Extracted text (via pymupdf)
84507 characters
January 15, 2020
Z2019019
Page 1 of 2
Report to the Board of Supervisors
Prepared by the Maricopa County Planning and Development Department
Board Hearing Date:
January 15, 2020
Case #/Title:
Z2019019 – Anchorpoint Welding
Supervisor District:
3
Applicant/Owner:
Michael Rolland/Jonathan Thiele
Request:
Special Use Permit (SUP) for a Cottage Industry in the Rural-43
district
Site Location:
Generally located ¼ mile north of the NEC of Carefree Hwy.
and 10th St., in the New River area
Site Size:
Approximately 1.4 acres
County Island Status:
N/A
Additional
Comments:
Proposal is for a home-based welding business. There were 29
signatures of support received, 9 in opposition. At the
Planning and Zoning Commission hearing 3 people spoke
against the request and 2 in support. Subsequently, staff
received 3 Appeal of the P&Z Commission Recommendation
in opposition.
Commission
Recommendation:
On 12/12/19, the Commission voted 8-0 to recommend
approval of Z2019019 subject to conditions ‘a’ – ‘h’:
a.
Development of the site shall comply with the Site Plan entitled “Thiele Workshop“,
consisting of 2 full-size sheets, dated 4/24/2019, and stamped received October 4,
2019, except as modified by the following conditions.
b.
Development of the site shall be in conformance with the Narrative Report entitled
“Anchorpoint Welding”, consisting of 9 pages, dated May 9, 2019, and stamped
received October 4, 2019, except as modified by the following conditions.
c.
The following Planning Engineering conditions shall apply:
1.
Drainage review of planning and/or zoning cases is for conceptual design
only and does not represent final design approval nor shall it entitle applicants
to future designs that are not in conformance with Section 1205 of the
Maricopa County Zoning Ordinance and the Maricopa County Drainage
Policies and Standards.
January 15, 2020
Z2019019
Page 2 of 2
2.
All development and engineering design shall be in conformance with
Section 1205 of the Maricopa County Zoning Ordinance and current
engineering policies, standards and best practices at the time of application
for construction.
3.
The grading and drainage plan shall be modified per the attached
Engineering Plan Review Comments memo before submitting for the Building
permit.
4.
Storage of materials, walls/fence, parking and storm water retention are
prohibited in the MCDOT right-of-way.
d.
This Special Use Permit shall expire 10 years from the date of approval by the Board
of Supervisors for a period of 90 or more consecutive days, or upon termination of
the use, whichever occurs first. All of the site improvements shall be removed within
60 days of such termination or expiration.
e.
Noncompliance with any Maricopa County Regulation shall be grounds for
initiating a revocation of this Special Use Permit as set forth in the Maricopa County
Zoning Ordinance.
f.
The granting of this change in use of the property has been at the request of the
applicant, with the consent of the landowner. The granting of this approval allows
the property to enjoy uses in excess of those permitted by the zoning existing on
the date of application, subject to conditions. In the event of the failure to comply
with any condition, and at the time of expiration of the Special Use Permit, the
property shall revert to the zoning that existed on the date of application. It is,
therefore, stipulated and agreed that either revocation due to the failure to
comply with any conditions, or the expiration of the Special Use Permit, does not
reduce any rights that existed on the date of application to use, divide, sell or
possess the property and that there would be no diminution in value of the
property from the value it held on the date of application due to such revocation
or expiration of the Special Use Permit. The Special Use Permit enhances the value
of the property above its value as of the date the Special Use Permit is granted
and reverting to the prior zoning results in the same value of the property as if the
Special Use Permit had never been granted.
g.
Outdoor storage shall remain below the height of the perimeter wall.
h.
All commercial business work using power tools shall be conducted within an
enclosed building sound attenuated to achieve maximum of 55 db as measured
outside property lines.
Presented by:
Eric R. Smith, Planner
Reviewed by:
Darren Gerard, AICP, Planning Manager
Attachments:
12/12/19 P&Z Packet (38 pages)
12/12/19 P&Z handout opposition (10 pages)
Appeal of P&Z Commission Recommendation (12 pages)
Note:
12/12/19 Draft P&Z Minutes are not available as of the writing of this report, but can
be provided upon request later when available.
Z2019019
Page 1 of 6
Report to the Planning and Zoning Commission
Prepared by the Maricopa County Planning and Development Department
Case:
Z2019019 – Anchorpoint Welding
Hearing Date:
December 12, 2019
Supervisor District:
3
Applicant:
Michael Rolland, Anchorpoint Welding
Owner:
Jonathan Thiele
Request:
Special Use Permit (SUP) for a Cottage Industry (Welding Business) in
the Rural-43 district
Site Location:
Generally located ¼ mile north of the NEC of Carefree Hwy. and
10th St., in the New River area
Site Size:
Approx. 1.4 acres
Density:
N/A
County Island:
No
County Plan:
New River Area Plan - Rural Densities (0-1 d.u./ac)
Municipal Plan:
N/A
Municipal Comments:
None received to date
Support/Opposition:
29 signatures of support/6 of opposition
Recommendation:
Approve with conditions
Z2019019
Page 2 of 6
Project Summary:
1.
The purpose of this request is to obtain a Special Use Permit, to continue operations of a
custom welding business on the subject property. The business includes the installation of
flat beds attached to pickup trucks, welding services and custom steel fabrication.
According to the narrative, in order to control noise, dust, or light pollution mitigating
disruption to the neighboring community all business operations are conducted indoors.
Truck beds are delivered by a tractor-trailer on a monthly, sometimes bi-monthly, basis.
The proposed workshop will be a 60’ x 55’ fully enclosed steel building, positioned along
the eastern border, forty-feet from the southern boundary and twelve-feet from the
eastern boundary of the site. The narrative states the business is a low volume business,
where a customer visit to the property is minimal and does not increase neighborhood
traffic.
2.
According to the narrative, the business is specifically tailored, to ensure that the welding
complies with all minimum county requirements, and to preserve the current rural
character of the neighborhood. The business hours of operation are Monday – Friday,
9:00 a.m. to 5:00 p.m. No work is conducted outside of these days and times. There is a
single employee. No one else is permitted on the site for business purposes after hours.
3.
There are some items stored outdoors; the aforementioned truck beds stacked three
high, not to exceed 6’ (h) and not appearing above the fence line. The storage of the
stacked beds comprises approximately one-third of the rear portion of the outside area.
A forklift is employed to lift the truck beds onto the trucks being fitted for these beds.
Welding equipment is used as well as small hand-held power tools. All machinery will be
housed and used exclusively within the proposed workshop. Compressed oxygen and
acetylene, in cylinders, in its welding operations with both located in the shop. No lighting
is proposed for the project. An 8’ masonry block wall is proposed along the western side
of the site to further ensure that truck beds stored on the subject site are not visible, as
well as the delivering semi-trucks being able to enter and exit through a gated area. The
wall will separate the front from the rear blocking the view of any operations conducted
at the rear of the site. There is a violation case on the property (V201801196) with a
compliance agreement to bring the property into compliance by 12/31/19 with
completed permits/entitlements. Staff has administratively extended the compliance
deadline for 90 days to 3/31/20.
Existing On-Site and Adjacent Zoning / Land Use:
4.
On-site:
Rural-43/Single family residence
North:
Rural-43/Single family residence
South:
Rural-43/Single family residence
East:
Rural-43/Single family residence
West:
10th St. then Rural-43/Single family residence
Utilities and Services:
5.
Water:
Town of Cave Creek and Desert Hills Water Company
Wastewater:
Septic
School District:
Deer Valley Unified
Fire:
Daisy Mountain Firehouse
Police:
MCSO
Z2019019
Page 3 of 6
Zoning Map
Site Plan
Z2019019
Page 4 of 6
Aerial-photo
Right-of-Way:
6.
The following table includes existing and proposed half-width right-of-way and the future
classification based upon the Maricopa County Department of Transportation (MCDOT)
Major Streets and Routes Plan.
Street Name
Half-width Existing R/W
Half-width Proposed R/W
Future Classification
10th Street
40-ft
40-ft
Local
Adopted Plan:
7.
New River Area Plan (adopted April 7, 1999): The plan designates the site as Rural
Densities (0-1 du/ac.) The proposal is a commercial use, and as such, the request is not in
concert with the plan.
.
Z2019019
Page 5 of 6
Public Participation Summary:
8.
The applicant complied with the Maricopa County Citizen Review Process with the
required posting of the site and notification by first class mail to adjacent property owners
within 300’ of the subject parcel and interested parties. The applicant received
opposition and support to the proposal during the public participation process. The
applicant also provided a log of phone conversations. Staff received no calls, there
being 29 signatures of support and 8 of opposition as of writing of this staff report.
Opposition includes the New River Desert Hills Community Association (NRDHCA) who are
concerned with potential commercialization of the area.
Outstanding Concerns from Reviewing Agencies:
9.
N/A.
Staff Analysis:
10.
The proposed use meets the conditions outlined in the MCZO article 1301.1.18 under the
home-based cottage industry special use requirements. The proprietors resides on the
property. There were no discrepancies with the lot width, setbacks, or lot coverage,
according to the site plan. The use is commercial, where the business is conducted by a
single employee, and is not customer extensive. The property has a violation for
construction without permits and business in the residential zoning district. Staff is in
support of the proposed Special Use Permit for ten years.
Recommendation:
11.
For the reasons outline in this report, staff recommends the Commission motion for
Approval, subject to conditions ‘a’ – ‘f’.
a.
Development of the site shall comply with the Site Plan entitled “Thiele Workshop“,
consisting of 2 full-size sheets, dated 4/24/2019, and stamped received October 4,
2019, except as modified by the following conditions.
b.
Development of the site shall be in conformance with the Narrative Report entitled
“Anchorpoint Welding”, consisting of 9 pages, dated May 9, 2019, and stamped
received October 4, 2019, except as modified by the following conditions.
c.
The following Planning Engineering conditions shall apply:
1.
Drainage review of planning and/or zoning cases is for conceptual design
only and does not represent final design approval nor shall it entitle applicants
to future designs that are not in conformance with Section 1205 of the
Maricopa County Zoning Ordinance and the Maricopa County Drainage
Policies and Standards.
2.
All development and engineering design shall be in conformance with
Section 1205 of the Maricopa County Zoning Ordinance and current
engineering policies, standards and best practices at the time of application
for construction.
Z2019019
Page 6 of 6
3.
The grading and drainage plan shall be modified per the attached
Engineering Plan Review Comments memo before submitting for the Building
permit.
4.
Storage of materials, walls/fence, parking and storm water retention are
prohibited in the MCDOT right-of-way.
d.
This Special Use Permit shall expire 10 years from the date of approval by the Board
of Supervisors for a period of 90 or more consecutive days, or upon termination of
the use, whichever occurs first. All of the site improvements shall be removed within
60 days of such termination or expiration.
e.
Noncompliance with any Maricopa County Regulation shall be grounds for
initiating a revocation of this Special Use Permit as set forth in the Maricopa County
Zoning Ordinance.
f.
The granting of this change in use of the property has been at the request of the
applicant, with the consent of the landowner. The granting of this approval allows
the property to enjoy uses in excess of those permitted by the zoning existing on
the date of application, subject to conditions. In the event of the failure to comply
with any condition, and at the time of expiration of the Special Use Permit, the
property shall revert to the zoning that existed on the date of application. It is,
therefore, stipulated and agreed that either revocation due to the failure to
comply with any conditions, or the expiration of the Special Use Permit, does not
reduce any rights that existed on the date of application to use, divide, sell or
possess the property and that there would be no diminution in value of the
property from the value it held on the date of application due to such revocation
or expiration of the Special Use Permit. The Special Use Permit enhances the value
of the property above its value as of the date the Special Use Permit is granted
and reverting to the prior zoning results in the same value of the property as if the
Special Use Permit had never been granted.
