Supporting Document (64ded1ce...)
Extracted text (via pymupdf)
240441 characters
Item 7
CITY COUNGIl
REPORT
m
w
k
tr*-
•tu
Meeting Date:
General Plan Element:
General Plan Goal:
March 24, 2026
Economic Vitality
Sustain Scottsdale as a tourist destination
ACTION
Adopt Resolution No. 13587 approving the WestWorld Strategic Plan, which focuses on clarity of mission,
operational excellence, and enhanced visibility in a competitive regional and national event market, in
support of the Vision to "Bring the modern West to Scottsdale as its premier event-driven economic engine".
BACKGROUND
WestWorld is a signature public event venue and a vital component of the City's tourism, economic
development, and cultural portfolio. The facility hosts a diverse range of activities, including internationally
recognized equestrian and automotive events, community festivals, and other public gatherings, all of which
contribute to the City's economic vitality and quality of life.
A strategic plan establishes a structured framework for long-term decision-making by defining an
organization's mission, strategic priorities, and implementation actions. It informs policy direction, supports
resource allocation, and guides operational and capital planning. For WestWorld, the Strategic Plan shifts the
focus from near-term operational considerations to long-range sustainability, market competitiveness, and
community benefit. To support long-term planning aligned with City Council goals, the City of Scottsdale,
retained Keen Independent to prepare a comprehensive Strategic Plan for WestWorld to guide future
management and investment decisions.
The WestWorld Strategic Plan identified opportunities to strengthen the venue's role as a premier
destination. The recommended strategic direction emphasizes clarity of mission, operational excellence, and
enhanced market visibility to maintain competitiveness at the regional and national levels.
The WestWorld Strategic Plan identified four strategic priorities to meet the Vision over the next five years,
which include:
1. Compete for the best;
2. Strengthen and unify our organization;
3.
Engage the City and region; and
4.
Plan for the future.
As a cornerstone of Scottsdale's tourism and cultural strategy, WestWorld is positioned to continue
generating economic impact while preserving its equestrian heritage and expanding its function as a flexible,
multi-use public venue.
Blueink Bundle ID: BsxE8P5W2H
City Council Report | WestWorld Strategic Plan
ANALYSIS AND ASSESSMENT
Keen Independent facilitated the creation of the WestWorld Strategic Plan, which includes a comprehensive
assessment of existing conditions, operational challenges, and future opportunities. This strategic planning
process was informed by market analysis, key performance indicators, stakeholder and community feedback,
relevant City planning documents, and benchmarked against similar facilities. Attached is the Executive
Summary, which outlines the key details, and the full report for reference.
OPTIONS & STAFF RECOMMENDATION
Staff recommends the adoption of Resolution No. 13587
RESPONSIBLE DEPARTMENT(S)
Enterprise Operations Department, WestWorld Division
STAFF CONTACT(S)
Will Lofdahl, WestWorld General Manager, (480) 312-6807; wlofdahl(S)ScottsdaleAZ.gov
APPROVED BY
3/10/26 07:37 MST
Judy Doyle, Deputy City Manager
480-312-2691, idovle(S)scottsdaleaz.gov
Greg Caton, City Manager
480-312-7759, gcaton@scottsdaleaz.gov
ATTACHMENTS
1.
Resolution No. 13587
2. WestWorld Strategic Plan - Executive Summary
3. WestWorld Strategic Plan - Full Report
Blueink Bundle ID: BsxE8P5W2H
Date
3/10/26 07:39 MST
Date
Page 2 of 2
I
RESOLUTION NO. 13587
A RESOLUTION OF THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF SCOTTSDALE,
MARICOPA COUNTY, ARIZONA, APPROVING THE WESTWORLD
STRATEGIC PLAN, WHICH FOCUSES ON CLARITY OF MISSION,
OPERATIONAL EXCELLENCE, AND ENHANCED VISIBILITY IN A
COMPETITIVE REGIONAL AND NATIONAL EVENT MARKET, IN
SUPORT OF THE VISION TO “BRING THE MODERN WEST TO
SCOTTSDALE AS ITS PREMIER EVENT-DRIVEN ECONOMIC
ENGINE.”
WHEREAS, The City retained Keen Independents prepare a comprehensive Strategic Plan
for WestWorld to guide future management and investment decisions; and
WHEREAS, The WestWorld Strategic Plan identified opportunities to strengthen the venue’s
role as a premier destination by shifting the focus from near-term operational considerations to
long-range sustainability, market competitiveness, and community benefit;
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the Council of the City of Scottsdale, Maricopa
County, Arizona, as follows:
Section 1. That the Council authorizes adoption of Resolution No. 13587 approving the
WestWorld Strategic Plan, which focuses on clarity of mission, operational excellence, and
enhanced visibility in a competitive regional and national event market, in support of the Vision to
“Bring the modern West to Scottsdale as its premier event-driven economic engine.”
PASSED AND ADOPTED by the Council of the City of Scottsdale, Maricopa County,
Arizona this____day of__________________ , 2026.
ATTEST:
Ben Lane, City Clerk
APPROVED AS TO FORM:
CITY OF SCOTTSDALE, an Arizona
municipal corporation
Lisa Borowsky, Mayor
Luis E. Santaella,''lnterim City Attorney
By: William Hylen, Deputy City Attorney
18975809
Page 1 of 1
ATTACHMENT 1
S'
■ li
:
>»•i
SFt
iTt,' >• -
a-
y;
r ■^’v 1
’%
T,
WESTWORLD OF SCOnSDALE 2026 -
STRATEGIC PLAN
Executive Summary
issiil
i
O \
PT-V-
/'z
i
i.f^
2031
f
. !l
„®iL.J|
4^
>/
m
V
iSr¥^
r
'in
I
i'-
WESTWORLD
OF SCOTTSDALE
v^'qjY of
#SCOnSDALE
ATTACHMENT 2
OUR VISION
In support of the City of
Scottsdale’s vision,
WestWorld will:
Bring the modern
West to Scottsdale
as its premier
event-driven
economic engine
- .T-
\
/
b
\
rc
5"lki<C
c/ W...,.
“1.
i i
-.«a
m
t
w
» r, ', ■'Mi
I
<
/XI
m:
« U;"!-.'' *41,-J /
OUR VALUES
At WestWorld, we hold our staff, contractors and
volunteers to a high standard. We are:
ACCOUNTABLE
^
Exhibit ownership, understanding, honesty and follow-through.
^ FLEXIBLE
\\ Highlight adaptability in a rapidly changing event world.
^ COLLABORATIVE
Ensure a producer friendly environment with strong internal and
external partnerships.
^ SERVICE ORIENTED
Demonstrate respect and thoughtfulness in all interactions with a
strong commitment to success.
STEWARDS
\ 1-^ ' V,'" Manage all forms of risk to guests, clients and City assets.
fi lyX 'A '* '■ ^ ^
^
■ i 7
m
1^.: -V
T -1: ^
V' t ' X- - •
a..
r
t
f ‘
1
1
I
. a
a- *U;
\ :<
%-iti
m
^7'y;
*-'■' .: ' - ^i-'^'^'t X‘ - '
:r.‘l..
Lv5'
^ -^if III!! ij||! 1
:■S^
.11!
ytflMF
*
'l l
OUR STRATEGIC PRIORITIES
2026-2031
As we work toward our vision and
fulfill our mission and values, our
strategic priorities will be:
■ Compete for the best
■ Strengthen and unify
our organization
■ Engage City and region
■ Plan for the future
.1^
f6
;
, I ■
J'l
m
•J&
; ^ Ji -
:T|I
ii{?3mi
■<km:
■5^'
m.:i
mm
<
r
r
f
P?r-
l^iv.
;S
A.
Mt- Q-
r
\T
<0
I 4^.
I//'-
•'• v-
• j i t
k
■»»a
Ifl
f
^ / /
';iki'
'N>,
!l V
'4:
. /
OUR PLAN
The following pages sunnmarize the
key objectives related to each
strategic priority that we will tackle
over the next five years. Our
implementation plan will guide us
through this work. It details
corresponding tactics for each
objective, assigns responsibility, sets
timelines and defines metrics and
other indicators that will help us
know if we have been successful.
Strategic Priority 1:
Compete for the best
OBJECTIVES:
■ Establish event profile criteria.
■ Identify and pursue the best type of
programming for WestWorld.
■ Enhance the producer experience.
■ Use facilities more efficiently and strategically.
■ Address immediate maintenance and
equipment upgrade needs.
Strategic Priority 2:
Strengthen and unify our organization
OBJECTIVES:
■ Improve consistency across all
business processes.
■ Improve communication throughout
the customer journey.
■ Build a consistent, effective training
experience for all staff.
■ Strengthen staff cohesion.
■ Instill venue management culture.
■ Evaluate and optimize staffing.
■ Strengthen internal partnerships
within the City.
strategic Priority 3:
Engage the City and region
OBJECTIVES:
■ Tell the story of WestWorld.
■ Be neighborly.
■ Improve visibility and wayfinding.
■ Engage internally with City stakeholders.
strategic Priority 4:
Plan for the future
OBJECTIVES:
■ Strengthen long-term asset and
capital planning
■ Strengthen long-term business planning
■ Strengthen risk management and
emergency preparedness
'
!■
•*
, V
•I.
I
fl- 3.’;k
t r % _
.• ■•
. fr;
-y'b'*
/i-
i
I '''
-'. V
tL
.a
»>-
1'
V .
,ll'.
- .
V,'l
:.m
'im'i -«ii>
f'“
II
V|
.a.— -.■• • , ■■
,';W
'
Ly%
, iv:' -iJ
%
m
11
X
Si
t
>
:3 l«*
-f.l
‘»!
ifn
||^
WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE 2026
2031
I
■f X.. V
s\
1‘i'P
STRATEGIC PLAN
*5^
,m.i I ,1
K-
'V* ...ivL.iitii
jsRBa
-TK^
' M KE
itfiny:
I
5"-';:
WESTWORLD
OF SCOTTSDALE
^ CITY OF
#SCOnSDALE
ATTACHMENT 3
-1
Table of
Contents
■d
I
CJ
V- V w
m~MM
-%■
-i
Se.
-*.f.
H
►>
5
.7!
■%
•iC'
i?5
:!
1^
r.'
K.
Vfm^
I
SECTION 1. INTRODUCTION
SECTION 2. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Our Vision............................................................................................................ 2-1
Our Mission..........................................................................................................2-2
Our Values............................................................................................................2-3
Strategic Priorities, 2026-2031.......................................................................... 2-4
Priority 1; Compete for the best......................................................................... 2-6
Priority 2: Strengthen and unify our organization.........................................2-7
Priority 3: Engage City and region.................................................................... 2-8
Priority 4: Plan for the future.............................................................................2-9
SECTION 3. KEY ISSUES SUMMARY
SECTION 4. IMPLEMENTATION PLAN
SECTION 5. APPENDICES
Summary of Appendices...................................................................................5-1
Appendix A: Market Analysis.............................................................................A-1
Appendix B: Summary of Key Performance Indicators..................................B-1
Appendix C: Summary of Relevant Plans....................................................... C-1
Appendix D; Community Feedback................................................................ D-1
Appendix E: User and Key Stakeholder Feedback......................................... E-1
Appendix F: Benchmark Research.................................................................... F-1
Appendix G: Implementation Tracking.......................................................... G-1
Cover photo credits: WestWorld of Scottsdale
I.
msw
iZS:.
■ ^ifiigmr
K - ■ ■ ■■ r r'^V i'l^
; •
SECTION 1
Introduction
r
^1
5!?S®
-4i
-'yHiitei.-i^
m
mm
-3 J
SECTION 1. Introduction
The City of Scottsdale engaged Keen Independent Research LLCto
guide a strategic planning process for its multipurpose event venue,
WestWorld of Scottsdale (WestWorld).
Approach and Outcome
WestWorld worked with Keen Independent between January 2025 and
March 2026 to develop WestWorld's strategic plan. City leadership
reviewed and provided input on initial findings and draft deliverables.
WestWorld staff and longstanding event producers participated in a
full-day visioning session to workshop concepts for a revised mission, as
well as a new vision and to define values and strategic priorities. In a
subsequent action planning workshop, staff continued an iterative
revision process to WestWorld's mission, vision and values and began
developing strategic priorities and objectives.
The resulting strategic plan establishes an exciting new vision and
mission; sets strategic priorities; defines measurable goals and tactics;
and presents an implementation plan that will guide the work of the
venue from 2026 to 2031.
Dear WestWorld Stakeholders,
On behalf of the WestWorld of Scottsdale team, I am pleased to present
the WestWorld of Scottsdale Strategic Plan. This plan represents an
important milestone for our organization and provides a clear,
forward-looking framework to guide WestWorld's continued evolution
as one of the City of Scottsdale's premier "windows to the world."
WestWorld of Scottsdale is a nearly 400-acre, city-owned event campus
that hosts approximately 80 equestrian and non-equestrian events each
year. From globally recognized signature events such as the Barrett-
Jackson Auto Auction, the Scottsdale Arabian Horse Show, and the
Arizona Sun Circuit, to a wide range of community and specialty events.
5
WestWorld plays a vital role in advancing Scottsdale's reputation,
economic vitality, and quality of life.
The purpose of this Strategic Plan is to define WestWorld's long-term
vision, establish clear and measurable goals, and create a practical
roadmap with actionable steps to achieve them. The plan is designed to
ensure that resources are aligned, efforts are focused, risks are
identified and mitigated, and progress can be evaluated over time. Most
importantly, it connects WestWorld's mission and vision to daily
operations, enabling sustained success while positioning the facility to
adapt to changing market conditions and community needs.
This effort would not have been possible without the generous support
of the City of Scottsdale's Tourism Development Commission, whose
funding made this strategic planning initiative possible. We are also
grateful to the Mayor and City Council for their continued leadership and
support of WestWorld and its role within the broader tourism and
: economic development ecosystem of Scottsdale.
I would also like to extend my sincere appreciation to the WestWorld
staff event partners, community stakeholders, and city departments
who contributed their time, insight, and expertise throughout this
process. Their thoughtful input and collaboration were instrumental in
shaping a plan that is both aspirational and grounded in operational
reality.
As we move forward, this Strategic Plan will serve as a guiding
document to help ensure WestWorld remains a premier event
destination, a strong community asset, and a driver of economic impact
for the City of Scottsdale for years to come.
1
Respectfully,
Will Lofdahl
General Manager, WestWorld of Scottsdale
■
i
'•SXSSm
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
SECTION 1, PAGE 1
SECTION 1. Introduction
Methodology
Keen Independent used the following methods in the planning process.
Community engagement. Keen Independent conducted extensive
virtual and in-person stakeholder engagement. Over 600 external
stakeholders, including Scottsdale residents and WestWorld event
attendees, shared their perspectives as part of this process through
the following channels:
■
Community input survey, including intercept surveys at
WestWorld events; and
■
Study hotline and email feedback.
Internal stakeholder engagement. Keen Independent gathered input
from WestWorld staff. City leaders, event producers and vendors
through the following methods;
■
In-depth interviews and focus groups;
■
Virtual input questionnaire for City staff;
■
In-person full-day visioning session with WestWorld staff and
event producers;
■
In-person full-day action planning workshop with
WestWorld staff; and
■
Draft plan presentation to City Council in a work session.
Additional research. Keen Independent also:
■
Analyzed WestWorld budgets, attendance and other data;
■
Conducted market research including demographic analysis
and population growth forecasting; and
■
Benchmarked similar venues in the region and nationally.
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
--■V■mmm
3.,
fv:^
Intercept surveys at Barrett-Jackson Car Auction
Source: Keen Independent Research
a*?
f
1/1
t
A
IS
th.
rnkm
■»/
Sm. !■
'flSr ' Visitor engagement at Arabian Horse Show
Source; Keen Independent Research
SECTION 1, PAGE 2
SECTION 1. Introduction
Message from the Study Team
The strategic plan for WestWorld was made possible by City leadership
and staff as weil as WestWorld's stakeholders and community
members, inciuding the diverse residents of Scottsdale and attendees
of WestWorld events.
City leadership. We recognize and thank City ieadership for providing
support and oversight for this planning process.
Scottsdale City Council
■
Lisa Borowsky, Mayor;
■
Adam Kwasman, Vice Mayor;
■
Barry Graham, Councilmember;
■
Jan Dubauskas, Councilmember;
■
Kathy Littlefield, Councilmember;
■
Maryann McAllen, Councilmember; and
■
Solange Whitehead, Councilmember.
Scottsdale City Leadership
■
Greg Caton, City Manager; and
■
Judy Doyle, Deputy City Manager.
WestWorld Leadership
■ Will Lofdahl, WestWorld General Manager
WestWorld staff. WestWorld staff participated in multiple working
sessions, including full-day strategic planning workshops, and helped
shape this document.
Event producers. WestWorld event producers provided input through
in-depth interviews and participation in a visioning session, which
helped shape this document.
Community members and stakeholders. This project would not have
been possible without the active participation of Scottsdale's
community members and stakeholders who took time to lend their
voices and ideas in interviews, focus groups and surveys.
Study team. Keen Independent Research, www.keenindependent.com,
conducted the study. Team members included:
■
Alex Keen, Managing Principal; and
■
Jennifer Tuchband, General Manager and Senior Consultant.
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
SECTION 1, PAGE 3
'-V'---------- *
■ ■ 'S^'
^esi
X
■1%.
S-
a '^-
•.'y
m
~ —
X-
*>
f
'.^-
Vv2
HP
^'>«-¥l^v'C!;.‘^;.
•rv... .
.:'
t'-'
1
1-^r..
'
- T^; W
i'
:s»-TCr
i.-W
*«•»»
»•
,.:-=aif
✓
/
■ %*;.4^. .;« ^
Ajeuiuins aA^noax]
I N0I133S
gr.^ 'V
gSyVj—'* "■
__Ini'-
15*
s
, I*.*
>*'■•
- '^ . ■’ ;^x- flf?'V :- .7' :f A
i-'S’
^
OUR VISION
I n su pport of the City of
Scottsdale’s vision,
WestWorld will:
Bring the modern
West to Scottsdale
as its premier
event-driven
economic engine
&
M
I'
\
!
1^.
Vi
• *'
\
I.
f 4^. ..m
1
f)..'■*;
to
an^v
-<--' c! —
w^M&
...
OUR MISSION
In support of the City of
Scottsdale’s nnission,
WestWorld will:
Deliver success
to Scottsdale
with our diverse,
high-impact
equestrian and
special event
programming
'I
fftsiSJWS^•-.■
’., ;
'fiiL
wfw^-'
I
I
'm
OUR VALUES
7J.
m£m
6*'i
Ffm inrj L-V.V* .—,
ii>
1^
?
f
Pf
j, Z
imm
0M
¥
%
i
vvXl
'* ^ ^
•fj
iilr^
%
mm
At WestWorld, we hold our staff, contractors
and volunteers to a high standard. We are:
ACCOUNTABLE
Exhibit ownership, understanding, honesty and
follow-through.
FLEXIBLE
Highlight adaptability in a rapidly changing
event world.
COLLABORATIVE
Ensure a producer friendly environnnent with
strong internal and external partnerships.
SERVICE ORIENTED
Dennonstrate respect and thoughtfulness in all
interactions with a strong comnnitment to success.
STEWARDS
Manage all fornns of risk to guests, clients and
City assets.
_
'
llllll»'’“....
i''.
1^
\. . ' «
»
^1 #'■'?>,'■ ..X
■i^5
OUR STRATEGIC PRIORITIES
2026-2031
As we work toward our vision and
fulfill our mission and values, our
strategic priorities will be;
■ Compete for the best
■ Strengthen and unify
our organization
■ Engage City and region
■ Plan for the future
mm-
’m^
iJmm
I ^
■I'
" '*;■ ii
1.^?#
f»7
L*K
\T^
^•r
m m
f vX^
\
'i?i. i
//
M'
AT-
OUR PLAN
The following pages summarize the
key objectives related to each
strategic priority that we will tackle
over the next five years. Our
implementation plan will guide us
through this work. It details
corresponding tactics for each
objective, assigns responsibility, sets
timelines and defines metrics and
other indicators that will help us
<now if we have been successful.
Strategic Priority 1:
Compete for the best
OBJECTIVES:
■ Establish event profile criteria.
■ Identify and pursue the best type of
progranaming for WestWorld.
■ Enhance the producer experience.
■ Use facilities more efficiently and strategically.
■ Address immediate maintenance and
equipment upgrade needs.
Strategic Priority 2:
Strengthen and unify our organization
OBJECTIVES:
■ Improve consistency across all
business processes.
■ Improve communication throughout
the customer journey.
■ Build a consistent, effective training
experience for all staff.
■ Strengthen staff cohesion.
■ Instill venue management culture.
■ Evaluate and optimize staffing.
■ Strengthen internal partnerships
within the City.
strategic Priority 3:
Engage the City and region
OBJECTIVES:
■ Tell the story of WestWorld.
■ Be neighborly.
■ Improve visibility and wayfinding.
■ Engage internally with City stakeholders.
Strategic Priority 4:
Plan for the future
OBJECTIVES:
■ Strengthen long-term asset and
capital planning
■ Strengthen long-term business planning
■ Strengthen risk management and
emergency preparedness
/ %
r*.
t
\
X*-*
-1
4
/'
4'
/■'
7
/
/*T
#
i<-
■// ■ '
iL
SECTION 3
Key Issues Summary
i\cy idduco ouliiiiiai y
^ .
