Extracted text (via pymupdf)
61793 characters
• Planning & Zoning Commission hearing date
SEPTEMBER 23, 2021
• Agenda item and case number
ITEM #3 CASE# Z2019134
• Name: Brent Bialik
• Address: 11620 S 44th Ave, Laveen Village, AZ 85339
• e-mail: rmp5s1@gmail.com
• phone number: 8599072433
I am in OPPOSITION to this proposal!! I have no idea who in their right mind would think putting a
WEDDING VENUE in the middle of a neighborhood (where there is no city water or sewer!) is a good
idea but it's not. It's a terrible idea. For everyone involved. It MUST NOT BE ALLOWED.
I will be attending the virtual meeting tomorrow and I DO wish to speak.
--Brent
•Planning & Zoning Commission hearing date: SEPTEMBER 23, 2021 •Agenda item and case number:
ITEM #3 CASE# Z2019134
• Tracie Riggs
• 7220 S 27th Ave
• tkriggs@asu.edu
• 602-793-0038
I am in opposition to this agenda item.
I live 3 houses down from a wedding venue and wouldn’t want another residential neighborhood
dealing with the issues we face. We get drunk people wandering up and down the road. We had to build
a gate as people came onto our property...including an intoxicated Phoenix police officer who decided
he could cite city code to justify trespassing! They set off fireworks without notification. Music plays all
through the evening, and they operate all through the week.
This is a residential neighborhood. A commercial operation has NO business intruding into this area. The
whole community is against this. Please listen!
Date: Wed, Sep 22, 2021, 2:31 PM
Subject: Planning and zoning hearing Sept 23, item #3, case #Z2019134
• Planning & Zoning Commission hearing date
SEPTEMBER 23, 2021
• Agenda item and case number
ITEM #3 CASE# Z2019134
• Name: tiah Bialik
• Address: 11620 S 44th Ave, Laveen Village, AZ 85339
• e-mail: tiah.sonny@gmail.com
• phone number: 8596204215
I am in OPPOSITION to this proposal!! I have no idea who in their right mind would think putting a WEDDING
VENUE in the middle of a neighborhood (where there is no city water or sewer!) is a good idea but it's not. It's a
terrible idea. For everyone involved. It MUST NOT BE ALLOWED.
Zoning and Planning Commission Case Number 20191354
Enchanted Garden
Objections to Special Use Permit
Hearing 9/23/2021
I object to the request for a Special Use Permit to allow the building and operation of a party
venue in my neighborhood. The proposal is a blatant attempt to misuse the Special Use Permit
process to circumvent the current R-43 Zoning and to permit a Commercial project in a rural
residential neighborhood. The project is flawed and should be denied.
The proponents of this project are requesting numerous variances in order to make the project
remotely feasible. These include extending the time frame for the permit from 10 years to 15
years because it will take five years to complete construction of the project. There is no
explanation for this great length of time needed but it can be assumed that lack of money is the
main factor. This obviously raises concerns of the project being started then left undone or
being finished, and the business failing leaving an unusable unsightly mess on the mountain, a
smaller version of the “quarry” on the eastern edge of Carver Mountain.
This request for a Special Use Permit is not from someone who lives in the area, already lives on
the property and has most of the infrastructure and buildings, but a project on a raw piece of
land where building and infrastructure has to start from nothing. There are too many
unanswered questions to approve the project. The person proposing the venue is not even the
owner of the property.
Proponents are also requesting a variance to increase the amount of the mountain they can
bulldoze down. Again, the property and the Zoning do not support the plan proposed. A
variance to allow more of the mountain hillside to be destroyed should not be granted. The
proposal is suitable for the site and the current zoning.
Proponents want a variance to construct a 44 foot tall “tower”, a completely unnecessary
eyesore for the neighborhood and not in conformance with the neighborhood or zoning.
Proponents should find a site that is suitable for their needs, and does not violate zoning or
community standards.
The plan as outlined does not address issues such as rainwater runoff from the mountain.
Those of us who live in the area know that during particularly heavy rainstorms a very large
amount of water comes off Carver Mountain. There is no plan for ensuring that the rainwater
goes where it is supposed to and does not flood the neighborhoods.
The plan does not address the specifics of the septic system, or whether a septic system is even
feasible considering the hundreds of people a day it would need to accommodate.
The plan says the project would take 5 years to complete, will be done in stages, and requests
again a variance to allow for a Special Use Permit for 15 years instead of the normal 10. There is
no schedule for construction, no estimate of anything nor any hint of whether the venue would
expect to be operational at any time during the construction and what that would look like or
how it would affect the surrounding neighborhood.
There is no need for another party venue on Carver Mountain. There are already several
wedding/party venues in the area and there is no need for a high risk project that serves no
purpose for the neighborhood, is a high risk business venture and could potentially leave the
site damaged and unfinished.
Impact on the Neighborhood
1. The proposed project will permanently alter the character of the neighborhood, which is a
unique rural/residential oasis nestled between the far western edge of South Mountain and
Carver Mountain. The area is zoned R-43, as is the site for the proposed party venue, and the
area residents enjoy the quiet and solitude with their horses, goats, children and other
amenities that come with a semi-rural lifestyle.
2. The neighborhood is extremely quiet and tranquil and offers value to Maricopa County as
one of the unique, diverse neighborhoods that attract people to live in the County. It stands in
stark contrast to the hundreds (or thousands) of other “cookie cutter” neighborhoods in the
County. The neighborhood, along with Carver Mountain and South Mountain themselves,
deserves to be preserved.
3. The proposed party/wedding venue will bring an inevitable end to the tranquil neighborhood
by imposing a commercial enterprise on its residents, along with the accompanying noise,
traffic and intrusions into the neighborhood that a party venue expected to regularly host 250
people will do.
4. The party venue will not benefit any resident of the area, but the resultant, inevitable noise,
traffic, light pollution, etc. will violate resident’s fundamental right to the enjoyment of the
quiet, peace and tranquility of their property.
The Party Venue Will have Specific and Direct Negative Impacts on the Neighborhood
1. Increased traffic which will cause backups, traffic jams, and delays for the residents. The
proposed party venue is located on the only main road in and out of the neighborhood. It is a
single lane in each direction and there are only small neighborhood streets that intersect in the
area near the proposed venue.
2. The nature of the proposed business is to have multiple events at scheduled intervals . With
250 + people arriving and leaving at the same time, and up to six or so times a day. They will all
be coming and leaving at exactly the same time, causing inevitable delays and traffic backups
and increased chance of accidents. Residents frequently walk, bike ride, and horseback ride in
the area and the increased traffic (possibly of people under the influence of alcohol) puts
residents in danger. The increased traffic (at times perhaps not known to residents) could cause
delay of people trying to get to work, or even delay lifesaving first responders racing to save a
life. There will also be additional traffic due to caterers, suppliers, etc.
