problem with the IRS building and the other
large stores
Dumpster pickup at 5 am noise – there is already dumpster pickup noise at 5 am for existing
businesses
I hope that the Planning Commission approves this project and look forward to having relatives
and business associates stay at this nice Hotel close to my house.
Best Regards,
Randy Huston, CFP®
Yellowstone Trust Administration, Inc. 800-572-6394
From:
Randy Huston
To:
Walker-Hall, Tawanda; Perry, Tabitha; Lerma, Alex
Subject:
Planning Commission meeting comments for August 24th meeting
Date:
Saturday, August 19, 2023 1:46:58 PM
Attachments:
Stay APT project comments.docx
Some people who received this message don't often get email from yellowstoneta@yellowstoneta.com. Learn why
this is important
To whom it may concern:
Here is my comments for the Planning Commission meeting on August 24th. Please submit
this opinion page to the Commissioners.
Best Regards,
Randy Huston, CFP®
Yellowstone Trust Administration, Inc.
Randy Huston's direct lines:
Phone: 800-572-6394
Fax: 602-926-2584
2070 Overland Ave., Suite 104
Billings, MT 59102
Website: www.yellowstoneta.com
Email: yellowstoneta@yellowstoneta.com
Note: Unless otherwise specifically noted in this e-mail letter, the author is not engaged in rendering legal, accounting, tax or other
professional services with the dissemination of information in this e-mail letter. The opinions expressed in this e-mail, while intended to
be accurate, are for general educational and informational purposes only.
Planning Commission Hearing for Stay APT project
To whom it may concern:
I was at the meeting at the Foothill Aquatic Center on Monday, August 7th for the presentation
and questions for the Stay APT project.
The developer group did a great job of explaining how the project is not the typical Extended
Stay hotel. They clearly explained that the price point is higher than typical Extended Stay
Hotels, that they have the on-site manager to keep things under control as well as explaining
why the clientele is mostly a working during the day group of clients and not the type of patron
who would likely be a threat to the neighborhood.
I live in the Hidden Manor neighborhood on the west side of 75th Ave and go to the food
establishments often near the project property.
I am an owner of Yellowstone Trust Administration and know what it means to start your own
business with the needed capital and time to put into it to make it successful. This appears to
be a major personal commitment by the Developer who has a lot at stake to be a good
neighbor at this site. I attended the meeting to see what the project is and to see if it was
possibly the type of Extended Stay hotel that would be all the problems that some people were
inferring about the project. I was totally convinced that this is a good project and an asset to
the neighborhood.
At the meeting, the opposing points were very directly refuted, even though the same
misinformed points were repeated over and over by audience members:
Problems with the typical ESH – this is not a typical ESH (fewer police calls, better security, on
site manager, little traffic access to the neighborhood
Line of site problems – there is already a line of site problem with the IRS building and the other
large stores
Dumpster pickup at 5 am noise – there is already dumpster pickup noise at 5 am for existing
businesses
I hope that the Planning Commission approves this project and look forward to having relatives
and business associates stay at this nice Hotel close to my house.
Best Regards,
Randy Huston, CFP®
Yellowstone Trust Administration, Inc. 800-572-6394
From:
bpray
To:
Walker-Hall, Tawanda
Subject:
Re: CUP 23 04
Date:
Monday, August 21, 2023 10:50:00 AM
Attachments:
Stay Apt Citizen Report.pdf
Good Morning Tawanda,
I reviewed the documents attached to the Planning Commission meeting agenda regarding
CUP 23 04 for StayApt. Unfortunately, my citizen particiaption document below was not
included. Instead my opposition document was posted twice.
Is there any way to rectify this?
Thank You,
Pam Ray
On Aug 17, 2023, at 12:29 PM, bpray <bpray@cox.net> wrote:
Good Afternoon Tawanda,
I had understood anything I sent to Matthew and copied staff on would be in the
packet.
Will the attached Citizen Report I sent him on Monday be included? I was
expecting so or I would have sent that as well yesterday.
Thank You
Pam Ray
On Aug 17, 2023, at 9:29 AM, Walker-Hall, Tawanda
<TWalker@GLENDALEAZ.com> wrote:
Good morning Pam –
Your email seven (7) page opposition presentation has been received and
included in the Planning Commissioners' packets.
Thank you for your feedback.
Enjoy the balance of your week!
You don't often get email from bpray@cox.net. Learn why this is
important
We are moving…
Glendale City Hall is being remodeled. Effective Monday, August 21, 2023,
Development Services Department - Building Safety/ Planning will be located at 5754
W Glenn Drive formerly known as The Bead Museum. All department emails and
phone numbers will remain the same.
From: bpray <bpray@cox.net>
Sent: Thursday, August 17, 2023 7:44 AM
To: Walker-Hall, Tawanda <TWalker@GLENDALEAZ.com>
Cc: Perry, Tabitha <TPerry@GLENDALEAZ.com>; Lerma, Alex
<alerma@GLENDALEAZ.com>; Malnar, Raymond
<RMalnar@GLENDALEAZ.COM>; Taylor, Matthew
<MTaylor@GLENDALEAZ.com>
Subject: Re: CUP 23 04
Good Morning Tawanda,
Thank you for the confirmation. I also sent documents on 8/15. Can you
please confirm they will also be included in the packet?
If you need me to send them again, please advise.