Presented by:
Eric R. Smith, Planner
Reviewed by:
Matthew Holm, AICP, Planning Supervisor
Attachments:
Case Map (1 page)
Site Plan (reduced 8.5”x11”, 2 pages)
Narrative Report (9 pages)
Engineering comments (2 pages)
MCESD comments (1 page)
Support (11 pages)
Opposition (8 pages)
ONE
STOP
SHOP
MARICOPA COUNTY
_
.
‘_-_•
-
, r
_
.
‘
, ;. ,
21102409C
-ra - •
ii.614118E, —
. ..
. .
,
-
:
w
L
n I. 1.-mxi.L.1 • . . . •
)
I
•
1
--.
, -
‘
I
'
II
I
'
• '1'
S;
alli
(
I
il
1r
ii
-,
_
,
N.
V;
Til
- 0513
1
I
1
1
--
1
Sig
.._
1
1
A
I
41
•
1
1
•&
1
.
1
-
l'r
,
O
V ,..
_
--
-
.-.
\01
relAl
..:•
A
'
n11'- -
R.
101--11:7 7Th
-*- -IC
Oil
.
ii
11101.11
.1-.;
1
1 .4
toi
,
_
.-.
.
1.1,,,,
:..
refilz
b
_G, I
,_ mini ,4. Allialik
Application Name: Anchorpoint Welding
Legal Description
TO5N RO3E 4,
Applicant
MICHAEL ROLAND, ESQ for ENGELMAN BERGER, PC
Applicant Phone/Email
602.271.9090
MPR@EBLAWYERS.COM
Z2019019
Case Address
35011 N 10TH St
PHOENIX AZ 85086
Parcel Primary: 211-52-105B
Generated November 19, 2019 10:30 AM
Gross Acres: 2 approx.
Map scale 1:660
Supervisor District No. 3
ANCHORPOINT WELDING SPECIAL USE PERMIT
WE
Maricopa County Planning & Development - Phoenix, AZ
CALVIN
STREET
P
. yi SITE
li
CAREFREE
TIWY.
f\ VICINITY MAP
11IkJ, / sw 1/4. SECTION 5,155. 1430
(NOT TO SCA.)
LEGAL DESCRIPTION
A PORTION OFNIE SOCIIIIVEST QUARTER OF THE
NORTHEAST QUARTER OF THE SOUTHWEST QU.ARTER OF
SECTION 4, TOWNSHIP 5 NORTIL RANGE 3 EAST OF THE GT,
AND SALT RIVER BASE .1:MERIDIAN MARICOPA cownr,
ARIZONA, AND IS mon PARIICULARLY DESCRIBED.
FOLLOWS:
COMMENCI140 AT THE NORTHWEST CORNER OF THE
NDICITEAST QUARTER OF THE SOUTHWEST QUARTER. OF
SAID
SECHON 4 BEING AT THE INTEILIECTION OF GALVEN STREET
AND 10TH STREET;
THENCE ALONG THE CENTERLINE OF 10711 STREET. SOUTH 00
DEGREES 22 A ENITIES EAST. A DISTANCE OF
107548 FEET TO A powr ON SAID CENTERLINE:
THENCE LEAVING SAID CENTERLINE SOUTH 110 DEGREES 32
MINUTES 15 SECONDS EAST. A DISTANCE OF
4500 EMT TO A POINT ON THE RIGHT OF WAY UNE OF 10TH
MEET, BEING THE TRUE POINT OF BEGDINING1
NONCE SOUTH 80 DEGREES 32 MINUTES 15 SECONDS EAST,
FOR. A D1STANCE OF 20.50 FEET;
THENCE sourn o DEGREES 051 MINUTES 2.6 SECONDS WEST.
FOR A DISTANCE OF 23.3 FEET;
THENCE NORNI 89 DEGREES 32 MINUTES 15 SECONDS WEST,
FOR A DISTA.NCE OF 265.3L FEET:
NIENCE ALONG SAID SB FOOT RIGHT OF WAY LINE OF 1071-1
STREET, NORTH OD DEGREES 22 MINUTES 03
SECONDS WEST, FOR A DISTANCE OF 2-32.25 FEET TO THE
TRUE POINT OF BEGINNING
SITE DATA
APN: 211.5,105B
EXISTING 2.01411,10, R13-13
PROPOSED ZONING: RU-I3
emsnNa USE: RESIDENHAL
PROPOSED USE, HOME OCCUPATION
LOT AREA: 61,872 SF 1.42.ICRES
ESTINLATED DISTURBANCE 11,000 SF
FRONT .0 REAR 'YARD SETBACKS, 401
SIDE YARD SETTIACK-S,
BUILDING SUMMARY
EXISTING UVABLE 2.241 SF (COUNT,' RECORDS,
vagmuo UNDER ROOF: 2.026 SF (PER SURVEY)
EXISTING DETACHED GARAGE: 010 SF
PROPOSED WORKSHOP 3,300 SF
TOTAL UNDER ROOK 0.036 SF
11.284 COVERAGE: 8,038 / 61.872
2500MAX ALLOWABLE COVERAGE
30' MAX ALLOWABLE BUILDING IMIGHT
MARICOPA COUNTY PAD COMMERCIAL GENERAL NOTES AND CONDITIONS
I. REFERENCE MAR1COPA COUNTY PERMIT AND ADDENDUMS FOR ADDMONAL CONDMONS.
IN, WORK PERFORMED WITHOUT APPROVAL OF THE APPLICABLE COUNTY DEPARTMENT OR AFFECTED unun .
COMPANY ANIXOR ALL WORK AND MATERIAL NOT IN CONFORMANCE WINK= CONSTRUCTION DOCUMENTS IS
SUBTECT TO REMOVAL AND REPLACEMENT AT THE OWNER'S EXPENSE.
3. THE ISSUANCE OF ANY CONSTRUCTION PERMIT SHALL NOT RELIEVE THE OWNER OR OWNER, AGENT FRON1
COMPLI.ICE WITH ALL OTHER GOVE1LNMENTAL REGULATIONS AND ORDINANCES INCLUDING BUT NOT MATED TO
ZONING &RUILBINORERCIOEMEIZIN.
RAG SPECIFIED 55 155) PERMIT CONDITIONS, CONTACT MARTCOPA COUNTY TO SCHEDULE AVIN-PROGRESS
INSPECT/ ON FOR ALL IMADWALLS. CUT OFF WALLS. AND WEIRS /ICIER EXCAVATION AND FORM PLACEMENT BUT
PRIOR TO PLADFAIFKIT OF ANY MATERIAL
5. AS SPECIFIED IN THE PERMIT COW/MONS. CONE-ICE MAI.001, COUNTY TO SCHEDULE AN IN-PROGRESS
INSPECTION FOR ALL 0013105 WINLESS., RIP-RIP, FILTER FABRIC. AND/OR GRAVEL UNDERLAYMENT AFTER
EXCAVATION MIT PRIOR TO PLACEMENT OF ANY MATERIAL.
S. AS SPECIFIED IN THE PERMIT CONDITIONS. coNTAcr NIARICOPA COM,' TO SCIMDULE 114-PROGRESS
INSPECTION FOR ALL RETAINING WALLS AFTER EXCAVATION BUT PRIOR TO PLACEMENT OF CONCRP.TE. BLOCK, OR
OITIER RETAINING WALL MATERIAL_
ADDMONAL INSPECTIONS AND/OR RE-INSPECTIONS SHALL BE ASSESSED AMMON.. FEES IN CONFORMANCE
SITE ADOPTED FEF. SCHEMES.
8. RIP-ILAP AREAS SIMI BE OVER-EXCAVATED SUCH THAT TOP OF ILII,RAP IVILL MEET ADJACENT GUDE.
CERTIFIED AS-BUILT PIANS, PREPARED IN CONFORAIANCF. WITH MARICOPA COUNTY ASBUILT SUBMITTAL
REQUIREMENIS SHALL BE sum, Era. TO INARICOM COUNTY FOR APPROVAL PRIOR. TO FINAL DRAINAGE
CLEARANCE.
10. PRIOR TO FINAL DRAINAGE CLEARANCE EACH RETENTION BASIN IVITH DEPITIS GREATER THAN I-FOOT OR A.8
DETERMINED BY MARICOPA =Nis' SHALL BE TESTED PER THE DRAINAGE POLICIES AND STANDARDS FOR
MARICOPA COUNTY STANDARD BILIS. THE TEST RESULTS, BORING LOGS. AND REVISED DRAIN-00,04 TIME
CALCULATIONS
DEMONSTIUTING THAT ALL RETENTION BASINS DRAIN WITHIN 34-HOURS, SIGNED AND SEAU:12 BY AN ARIZONA
REGISTERED PROFESSIONAL ENGINEER, SIGEL BE SUBMITTED FOR APPROVAL WITH TIM ASBUILT PLAN
DOCUMENTATION. SOIL INFILTRATION TESTING OBTAINED DURING DESIGN PHASE ..VILE ACCEPTABLE.
1 1. ALL DRYWELL PERCOLVTION RATES SHALL BE DE-RATED IN ACCORDANCE WITH ALARICOPA comn . STANDARD
8.10.13.111E DRYIVELL TEST RF-SULTS, BORING LOGS, PROOF OF DRYWF.11- REGISTRATION, AND REVISED
DILAINDOWN CALCULATIONS SEALED BY AN ARIZONA REGISTERED PROFESSIONAL ENGINEER DEMONSTRATING
THAT AL...IT:TRION BASINS DRAIN WITT. 30-HOURS SHALL BE SUBMITTED FOR APPROVAL BTITI THE AS.BUILT
PLAN DOCUMENTATION.
REQUIRED DRAINAGE OPENINGS FOR CX111 WAILS SHALL BE AS PER THE APPROVED P/AN DETAIL. IF NO DETAIL,
SHOWN, PROVIDE NON-DECORNIIVE TURNED BLOCK. EVERY OTHER BLOCK AT GRADE. 01 TWO BLOCKS NEXT TO
EACH MILER ARE NOT TURNED, TWO TURNED BLOCKS NEXT TO EACH OTT. SHALL THEN FOLLOW.
13. SHOULD ANY PROPOSED DEVELOPMENT REQUIRE CLARIFICANON AS DETERMINED BY MARICOPA COUNTY, A
PLAN ADDENDUM SIGNED AND SEALED BY A REGISTERED PROFESSIONAL ENGINEER SHALL BE SUBMITTED FOR
APPROVAL SUBMITTAL OF AN ADDENDUM MAY REQUIRE FORMAL PIAN MODIFICATION AS DEEMED BY MARICOPA
COUNT,
14. ALL CONSTRUCTION FILL STIALL MEET OR EXCEED NIAG SPECIFICATION 211.
15. ALL CONSTRUCTION SHALL MEET OR EXCEED CURRENT MACI SPECIFICATIONS AND STANDARDS.
14. AN APPROVED SET OF PLANS SHALL BE WITUNTAINED ON THE TOD SITE AT All TIMES PERMIT IS ACTIVE
17. OMISSIONS OR CONFLICTS BETWEEN VARIOUS ELEMENTS OF THE DRAWINGS, NOTES, AND DETAILS SHALL BE
BROUGHT TONLE ATTE/MON OF THE ENGIWIEER OF RECORD AND RESOLVED WITH MARICOPA COUNTY PRIOR TO
PROCEEDING wmi THE WORK.