• v4 v«
4" ■''•■
'. 7. :
■N^
f
'
^
^
r
SECTION 3. Key Issues Summary — Introduction
To identify key issues for WestWorld's strategic planning process, the
planning team analyzed:
■
Market conditions, including population demographics and
forecasts, geographic reach and potential competitors and
collaborators (see Appendix A);
■
Organizational background information, including key
performance indicators (see Appendix B);
■
Relevant Scottsdale City plans with potential overlap with this
strategic plan (see Appendix C);
Community feedback and perspectives gathered through a
community survey, intercept surveys and online reviews
(see Appendix D);
■
Stakeholder perspectives gathered through interviews, group
discussions and a City-wide survey (see Appendix E); and
■
Benchmark case studies (see Appendix F).
Drawing on the project components above, the planning team created a
working summary of strengths, weaknesses, opportunities and threats
(SWOT analysis) and updated it as new findings emerged. Throughout
the planning process, the SWOT analysis served as a summary of key
issues to guide identification of priorities.
The table summarizing primary aspects of the SWOT analysis is provided
on the next page, followed by a synthesis and description of pertinent
information about each key issue.
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
jOWHig;
w' ^
M
■r-M
■r~\
S'*-'
% ■ ■
'
A-irasii
SECTION 3, PAGE 1
3. Key Issues Summary — SWOT Analysis
3-1. WestWorld SWOT analysis summary
Strengths
Strong economic driver for Scottsdale and region
Flexible facilities and amenities
Diverse event offerings
Ample parking
Dedicated staff
Cleanliness and grounds upkeep
Opportunities
Maximizing major multi-day
events that contribute to economic impact
Telling the story of WestWorld and build visibility
Improving guest experience
Strengthening organizational knowledge
and capacity
Building collaboration and trust
Planning and risk management
Weaknesses
Deferred maintenance and upgrades
Unclear identity and branding
Limited marketing visibility
Internal and external communication gaps
Parking operations and wayfinding
Food and beverage restrictions
Inconsistences in contracts and standard
operating procedures
ii
Threats
Staff turnover and potential loss of institutional
knowledge
Restrictions around bidding, contracting, marketing and
other items hindering venue processes
Neighborhood complaints
Inadequate future planning
Safety, security and evolving risk for large events
Source:
Keen Independent Research.
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
SECTION 3, PAGE 2
3. Key Issues Summary — Internal conditions
Internal conditions at WestWorld include staffing, events, services and
physical assets. Often, internal conditions are factors that a venue has
substantial control. This section describes the internal conditions that
the research and planning process identified as WestWorld's
primary strengths.
Strengths
strong economic driver for
Scottsdale and region
Flexible facilities and amenities
Diverse event offerings
Ample parking
Dedicated staff
Cleanliness and grounds upkeep
Strengths
strong economic driver for Scottsdale and region. Community and
stakeholder input consistently emphasized WestWorld's role as a
meaningful contributor to Scottsdale's visitor economy and broader City
prosperity. Participants pointed to the venue's ability to attract
destination events that generate hotel stays, visitor spending and
regional visibility, while also supporting local businesses and tax
revenues. A 2024 study showed that WestWorld generated
approximately $164 million in economic impact for the region that year.
This economic value reinforces the importance of maintaining
WestWorld's operational readiness and reliability as a host for
high-impact events and clearly communicating how major events
transiate into benefits for the City and region.
Flexible facilities and amenities. WestWorld's flexible mix of indoor
and outdoor spaces, equestrian-specific assets and large-format event
capacity represents a core competitive advantage that supports a wide
range of event types and operating models. Community members and
stakeholders consistently pointed to WestWorld's uniqueness in the
region, inciuding its ability to host large signature events as well as
smaller, specialized programs, creating opportunities to optimize the
campus for both economic-impact events and community-facing
programming as priorities and market needs evolve.
Diverse event offerings. Community and stakeholder feedback
highlighted the value of WestWorld's balanced mix of equestrian and
special events, noting that this range helps serve multiple audiences.
Stakeholders emphasized that diverse programming supports resilience
against market shifts and creates opportunities to refine the event mix
over time, strengthening alignment with City priorities, economic
impact goals and community benefits while maintaining appeal to both
regional visitors and local residents.
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
SECTION 3, PAGE 3
3. Key Issues Summary — Internal conditions
Ample parking. WestWorld's parking supply is a significant operational
asset, enabling large-attendance events and supporting flexible site use
during peak periods. At the same time, feedback indicates that parking
is not only a capacity issue but also an experience issue, making this
strength most valuable when paired with clear wayfinding, traffic flow
planning, staffing and communications that help guests arrive and
depart smoothly.
Dedicated staff. Stakeholders and partners frequently described
WestWorld staff as committed, responsive and invested in event
success, which supports long-standing client relationships and repeat
business. This service-oriented culture is a key strength to build on
through training, clearer processes and internal coordination so that
these efforts are reinforced by consistent standards and tools rather
than relying solely on individual knowledge or workarounds.
Cleanliness and grounds maintenance. Community and stakeholder
feedback consistently cited cleanliness and well-maintained grounds
as important contributors to positive first impressions and overall
event-day experiences at WestWorld. Participants noted that visible
upkeep signals professionalism, care for City assets and respect for
guests and producers. Maintaining this standard is important to
protecting and enhancing WestWorld's reputation.
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
r
f/A
U
a
Outdoor events at WestWorld
Source: WestWorld of Scottsdale
I .n
SECTION 3, PAGE 4
3. Key Issues Summary — Internal conditions
Next, we describe internal conditions that the planning process
identified as weaknesses.
Weaknesses
■
Deferred maintenance
and upgrades
■
Unclear identity and branding
■
Limited marketing visibility
■
Internal and external
communication gaps
■
Parking operations and wayfinding
■
Food and beverage restrictions
■
Inconsistences in contracts and
standard operating procedures
Weaknesses
Deferred maintenance and upgrades. Deferred maintenance and
limited investment in upgrades can reduce efficiency, increase
event-day friction and weaken WestWorld's competitiveness over time.
Stakeholders described needs tied to functionality and experience
(e.g., footing, technology, dust control, drainage, ADA access and other
infrastructure), suggesting that near-term prioritization of "high-impact
fixes" alongside a longer-term capital plan will be important for
protecting existing signature events and attracting new opportunities.
Unclear identity and branding. WestWorld's identity and year-round
value are not always well understood across audiences, which can dilute
its market position and community connection. Community and
stakeholder input suggests that many people primarily associate
WestWorld with a small number of major events (e.g., Barrett-Jackson
and Arabian Horse Show) and may be unaware of the breadth and
quality of programming hosted throughout the year. A clearer, more
consistent identity paired with messaging that highlights the full
calendar, the variety of events and the venue's role for both visitors and
residents could help build stronger awareness and understanding
among community members and stakeholders.
Limited marketing visibility. Stakeholders noted that marketing is
especially important for improving regional participation beyond
signature events, strengthening the venue's brand presence year-round
and helping residents understand what is happening on site, when it is
happening and why it matters to the City.
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
SECTION 3, PAGE 5
3. Key Issues Summary— Internal conditions
Internal and external communication gaps. Communication
challenges can create avoidable inefficiencies and inconsistent
experiences. Stakeholders pointed to issues such as handoffs, timelines,
clarity of responsibilities and event-day coordination. Addressing these
gaps through standardized processes, shared tools and clear points of
contact could improve producer confidence, staff effectiveness and
overall reliability.
Parking operations and wayfinding. Even with ample parking,
operational and wayfinding challenges can negatively shape first
impressions and guest satisfaction, especially at large events.
Community and stakeholder feedback indicates that signage, traffic
flow, entry and exit management and on-site navigation can be
improved. Implementing consistent wayfinding strategies and scalable
parking operations plans could support accessibility and help deliver a
more predictable experience across event types.
Food and beverage restrictions. Constraints related to food and
beverage offerings can limit flexibility for event producers and affect
guest satisfaction. Stakeholders also noted a structural challenge in
which the contracted food and beverage vendor may have difficulty
generating sufficient revenue at smaller events but remain obligated to
provide service, which creates tension among service expectations,
financial feasibility and event needs. Clarifying policies and exploring
adaptable approaches (e.g., scaled service models, pre-set minimums or
alternative options for small events where allowable) could enhance the
overall event experience while supporting sustainable operations for
both WestWorld and its food and beverage vendor.
Inconsistences in contracts and standard operating procedures.
Inconsistent contracts and standard operating procedures can increase
uncertainty for producers, slow internal workflows and make outcomes
dependent on individual staff knowledge. Stakeholders described needs
for streamlined and transparent processes that reduce avoidable steps
and clarify requirements. Strengthening standard operating procedures
and contract consistency could support operational efficiency and
improve risk management.
' Tl.
■iM
Polo Championships
Source: WestWorld of Scottsdale
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OE SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
SECTION 3, PAGE 6
3. Key Issues Summary — Strategic implications
strategic implications translate what we learned from internal and
external conditions into what WestWorld should do next. This section
highlights the most consequential takeaways, including where
WestWorld has clear leverage to improve performance or expand
impact, where risks require mitigation and where choices or tradeoffs
will matter most. Rather than restating findings, these implications
frame opportunities for actionable direction for priorities, objectives
and decisions.
Opportunities
■
Maximizing major multi-day
events that contribute to
economic impact
■
Telling the story of WestWorld and
build visibility
■
Improving guest experience
■
Strengthening organizational
knowledge and capacity
■
Building collaboration and trust
■
Planning and risk management
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
Opportunities
Maximizing major multi-day events that contribute to economic
impact. WestWorld has an opportunity to strengthen its role as an
event-driven economic engine by intentionally prioritizing best-fit,
multi-day events that align with City goals and the venue's operational
capacity. Clarifying event profile criteria, such as anticipated hotel
nights, visitor spending, seasonal fit, campus footprint, community
compatibility and operational complexity, can help focus sales efforts
on the highest-value opportunities and set clear expectations
for producers.
Pairing these priorities with efficient booking and delivery processes
is critical. Clear pricing and fee structures, standardized contracts,
predictable planning timelines and consistent service levels can improve
producer confidence. Aligning near-term facility improvements and
operational readiness with the needs of high-impact events will help
protect existing signature events while strengthening the pipeline for
future, best-fit bookings.
Telling the story of WestWorld and build visibility. Community and
stakeholder feedback suggests that WestWorld's role, value and range
of offerings are not always well understood, particularly outside major
events like Barret-Jackson and the Arabian Horse Show. Clarifying and
consistently communicating WestWorld's identity as both an economic
driver and a community asset can strengthen market positioning and
align expectations among residents, partners and producers.
Improved visibility through coordinated branding, promotion and
public-facing communications can expand regional awareness, improve
attendance for smaller events and reinforce WestWorld's contribution
to City objectives. Over time, a clearer narrative can also reduce
confusion that contributes to neighborhood concerns and build
broader support for WestWorld's programming and investments.
SECTION 3, PAGE 7
3. Key Issues Summary — Strategic implications
Improving guest experience. Targeted improvements to the guest
experience offer a practical opportunity to increase satisfaction and
enhance overall event success. Feedback consistently points to first- and
last-touch moments (e.g. arrival, parking, wayfinding, accessibility and
comfort) as areas where changes can have a significant impact across
event types.
This opportunity includes strengthening traffic and parking operations,
improving wayfinding and signage, ensuring consistent event-day
communications and addressing high-impact facility needs such as
technology readiness and basic infrastructure. A more predictable and
welcoming guest experience also supports producer outcomes and
helps differentiate WestWorld in a competitive regional venue market,
reinforcing its reputation as a reliable host for high-impact events.
Strengthening organizational knowledge and capacity. WestWorld
can reduce vulnerability to turnover and improve consistency by
investing in standardized training, documentation and clear operating
procedures that support a shared venue management culture. This
opportunity is closely tied to producer-friendliness. Clear internal
handoffs between sales and operations, defined roles and
responsibilities and standard planning tools can improve efficiency and
create a more reliable experience for both staff and producers, which
can contribute to building long-term trust.
Building collaboration and trust. WestWorld's success depends on
effective collaboration with many City entities, operating partners and
community stakeholders. Stronger internal alignment across City
partners can improve coordination around staffing, safety and
capital planning.
Externally, proactive and consistent engagement with producers and
neighbors can build trust, reduce conflict and support more predictable
event planning. Collaboration also creates opportunities to align
programming with City priorities related to economic impact,
community benefit and quality of life.
Planning and risk management. Integrating business planning, asset
and capital planning and risk management provides an opportunity to
support safe, predictable and cost-effective event delivery. As
expectations for safety, security and emergency readiness continue to
rise, scalable standards and clear protocols become increasingly
important to maintain trust among producers, guests, residents and
the City.
This opportunity includes clarifying roles and responsibilities,
standardizing planning requirements based on event size and
complexity, strengthening coordination with public safety partners
and improving documentation and training. Proactive risk management
can reduce last-minute costs and uncertainty, protect people and City
assets and enable WestWorld to continue to confidently host
high-profile and complex events.
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
SECTION 3, PAGE 8
3. Key Issues Summary — External conditions
External conditions describe the forces and trends that shape
WestWorld's operating environment but are iargely outside its direct
control. These include market demand, competition, demographic and
tourism dynamics, regulatory and policy context, regional development
patterns and broader economic conditions. While WestWorld cannot
"manage" these factors In the same way It manages Internal operations,
understanding them is essential for anticipating change, identifying
constraints and calibrating where to lean in or adjust strategy.
The planning team describes factors that the planning process identified
as key threats.
Threats
Staff turnover and potential loss of
institutional knowledge
Government restrictions around
the contract process, marketing
and other items hindering
venue processes
Resident complaints
Inadequate planning
Safety, security and evolving risk
for large events
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
Threats
Staff turnover and potential loss of institutional knowledge.
Turnover can disrupt continuity and weaken operational consistency,
particularly In specialized venue functions. Without strong
documentation and cross-training, institutional knowledge may be
difficult to retain or replace.
In addition, WestWorld is currently experiencing a relatively high
turnover rate among operations staff, which has immediate impiications
for event delivery, training demands and workload distribution. A clear
driver described in staff feedback is misalignment between role
expectations and the reality of the job. This mismatch can contribute to
eariy departures and recurring vacancy cycles. Frequent onboarding of
new staff can strain supervisors and reduce consistency in event
execution, particularly during peak event periods. Clarifying and
modernizing job descriptions and titles and providing realistic job
previews during hiring and onboarding are practical steps to better align
expectations and improve retention.
Government restrictions around the contract process, marketing
and other items hindering venue processes. Stakeholders described
several ways that City and regulatory requirements can constrain
WestWorld's flexibility and competitiveness relative to other competing
venues. These constraints are primarily related to ordinances, land-use
rules and administrative requirements that shape what is feasible, how
quickly decisions can be made and how easily producers can plan, price
and promote events.
Specific constraints raised through stakeholder input include signage
ordinance limitations that affect on-site and off-site wayfinding and
visibility, restrictions on collecting sponsorships associated with facilities
located on federal land and restrictions on providing incentives to
attract large, high-impact events.
SECTION 3, PAGE 9
3. Key Issues Summary — External conditions
Resident complaints. Although WestWorld predates much of the
nearby residential development, stakeholders reported recurring
complaints about noise, lights and the venue's aesthetic. Stakeholders
expressed concern that continued community gro\wth could increase
scrutiny and make future development or operational changes more
challenging. Proactive neighbor engagement, clear communications and
practical mitigation measures will be important to maintain community
support and minimize potential constraints on programming.
Inadequate planning. If planning and prioritization are not sufficiently
aligned to venue needs, WestWorld could face a heightened risk of
reactive decision-making that increases costs and slows progress over
time. Stakeholders noted that planning processes can become barriers
when key stakeholders are not consistently engaged, when the most
critical upgrades are not clearly prioritized or when timelines extend
long enough that priorities shift with changes in City leadership. Over
time, these dynamics could delay necessary improvements, reduce
producer confidence and weaken long-term competitiveness.
Safety, security and evolving risk for large events. Expectations for
safety and security continue to rise, with reputational and operational
implications. Failure to proactively anticipate and manage these risks
can undermine trust among producers, guests and the City.
Community and stakeholder feedback suggests that risk is not limited to
rare incidents. It also includes day-to-day readiness for large crowds,
traffic and parking management, heat and weather exposure, emergency
access and clear coordination among venue staff, contractors and public
safety partners. Strengthening scalable safety and security planning can
reduce uncertainty, control costs and reinforce confidence among guests,
residents and event producers.
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
sf.
' ' ■■ ■—---------------------- ------------ .
SECTION 3, PAGE 10
\r.
n--^.
Jy.
MJ
Vi -->1
^ii
I
— V I ^
..... .
n;
•s^
__ ■;
9
.*» !
SECTION 4
Implementation Plan
g^T'
f°ii
V.VI
f
J«»l
r*..
. -v >: I
i J
\1
f..-
4‘;i
L*J
. <.:
/3--' mil
n-r
M
f#*
l!a
SECTION 4. Implementation Plan
The implementation plan matrices in this section offer a roadmap for
action on strategic priorities, including assigned leadership, timelines
and potential metrics or other indicators of success.
Oversight, Monitoring and Evaluation
Implementation of the WestWorld strategic plan will not happen
overnight. As reflected in the following matrices, work has already
begun on some priorities and tactics, but progress toward strategic
priorities will require consistent focus over time. These efforts will
benefit from systematic approaches that operationalize the venue's
action plan as a part of its regular activities such as standing meeting
agendas, performance management and communication updates.
Maintaining the implementation plan overtime.
The implementation plan reflects the best forecasts of WestWorld staff
based on information available at the time of this report in early 2026.
In any such multi-year plan, changes arising from new information and
evolving circumstances should be expected. To keep the plan relevant,
WestWorld should:
■
Treat the plan as a living, working document, adapting it to
new information or circumstances when needed;
■
Use the implementation tools as described in Appendix G
regularly to note progress, status and comments;
■
When timelines, assigned leads, priority levels, metrics or
other details require substantial alterations, edit the team's
working version of the plan accordingly; and
■
Monitor timelines closely and expect some to shift as
conditions evolve.
Assign responsibility for each tactic outlined in the strategic plan
to an identified champion.
■
Outline the expectations for each champion to "take point" on
monitoring and reporting progress; convening and organizing
actions; and identifying and resolving or elevating roadblocks.
■
Embed strategic plan progress reviews and reporting into
regular meeting agendas, including leadership, all-staff and
one-on-one check-ins with staff.
■
Integrate strategic plan implementation efforts into internal
and external communications to sustain interest and
momentum by sharing stories about "quick wins" and
progress towards longer-term aspirations.
■
Use and refine measurable goals for key indicators tied to
strategic priorities and share these internally and externally in
a digestible format (see the sample dashboard in Appendix G).
■
The implementation matrices in this section suggest
preliminary metrics and indicators for each tactic. Once data
collection and reporting on measurable indicators are in place,
consider distinguishing between baseline goals and
aspirational targets or "stretch goals."
■
Establish and implement a regular cadence of
comprehensive strategic plan progress reports for internal
and external stakeholders.
■
Conduct a mid-point review to update objectives, tactics and
timelines as necessary.
■
Begin strategic planning for 2031-2035 by December 2029.
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
SECTION 4, PAGE 1
SECTION 4. Implementation Plan — Priority 1. Compete for the best
PRIORITY ONE (1 of 2)
1. Compete for the best
1-1, Establish event profile criteria
Lead
role
Key
collaborators
Start by Due by Example metrics/
M-Yr M-Yr success indicators
a. Define clear, measurable criteria for evaluating and
prioritizing events based on the City's priorities
City Council, City
A City leadership-approved priority list for ail events booked at
General Manager Manager, Deputy City Mar-26 Oct-26 WestWorld (e.g.. Priority 1: Economic impact. Priority 2: Potential for
Manager, Sales
cost recovery. Priority 3: Community Enrichment.)
b. Develop a tiered booking schedule with priority
windows that reflect the agreed-upon event profile
General Manager
Sales
Oct-26 Mar-27 Compare new events booked to criteria outlined in 1-la
c.
Review all existing events to assess alignment with the
new criteria and identify potential adjustments’*
Sales, City Manager's
General Manager Office, Deputy City Mar-27
Manager
Jun-27
All events on schedule reviewed and categorized by priority level.
Recommended adjustments for future bookings documented.
1-2. Identify and pursue the best type of programming
for WestWorld
a. Target client acquisition based on WestWorld’s
strengths and assets*
Sales
Tourism Development
Commission, M Culinary
. .....
List of prospective priority producers/clients created, 10 outreach efforts
to prospective priority producers per year, with the objective of securing
2 new events per year. Given the finite amount of availability, we will
prioritize events with the highest value utilizing the new objectives.
Jul-27 Jun-28 Lower tiered priority events will be moved to less desirable dates and
less utilized rental space or will not be renewed for the followingyear.
Each year, the bottom 10% of events based on booking priority will be
replace within 24 months assuming that more attractive events can be
secured.
Assess and reorganize the event calendar as needed to
b. free up dates, improve sequencing and accommodate
high-priority new events*
Sales
WestWorld Leadership,
Senior Director
Jul-27 Jun-28
Adherence to the modified booking priorities outlined in 1-la will be the
metric used to access success of this deliverable
Establish a vetting process to evaluate prospective
c. producers based on experience, quality, financial
stability and alignment with WestWorld’s priorities
Sales
WestWorld Leadership Jul-27 Jun-28
Vetting checklist created and applied to 100% of new producer Inquiries
Note:
Implementation plan details, including start by and end by dates, are subject to change.
•Dependent on a new resource (e.g. budget, technology, etc.)