Thank You,
Pam Ray
623-498-7595
bpray@cox.net
On Aug 16, 2023, at 11:52 AM, Walker-Hall, Tawanda
<TWalker@GLENDALEAZ.com> wrote:
Greetings, Pam Ray –
Some people who received this message don't often get
email frombpray@cox.net. Learn why this is important
Your presentation and comments have been received and
will be included in the Planning Commissioners' August
24th packets.
Thank you,
We are moving…
Glendale City Hall is being remodeled. Effective Monday, August 21,
2023, Development Services Department - Building Safety/ Planning
will be located at 5754 W Glenn Drive formerly known as The Bead
Museum. All department emails and phone numbers will remain the
same.
From: bpray <bpray@cox.net>
Sent: Wednesday, August 16, 2023 11:44 AM
To: Taylor, Matthew <MTaylor@GLENDALEAZ.com>
Cc: Walker-Hall, Tawanda <TWalker@GLENDALEAZ.com>;
Perry, Tabitha <TPerry@GLENDALEAZ.com>; Lerma, Alex
<alerma@GLENDALEAZ.com>; Malnar, Raymond
<RMalnar@GLENDALEAZ.COM>
Subject: CUP 23 04
Good Morning Matthew,
Attached is a document I prepared outlining why we believe
the CUP 23 04 should be denied according to city guidelines.
It also includes stipulations we suggest if for some reason
the use is approved.
Thank You
Pam Ray
623-498-7595
bpray@cox.net
Ray Family Impacts
StayApt CUP 23 04
Ray Resident’s Citizen Participation Report
The Ray Family
7305 W Angela Drive
Live Directly North (260’) of the Proposed StayApt Hotel
Ray Resident’s Citizen Participation Report
• With a 300 foot notification guideline and large lots in the neighborhood only 3 residential neighbors were notified about the virtual
neighborhood meeting in April
• All 3 plus one more neighbor attended the April meeting - There was 100% opposition
• We understand the city recognizes the limited notifications using a 300 foot boundary and is in the process of updating them with the goal
of reaching a larger audience
• Fortunately neighbor’s have been speaking to each other with some posting signs to get the word out - no one supports the use of an extended
stay hotel
• There are over 600 signatures on the petition opposing the use
• 100% of residents are opposed to the use
• Due to the amount of opposition Council Member Ray Malnar held a community meeting
• There were over 100 people at the meeting - all would have attended the meeting in April had they known about it
• Not one resident in attendance was in favor of the use
• Councilman Malnar said the meeting was strictly informational and cannot be considered by the planning commission
• Why can’t the planning commission be aware of such a strong opposition?
• The notification sign for the public hearing by Planning Commission was initially posted behind the only overgrown vegetation on the lot
• The placement seems to be suspicious, we believe the sign was put up by a subcontractor who would have been told where to place the sign
• The applicant has since moved the sign due complaints
Notification Concerns
Ray Resident’s Citizen Participation Report
• Safety Concerns have been raised due to extended stay hotels having high crime rates Citizens have cited concerns such as aggressive
panhandling, human trafficking, drug use, and transients.
• Applicant recognizes there are crime issues with low budget extended stay hotels - To address the concerns:
• Applicant has stated the StayApt chain has lower crime rates than competitive extended stay hotels
• Applicant has stated this StayApt won’t have issues because there is keyed access to the building using an app, guest must have a
credit card, a general manager will be living on site, and the hotel is upscale and modern
• The applicant stated their rates would be $92/night in the virtual neighborhood meeting in April which is inline with Extended
Stay America
• At the community meeting on August 7th they stated there rated would be $166/night and that this would equal $3,000/month(?)
• What happens to the neighborhood security as the building ages?
• Applicant will have security cameras however the number and location are not determined
• Applicant will not have perimeter fencing as an added security measure
• Report notes there isn’t a neighborhood uniform architectural or color scheme in the neighborhood north of the parcel
• There is an architectural & color scheme in the existing surrounding commercial buildings, which is what the neighborhood
participants were referring to.
• Existing commercial buildings were developed following the North Valley Area Specific Plan and should be applied
• Report did not include the neighbor’s request for larger evergreen trees to be planted
• Applicant has subsequently offered to purchase trees to be planted in the Ray Family backyard
Corrections and Updates
Ray Resident’s Citizen Participation Report
• Report did not mention the flaws identified in the line of sight view provided
• The report stated the proposed hotel would be 400 feet from homes - It is only 260 feet from the Ray
family home
• As a point of reference a football field is 360 feet long with expected views from all seating
• Report states there is “potential visibility into residential back yards”
• This is NOT a potential or a possibility, it is a REALITY and the Impacts are not minimal
• Mr. Dymski agrees acknowledges there are privacy intrusions and visibility into our yards
• Report states the building was moved 65 ft to the west to shield most of, if not all, of the hotel building
views to the residential uses to the north
• Mr Dymski stated the building would not be moved further west due to it being too costly
• Mr. Dymski has offered to plant trees in the Ray’s backyard
• With a 3 story building, even 15 foot trees won’t provide a buffer for years to come
• Trees in our yard will not help neighbors who will have privacy issues as well
Corrections and Updates Continued
Ray Resident’s Citizen Participation Report
• In a meeting/call with City of Glendale Planning Department on 7/19 we were told:
• Citizen Participation Reports are not updated or corrected
• Our concerns are reasonable, understandable and valuable
• They can impact your quality of life
• Hold firm with our concerns, bring them up at the planning commission
• Suggest changes and stipulations to the planning commission
Corrections and Updates
From:
Debbie Carlston
To:
Walker-Hall, Tawanda; tperry@glendaleaz.co; Lerma, Alex
Subject:
Secluded Acres... stay APTS Suites... AGAINST
Date:
Monday, August 21, 2023 6:19:39 PM
Some people who received this message don't often get email from 2vettenut@gmail.com. Learn why this is
important
Dear Planning Commission Members,
My name is Debbie Carlston/resident/home owner in Secluded Acres ( and I would like to
keep it this way... secluded ), the neighborhood in question for a proposed stay APT Suites.