IL CONTACT BLUE SLAKE AT 002-263-1100 A MININTL.1 OF 2-DAYS PRIOR TO CONSIRUCTION.
SEPTIC SETBACKS
f ANY PORTION OF SEPTIC SYSTEM)
FRONT BUILDING: 10'
FRU,/ PROPERTY LINES ON WELL: 50
FRONI WATER WELL: IVY
FROM DRIVEWAY:
FROM POOL:
FROM WATER SERVICE LINE: 0
FROM PROPERTV LINES W/ WATER SERVICE 5'
THIELE WORKSHOP
35011 N. 10TH STREET, PHOENIX AZ 85086
GRADING & DRAINAGE PLAN
PROJECT
CONSTRUCT A WO.SHOP
OWNER / DEVELOPER
JONATHAN THIELE 1RREVOCABIE TRUST
35011 N ION'S-MEET
PHOENIX AP. 85086
100111 IAN_Ti IIELESYA0OO.0001
480.2.3898
SURVEYOR
ST.TINK SURVEVING, INC.
s-rm 5110 00000) ILLS.
705 W. ADOBE DR
GLENDALE . 8530I1
623.322.11
SURVEYED IN FEB XI.
QUANTITIES
CUT: 250 CY
FILE 170 CE
IN-PLICE VOLUMES OW SHRINK OR
SWELL TAKEO INTO ACCOTRO)
BENCHMARK
7111 STREET AND GALVIN MEET
24.C.D.O.T. BRASS CAP IN HANDHOLE. DOWN
06', STAMPED 72N R. 55 SC:
ELEV. 1750154 (NAND. IL SSP.00.T. 85241147)
SITE BENCHMARK T TEM
AS SHOWN ON PL.
FINISHED FLOOR CERTIFICATION
THE MN1SHED FLOOR 011151E STRUCTURE IS SAFE
FROM INUNDATION DURING A 100-YEAR PE.
RUNOFF EVENT IF CONSTRUCTED ACCORDING TO
nm APPROVED SET OF PLANE
FEMA FIRM
PER MAP 04013C0820L DATED 0,14 2013.THE ENTIRE
PARCEL IS WITHIN FLOOD ZONE X.
DRAINAGE STATEMENT
VOL CHERALL WATERSIIED DRAINS SOUTHERLY. THE EXISTING
LOT IS DEVELOPED WIN !SPARSE VEGETATION. PROPOSED
GRADING MAINTAINS HISTORICAL DION...1E PATTERNS. A
niturion: BASIN IS PROVIDED FOR THE PLANNED AREA OF
DEVELOPMENT. HISTORICAL DRAINAGE MCFALL MUST BE
MAINTAINED ALONG THE SOUTHERN BOUNDARY.
CONSTRUCTION HAS NEGLIGIBLE IMPACT TO NEIGHBORING
PROPERTIES.
UTILITIES
WATF.11, CAVE CREEK
SEWER: SEPTIC
FIRE PROTF.CTION: DAISY MOUNTAIN
ELECIR-IC: APS
GAS: SOUTHWEST G.
TELEPHONE: CENTURYLINK
REFUSE: REPUBLIC SERVICES
SCHOOL
DEER VALLEY SCHOOL DISTRICT
RETENTION CALCULATIONS
RETENTION CALCULATED FOR THE PLANNED AREA OF DEVELOPNIF.NT.
IE ON-SITE RUNOFF GENERATED FROM A 1004Y0 2-H1R STORM EVENT EQUALS:
V CW(P/12)A 0.05(2.61412024,660 SF) 5541/1250884 SET= 0. I111 CF REQUIRED
(P IS FROM NO.AA .ATLAS 1.11
10884 SF REPRESENTS THE RETENDON BASINS)
VOLUME PROVIDED 1ST TWO CONNECIED BASINS. ALL CONNECTED AT SAME HAVE
BK V 0/20.136 SF + WITS SF A0.0)
4.,00 PRO,TI.1..
132: V .-. (142)(1,6711 SF 2.001 SF TION) 2,092 CE PROVIDED
TOTAL N'OLLINIE: 0,287 OF PROVIDED
BASINS ARE CONNECTED AND EQUALI. AT TIM SAME 17001 HIGH AV:ITER ELEVAIION (11WE2
BASINS FIAVE ONE FOOT OR LESS OF PONDING, THEREFORE, DRY-LIP IS BY PERCOLATION Sc EVAPORATION.
OLITFALL TO THE SOUTH T HISTORICAL AT THE HAVE ELEVANON OF rm.
RETENTION BASIN TABLE
BASIN
VOLUME
VOLUME
VOLUME
AS-DESIGNED REQUIRED
AS-BUILT
BI
4.190 CF
4,130 CF
B2
2,097 CF
2,040 CF
AS-BUILT CERTIFICATION
1 CERT11101, BASED ON FIEID VERIFICATION, TT-LVCTTBS SET OF AS-BUILT PLA.NS
ACCURVIELY REFLECTS THE CONDITIONS AS THEY EXIST ON THE PROPERTY.
I FURTHER CERTIFY AS FOLLOWS:
A THAT HIE DEVELOPMENT HAS BEEN COMMENTED SUBSTANTIALLY IN
ACCORDANCE WMT THE APPROVED GRADING /1.ND DRAINAGE PLANS AND TIE
IMPROVEMENTS PLANS.
B. THAT THE DRAINAGE SYSTEM ST TALL FUNCTION AS DESIGNED AND PERMTITF.D.
C. BASED ON TESTING DATA FORTIES PROJECT, me RETENTION SYSTEM WEL
FUNCTION AS DESIGNED TO DRAIN WITHIN 36 HOURS PER MARICOPA COUNTY
REQUIREMENTS.
DECLARATION OF RESPONSIBLE CHARGE
IMAM lAr4UCE MAR. I .1 THE FM:1FR. 11ORA
FOR THIS PROVECT, THAT !WE RAMMED RESPONSIBLE
MARGE . OVER I710000)OVGFI'IACI'OSRICCI'ASOCPZVCG
CV
OCCFSO,V24.AB,AEI OF ME RULES OP TB' E . ARIZONN SIAM
BOARD OF MINIM, ILREGISIRATION.AD IMMIX
DESIGN CONSISTEN F IFITH CURREAT SIANDARDS.
I UNDERSTAND THAT TH£ REVIEW OF THE PROJECT
DR.11171.5 AND SPECIFICATIOVS ItrAtARICOM COUNTY IR
COMFINED 71,1REVIRIF OM,WO DOES NOT R !EVE 11E.
AS ENGINEER OF RORK; OF AirRESPONSIBILOT£S FOR MR
YROIECT AMON.
JOB NO.
19-1458
SHEET
NAME
CASE #: Z2019019
I 0F2
THIELE WORKSHOP
35011 N. 10TH STREET, PHOENIX
GRADING & DRAINAGE PLAN
20
ID 0 ip 20
IT1T11
DIC.911:
32
,
1
Av
INI:N FENCE-I
BASIN, HI
[
DI. BLOCK WALL
!ME 170.2
W/ NO OPENINGS r ,„.. 4330Cr
4,190CF
207.50'
SET 1/10 REBAR
W/ 1 I/2- BLUE CAP
STAMPED 'BENCHMARK.
5/ SITE BENCHMARK
ELEV.. 702.15
PATRICK et DOROTHY LARKIN
APII 1211-5,10W
(00Z`..7°)
JOE .5 JANET
.1.0.
APA 1111-51-1110£
(DEVELOPED)
LEGEND
DRAINAGE DIRECTION
----1791---- EX. CONTOUR ELEVATION
—1791— CONTOUR ELEVATION
FINISHED ELEVAllON
— - - — PROPERTY UNE
--c.
---0€-- OVERHEAD ELECTRIC
8.
SIGHT VISIBILITY TRIANGLE
TYPICAL TRUCK BEG STORAGE
CONSTRUCTION NOTES
REMOVE EXISTINL: G.ULAGE AND SHEDS
RETIOVF. A COR.NER SECTION OP THE ENUSTINO PAVERS
INSTALL PAVERS TO SQUARE UP PART9NG / DRIVEWAY
CONSTRUCT RETEMTON BASIN WITH V SLOPES ADIACENILD PERIMETER WALLS
AND 101910 SLOPES .1014107210 00 DRIVEWAYS
MISHIT:WIN MDT UDT MINUS DECOMPOSED GRANITE FOR DUST/PROOFING.
leel
INSTALL I/O' MINUS DECOMPOSED GRANITE DRIVE
(!) INSTALL 8' HIGH CIL ILI FENCING STI11 DRAINAGE OPENINGS EVERY 43 SEE DETALL
.545)000 VEGETATION AS REQUIRED FOR NEW CONSTRUCTION
- CONDUCTOR TO PROVIDE POMMY DEUNALIE AWAY FROM STRUCTURE
- ALL FILL SHALL. BE COMPACTED TO 95, MIN. INIERLOCIWIL
AND SATIEGLIED AGAINST WATER SEEPAGE P000200 SECTION 211
- SEPTIC SYSTEM PER .U1.120NA STATE SPECIFICATIONS LORRY SEPARATE PERMIT
- WATER SERWCE BY MEIER SL SEPARATE AGREEMENT
- WATER & SEWER LINES PER 1PC
• CONTRACTOR TO LOCATE AND VERIFY ;ANY CONFLICTS WITH EXISTING UTEMES
• ALL OUTDOOR um rmo SMALL COMPLY MIDSECTION 1112 OP THE MARICOPA
COUNTY ZONING ORDINANCE
- CONTACT MARICOPA COLNIX TO SCHEDULE A FINISHED FLOOR INSPECTION AFTER
E.XC.AVATION. PLACENIENT OF SUI3ORADE AND MEM WORK. BUT PRIOR TO PLACEMENT'
OF CONCRETE OR OTI IER FINISHED FLOOR MATERIAL.
NOTE
• NO SIGNAGE PROPOSED AT THIS ID IF
- ANY PAR.. LOT 1301IT(S) TO BE BLIEDINO MOUNTED
• ITIE ONLY OUTSIDE STORAGE IS FOR TRUCK BEDS.
'TOO LOCATIONS SHOWNWOR THE. TRUCK BED SIDRAGE ARE CONCEPTUAL-
- MISC. MATERIAL SIDIUGE WILL BE INSIDE TIIE S'ORKSHOP
NOTES'
-ALL CE1LS CONTAININO PEBAR SHALL BE
GROUTED SOLIS
- GRADE DIFFERENTIAL SHALL BE NO
GREATER THAN I?
-EVERY AT, BLOCIOURNED AT BASE
COURSE NO DECORATIVE BLOCK ALLOWED.
BLOCK FENCE DETAIL
NuT TO SCALE
1-04 HORIZONTAL BAR
IN CONTINUOUS BONO
BEAN1 AT TOP COURSE
=MIMI =MOM=
1111111•11111111=•111•11
MI= EMU
Ellb11111111111=11111•111
MOM MENU
MUUMI=
Ell MI= MENU
11111111.0111111111111111111.01
NE MIN MENU
PI VERTICAL •
RABID
32.
ALTERNATING
10,101
BENDS
87 8,16" STEM
ADE
GROUT SOLID
00 CONTINUOUS F001100-..
24A1
HORIZONTAL
CONMUOUS
IN FOOTING
1.0.0.0.101
DRIVEN/Al
4131V MAX
FINISHED
EXISTING
- - - —
OPADE
WOUND
1.3.1.(fC/77--
M
ITE OVE
SIDUCTURES
SIDE SLOPE
47E 17,0
1790
Lc
RETENTION BASIN
11347,700.2
REA EWE ROT 17119.3
STIDULDIDES
311.1V
•Lr 0EE/8179G 111,,
EX. C
4_
BLO
CK
OCR
.1IIr
1750
RETENTION BASIN
VERTWAL. - 5'
1011101790.2
HOISEONTAL - 00'
BO, 1789.3
SECTION B-B
JOB NO.