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
SECTION 4, PAGE 2
SECTION 4. Implementation Plan — Priority 1. Compete for the best
PRIORITY ONE (2 of 2)
m'
m
Lead
role
Key
collaborators
Start by Due by Example metrics/
M-Yr M-Yr success indicators
success indicators
1-3. Enhance the producer experienc
"■
streamline event contracts to improve clarity,
a. efficiency and turnaround time
Contract
Coordinator
Administration,
Legal, Purchasing
Updated contract templates launched. Average contract delivery in a
Jul-26 Jun-27 reasonable amount of time, within five days of receiving all
pertinent information
b. Strengthen client relations through consistent
communication and responsive support
Director
Westworld Leadership,
Facility Managers
Mar-26 Mar-27 All client satisfaction ratings at a 4 or higher on a 5-point scale
Reevaluate the food and beverage commission model
c. to ensure it supports caterer viability and provides fair,
high-quality options for producers
1-4. Use facilities more efficiently and strategically t
Assistant
WestWorld Leadership,
All satisfaction ratings regarding F&B cost and quality at a 4 or higher on
MsF’So M3r"27
General Manager
M Culinary
aS-pointscale
a. Cluster similar events to improve changeover efficiency
Sales
Facilities Managers Mar-28 Jun-31 Reduce overtime during changeovers by 5%
1-5. Address immediate maintenance and equipment
upgrade needs
Complete priority maintenance and implement
necessary upgrades*
Facilities Manager Maintenance Workers Jan-29 Dec-29
The length of time that it takes to complete each project Is within
estimates determined during the planning process
b. Upgrade the PA system to improve sound quality and
reliability for events*
Facilities Manager Maintenance Workers Dec-25 Feb-26 PA system installed by target date
Note:
Implementation plan details, including start by and end by dates, are subject to change.
‘Dependent on a new resource (e.g, budget, technology, etc.)
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
SECTION 4, PAGE 3
SECTION 4. Implementation Plan — Priority 2. Strengthen and unify our organization
PRIORITY TWO (1 of 3)
Lead
role
Key
collaborators
Start by Due by Example metrics/
M-Vr M-Yr success Indicators
2. strengthen and unify our organization
2-1. Improve consistency and standardization across all
business processes
a. Standardize policies and operational procedures to
ensure consistent practices across the organization
Policy and operational policy needs inventoried and prioritized. Then
General Manager WestWorld Leadership Jul-26 Jun-28 100%otpolicyandoperationatprocedureprioritiescompleted
and adopted
b. Provide training and communication to ensure all staff
follow unified processes and expectations
General Manager WestWorld Leadership Jul-27 Jun-29
100% of staff trained on unified processes. All staff compliant
with processes
^ Improve the RV reservation system to enhance usability rv Office Lead Facility Mangers,
and client experience*
ITStaff
2-2. Improve communication throughout the customer
journey, from sales to service delivery and follow up
■Esesa
ajuinfuiMiii. 1,1,iiiiwuio iuui„.»rr:>asasgm
Strengthen communication workflows to ensure timely,
a. accurate information sharing among staff and with
Director
clients
Mi S'.v .
?1>
Facilities Manager, Sales,
Event Staff
Track the number of instances in which RV staff were needed to step in
Apr-26 Apr-26 and provide customer assistance when the system was not successful
at competing the reservation process
sir-
Mar-26 Jun-27 Communication protocol adopted
il'
.1*
b. Hold regular production meetings to align teams and
address operational needs in advance
Director
Facilities Managers Mar-26 Jun-31
2-3. Build a conslsteot, effective tralnii^ experleitce ter
all staff
a. Create a structured onboardingand training program
for all operational staff
Facilities Managers WestWorld Leadership Mar-26 Sep-26
Develop a system to determine which events will require pre-event
production meetings and in-turn ensure that the meetings take place
Training program is established and documented. All new hires
complete this training program within 60 days of start date
b. Provide ongoing role-specific training to maintain
consistency and build expertise
General Manager WestWorld Leadership Jul-26 Jun-31
Identify recommended monthly/hourly training hours per employee by
role or type of position. All staff complete required training
Note:
Implementation plan details, including start by and end by dates, are subject to change.
•Dependent on a new resource (e.g. budget, technology, etc.)
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
SECTION 4, PAGE 4
SECTION 4. Implementation Plan — Priority 2. Strengthen and unify our organization
PRIORITY TWO (2 of 3)
2-4. Strengthen staff cohesion
Lead
role
Key
Start by Due by Example metrics/
collaborators M-Yr M-Yr success indicators
a. Increase employee engagement to build a more
connected and collaborative team
General Manager WestWorld Leadership Jul-27 Jun-31
100% of employees participating in engagement activities. Each
employee to participate in three activities each year
b. Leverage staff from other departments during surge
periods to support operations
WestWorld Leadership
Facility Managers
and Other
Mar-26 Mar-27 10% reduction in overtime over base year
City Departments
c. Enhance internal customer service to improve
collaboration and mutual support across teams
General Manager WestWorld Leadership Mar-26 Jul-27 Average employee satisfaction rating of 4 or higher (on a 5 point scale)
2-5. Instill venue management culture
Mr-
Expand professional development opportunities to
build staff expertise in venue management*
At least one employee attains venue management credentials. All staff
General Manager Deputy City Manager Mar-26 Jun-31 attend at least one professional development opportunity annually.
when budget and time altow
b. Clarify and update job titles to align with industry
standards and responsibilities
General Manager Human Resources Mar-26 Jun-27 Updated titles approved and in line with venue industry standards
....... .
when budget and time allow
d. Ensure staff understand how their roles contribute to
WestWorld’s overall mission and operations
General Manager Department Heads Mar-26 Sep-26
Onboarding and training includes how positions fit within the bigger
picture (see objective 2-3 above)
■'
: -i/;
Note:
Implementation plan details, including start by and end by dates, are subject to change.
•Dependent on a new resource (e.g. budget, technology, etc.)
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
SECTION 4, PAGE 5
SECTION 4. Implementation Plan — Priority 2. Strengthen and unify our organization
PRIORITY TWO (3 of 3)
Lead
role
-'5'
Key
collaborators
Start by Due by Example metrics/
A-'. - i --vT.' i'.
irs M-Yr M-Yr
success indicators
mr-''
Assess current staffing levels and roles to identify gaps,
redundancies and future needs
2-7. strengthen internal partnerships within the City
improve coordination with City departments to clarify
a.
Note:
service requirements in advance of each event
General Manager,
Assistant
General Manager
Director
Deputy City Manager,
HR Department
Jul-27 Jun-28
Professional staffing consultant assessment completed
and implemented
Facilities Manager Mar-26 Jun-31
Ensure all events have pre-event coordination communicafi'ons or
meeting with all relevant departments
Implementation plan details, including start by and end by dates, are subject to change.
‘Dependent on a new resource (e.g. budget, technology, etc.)
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
SECTION 4, PAGE 6
SECTION 4. Implementation Plan — Priority 3. Engage the City and region
PRIORITY THREE (lot 2)
3. Engage the City and region
3-1. Tell the story of WestWorld
Lead
role
Key
Start by Due by Example metrics/
collaborators M-Yr M-Yr success indicators
a. Provide quarterly updates to City Council to share
accomplishments and upcoming priorities
General Manager Management Analyst, |u|g^.20
Quarterly updates presented at City Council meetings
Sal6s
Develop and maintain coordinated public
b. communications, including newsletters, email blasts
and event calendars
Monthly newsletter and email blasts sent and open/rates documented.
Sale Team
Management Team Jul-26 Jun-31 Event calendar is updated as events are added to or dropped off the
calendar
c. Improve on-site signage to enhance wayfinding and
increase visibility of current and upcoming events*
Assistant
Director,
General Manager Facilities Manager
Jan-28 Dec-29 Digital signage installed throughout WestWorld
^ Strengthen cross-promotion with City departments and
„ ,
^
Increased number of cross promotions completed with a goal of
d. . ®
Sales
City Communications Mar-26 Jun-31
regional partners to broaden event exposure
two per year
e. Develop a marketing plan
Sales
WestWorld Leadership Mar-26 Mar-27
A marketing plan that outlines market research, target audience,
marketing strategies and performance metrics completed
; 3-2. Be neighborly
a. Notify nearby neighborhoods about events that may
cause inconveniences such as noise or traffic
Assistant
General Manager
Sales
Establish regular communications cadence to improve neighbor
Mar-26 Jun-31 relations (at least once per quarter) and an ad hoc notification process
for higher impact events to reduce complaints
Note:
Implementation plan details, including start by and end by dates, are subject to change.
‘Dependent on a new resource (e.g. budget, technology, etc.)
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
SECTION 4, PAGE 7
SECTION 4. Implementation Plan — Priority 3. Engage the City and region
PRIORITY THREE (2 of 2)
*
Lead
rote
Key
Start by Due by Example metrics/
collaborators M-Yr M-Yr success indicators
^ Improve vlsIbWIy and wayfinding
Evaluate key entry points, pathways and road-facing
a. areas to identify wayfinding needs and opportunities to
increase drive-by visibility*
Assistant
General Manager
Director
Jul-26 Jul-27 Evaluation of wayfinding needs and opportunities documented
b.
Add clear, consistent signage to enhance visibility and
Assistant
Director,
help visitors navigate to the property*
General Manager
Facility Manager
Jul-27 Dec-29 Signage improvements recommended in Tactic 3-3-a are Implemented
3-4. Engage internally with City stakeholders
a. Leverage Scottsdale Insider and other City channels to
share WestWorld updates and opportunities
Sales
Tourism,
City Communications
Jul-26 Jun-27 WestWorld updates and opportunities shared with all City staff monthly
b. Develop a staff shadowing program for WestWorld staff
Assistant
Director,
to build understanding of WestWorld operations
General Manager Facilities Manager
Jul-27 Jun-31 10 shadowing experiences to take place annually
c. Offer WestWorld facilities as meeting space for City
departments when available
Sales
WestWorld Leadership Jul-27 Jun-31 Allow City meetings to be hosted with the goal of 5 per year
Note:
Implementation plan details, including start by and end by dates, are subject to change.
•Dependent on a new resource (e.g. budget, technology, etc.)
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
SECTION 4, PAGE 8
SECTION 4. Implementation Plan — Priority 4. Plan for the future
PRIORITY FOUR (1 of 2)
4. Plan for the future
Lead
role
Key
Start by Due by Example metrics/
collaborators M-Yr M-Yr success indicators
p 4-1. Strengthen long-term asset and capital planning
General Manager
produc^rT*^” Dec-26 Dec-27 Master plan completed and formally adopted
a. Complete an infrastructure master plan*
b. Complete a capital improvement plan*
Assistant General WestWorld Leadership, , _ _
, „ Capital improvement plan completed. Priority projects identified and
JuI“2d Jun*29
Manager
Administration
preliminary estimated budget for priority projects identified
c. Complete an asset management plan*
Assistant General WestWorld Leadership, , _ _
, „ Asset management plan completewith asset inventory and lifecycle
Jul~2G Jun“2/
Manager
Administration
data. Plan is formally adopted
^
L..
Additional infrastructure investments such as conference center, hotel.
Explore other uses and opportunities for WestWorld „
WestWorld Leadership,
^
^
d.
General Manager
Jul-26 Jun-29 etc. are explored with City Leadership and incorporated into the
infrastructure
Administration
. ,
.
.
infrastructure master plan and capital improvement plans
4-2. Strengthen long-term business planning
a. Complete a business continuity plan
V
Director, Contracts
General Manager
Coordinator
Feb-26 Dec-26 Businesscontinuityplan completed and updated annually
a. Complete a staffing and succession plan
General Manager WestWorld Leadership Jul-26 Jun-27 Staffing ahd succession plan completed
b. Evaluate rates and fees structure
Work with Keen
Independent
WestWorld Leadership Jul-25 Apr-26
Rates review completed and proposed adjusted rates and approved by
City leadership
c Refresh the strategic plan*
Senior Management
General Manager team. Contract Jul-30 Jun-31 Strategic plan refresh completed and formally adopted
Coordinator
Note:
Implementation plan details, including start by and end by dates, are subject to change.
•Dependent on a new resource (e.g. budget, technology, etc.)
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
SECTION 4, PAGE 9
SECTION 4. Implementation Plan — Priority 4. Plan for the future
PRIORITY FOUR (2 ot 2)
Lead
role
Key
collaborators
Start by Due by
M-Yr M-Yr
Example metrics/
success Indicators
a. Conduct a comprehensive risk assessment*
General Manager
Risk,
WestWorld Leadership
Jul-26 Jul-27 Risk assessment completed. Mitigation actions prioritized
b. Enhance emergency procedures plan
Assistant
City Police and Fire,
General Manager Managers, Director
Jul-30 Jun-31 Updated emergency procedures documented and revisited annually
c. Provide regular safety and security training for staff
Assistant
Risk,
General Manager WestWorld Leadership
Jul-26 Jun-27 All staff complete annual training
Note:
implementation plan details, including start by and end by dates, are subject to change.
•Dependent on a new resource (e.g. budget, technology, etc.)
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
SECTION 4, PAGE 10
SECTION 4. Implementation Plan — Rollout
Resource Dependences and Opportunities
WestWorld identified many tactics within its strategic plan that
are dependent on additional resources, such as budget. The
implementation matrices for each tactic list resource dependencies.
Addressing these dependencies is crucial to ensuring WestWorld can
make progress toward its priorities. As WestWorld staff activate the
strategic plan, they may wish to consider the following steps:
■
Evaluate resource reallocation. Start by inventorying
existing staff time, contracted services and operating dollars
currently supporting WestWorld's highest-volume activities
(event delivery, maintenance/grounds, sales/booking support,
communications). Identify tasks that:
>
Are mission-critical and time-sensitive;
>
Can be paused or scaled; and
>
Could be shifted to reduce reliance on outside
contractors or duplicative City processes.
Then reallocate capacity toward near-term "quick wins"
that improve client experience and competitiveness while
protecting the operational basics that make events successful.
■
Analyze resource gaps. To address gaps between what
WestWorld aspires to do and what its current resources
allow, WestWorld will need to clearly define what is required
(e.g. additional staff, budget, technology, etc.). Other
resource gaps may need to be assessed in tandem with or
after consideration of broader resource allocation decisions.
w 1:
' N >■''i' j
iv
Equestrian events at WestWorld
Source: WestWorld of Scottsdale
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
SECTION 4, PAGE 11
SECTION 4. Implementation Plan — Rollout
Examine value of events to bottom line and local
economy. As an economic driver, it is crucial that WestWorld
maximize its resource utilization to enhance impact.
WestWorld leadership should consider implementing policies
related to event economic impact and applying booking
advantages to events that generate the greatest level of new
outside spending for Scottsdale and the region.
Pursue opportunities to increase funding from sources
outside the City. Frame external funding not as a request for
discretionary support, but as a justified investment that
reflects WestWorld's demonstrated economic, tourism and
fiscal contributions at the local, regional and state levels.
Emphasize WestWorld's role in generating visitor spending,
tax revenues and statewide visibility and position County and
State participation as ways to sustain and amplify these
benefits. Advocacy efforts should clearly articulate the return
on investment and align WestWorld priorities with broader
County and State goals related to tourism promotion,
economic development and major-event attraction.
4-1. Ratios of the number of economic impact dollars per dollar subsidized at
other public assembly venues compared to WestWorld of Scottsdale
Estimated subsidy Estimated
Study or contributions economic Impact
year (in millions) (in millions) Ratio
Events DC
Washinton DC
Orange County Convention Center
Orlando, FL
Central States Fairgounds
Rapid City, SD
McCormick Place Convention Center
Chicago. IL
Georgia World Congress Center Authority
Altanta, GA
WestWorld of Scottsdale
Scottsdale, AZ
Will Rogers Memorial Center
Fort Worth, TX
Massachusetts Convention Center Authority Boston. MA
Phoenix Convention Center
Phoenix, AZ
Credit Union of Texas Event Center
Allen, TX
2024
2024
2022
2024
2025
2024
2024
2022
2024
2024
$ 121.0
62.8
1.3
53.5 *
48.9
4.2
6.0 •
44.9
48.0
2.0
$ 11,400
3.900
69
2,240
1,940
163
217
870
840
11
$ 94.2
62.1
53.4
41.9
39.6
38.8
36.2
19.4
17.5
5.5
Note:
*Debt service not explicitly Included. Unclear whether loss includes debt service.
Impact data are pulled from a variety of sources, including published impact studies and
statements made by the venue's governing body. Keen Independent cannot guarantee
the accuracy of impact estimates beyond publicly presented data. Subsidy and
contributions are determined by net Income (loss), which include operating and non
operating expenses, as indicated on publicly available financial documents. Accounting
practices can vary by venue, which can affect the ratio illustrated in this table.
Source:
Keen Independent Research.
Plan for upcoming replacement costs. As a large, heavily
used public assembly venue, WestWorld faces predictable
lifecycle replacement needs for infrastructure, building
systems, event-related equipment and technology. When
these costs are not anticipated and planned for, replacements
are more likely to be deferred, funded reactively or compete
with other City priorities. Proactive planning for replacements
can reduce operational disruptions, smooth budget impacts
over time and provide clearer justification for shared
investment and funding advocacy.
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
SECTION 4, PAGE 12
SECTION 4. Implementation Plan — Rollout
Explore alternative governance models. City of Scottsdale
staff who work at WestWorld struggle with the reality that if a
client disagrees with an operational decision, the client can
bypass staff and appeal directly to City elected officials and
leadership to apply pressure. This challenge is not unique to
WestWorld and is seen across the country in municipally
owned and operated venues. It can be challenging for all
involved if it is unclear who ultimately makes decisions for the
success of the venue. Stakeholders emphasized the need for a
more consistent, knowledgeable City decision-making
structure that preserves institutional understanding of the
venue. An updated structure could provide a clear and
informed point of accountability for operational, strategic and
community concerns, while maintaining appropriate public
oversight and transparency.
Some Cities have chosen to appoint boards or commissions to
oversee venue operations. These boards can include
representation from a variety of sources, including individuals
with expertise in venue operations and economic
development. The City of Scottsdale could consider this option
for WestWorld to ensure accountability and to reduce City
leadership intervention in day-to-day operations.
Adjust tactics timeline if resource dependences are
unresolved. If key resource needs are not resolved on the
expected schedule, update "start by/end by" dates
accordingly, clarify interim milestones so momentum
continues and communicate changes transparently in regular
progress reporting so stakeholders understand what is moving
forward now versus later.
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
Ip*
\
Exposition areas at WestWorld
I V-,
Source:'WestWorld.of Scottsdale
Exposition areas at WestWorld
Source;'WestWorld.of Scottsdale
SECTION 4, PAGE 13
m
I
\:
f]
mm
; ilPfOPlPr
iS-asiSW
;
.A.
rfl.
fM
VJ
V /'
fe' :K'^^:::^■
iA
"-n
I
SECTION 5
Appendices
V
'V ' h
■
/ vJUm. '•
^ENDLE’
ijl WHISK
Vi
/
”■ jMiSg
^ ' ",' W'
m
?».
. . ,
_ -^MrT-. ’
1
■- ^.- #*«f- ■
>f-ZAr^
SECTION 5. Appendices
The following supporting appendices document the research and
analyses that inform and support WestWorld's strategic plan.
Market Analysis
Appendix A includes an assessment of WestWorld's market position
within the broader special events and equestrian landscape. It lays
out the market areas used for analysis, reviews population and
demand indicators, inventories comparable venues and benchmarks
rental rates to understand WestWorld's competitive positioning.
Key Performance Indicators (KPIs)
Appendix B compiles baseline KPIs and supporting data for tracking
WestWorld performance overtime. It summarizes multi-year
operating results and explains key economic impact metrics drawn
from a 2024 economic impact study.
Relevant Plans
Appendix C summarizes City of Scottsdale plans and documents that
include or affect initiatives related to WestWorld and events hosted
there. The intent is to show how WestWorld's future direction can
align with the broader City vision and community priorities reflected in
adopted plans (e.g.. General Plan, Tourism & Events Strategic Plan
and the City's Organization Strategic Plan).
Community Feedback
Appendix D provides the quantitative and qualitative findings from
community outreach, including survey promotion and distribution,
participation levels, key themes and supporting visuals. It includes
demographic and interest profiles to contextualize results, helping the
project team understand whose voices are represented and where
perceptions are strongest.
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
User and Key Stakeholder Feedback
Appendix E captures targeted feedback from WestWorld users and
key stakeholders (including City staff, renters, vendors and City
leaders) via interviews and group discussions. The appendix organizes
perspectives across strengths and weaknesses, opportunities for
success, barriers to success and priorities.
Benchmark Research
Appendix F summarizes benchmarking of selected national peer
venues (including Will Rogers Memorial Center, National Western
Center/Complex and OC Fair & Event Center). It documents key
takeaways on operating practices such as event management
software usage, rate structures for space/labor/equipment and
common reliance on subsidies (via major events or government
funding mechanisms).
Implementation Tracking Tool Guide
Appendix G is a practical "how-to" guide for using the implementation
tracking tool. This appendix explains how to update actions, owners,
timelines, status, dependencies and performance measures so
City leadership and WestWorld staff can track progress, flag issues
and report on implementation status over time.
SECTION 5, PAGE 1
APPENDIX A. Market Analysis
Keen Independent presents a nnarket analysis examining the special
events landscape in Scottsdale, Arizona.
Market areas. For this market analysis, Keen Independent gathered
demographic, spending and market potential information about the
population of the following market areas we defined:
Introduction
This appendix includes an analysis of the following elements to help
illustrate WestWorld's position among the greater special events and
equestrian marketplace.
■
Primary market (within 15 minutes of drive time);
■
Secondary market (within 30 minutes of drive time); and
■
Tertiary market (within 60 minutes of drive time).
These market areas are illustrated in Figure A-1.