Our neighborhood is just north of the area they "wish" to build.
I am completely and entirely opposed/against to the building of any extended stay motel,
hotel, and any other short term living facility for many reasons, which I will list below.
1. SAFETY...the safety of our "children", our homes/property, pets and of course ourselves.
a. Our children to play in the neighborhood without fear of an added facility with many
people coming and going.
b . Our children not to be approached my sex traffickers, pill pushers, child traffickers and
people who get off with children and porn.
c. Our children need to feel safe as well as parents, grandparents raising children that they
can ride bikes in the neighborhood and on the bike path that is close to Secluded Acres and the
proposed site in question.
d. I want to feel safe myself walking and riding my bike.
e. Our home is located next to the wash and a concrete wall (6ft.), it will make it very
accessible for stay APT residents to access it, look into our yards, enter our yards if they see
something they are interested in.
f. Our home for theft/vandalism/trash as they walk our neighborhood drinking, eating,
smoking, talking on their phones taking a walk ....as residents of APT are coming and going.
g. Our pets....if they are going to choose walking their pets ( on or off a leash ) in our quiet
neighborhood....our pets may be challenged/possibly getting hurt.
h. Schools are close... too close for safety of riding bikes, walking and added traffic, not to
mention the predators that look and wait for our sweet precious children. Arrowhead
Elementary on Union Hills Dr. is the closest school in question not to mention Jr. High and
High schools.
I strongly feel that our "safety" will be compromised by any criminal activity from ANY stay
APT
2. Property Values... will decline this is a for sure thing. Homes in our area are purchased for
safe living with no HOA and an area that increases for our financial retirement.
3. stay APT is planned to be a 3 story building, which will compromise many of our
neighbors to the south of our home. Allowing residents of stay APT to look into their homes.
a. Trees... is not the answer unless stay APT plans on paying for the planting, watering and
trimming of these trees.....that they cannot plant on stay APT property because there is not
efficient space to plant....on their property.
b. Privacy... is why we live here on larger lots with Secluded views.
We do not want our privacy compromised in anyway ....it is why we live here.
4. Traffic.... this will bring more traffic into our neighborhood and especially on Grovers and
73rd Ave. These roads lead North to the Phoenix Children's Hospital, CCV ( if they wish to
attend church), Midwestern University, and many business/eating locations.
a. the road in question from stay APT to 75th is a dangerous road now and it will be even
worse IF this goes through.
b. there are not sidewalks and this will make it unsafe for residents of stay APT to walk to the
Arrowhead Mall and surrounding businesses/eating locations.
I work daily at a local elementary school with kiddos with special needs, Autism, Epilepsy,
Serum Palsy behaviors and more. This is definitely in the RED ZONE = NOT
ACCEPTABLE.
Finally, I am totally opposed to the building of stay APT or any facility of this kind, near our
Secluded Acres. I do not approve in any way or form, nor can I be persuaded by the pretty
interiors and newness of it....as it will compromise our "children"..."safety"..."home
values" ..."traffic".
Thank you for reading and taking our Secluded Acres into consideration.
Debbie Carlston
7116 W. Villa Theresa Dr.
Glendale, AZ
85308
Phone # 602-547-2110
1
Lerma, Alex
From:
grammygail923@cox.net
Sent:
Tuesday, August 22, 2023 2:09 PM
To:
Lerma, Alex
Subject:
Proposed STAY APARTMENTS at 73rd Avenue and Camino San Xavier
Dear Mr. Lerma,
We have lived on 73rd Ave at St John in Secluded Acres for 20 years. We raised our daughter here and now are raising 2
grandchildren. Secluded Acres and Secluded Estates is a liƩle piece of country hidden right behind a busy commercial
area. No curbs or sidewalks, limited street lighƟng, and a variety of incredible unique homes on lots measured by the
acre. With one of the lowest crime rates in the Glendale and the Phoenix area, people acƟvely seek to buy here, and
homes sell quickly. We have no HOA, yet properƟes are well maintained. Many self-employed contractors and business
owners live here including us before our reƟrement. We are a neighborhood of folks who like making their own choices!
As the commercial area along Camino San Xavier has grown, liƩle has changed for residents. Development has been
respecƞul of the neighborhood. Nothing is visible from our homes, no property towers over private residences. Although
exisƟng businesses have slightly different hours of operaƟon, they are basically all service or retail, with morning-to-
evening hours with restaurants open the latest. People from Glendale, Peoria, Sun City, etc. come and go during normal
business hours in a steady trickle morning to night. In our 20 years here, there has never been a reason to noƟce, much
less object to commercial development. It has always been a convenience, never a problem.
The proposed Stay Apartments has changed that.
A three-story building at the property line of our neighborhood cannot be totally blocked from our view, nor can the
views into our yards and at night into our windows be blocked unless rooms are windowless. No other business brings
dozens of non-residents to stay 24/7 in our neighborhood. Secluded Acres and Estates will be secluded no more. There is
no quesƟon that this will lower property values, significantly dragging down values in nearby neighborhoods such as
Hidden Manor and Arrowhead as well.