19-1458
SHEET
GROUND
SECTION A-A
lILLY
VERTICAL
BORIZENTAL- I' -
11011170000 SAM
HWE-I 700,2
001. 1710.3
CASE #: Z2019019
2 OF 2
PROJECT NARRATIVE
PROJECT NAME:
ANCHORPOINT WELDING
GENERAL LOCATION:
35011 N. 10TH STREET, PHOENIX
CASE TRACKING NO.: Z2019019
REVISED 5/10/19
(0005670.0001/00929744.DOCX / 6)
Jonathan Thiele Irrevocable Trust
do Michael P. Rolland, Esq.
ENGELMAN BERGER, P.C.
2800 N. Central Ave., No. 1200
Phoenix, AZ 85004
602.271.9090
Email: mpr@eblawyers.com
Z 2 0 1 9 0 1 9
k 'RECEIVED OCT 0 4 2019
B.
Purpose of Request
The purpose of this request by Hans, Gail, and Jonathan Thiele
("Applicant") is to obtain a Special Use Permit, so that Jonathan Thiele may continue to
operate his small, custom welding business Anchorpoint Welding LLC ("Anchorpoint")
at 35011 N. 10th Street, Phoenix, AZ 85086 (the "Subject Property"). The amount of time
requested for the SUP entitlement is ten (10) years.
All business operations will be conducted entirely indoors, and will not cause any
noise, dust, or light pollution disruptive to the community. As a low volume business,
customer visits to the property are minimal and do not meaningfully increase
neighborhood traffic. Jonathan Thiele is an Arizona native, and cherishes the dark skies
and rural character of the Desert Hills community. As you will see, Anchorpoint's
business operations as proposed in this application are specifically tailored, not only to
ensure that Anchorpoint Welding complies with all minimum county requirements, but
also to preserve the current rural character of the neighborhood.
As is discussed in greater detail in the Citizen Participation Results Report,
Applicant has received overwhelming support from the community. This is evidenced by
29 written letters of support signed by Applicant's neighbors, including 6 by neighbors
residing directly adjacent to the subject Property. Applicant received only three written
objections to the application, which are based primarily on concerns that Anchorpoint's
operations may increase levels of dust and noise. Applicant has taken note of these
concerns and, as described more fully herein, Applicant will build a new workshop so
that all operations can be conducted indoors, and an 8' foot block wall along the western
boundary of the Property, which will eliminate any potential dust or noise issues and
screen the operations from neighbors.
{0005670.0001/00929744.DOCX /
Jonathan Thiele Irrevocable Trust
do Michael P. Rolland, Esq.
ENGELMAN BERG ER, P.C.
2800 N. Central Ave., No. 1200
Phoenix, AZ 85004
602.271.9090
Email: mpr@eblawyers.com
C.
Description of Proposal
Proposed Uses:
Applicant proposes to operate Anchorpoint at the Subject Property.
Business Operations:
Anchorpoint is in the business of installing flat beds onto pickup trucks, as well as
providing custom steel fabrication and welding services. In general, these services
require the use of a fork lift, welding equipment and small power tools (all indoors), and
delivery and storage of the truck beds to operate its business. Anchorpoint's business
activities do not interfere with the delivery of utilities or other services to the area.
I.
Workshop
Anchorpoint operations are currently conducted, to the extent possible, inside of a
small workshop on the southern end of the Subject Property. As a part of this Application
(as described further below in the "Description/Location of Buildings" section),
Applicant will obtain the proper permits to construct a slightly larger 60' x 55' enclosed
steel building (the "Workshop") near the southeastern corner of the Subject Property. See
Site Plan attached hereto. Thereafter, all operations will be conducted inside the
Workshop.
The Workshop will not change the appearance of the actual residence (house), and
generally will not be viewable from the street. Anchorpoint already does not generate
much noise or dust; however, by constructing the Workshop, erecting the 8 foot block
wall, and conducting all operations inside, Applicant has ensured that its operations will
be virtually undetectable to neighbors.
{0005670.0001/00929744.DOCX / 6}
Jonathan Thiele Irrevocable Trust
ao Michael P. Rolland, Esq.
ENGELMAN BERGER, P.C.
2800 N. Central Ave., No. 1200
Phoenix, AZ 85004
602.271.9090
Email: mpr@eblawyers.com
2.
Customers and Services
Very few customers visit the Subject Property on a monthly basis. Anchorpoint
averages just four to five (4-5) installations of flat beds per month. Customers of
Anchorpoint may make an appointment during regular 9:00 am to 5:00 pm business
hours to visit Anchorpoint only to drop off or pick up their trucks, and spend minimal
time on the Subject Property. There are never more than 2 or 3 customers at the Subject
Property at any one time. Anchorpoint provides sufficient (no more than 6) off-street
parking spaces for its customers. Anchorpoint also has the ability to arrange for pick-up
and drop-off of the trucks to customers, to further minimize customer presence on the
property.
Anchorpoint also makes custom handrails, gates, fences and other decorative items
for installation at homes or offices. However, purchasers of these custom items typically
do not ever visit the Subject Property. Anchorpoint only makes pre-ordered and custom
items—there are no retail sales being conducted at the Subject Property. When an
item is completed, Anchorpoint contacts the customer and arranges for an offsite
installation date, or ships the items directly to the customer.
Due to the low volume nature of Anchorpoint's business, it is clear that approval
of this SUP application will not result in a meaningful increase of traffic. Accordingly,
without an increase in traffic, there will not be an increase in dust from the roads or other
traffic related concerns.
3.
Delivery
Truck beds are delivered by a tractor-trailer (semi-truck) on a monthly, or
sometimes bi-monthly, basis. The deliveries do not restrict traffic in the area. Delivery
trucks will enter the Subject Property through the southern gravel driveway, and will exit
through the northern gravel driveway.
{0005670.0001/00929744.DOCX /
Jonathan Thiele Irrevocable Trust
c/o Michael P. Rolland, Esq.
ENGELMAN BERGER, P.C.
2800 N. Central Ave., No. 1200
Phoenix, AZ 85004
602.271.9090
Email: mpr@eblawyers.com
4.
Storage
The only items stored outdoors are the Applicant's truck beds. The beds are
stacked three (3) beds high in the back outside area of the Subject Property, not
encroaching onto the front or side yards. The beds, when stacked, do not exceed 6' high,
do not rise above the fence line, and generally are not visible to anyone standing outside
the property. The storage of the stacked beds comprises approximately one-third of the
back outside area of the Subject Property, which is significantly less than 25% of the
entire lot size.
5.
Machinery
Anchorpoint uses a fork lift to lift the truck beds onto the trucks. Anchorpoint also
uses welding equipment and small hand-held power tools to install the truck beds. The
fork lift, welding equipment, and power tools do not generate excessive noise, vibration,
smoke, dust, odors, heat, glare, or electrical interference with radio or television
transmission in the area that would exceed that normally produced by a dwelling unit in a
zoning district used solely for residential purposes. Other than transportation of truck
beds into the Workshop, all machinery, including the forklift and power tools, will be
housed and used exclusively inside the Workshop. A list of all power tools used in
Anchorpoint's business set forth below:
1. Toyota Forklift Truck model 7FGAU50
2. Challenger Lift model #18000
3. 60 gal. Husky air compressor
4. Millermatic 252 GMAW welding machine
5. Evolution 14" chop saw
6. Thermal Dynamics cuttmaster 38 plasma cutter
7. Bader III 2" x 72" belt grinder
8. Central Machinery 12 speed production drill press
9. Chicago Electric 1/2" heavy duty spade handle drill
10. Dewalt 4 Y2" grinder
11. Central Pneumatic Earthquake impact wrench
{0005670.0001/00929744.00CX / 6}
Jonathan Thiele Irrevocable Trust
c/o Michael P. Rolland, Esq.
ENGELMAN BERG ER, P.C.
2800 N. Central Ave., No. 1200
Phoenix, AZ 85004
602.271.9090
Email: mpr@eblawyers.com
Anchorpoint uses compressed oxygen and acetylene in its welding operations.
The compressed oxygen is in a 225-cubic-foot cylinder, and the acetylene is in a 60-
cubic-foot cylinder. Both cylinders will be chained to a cart located in the shop, and will
be used exclusively inside the shop. Anchorpoint also heats the welding shop in the
winter with 3 small propane tanks stored on the bottom shelf of a storage rack in the
shop.
6.
Lighting
Anchor Point will use no outdoor lighting.
All operations occur inside the
enclosed Workshop.
Hours/days of Operation:
Anchorpoint's hours of operation are Monday — Friday, 9:00 a.m. to 5:00 p.m. No
work is conducted in the evening hours, weekends, or holidays. No non-resident
employees, customers, clients, or students are permitted on the Subject Property for
business purposes after hours.
Number of Employees:
Anchorpoint has only one full-time employee, Jonathan Thiele, who resides at the
Subject Property. Mr. Thiele's partner, Jonathan McMahon, spends part-time to full-time
hours at Anchorpoint, depending on work flow, but does not live at the Subject Property.
No other employees or students come to the Subject Property.
The only vehicles parked regularly at the Subject Property are Jonathan Thiele's
passenger vehicle, Anchorpoint's truck, and the vehicle driven by Mr. Thiele's partner,
Jonathan McMahon. There are no other vehicles parked at the Subject Property that are
used for commerce.
Description/location of Buildings:
As shown on the site plan, the Workshop will be a 60' x 55' fully enclosed steel
building located along the eastern border and forty feet from the southern side of the
{0005670.0001/00929744.DOCX /
Jonathan Thiele Irrevocable Trust
c/o Michael P. Rolland, Esq.
ENGELMAN BERGER, P.C.
2800 N. Central Ave., No. 1200
Phoenix, AZ 85004
602.271.9090
Email: mpr@eblawyers.com
Subject Property. The Workshop will be built on a concrete pad and powered with
electricity. The Workshop will be a "dry" building, meaning there will be no plumbing or
drainage. The Workshop is 46.3' from the house, and approximately 100' from the septic
tank.
Screening Wall Details and Location:
As indicated as Items 4 and 5 on the attached Site/Grading & Drainage Plan, an
existing 6' block wall runs along the northern, eastern, and southern sides of the Property.
Applicant is building an 8' masonry block wall along the western side of the Property to
further ensure that truck beds stored on the Subject Property are not visible, and so that
the semi-trucks delivering the beds can enter and exit through a gated area, causing
minimal disruption to the neighboring area. The new masonry 8' block wall will separate
the front of the Subject Property from the back and block the view of any operations
being conducted in the back of the Subject Property. The wall is 8' in height and the
stored beds will not be stacked higher than 6' in height.
D.
Relationship to Surrounding Properties
The surrounding rural area is zoned as Rural-43, which is the same zoning as the
Subject Property, and is comprised of mostly 1-acre+ lots. Most of the houses are
occupied, and a number of the neighboring properties are permitted and/or used for
commercial activities. Anchorpoint's business activities do not affect neighboring
properties. All welding is done on a concrete pad, which is at least 40 feet away from the
nearest neighbor's house.