3.. The increased traffic will cause additional dust and noise will which also impact the ability of
residents to enjoy their property.
4. There will inevitably be overflow parking clogging our neighborhood streets. The proposal
only includes 114 parking places, with 3 handicapped spots. This is not nearly enough to
accommodate the expected attendance at the parties. This means that party goers will be
parking in the neighborhood and driving through the neighborhood streets. Weddings and
parties include alcohol, and intoxicated people will be driving and walking through the
neighborhood on a regular basis endangering residents and their animals in addition to causing
general disruption to the peace of the neighborhood.
5. Noise. It is inevitable that 250 + party goers will create a lot of noise. Shockingly, the
Proponents of this project plan to “direct the noise to the south” to supposedly prevent the
noise from echoing from the mountain. (As noise travels outward in all directions it is doubtful
this plan would succeed) My house, as well as my neighbors, is directly south of the proposed
site and it is horrifying that their plan is to direct their noise onto my property. I have a right to
the enjoyment of my property and the proponents of this party venue hope to take that from
me and my neighbors.
6.. The proposal states that they party venue would be operational from 8 am to 10 pm
weekdays and 8 am to 11 pm weekends. This means that I and my neighbors can be subjected
to the noise and disruption from the parties all day every day and until 11:00 at nights on the
weekends. The caveat that the parties will be mostly on Saturdays is not comforting as Saturday
and the rest of the weekend is when I have the time to enjoy the peace and quiet of my house.
Other concerns:
They talk about the 40 foot tower, bride and groom comes up separate sides handy cap
accusable? EYE Sore!! (No plan)
Parking for handy-cap people/cars or vans (no plan)
Loose gravel walking a challenge
Large Tent, very limited flat surface, Eye Sore for those of us that own $500,000 and up homes
250 attendee’s requirement/emergency accessible? (no plan)
Water retention from tent and parking lot, trailer for portable facilities (no plan)
NO means of providing utilities Water for future residence’s Waste
Trash removal, Trash on streets
Very limited roads to arrive and depart (2) single lane each way
Traffic on our roads, two of which are dead ends!
All of the residents abide by set backs, there is no presidencies to change them
Music?? Every night Non English? Loud till midnight we are a working neighborhood and
require rest!
Disrupting our neighborhood
September 22, 2021
Planning and Zoning Commission
301 W. Jefferson St., 1st Floor, Suite 170
Phoenix, Arizona 85003
Hearing Date: Thursday, September 23, 2021 at 9:30 AM
Agenda Item: Enchanted Garden
Case Number: Z2019134
Applicant in Opposition
Lynn Davis-I am in OPPOSITION to Enchanted Garden
4303 W. Calle Poco Laveen, AZ 85339
lyndavis19@aol.com
480-694-9780
I wish to speak
Rachel.Applegate@Maricopa.Gov
Attn. Rachel Applegate of Zoning Hearing September 23, 2021 at 9:30 AM:
The residents of this community strongly OPPOSE and OBJECT to Agenda
Item Enchanted Garden which is Case Number Z2019134, which is a
request for a Special Use Permit (SUP) for public assembly to accommodate
a wedding/event facility in the Rural-43 zoning district generally located 700’
northwest of the northwest corner of Carver Rd. and 43rd Ave. in the Laveen
area, because this Special Use Permit is in direct violation of the purpose of
this District, which is designed to encourage, preserve, and protect the
historical, rural, and agricultural character of the area.
A commercial wedding/event facility in the proposed location on Carver will
be detrimental to the residents of this area. The proposed commercial
venture will significantly increase traffic, noise, vehicle emissions, pollution,
water drainage, and sewer issues, unruly and inebriated visitors, and crime
to the area. The proposed 40-foot tower will be an eyesore against the
backdrop of majestic trees and the green, serene landscape of this rural
area. The addition of the lighting needed to illuminate this commercial
venture along with the rowdy crowds will transform the night sky and the
tranquil community from a peaceful, star-filled, moonlight paradise, to a sky
resembling the blinding lights of a major athletic stadium filled with screaming
fans.
The proposed commercial development will significantly increase the
population and vehicular traffic; thus, creating a traffic nightmare, and place
pedestrians, beloved pets, and horseback riders using this tiny two-lane
section of Carver Road in danger of pedestrian and pet fatalities. The trees,
green grass, natural vegetation, and landscaping will be replaced by
concrete, asphalt, glass, and steel, thus contributing to even hotter
temperatures and a concrete jungle along this small, concentrated area of
Carver Road.
Developing the site in this manner will adversely affect the residents; and
open the floodgates to other objectionable commercial ventures; that will
destroy this quiet, peaceful environment, and the surrounding community.
Deleterious factors such as overpopulation, traffic congestion, pollution,
water and sewage issues, vehicular homicides from intoxicated drivers,
elimination of natural vegetation, and excessive temperatures will be the
result of this proposed commercial development. The character of the
neighborhood should remain single-family residences with acre-plus lots
filled with trees, flowers, green grass, citrus trees, beloved pets, horses,
livestock, and poultry.
Agenda Item Enchanted Garden which is Case Number Z2019134 SHOULD
NOT BE APPROVED because the reasons for the Special Use Permit to
develop a wedding/event facility in the middle of a small rural community is
not feasible and does not protect or safeguard the community, the
environment, and the public.
Thank You
Hello Ms Applegate,
I'm writing concerning the Planning & Zoning Commission hearing date
SEPTEMBER 23, 2021, 9.30.
The Agenda item and case number, ITEM #3 CASE# Z2019134
Ines Hughes
4206 W Carver Rd, Laveen Village, AZ 85339
ines.hughes@gmail.com
602/451/6212
I'm opposed to this case.
There are many issues that arise from this case.
This is a residential, very quiet rural neighborhood. We have no commercial activities and our roads are
not suited for the additional traffic. The business will broadcast music throughout the valley at all hours
of the day and evening. We are between South Mountain and Carver and the sound echos back and
forth which amplifies every sound. The 40 foot tower stands out as an abomination in this area and
simply doesn't fit with anything else.
The construction plan doesn't account for dust and since it is drawn out over a long period of time we
will have a constant construction area.
Noise, traffic, visual abominations, construction and dust all in a small residential neighborhood speak
against this case.
Please support our neighbourhood with their concern and do not approve this.
I do not wish to speak.