Camino San Xavier is a narrow, almost alley-like street with no way to widen it. It has a hairpin turn that can be
dangerous. With 72 units on a plot the size of 2-4 Secluded Acres lots, the traffic will be bad even if only half full. The
developer states mostly professional people would be staying there; if so, dozens of them would be trying to get out or
in during AM and PM rush hours, with only 73rd to Bell and Camino San Xavier at 75th Avenue as street exits.
Safety is my greatest concern. The gentleman seeking to build is not from Glendale, or AZ or even the Southwest. He
lives over 2000 miles away and will not be around when things go wrong. At Councilman Malnar’s meeƟng possible
crime was discussed not prevenƟvely, but from the view of how things would be handled aŌer-the-fact. I personally
have had that experience.
Several years ago, my just-turned-eighteen daughter, who is cogniƟvely disabled and Seriously Mentally Ill, asked to
walk our dog around the block. She instead walked to the McDonalds at 75th Ave and Bell. There, a man 20 years her
senior quickly tuned in to her disability and invited her to his room at the Extended Stay Motel 2 blocks away. Once
there, he took nude photos of and had sexual relaƟons with her. I was later able to piece together what happened.
Because I did not yet have guardianship, and my daughter was just weeks over 18, Peoria PD refused to press rape
charges. This was against my objecƟons and those of the ER doctor who quickly ascertained and told them that she
could not give consent. I later found the man’s Facebook page, where he laughed about what happened and referred to
my daughter as “slow.”
You don't often get email from grammygail923@cox.net. Learn why this is important
2
While upset and concerned since hearing of this proposal, the meeƟng at Foothills RecreaƟon brought up feelings about
that incident I thought were long gone. I have been suffering physical anxiety symptoms since, as I think about a similar
business being just 4 houses away. Our neighborhood would be forever changed, not in a good way.
This is the wrong business to build next to a highly desirable residenƟal area, a quarter mile from a hiking and biking
trail, a block from a school bus stop. It will predominantly serve people with no connecƟon to our area. While some
locals may take up residence, I fear it could lead to doubling and tripling up, a situaƟon I have observed firsthand in the
disability community. It oŌen involves people who take advantage of others financially.
From peƩy theŌ to breaking and entering to scarier crimes, this complex will offer access and cover for lawbreakers and
troublemakers overnight. I see no benefit to the longƟme residents of the area. Some businesses will see a small benefit,
as those staying there buy a sub sandwich or a pizza, but no furniture, home decor or new car. These are not people
puƫng down roots in our community.
I sincerely hope this commiƩee agrees that this is neither the right business or building for this site. It would be very
detrimental to our neighborhood and others nearby. It compromises our privacy, our property values, and our
safety. So far, there has been a happy marriage of residenƟal and business here. Please assure that good relaƟonship
conƟnues, one favoring the long-term value and stability of this area.
Thank you for your consideraƟon.
Gail Tewalt and Family
From:
grammygail923@cox.net
To:
Walker-Hall, Tawanda
Subject:
Proposed STAY APARTMENTS at 73rd Avenue and Camino San Xavier
Date:
Tuesday, August 22, 2023 2:05:34 PM
You don't often get email from grammygail923@cox.net. Learn why this is important
Dear Ms. Walker,
We have lived on 73rd Ave at St John in Secluded Acres for 20 years. We raised our daughter here
and now are raising 2 grandchildren. Secluded Acres and Secluded Estates is a little piece of country
hidden right behind a busy commercial area. No curbs or sidewalks, limited street lighting, and a
variety of incredible unique homes on lots measured by the acre. With one of the lowest crime rates
in the Glendale and the Phoenix area, people actively seek to buy here, and homes sell quickly. We
have no HOA, yet properties are well maintained. Many self-employed contractors and business
owners live here including us before our retirement. We are a neighborhood of folks who like
making their own choices!
As the commercial area along Camino San Xavier has grown, little has changed for residents.
Development has been respectful of the neighborhood. Nothing is visible from our homes, no
property towers over private residences. Although existing businesses have slightly different hours
of operation, they are basically all service or retail, with morning-to-evening hours with restaurants
open the latest. People from Glendale, Peoria, Sun City, etc. come and go during normal business
hours in a steady trickle morning to night. In our 20 years here, there has never been a reason to
notice, much less object to commercial development. It has always been a convenience, never a
problem.
The proposed Stay Apartments has changed that.
A three-story building at the property line of our neighborhood cannot be totally blocked from our
view, nor can the views into our yards and at night into our windows be blocked unless rooms are
windowless. No other business brings dozens of non-residents to stay 24/7 in our neighborhood.
Secluded Acres and Estates will be secluded no more. There is no question that this will lower
property values, significantly dragging down values in nearby neighborhoods such as Hidden Manor
and Arrowhead as well.
Camino San Xavier is a narrow, almost alley-like street with no way to widen it. It has a hairpin turn
that can be dangerous. With 72 units on a plot the size of 2-4 Secluded Acres lots, the traffic will be
bad even if only half full. The developer states mostly professional people would be staying there; if
so, dozens of them would be trying to get out or in during AM and PM rush hours, with only 73rd to
Bell and Camino San Xavier at 75th Avenue as street exits.
Safety is my greatest concern. The gentleman seeking to build is not from Glendale, or AZ or even
the Southwest. He lives over 2000 miles away and will not be around when things go wrong. At
Councilman Malnar’s meeting possible crime was discussed not preventively, but from the view of
how things would be handled after-the-fact. I personally have had that experience.