Per the County's "PlanNet" overlay mapping website, Applicant's search for
special use permits in the surrounding area revealed that special use permits had been
granted on properties at the corner of 12' Street and Carefree Highway (APN 211-52-
002A) and at the corner of 14th Street and Carefree Highway (APN 211-52-077).The
Subject Property is surrounded by CUPD and C-2 zoned sites, and it appears that special
use permits have been granted for APN Nos. 211-52-014C and 211-52-014E, with "other
status" relating to permits on APN Nos. 211-52-011A, 211-74-012B and 211-74-102.
A drive through the neighborhood revealed that at least one adjacent neighbor
appears to be operating an auto repair shop in the back yard of his premises, and another
{0005670.0001/00929744.DOCX /
Jonathan Thiele Irrevocable Trust
cio Michael P. Rolland, Esq.
ENGELMAN BERGER, P.C.
2800 N. Central Ave., No. 1200
Phoenix, AZ 85004
602.271.9090
Email: mpr@eblawyers.com
neighbor has heavy machinery (earth moving) parked in the front yard which does not
appear to be used on the premises, and thus, may be used in the operation of a business.
In light of the Rural-43 zoning designation for the area, along with the above SUP
applications and business activities taking place in the general vicinity, Anchorpoint's
business will not be a disruption to the neighborhood and will blend in to the present
scenery, flow and purpose of the area. It appears from Applicant's research of the area
that most occupants purchased their properties with an eye toward the potential for home-
based businesses.
E.
Location and Accessibility
Anchorpoint is fully accessible from 10th Street, which is not a major
thoroughfare. Anchorpoint's business does not affect or disrupt any traffic on 7' Street,
Galvin Street, 12 111 Street, or Carefree Highway.
F.
Circulation System
See Grading & Drainage Plan attached hereto.
G.
Development Schedule
Applicant estimates that obtaining building plans and completing the review
process will take 2 to 3 months, with completion of all construction at the Subject
Property within 9 months to a year.
H.
Community Facilities and Services
The Site is located within the Deer Valley Unified School District (elementary
school) and Deer Valley Unified #97 School District (high school).
I.
Public Utilities and Services
Water is provided by the Town of Cave Creek and Desert Hills Water Company.
Refuse services are provided by Republic Services. Electricity is provided by Arizona
Public Service. There is a Maricopa County Sheriff's substation in Anthem. The Subject
Property is within the Daisy Mountain Fire District, but there are two firehouses in the
area — the Daisy Mountain Firehouse on 15t h Avenue and Desert Hills Drive, and the
Carefree Firehouse on Carefree Highway and North Valley Parkway.
(0005670.0001/00929744.DOCX / 6}
Jonathan Thiele Irrevocable Trust
c/o Michael P. Rolland, Esq.
ENGELMAN BERGER, P.C.
2800 N. Central Ave., No. 1200
Phoenix, AZ 85004
602.271.9090
Email: mpr@eblawyers.com
Applicant underwent an inspection of the business premises by the Daisy
Mountain Fire Department ("DMFD"). Following the inspection, on April 29, 2019,
DMFD issued a Permit Certificate to Applicant, Permit No. 1819-215. The Permit
expires on April 30, 2021. A true and correct copy of the Permit Certificate is attached
hereto, with a copy of the invoice paid by Applicant to have the inspection completed.
According to Maricopa County GIS maps, other area interests are: New River
Preservation Group, Foothill Focus, Dove Valley Coalition, Arizona Department of
Transportation, Carefree Highlands HOA, Anthem Community Council, Arizona Horse
Council, Maricopa Association of Governments, ADOT Right of Way Project
Management, and New River/Desert Hills Community Association.
J.
For RUPD's [Residential Unit Plan of Development] — Comparison
Chart
N/A
K.
Other Information
Following the TAC meeting held on April 2, 2019, Applicant made a number of
revisions to this narrative, the Grading and Drainage Plan, in accordance with the
comments from the TAC Committee. Applicant has also gone to great lengths to reach
out to his neighbors, including inviting neighbors over for an open house and meet &
greet on April 27, 2019. This event was a great success, as reflected by the 16 letters of
support signed by Applicant's neighbors.
8.
TRAFFIC IMPACT STUDY
Not applicable in accordance with pre-Application meeting.
{0005670.0001/00929744.DOCX / 6)
Jonathan Thiele Irrevocable Trust
ao Michael P. Rolland, Esq.
ENGELMAN BERGER, P.C.
2800 N. Central Ave., No. 1200
Phoenix, AZ 85004
602.271.9090
Email: mpr@eblawyers.com
Maricopa County
Planning & Development Department
Engineering Plan Review
Robert Fedorka, P.E.
Planning & Development
501 North 441h Street, Suite 200
Phoenix, Arizona 85008
Phone: (602) 506-7151
Fax: (602) 506-8762
wnvw.marieopa.govielanning
Email address:
RobertFedorkaOmail.maricopa.qov
Date:
May 31, 2019
Memo To: Darren Gerard, AICP, Deputy Director, Department of Planning &
Development
Attn:
Eric Smith, Planner, Planning & Development Services
From:
Jim Kary, P.E., Drainage Engineering Supervisor, Planning &
Development Services
CC: Michael Norris, P.E., Drainage Engineering Manager, Planning &
Development
Subject:
Z2019019 — Special Use Permit for Anchor Point Welding
(E2 Memo)
Job Site Address: 35011 North Sunset Trail Phoenix, Arizona 85086
APN(s): 211-52-105B
I have reviewed the 2st submittal Special Use Permit for Anchor Point Welding.
Engineering Plan Review (DPR, FCDMC and MCDOT) has no objections to the
application. No development approval is inferred by this review.
Drainage Plan Review Comments
1. No additional revisions required for the Special Use Permit.
Flood Control District Comments
. The site is not located in a Special Flood Hazard Area. The Flood Control
District has no comments on this application.
MCDOT Comments
1. Storage of materials, walls/fence, parking and storm water retention are
prohibited in the MCDOT right-of-way.
Approval of this case should include the following stipulations:
1. There is an open violation case V201801196 for a business on a residential lot
and constructing fence without a permit. Bring the site into compliance by
12/31/19 with completed permits/entitlements.
2. Drainage review of planning and/or zoning cases is for conceptual design only
and does not represent final design approval nor shall it entitle applicants to
future designs that are not in conformance with Section 1205 of the Maricopa
County Zoning Ordinance and the Maricopa County Drainage Policies and
Standards.
3. All development and engineering design shall be in conformance with Section
1205 of the Maricopa County Zoning Ordinance and current engineering
policies, standards and best practices at the time of application for construction.
4. The grading and drainage plan shall be modified per the attached Engineering
Plan Review Comments memo before submitting for the Building permit.
Please contact me if you have any questions or require any additional information.
Maricopa County
Environmental Services Department
Water and Waste Management Division
Subdivision, Infrastructure &
Planning Program
1001 N. Central Avenue #150
Phoenix, Arizona 85004
Phone: (602) 506-1058
Fax: (602) 506-5813
TDD 602 506 6704
DATE: March 11, 2019
TO : Eric R. Smith, Planning & Development Dept.
Planner
FROM: Souren Naradikian, P.E.
Senior Civil Engineer
SUBJECT: Zone change for SUP. Z2019019
The Maricopa County Environmental Services Department (MCESD) has reviewed
documents received from the Maricopa County Planning and Development Department
for the above referenced project. This request is for SUP to allow small welding
business to be operated at 211-52-105B. Sewer and Water provider information is not
provided. MCESD has concerns, minor plan review approval may be needed.
Stormwater - The proposed project is located within the unincorporated urbanized
area regulated by the Maricopa County Stormwater Quality Program and may need a
stormwater approval and permit (SWPPP) prior to any building permits approval.
For further information, go to www.maricopa.gov/stormwater.
Based on the above, MCESD raised no objection to this project to the Planning &
Development Department in Accela Automation on March 6, 2019 and the project
may proceed at this time subject to the following stipulations:
Condition: None.
It should be noted that this document does not approve the referenced project.
Comments are provided only as advisory to Maricopa County Planning and
Development Department to assist staff to prepare a staff report. Other Maricopa
County agencies may have additional requirements. Final review and approval will be
made through Planning and Development Department procedures. Applicant may
need to submit separate applications to the Maricopa County Environmental Services
Department for approval of proposed facilities regulated by the Department. Review
of any such application will be based on regulations in force at the time of
application.
1
I
„, 1 ! ) .,,,1
1, mit
t.
• I 'I
210 ,m1 , 1
1
. 1
351,11
ItIIh ,01,1„
A d
1
I
I
k
N., 1thStreil,I Ar
ti I I 'Ikk.! II I:1
I j ji
Applirol ow
1.:111"111" kilvilar i Plitit
I 39111
1001
I
1111 t•
I l':111
lit 1
HIT
11 k'kv iturrittl NTH],
'rIt' 11 1 1•1
ItI , Ii t
.ITii
1 ,1 itc.2 (
135411
III N., IiHit
,
II
ii lij.Jl.'ll
1
I I st ,
Ii lJ. l IiI
1 5if
I I
HICII I I N,
tIvi si , 111111,0 t it
I
kldiw
I
111111-L,
-
I
$111f V•1
35011N.idth
t.Ii.ui .‘
Si
I vitt r
qirt or
-111 11
, 11 11 ti I
‘k\
: .; 7I 1 1 : -: 1 ,
1
Ith I LA..i..11:.•
`‘;ik 1,1111U/tilt
ildinr Li .1
3:7.1111
.
'1)1H5 ",
t , k,•11,,I t ki t
37:1M
ftIt ',tic, 1 I'll,- ik
str.k..;
o.: • .k•toi CkkAk l'kerfrkit ‘Hiiik. il111 Cdki. in-
/191191119 Nut
135011
11111‘ 1111
I
!M . )! \ 11 , 1%• I Iii li;11
N,
•I tro.1,
Ntilt86
11 -.I!!"
I .1h r it 1911 , rt
‘..r, • 11 tt
tit tpplic:fti.•i i
i
rDi1)111.1
1,%.1;',In :! I 1
, 4
III
!GO!
t I S./ !..11:,;(,
II IF 1!,1111
t I 111 I ,' I
1111,11
i
I
I
11 'sittI 1.
'111'11111 1,1 , 10
''= , 1 , 1 I
111,: I
.11 , i
oi'llt..rd
uhir1iirt
Iii
I I,(
3 4-0111
Pith 'Al• .1. l'h..-:11\
. RECEIVED APR 3 2019,
To: Mr. Eric Smith
Planner
Maricopa County Planning & Development
501 N. 44th St Suite 200 Phoenix, AZ 85008
From: Mr. Robert Thul
35119 N. 10th St Phoenix, AZ 85086
602-885-1960
I am sending this letter to you today regarding my concerns of having a commercial business located less
than 300 FT from my residence. The business in discussion is Anchorpoint Welding, ELC at 35011 N. 10t h
St, Phoenix, AZ 85086, Parcel No. 211-52-105B, business owner by the name of Jonathan Thiele, Case
No. Z2019019.
First and foremost, I would like to declare that I am NOT in support of the (above) commercial business
receiving permits to be able to operate in my residential zoned area.
Various reasons consist of:
1- Consistent Daily Noise Pollution
2- Poorer Air Quality within my Proximity due to Large Machinery and Equipment
3- higher Traffic Amounts on N. 10th St., of which (above) business is located on the "non-paved
private portion" of N. 10th St. of which there will be an increase in costs Incurred to the property
owners in the neighborhood, for example, with,pothole repairs, drainage repairs etc.