Thank you,
Ines Hughes
Dear Commission,
I have a few issues to address,
Allowing a permit from 10 to 15 years, They state it could take a while to complete. We do not
want to listen to construction off and on for
an undetermined amount of time. If for some reason it does not get completed the mountain
will be destroyed.
Traffic is another issue.
The entrance and exit to the venue are showing at 43rd avenue and Carver road across from
our neighborhood. Carver and 43rd avenue are narrow roads so not set up to handle extra
traffic.
In our neighborhood 43rd avenue has two dead end streets on it with the only way out via Calle
Poco going east.
People leaving the venue, possibly under the influence of alcohol, can end up in our
neighborhood late at night, causing more unwanted traffic, possibly property damage, and
noise as they try to figure their way out.
Parking will be an issue if there is overflow into our neighborhood.
Rainwater will be an issue as we get large volumes of water off of Carver mountain that
currently flows down Carver road.
Putting a structure in front of our neighborhood will affect the way water flows, possibly
pushing it into our neighborhood.
What are their plans to control this?
Noise
Putting up to 250 people in the area will be noisy regardless of steps taken. The mountain is a
natural amplifier of sound and will
push it right into our neighborhoods. I nor my neighbors do not want to listen to music until 10-
11 am every night.
We like our nice quiet community.
Lights
Having this venue will create much unwanted light pollution in the neighborhood.
We in the Orange Grove community love our quiet and friendly community.
In the mornings and evening it is very quiet, at night you can see the stars as if you were up in
the mountains.
Part of living here is having Carver mountain buffer all the noise and light from the greater
Laveen area.
We do not need a lighted structure with amplified music on Carver mountain.
This event venue will take that all away and diminish our property values.
Thank you for your time,
David Lee
4419 West Calle Poco
Laveen,AZ 85339
Conserving Rural Laveen!
To Whom It May Concern:
I strongly oppose the special use permit on Carver Rd and 43rd Ave for a wedding venue (case #
Z2019134). The size of the venue does not belong in a residential neighborhood. The fact that they have
to request several variances means that it is not suited for the area. They are essentially asking for a
blank check since nothing is built already. Also, by approving these variances you are setting a new
precedent for the area. We do not want buildings taller than 30 feet that will obstruct the view and
ambiance of the area.
We do not need the added traffic of up to 250 people arriving and leaving around the same time of an
event. Our road is enjoyed by all the residents for outdoor activities, especially on the weekends.
Residents of this area ride their horses, ride their ATV’s and mountain bikes on this road during the
weekends along with the walkers and joggers. The increase of cars is putting their lives potentially in
danger since we do not have sidewalks on our road. Not to mention the potential increase in car
accidents due to the road and not knowing all the little curves of the road in the dark. We have had cars
crash in front of our house and 99% of the time we lose power is due to a car accident at the big curve
or the hill on 35th Ave. Not to mention, alcohol will most likely be served at these events.
We moved out here for the quiet atmosphere and the darkness of night with the ability to see the stars.
Both of those are in jeopardy if this venue is built on our road. It is likely to have several lights at the
venue and their parking lot. It is also likely to have loud music as most celebrations do. Sound travels
through the valley out here much further than in the city where buildings and the concrete jungle and
stop the sound.
Another concern is the use of a septic tank and well for this size of venue. In a previous response,
Carmen has stated that an owner of an adjoining property has agreed to share a well. The use of a
shared well for 4 or more events of 250 people a week will drain that well. It potentially will effect the
water table in the surrounding areas for their wells also.
This is a commercial size venue that doesn’t belong in a residential neighborhood. Not to mention there
are several other wedding venues around the area. There is one on the other side of carver mountain
which is better situated because other houses are not in the immediate area. Also, Corona Ranch, venue
at the Grove, and the Secret Garden are all venues that host weddings. Therefore, the need for another
wedding venue is non-existent.
Respectfully,
Nicole and Thomas Glasgow
3717 West Carver Rd
Laveen, AZ 85339
I grew up in Laveen. Went to school here, my parents built their house here to have a better life
for their family. I was able to buy my home in the shadow of Carver Mountain. This was such a
unique area, but in a rush for what some call progress, we are in danger of losing that.
Where fields and horses were, we now have freeways and bill boards. Approval of this venue
on the Mountain will be allowing a commercial enterprise at the expense of the families who
have built their homes and lifestyles on what is quickly becoming a rare dream - dark skies,
quiet country type living, and peace and quiet.
Our roads are not adequate for commercial type traffic. If the plan is to widen the road then is
the plan to take others property to do so, or is it to rip out more of the mountain. I find either
option incredibly selfish.
Once zoning is approved for this wedding venue, it will leave an open door. Should the owners
decide to move on to the next attractive, unique spot - then any other type of business can
come in.
I am 100% opposed to approval of this venue. There are other places this would be appropriate
and successful. It is wrong for those of us living here to have this forced upon us.
Thank you for your consideration.
Juan J.M. Romero
4315 W. Calle Poco
Laveen, Az 85339
romeroracing@msn.com
602- 481-0401
22 September 2021
Planning & Zoning Commission hearing date: SEPTEMBER 23, 2021
Agenda item and case number: ITEM #3 CASE# Z2019134
To whom this may concern:
I’ve been made aware of the Wedding Venue plan anticipated for our area. I am in opposition to
this plan and have outlined my reasoning for this below.
Page 13, Item #2, last two sentences: “The applicant proposes to add dense landscaping
behind these feces as screening. Other than the grass lawn, the landscaping of the site will
entail lush landscaping to create a desert oasis theme.”
o I assume “feces” was meant to be fences. I’m sure this is an oversight – and will
ignore all other errors.
o Lush Landscaping: We live in a desert. We live in a place where water is a
precious commodity. Arizona is well-known to be in & out of drought periods
constantly. Arizona, to my knowledge, has a questionable assurance on the “100-
year water supply”. Unless the venue plans on growing fruits, vegetables and
beneficial native trees, I don’t understand the need for lush landscape. Perhaps
terms defined would be helpful here? Aside from aesthetics, what’s the point of
having a lush landscape and using copious amounts of water for maintenance
when xeriscaping could achieve a pleasing aesthetic effect? Especially since it
isn’t a primary residence? A farm to benefit residents near and far would be much
more ideal. We’re in a desert, not a tropical oasis or paradise-like utopia.
Page 30, Section F. – Circulation System: “Due to the nature of typical guest arrival and
departure patterns, there should be no loss of service along Carver Road.”
o “should be no loss” is what where my issue resides. I strongly recommend several
traffic studies to be completed with an analysis of projected growth projections,
and a 3rd party peer review. “should be” is not an acceptable response as it tells
me either (a) No analysis was completed or (b) an abridged preliminary
observation was done, but nothing is confirmed.