Several years ago, my just-turned-eighteen daughter, who is cognitively disabled and Seriously
Mentally Ill, asked to walk our dog around the block. She instead walked to the McDonalds at 75th
Ave and Bell. There, a man 20 years her senior quickly tuned in to her disability and invited her to his
room at the Extended Stay Motel 2 blocks away. Once there, he took nude photos of and had sexual
relations with her. I was later able to piece together what happened. Because I did not yet have
guardianship, and my daughter was just weeks over 18, Peoria PD refused to press rape charges.
This was against my objections and those of the ER doctor who quickly ascertained and told them
that she could not give consent. I later found the man’s Facebook page, where he laughed about
what happened and referred to my daughter as “slow.”
While upset and concerned since hearing of this proposal, the meeting at Foothills Recreation
brought up feelings about that incident I thought were long gone. I have been suffering physical
anxiety symptoms since, as I think about a similar business being just 4 houses away. Our
neighborhood would be forever changed, not in a good way.
This is the wrong business to build next to a highly desirable residential area, a quarter mile from a
hiking and biking trail, a block from a school bus stop. It will predominantly serve people with no
connection to our area. While some locals may take up residence, I fear it could lead to doubling and
tripling up, a situation I have observed firsthand in the disability community. It often involves people
who take advantage of others financially.
From petty theft to breaking and entering to scarier crimes, this complex will offer access and cover
for lawbreakers and troublemakers overnight. I see no benefit to the longtime residents of the area.
Some businesses will see a small benefit, as those staying there buy a sub sandwich or a pizza, but
no furniture, home decor or new car. These are not people putting down roots in our community.
I sincerely hope this committee agrees that this is neither the right business or building for this site.
It would be very detrimental to our neighborhood and others nearby. It compromises our privacy,
our property values, and our safety. So far, there has been a happy marriage of residential and
business here. Please assure that good relationship continues, one favoring the long-term value and
stability of this area.
Thank you for your consideration.
Gail Tewalt and Family
From:
Mary Park
To:
Taylor, Matthew
Subject:
Opposing CUP 23-04
Date:
Wednesday, August 16, 2023 10:08:19 AM
You don't often get email from mbpark814@gmail.com. Learn why this is important
Dear Planning Commission, Mr. Taylor
My name is Mary Park and I am a resident of Buckeye. Although I am a resident of
another city, I am a frequent shopper and visitor of the Glendale area and belong to
organizations that gather in Glendale often. I am writing to oppose the CUP 23-04 -
Modern Stay near Arrowhead Mall.
The Hotel’s location would be too close to a School and also it takes away the privacy of
the neighbors from the upper floors. With the Phoenix area so close it would expand the
safety issue of children because of the criminals for Human Trafficking, Kidnapping not
to mention the additional traffic.
I sincerely hope you consider opposing the Modern StayApt and am asking you to vote
NO for the CUP 23-04.
Thank you,
Mary Park
mbpark814@gmail.com
From:
Erin Cole
To:
Taylor, Matthew
Cc:
Lerma, Alex; Malnar, Raymond; Perry, Tabitha; Walker-Hall, Tawanda
Subject:
Re: August 7th Meeting Follow Up From Council Member Malnar
Date:
Friday, August 18, 2023 8:13:54 AM
Wonderful news!
It has not been mentioned that the amendment was going to be added to this new agenda,
hence my confusion.
See you all next week!
-Erin
On Fri, Aug 18, 2023 at 8:10 AM Taylor, Matthew <MTaylor@glendaleaz.com> wrote:
Erin,
The city received an amended CPP final report from the applicant after the neighborhood
meeting. It will be available on the city’s public meetings and notices page later today as an
agenda item attachment.
From: Erin Cole <erinscole@gmail.com>
Sent: Friday, August 18, 2023 8:02 AM
To: Taylor, Matthew <MTaylor@GLENDALEAZ.com>
Cc: Lerma, Alex <alerma@GLENDALEAZ.com>; Malnar, Raymond
<RMalnar@GLENDALEAZ.COM>; Perry, Tabitha <TPerry@GLENDALEAZ.com>;
Walker-Hall, Tawanda <TWalker@GLENDALEAZ.com>
Subject: Re: August 7th Meeting Follow Up From Council Member Malnar
Thank you for your response.
I am very confused. I have attached a photo as a refresher. Deliberate or not, it was
misleading and incorrect. Mr. Alleman admitted it, and the City has been aware of it for
over 30 days.
Thanks,
Erin
On Fri, Aug 18, 2023 at 07:19 Taylor, Matthew <MTaylor@glendaleaz.com> wrote:
Good morning Erin,
As stated in my previous message, I am unaware of any deliberate or intentionally
misleading information provided by the applicant. That is my response as project
manager.
I encourage you to express concerns regarding this project during the August 24, 2023,
Planning Commission public hearing. Planning staff continues to work diligently to
ensure the Commission has all public input regarding this application prior to the public
hearing.
The public hearing agenda will be posted later today on the city’s public meetings and
notices page: Public Meetings & Notices - City of Glendale (glendaleaz.com).
Thank you.
From: Erin Cole <erinscole@gmail.com>
Sent: Friday, August 18, 2023 6:01 AM
To: Taylor, Matthew <MTaylor@GLENDALEAZ.com>
Cc: Malnar, Raymond <RMalnar@GLENDALEAZ.COM>; Walker-Hall, Tawanda
<TWalker@GLENDALEAZ.com>; Perry, Tabitha <TPerry@GLENDALEAZ.com>;
Lerma, Alex <alerma@GLENDALEAZ.com>
Subject: Re: August 7th Meeting Follow Up From Council Member Malnar
Good morning,
2nd request: Please review attached response from Mr. Alleman, June 29 at 0927.