Population projections. We developed and analyzed population
projections for the City of Scottsdale based on data provided by the
Arizona Office of Economic Opportunity and the U.S. Census Bureau.
Venue inventory. We inventoried relevant high-capacity special event
and performance venues as well as equestrian centers and RV
campgrounds. We then mapped their locations to illustrate how they
relate geographically to WestWorld.
Rental rates. Keen Independent collected rental rates at comparable
venues to compare WestWorld's pricing with that of other venues in the
marketplace.
Tourism. Finally, the study team examined tourism data provided by
the City to gain insight into how visitors interact with the arts.
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OE SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
A-1. Map of WestWorld market areas
h
T(
V
H
$^ria
_ r
m §
1
Phoeni
A
rsT
o
Mesa
o
GiW^veqndian y
ReservatMir
Drive times to WestWorld
r:—Less than 15 minutes
9i£ 15-30 minutes
i 30-60 minutes
-4
(..SasalSrande
O '5^.re
source:
Esri, HERE, Garmln, SafeGraph, FAO, METI/NASA, USGS, EPA, NPS, ArcGIS,
Keen Independent Research.
APPENDIX A, PAGE 1
A. Market Analysis — Demographics
Keen Independent analyzed the population within WestWorld's market
areas and compared them to national averages.
Age, Race and Ethnicity
Figure A-2 displays population, median age and race/ethnicity for
market area populations compared to the national average. The primary
market area has an older population with a median age of more than
five years older than the other market areas and national average.
A-2. Age, race and ethnicity for Westvyorld market area population, 2024
Primary Secondary Tertiary
United
market market
market
States
Total population
Median Age
Race
African American
Asian American
Native American
Pacific Isiander
Other race
Two or more races
White
Total
Ethnicity (of any race)
Hispanic American
Non-Hispanic
Total
345,792
44.7
2.2 %
7.2
1.1
0.1
4.7
9.5
75.1
2,341,828
38.2
5.6 %
5.7
2.7
0.3
11.4
12.8
61.6
4,868,702
37.9
6.1 %
4.8
2.5
0.3
13.9
14.1
58.3
338,056,045
39.3
12.5 %
6.4
1.2
0.2
8.8
10.7
60.3
100.0 %
13.0 %
87.1
100.0 %
26.2 %
73.8
100.0 %
31.4 %
68.6
100.0 %
19.6 %
80.4
100.0 %
100.0 %
100.0 %
100.0 %
Source:
U.S. Census Bureau American Community Survey via Esri.
Household Income and Educational Attainment
Figure A-3 provides an overview of income and educational attainment
for market area populations compared to the national average. The
primary market area is notably wealthier than the other market areas
and the national average. All market areas have a higher median
household income than the national average. The primary market area
population also has the highest portion of individuals age 25+ with
Bachelor's and Graduate degrees.
A-3. Household income and educationai attainment for WestWorid market
area population, 2024
Primary Secondary
Tertiary
United
market market
market
States
Total households
154,137
Household income
$24,999 or less
7.7 %
$25,000 to $49,999
11.4
$50,000 to $74,999
13.1
$75,000 to $99,999
12.9
$100,000 to $199,999
32.6
$200,000 or more
22.3
Total
100.0 %
963,976
1,825,505
130,537,241
11.8 %
15.5
16.1
13.9
29.2
13.6
10.7 %
14.7
16.3
14.3
31.1
13.0
14.9 %
16.8
15.7
12.8
27.2
12.6
100.0 %
100.0 %
100.0 %
Median household income $ 108,818
$ 85,203
$ 87,849
$ 79,043
Education (population age 25+)
Less than high school
3,8 %
7.9 %
High school
14.4
20.5
Some college
24.6
29.0
Bachelor's degree
35.0
26.8
Graduate degree
22.4
15.8
Total
100.0 %
100.0 %
9.2 %
23.5
30.2
23.8
13.3
9.4 %
26.8
27.1
22.5
14.3
100.0 %
100.0 %
—--------------
Source; U.S. Census Bureau American Community Survey via Esri,
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
APPENDIX A, PAGE 2
A. Market Analysis — Spending and behavior
Keen Independent analyzed the spending and market potential
behaviors of the population within WestWorld's market areas and
compared them to national averages.
Entertainment Spending Potential
Figure A-4 displays selected spending potential indices (SPI) for
WestWorld market area population for categories such as
entertainment/recreation and sports events.
Spending potential indices (SPI) compare the average amount spent
locally for a product to the average amount spent nationally. An index
of 100 reflects the U.S. average. All SPIs measure a 12-month period
unless otherwise stated in the chart.
Spending potential is notably higher among the primary market area
population than other market areas. However, nearly all market areas
exceed the national average in spending potential. This is consistent
with the market area's higher annual household income levels.
A-4. Spending potential indices for WestWorld market area population, 2024
Primary Secondary
Tertiary
United
market market
market
States
Entertainment/recreation
Index
Average
137
$ 5,614
Entertainment/recreation fees/admissions
Index
145
Average
$ 1,194
Tickets to theater/operas/concerts
Index
149
Average
$
113
Tickets to parks or museums
Index
139
Average
$
52
Tickets to movies
Index
143
Average
$
35
Live entertainment-catered affairs
Index
136
Average
$
27
Sports events admission
Index
138
Average
$
109
105
$ 4,312
106
S 877
109
$
83
$
109
41
117
$
29
105
S 21
103
S 81
105
$ 4,311
106
S 873
106
$ 81
no
$
41
116
S 29
99
$ 20
100
$
79
IC’;.-:.. ' ■
100
S 4,104
100
$ 820
100
S 76
100
S 37
100
$
24
100
$ 20
100
$
79
Source:
Esri spending potential database based on U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics Consumer
Expenditure Survey (2024).
[
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
APPENDIX A, PAGE 3
A. Market Analysis — Spending and behavior
Entertainment Market Potential
Figures A-5 and A-6 display selected market potential indices (MPI) of
the WestWorld market areas. Market potential indices (MPI) measure
the relative likelihood of local consumers in the specified areas to
engage in selected activities or demonstrate potentially relevant
behaviors or purchasing patterns. An MPI of 100 represents the national
average. This measure indicates the percentage of residents who have
engaged in an activity or behavior at least once in 12 months.
A-5. Market potential indices for WestWorld market area population, 2024
Primary Secondary Tertiary United
Market Market Market
States
High school super sports fan
2%
2%
2%
2%
Index
81
84
91
100
Ordered sports event tickets
online (last 6 months)
6%
6%
5%
5%
Index
109
107
100
100
Attended a...
High school sports event
4%
3%
4%
4%
Index
103
96
100
100
Sports event
17 %
is %
16 %
16 %
Index
109
102
100
100
Horseraces
2 %
2 %
2 %
2 %
Index
92
97
100
100
Auto show
6%
5%
5%
5%
Index
104
100
100
100
State or county fair
9 %
10 %
11 %
11 %
Index
87
97
100
100
Source:
Esri market potential database based on MRI Simmons Survey (2024).
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
A-6. Market potential indices for WestWorld market area population, 2024
Primary Secondary Tertiary United
Market Market
Market
States
Went to a museum
16 %
15 %
14 %
13 %
Index
122
110
104
100
Went to an art gallery
12%
10%
10%
9%
Index
125
112
104
100
Went to a live theater
11%
9%
9%
9%
Index
123
108
103
100
Danced or went dancing
6%
7%
7%
7%
Index
94
109
110
100
Attended a...
Classical/opera performance
4%
4%
3%
3%
Index
129
112
102
100
Country music performance
5%
5%
5%
5%
Index
100
102
107
100
Dance performance
3%
3%
3%
3%
Index
105
104
101
100
Movie (last 6 months)
45 o/„
45
45 o/„
44 %
Index
103
103
103
100
Rock music performance
10 %
9 %
9 %
8 %
Index
118
109
105
100
Source:
Esri market potential database based on MRI Simmons Survey (2024).
APPENDIX A, PAGE 4
A. Market Analysis — Population forecasts
Population projections can inform potential future demand for various
types of events that may take place at WestWorld. Figure A-7 depicts
the population projections for the City of Scottsdale based on data from
the Arizona Office of Economic Opportunity and U.S. Census Bureau. In
2022, the City population was just under 250,000 and it is projected to
increase to about 350,000 people by year 2050.
Population by Age in 2022
Figure A-8 on the following page illustrates the age distribution of the
Scottsdale population. The graphs show the population group according
to widely recognized generations beginning with the Silent Generation
(born between 1926 and 1945) to Gen Z (born between 1996 and 2010)
and the Alpha Generation (born in 2011 and later years).
In 2022, Baby Boomers (ages 55 to 74) were by far the largest
generation totaling nearly 68,000. Gen X (ages 40 to 54) and Millennials
(ages 25 to 39) made up roughly equal shares of the population at
45,000 and 47,000, respectively. The Silent Generation (ages 75 and
older) and Gen Z (ages 10 to 24) made up roughly equal shares of the
population at 32,000 and 35,000, respectively, and Alpha Gen
(ages 0 to 9) comprised about 16,000 of Scottsdale's residents.
Population by Age in 2050
Figure A-8 also presents the projected age distribution for the
Scottsdale population. In 2050, the Scottsdale population will have
significantly aged. Millennials and Gen X are projected to each have
populations of over 70,000.
The proportion of residents under 40 remains relatively consistent
between 2022 and 2050, which is reflective of recent trends of Gen X,
Millennials and Gen Z having fewer children.
A-7. Projected population change for City of Scottsdale, 2022-2050
400,000 1
350,000 -
300,000 -
250,000 -
200,000 -
150,000 -
100,000 -
50,000 -
2022
2030
2040
2050
Source:
Arizona Office of Economic Opportunity, U.S. Census Bureau and
Keen Independent Research,
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
APPENDIX A, PAGE 5
A. Market Analysis — Population forecasts
A-8. City of Scottsdale population by age in 2022 and 2050
35,000
30,000 -
25,000 -
20,000 -
15,000 -
10,000 -
5,000 -
0
I Gamma Gen (2041-2055)
Beta Gen (2026-2040)
Alpha Gen (2011-2025)
I Gen Z (1996-2010)
I Millennial (1981-1995)
I Gen X (1966-1980)
I Baby Boomer (1946-1965)
■ Silent Generation (1926-1945)
^ ^ <?> <§>
^
'V^'
'P'
2022 age
35,000
30,000
25,000
20,000
illlllllll
>
<o>
'i?'
cf>' 4>'
(p'
<P'
&
<o'
X
2050 age
Source:
Arizona Office of Economic Opportunity, Keen independent Research.
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
APPENDIX A, PAGE 6
A. Market Analysis — Venue inventory
To identify potential gaps in the market for various types of venues.
Keen Independent compiled an inventory of high-capacity event venues,
high-capacity performance venues, equestrian arenas, RV campgrounds
and convention/conference/expo centers in the metro Phoenix area.
Figures A-9 through A-12 display the names, locations and capacities of
the venues we inventoried. Following the inventory tables, we include
maps showing the locations of all venues in relation to WestWorld's
market areas (Figures A-14 to A-17).
High-Capacity Event Venues
Figure A-9 provides a list of event spaces with capacities of 700 or more.
The metro Phoenix area has a high concentration of event venues,
creating strong competition for WestWorld in attracting events to
Monterra. Because many of these venues host upscale, luxury-level
events, WestWorld may need to emphasize what distinguishes
Monterra from nearby competitors to attract certain events.
Figure A-15 later in this appendix illustrates the close proximity of about
nine event venues within a three-mile radius of WestWorld, with two of
those venues being able to accommodate at least 1,000 individuals.
A-9. Event spaces in the metro Phoenix area with a 700+ capacity
Event spaces (700+ capacity)
City
Capacity
WestWorld (Monterra)
Scottsdale
800
American Royal Palace
Phoenix
1,200
Arizona Grand Resort & Spa
Phoenix
Canyon Ballroom
2,200
Arizona Grand Ballroom
2,200
Sonoran Sky Ballroom
1,540
South Mountain Ballroom
880
Oasis Patio
700
The Barn at Desert Foothills
Scottsdale
1,500
Caesars Republic Scottsdale (Romulus Ballroom)
Scottsdale
900
Clayton House - Great Room
Scottsdale
800
Delta Hotels Phoenix Mesa
Mesa
Arizona Ballroom
1,000
Main Hall
1,815
DoubleTree Resort by Hilton Hotel Paradise Valley - Scottsdale
Scottsdale
The Forum
1,500
Paradise Park
1,400
North Forum
750
South Forum
750
DoubleTree by Hilton Hotel Phoenix - Gilbert (Grand Ballroom)
Gilbert
800
Eduardo's Reception Hall
Mesa
800
El Gran Salon & El Gran Palacio Reception Hall
Phoenix
900
Source:
Keen Independent Research,
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
APPENDIX A, PAGE?
A. Market Analysis — Venue inventory
Capacity
A-9. Event spaces in the metro Phoenix area \with a 700+ capacity (continued)
Event spaces (700+ capacity)
Embassy Suites by Hilton Phoenix Scottsdale (Ballroom)
Fairmont Scottsdale Princess
Palomino Ballroom
Princess Ballroom
East Foyer
Gila River Resorts & Casinos - Wild Horse Pass
Palo Verde Ballroom
The Showroom
Grand Hyatt Scottsdale Resort
Vaquero Ballroom
Arizona Ballroom
Lawn Court
Hilton Phoenix Resort at the Peak
Anasazi Ballroom
Hohokam Ballroom
Hilton Scottsdale Resort & Villas
Grand Ballroom
Pavillion
Hyatt Regency
Regency Ballroom
Atrium
Phoenix
Scottsdale
Chandler
Scottsdale
Phoenix
Scottsdale
Phoenix
700
2,990
2,990
860
1,245
1,400
1,030
1,400
800
1,020
900
900
756
1,100
700
Source; Keen Independent Research.
A-9. Event spaces in the metro Phoenix area with a 700+ capacity (continued)
Event spaces (700+ capacity)
City
Capacity
JW Marriott Phoenix Desert Ridge Resort & Spa
Phoenix
The Grand Canyon Ballroom
4,000
The Grand Sonoran Ballroom
2,900
Grand Saguaro Ballroom
2,750
Ballroom Lawn
1,800
Tierra Madre
2,150
Desert Kivas
900
Sunset Lawn
1,000
JW Marriott Scottsdale Camelback Inn Resort 8i Spa
Scottsdale
Arizona Ballroom
2,100
Paradise Ballroom
1,570
Sonoran Terrace
800
Mummy Mountain 1
700
Marriott Phoenix Resort Tempe at The Buttes (Kachina Ballroom)
Tempe
900
Omni Scottsdale Montelucia (Alhambra Ballroom)
Scottsdale
1,000
Omni Tempe Hotel
Tempe
1,350
The Phoenician
Scottsdale
Phoenician Grand Ballroom
2,5(K)
Ballroom South Foyer
1,332
Estrella Theater
872
Ballroom East Foyer
1,046
The Camelback Ballroom
1,500
Phoenix Shrine Auditorium and Event Center (Auditorium)
Phoenix
1,500
Source:
Keen Independent Research,
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
APPENDIX A, PAGE 8
A. Market Analysis — Venue inventory
Capacity
A-9, Event spaces in the metro Phoenix area with a 700+ capacity (continued)
Event spaces (700+ capacity)
Rawhide
Rodeo Arena
Rawhide Event Center
Maricopa Welis
Renaissance Phoenix Downtown Hotei
Grand Bailroom
Pueblo
Renaissance Phoenix Glendaie Hotel & Spa
Solana Ballroom
Cira Ballroom
Media Center
Scottsdale Private Event Venues
The Aviator Hangar
Hangar 7 Scottsdale
Deadhead Event Hangar
Legacy 600 Event Hangar
Lux Air Hangar Goodyear
Scottsdale Hangar
Scottsdale Corporate Event Venues
The Scottsdale Resort and Spa, Curio Collection by Hiiton
Grand Coronado
McCormick Pool
Chandler
Phoenix
Glendale
Scottsdale
Scottsdale
6.500
6,000
1.500
950
850
3,200
750
3,400
2,000
800
1,500
1,000
1,500
1,500
1,000
1,000
700
Source:
Keen Independent Research.
A-9. Event spaces in the metro Phoenix area with a 700+ capacity (continued)
Event spaces (700+ capacity)
Sheraton Grand at Wild Horse Pass
Akimel Ballroom
Kave Ballroom
Komatke Ballroom
Hemapik Lawn
Sheraton Mesa Hotel at Wrigleyvilie West (Canyon Ballroom)
Talking Stick Resort (Salt River Grand Ballroom)
Venue at Volanti (Hangars)
W Scottsdale (WET Deck)
We-Ko-Pa Casino Resort
Wassaja Ballroom
Cholla Golf Course
Resort Courtyard
La Puesta Del Sol
Rosa's Ranch
The Westin Kierland Resort & Spa
Herberger Ballroom
Kierland Grand Ballroom
Trailblazer Ballroom
Wigwam Arizona (Ballroom)
City
Chandler
Mesa
Scottsdale
Scottsdale
Scottsdale
Fort McDowell
Scottsdale
Litchfield Park
Capacity
1.900
700
1,500
1,000
1,250
2.900
5,000
1,000
1,000
500
300
500
300
2,005
3,601
1,216
1,200
Source:
Keen Independent Research.
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
APPENDIX A, PAGE 9
A. Market Analysis — Venue inventory
High-Capacity Performance Venues
Although WestWorld does not have a dedicated performance venue, it
has hosted concerts on its grounds \A/ith a temporary stage build.
Figures A-10 provides an inventory of high-capacity performance venues
in the metro Phoenix area. The metro area includes many
high-capacity performance venues, most of which are located further
south and west of WestWorld. About four venues on this list are
amphitheaters/outdoor performance venues.
A-10. Performance venues in the metro Phoenix area with a 1,000+ capacity
Performance venues
E. Lowell Rogers Amphitheatre
Faith Arena
Nile Theater
Glendale Civic Center
Sundial Auditorium
Higley Center for the Performing Arts
The Vista Center for the Arts
The showroom at Wild Horse Pass
Orpheum Theatre
Marquee Theatre Tempe
Phoenix Shrine Auditorium
Chandler Center for the Arts - Malnstage Theatre
Mesa Arts Center - Tom and Janet Ikeda Theater
Scottsdale Civic Center Amphitheater
The Van Buren
We-Ko-Pa Conference Center
City
Glendale
Surprise
Mesa
Glendale
Sun City
Gilbert
Surprise
Chandler
Phoenix
Tempe
Phoenix
Chandler
Mesa
Scottsdale
Phoenix
Fort McDowell
Capacity
1,000
1,000
1,000
1,100
1,158
1,235
1,286
1,400
1,410
1,500
1,500
1,508
1,600
1,800
1,800
2,000
Source:
Keen Independent Research.
A-10. Performance venues in the metro Phoenix area with a 1,000+ capacity
(continued)
Performance venues
City
Phoenix Symphony Hall
Phoenix
Celebrity Theatre
Phoenix
ASU Gammage
Tempe
Walter Where?House
Phoenix
Arizona State Fair Grandstand Arena
Phoenix
Mesa Amphitheatre
Mesa
Arizona Financial Theatre
Phoenix
Mullett Arena
Tempe
Rawhide Event Center
Chandler
Grand Canyon University - Global Credit Union Arena
Phoenix
Sun Bowl Amphitheater
Sun City
Arizona Veterans Memorial Coliseum
Phoenix
Footprint Center
Phoenix
Desert Diamond Arena
Glendale
Talking Stick Resort Amphitheatre
Phoenix
Chase Field
Phoenix
State Farm Stadium
Glendale
Source:
Keen Independent Research.
Capacity
2,312
2,650
3,000
3,000
4,000
4,950
5,000
5,000
6,000
7,000
7,000
14,870
18,422
19,000
20,106
48,633
63,400
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
APPENDIX A, PAGE 10
A. Market Analysis — Venue inventory
Equestrian Arenas
Figure A-11 is a list of equestrian arenas in the metro Phoenix area.
While there are a notable number of equestrian arenas in the area, they
cannot accommodate events at the same scale or capacity as
WestWorld. These other venues may be suitable for smaller equestrian
events during times when WestWorld's unavailable to host them.
A-11. Equestrian arenas in the metro Phoenix area
Name
4D Arena
Apache Junction Rodeo Grounds
Arizona Horse Lovers Park
Buckeye Arena
Casa Grande Rodeo Grounds
Cave Creek Memorial Arena
Desert Palms Equestrian Center
Dillons Western Trails Ranch
Downtown Roping Arena
Dunn's Arena
Dynamite Arena
Everett Bowman Rodeo Arena
Horseshoe Park & Equestrian Centre
KOLI Equestrian Center
P&M Arena
Ponderosa Rebel Arena
Rancho Ochoa
Rancho Rio Arena
Rawhide
Stonegate Equestrian Park
Source:
Keen Independent Research.
Wittmann
Apache Junction
Phoenix
Buckeye
Casa Grande
Cave Creek
Phoenix
Morristown
Wickenburg
Litchfield
Cave Creek
Wickenburg
Queen Creek
Chandler
Mesa
Phoenix
Phoenix
Wickenburg
Chandler
Scottsdale
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
APPENDIX A, PAGE 11
A. Market Analysis — Venue inventory
RV Campgrounds
Figure A-12 provides a list of RV campgrounds in the metro Phoenix
area. Outside of dates when large events are held at WestWorld, there
is notable competition from other campsites in the area. Other
campsites offer more natural, scenic settings or more affordable options
in central locations. Figure A-16 later in this appendix illustrates the
location of other RV campgrounds in relation to \A/estWorld.