Page 30, Section G – Development Schedule. “Bride and Grooms suites will be
constructed”.
o This has not been identified in the Site Plan on page 45 of the document titled
09232021Plus (2).pdf.
o “suites” – is there an expectation there will be more than one?
o Where is there a comprehensive plan of what the venue will look like within the
next 15 years?
o We realize the ask is to expand the development plan to 20 years taking into
consideration the concessions. A depiction of that plan is advised so local
residents can understand what to expect – even with the use/request/ask of a
Special Use Permit.
Page 31, Section I – Utilities: “Telephone and cable will be provided by Cox
Communications”
o I’m sorry – this is a complete load of crap and makes me very upset. The venue
identifies itself as within bounds of unincorporated Maricopa County, and as such
should be subjected to the identical confines of the existing telephone and cable
availability of the existing residences – like myself, isolated to CenturyLink. Why
should the Wedding Venue be provided a Carte Blanche to high-speed, fiber optic
cable generally offered through Cox Communications, when unincorporated
Maricopa County Neighborhoods, such as Laveen Estates and Laveen Estates
East have not had updates beyond DSL connectivity? The existing residents –
many in the unincorporated areas are using DSL today because no alternative
(sans Satellite) is available. We were under the impression there is a tariff on
upgrading these lines and I’ve brought this issue to Maricopa County’s attention. I
believe the existing residents should experience the benefit of upgraded telephone
and telecommunications before the Wedding Venue. Many of my neighbors have
been here since circa 1975. Why would the Venue be placed as priority over the
existing populous?
Page 43, list of concessions.
o How, exactly, is the community expected to hold the venue accountable to these
“concessions”? How do we hold the establishment accountable?
Are we expected to cotact MCSO each time we suspect a violation
occurred or is occurring?
Are we expected to conduct a head-count for each event?
Define Dust-Control Materials?
Ecological Study: Was an ecological study conducted? I ask because, with the recent
expansion of development we’ve seen an increase in Coyote sightings. While generally
not an issue, I find myself, specifically in the last 18 months, having to “chase away”
coyotes coming close to my home – coyotes in which move to the Carver Mountain
Hill(s). The volume of events since early 2020 have increased more so than the last six
years. Considering the plan is to level an area which is currently sloped and uninhabited
by humans I would expect this issue to increase. Has this been taken into consideration?
Traffic Study update: I propose a continuation on the traffic study. Additional housing
development is underway at the Carver Rd & 35th Avenue Junction, and should also be
taken into consideration. Today, the residents see an increase in traffic congestion
(unrelated to tractors – which was the case ~10 years ago), drivers who are ignorant to
right-of-way rules, and an increase in accidents at the crossroads of 35th Avenue and
Dobbins Road. Seven years ago, I didn’t mind driving that route circa 2014. Today, I
dread driving through that location. The venue will undoubtedly increase the traffic flow
at that intersection. Why is there a commercial establishment going into a residential area
when there is already an issue with traffic?
Flood Control: I would like to see additional studies done for Flood Control
Management. I understand the County has made incredible progress on flood
management though also believe Laveen is not clearly understood and can be taken with
further critical consideration. Vaquero Estates and Dobbins Point Developments were
planned – and on several occasions those basins over-flooded, causing water to backflow,
at least onto Piedmont. You may find some of my neighbors with sandbags from that
period. One next-door to me still does not use their garage due to the flooding from 2014
and remembers the flow of water coming down the street post-monsoon. I do not think
the existing plans including the basins will suffice for the area. A re-design and/or
expansion is recommended.
I apologize in advance if any part of this sounds like a gripe, however it appears the plans which
are presented to the community can benefit from further and deeper vetting. There appears to be
gaps which currently leaves the community rather concerned as to the impact this wedding venue
would provide to the community. Promises are made to a degree, though not much set in stone,
and no tangible community promises and commitment. Hence reason why I am opposed to this
establishment in our community.
Respectfully yours,
Benjamin W. Fisher
4745 West Piedmont Drive
Laveen, AZ 85339-9644
602.617.6143
benjamin_fisher@hotmail.com
Appeal of Planning and Zoning Commission Recommendation
Appeal Form
If the Planning & Zoning Commission recommends approval of a particular case it
will be placed on a consent agenda for the Board of Supervisors hearing. However,
if this appeal form is received within 15 calendar days following Commission
hearing, then the agenda item will be placed on the regular agenda for the Board of
Supervisors hearing.
Name
Brent Bialik
Email Address
rmp5s1@gmail.com
Address
11620 S 44th Ave
City
Laveen
State
AZ
Zip Code
85339
Phone Number
8599072433
Fax Number
Field not completed.
Case Number / Project
Name
Z2019134
Planning & Zoning
Commission Hearing Date
20210823
Reason for the Appeal of
the Subject Case
EVERYONE opposed this case yet you approved it anyway. As
a resident of Laveen, I DEMAND to know why the voice of the
residents do not matter.
Electronic Signature
Agreement
I agree.
Electronic Signature
Brent Bialik
Appeal of Planning and Zoning Commission Recommendation
Appeal Form
If the Planning & Zoning Commission recommends approval of a particular case it
will be placed on a consent agenda for the Board of Supervisors hearing. However,
if this appeal form is received within 15 calendar days following Commission
hearing, then the agenda item will be placed on the regular agenda for the Board of
Supervisors hearing.
Name
Tayler Burchard
Email Address
Taylerbell691@yahoo.com
Address
Field not completed.
City
Field not completed.
State
Field not completed.
Zip Code
Field not completed.
Phone Number
6023705261
Fax Number
Field not completed.
Case Number / Project
Name
Z2019134/Enchanted Garden
Planning & Zoning
Commission Hearing Date
September 23 2031
Reason for the Appeal of
the Subject Case
I oppose this case because of the commercial use in residential
property. Carver road and nearby residents will suffer due to
this property.
Electronic Signature
Agreement
I agree.
Electronic Signature
Tayler Burchard
Appeal of Planning and Zoning Commission Recommendation
Appeal Form
If the Planning & Zoning Commission recommends approval of a particular case it
will be placed on a consent agenda for the Board of Supervisors hearing. However,
if this appeal form is received within 15 calendar days following Commission
hearing, then the agenda item will be placed on the regular agenda for the Board of
Supervisors hearing.
Name
John Bzdel
Email Address
bzdel@earthlink.net
Address
12120 S 39th Ave
City
Laveen
State
AZ
Zip Code
85339
Phone Number
2535496826
Fax Number
Field not completed.