Perhaps I have overlooked a detail, but in what forum and when did the applicant
respond to my accusations? I did not receive any written response and would like to have
a copy. Please let me know what I need to ask for in a PRR to receive the applicant's
response.
And I have noted zero reply regarding last week's meeting. I am grateful the Rays were
able to attend on such short, unannounced notice.
Thanks,
Erin
On Thu, Aug 10, 2023 at 8:26 AM Erin Cole <erinscole@gmail.com> wrote:
Good morning,
Thank you for your reply!
Please review attached response from Mr. Alleman, June 29 at 0927. Perhaps I have
overlooked a detail, but in what forum and when did the applicant respond to my
accusations? I did not receive any written response and would like to have a copy.
Please let me know what I need to ask for in a PRR to receive the applicant's response.
Also, I noticed there is a P&Z Commission Workshop tonight. Will this meeting be
broadcast on YouTube like the other P&Z Commission meetings? My neighbors and I
would love to attend this public meeting, but we didn't receive any notice from the City
website.
Thank you all!
Erin Cole
602.770.9799
erinscole@gmail.com
On Thu, Aug 10, 2023 at 8:06 AM Taylor, Matthew <MTaylor@glendaleaz.com>
wrote:
Good morning Erin,
Yes, email correspondence will be provided to the Planning Commission prior to the
public hearing.
The applicant responded to your accusation of falsifying application information – as
project manager for this item, I am unaware of any deliberate falsifications made by
the applicant. I encourage you to express this concern on the record during the public
hearing.
Thank you.
From: Erin Cole <erinscole@gmail.com>
Sent: Wednesday, August 9, 2023 8:20 PM
To: Malnar, Raymond <RMalnar@GLENDALEAZ.COM>
Cc: Taylor, Matthew <MTaylor@GLENDALEAZ.com>; Walker-Hall, Tawanda
<TWalker@GLENDALEAZ.com>; Perry, Tabitha
<TPerry@GLENDALEAZ.com>; Lerma, Alex <alerma@GLENDALEAZ.com>
Subject: Re: August 7th Meeting Follow Up From Council Member Malnar
Hi Ray,
Thank you for your email. And thank you, again, for hosting the meeting.
I trust that the countless emails that Mr. Taylor has already received will be included
in P&Z Commission's packet, and that the linked email addresses will be
supplementing what has already been sent? Perhaps City staff can confirm that... ?
In addition, this is my third request to City staff asking the ramifications of an
applicant providing false information on their submitted report. Please advise if the
P&Z Commission was notified of the erroneous report, the penalties thereof, and how
the City will ensure that the next report is accurate.
Thanks to you all!
Erin Cole
602.770.9799
erinscole@gmail.com
On Wed, Aug 9, 2023 at 1:32 PM Malnar, Raymond <RMalnar@glendaleaz.com>
wrote:
Dear Resident,
I would like to begin by thanking you for attending Monday’s meeting at the
Foothills Recreation and Aquatics Center. My goal in having this informational
meeting was to give more residents an opportunity to hear directly from the
developer and ask questions and express concerns.
Many of you expressed an interest in sending letters to the Planning Commission
prior to the request being heard at their meeting on August 24th at 6:00pm to be
located at Glendale Civic Center, 5750 W Glenn Dr, Glendale, AZ 85301 .
Please submit your letters to the following city staff: twalker@glendaleaz.com ,
tperry@glendaleaz.com , and alerma@glendaleaz.com .
If you plan on speaking, you will need to fill out a speaker card at the meeting. We
recommend that you prepare a statement prior to the meeting as you will be limited
to 3 minutes speaking time.
Additionally, my office confirmed with the City Clerk’s office that the agenda will
be posted by August 22nd. Once it’s posted, you can click HERE to review it.
Once again, thank you for attending this important meeting- should you have any
questions, please feel free to reach out.
Thank you,
Council Member Ray Malnar
Sahuaro District
From:
Perry, Tabitha
To:
Erin Cole; Lerma, Alex; Walker-Hall, Tawanda
Subject:
RE: Petition link attached
Date:
Wednesday, August 30, 2023 7:41:37 AM
Attachments:
image001.png
image002.png
Good morning.
Confirmed.
From: Erin Cole <erinscole@gmail.com>
Sent: Tuesday, August 29, 2023 6:31 PM
To: Lerma, Alex <alerma@GLENDALEAZ.com>; Perry, Tabitha <TPerry@GLENDALEAZ.com>; Walker-Hall, Tawanda <TWalker@GLENDALEAZ.com>
Subject: Re: Petition link attached
Hello City Staff,
Third request - please ensure this complete thread is added, or the entire threat removed as it is neither support nor opposition to this project.
I find it very unsettling and unprofessional that this was added as it meets zero criteria for inclusion, per Ms. Perry on August 23. Please explain to me the value this adds to the Commission's packet.
Thank you,
Erin Cole
602.770.9799
erinscole@gmail.com
On Wed, Aug 23, 2023 at 12:19 PM Erin Cole <erinscole@gmail.com> wrote:
Hi Tabitha,
Thank you for your call today.
This email needs to be added to show my response, please. It was forwarded well before the 0930 cut off today. If it cannot be added, then I respectfully request the entire thread be removed.