Convention/Conference/Expo Centers
Figure A-13 provides a list of convention/conference/expo centers in
the Phoenix area along with their available square footage for meetings
and expos. Convention, conference and expo centers typically attract
events and attendees at a wider, more regional scale. With such high
capacities and square footage, it is reasonable to see fewer venues of
this type within a market.
AZ Exposition & State Fairgrounds has similar square footage to
WestWorld. While WestWorld may compete with all these venues
for regional high-impact events, it is most comparable to the
AZ Exposition & State Fairgrounds.
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
A-12. RV campgrounds in the metro Phoenix area
Name
City
Cave Creek Regional Park
Cave Creek
Clay Target Center
Phoenix
Covered Wagon RV Park
Phoenix
Desert Sands RV Park
Phoenix
Desert Shadows RV Resort
Phoenix
Encore Paradise (age 55 plus)
Sun City
Estrella Mountain Park
Goodyear
Lake Pleasant Regional Park
Morristown
McDowell Mountain Park
Scottsdale
Phoenix Metro RV Park
Phoenix
Pioneer RV Resort (age 55 plus)
Phoenix
Plaza Verde RV & Mobile Flome Park
Phoenix
Pleasant Flarbor RV Resort
Peoria
Usery Mountain Regional Park
Mesa
White Tank Mountain Regional Park
Waddell
Source:
Keen Independent Research.
A-13. Convention/conference/expo centers in the metro Phoenix area
Name
We-Ko-Pa Conference Center
City
FortMcDowell
Mesa Convention Center
Mesa
AZ Exposition & State Fairgrounds Phoenix
WestWorld
Scottsdale
Phoenix Convention Center
Phoenix
Total meeting/expo
space square footage
25,000
40,000
283,906
300,000 +
1,000,000
Source:
Keen Independent Research.
APPENDIX A, PAGE 12
A. Market Analysis — Venue inventory
A-14. Map of event venues, performance venues, equestrian arenas and RV campgrounds in the metro Phoenix area
liU
ii
□
£
1
•Mi*
f
9
9
m
ft
74
WestWorld of Scottsdale
f
■1“
9
f f
9
/£
9
ft
■£
T
9
03
-4^
9
L.
1.’
9
i.;,
*
ft
9
9
£
ri
r^i
i
Sait
9
r
f
Ri>Si>rva
?
%
ft
:>rv
N«
4
f9 9
9
-V
...
9
r
9f
0
9
9
«
WestWorld of Scottsdale Inventory
^ RV campgrounds
Equestrian arenas
9 Event spaces (outdoor)
^ Event spaces
“ip Performance venues
WestWorld drive times
Less than 15 minutes
' 15-30 minutes
30-60 minutes
9
1
f
Paradise
J.
?
Valley
h
•-r
S
77
E]
9
f i
♦
.7
t
[ig
OfleHiVef
Czg
'1
N
Floienee
4-
□
‘vf
J-
w
»7
Source:
Esri, HERE, Garmin, SafeGraph, FAO, METI/NASA, USGS, EPA, NPS, ArcGIS, Keen Independent Research.
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
APPENDIX A, PAGE 13
A. Market Analysis — Venue inventory
A-15. Location of event venues within about three miles of WestWorld
CT-..
V af ts
I
9
3
ns
Z
9
10
i
9
S'*
9
19
9
%
<5
?!
o
■n
:rt
c
I
1I J
jj
0
1.5
Miles9
III
V
^ } V
m
m
Source:
Esri, HERE, Garmin, SafeGraph, FAO, METI/NASA, USGS, ERA, NPS, ArcGIS, Keen Independent Research.
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
APPENDIX A, PAGE 14
A. Market Analysis — Venue inventory
A-16. Map of event venues and performance venues with 1,000+ capacity as well as equestrian arenas and RV campgrounds in the metro Phoenix area
lEI
a
n
£
4
£
V
i,
-w
mm
i
74
WestWorid of Scottsdale
j
/
.. 4'^'
'I
tOI
4;
A
r
303
2
3
9
I
■m
"1
i
: -
•f
is
\
I,
■u1
KM#
( Shej «t«
%
Q
9
9^
9
u
i
r
S
A
m
JBI
rr.
9»
K
9
1
S r
WestWorid of Scottsdale Inventory
A RV campgrounds
(3) Equestrian arenas
9 Event spaces w/ 1,000+ capacity (outdoor)
^ Event spaces w/ 1,000+ capacity
'p Performance venues w/1,000+ capacity
WestWorid drive times
” ’ Less than 15 minutes
15-30 minutes
30-60 minutes
Paradise
Valley
Or
T
1^
- t
.-M I I ;
rr^ -X
i
ri^
f
c
Vs
Reaervation
/ r
rt
N
Fkvenca
E-
■ TJ
w4-e
1
ncopat#A
387
Source:
Esri, HERE, Garmin, SafeGraph, FAO, METI/NASA, USGS, EPA, NPS, ArcGIS, Keen Independent Research.
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
APPENDIX A, PAGE 15
A. Market Analysis — Venue inventory
A-17. Map of event venues and performance venues with 1,000+ capacity
(X i
■r
X
i£-
'-V/
f.
[nf
■*1
mj
WestWorid of Scottsdale
r ^
s
'■il:
3
...
r
03
f r «.*'
i
9
*'5'
•t
15
fr'
V
1
s.in FMvar
aiv
V.?
?
I
ST.
9
r-
’
■ny
r;
9
JL'
1
Parad le
T
Vallay
+/
V-'
77
0
a
pnri^v
' "RcatrvaUon
VS
c»
JjlE
!Y
N
Florancfl
f X
V.J-M r.ijM
i
»7
WestWorid of Scottsdale Inventory
Venues with capacity over 1,000
f Event spaces
9 Event spaces (outdoor)
'? Performance venues
WestWorid drive times
iS”?1 Less than 15 minutes
15-30 minutes
30-60 minutes
Source:
Esri, HERE, Garmin, SafeGraph, FAO, METI/NASA, USGS, ERA, NPS, ArcGIS, Keen Independent Research.
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORID OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
APPENDIX A, PAGE 16
A. Market Analysis — Rental rates
Keen Independent researched the space rental rates for nearby
convention and expo centers as well as other similar venues nationally
and compared these rates to WestWorld space rental rates. For more
information on benchmark venues, see Appendix F.
Note that space rental rates do not include an analysis of equipment or
labor charges. All venues studied have additional charges related to
labor and equipment and sometimes require working with third-party
companies (e.g. working with an AV company for audio/visual needs).
Arenas and Amphitheaters
We compared rental rates for amphitheaters and arenas with rental
rates at WestWorld in Figure A-18. To enable a more direct comparison
of venues with varying capacities, we caiculated the price per seat. In
this figure, spaces are organized by their price per seat available in the
venue from highest to lowest.
The Equidome daily rate and price per seat is at the lower end of
benchmarks studied, with pricing falling below the median and average
of compared rates. Venues with higher rental rates, such as Symphony
Hall, Orpheum Theater and SYEC Auditorium, are indoor theaters that
have updated sound and lighting systems.
A-18. Rental rate comparison between arenas, amphitheaters and theaters at
locai and national benchmark venues
Venue
National Western Center
National Western Center
Phoenix Convention Center
Phoenix Convention Center
Will Rogers Memorial Center
Will Rogers Memorial Center
Will Rogers Memorial Center
OC Fair and Event Center
Will Rogers Memorial Center
WestWorld
OC Fair and Event Center
National Western Center
WestWorld
Space
SYEC Auditorium
LVC Arena
Symphony Hall
Orpheum Theater
James L, West Sale Arena
John Justin Arena
Will Rogers Auditorium
Pacific Amphitheatre
Historic Will Rogers Coliseum
Equidome
Action Sports Arena
Amphitheater
Wendell Arena
Capacity Dally rate Price per seat
Median
Average
Source:
Keen Independent Research.
630
3,000
2,312
1,364
640
1,934
2,856
8,000
5,652
3,400
7,000
N/A
N/A
$
7,500
15,000
4,000
2,300
1,000
2.500
3.500
9,425
4,250
2.500
3,125
5,000
800
$
2,856
$
3,500
3.344
4,685
$
11.90
5.00
1.73
1.69
1.56
1.29
1.23
1.18
0.75
0.74
0.45
1.29
2.50
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
APPENDIX A, PAGE 17
A. Market Analysis — Rental rates
Outdoor Event Space
Figure A-19 provides a comparison of the rental rates for outdoor event
spaces at local and national benchmark venues. To provide a more
side-by-side comparison of venues with varying capacities, we
calculated the price of each space per square foot. WestWorld's fee for
renting its field is lower than the median and average of both the daily
rate and price per square foot of comparable venues. Outdoor spaces at
higher rates at the National Western Center include power and water
access throughout the event space.
Indoor Event Space
Figure A-20 compares space rental rates for indoor event spaces at local
and national benchmark venues. Rental fees for WestWorld indoor
event spaces are consistently below both the median and average price
per square foot at other similar venues. Venues with higher rental rates
have updated sound and lighting systems.
A-19. Rental rate comparison between outdoor event spaces at local and
national benchmark venues
Venue
National Western Center
National Western Center
National Western Center
National Western Center
National Western Center
Mesa Convention Center
WestWorld
OC Fairs Event Center
OC Fairs Event Center
Space
LVC Plaza
SYEC West Plaza
SYEC North Plaza
Riverfront Park
SYEC The Yards
Grand Plaza
Field West and Lot D
Festival Fields (asphalt)
Festival Fields (grass)
Median
Average
Price per
Square feet Dally rate
square toot
43,560 * $
5,000
$
0.11
60,000
70.000
261,360 *
566,280 ♦
39,150
871,200 *
N/A
N/A
70,000 $
273,079
5,000
5,000
15,000
25,000
1,000
4.750
3.750
2,650
5,000
7,461
$
0.08
0.07
0.06
0,04
0.03
0.01
0.06
0.06
Note:
‘Square footage estimated based on number of acres available.
Source:
Keen Independent Research.
A-20. Rental rate comparison between indoor event space at local and national
benchmark venues
Venue
Space
National Western Center
National Western Center
National Western Center
Phoenix Convention Center
Phoenix Convention Center
Phoenix Convention Center
National Western Center
Mesa Convention Center
Mesa Convention Center
OC Fairs Event Center
OC Fairs Event Center
OC Fairs Event Center
OC Fairs Event Center
Mesa Convention Center
OC Fairs Event Center
OC Fair S Event Center
National Western Center
OC Fairs Event Center
Will Rogers Memorial Center Round Up Inn
Will Rogers Memorial Center Texas Room
WestWorld
South Hall
WestWorld
Multi-use Tent
WestWorld
North Hall
WestWorld
TNEC
Median
Average
Source:
Keen Independent Research.
LVC Flex
LVC 360
SYEC Expo Hall
Multipurpose Rooms
North Ballroom
Exhibit Halls
LVC Expo North
Building B
BuildingA
Anaheim Building
Los Alamitos Building
Huntington Beach Building
The Hangar
Building C
OC Promenade
Santa Ana Pavilion
LVC Expo South
Costa Mesa Building
Price per
Square feet Dally rate square foot
10,000
3,000
18,000
N/A
45,600
403,500
40,000
8,686
7,620
12,636
16,640
19,572
22,245
19,671
18,025
16,325
120,000
34,025
18,000
94,460
37,000
120,000
117,000
300,000
$
7.500
2,000
10,000
N/A
N/A
N/A
12,000
2,250
1,750
2,725
3.425
3.825
4,025
3,000
2,725
2.425
17,500
4.825
2.500
8.500
3,000
8,400
7,000
11,000
$
0.75
0.67
0.56
0.39
0.39
0.33
0.30
0.26
0.23
0.22
0.21
0.20
0.18
0.15
0.15
0.15
0.15
0.14
0.14
0.09
0.08
0.07
0.06
0.04
19,671
$
3,825
$
0.19
65,305
5,732
0.25
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
APPENDIX A, PAGE 18
A. Market Analysis — Tourism data
Keen Independent reviewed tourism data provided by the City of
Scottsdale. Longwoods International compiled this data on visits for
2022 and 2023.
Overall Trends
In 2023, visitors took 4.8 million overnight trips to Scottsdale, an
increase of just over 1 percent from 2022. Spending on overnight trips
totaled more than $1.56 billion, a 5 percent increase from 2022. Visitors
spent about 10 percent of 2023 total spending on recreation and
entertainment, which equates to about $160 million. Trips were fairly
evenly distributed throughout the year, with slightly more from January
through March and slightly fewer from July through September.
Visitor Profiles
Visitors from Arizona and California made up over 40 percent of
overnight visitors to Scottsdale in 2023. Figure B-20 displays additional
characteristics, including income, age and race/ethnicity of overnight
visitors to Scottsdale in 2022 and 2023. In 2023, the average overnight
traveler had a higher median income and was slightly older than the
average overnight traveler in 2022.
Activities During Visit
Of all the 2023 overnight visitors to Scottsdale, about 65 percent
indicated that they attended entertainment events and about
43 percent reported attending cultural activities. About 10 percent in
2023 said the purpose of their visit was to attend a special event
(on par with 2022, which was 9 percent).
A-21. Scottsdale overnight visitor demographics, 2022 and 2023
2022
2023
Household income
$49,999 or less
$50,000 to $74,999
$75,000 to $99,999
$100,000 to $149,999
$150,000 or more
Total
31 %
23
17
18
11
27 %
19
16
22
15
100 %
Median household income $ 74,400
Age
18 to 24
25 to 34
35 to 44
45 to 54
55 to 64
65+
Total
Median age
Race/ethnicity
African American
Hispanic American
White
Other race
12 %
22
20
18
14
15
100 %
$ 95,100
9 %
21
22
13
18
18
100 %
44.7
10 %
17
81
11
100 %
46.5
10 %
17
80
14
Note:
Source:
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
■ ..............................................................................■
Median Income from 2022 is based on average income of visitors to the Phoenix and
Scottsdale areas (reported In an Arizona state tourism document) because 2022 median
income was not available in the Scottsdale tourism report. Participants could select
more than one race/ethnicity so numbers do not add up to 100.
Longwoods International, City of Scottsdale, Keen Independent Research, 2024.
APPENDIX A, PAGE 19
APPENDIX B. Summary of Key Performance Indicators — Introduction
In this appendix, we analyze initial performance indicators for
WestWorld operations to establish a baseline understanding of facility
operations. This will inform future data collection that may be needed
to measure key performance indicators requested by City leadership.
The performance indicators analyzed in this appendix include:
■
Utilization. This includes the number of events held at
WestWorld and number of use days;
■
Attendance. We examine overall annual attendance, as well
as average attendance per event to account for annual
variation in the number of events;
■
Financials. This includes revenues, expenses, net operating
income (or loss) and debt service; and
■
Estimated economic impact. This includes total estimated
economic impact and estimated transaction privilege
tax revenue.
B-1. Inside the tent at the Barrett-Jackson Car Auction
K
Source:
Keen Independent Research.
i
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
APPENDIX B, PAGE 1
B. Summary of Key Performance Indicators — Utilization
Keen Independent analyzed the total number of events and use days at
WestWorld from fiscal year 2016 through fiscal year 2024.
Total events. Figure B-2 shows annual number of distinct events at
WestWorld by event type (equestrian or special event) and by fiscal
year. Distinct events include single-day equestrian shows as well as
multi-day signature events that span multiple weeks.
WestWorld typically hosts nearly 100 distinct events each year, with a
peak of about 120 distinct events in fiscal year 2017 and a low of about
70 distinct events in fiscal year 2020. The decline in the number of
distinct events in fiscal year 2020 was likely due to cancellations related
to the COVID-ig pandemic.
Over the last eight years, the number of equestrian events has been
similar to the number of special events that take place at WestWorld.
Use days. Event use days include the total number of days an event
utilizes space at WestWorld, including days used for event set up and
take down. Use days for events can overlap when more than one event
is taking place at WestWorld, therefore, it is not unusual to see total use
days exceeding 365 annually. WestWorld typically has between 140 and
190 days annually with more than one event occurring at the same
time. Each of these days include more than one "use day."
Note that the spike in use days in fiscal year 2021 are due to WestWorld
accommodating events from other venues that had closed and hosting a
number of alternative events like a vaccination drive-thru clinic.
Figure B-3 illustrates the number of use days at WestWorld by event
type. Special events consistently account for more use days than
equestrian events, despite a similar number of each event type per
year. This indicates that special events tend to utilize WestWorld for a
greater number of days for each event.
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
B-2. Total events at WestWorld by event type and fiscal year, FY16-FY24
140 1
120
100
80
60
40
20
0
Total events
Equestrian
events
Special events
<^0^
Source:
WestWorld of Scottsdale.
B-3. Total number of use days at WestWorld by event type and fiscal year,
FY16-FY24
800 n
600
400 -
200 -
Total event
use days
Special event
use days
Equestrian
use days
Source: WestWorld of Scottsdale.
APPENDIX B, PAGE 2
B. Summary of Key Performance Indicators — Attendance
Figure B-4 illustrates annual attendance at WestWorld events by fiscal
year. With the exception of a decline in attendance in fiscal year 2021
(due to the effects of the COVID-19 pandemic), attendance at
WestWorld typically ranges between 700,000 and 900,000.
Average attendance per event. Figure B-5 illustrates average
attendance per event at WestWorld by fiscal year. Observing average
attendance allows us to compare the quality of events from year to year
as it relates to attendance. Even though the total number of events at
WestWorld annually decreased from fiscal year 2017 to fiscal year 2020,
the events that did occur had higher attendance numbers on average.
Note that Barrett-Jackson Car Auction and Arabian Horse Show are each
considered one event in this calculation and attract 250,000 to 350,000
attendees at each event. Events with more event days have a higher
likelihood of greater attendance numbers. To further analyze event
attendance and provide a more precise assessment of attendance at
each event, we recommend tracking the number of event days to
calculate average attendance per event day.
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
B-4. WestWorld annual attendance by fiscal year, FY16-FY24
1,000,000 -1
800,000 -
600,000 -
400,000 -
200,000 -
Source: WestWorld of Scottsdale.
B-5. Average attendance per event at WestWorld by fiscal year, FY16-FY24
14,000 1
12,000
10,000
8,000
6,000
4,000
2,000
<0^
Source: WestWorld of Scottsdale.
APPENDIX B, PAGE 3
B. Summary of Key Performance Indicators — Financials
Keen Independent studied operational expenses for WestWorld from
fiscal year 19/20 through fiscal year 23/24. Figure B-6 provides a
summary of WestWorld's operational expenses over the
five-year period.
Personnel expenses. Personnel expenses Include wages, salaries,
benefits and overtime. This does not include expenses for services that
have been contracted out to a third party. Personnel expenses have
gradually increased as the cost of labor has increased. Although
personnel expenses have increased, WestWorld has reduced the
number of full-time equivalent (FTE) staff from 33 in fiscal years 19/20
through 22/23 to 31 in fiscal year 23/24.
Net operating income. Net operating income has ranged from a
$1.6 million loss to $360,000 profit (before debt service expenses) over
the five fiscal years studied. Note that the years that show positive net
operating income were the fiscal years that were most affected by the
CO\/ID-19 pandemic.
City operational subsidy. The net operating income loss and debt
service are paid for by the City and therefore considered a subsidy to
the operations of WestWorld. The debt service includes debt from past
capital expenditures related to the facilities. Part of this debt service
($1.2 million) is funded by Bed Tax contributions.
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
B-7. Summary of WestWorld statement of operations, FY19/20-FY23/24
FY 19/20
FY 20/21
FY 21/22
FY 22/23
FY 23/24
S 2,261,538
$
3,601,497
$
3,675,360
$
3,781,955
S 3,834,129
4,281,724
Facility rental
Other revenue
2,338,241
2,660,848
3,760,271
3,957,510
Total revenue
$
4,599,779
$
6,262,345 $
7,435,631
$
7,739,465
$
8,115,853
Personnel services
$
2,076,128
$
1,947,387 $
2,318,441
$
2,419,431
$
2,745,065
Contractual services
Other expenses
2,958,872
1,155,497
2,668,119
1,355,728
3,267,559
1,488,955
3,989,653
1,712,546
3,758,989
1,913,302
Total expenses
S
6,190,497
$
5,971,234
$
7,074,955
$
8,121,630
$
8,417,356
Net income
$
(1,590,718) $
291,111
$
360,676
$
(382,165) $
(301,503)
Debt service
$
4,363,373
$
3,494,782
$
4,570,462
$
3,591,426
S
3,590,111
One-time repairs
-
-
-
623,230
309,787
Income after
debt service and $
(5,954,091) $
(3,203,671) $
(4,209,786)
$
(4,596,821) $
(4,201,401)
one-time repairs
Source: WestWorld of Scottsdale.
APPENDIX B, PAGE 4
B. Summary of Key Performance Indicators — Estimated economic impact
In 2024, the Arizona State University Seidman Research Institute
conducted an economic impact study for WestWorld. This study
included over 2,000 surveys collected from attendees at 22 equestrian
and non-equestrian events held at WestWorld during fiscal year 2024.
Total economic impact. Arizona State University estimated that
WestWorld events generated approximately $163 million in economic
impact for the City of Scottsdale in fiscal year 2024. Figure B-8 illustrates
the sources of this economic activity.
Transaction privilege tax (TPT) revenue generated. Arizona State
University also estimated TPT revenue generated as a result of events
taking place at Westworld. Figure B-9 shows that an estimate of about
$4.8 million in TPT revenue was generated by WestWorld events, with
about $4 million specifically being from non-equestrian events, like the
Barrett-Jackson Car Auction.
This TPT revenue exceeded the City's debt service payments for
Westworld in the same year, which totaled about $3.5 million.