4- JHome values in the neighliorhoix1 may decrease iminensely due to activity and operations of a
Corrimereial Business Allowance
5- Theft and Crime may increase in our neighborhood with the hiring of various employees needed
to operate a commercial business, as these "so called employees" are-considered "non-
residents" of our residential zoned area
6- There is always an uncertainty of how much any business can impact a residential
neighborhood. Most importantly regarding Growth of a business; the "now" and "projection
forward in years", therefore, the (above) concerns/ risks may in fact escalate, leaving that
"unknown burden to the property owners" of N. 10th St
7- Once a commercial business is allowed and permitted in a residential zone, others may want to
potentially follow, leaving many "unknowns" on all (above) concerns within our neighborhood
I would like to have N. 10th St zoned as Residential ONLY, NON Commercial. Thank you for allowing
me to shire my Viewpoint drythii Matter. lith available for cOnversation if yqu'deerh appropriate.
NEW myna/
DESERT HILLS
Macelotion, Inc.
New River/Desert Flills Community Association, Inc.
PO Box 75068
New River, AZ 85087-1000
Phone: 602-739-1235
Website: www.NRDHCA.org
President's emails: Ed@NRDHCA.com
Date:
April 30, 2019
Darren Gerard
Maricopa County Planning and Development
501 North 44th Street, Suite 200
Phoenix, AZ 85008
Dear Darren Gerard,
The New River/Desert Hills Community Association (NR/DHCA) Board has a quorum
for the following comment:
Case: Z2019019
Recommendation: DENIAL
Due to the objectives covered in our Board's analysis attached.
See our Board's analysis for more explanation.
Respectfully,
Alan Muller, Director
New River/Desert Hills Community Association
Attachment: Board's analysis
New River/Desert Hills Community Association Board
Date: April 30, 2019
Case: Z2019019
To: Eric Smith/Darren Gerard
Related Case: V201801196
Review by date: N/A
Planner:: Eric Smith
Type Case: P & Z
J BOA
E TAO
n other
Current Zoning: R-43
Property APN: 211-52-105-B
Owners: Jonathan Thiele
Applicant: Michael P. Rolland
Current Use: Residential/Cottage Ind.
Developer:
Request for: SUP A 35011 N 10th St
Background: Code Violation attached to property for using as a business in
R43 zoning'
Opinion: After meeting with the owners and viewing the parcel located in a residential
RU-43 area approximately 3/4 mite N. of Carefree Hwy we have come to the conclusion
that the commercial use is not a correct application for this residential neighborhood.
if the SUP were allowed, it would set precedent for ALL RU-43 parcels and would turn
this beautiful, residential community into a commercial district without rezoning.
Recommendation:
Denial H Approval
Respectfully submitted,
NRDHCA Board
No manufacturing In a
Other R1143 area
April 27, 2019
Maricopa County Planning and Development Dept
501 (444th St Suite MD
Phoenix, AZ 85008
Atten: Mr. Eric Smith
RE: Special Use Permit, for the property located at 35011 N 10th St, Phoenix, AZ Case #
Z2019019
Dear Mr. Smith;
My name is Jeanette Reynolds and I am the medical power of attorney and caregiver for
Raymond R Reynolds who resides at and owns the property located at 34845 N. 10th Street,
Phoenix, AZ. Mr Reynolds is currently in the hospital and has requested that I write this letter
on his behalf. Mr. Reynolds would like to object to the issuance of a special use permit to a Mr.
J Thiele that would allow a commercial business to be conducted on a property currently zoned
residential, located at 35011 N. 10th St, Phoenix, AZ. Mr Reynolds recently had a bone marrow
transplant which has totally eliminated his immune system and will have a severely
compromised immune system for a minimum of a year while the new cells grow.
This proposed commercial business is approximately 100' from the door that Mr Reynolds uses
to access his house. Because of his compromised immune system Mr. Reynolds cannot be
exposed to fumes, dust and other airborne toxins that this business may genera te. The outdoor
use of commercial equipment to move heavy materials, as well as welding and grinding would
cause an undue hardship on Mr Reynolds making him a virtual prisoner in his own home. All
doors and windows would have to be kept closed at all times and Mr. Reynolds would be
denied the right to simply sit or walk on his own property. The simple act of getting into a
vehicle for his doctor appointments would put him at risk.
This property was bought in the mid 70s as a residential property and has been used as such
continually since then. Mr Reynolds respectfully requests that this special use permit be denied
allowing him the right to continue to use his property in the manner that it was designed for,
residential..
Respectfully,
"Jeannette Reynolds for
Raymond R Reynolds
Mr. Eric Smith
C/O Maricopa County Planning and Development Dept
501 W 44th St Suite 200
Phoenix, AZ 85008
RE: Opposition to Special Use Permit, for the property located at 35011 N 10th St, Phoenix, AZ Case #
Z2019019, parcel #211-52-105B
Dear Mr. Smith;
My name is Jeannette Reynolds and I own two contiguous parcels with the address of 34831 N 10th St,
Phoenix, AZ. The parcel numbers are, 211-52-057B and 211-211-52-057C. I would like to object to the
issuance of a special use permit to a Mr. J Thiele that would allow a commercial business to be
conducted on a property currently zoned residential, located at 35011 N. 10th St, Phoenix, AZ. My
reasons for opposing this permit are as follows:
This proposed business is not a reasonable sized, homebased business but is actully boardering on an
industrial use. I purchased my property in the mid 70's and moved here because I wanted to live in a
nice rural, residential area. Now as a disabled senior citizen my quality of life is being severly effected.
Since the applicant has applied for this use permit, he has continued operating his business with no
regard for his neighbors. He has kept an inventory of up to 40+ flat beds to be installed on pickup trucks,
utilizing a forklift to unload deliveries of the beds, and to move them around the property as more are
delivered or he installs them. This creates a noise issue as well as a dust concern in an area that a high
incident of valley fever. In addition he operates at all hours and days of the week. He may be working at
6am or 11pm. As a neighbor I have had to exsist with excessive noise, loud music, loud talking, grinding,
beating on metal and the backup alarm on the forklift. This may occur any day of the week, includig
Saturday, Sunday and holidays. Again he has shown no concern for the effect this has on his neighbors.
This has created a hardship for me as I can no longer enjoy simple outdoor activities on my property. I
do not have air conditioning so even having my windows open in the summer to cool the house has
become difficult.
Please help keep our neighborhood with the rural/residential enviorment that it is currently zoned as
and deny this reqrest for a special use permit. If he doesn't show respect for his neighbors now, I fear
with the issuance of the permit, it will only get worse. Thank you.
Respectfully,
Jeannette Reynolds
34831 N. 10th St
Phoenix, AZ 85086
RECEIVED DEC 03 201
RECEIVED 1)..0 93 2019
December 1, 2019
Case fl22019019
Dear Mr_ Smith,
I'm writing in opposition to the Special Use Permit requested by Anchorpoint Welding for operating a
welding business out of a residence, parcel number 211-52-105B. My family purchased 35845 N 10' h St.
(Parcel # 211-52-109-X) in 1974, and built a house in 1977 to reside, and raise their families in a nice
peaceful residential area, In June of 2019, my father, Raymond R eynolds passed away after being
confined to his house for several months prior to his hospitalization, because recent increase In dust and
odors in the area
There are multiple reasons that I oppose the approval of the special use permit AnChOrpoint Welding is
requesting. The main point of entry to our house is on the northside, which faces parcel #211-52-105B,
The wall, hoists and the oversized building is not something that I would like to see when I look out my
door every morning, and with my wife's health issues (Chronic Migraines, Multiple Chemical
Sensitivities, and Chronic Coccidiornycosis, aka valley Fever, which left her with her severe asthma),
approval of this request would limit our ability to utilize our property, affecting my family's quality of
life, and violating our civil rights to enjoy a peaceful existence. My Family moved out of the city to enjoy
a peaceful life with beautiful views of the desert. With the changes that Anchorpoint Welding is
proposing, It will dramatically affect the peaceful residential area by converting it into commercial,
permanently changing the ambience that everyone that moved out there to enjoy.
I am not just speaking as a rl generation property owner in the area, I am speaking on behalf all the
people's fife the Anchorpoint Welding would affect.
Please don't allow our neighborhood to turn into an industrial complex.
Upon his passing my father left the property to myself and my siblings. I'm including a copy of the
beneficiary deed to show ownership. The property has been placed in a family trust, and I am still a
shared owner.
Ronald Reynolds
Planning & Development
Department
DATE:
December 11, 2019
TO:
Planning and Zoning Commission
FROM:
Eric R. Smith, Planner
SUBJECT:
Z2019019 - Anchor Point Welding
Agenda Item: 17
After writing of the staff report for Z2019019, staff has received five (5) additional
opposition documents (1 letter and 4 emails). These documents have been included as
attachments to this memo for your considerations.
Attachments: Additional Opposition Documents (5 pages)
502 N. 44th Street, Suite 200 • Phoenix, AZ 85008 • (602) 506-2364 • (602) 506-3711 fax
>Internet: www.maricopa.gov/planning
vt.,149._
Mr. Eric Smith
C/O Maricopa County Planning and Development Dept
501 W 44th St Suite 200
Phoenix, AZ 85008
RE: Opposition to Special Use Permit, for the property located at 35011 N 10th St, Phoenix, AZ
Case # Z2019019, parcel #211-52-105B
Dear Mr. Smith;
My name is Jeannette Reynolds and I own two contiguous parcels with the address of 34831 N
10th St, Phoenix, AZ. The parcel numbers are, 211-52-057B and 211-211-52-057C. I would like
to object to the issuance of a special use permit to a Mr. J Thiele that would allow a commercial
business to be conducted on a property currently zoned residential, located at 35011 N. 10th St,
Phoenix, AZ. My reasons for opposing this permit are as follows:
This proposed business is not a reasonable sized, homebased business but is actully boardering
on an industrial use. I purchased my property in the mid 70's and moved here because I wanted
to live in a nice rural, residential area. Now as a disabled senior citizen my quality of life is being
severly effected. Since the applicant has applied for this use permit, he has continued operating
his business with no regard for his neighbors. He has kept an inventory of up to 40+ flat beds to
be installed on pickup trucks, utilizing a forklift to unload deliveries of the beds, and to move
them around the property as more are delivered or he installs them. This creates a noise issue
as well as a dust concern in an area that a high incident of valley fever. In addition he operates
at all hours and days of the week. He may be working at 6am or 11pm. As a neighbor I have had
to exsist with excessive noise, loud music, loud talking, grinding, beating on metal and the
backup alarm on the forklift. This may occur any day of the week, includig Saturday, Sunday and
holidays. Again he has shown no concern for the effect this has on his neighbors. This has
created a hardship for me as I can no longer enjoy simple outdoor activities on my property. I
do not have air conditioning so even having my windows open in the summer to cool the house
has become difficult.
Please help keep our neighborhood with the rural/residential enviorment that it is currently
zoned as and deny this req rest for a special use permit. If he doesn't show respect for his
neighbors now, I fear with the issuance of the permit, it will only get worse. Thank you.
Respectfully,
J6tinnette Reynolds
34831 N. 10th St
Phoenix, AZ 85086
'I
Eric Smith (PND)
From:
Stevie Reno <sreno_iinsure@cox.net >
Sent:
Friday, December 6,2019 11:29 AM
To:
Eric Smith (PND)
Subject:
case Z2019019
Hello,
I am writing to submit my formal protest to a zoning change for Anchorpoint Welding. Our parcel number is 211-52-
107B.
I oppose this change as I am very concerned about the existing noise coming from the property as it is and feel this will
only get worse with a special use permit as a welding business. This is a quiet residential area and that is one of the
reasons we purchased here. To allow one neighbor to purchase a property for only business use is opening the door for
other with would drop our property value and reduce the quality of life here. Please record my opposition to this
request for special use permit. Please confirm receipt.