To your point on our call, the addition of certain messages add value (in either opposition or support). This email thread between Mr. Swanson and I does not qualify as either. While I realize he is trying to be amenable to the City due to his financial arrangements/contracts, it does not qualify as opposition or support for CUP 23-04. With that, it paints a picture that I am using OSBI in an unethical fashion - which is absolutely not the case. It is noted that my reply was not submitted by OSBI and/or its assignees.
As always, I thank you for your time.
Erin Cole
602.770.9799
erinscole@gmail.com
On Sun, Aug 20, 2023 at 9:33 AM Erin Cole <erinscole@gmail.com> wrote:
Good morning,
While reading through the Citizen Comments of CUP 23-04, I noticed the below correspondence was submitted, but was missing the requested response and my reply.
Please be sure to add this to the packet at page 59. I replied, cc'd the neighbor (below), and he edited his signs that afternoon.
I can only assume the exclusion of this response was an oversight.
From my experience, agenda edits are allowable up to the afternoon of the scheduled meeting. I trust this will be added.
Regards,
Erin Cole
602.770.9799
erinscole@gmail.com
---------- Forwarded message ---------
From: Erin Cole <erinscole@gmail.com>
Date: Thu, Jun 15, 2023 at 4:19 PM
Subject: Re: Petition link attached
To: Jeff Swanson <jeffswanson@osbi.org>
Cc: Barry And Paula Prather <sss510@cox.net>, Mike Homco <mikehomco@osbi.org>
Mr. Swanson,
Received.
My apologies for the confusion on the flyer, though I am not the author nor distributor. I have spoken to that individual and cc’d him. He stated he will correct the verbiage.
I received and thanked you for your detailed email (below), and have since removed OSBI from the email list, with no further contact until today.
While I am coordinating many efforts to oppose this proposed project, I have no control of the actions of others. It is, for lack of a better term, an unorganized “hodgepodge” of families and homeowners trying to do their part(s), all while working full time, going to school full time, raising families, caring for elderly family members, etc. That said, I can understand why OSBI would assume it was my doing as I have been your only point of contact.
Erin
On Thu, Jun 15, 2023 at 15:42 Jeff Swanson <jeffswanson@osbi.org> wrote:
Ms. Cole,
I received a call from an individual this afternoon that saw your neighborhood posting specific to the project we discussed several weeks ago in my office at One Step Beyond, and they sent me the attached photo.
I’d ask that you remove/change the verbiage ASAP…as we discussed, One Step Beyond provides programming for ADULTS who have intellectual disabilities (not challenged), we serve ZERO children/youth as is clearly depicted on the flyer…and this is misleading/not appropriate to many residents, many of whom support us financially and through volunteer efforts and know the quality of our programs and those we serve.
Please reply that you received this and the action taken. I sent you a pretty detailed message last week (below) with the recommendations on the proper ways to address the project (specific to zoning/permitting) with the City of Glendale.
Jeff
Jeff Swanson
Executive Director of Administration
C: 602-768-3868 | O: 623-215-2449
9299 W. Olive Ave. | Suite 311 | Peoria, AZ 85345
OSBI.org
Unless expressly specified otherwise, this email and its contents, attached, referenced, or otherwise, ("Contents") do NOT contain legal, financial, or tax advice; and rather, represent the (business) opinions of the author only. We are a 501(c) 3 non-profit organization (EIN: 86-1036448, QCO 20638) EST. 2003, One Step Beyond, Inc. provides unique and empowering programs and services to individuals who have Intellectual Disabilities and their families by creating unique opportunities and promoting community inclusion. This message and the Contents are intended solely for the person(s) to whom they are directly and intentionally sent, and may contain privileged, protected, and/or confidential information. If you receive this message by mistake or otherwise and/or are a non-intended recipient, please destroy this message and Contents immediately. Thank you.
From: Erin Cole <erinscole@gmail.com>
Sent: Friday, June 9, 2023 6:17 AM
To: Jeff Swanson <jeffswanson@osbi.org>
Subject: Re: Petition link attached
Thanks, Jeff.
-Erin
On Thu, Jun 8, 2023 at 10:00 AM Jeff Swanson <jeffswanson@osbi.org> wrote:
Hi Erin,
Thanks for including us on this…
Unfortunately we have a zero solicitation policy in our contract with DES/DDD, and this potential project doesn’t affect services provided to our participants, so we can’t simply send this out to families and staff…I did see a couple days ago that the city posted the public meeting scheduled for 6/22…that seems like a great platform to meet with leadership.
I will share with you that I did in fact meet with several staff within City of Glendale regarding potential concerns several weeks ago that I could foresee, one of which was based solely on access points to entry/egress and the current traffic on Camino…
My recommendation to you would be to base your comments at the meeting on very specific zoning/permitting issues you see, NOT based on the pieces on the flyer (attached) circulated or the comments regarding drugs, crime, etc. While I might agree with you on the very distant “potential” to those things, its NOT what the City will base their zoning/permitting decisions on…
Hope this helps…
Jeff
Jeff Swanson
Executive Director of Administration
C: 602-768-3868 | O: 623-215-2449
9299 W. Olive Ave. | Suite 311 | Peoria, AZ 85345
OSBI.org
Unless expressly specified otherwise, this email and its contents, attached, referenced, or otherwise, ("Contents") do NOT contain legal, financial, or tax advice; and rather, represent the (business) opinions of the author only. We are a 501(c) 3 non-profit organization (EIN: 86-1036448, QCO 20638) EST. 2003, One Step Beyond, Inc. provides unique and empowering programs and services to individuals who have Intellectual Disabilities and their families by creating unique opportunities and promoting community inclusion. This message and the Contents are intended solely for the person(s) to whom they are directly and intentionally sent, and may contain privileged, protected, and/or confidential information. If you receive this message by mistake or otherwise and/or are a non-intended recipient, please destroy this message and Contents immediately. Thank you.