Return on investment. With an operational subsidy of about $300,000
from the City of Scottsdale in fiscal year 23/24, for every dollar that was
subsidized by the City, WestWorld events generated about $540 dollars.
If the City's debt service contribution for WestWorld in fiscal year 23/24
is included, then WestWorld generated about $39 dollars for every
dollar subsidized by the City.
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
B-8. Estimated economic impact of WestWorld on the City of Scottsdale, 2024
TOTAL IMPACT SOURCE
Participant & Visitor Expenditures
STATE GDP EMPLOYMENT LABOR INCOME
(Millions $)^ (Job Years) * (Millions $)^
Event Organizer Expenditures
Westworld Employment & Operations
$116.1
$23.7
$23.8
1,350
292
Total Economic Impact $163.6
171
1,813
$58.5
$16.5
$10.6
Source:
Arizona State University Seidman Research Institute (2024), The Annual Economic
Impact of Westworld for the City of Scottsdale.
B-9. Estimated direct TPT revenue impact of WestWorld's annual events for the
City of Scottsdale, 2024
Equestrian Events (includinE Arabian Horse Shovy)
Non-Equestrian Events (including Barrett Jackson)
Scottsdale's State-Shared Allocation of TPT Revenues
Direct Tax Collections
(Millions $)
$0.7
$4.0
$0.1
Total Direct TPT Revenues
Source:
Arizona State University Seidman Research Institute (2024), The Annual Economic
Impact of Westworld for the City of Scottsdale.
APPENDIX B, PAGE 5
APPENDIX C. Summary of Relevant Plans — Introduction
This appendix provides a summary of plans and ordinances for the City
of Scottsdale that include or impact initiatives related to WestWorld
and events held at the venue. Information for each document is
presented as it was written at the time it was adopted.
Introduction
Keen Independent reviewed the following City plans and documents in
the development of the WestWorld Strategic Plan, presented in
chronological order:
■
City of Scottsdale General Plan 2035 (ratified by voters
in 2021);i
■
Scottsdale Tourism & Events Strategic Plan (2023);^ and
■
City of Scottsdale Organization Strategic Plan (2024).^
These documents collectively provide a foundation for strategic
direction, operational values and community aspirations that can
inform the vision and strategic direction of WestWorld.
^ City of Scottsdale General Plan 2035 (2021), Retrieved July 18, 2025 from
https://www.scottsdaleaz.gov/docs/default-source/scottsdaleaz/general-
plan/scottsdale-general-plan-2035—executive-summary.pdf?sfvrsn=d7021b0d_l
^ Scottsdale Tourism & Events Strategic Plan (2023), Retrieved July 18, 2025 from
https://www.scottsdaleaz.gov/docs/default-source/scottsdaleaz/tourism/tourism-
strategic-plan-2023.pdf?sfvrsn=f6d5424c_l
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
C-1. Horse sculpture at WestWorld
iitii
Sr^i.'
r-
fi.
wi
vm
la
mmrn
Source:
Keen Independent Research.
.li!:jimf
to’
a
I®
F?
3 2024 Organization Strategic Plan, Retrieved July 18, 2025 from
https://www.scottsdaleaz.gov/docs/default-source/scottsdaleaz/mayor-and-
council/organization-strategic-plan.pdf?sfvrsn=6daf39a6_7
APPENDIX C, PAGE 1
C. Summary of Relevant Plans — City of Scottsdale General Plan 2035
The General Plan 2035 is Scottsdale's principal long-range planning
document, establishing the City's vision and guiding policy and decision
making through 2035 regarding community character and design, land
use, open space and the natural environment, business and economic
development, community services, neighborhood vitality,
transportation and growth. Shaped by extensive community input and
ratified by voters, the plan is organized around core aspirations such as
experience, livability, prosperity and character, and outlines goals and
policies that provide a framework for development, revitalization and
resource stewardship.
The following elements of the General Plan 2035 could be applied to
strategic decision making at WestWorld:
■
General Plan vision regarding distinctive character. The
vision statement states that Scottsdale will respect and be
sensitive to its history and equestrian legacy. With WestWorld
serving as a premier equestrian facility, it continues to serve
as a resource for Scottsdale's equestrian community.
■
Goal CD 7. Honor Scottsdale's western and equestrian
lifestyle. Although elements of this goal specifically point to
development, land use and the Historic Old Town District,
WestWorld also contributes to this goal through its support of
equestrian events.
■
Goal ACC 2. Build on Scottsdale's reputation as the
regional leader and widely-recognized destination in arts,
culture and creativity. This goal includes an objective to
develop partnerships to build regional, national and
international tourism and cultural exchange programs.
WestWorld's size, visibility and flexibility can enhance
Scottsdale's role as a regional leader in arts, culture and
creativity through these partnerships.
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
C-2. Cover page of the City of Scottsdale General Plan 2035
CITY OF SCOTTSDALE
GENERAL PLAN 2035
Adopted by City Council on June 8. 2021 - Resolution No. 12177
Ratified by Scottsdale Citizens on November 2, 2021 - Proposition 463
Amended on November 21, 2022 to comply with House Bill 2482 • Resolution No. 12655
f.
• 1
iy,
/
ti!
ri
Source: City of Scottsdale.
APPENDIX C, PAGE 2
C. Summary of Relevant Plans — City of Scottsdale General Plan 2035
■
Goal T1. Strengthen Scottsdale's position as a premier
regional, national and international tourism and resort
destination. WestWorld strengthens Scottsdale's position as
a premier tourism and resort destination by serving as a
high-impact venue that draws regional, national and
international visitors through signature events. Its flexible
infrastructure, proximity to luxury resorts and ability to
support year-round programming position it as an ideal
partner in attracting diverse tourist segments. By expanding
its event portfolio to include more signature events and
enhancing premium visitor experiences, WestWorld
can amplify Scottsdale's brand, support resort industry
partnerships and contribute to the city's tourism economy and
international appeal.
■
Goal T 2. Enhance visitor and resident mobility,
accessibility and wayfinding. Community feedback about
WestWorld identified wayfinding and parking as areas of
improvement. Directly addressing this community feedback
would also be addressing this goal from the General Plan.
■
Goal T 3. Support and expand special events, spaces and
venues. This goal may be able to provide some guidance
when making decisions on which events to book when there
are conflicting date requests. This goal includes objectives
that involve:
>
Building and retaining sporting, western and
equestrian events;
>
Maximizing the potential of art and cultural events for
generating economic activity, including new, high-
quality signature festival events; and
>
Programming to attract residents and visitors.
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
C-3. Line of cars at Barrett-Jackson Car Auction
I
Source:
Keen Independent Research.
APPENDIX C, PAGE 3
C. Summary of Relevant Plans — Scottsdale Tourism & Events Strategic Plan
Commissioned by the City of Scottsdale in partnership with Experience
Scottsdale, the 2023 Tourism & Events Strategic Plan outlines a five-year
roadmap to advance Scottsdale's position as a premier travel and
events destination, it incorporates insights from resident and visitor
surveys, stakeholder interviews, market analyses and benchmarking
against peer destinations. The plan emphasizes sustainable tourism,
community well-being, destination branding, event development and
infrastructure investment.
The following elements of the Tourism & Events Strategic Plan could be
applied to strategic decisions for WestWorld:
■
Strategy FE.2. Improve and diversify WestWorld's hosting
capacities. This strategy indicates that performance metrics
for WestWorld should be more in line with performance
metrics of other convention and event facilities throughout
the nation, with a focus on hosting larger events that attract
attendees from a wider area and generate more room nights
in Scottsdale.
■
Strategy FE.l. Increase the positive impact of existing
events and attract new year-round events. This strategy
encourages the addition of a world-renowned indoor
signature event as well as focusing on events that increase
hotel stays, particularly during the summer. WestWorld is well
positioned to support this goal with its indoor event spaces.
■
Strategy PE.4. Position and market Scottsdale as a premier
luxury destination. This Pian emphasizes the importance of
aligning both the product and marketing with changing
consumer behaviors to anchor Scottsdale as a premier luxury
destination. This can be used to guide event booking decisions
at WestWorld when there are conflicting date requests.
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
C-4. Cover page of Scottsdale Tourism & Events Strategic Plan
trrsf?
^komwui i scViiisiViii
Scottsdale
Tourism & Events
Strategic Plan
i :
I
S
fa
r
%
Source:
City of Scottsdale.
APPENDIX C, PAGE 4
C. Summary of Relevant Plans — Scottsdale Tourism & Events Strategic Plan
Strategy CW.2. Focus on community quality of life. The
Plan states that monitoring resident perceptions and priorities
about tourism and its impact on quality of life is critical to
informing how Scottsdale is managed as a destination.
WestWorld can contribute to this monitoring when evaluating
programming and visitor experience, while also being mindful
of any comments from residents in the surrounding area.
Target audiences. The Plan identified four key target
audiences that have the greatest future market potential
for Scottsdale:
>
Active adventurers. Individuals with an interest in
outdoor sports, nature, health and fitness activities
fall within this category.
>
All-in enthusiasts. This inciudes visitors who are
interested in a wide variety of activities as they have
many different motivations for their travel and
vacations. Shopping, nightlife and attending events
are most preferred by All-in Enthusiasts compared to
other types of travelers.
>
Bleisure travel. Bleisure, or "business and leisure
travel," refers to travelers that extend work trips (i.e.,
conferences, meetings and staff retreats) to include
leisure time before or after the event.
>
Conferences and meetings. This includes individuals
visiting Scottsdale for professional-related events,
such as conferences and meetings.
When booking events with a focus on maximizing tourism,
WestWorld could consider these target audiences as potential
event attendees.
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
C-5. Temporary stage set up for Arizona Bike Week
r=rJ=5te-
''l'
I
^ i I
-I
I
I tj.ii ' .. j
i
I
T r-, i:l_t
__ 1^.
-;l
- -i-- M-J.
U
5,
■ T'
s
a
r
1
/I-
r
Source:
Keen Independent Research.
APPENDIX C, PAGES
C. Summary of Relevant Plans — City of Scottsdale Organization Strategic Plan
The City of Scottsdale's Organization Strategic Plan provides a tactical
roadmap for implementing the broader General Plan goals. Developed
by City leadership, this plan articulates the City's near-term priorities by
outlining detailed action items, responsible departments and timelines.
The plan is structured around key strategic goals, such as environmental
conservation, economic vitality, community engagement and cultural
preservation. Each section includes measurable outcomes and assigns
accountability to specific City divisions.
The goals from this plan that could be relevant to WestWorld
operations include:
■
F. Revitalize responsibly. Goals include managing noise and
neighborhood impacts, which are issues that intersect with
WestWorld's operations in terms of event impact on
surrounding areas.
■
G. Advance innovation and prosperity. Goal G2 calls to
"comprehensively market city-owned tourism and event
facilities," including WestWorld. Recommended actions
include enhancing the venue's digital presence, improving
brand awareness and strengthening venue visibility.
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
C-6. Lounge at the Arabian Horse Show
'At
m
Source:
Keen Independent Research.
APPENDIX C, PAGE 6
Appendix D. Community Feedback - Introduction and methodology
Keen Independent administered a survey for Scottsdale and
Phoenix-metro area community members, as well as WestWorld
patrons, to gather input for the WestWorld's Strategic Plan.
Distribution
The survey was promoted on WestWorld's social media, including
instagram and Facebook. The study team also conducted direct
outreach to community groups, such as car enthusiasts, equestrian
enthusiasts and Scottsdale homeowner associations. The survey was
open from January 25 to May 31, 2025.
The study team also developed an abbreviated version of the survey to
collect intercept responses from attendees to the Barrett-Jackson
Car Auction and Arabian Horse Show at WestWorld. A QR code linking
to the survey was displayed on A-frame signs at these WestWorld
events. Respondents were given a matchbox car as a thank you for
their participation.
Additionally, Keen Independent gathered feedback from WestWorld
facility staff and City of Scottsdale employees about their experiences at
the facility. Their feedback to questions that aligned with the
community and patron-focused survey is also included in this appendix.
Participation
In total, this survey collected 599 responses. The survey for facility
staff members and City of Scottsdale employees collected 31 total
responses. All questions asked in these surveys were optional. Both
completed and partial surveys are included in the analysis, as many
partial responses contained substantive feedback.
Quotes from Participants
Selected quotes are included in this appendix to illustrate themes the
study team found during analysis of survey participant input.
Participants were informed that their responses would be analyzed in
aggregate and that no individually identifying information would be
reported. Quotes are attributed in a non-individualiy identifying
manner, such as "Scottsdale resident" or "Out-of-town visitor."
Topics
The survey analysis in this appendix reflects the perspectives of
approximately 600 respondents and is organized by the following topics:
Introduction and methodology;
Demographics;
Affiliations and residencies;
Reasons for not visiting;
Recent attendee experiences;
Facility feedback;
Opportunities for success; and
Preferences and priorities.
Online Reviews
Keen Independent also analyzed Google reviews posted between
April 15, 2024 to April 15, 2025 to gather additional insights into visitor
experiences and perceptions of WestWorld.
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
APPENDIX D, PAGE 1
D. Community Feedback ~ Demographics
Keen Independent examined the survey participants' demographic
information, including race, ethnicity, gender, age, residency and
affiliation with WestWorld.
Race and Ethnicity
Figure D-1 shows the race and ethnicity of survey participants. Of the
survey participants who responded about their race and ethnicity,
73 percent identified as white, 6 percent identified as Hispanic or Latino
and 6 percent identified as two or more races.
D-1. Race and ethnicity of survey participants
Other race (1%)
American Indian and
\
Alaskan Native (1%!^
\
African American {1%_
Asian (1%)
Two or more races
(6%)
Hispanic or Latino (6%),
Prefer not to answer
(10%)
White
(73%)
Note; N=503. Participants could also select Native Hawaiian/Pacific Islander as a response.
Source:
Keen Independent Research.
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
APPENDIX D, PAGE 2
D. Community Feedback - Demographics
Gender
Figure D-2 shows that nearly three-quarters of participants identified
as female (73%) and almost one-fifth identified as male (19%). The
remaining participants either preferred not to answer (7%) or chose
non-binary (1%).
D-2. Gender of survey participants
Non-binary
(1%)
Prefer not to answer (7%)
Male
(19%)
Note:
Source:
Female
(73%)
N=503.
Keen Independent Research.
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
APPENDIX D, PAGE 3
D. Community Feedback - Demographics
Age
Figure D-3 depicts the ages of individuals who completed the survey.
Survey participants represented a broad age range. Just over 60 percent
were between the ages of 35 and 64, with the largest group (22%) In the
45 to 54 age bracket. An additional 13 percent were ages 25 to 34, and
14 percent were 65 or older.
Household Ages
Respondents reported a range of household age groups (Figure D-4).
Twenty-five percent indicated that their household includes a person 12
or younger, and the same percentage reported a household member
age 45 to 54. Just under 25 percent reported having someone 35 to 44
or 55 to 64 in their household. Nine percent indicated that they were
the sole member of their household.
D-3. Age of survey participants
75 +
1%)
Prefer not to answer Younger than 18
(!%> X (3%)
/
^18 to 24 (5%)
25 to 34
(13%)
55 to 64
(21%)
65 to 74
(13%).
35 to 44
(21%)
45 to 54
(22%)
Note:
N=505.
Source:
Keen Independent Research.
D-4. Reported ages of other members of survey participants' household
30%
25%
21% - 22%
25%
20%
16% 16%
15%
14%
9%
10% -
4%
3%
0%
^
7?*
(b^
>0* ^ A
Note:
N=494. Participants could select more than one answer.
Source:
Keen Independent Research.
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
APPENDIX D, PAGE 4
D. Community Feedback - Demographics
Other Demographic Identifiers
Keen Independent invited survey participants to share any additional
demographic identifiers that could help the study team better
understand their experiences or those of other members of their
household. A total of 121 participants provided additional identifiers,
including disability status, veteran/military status, LGBTQ+ identity,
bilingual/multilingual ability or other categories. Respondents
could select multiple options. Figure D-5 shows the demographic
self-identification of respondents.
D-5. Demographic self-identification of survey participants or their household
members
Other demographic identifiers
Veteran/military
Disability status
Bilingual/multilingual
LGBTQ-h
Other
Number of
responses Percent
57
28
20
19
5
28
11
8
8
2
%
Note; N=253. Prefer not to answer Is excluded. Participants could select more than
one answer.
Source:
Keen Independent Research.
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
APPENDIX D, PAGE 5
D. Community Feedback -Affiliations and residencies
Survey participants were asked to share information about their
interests, residency and affiliation with WestWorld.
Residency and Interests
Survey participants shared information about their WestWorld-related
interests and residencies (Figure D-6). For interests, most survey
participants identified as equestrian enthusiasts, while a quarter of
respondents identified as outdoor or rodeo enthusiasts. Just under
100 participants identified as athletes or car enthusiasts.
About half of participants identified as Phoenix metro area residents
and about one-quarter of identified as City of Scottsdale residents. Four
respondents identified as both Scottdale residents and Phoenix metro
area residents. Seventy respondents identified as out-of-town visitors,
with 34 residing elsewhere in Arizona and 34 visiting from out of state.
These data indicate that most perspectives in this appendix come from
Phoenix and Scottsdale residents (73%), and from individuals with
interests in equestrian and/or rodeo disciplines (92%).
D-6. Participant residency and relevant interests
am a/an...
Equestrian enthusiast
Phoenix metro area resident
Outdoor enthusiast
City of Scottsdale resident
Rodeo enthusiast
Business owner
Athlete
Car enthusiast
Out-of-town visitor
Artist or creative
None of the above
Number of
responses Percent
405
279
157
154
143
107
99
84
70
38
5
68 %
47
26
26
24
18
17
14
12
6
1
Note:
N=595. Participants couid seiect more than one answer.
Source:
Keen independent Research.
KEEN iNDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGiC PLAN
APPENDIX D, PAGE 6
D. Community Feedback-Affiliations and residencies
ZIP Code Mapping
ZIP Code data was used to develop a heat map of respondent locations.
Figure D-7 depicts participants who live in Arizona, as well as those
concentrated in the Phoenix metro area. This map shows that
WestWorld attracts participants from across Arizona, but most
respondents live in or near Scottsdale.
D-7. Reported location of survey participants
Fl.igs'.aff
m-
inn
Pre■cott^
* Arizona
I
''?r’
7
- • .
fm
•1
1
fr
1.
A
El
■
\h^
:? y.
.. -1
,1
Fountain Hills
I
; Surprise ^
Giendale
Goodyear
Tij''.'on»
ib
% ^
%■
Eitrella
-Phoenixj^
Parad.se ^
^
. r r ,
___
^ ~
« !::• j . Tj
Mesa ^
t .. -
t
Number of survey participants
1
I . .
'Jogales
't
Agua Pr
Gila Crossing
Apache
^ j Junction
Gilbert ■
‘
J\
f ^
Uceen Cr ek
-C : 9
v;-
\
{
j
!«■
^San Ian valley
•a
1
Note:
N=586.
Source:
Tableau, Keen Independent Research.
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
APPENDIX D, PAGE?
D. Community Feedback-Affiliations and residencies
Affiliation with WestWorld
Figure D-8 depicts survey participants' affiliations with WestWorld.
Three-quarters reported attending events at the venue and about half
were exhibitors or performers at WestWorld. Ten percent of
respondents said that they had no affiliation with WestWorld.
D-8. Survey participants reported affiliations with WestWorld
Affiliation with WestWorld
Number of
responses Percent
WestWorld event attendee
WestWorld event exhibitor or performer
WestWorld contractor or vendor
City of Scottsdale employee
(not at WestWorld)
Other
No affiliation to WestWorld
Note:
N=517. Participants could select more than one answer.
Source:
Keen Independent Research.
400
256
21
5
13
51
77
47
4
1
5
10
%
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
APPENDIX D, PAGE 8
D. Community Feedback - Affiliations and residencies
Most Recent Attendance to WestWorld
Nearly three-quarters of survey respondents had visited WestWorld
within the past three months, while 20 percent had visited within the
last two years. Figure D-9 shows all attendance shared by survey
participants.
With more than 90 percent of survey respondents having visited
WestWorld within the last two years, most of the feedback shared in
this appendix reflects recent experiences at the venue. It is also possible
that individuals with more recent visits were more likely to complete
the survey.
D-9. Participants most recent attendance to WestWorld
More than 5 years agi
(3%)
Between 2 and
5 years ago
(2%)
Within the
past two yearSj
(20%)
Never visited WestWorld
(4%)
ithin the past
three months
(71%)
Note:
N=599.
Source:
Keen Independent Research.
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
APPENDIX D, PAGE 9
D. Community Feedback - Reasons for not visiting
Survey respondents who had not visited WestWorld within the past two
years were asked why they had not visited recently and what might
encourage them to visit in the future.
Reasons For Not Visiting WestWorld
As depicted in Figure D-10, among respondents who had not visited
WestWorld within the last two years, the most commonly reported
reasons were lack of information or awareness (36%) and distance from
the venue (32%). Other common barriers to visitation included lack of
time (21%) and disinterest in WestWorld's events (15%) or camping
services (11%).
Encouraging Future Visitation
When asked what might encourage future visits to WestWorld, most of
the thirty-two respondents elaborated on the events that they would
like to attend. Many participants called for additional equestrian events,
while others also suggested expanding to include more car shows, dog
events, markets, festivals or concerts. Six respondents indicated that
WestWorld could be doing better advertising, and four respondents said
that WestWorld should be more affordable.
D-10. Reasons for not visiting WestWorld
Lack of information or awareness
I live too far away from WestWorld
Lack of time
Not interested in
WestWorld's events
Not interested in WestWorld's
RV/camping services
I find WestWorld inaccessible
Lack of childcare or
family assistance
WestWorld Is difficult to get to
Other
Note:
N=47. Participants could select more than one answer.