Thank you,
Stephanie Reno
35043 N loth a Phoenix, AZ 85086
sreno iinsure@cox.net
1
Eric Smith (PND)
From:
Denice Reynolds <neice3206@aol.com >
Sent:
Wednesday, December 4, 2019 10:29 AM
To:
Eric Smith (PND)
Subject:
Case number Z2019019
I am writing in regards to case number Z2019019 parcel number 211-52105B. My name is Denice Reynolds Griffin. I am
opposed to the permit being requested for parcel Number 211-52105B. My family bought parcel number 211-52109X,
211-52057B, and 211-52057C in the mid 70s to move away from the city to a rural area. The hearing has been even
happened yet and there are dozens of rigs already being worked on. We are already concerned about the dust, noise,
and fumes caused by this property. Our entrance is to the north side of the property along with the front door to the
house which is Ames parcel 211-52105B. I am a partial owner of Parcel 211-52109X. In the a puzzle of this hearing the
other two parcels belong to my Jeanette Reynolds who has also lived there since 1974. This is going to be damaging to
my mothers health at her age and my stepfather's. I am on the trust to these two parcels as well. This leaves five
generations that have shared these parcels please keep our property of 45 years safe from commercial case number
Z2019019.
If you have any further questions for me feel free to call me at 602-488-5945
Sent from my iPhone
1
Eric Smith (PND)
From:
Sent:
To:
Cc:
Subject:
Michael Sankey <ms4344@msn.com >
Wednesday, December 4, 2019 5:53 PM
Eric Smith (PND)
Stevie
Case# Z2019019 Archpoint Welding
Mr. Smith,
I recently received a post card concerning the hearing for this business. The postcard states that a letter must
be received by the Friday before the hearing which is set for 12/12/19. Will this email suffice as a letter? I
plan to attend the hearing
I am not in support for this to be approved. This is a residential area. The property that this case is based is a
house. The owner does not live at the property and the property is used as a business.
If this is approved does this mean that I can request a permit to build a Jiffy Lube if my neighbors support it or
my neighbors can turn their property into a commercial business?
Please advise if my email will suffice as a letter of protest. I will mail a copy tomorrow.
Thank you
Mike Sankey
35043 N. 10th ST
Phoenix, AZ 85086
1
Case # Z2019019
November 30, 2019
Dear Mr. Smith,
I'm writing in opposition to the special use permit for the welding business being run out of a
residence. Parcel number 211-52-105B. I am a shared owner to the property next door to the south.
Parcel number 211-52-109x. My property was previously owned by my father, who unfortunately
passed in June of this year. He was also strongly opposed to this business. My father, who loved the
outdoors, was limited in his final months and needed to stay close to home. This business made it tough
for my him to enjoy the outdoors of his own property. Noise and dust among other things kept him
indoors. He knew my fathers' condition, and never stopped. It is understood that if the welding
operation gets their special use permit, they would probably be required to build a wall. But that won't
block the view of his hoists. It won't block the view of an oversized workshop. It won't stop the dust. It
won't stop the noise. It won't stop the fumes. It won't reduce customer traffic.
My family has owned this land since the mid-70s. They/we didn't move to the Desert Hills area
to live in an industrial neighborhood.
The individual that is requesting the special use permit has not been playing by the rules. Why
should we assume that he will moving forward? His yard is full of equipment and is an industrial blight
on the neighborhood. There are plenty of areas that are zoned accordingly for his type of business.
Please don't allow our neighborhood to turn into an industrial complex.
Thank you
John P Reynolds
P.S. I'm including a copy of the beneficiary deed to show ownership. As the property has been placed in
a family trust since then. I'm still a shared owner.
"14
Rwand,
ft' a yrpwad Rone5. ,-,1 RE-1n RrOrlg
34345 Nli)'" si
'VC,R6
2,Cir? • 16 6•-:=F-43'1
Fv. ,3
'
KRAUS:qt.!
RT.
I .1
S042'-g
• IT AY.A)
VAT "Eq7uAr
rt.31,4ai..41'
ond Rortak) ernth the undersigmd5 P`t,t0110, dio bei.-eby ecnvey
to dioltri Reyaeldg, Floariito. ileirizo/dA ztnd D:;t1lbt.' &r._61014
tOATOS3 ;',"3.17,M,P511,0)11,
grayttee effective en ?,fty deAth, all rights, t xid igierefit in that f,'-crtain, property situ5teo
MARICOPA COUNTY, StaT ArU7ONA znd fk-fisoiteJ
LEGAL. -DESC.;:,
NI':
hi)
n49,ChFe ':trete
t NE:ma:0
Commati - mr 34?45 N 0th
Phmnix, AZ
PROPVITY EV.;
A. 11-1134
Dwed j
cATE OF ARY7,0N.<9
1..70UNT V OF MAR ICOV-1,5
/
'kJ.. .2.
••
••
-
•)-.\ A
_
-
„ • N,
,
•
:%., I" -,.., J"."- 1 ,,,J:
, s..!
P %
-i..." 7. 1, ,;.c..- /?..
''' f
•
2
'
:--
•
..
:
---
,..4
'
.
..
../
. -
.
..
.
-
/
/-'
3 '///
7
,f
/1
'
7
/
->,777, 7
',/
> l
->..-
7..
1
77
.
'\.
7
/:V/tXY / /-
2;i
. .
"
,''7
1
./
•-
—t
;•'
/ p.
-: \-
„"
-
- ,
/
Rachel Applegate (PND)
Subject:
FW: Special Use Permit Z2019019
Original Message
From: Jeannette R. <jeannette_reynolds@hotmail.com >
Sent: Saturday, December 21, 2019 5:39 AM
To: PND PZAppeal <PNDPZAppeal@maricopa.gov>
Subject: Re: Special Use Permit Z2019019
I would like to submit a formal request to appeal the decision to approve the special use permit for Anchorpoint
Wielding to be located at 35011 N. 10th St. The recommended approval took place at the hearing conducted on
December 12, 2019. My basis for this appeal is:(1) of the 20 letters in support many if not all of them or not within 300
feet of this proposed business. The majority of us that are adjacent to this property are not in support of this. We are
the ones that this will have the most adverse affect on, taking away our quality of life and reducing our property values;
(2) the property that is adjacent to this proposed business has been placed in my family trust. This property is on the
south side where there is nothing more than a chain-link fence. There were no stipulations to correct this issue. All
activity and storage will be visible from this property severely affecting the ability to enjoy the property at 34845 N 10th
St; (3) it is my understanding that a very large building will be placed at the south east corner of this property which
again would adversely affect the property on the south with the noise and dust as work is conducted moving trucks,
truck beds and other items back and forth into the building with a forklift in addition to causing a visual blight.
The letters of support was a form letter drawn up by the lawyer representing the business owner and do not accurately
represent the properties that will most seriously be negatively affected.
Respectfully,
Jeannette Reynolds
34831 N 10th St
602 348-7211
Sent from my iPhonet from my iPhone
1
Rachel Applegate (PND)
From:
Sent:
To:
Cc:
Subject:
Attachments:
Rachel Applegate (PND)
Friday, December 27, 2019 8:08 AM
Eric Smith (PND)
Rachel Applegate (PND)
FW: SUP #Z2019019
SUP Appeal_0001.pdf; 20191225_141510jpg; 20191225_135535.jpg; 20191225_
135511.jpg; 20191225_135453jpg
From: Ron Reynolds <reynolds_racing@cox.net >
Sent: Wednesday, December 25, 2019 8:40 PM
To: PND PZAppeal <PNDPZAppeal@maricopa.gov >
Subject: FW: SUP #Z2019019
I would like to formally appeal the request of SUP #Z2019019. I have attached a letter addressing my issues with this
request along with photos of my parcel and what we will be able to see daily. As you can see in some of the photos the
property owner is currently stacking trunk beds higher than the existing wall, which would interfere with the views of
the adjoining neighbors.
I am asking you to please reconsider the recommendation for approval of SUP #Z2019019
That you for your time
Ronald Reynolds
1
December 20, 2019
Case ttZ2019019
Dear Maricopa County Zoning Appeal Board,
I'm writing to formally appeal, the Maricopa County's Planning and Zoning Commission's
recommendation of approval of the Special Use Permit requested by Anchorpoint Welding for operating
a welding and vehicle modification business out of a residence, at 35011 N. 10' n St. (parcel 211-52-
10513), My family purchased 35845 N 10 u St, (Parcel l 211-52-109-X) in 1974, and built a house in 1977
to reside, and raise their families in a nice peaceful residential area. In June of 2019, my father,
Raymond Reynolds passed away after being confined to his house for several months prior to his
hospitalization, because recent increase in dust and odors in the area.
There are multiple reasons that I oppose the approval of the special use permit that Anchorpoint
Welding is requesting. The main point of entry to our house is on the northside, which faces parcel
4211-52-105B. The increased traffic, the hoists and the proposed oversized building and is not
something that I would like to see when I look out my door every morning and will affect the property
value, it does not appear that these conditions were taken into consideration with their
recommendation. Currently my wife has multiple health issues (Chronic Migraines, Multiple Chemical
Sensitivities, and Chronic Coccidiomycosis, aka Valley Fever, which left her with her severe asthma),
approval of this request would limit our ability to utilize our property, affecting my family's quality of
life, and violating our civil right to enjoy a peaceful existence. My family moved out of the city to enjoy a
peaceful life with beautiful views of the desert. The changes that Anchorpoint Welding is proposing will
dramatically affect this peaceful residential area by converting it into a commercially zoned parcel and
permanently changing the ambience that everyone moved here to enjoy.
I am not just speaking as a 3ril generation property owner in the area, I am speaking on behalf of all the
people whose lives the Anchorpoint Welding would affect.
Please don't allow our neighborhood to turn into an industrial complex.
Upon his passing my father left the property to myself and my siblings. I'm including a copy of the
beneficiary deed to show ownership. The property has been placed in a family trust, and I am still a
shared owner.
Respectfully,
Ronald Reynolds
II OF /
ORIGINAL
ETA7E COPY
STATE OF ARIZONA
DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH SERVICES-BUREAu OF VITAL RECORDS
CERTIFICATE OF DEATH
State Rie Number
102-2019 025936
1 11C.,.:E:W211 I LI. ;_•.1 es..•.!....: ,t1r, ! VI•II.I...F— 1.,:., 1 7..lf D 1 , 1
RAYMOND RtiwAio, werloLiss
.
',TEE. :.! .t ,,
ogroli2019
nrrttr L r ..,.. / 'dr, !.. , 61.
MALE
527-72-3572
ii.i C, 12;Rttl
12/18/1946
72 YEARS
!, r•TVIC/MI.C(3910Y1,t1321t , 01‘ . LICA111101 1 ,1:Mil
6COTT51.)41_ IL MARICOPA 95261; ,
_ ....VV._
_.
...E-=':
MEDICAL CENTER
, . a:2E V" r....0 . , • 7').f .