From: Erin Cole <erinscole@gmail.com>
Sent: Wednesday, June 7, 2023 8:55 PM
To: Jeff Swanson <jeffswanson@osbi.org>; Mike Homco <mikehomco@osbi.org>
Subject: Fwd: Petition link attached
Gentlemen,
I wanted to forward this email from my personal account, as perhaps the "NoToStayApt" was marked as spam through OSBI.
We have exceeded my original goal of 100 signatures, and need as many more as possible before the CUP Meeting 6/22 @ 6pm.
Please let me know what I can do to get your staff, members, and parents/guardians engaged.
Very respectfully,
Erin Cole
602.770.9799
erinscole@gmail.com
---------- Forwarded message ---------
From: NoTo StayApt <notostayapt@gmail.com>
Date: Sat, Jun 3, 2023 at 8:48 AM
Subject: Petition link attached
To: bkhutton@cox.net <bkhutton@cox.net>, bpray@cox.net <bpray@cox.net>, crabbyaz <crabbyaz@q.com>, D Adams <azchrome@yahoo.com>, Dan Mareska <danmareska@q.com>, Don Robertson <don.c.robertson@gmail.com>, erinscole@gmail.com <erinscole@gmail.com>, George Gaspar <georgesgaspar@yahoo.com>, gregacole@gmail.com <gregacole@gmail.com>, jeffswanson@osbi.org <jeffswanson@osbi.org>, jgatt@cox.net <jgatt@cox.net>, jillteaches@yahoo.com <jillteaches@yahoo.com>, Larry Alexander <aprilmoon821@gmail.com>, littl918@yahoo.com <littl918@yahoo.com>, Littlmrs7243@gmail.com <Littlmrs7243@gmail.com>, mikehomco@osbi.org <mikehomco@osbi.org>,
saranne1211@gmail.com <saranne1211@gmail.com>, skipcrandall@hotmail.com <skipcrandall@hotmail.com>, sss510@cox.net <sss510@cox.net>, <Paul.Carver@dvusd.org>, <Ann.Ordway@dvusd.org>
Hi all,
Please see attached petition, sign, and forward.
This is my first time making a petition, and first time on this website. I am open to suggestions...
Jeff and Mike: Is there a way we can get this forwarded to your staff and guardians of your members, please? Say the word, and you know I will do whatever I can.
Ann and Paul: What do I need to do to get this on DVUSD Board's next agenda? Parents need to be notified immediately. Say the word, and I will do anything in my power.
Reminder: CUP Meeting is 6/22/23 at 6pm at City Council, 5850 W. Glendale Ave. We need as many signatures as possible before the meeting. Please plan to attend. We need to have a presence!
Lastly, I don't have a Facebook account, and perhaps I should make one...? In any case, please share to yours, if you have one.
https://www.ipetitions.com/petition/no-to-stayapt-extended-stay
Thank you all!
Erin
--
Erin Cole
602.770.9799
erinscole@gmail.com
From:
Perry, Tabitha
To:
bpray
Cc:
Lerma, Alex; Walker-Hall, Tawanda
Subject:
FW: CUP 23 04
Date:
Wednesday, September 6, 2023 11:45:36 AM
Attachments:
Planning Commission Sept 14 B.pdf
Good morning Pam,
Received and confirmed to include in the 9/14 packet.
-----Original Message-----
From: William Ray <241logan@gmail.com>
Sent: Wednesday, September 6, 2023 10:52 AM
To: Perry, Tabitha <TPerry@GLENDALEAZ.com>
Cc: Lerma, Alex <alerma@GLENDALEAZ.com>
Subject: CUP 23 04
Good Morning Tabitha,
Can you please make sure the attachment is included in the Planning Commission packet for CUP 23 04? I believe
the CUP will be heard at the meeting on 9/14/23.
Thank You So Much,
Pam Ray
Planning Commission CUP 23 04 StayApt
The Ray Family
7305 W Angela Drive
Live Directly North (260’) of the Proposed StayApt Hotel
09/14/2023
Planning Commission
•We are the Ray Family and live only 260 ft north of the proposed development
•We believe the use , hours, colors and size of the building DO NOT fit the
surrounding buildings and neighborhood.
•Neighborhood Privacy and property values will be negatively impacted
•The negative impacts are in direct opposition to city CUP guidelines 3.605 and
policy CRR-2.5 which state the city should protect established neighborhoods and
not allow them to be negatively impacted
•Mr .Taylor with the City planning department agreed with our concerns, stated our
quality of life will be diminished and told us to hold firm
•The Planning Department said to suggest stipulations to you, the commission
Stipulations
•If this project is approved by the commission we request the following Stipulations:
•Stipulate the building to be limited to 2 stories
• This will be in conformity of surrounding buildings, reduce visibility from neighboring
backyards and help minimize the devaluation of our properties
• NOT unreasonable - 7 out of 15 of the operational StayApts are 2 story today
•Amend the proposed exterior privacy screen stipulation to require them on all windows with
views into residential yards - Final determination of windows requiring treatment will be
made when actual views can be safely and accurately determined
•Require the building colors to conform to the surrounding buildings in the business park
• The facility in Alexandria Virginia has colors suitable to our environment
•Thank you very much for your consideration of these stipulations