Case Number / Project
Name
Z2019134
Planning & Zoning
Commission Hearing Date
SEPTEMBER 23 2021
Reason for the Appeal of
the Subject Case
Just because a Special Use Permit is ask for doesn't mean that
it should be approved, especially this one. The Applicant was
specifically told to participate in a local Public Hearing to vet
the Project with the local Community and the Laveen Planning
Committee to personally address Community concerns. This
NEVER happened! When the Maricopa Reviewing Staff made
statements in the initial Maricopa County Review like "there are
no other homes within 500 feet", this is absolutely absurd, they
should be looking at the Fact that the residential community will
continue to grow and who will want to build a private residence
adjacent to a non-complying eyesore? No one. This whole
case was assembled with County Bias to approve...another
example of this is the deviation for the Tower height, there is no
just cause for this when no other structure in the surrounding
area deviate. There will be no pavement to mitigate dust and
clearly traffic will be a concern, again especially in the future
when there are houses North of Carver Rd, not as the Staff has
indicated that CURRENTLY there are no homes.
Please follow your County Process and use the local
Community input! It is a requirement of your process and this
was not followed!
Electronic Signature
Agreement
I agree.
Electronic Signature
Field not completed.
Appeal of Planning and Zoning Commission Recommendation
Appeal Form
If the Planning & Zoning Commission recommends approval of a particular case it
will be placed on a consent agenda for the Board of Supervisors hearing. However,
if this appeal form is received within 15 calendar days following Commission
hearing, then the agenda item will be placed on the regular agenda for the Board of
Supervisors hearing.
Name
Kathleen Cheatham
Email Address
Lkmb1234@aol.com
Address
11202 S 51 Ave
City
Laveen
State
Az
Zip Code
85339
Phone Number
602-237-4619
Fax Number
Field not completed.
Case Number / Project
Name
Enchanted Garden
Planning & Zoning
Commission Hearing Date
Sept
Reason for the Appeal of
the Subject Case
I personally don’t feel Laveens needs another wedding or party
venue. We are on the outskirts and we don’t think we need
another noise maker, drunken driver speed racing . We have
already seen the effects of houses along the mtns with flooding
everytime we get a biin. Enough is enough
Electronic Signature
Agreement
I agree.
Electronic Signature
Kathleen E Cheatham
Appeal of Planning and Zoning Commission Recommendation
Appeal Form
If the Planning & Zoning Commission recommends approval of a particular case it
will be placed on a consent agenda for the Board of Supervisors hearing. However,
if this appeal form is received within 15 calendar days following Commission
hearing, then the agenda item will be placed on the regular agenda for the Board of
Supervisors hearing.
Name
Daniel B Penton
Email Address
dpenton85339@gmail.com
Address
8216 S 42ND AVE
City
LAVEEN
State
AZ
Zip Code
85339
Phone Number
6023848201
Fax Number
Field not completed.
Case Number / Project
Name
Z2019134 / ENCHANTED GARDEN
Planning & Zoning
Commission Hearing Date
09/23/2021
Reason for the Appeal of
the Subject Case
Applicants representative misrepresented the facts regarding
many of the stipulations that were included in staff report, and
blatantly lied about, and failed to conduct citizen participation
per the requirements outlined in the zoning ordinance and
adopted regulations.
Applicants representative stated that the Laveen Citizens for
Responsible Development and the Laveen Planning
Committee we're acting as agents/representatives of the
surrounding Community , and property owners/residents.
THAT STATEMENT IS PATENTLY FALSE!
Mr Jarvis knowingly used that to subvert the Citizen
Participation Process on order to avoid conducting
Neighborhood meetings with the surrounding residents, who
are opposed to this project. There is no negotiation, because
the residents do not want this in their backyard.
Mr Jarvis also lied about having offered to attend a meeting of
the LCRD, to which the LCRD never responded.
AGAIN, THAT STATEMENT IS PATENTLY FALSE!.
The truth is, I Personally sent an email to Applicant/Owner
Carmen Eggleston on Jan 23 2020 to invite her and her
representative at the time to the Feb 3 2020 Monthly meeting
of the LCRD. The intent and purpose behind this was to have
her present her application and answer questions from the
community and surrounding residents to alleviate any concerns
regarding misinformation and to hopefully get them to work
together.
I never received a response, although an attorney from Earl &
Curley did contact me by phone and said he would attend, and
would have Applicant come with him.
The meeting was noticed out to the community. And on Feb 3
2020, sixty five (65) people took time out of their evening,
rearranged their schedules, and made an effort to show up
watch a presentation for ENCHANTED GARDEN, and listen to
what applicant had to say.
Carmen and her Attorney were a NO-SHOW! I have the email
inviting them, and the minutes from Feb 3 2020.
There are many other statements and promise s in the
application and staff report, which misrepresent the facts of
what actually happened or patently false.
This case should be denied and if they're sincere about
wanting to move this forward they need to refile and actually
conduct and complete a citizen participation plan.
Thank you
Electronic Signature
Agreement
I agree.
Electronic Signature
Daniel B Penton
Appeal of Planning and Zoning Commission Recommendation
Appeal Form
If the Planning & Zoning Commission recommends approval of a particular case it
will be placed on a consent agenda for the Board of Supervisors hearing. However,
if this appeal form is received within 15 calendar days following Commission
hearing, then the agenda item will be placed on the regular agenda for the Board of
Supervisors hearing.
Name
Patrick dunn
Email Address
Theseavers@cox.net
Address
4402 w Calle poco
City
Laveen
State
Az
Zip Code
85339
Phone Number
6022903444
Fax Number
Field not completed.
Case Number / Project
Name
Z2019134 enchanted garden
Planning & Zoning
Commission Hearing Date
Sept 23 2021
Reason for the Appeal of
the Subject Case
Just plain wrong. Look at flooding issues. Safety and traffic. It
does not and will not conform to the existing neighborhoods. It
will be strictly for their financial gain and taxes to the city
Electronic Signature
Agreement
I agree.
Electronic Signature
Pat dunn
Appeal of Planning and Zoning Commission Recommendation
Appeal Form
If the Planning & Zoning Commission recommends approval of a particular case it
will be placed on a consent agenda for the Board of Supervisors hearing. However,
if this appeal form is received within 15 calendar days following Commission
hearing, then the agenda item will be placed on the regular agenda for the Board of
Supervisors hearing.
Name
Ines Hughes
Email Address
ines.hughes@gmail.com
Address
4206 W Carver Rd
City
Laveen
State
AZ
Zip Code
85339
Phone Number
602-451-6212
Fax Number
Field not completed.
Case Number / Project
Name
Z2019134
Planning & Zoning
Commission Hearing Date
9/23/2021
Reason for the Appeal of
the Subject Case
As a direct neighbour of the planned vevue (we live 3 houses
to the East) me and my family will have to live with all the
negative impacts of this project.