1,'Irrrr',_ , , . = , , . i .7
INPAT IENT - HoNoRi-irnt_ili SCOT rsDAI. I'. !-_11 ILA
• n tyrtrrt...LE ILA r AN:JOLT!: NI t cg ,ELErt !Atilt: Mr)
',lit IIREVF.ROR I t. 0 CJISIANA
It 10. 1 ..1?-1 ETATIA
DIVORCED
lz nA1.1.01- 11 , ,14 ,7),172. spou,:i 'prime IC golf 1,11mor,3, If. 41 Ult2D f.,
1.51 cUrrixt
NOT LISIED
11 ti LL•KE--,- fi lit Pc REED,.!. I V4CEEttn ;`,1 I41 1 7 Egr V. ,',I)III , 31.I'L: .90,
34845 N 10111 S IREET, PHOENIX MARICOPA, AZ, 850M
II I: El'EE
NO, NOT sfrANISHIHISPAr4ictuk1irio
vAIITE
-
_
YES
.....
i ? eiv,cmpAtiut,
coNSIRUCTRw!ilJPERIFLII,NriFt4i
:t r..r-
r.r.I , Er:- ,,r;,': •,I '...... 1_,Lf,'!1
.
I (USSELL . RIE.I40, REYNOLDS
I; tioT!-E.....!. :1`.-It .--- r i gLE, r._, -
EUNICE, INEZ, WORTHINGTON
•.,•.;!..',E I;;3 VII- •_-.1 ; L.,.!:: _SUFFIX)
?...., Irgt3.93,1,141 , r,, LIE0- 1 11 0, 111 01)11.1 ,....7 Id 0 11.
irAt•Itcrri 1
REYel ,..
;Logy...! 1 ,, . tiryt.r, I1r,Ir. •-• I • ,, L7,t'LL. 7,rf t - tr...71:
, WADS'A'OR I . H
1.
ALLISON
21 1.4 IAIIMES-IP
2: IA- I II"' yivaco
F1252
11 InFOFV.,,,,,, V.' .
34031 NUTTII SWEET, , PHOENIX, AZ 850E0
..1!:?.•IF..:,-:,,_ , , r_j 7, c. r L , ..! ,,, L .r. ,:.i.; ,. : • •.r - .s.c- ..1. 1 12.--2,4
St IAD0'.,.` MOUNTAIN MORTUARY
2350 5 GREEMVAY ROAR PI ipErox A7.., tIti022
vETI-IDDM CI 111S1'OSrt ,,t,
21 NAME iV.D L Or.itt 1 ,.91 G. 1ST r.if.1'0 .1.1' ON FAE III r
1 1 1 IOWA. Mr: I il ,:ArKiti ,'; rtin DSPr',',,I,L1r, I i,r,ILrry
IGRELNwo 013 MEMORY LAWN CREMATORY
I FLEMATIN
P 1-1 L.1.: NIX, AZ. US
I_
, ,i ...EL, ,,, T1 I ,,,.. L E C.F CL ^III
NUL 110R3/01 L I Y5TEPL1 FM URE
MEDidliCDERTIFititTioN SEDTION CAUSE OF DEATH PART I
V
,
' , ..r•isi,..,..r• il !WU, ." _
2 DAYS
•
' ;,:i.l.t 0 I.:1.1 , • I IVER,1",1
30 DAYS
, 2.'...l.CC.!, -.:•.'; I '• - I C
hitt 1 VERStiN HOST OLf.3EASE. GRADE 4 REFRACTORY
3 e DUE TO ell 1, ,.. r3 E.011:11, 21 , 111cE ur
7,11,r, , •_, ',-,T EM CELL 11q.., AL.SPLMii
.
PARTE
NO
_
NATURAL.
31 1,1734:33, 0,110 , VTE...1204..
:Itmr,./ lb-IS _
12 MON. II IS
KIYELODYSP I AST'S` SYNDROME
DEATH
AUSE OF
CAUSE AND MANNER
1G OW51
SRIC;(,S
,),.,goms'i
l' I F THE
,I, 1.4TE
LIEATI-t
UF13Eitilt
,I1 FL.::
CERTIFICATION
06 2I
rtAr•
41 Ww.!.. All ALITIll•M 3 7„.141
1 E.11 L•rOsi ut
lE CC, I,11. 1
. t
01,'04/291C ,
111, 1•ro3),Wr."3,111,1'
SAL; ,i 14' DEATH)
,.. _ 1 , 1 ,
.r. t:. ,), ig FEFIE '3NCX. I.111.1-1
Ti) illit Lf.2.2 LA Lw1c'41LLOL,L: till 11' 4‘ , AV71;- ,I ,
,t.ltri ,.1•43E.r. hitt" ; r ..t.g) 11 ...F EFAIII CC, (:111tIlrf, 1 ,, L
l•-• I! I C'....__f . 'i • ..,it ,,.......7.11 ..,1,,,, ft
' AD R t E1.1N 'E
1.1003 E Si ILA BOULEVARD, S _ ' ISOALEA2, $5260
.
lide Reg racit.0 ot3rl)4/2019
Dtoe laset:Li 05/10,201[ 1
VS-40 Rev 12/2017
Milt; MI r;•;;LBUrri
HAAR
r‘—trit7tAVI
f
71---nri, JIf 1
e--
1111. 111IT
Raymon onald Reynolds Grant&
Unofficial
Document
When Recorded Mail to:
Raymond Ronald Reynolds
34845 N 10'h St.
Phoenix, AZ 85086
MI
2007-1162561 10/26/07 01:10 PM
1 OF 3
f4FUVO-I
BENEFICIARY DEED
KNOW ALL MEN BY THESE PRESENTS:
That I Raymond Ronald Reynolds the undersigned, granthr(s), do hereby convey
to John Reynolds, Ronnie Reynolds and Denise Reynolds as tenants in common,
grantee, effective on my death, all rights, title and 'interest in that certain property situated
in MARICOPA COUNTY, State of ARIZONA and described as follows:
LEGAL DESCRIPTION:
See Exhibit "A" attached hereto and made a part hereof..
Commonly Known as: 34845 N lOth Street, Phoenix, AZ
Parcel Number; 21 I-52-109'-X
PROPERTY EXEMPT FROM AFFIDAVIT AND FILING FEES PURSUANT TO
A.R.S. 1-113-I b-2
Dated 1 Oh -I)
STATE OF ARIZONA
}SS:
COUNTY OF MARICOPA }
This Itioefieiary Deed wa5rAcknowledeA1 bef9cvine tj,
day of ;
ary Public, on this
In Witne:-;s whereof. I herewith set n
20071162561
„—
+s,
S I ATE OP ARIZONA
SS
COUNTY OF MARICOPA
This Beneficiary Dced was acknowledged before me, a Notary Public, on this
:day of
, 2002 by
In Witness whereof, I herewith set my hand and official seal.
Notary Public
STATE OF Colorado
SS:
COUNTY OF
This Beneficiary Deed was acknowledged before me. a Notary Public, on this
day of
.2002 by
In Witness whereof, I herewith set my hand and official seal.
Notary Public
20071162561
20051738082
"Exhibit A"
mscatrrioN
THE NORTHERLY PART OF PARCEL 211-52-057 A & PARCEL 2 1 -52409 G
A Portion of the SoUthvrest Quarter of Section 4, T5N, R3E of the Cl & &RE, & M,,
Maricopa County, 4rizo
. na and is more particularly described as follows:
Commencing at a Etass Cap in a Hand hole at the South Quarter Corner of Section 4, T5N,
F.3 E;
thence along the Southerly Line of Section 4, 5g9°5909" W 1318.81' to a Point in Same
and at the Southwest Corner of the Southeast Quarter of the Southwest Quarter of
Section 4;
thence along the Westerly Line of Said Southeast Quarter of the Southwest Quarter of
Section 4, N 0019'08" W 1254.04' to a Point in Same and at the Extended Southerly
Line of this Parcel;
thence along the Said Extended Southerly Lined this Parcel S 89 1'3312" B 40.00' to the
Southwest Corner of this Parcel and TEE TRUE POINT OF BEGINNING,
thence along the Easter.IY Right-of-Way Line of 101 Street N 0019'08" W 167.72' to a
, Point in Same and. the Northwest Corner of this Parcel;
thence along the Northerly Line of this Parcel S 89°29'19" E 629.26' to the Northeast
Corner of this Parcel;
thence along the Extended Easterly tine of the West Half of the Southeast Quarter of the
Southwest Qua!ter of Section 4, S 00°04'39" W 167:00' to a Point at the Southeast
Corner of this Parcel;
ewe along the Southerly Line of e
-c,7T 89,3'12" W 628.10' to THE TRUE POINT
OF BEGINNING.
ntaining 2.4153 Acres Net of land be the same more or less.
•
.1
fi
-1 IP -6..
.:1
:17-I.
24
P.I i ::tti
,
,'.,.... t,,,
:I • k.... 0. , .../11'"Al
•Tr'1. ii'‘ -11"'Ci9;1
" t'kt.,40.1
..*%
4
_ i
l'i2.01.i,l-b
N
11''OL"
'6i I •
4,1.71 INA,: •
i MI AI. 1111
Vge:;;Wo .
'111fi
jej-411"..2"gfrttM
riikgml-T•t•-
(Po_tr.is -
mit
a
4--- \---:1-1-1--*'" t'-C'fil:'
inmr--
--,--
- -e:,•','•'_. ' -":-
.-
- -•••-e:,:-0- adit--4.4, -- --4•2 .-----="-----A
'•?.:114:,4,?-•-Noi"
• ,
"::;'10/111,
__
_
...
- , • :,,,, 4,e,"•:';--.0--.!
,"..±.4, ' • ":#;"'erffi 401
....,- . . • - ..,. --,..:.:'2 .- -: - ,:".4-:4,,..0,!:,q,'.-
,..,....:....,... ......i. ••01/it
:if_
vo
.F.74
.X.,;(...14. 14
,;,=,.....,,,,..„,...,.
i e y'A.,91%, wett24P
7,.—
.....—,=.:
so:44....
AWN'. .11 • •;.de•
• ,;.1fr•
.--44.11.6011110"....04714#0
r.
Ate.;
• -
4.44
11‘1"1
1
•0:;•‘,,K.1.4-7,7JMNIM
rayfic
t lyetp, it,),V,Akf-Als
my,"
• • .1.04-4.4 • • *A • • .11
vi9
—
AttizivtAtoweweemoo f
sievAndamtwp,......*rn r
;.•
A •
•2_41E:11_;zrz.rfa
•
r0,474 vir""004 WOO WI" 4 vi WW1' ri
:02,7
..".:I•••0....wo :4! -
-44A-4!..*A1Aft
" 51"FAVAS
frigOr-
-
PI/
I
1A7/
403471
/1/1
- •
ftA
•
•
: r;:r4ti;?&1074.41:
"
VIM Wan- fikr,
_
•
-
7 7,1
I••
-
. - -
-
17',7
•
.4 • t'"'"..
1"7"-nf
Rachel Applegate (PND)
From:
Sent:
To:
Cc:
Subject:
Importance:
Rachel Applegate (PND)
Friday, December 27, 2019 2:54 PM
Eric Smith (PND)
Rachel Applegate (PND)
FW: SUP#Z2019019 *URGENT*
High
From: John Reynolds <reynrace@msn.com >
Sent: Friday, December 27, 2019 1:13 PM
To: PND PZAppeal <PNDPZAppeal@maricopa.goy>
Subject: SUP#Z2019019 *URGENT*
Importance: High
I would like to formally appeal the request of SUP #Z2019019. Parcel number 211-52-105B. I am a tenant in
common located directly to the south. Parcel 211-52-109X. This plan goes against what the majority our
affected neighbors want. The property owner is already stacking materials higher than the back wall of the
property. We can't allow our residential neighborhood to deteriorate into industrial. My family has owned
this property since the mid 70s. Anchorpoint welding has only been in that location for a short
time. Approximately 2 years. The majority of people who reside in New River and Desert Hills moved out
there for the rural lifestyle. Please keep it that way.
I am asking you to please reconsider the recommendation for approval of SUP #Z2019019
Thank you
John Reynolds
1