Source:
Keen Independent Research.
36%
32%
21%
15%
11%
4%
2%
2%
11%
10%
20%
30%
40%
Host more of the smaller shows and horse events.
Out-of-town visitor
Hold dog events the way they used to.
More information/advertising.
Be open and financially accessible.
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
Phoenix metro-area resident
Phoenix metro-area resident
Out-of-town visitor
APPENDIX D, PAGE 10
D. Community Feedback - Recent attendee experiences
Survey participants who reported visiting WestWorld within the last
two years were asked a series of questions about their experiences
recently attending events at WestWorld.
Recently Attended Events
When asked what events participants had recently attended, the
majority of respondents (90%) reported that they had attended an
equestrian event. Just under half of respondents reported having
attended a trade show or expo or a rodeo event. Figure D-11 shows the
full range of events that recent participants reported that they attended
at WestWorld.
100%
-1 90%
80%
- H
60%
- H
■
44%
42%
40%
- H III H
20%
- I
I 12%
/ / / </ /
cO
Note:
N=474. Participants could select more than one answer.
Source:
Keen Independent Research.
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
APPENDIX D, PAGE 11
D. Community Feedback - Recent attendee experiences
Overall Experience
Figure D-12 shows that over three-quarters of recent attendees
reported a somewhat positive to extremely positive experience
at WestWorld.
Net rating. Using a modified Net Promoter Score framework, responses
were condensed by excluding the neutral option and categorizing the
remaining responses into positive or negative sentiments. The net rating
is calculated by subtracting the percentage of negative sentiments from
positive sentiments. This scoring method provides a clear measure of
overall agreement or disagreement to a statement. In the
accompanying graphs, a positive net rating indicates a higher proportion
of positive responses, while a negative net rating indicates greater levels
of disagreement. Figure D-13 shows the net score for overall experience
at WestWorld is 76.
While a net score of 76 is strong, WestWorld could consider tracking
this rating as a key performance indicator to monitor future changes in
this score.
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
D-12. Survey participant overall experience ratings
Overall experience at
WestWorld
7%
43%
0%
25%
50%
75%
100%
■ Extremely negative
Somewhat positive
Note:
Negative
Postive
I Neutral
Somewhat negative
■ Extremely positive
N=506. Percentages are rounded to the nearest whole number and therefore may not
sum to 100. Includes responses from facility staff and City employees.
Source:
Keen Independent Research.
D-13. Survey participant overall experience rating net score
Overall experience at
WestWorld
100%
75%
50%
25%
0%
25%
50%
75%
100%
H Negative (somewhat to extremely) ■ Positive (somewhat to extremely)
Note:
N=506. Includes responses from facility staff and City employees.
Source:
Keen Independent Research.
84%
APPENDIX D, PAGE 12
D. Community Feedback - Recent attendee experiences
Age-specific Experience
Survey participants were asked to rate the overall experience of events
for specific age groups. Figure D-14 shows all responses along a
seven-point scale ranging from "extremely negative" to "extremely
positive." Participants reported events being most positive for adults
ages 45 to 64 and ages 25 to 44, with over 80 percent of responses
being "extremely positive," "positive" or "somewhat positive." All age
groups received at least 70 percent of positive-leaning responses.
D-14. Age-specific experiences
4%
4%|
7%
9%
45%
,
43%
"1
33%
8%
f
S'.
Ij. 7% I 12% I 11%
10%
k-''.
42%
40%
28%
’ St
38%
Adults, ages 45 to 64
Adults, ages 25 to 44
Young adults, ages 18 to 24
Adults, ages 65 and over
Teens, ages 13 to 17
Children, ages 12 and under
0%
25%
50%
75%
100%
■ Extremely negative Negative Somewhat negative ■ Neutral Somewhat positive Positive ■ Extremely positive
Note:
N=327-437. NA or I Don't Know responses are excluded. Percentages are rounded to the
nearest whole number and therefore may not sum to 100, Includes responses from
facility staff and City employees.
Source:
Keen Independent Research.
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
3%|
8% mm :
39%
APPENDIX D, PAGE 13
D. Community Feedback - Recent attendee experiences
Net rating. Figure D-15 highlights the net rating for the same
age-specific experience questions as Figure D-14. The overall experience
net rating was highest for adults ages 45 to 64 and 25 to 44, with ratings
of 80 and 79 respectively. The overall experience rating was lowest for
children ages 12 and under, with a rating of 65.
D-15. Age-specific experience net ratings
Adults, ages 45 to 64
Adults, ages 25 to 44
Young adults, ages 18 to 24
Adults, ages 65 and over
Teens, ages 13 to 17
Children, ages 12 and under
85%
5%
Net
80
6%
85%
79
6%
79%
73
10%
79%
69
74%
5%
69
71%
6%
65
100%
75%
50%
25%
0%
25%
50%
75%
100%
■ Negative (somewhat to extremely) ■ Positive (somewhat to extremely)
Note; N=327-437. NA or I Don't Know responses are excluded. The net rating is calculated by
subtracting the sum of the "strongly negative," "negative," and "somewhat negative"
responses from the sum of the participants who said "extremely positive," "positive,"
and "somewhat positive." Includes responses from facility staff and City employees.
Source:
Keen Independent Research
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
APPENDIX D, PAGE 14
D. Community Feedback - Recent attendee experiences
Inclusivity
Recent WestWorld attendees were asked about their level of
agreement with the statement, "As a venue, WestWorld is inclusive and
fosters belonging for people from a wide range of demographic groups."
WestWorld staff and City of Scottsdale employees were asked to
respond to the statement, "As a venue, WestWorld is welcoming for
people from a wide range of demographic groups." Figure D-16 shows
that over half of respondents (66%) slightly to strongly agreed that
WestWorld is inclusive and fosters belonging. About one quarter of
respondents were neutral on this topic.
Net rating. Figure D-17 shows that WestWorld has an inclusivity net
rating of 55. Respondents' reasons for viewing WestWorld as inclusive
or not inclusive are detailed on the following page.
D-16. Survey participant inclusivity agreement
WestWorld is welcoming,
inclusive and fosters
belonging for people from
a wide range of
demographic groups.
IlMe6%E^2%’
9% t
34%
23%
0%
25%
50%
75%
100%
■ Strongly disagree Disagree Slightly disagree s Neutral Slightly agree ' Agree ■ Strongly agree
Note:
N=463. NA or I Don't Know responses are excluded. Percentages are rounded to the
nearest whole number and therefore may not sum to 100. Includes responses from
facility staff and City employees.
Source:
Keen Independent Research.
D-17. Survey participant inclusivity agreement net score
Net
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
WestWorld Is welcoming, inclusive and
fosters belonging for people from a wide
range of demographic groups.
11%
66%
100% 75% 50% 25% 0% 25% 50% 75% 100%
■ Disagree (slightly to strongly) ■ Agree (slightly to strongly)
Note:
N=463. NA or I Don't Know responses are excluded. The net rating is calculated by
subtracting the sum of the "strongly disagree," "disagree," and "slightly disagree"
responses from the sum of the participants who "strongly agree," "agree," and
"slightly agree." Includes responses from facility staff and City employees.
Source:
Keen Independent Research.
APPENDIX D, PAGE 15
D. Community Feedback - Recent attendee experiences
How WestWorld is inclusive. Respondents who shared reasons as to
why WestWorld is inclusive defined inclusivity in various ways. Many
indicated that they thought of WestWorld as welcoming to a range of
ages and backgrounds, as well as aficionados of different event
activities. They also talked about the diversity of events that WestWorld
offers and how that attracts people from different walks of life.
Several respondents shared that WestWorld is ADA accessible and easy
to get around. Other respondents described inclusivity in terms of
WestWorld being a public place that anyone is welcome to attend if
they so desire.
How WestWorld is exclusive. Respondents who viewed WestWorld as
not inclusive reported economically inaccessibility for exhibitors,
performers and spectators. Some respondents said WestWorld
prioritizes larger, high-revenue events like Barrett-Jackson over smaller
groups, especially smaller equestrian organizations.
Respondents also stated that the price to attend an event is expensive,
particularly the parking and concessions. Some equestrian enthusiasts
indicated that WestWorld is not meant to be inclusive, as it should be
prioritizing the equestrian events that the facility was designed to
showcase. Several respondents reported that WestWorld events cater
to a white and wealthy crowd.
A few noted that WestWorld could be more physically accessible to
people with disabilities and older audiences, such as adding seating and
shade, as well as limiting distance walking.
All the events I've attended at WestWorld have been inclusive
regardless of age, race, gender or disability.
Out-of-town visitor
At the horse shows, there are people from many different cultural
and economic backgrounds.
Out-of-town visitor
ADA accommodations .seem to he very present from parking to inside
the Equidome.
Phoenix metro-area resident
[The] public is welcome. [The] public is diverse.
Scottsdale resident
WestWorld has become punitive in its policies towards equine events.
It's clear that only big dollar events are welcome.
Phoenix metro-area resident
I don't view WestWorld as meant to be inclusive of all, but rather
built to accommodate and host equine events at its core.
Equestrian enthusiast
The biggest events have a conservative / white majority vibe
(i.e. Barret- Jackson, Arabian Show, RV&Boat & Home shows).
Phoenix metro-area resident
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
Seating could be improved to accommodate those with disabilities.
Scottsdale resident
APPENDIX D, PAGE 16
D. Community Feedback - WestWorld strengths and areas for improvement
Survey participants offered positive and constructive feedback about
the WestWorld facility and programming.
Strengths
Survey participants were asked to share their thoughts on WestWorld's
greatest strengths.
Facilities and their amenities. Many survey respondents stated that
WestWorld's facilities and associated amenities were their greatest
strength. Most echoed that the facilities are excellent for equestrian
purposes, including the stables, barns and covered arenas. Participants
indicated that they appreciated that there were both indoor and
outdoor facilities and that the indoor area is climate controlled.
Respondents also reported that the facilities are flexible for many
different kinds of events.
Venue size. Many survey respondents remarked on the large size of the
WestWorld venue. They stated that the venue's expansive space allows
for big events, and it can accommodate multiple types of events
concurrently. Respondents noted that the venue does not feel too
crowded because of its size. Although it is a large venue, some
respondents added that WestWorld is walkable and easy to navigate.
Venue location. Survey respondents indicated that WestWorld's
location is one of its greatest strengths. Participants described the
facility's location as convenient, with easy highway access and its
proximity to metropolitan areas.
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
The facilities for equestrian events are world class.
Phoenix metro-area resident
Very good stabling; Covered arenas permit shows to go on in the
rain; Air-conditioning in the indoor spaces permit shows to he held
even in summer.
Equestrian enthusiast
[There is] infrastructure with [the] ability to host lots of people and
horses. [They have] convertible buildings that can host
different events.
Scottsdale resident
[WestWorld is] a well laid-out facility with plenty of room for
parking, exhibitors and spectators.
Phoenix metro-area resident
[WestWorld has] the room to attract and host all kinds of equestrian
events and big equestiian names worldwide (if it so desired!).
Scottsdale resident
The facility/grounds itself are not hard to manage or walk around.
Scottsdale resident
The location is fantastic for all types of events and for visitors to
enjoy our local shopping and dining.
Phoenix metro-area resident
Its incredible location with the McDowell Mountains as a backdrop.
It is easy to find [and] close to major roadways.
Phoenix metro-area resident
APPENDIX D, PAGE 17
D. Community Feedback - WestWorld strengths and areas for improvement
Event offerings. Survey participants indicated that they appreciated
WestWorld's events. Some said that the facility offers a diverse range of
programming, while others specifically discussed WestWorld's
horse-related programming, including equestrian and rodeo shows.
Cleanliness and grounds maintenance. Survey respondents remarked
that the WestWorld facility is clean and overall well-maintained. Some
respondents specifically noted clean restrooms.
Parking. Some respondents indicated that they appreciated not having
to worry about parking when attending WestWorld events. They said
that parking at WestWorld is expansive and having onsite RV hook-ups
is especially useful for horse shows.
[WestWorld] has a wide range of activities for all.
Phoenix metro-area resident
The horse shows have great competition and are some of the best in
the state.
Out-of-town visitor
[WestWorld has] large, clean facilities and well-kept arenas.
Equestrian enthusiast
[WestWorld has] gorgeous arenas [and]prompt and excellent
groundskeeping for horse shows.
Phoenix metro-area resident
Beautiful grounds.
Out-of-town visitor
RV parking for horse shows.
Easy parking.
Phoenix metro-area resident
Scottsdale resident
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
APPENDIX D, PAGE 18
D. Community Feedback - WestWorld strengths and areas for improvement
Community. Some respondents talked about community being a
strength of WestWorld. Participants indicated that they liked that
WestWorld is a local gathering place that hosts unique events. Some
described the venue as welcoming, friendly and family-oriented. Other
respondents said that WestWorld is supportive of the equestrian
community, culture and history. A few respondents reported that
WestWorld supports the economic well-being of the
surrounding community.
Staff and venue management. Some survey respondents said that
WestWorld's staff and management are a great strength. These
individuals described events being well-organized and responsive to
exhibitors. They also noted that the maintenance team does a great job.
[WestWorld’s] ability to bring together the community and host
many events.
Phoenix metro-area resident
Westworld has always provided an opportunity for people to gather
and experience events they may not normally attend.
Phoenix metro-area resident
[WestWorld’s] ability to hold any equestrian event and bring people
fi-om around the world to our state just through horses.
Phoenix metro-area resident
Events seem to be well-planned out and ran efficiently.
Phoenix metro-area resident
People within [WestWorld are] really nice and helpful.
Phoenix metro-area resident
Feels well-managed.
Scottsdale resident
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
APPENDIX D, PAGE 19
D. Community Feedback - WestWorld strengths and areas for improvement
Areas for Improvement
Survey participants were asked to share their thoughts on WestWorld's
greatest areas for improvement.
Commitment to the equestrian community. When asked about areas
for improvement, some respondents called for a stronger commitment
to horse-related programming, including equestrian and rodeo events.
As a facility specifically designed to host these types of events,
participants stated that WestWorld has over time made it harder for
smaller equestrian events to book at the venue due to cost and date
availability. Respondents also expressed interest in more variety in
equestrian events, such as more dressage and hunter/jumper events.
Some respondents indicated that equestrian programming should be
the venue's highest priority.
Improved footing. Equestrian enthusiasts discussed issues with arena
footing. Some respondents reported that the footing is too slick and too
hard for many equestrian disciplines to compete. Respondents
reiterated that this is dangerous for the horses and riders and suggested
that inadequate footing keeps the venue from hosting large-scale
hunter/jumper or rodeo events. Some participants reported that out-of-
state competitors are no longer attending events due to this issue.
Affordability. Survey participants stated that overall affordability
should be an area for improvement for WestWorld. Some respondents
suggested lowering ticket and concession prices. Others reported that
they wanted more affordable options for exhibitors to hold or take part
in events, and they suggested different tiers of pricing for local or
smaller organizations hoping to use WestWorld. Some participants
reported that they were against the requirement for equestrian
exhibitors to buy shavings from the venue. Several participants
described a perception that WestWorld prioritizes large,
revenue-generating events over smaller organizations.
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
Encourage and support the horse community to make these events
the priority, since this is what Westworld was created for.
Phoenix metro-area resident
Working with smaller equestrian associations to keep pricing and
availability affordable.
Equestrian enthusiast
Provide more opportunities for hunter jumper events so folks can
show locally and not have to travel to CA.
Phoenix metro-area resident
The footing for horses is often dangerously slick.
Out-of-town visitor
For hunter/jumper horses, the footing in the rings is too hard [and]
requires too much water to be safe and comfortable for horses.
Scottsdale resident
To attract high-end equine events that are just not western-focused,
people will only bring their expensive horses if the footing will not
create injuries for [their] very expensive horses.
Scottsdale resident
[WestWorld] needs to lower the co.st to put on and attend events.
Phoenix metro-area resident
Having food and alcohol catered through Westworld, and at a hefty
price tag at that, has limited clubs’ability to have fun community
events. The costs of hosting have also continued to go up ....
Scottsdale resident
APPENDIX D, PAGE 20
D. Community Feedback - WestWorld strengths and areas for improvement
Parking and wayfinding. Survey participants stated that they
recommend upgrades to parking, traffic flow and wayfinding. Some
reported that they want the parking lot to be paved so that it is easier
for driving and walking. They noted that paving would also create less
dust and improve the cleanliness of the venue. There were a few
suggestions for taxi or transportation services within the parking lot to
improve accessibility. Others indicated that they want WestWorld to
provide better wayfinding, including support for traffic flow at big
events and more signage for walking around the venue. Improved
signage and traffic support may be especially useful when multiple
events occur simultaneously.
Landscaping and shade. Participants suggested more landscaping to
improve the venue's appearance and provide additional shade for
attendees, which is particularly important in the summer heat. Some
participants said that the WestWorld facility looks desolate compared to
other equestrian areas they have visited.
Food and beverage. Participants said that WestWorld could improve
their food and beverage quality. Respondents requested more food
vendor options, including healthier and locally sourced choices. Some
respondents also suggested that the expense of food and beverage
options is prohibitive to small groups holding events at the venue.
Trailer parking lot is full of huge pot holes and difficult to maneuver.
Out-of-town visitor
Too many rocks and [unsteady] ground for [the] disabled, elderly or
young [to walk].
Scottsdale resident
Finding one's way around the property and knowing where things
are happening is sometimes confusing.
Scottsdale resident
The [WestWorld] spaces are functional, but visually appealing shades
and gates would provide more "photo-ready" opportunities.
Equestrian enthusiast
The facility, as a whole, has the look of an abandoned car lot.
Vast, empty and ugly.
Equestrian enthusiast
It [was] still quite hot out [and] the arena didn't offer any seating or
shade and we had young children and elderly in attendance.
Equestrian enthusiast
[Better]food vendors (variety, price, and quality).
Phoenix metro-area resident
Stop holding people hostage to buy your lousy food and
overpriced drinks.
Scottsdaie resident
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
APPENDIX D, PAGE 21
D. Community Feedback - WestWorld strengths and areas for improvement
Variety of events. Some participants provided feedback on events
held at WestWorld. Respondents indicated that they wanted more
community-focused events, such as events that highlight local groups
or child-friendly events. Respondents indicated interest in more
animal-focused events, such as equestrian and canine competitions.
Some respondents suggested that WestWorld do more arts and culture
events, while other respondents stated that WestWorld should host
more events in general.
Additional facility upgrades. Participants suggested several other
types of facility upgrades and modernizations that would be helpful to
have at the venue. Some respondents talked about adding permanent
barns and stalls. They also stated that more of the equestrian spaces
should be climate controlled, and a few indicated that there should be
better drainage around the stables and arenas. Other respondents
suggested upgrades that would create a better spectator experience,
such as more comfortable seating, restrooms (including family-friendly
ones) and RV hook-ups. Respondents said that accessibility could be
improved through ADA design considerations. They stated that greater
safety could be improved with additional security and lighting around
the venue.
Advertising. Some survey participants stated that WestWorld could do
a better job publicizing their events. Some participants found the
website to be confusing to understand, and others said that WestWorld
could have a stronger social media presence on sites such as Instagram
and TikTok. Other participants added that event signage, such as street
signs or billboards, in the local community could also bring attention to
venue events.
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
Get morefamily-friendly events and rodeos.
Phoenix metro-area resident
More equestrian events and canine competitions.
Scottsdale resident
More bams so horses are not stalled on tar in temporary stabling.
Better drainage in the arenas.
Out-of-town visitor
Need more comfortable seats in arenas.
Scottsdale resident
ADA port-a-pots and raised platform so wheelchair users can see.
Athlete
More security for parked vehicles. I had a purse stolen while I was
showing my horse in 2023.
Scottsdale resident
More local advertising of events.
Phoenix metro-area resident
I think Westworld could have a much better website that is more
helpful to show the schedule of events and details of those events. I
also think that social media should be updated as each event is there
and link to the individual website.
Scottsdale resident
APPENDIX D, PAGE 22
D. Community Feedback - Opportunities for success
Survey participants shared some visions for \A/hat future success might
look like for WestWorld.
Perceptions of Success for WestWorld
When asked how to describe future success for WestWorld, survey
participants shared the following ideas.
Equestrian-centric venue. Over half of participants echoed that the
future of WestWorld prioritizes horses. Participants indicated that they
hoped to see more equestrian and rodeo events that align with
WestWorld's original purpose and capitalize on its horse-focused
facilities. Participants also indicated that facility upgrades, such as
improved footing, could make WestWorld a premier equine venue.
Participants indicated hope that WestWorld expands its equine
offerings to include more dressage and hunter/jumper events. They also
indicated that they desire for WestWorld to collaborate more closely
with the equine community to become more welcoming and affordable
for smaller equestrian groups to host events at the venue.
Event variety with a community focus. Participants stated that they
have a desire for WestWorld to continue hosting a multitude and
variety of events and activities at their facility. In addition to horse-
related events, they expressed interest in events that showcase cars,
dogs, outdoor activities, expos, festivals and RV shows. Participants said
events should be fun, entertaining, engaging, community-oriented and
family-friendly so that there is something for everyone to enjoy at
WestWorld. Some participants said that WestWorld's future should be
creating value for local citizens.
Westworld has evolved over the decades to meet the needs of the
greater equestrian community and Arizona. Continue to host notable
equestrian events, and recruit new events. That is the legacy of
Westworld and should be its future.
Equestrian enthusiast
Horse enthusiasts have very few options for exhibiting in this region.
Please consider providing budget-friendly facilities available for
smaller equestrian events as they are the tributaries to the larger,
more financially lucrative, equestrian spectacles.