I feel that our concerns didn't get accounted for in your vote.
My main concerns among others are increase of traffic on our
old two lane road where me and my children walk our dogs and
ride our bikes, sound and light pollution and the fact that
whoever is looking out of the window in the 44 foot tower can
look directly into our yard. No building in this area is taller than
two stories high. There should be no exception made here.
I was also surprised when the applicant mentioned they would
be getting their water from city water lines because as far as I
know all houses in the area are on wells and have their own
septic. There definitely is no infrastructure in place on the piece
of property in question.
I urge you to please review your decision. Thank you.
Electronic Signature
Agreement
I agree.
Electronic Signature
Ines M. Hughes
Appeal of Planning and Zoning Commission Recommendation
Appeal Form
If the Planning & Zoning Commission recommends approval of a particular case it
will be placed on a consent agenda for the Board of Supervisors hearing. However,
if this appeal form is received within 15 calendar days following Commission
hearing, then the agenda item will be placed on the regular agenda for the Board of
Supervisors hearing.
Name
James Lindsey
Email Address
jimlindseytrucking@gmail.com
Address
4046 W Carver Rd
City
Laveen
State
AZ
Zip Code
85339
Phone Number
602-692-5141
Fax Number
602-237-2950
Case Number / Project
Name
Z2019134 / ENCHANTED GARDEN
Planning & Zoning
Commission Hearing Date
September 23, 2021
Reason for the Appeal of
the Subject Case
There cannot be a wedding venue next door to my house. This
is outrageous!
Electronic Signature
Agreement
I agree.
Electronic Signature
James Lindsey
Appeal of Planning and Zoning Commission Recommendation
Appeal Form
If the Planning & Zoning Commission recommends approval of a particular case it will be
placed on a consent agenda for the Board of Supervisors hearing. However, if this appeal
form is received within 15 calendar days following Commission hearing, then the agenda item
will be placed on the regular agenda for the Board of Supervisors hearing.
Name
Juan Romero
Email Address
romeroracing@msn.com
Address
4315 West Calle Poco
City
Laveen
State
AZ
Zip Code
85339
Phone Number
6022372602
Fax Number
Field not completed.
Case Number / Project Name
Z2019134
Planning & Zoning Commission
Hearing Date
October 20, 2021
Reason for the Appeal of the
Subject Case
The "Enchanted Garden Wedding Venue" should not be built in this
area. The Zoning board ( five of them) explained how they have
occasional backyard weddings in their neighborhoods, and there are
no problems with them. That is like apples and oranges - an
"occasional gathering as opposed to a commercial venue. Also one of
them brought up the issue of music saying when he goes outside in
HIS neighborhood he can hear the music of occasional parties - but
goes inside and can't hear it. Residents in this EXISTING
neighborhood have hobbies, livestock etc that lends to a more
"outside" lifestyle. The problem of intrusion of light in a previously dark
sky area is another minus. PLEASE listen to those of us who have
built our lifestyle around a quiet, rural, family neighborhood.
Appeal of Planning and Zoning Commission Recommendation
Appeal Form
If the Planning & Zoning Commission recommends approval of a particular case it
will be placed on a consent agenda for the Board of Supervisors hearing. However,
if this appeal form is received within 15 calendar days following Commission
hearing, then the agenda item will be placed on the regular agenda for the Board of
Supervisors hearing.
Name
Kathryn Greene
Email Address
Kathryn_Greene@hotmail.com
Address
11833 S. 44th Ave
City
Laveen
State
AZ
Zip Code
85339
Phone Number
6025711354
Fax Number
Field not completed.
Case Number / Project
Name
Z2019134
Planning & Zoning
Commission Hearing Date
September 23, 2021
Reason for the Appeal of
the Subject Case
I do not agree with the decision to change the zoning from R 43
to a zoning that accommodates commercial purposes.
Electronic Signature
Agreement
I agree.
Electronic Signature
Kathryn J. Greene
Appeal of Planning and Zoning Commission Recommendation
Appeal Form
If the Planning & Zoning Commission recommends approval of a particular case it
will be placed on a consent agenda for the Board of Supervisors hearing. However,
if this appeal form is received within 15 calendar days following Commission
hearing, then the agenda item will be placed on the regular agenda for the Board of
Supervisors hearing.
Name
Kenda
Email Address
Seavers
Address
4320 w Calle poco
City
Laveen
State
Az
Zip Code
85339
Phone Number
6232031589
Fax Number
Field not completed.
Case Number / Project
Name
Z2019143 enchanted garden
Planning & Zoning
Commission Hearing Date
Sept 23 2021
Reason for the Appeal of
the Subject Case
Please please don’t just look at the dollar signs and what you
as an outsider perceived to be an enhancement and progress.
Please consider the established community that has been here
for generations. Please consider the 250 party goers driving in
and out multiple times a day. They said they could have many
meetings with one hour intervals in between can you imagine
what that will do to the two-lane road of Carver and the traffic
trying to get in and out of this community please spare one little
rural section of Laveen from this one businesses goals and
financial gains
Electronic Signature
Agreement
I agree.
Electronic Signature
Kenda d seavers
Appeal of Planning and Zoning Commission Recommendation
Appeal Form
If the Planning & Zoning Commission recommends approval of a particular case it
will be placed on a consent agenda for the Board of Supervisors hearing. However,
if this appeal form is received within 15 calendar days following Commission
hearing, then the agenda item will be placed on the regular agenda for the Board of
Supervisors hearing.
Name
Lex Davis
Email Address
Lcorp110@gmail.com
Address
4303 W Calle Poco
City
Laveen
State
Arizona
Zip Code
85339
Phone Number
480 694 9780
Fax Number
Field not completed.
Case Number / Project
Name
Z2019134 / enchanted garden
Planning & Zoning
Commission Hearing Date
September 23, 2021
Reason for the Appeal of
the Subject Case
The proposed commercial development does not belong in a
rural 43 zoning district.
Electronic Signature
Agreement
I agree.
Electronic Signature
Lex Davis
Appeal of Planning and Zoning Commission Recommendation
Appeal Form
If the Planning & Zoning Commission recommends approval of a particular case it
will be placed on a consent agenda for the Board of Supervisors hearing. However,
if this appeal form is received within 15 calendar days following Commission
hearing, then the agenda item will be placed on the regular agenda for the Board of
Supervisors hearing.
Name
Kimberly Lindsey
Email Address
Kimberly85044@gmail.com
Address
4046 W Carver Rd
City
Laveen
State
AZ
Zip Code
85039
Phone Number
480-550-1480
Fax Number
602-237-2950
Case Number / Project
Name
Z2019134 / ENCHANTED GARDEN
Planning & Zoning
Commission Hearing Date
SEPTEMBER 23, 2021
Reason for the Appeal of
the Subject Case
NO ENCHANTED GARDEN WEDDING VENUE NEXT DOOR
TO MY HOUSE!
Electronic Signature
Agreement
I agree.
Electronic Signature
Kimberly Lindsey
Appeal of Planning and Zoning Commission Recommendation
Appeal Form
If the Planning & Zoning Commission recommends approval of a particular case it
will be placed on a consent agenda for the Board of Supervisors hearing. However,
if this appeal form is received within 15 calendar days following Commission
hearing, then the agenda item will be placed on the regular agenda for the Board of
Supervisors hearing.
Name
Daniel B Penton
Email Address
dpenton85339@gmail.com
Address
8216 S 42ND AVE
City
LAVEEN
State
AZ
Zip Code
85339
Phone Number
6023848201
Fax Number
Field not completed.
Case Number / Project
Name
Z2019134 / ENCHANTED GARDEN
Planning & Zoning
Commission Hearing Date
09/23/2021
Reason for the Appeal of
the Subject Case
Applicants representative misrepresented the facts regarding
many of the stipulations that were included in staff report, and
blatantly lied about, and failed to conduct citizen participation
per the requirements outlined in the zoning ordinance and
adopted regulations.
Applicants representative stated that the Laveen Citizens for
Responsible Development and the Laveen Planning
Committee we're acting as agents/representatives of the
surrounding Community , and property owners/residents.
THAT STATEMENT IS PATENTLY FALSE!
Mr Jarvis knowingly used that as away to subvert the Citizen
Participation Process on order to avoid conducting
Neighborhood meetings with the surrounding residents, who
are opposed to this project. There is no negotiation, because
the residents do not want this in there backyard.
Mr Jarvis also lied about having offered to attend a meeting of
the LCRD, to which the LCRD never responded.
AGAIN, THAT STATEMENT IS PATENTLY FALSE!.
The truth is, I Personally sent an email to Applicant/Owner
Carmen Eggleston on Jan 23 2020 to invite her and her
representative at the time to the Feb 3 2020 Monthly meeting
of the LCRD. The intent and purpose behind this was to have
her present her application and answer questions from the
community and surrounding residents to alleviate any concerns
regarding misinformation and to hopefully get them to work
together.
I never received a response, although an attorney from Earl &
Curley did contact me by phone and said he would attend, and
would have Applicant come with him.
The meeting was noticed out to the community. And on Feb 3
2020, sixty five (65) people took time out of their evening,
rearranged their schedules, and made an effort to show up
watch a presentation for ENCHANTED GARDEN, and listen to
what applicant had to say.
Carmen and her Attorney were a NO-SHOW! I have the email
inviting them, and the minutes from Feb 3 2020.
There are many other statements and promise s in the
application and staff report, which misrepresent the facts of
what actually happened or patently false.
This case should be denied and if they're sincere about
wanting to move this forward they need to refile and actually
conduct and complete a citizen participation plan.
Electronic Signature
Agreement
I agree.
Electronic Signature
Daniel B Penton
Appeal of Planning and Zoning Commission Recommendation
Appeal Form
If the Planning & Zoning Commission recommends approval of a particular case it
will be placed on a consent agenda for the Board of Supervisors hearing. However,
if this appeal form is received within 15 calendar days following Commission
hearing, then the agenda item will be placed on the regular agenda for the Board of
Supervisors hearing.
Name
Russell Douglas
Email Address
Russelldouglas11833@gmail.com
Address
11833 S. 44th Ave
City
Laveen
State
AZ
Zip Code
85339
Phone Number
6025717159
Fax Number
Field not completed.
Case Number / Project
Name
Z2019134
Planning & Zoning
Commission Hearing Date
September 23, 2021
Reason for the Appeal of
the Subject Case
I don't agree with changing the zoning
Electronic Signature
Agreement
I agree.
Electronic Signature
Russell Douglas
Appeal of Planning and Zoning Commission Recommendation
Appeal Form
If the Planning & Zoning Commission recommends approval of a particular case it
will be placed on a consent agenda for the Board of Supervisors hearing. However,
if this appeal form is received within 15 calendar days following Commission
hearing, then the agenda item will be placed on the regular agenda for the Board of
Supervisors hearing.
Name
Tiah Bialik
Email Address
Tiah.sonny@gmail.com
Address
11620 S 44th Ave
City
Laveen
State
Arizona
Zip Code
85339
Phone Number
8596204215
Fax Number
Field not completed.
Case Number / Project
Name
Z2019134
Planning & Zoning
Commission Hearing Date
09/23/2021
Reason for the Appeal of
the Subject Case
Zoning and Planning Commission Case Number 20191354
Enchanted Garden
Objections to Special Use Permit
Hearing 9/23/2021
I object to the request for a Special Use Permit to allow the
building and operation of a party venue in my neighborhood.
The proposal is a blatant attempt to misuse the Special Use
Permit process to circumvent the current R-43 Zoning and to
permit a Commercial project in a rural residential
neighborhood. The project is flawed and should be denied.
The proponents of this project are requesting numerous
variances in order to make the project remotely feasible. These
include extending the time frame for the permit from 10 years
to 15 years because it will take five years to complete
construction of the project. There is no explanation for this
great length of time needed but it can be assumed that lack of
money is the main factor. This obviously raises concerns of the
project being started then left undone or being finished, and the
business failing leaving an unusable unsightly mess on the
mountain, a smaller version of the “quarry” on the eastern edge
of Carver Mountain.
This request for a Special Use Permit is not from someone who
lives in the area, already lives on the property and has most of
the infrastructure and buildings, but a project on a raw piece of
land where building and infrastructure has to start from nothing.
There are too many unanswered questions to approve the
project. The person proposing the venue is not even the owner
of the property.
Proponents are also requesting a variance to increase the
amount of the mountain they can bulldoze down. Again, the
property and the Zoning do not support the plan proposed. A
variance to allow more of the mountain hillside to be destroyed
should not be granted. The proposal is suitable for the site and
the current zoning.
Proponents want a variance to construct a 44 foot tall “tower”, a
completely unnecessary eyesore for the neighborhood and not
in conformance with the neighborhood or zoning. Proponents
should find a site that is suitable for their needs, and does not
violate zoning or community standards.
The plan as outlined does not address issues such as
rainwater runoff from the mountain. Those of us who live in the
area know that during particularly heavy rainstorms a very
large amount of water comes off Carver Mountain. There is no
plan for ensuring that the rainwater goes where it is supposed
to and does not flood the neighborhoods.
The plan does not address the specifics of the septic system,
or whether a septic system is even feasible considering the
hundreds of people a day it would need to accommodate.
The plan says the project would take 5 years to complete, will
be done in stages, and requests again a variance to allow for a
Special Use Permit for 15 years instead of the normal 10.
There is no schedule for construction, no estimate of anything
nor any hint of whether the venue would expect to be
operational at any time during the construction and what that
would look like or how it would affect the surrounding
neighborhood.
There is no need for another party venue on Carver Mountain.
There are already several wedding/party venues in the area
and there is no need for a high risk project that serves no
purpose for the neighborhood, is a high risk business venture
and could potentially leave the site damaged and unfinished.
Impact on the Neighborhood
1. The proposed project will permanently alter the character of
the neighborhood, which is a unique rural/residential oasis
nestled between the far western edge of South Mountain and
Carver Mountain. The area is zoned R-43, as is the site for the
proposed party venue, and the area residents enjoy the quiet
and solitude with their horses, goats, children and other
amenities that come with a semi-rural lifestyle.
2. The neighborhood is extremely quiet and tranquil and offers
value to Maricopa County as one of the unique, diverse
neighborhoods that attract people to live in the County. It
stands in stark contrast to the hundreds (or thousands) of other
“cookie cutter” neighborhoods in the County. The
neighborhood, along with Carver Mountain and South Mountain
themselves, deserves to be preserved.
3. The proposed party/wedding venue will bring an inevitable
end to the tranquil neighborhood by imposing a commercial
enterprise on its residents, along with the accompanying noise,
traffic and intrusions into the neighborhood that a party venue
expected to regularly host 250 people will do.
4. The party venue will not benefit any resident of the area, but
the resultant, inevitable noise, traffic, light pollution, etc. will
violate resident’s fundamental right to the enjoyment of the
quiet, peace and tranquility of their property.
The Party Venue Will have Specific and Direct Negative
Impacts on the Neighborhood
1. Increased traffic which will cause backups, traffic jams, and
delays for the residents. The proposed party venue is located
on the only main road in and out of the neighborhood. It is a
single lane in each direction and there are only small
neighborhood streets that intersect in the area near the
proposed venue.
2. The nature of the proposed business is to have multiple
events at scheduled intervals . With 250 + people arriving and
leaving at the same time, and up to six or so times a day. They
will all be coming and leaving at exactly the same time, causing
inevitable delays and traffic backups and increased chance of
accidents. Residents frequently walk, bike ride, and horseback
ride in the area and the increased traffic (possibly of people
under the influence of alcohol) puts residents in danger. The
increased traffic (at times perhaps not known to residents)
could cause delay of people trying to get to work, or even delay
lifesaving first responders racing to save a life. There will also
be additional traffic due to caterers, suppliers, etc.
3.. The increased traffic will cause additional dust and noise will
which also impact the ability of residents to enjoy their property.
4. There will inevitably be overflow parking clogging our
neighborhood streets. The proposal only includes 114 parking
places, with 3 handicapped spots. This is not nearly enough to
accommodate the expected attendance at the parties. This
means that party goers will be parking in the neighborhood and
driving through the neighborhood streets. Weddings and
parties include alcohol, and intoxicated people will be driving
and walking through the neighborhood on a regular basis
endangering residents and their animals in addition to causing
general disruption to the peace of the neighborhood.
5. Noise. It is inevitable that 250 + party goers will create a lot
of noise. Shockingly, the Proponents of this project plan to
“direct the noise to the south” to supposedly prevent the noise
from echoing from the mountain. (As noise travels outward in
all directions it is doubtful this plan would succeed) My house,
as well as my neighbors, is directly south of the proposed site
and it is horrifying that their plan is to direct their noise onto my
property. I have a right to the enjoyment of my property and the
proponents of this party venue hope to take that from me and
my neighbors.
6.. The proposal states that they party venue would be
operational from 8 am to 10 pm weekdays and 8 am to 11 pm
weekends. This means that I and my neighbors can be
subjected to the noise and disruption from the parties all day
every day and until 11:00 at nights on the weekends. The
caveat that the parties will be mostly on Saturdays is not
comforting as Saturday and the rest of the weekend is when I
have the time to enjoy the peace and quiet of my house.
Other concerns:
They talk about the 40 foot tower, bride and groom comes up
separate sides handy cap accusable? EYE Sore!! (No plan)
Parking for handy-cap people/cars or vans (no plan)
Loose gravel walking a challenge
Large Tent, very limited flat surface, Eye Sore for those of us
that own $500,000 and up homes
250 attendee’s requirement/emergency accessible? (no plan)
Water retention from tent and parking lot, trailer for portable
facilities (no plan)
NO means of providing utilities Water for future residence’s
Waste
Trash removal, Trash on streets
Very limited roads to arrive and depart (2) single lane each way
Traffic on our roads, two of which are dead ends!
All of the residents abide by set backs, there is no presidencies
to change them
Music?? Every night Non English? Loud till midnight we are a
working neighborhood and require rest!
Disrupting our neighborhood
I am in OPPOSITION to this proposal!! I have no idea who in
their right mind would think putting a WEDDING VENUE in the
middle of a neighborhood (where there is no city water or
sewer!) is a good idea but it's not. It's a terrible idea. For
everyone involved. It MUST NOT BE ALLOWED.
Electronic Signature
Agreement
I agree.
Electronic Signature
Tiah N Bialik
Appeal of Planning and Zoning Commission Recommendation
Appeal Form
If the Planning & Zoning Commission recommends approval of a particular case it
will be placed on a consent agenda for the Board of Supervisors hearing. However,
if this appeal form is received within 15 calendar days following Commission
hearing, then the agenda item will be placed on the regular agenda for the Board of
Supervisors hearing.
Name
Terresa Ann Tate
Email Address
comfypetsofaz@gmail.com
Address
4543 W Estrella Dr
City
Laveen
State
AZ
Zip Code
85339
Phone Number
602-579-1437
Fax Number
Field not completed.
Case Number / Project
Name
Z20191354 / Enchanted Gardens
Planning & Zoning
Commission Hearing Date
September 23, 2021
Reason for the Appeal of
the Subject Case
It's ridiculous that the committee approved this venue to come
8n Laveen, off Carver & 43rd Ave. We didn't move to this
neighborhood to have a venue off Carver with late night music,
congested traffic off Carver, etc.
We beg you to reverse your decision or a lot of us will be
moving.
Electronic Signature
Agreement
I agree.
Electronic Signature
Terresa A Tate