Rodeo enthusiast
WestWorld should have the ability to attract people the way big horse
shows and large events do in other states.
Scottsdale resident
WestWorld should continue to host the many wonderful equestrian
events along with shows like Barrett-Jackson, Junk in the Trunk,
Home Shows and other events along this line. When these events are
well done, it makes me check my calendar regularly to see "What's
happening at WestWorld" this week.
Phoenix metro-area enthusiast
Future success at We.stWorld looks like family, Arizona residents, and
out-of-state visitors coming together, to enjoy together.
Scottsdale resident
Unique venue that embraces and showcases Arizona's diverse culture
with distinct activities, such as equestrian events and activities,
agricultural events, car shows, athletic events, musical events and
other community events as desired by Arizonans.
Phoenix metro-area resident
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
APPENDIX D, PAGE 23
D. Community Feedback - Opportunities for success
Financially accessible. Survey participants indicated that they have
hope that WestWorld will become more financially accessible for
exhibitors, especially smaller equestrian organizations. They also
expressed that greater financial accessibility for spectators attending
events at WestWorld could be achieved by lowering ticket and
concession prices.
Economically impactful. Survey participants expressed that they have
a desire for WestWorld to continue to be a revenue-generating venue
that attracts tourists from across the country. They noted that tourism
supports events and benefits local business. A few participants
suggested renting meeting spaces in the venue when they are not being
used for events to generate additional revenue.
Safe and accessible. Survey participants indicated that WestWorld
should prioritize safety and accessibility in the future. They specified
wanting greater venue access and event visibility for people with
disabilities, as well as making the venue more user friendly and safe.
Provide an equestrian facility that is financially attractive to all
groups and clubs, particularly those located in Arizona.
Phoenix metro-area resident
Affordable entrance fees allowing more people to attend. Reduce or
eliminate paid parking to alleviate the overall attendee cost.
Scottsdaie resident
Events that have a positive economic impact on the local economy.
Scottsdale resident
Highlights the city and brings in revenue and fun!
Scottsdale resident
Arizona has an opportunity to compete with the California equestrian
ch'cuit and bring in bright competitors and big tourism.
Out-of-town visitor
Allow more [ADA] areas, access and visibility.
Clean & safe premises.
Scottsdale resident
Equestrian enthusiast
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
APPENDIX D, PAGE 24
D. Community Feedback - Opportunities for success
Favorable parking. Survey participants stated that WestWorld should
have free and accessible parking options, as well as improved traffic
flow. Suggestions included implementing a shuttle service, upgrading
roads and offering parking passes.
Landscaping and shade. Participants expressed a desire for WestWorld
to improve the beautification of the venue by adding additional
landscaping and greenery around the venue. Additional trees and
shaded areas were cited as key to improving the spectator experience
throughout the year, particularly in warmer months.
Quality vendors. Survey participants recommended expanding and
improving WestWorld's food and beverage offerings at the venue. They
indicated that WestWorld could consider a greater variety of vendors
that would provide tasty, healthy and novel food options. Other
participants suggested allowing people to bring in their own food,
especially if they were hosting an event.
Well-advertised. Survey participants said that future success depends
on stronger advertising and communication about upcoming events.
Participants stated that the website could have current events and a
calendar view, and that WestWorld should have a greater social media
presence and more signage in the community about upcoming events.
Suggestions included seeking corporate sponsors, partnering with
school districts to reach families and promoting events through equine
association email lists.
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
You shouldn't charge for pm-king. It's an unnecessary barrier to
participation and limits the impact of the events you hold. It may also
prevent some events from happening.
Scottsdale resident
Improved traffic flow and parking for large events.
Scottsdale resident
I think improved landscape ... would be positive.
Scottsdale resident
Outdoor garden and seating areas to enhance the entrance and
surrounding areas. Trees with pathways, murals, and community
engagement spaces.
Scottsdale resident
Allow other food vendors to come in. Allow people to hold barn
parties with food and alcohol.
Scottsdale resident
The selection of food and drink is overpriced and ofsubpar quality.
Phoenix metro-area resident
Better event advertising, I never go because I don't know what's
happening there.
Scottsdale resident
[Advertising]family events through the school district would be one
great way to reach local families.
Scottsdale resident
APPENDIX D, PAGE 25
D. Community Feedback - Preferences and priorities
Survey participants provided their perceptions of how WestWorld
should prioritize sources of support.
Residents' Perceptions of the Funding Priorities
Figure D-18 presents Scottsdale residents' responses to statements
about how WestWorld should be supported financially using a
seven-point agreement scale ranging from "strongly disagree" to
"strongly agree."
Three-quarters of Scottsdale residents slightly to strongly agreed that
WestWorld should prioritize developing private sources of support to
supplement City support.
Just over half of Scottsdale residents supported the City identifying
sustainable sources of public funding for WestWorld. Almost 30 percent
of residents were neutral about this statement.
Net rating. Figure D-19 shows the net rating for the funding statements
described in Figure D-18. A net rating of 71 indicates that most
respondents agreed with WestWorld developing private sources of
support, such as sponsorships. With a net rating of 49, respondents
were not as positive toward the City prioritizing sustainable sources of
public support for WestWorld, such as taxes and bonds.
D-18. Perceptions of WestWorld's funding priorities
WestWorld should prioritize
developing private sources of support,
such as sponsorships, to supplement
what the City provides.
The City should prioritize
identifying sustainable sources of
public support (e.g. taxes, bonds, etc.)
for WestWorld.
4?” ^
18%
36%
I
l%5%
27%
19%
27%
0%
25%
50%
75%
100%
■ Strongly disagree Disagree Slightly disagree ■ Neutral Slightly agree Agree ■ Strongly agree
Note:
N=128-129. Non-residents of Scottsdale were excluded from analysis. Percentages are
rounded to the nearest whoie number and therefore may not sum to 100.
Source:
Keen independent Research.
Net
D-19. Net ratings for perceptions of WestWorld's funding priorities
WestWorld should prioritize developing
private sources of support, such as
sponsorships, to supplement what
the City provides.
The City should prioritize identifying
sustainable sources of public support
{e.g. taxes, bonds, etc.) for WestWorld.
100% 75% 50% 25%
0%
25% 50% 75% 100%
■ Disagree (slightly to strongly) ■ Agree (slightly to strongly)
Note:
N=128-129. Non-residents of Scottsdale were excluded from analysis. The net rating is
calculated by subtracting the sum of the "strongly disagree," “disagree," and "slightly
disagree" responses from the sum of the participants who "strongly agree," "agree,"
and "slightly agree."
Source:
Keen Independent Research.
76%
71
61%
12%
49
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
APPENDIX D, PAGE 26
D. Community Feedback - Preferences and priorities
Participant Event Priorities
Survey participants provided their views on what types of events and
programs WestWorld should prioritize. Figure D-20 shows all responses
along a seven-point agreement scale ranging from "strongly disagree"
to "strongly agree." Nearly three quarters (73%) of respondents said
that WestWorld should prioritize serving as a community gathering
space. About 70 percent of respondents said that WestWorld should
prioritize events and programs that enhance tourism.
Only 48 percent of respondents slightly to strongly agreed that
WestWorld should prioritize innovative programming. Just under half of
respondents were neutral about whether innovative programming
should be a priority.
D-20. Responses to the statement, WestWorld should prioritize...
...serving as a space
for community gatherings.
...events and programs
that enhance tourism.
...events and programs that create
substantial economic impact in the city.
...events and programs that enhance the
quality of life for residents in Scottsdale.
...innovative programming at the venue.
4^3% 3%p'" * 21%
20%
■
14%
3 4% 5%
6%
4%
26%
i
5%
m
37%
17% m
33%
1
14%
9%
%
29%
16%
Iaii ‘1
19% H
23%
20%
I Strongly disagree
0%
t' Disagree
25%
Slightly disagree
■ Neutral
50%
Slightly agree
75%
100%
. Agree ■ Strongly agree
Note:
N=499-579. Percentages are rounded to the nearest whole number and therefore may
not sum to 100. Includes responses from facility staff and City empioyees.
Source; Keen Independent Research.
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
APPENDIX D, PAGE 27
D. Community Feedback - Preferences and priorities
Participant Event Priorities
Figure D-21 highlights the net rating for statements discussed in
Figure D-20. WestWorld "serving as a space for community gatherings"
and "events and programs that enhance tourism" received the highest
net ratings of 66 and 59 respectively. Respondents to a lesser degree
said that WestWorld should prioritize innovative programming at the
venue, with a net rating of 38. These results align with respondent views
that WestWorld should prioritize events that are well-suited for their
facility and can attract attendees from other regions.
D-21. Responses to the statement, WestWorld should prioritize...
... serving as a space
for community gatherings.
...events and programs
that enhance tourism.
...events and programs that create
substantial economic impact in the city.
...events and programs that enhance the
quality of life for residents in Scottsdale.
... innovative programming at the venue.
Net
7%
73%
66
10%
69%
13%
63%
51
13%
61%
48
48%
10%
38
100%
75%
50%
25%
0%
■ Disagree (slightly to strongly)
25%
50%
75%
100%
■ Agree (slightly to strongly)
Note; N=499-579. The net rating is caiculated by subtracting the sum of the “strongiy
disagree," "disagree," and "slightly disagree" responses from the sum of the participants
w/ho "strongly agree," "agree," and "slightly agree." Includes responses from facility staff
and City employees.
Source:
Keen Independent Research.
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
APPENDIX D, PAGE 28
D. Community Feedback - Preferences and priorities
Future Event Interests
When asked about which events they are most interested in attending
at WestWorld, 83 percent of respondents indicated interest in
equestrian events (Figure D-22). Just under half of participants shared
interest in rodeo events. Some participants expressed interest in
tradeshows, expos, fairs and festivals. Sporting events and
RVs/camping-related events received the least number of responses.
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
D-22. Future event interests
100% -
80% -
60% ■
40%
20% -
0%
83%
44%
29%
/ / /■ ✓' y / /■ y
o°
Note:
N=583. Participants could select up to three responses. Includes responses from facility
staff and City employees.
Source:
Keen Independent Research.
APPENDIX D, PAGE 29
D. Community Feedback - Preferences and priorities
Event Experience Interests
When asked about event experiences of greatest interest, just over half
of respondents indicated that they wanted events that were
entertaining or family friendly. Around thirty percent of respondents
indicated that they are interested in community-oriented events or
hands-on/interactive events. Figure D-23 showcases the range of
experiences that survey respondents are interested in at WestWorld.
D-23. Event experience interests
60% 1 53%
53„/^
40% -
30%
26%
Note:
N=548. Participants couid select up to three responses.
Source:
Keen Independent Research.
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
APPENDIX D, PAGE 30
D. Community Feedback - Preferences and priorities
Communication Preferences
Survey participants were asked about how they learn about WestWorld
events currently and what their preferences are for future
communication (Figure D-24). Survey participants reported that they
learn about WestWorld events through a range of communication
modes, including social media (41%), word of mouth (25%), the
WestWorld website (18%) and local media (13%).
Participants shared that they have a preference for learning about
future events through social media (57%) and the WestWorld
website (23%).
D-24. Survey participants' communication preferences
80% 1
60%
57%
25%
23%
15%
13%
11%
5%
40%
20% -
0%
Social media Word of WestWorld Local media Other
mouth
website
■ Primary ■ Preference
Note:
N=599-505. Some participants selected more than one response.
Source:
Keen Independent Research.
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
APPENDIX D, PAGE 31
D. Community Feedback - Online reviews
Overall, WestWorld has a rating of 4.6 out of 5 stars on Google based on
nearly 5,000 reviews. Between April 15, 2024 to April 15, 2025,
WestWorld received more than 500 reviews. During the time period
analyzed, reviews mentioned a variety of events and customer
experiences at WestWorld.
Venue quality. On Google reviews, guests praised aspects of the venue
such as its spacious layout, easy access and great air conditioning for
indoor events. Some individuals also commented on the beautiful
desert mountain views from the venue.
Great event experiences. Many reviewers noted that WestWorld has
great events and experiences for kids, horse and dog lovers, car
enthusiasts and craft lovers. They mentioned the specific events they
attended such as Barrett-Jackson and Arizona Bike Week.
Parking and traffic flow. Some complaints about visitors' experience at
WestWorld included the fact that some parking lots were dusty,
unpaved or far from the entrances. Other reviewers noted a lack of
clear signage, which made it difficult for first-time visitors to navigate
the area. Some attendees indicated that traffic flow and exits could be
more efficient.
Pricing. Some commenters reported WestWorld as overpriced, citing
parking fees ($10 to $25), price for RV camping and food and beverage
($12 for hamburger and $6 for water) as examples.
Great place to go and enjoy all the activities
WestWorld Google review
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
The venue itself is indoors and I felt the air conditioning which was
amazing, so important during the sumnter here in Phoenix.
WestWorld Google review
Great venue with lots of beautiful hot'ses and over a dozen different
arenas with various different shows to choose from.
WestWorld Google review
Decent venue for car shows, horse shows and bikes.
WestWorld Google review
This is a great place to hold expos; it's an open and spacious
warehouse that leaves room for hundreds to navigate the room. The
only thing I have to say that is negative is the price of food is
rather high....
WestWorld Google review
Parking was chaotic, no signs, not well organized.
WestWorld Google review
Parking for Bar ett-Jackson was so-so. The parking lot was not paved
and, of course, was dirty, dusty, and poorly marked....
WestWorld Google review
The costs are ridiculous. You pay for parking, $6 for water and
forget food. Carnival food for 5 times its value.
WestWorld Google review
APPENDIX D, PAGE 32
Appendix E. User and Key Stakeholder Feedback - Introduction and methodology
k
e
Keen Independent conducted interviews and administered a survey
with WestWorld users, such as event producers, and key stakeholders
to provide input on future planning for WestWorld's Strategic Plan.
Survey of City Staff
The virtual survey was distributed to City of Scottsdale staff. This
survey collected information about the facility's public experience as
well as future goals, values and priorities. The virtual survey was open
from April 1 through May 30, 2025. In total, this survey collected
31 responses. All questions were optional. Both completed and partial
surveys are included in the analysis, as many partial responses
contained substantial data.
Group Discussions and In-depth Interviews
The study team facilitated group discussions and in-depth interviews
with WestWorld staff, renters and exhibitors, vendors and Scottsdale
City leaders. Keen Independent used a semi-structured interview
format, guided by a standard question set that allowed interviewers to
ask follow-up questions and probe when necessary to deepen
understanding or clarify comments. Keen Independent spoke with
approximately 60 stakeholders through discussions and in-depth
interviews for this study.
Interview questions explored the following topics:
■
Strengths and weaknesses;
■
Opportunities and perceptions of success;
■
Threats and barriers to success;
■
Future priorities; and
■
Key performance indicators.
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
Quotes from Participants
Selected quotes are included in this appendix to illustrate themes the
study team found during analysis of survey participant input.
Participants were informed their responses would be analyzed in
aggregate and that the study team would not report individually
identifying information. Quotes from survey participants include
non-individually identifying attribution such as, "community event
organizer," "event support staff," "City staff" or "City leader."
Topics
The analysis in this appendix reflects the perspectives of approximately
90 respondents. Analysis is organized by the following topics:
Introduction and methodology;
Facility feedback;
Opportunities for success;
Barriers to success;
Preferences and priorities; and
Survey demographics.
APPENDIX E, PAGE 1
E. User and Key Stakeholder Feedback - Strengths
Interviewees and discussion participants were asked to share their
thoughts on WestWorld's greatest strengths.
Facility
Stakeholders identified strengths of the physical infrastructure of
WestWorld as well as its location.
Unique property. Many stakeholders remarked on how "unique"
WestWorld is from other properties around the country that host
similar events. They described the facility as "one-of-a-kind,"
highlighting its size, location, variety of buildings and arenas, history
and character.
Location and access. Many stakeholders indicated that WestWorld's
location is one of its greatest strengths. They detailed that the facility's
location is convenient to access, as well as close to the highway and
metropolitan areas with hotels, restaurants and retail.
Venue size and capabilities. Many stakeholders stated that
WestWorld's size and associated facilities are a great strength. They
indicated appreciation for both indoor and outdoor facilities and that
the indoor area is climate controlled. Respondents also reported that
the property's size and variety of facilities make the venue flexible for
different kinds of events.
Pavement and traffic flow. A couple of stakeholders indicated that
WestWorld's expansive pavement is a strength for hosting different
types of events at WestWorld. They indicated that asphalt allows the
venue to be a multi-purpose space and is particularly useful for
accessible parking. A couple of stakeholders added that it is easy to
enter and exit the venue.
Operations and Programming
Stakeholders identified a number of positive aspects of WestWorld
operations and programming.
Economic driver. Some stakeholders commented on the economic
impact that WestWorld has on the Scottsdale community. They noted
that WestWorld events attract both residents and tourists, adding that
the venue's proximity to Scottsdale makes it an asset for supporting
nearby hotels and local businesses. Stakeholders indicated that
WestWorld has a good reputation locally and nationally.
Major regional and national events. Some stakeholders indicated that
WestWorld's diversity of events, as well as its signature events, such as
the Barrett-Jackson Car Auction and the Scottsdale Arabian Horse Show,
are part of its strengths. Stakeholders commented that these events are
prestigious and revenue-generating for WestWorld.
Hard-working staff. Stakeholders indicated that the front-line staff
work hard to ensure events run well. A few stakeholders indicated that
some staff have been at WestWorld for many years, which can be a
strength as they have ample institutional knowledge. Some indicated
excitement about the new General Manager.
Cleanliness and grounds maintenance. A couple of stakeholders
remarked that the WestWorld facility appears to be well-maintained.
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
APPENDIX E, PAGE 2
E. User and Key Stakeholder Feedback - Weaknesses
Interviewee and discussion group participants were asked to share their
thoughts on WestWorld's greatest weaknesses.
Facility
Some stakeholders identified certain structural aspects of the venue
as weaknesses.
Deferred maintenance and upgrades. Many stakeholders identified
facility upgrades as a key weakness at WestWorld. They cited the need
for improved electrical infrastructure, especially in areas lacking existing
power, along with upgrades to the facility-wide audio system to better
support wireless capabilities and perform reliably in dusty conditions.
Other suggested improvements included enhanced wayfinding for event
patrons, improved drainage to address flooding concerns, and more
weather-resistant spaces and hard-scape surfaces.
Lack of refinement. Some stakeholders described WestWorld as
lacking refinement. They characterized the venue as "raw and
uninviting," making it less appealing for organizations hosting indoor
events, such as galas. The prevalence of dust was noted as difficult to
control, contributing to the perception that spaces feel unclean. Several
stakeholders also remarked that WestWorld lacks a grand entrance,
which could help establish a stronger sense of arrival and destination.
External Communications
Stakeholders identified weaknesses in communication both within the
City and externally with the greater public and potential renters.
City interdepartmental interactions. Staff from multiple City
departments pointed to miscommunication and misunderstanding
between WestWorld staff, other City staff (such as Police and Fire) and
City leadership as a significant weakness.
Some WestWorld staff members reported feeling pressured to operate
the venue without sufficient staffing or resources. Stakeholders also
indicated a lack of clarity and coordination across City departments
regarding resourcing for safety and security. Several noted that City
staff often do not fully understand the role of WestWorld staff in
supporting the venue and event planning, which can hinder their
effectiveness. WestWorld staff also noted that departments sometimes
provide conflicting information.
Identity and branding. Many stakeholders reported that WestWorld
lacks a clear programming identity or vision expected from a premier
venue. They noted the absence of a strategic framework for prioritizing
events or necessary facility improvements. Stakeholders also
commented that WestWorld has not clearly defined its values or goals,
which could help guide planning and decision-making.
Promotion. A few stakeholders identified marketing as a weakness of
WestWorld. They stated that the venue is not doing enough to promote
upcoming events and suggested that nearby community members
may not attend simply because they are unaware of what is happening
at WestWorld.
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
APPENDIX E, PAGE 3
E. User and Key Stakeholder Feedback - Weaknesses
Staff and Management
Stakeholders identified elements of WestWorld's staffing and
management as a primary area of weakness.
Communication with clients. Several stakeholders who hold events at
WestWorld or support event coordination reported poor
communication during the planning process. They also noted that some
staff are not as knowledgeable as they could be about the venue.
Internal cohesion. Some stakeholders remarked that WestWorld staff
are missing a sense of urgency that is critical to successful event
execution and can appear resistant to change. Some stakeholders
reported a staff culture that lacks accountability and pride in the facility,
which they said is not in the best interest of hosting successful events or
facility upkeep.
Turnover. Some stakeholders cited continued management turnover as
a contributor to inconsistent leadership, negatively affecting event
planning and facility upkeep.
Other Weaknesses
Key stakeholders identified additional concerns related to operating
procedures, the contract process, facility utilization, food and beverage
restrictions, and outsourced services as weaknesses.
Standard operating procedures. A few stakeholders noted that
WestWorld lacks adequate standard operating procedures. They stated
that event organizers do not have clear standard operating procedures
to consult and that contracts do not clearly outline roles and
responsibilities of the venue or event organizer.
Contract process. Some stakeholders stated that contracts are too long
and not well-written. Others described the rental agreements and fee
structure as burdensome, with additional costs that seem to "nickel and
dime" event organizers, making it hard to determine the true overall
rental cost.
Some stakeholders noted inconsistencies with invoice timing and the
date reservation process. For example, one stakeholder questioned why
some organizers can book multiple dates at once, while others are
limited to reserving one date at a time.
A few stakeholders stated that WestWorld has not consistently
reviewed long-term contracts that may no longer serve the venue.
These contracts may occupy highly desirable dates while generating
limited revenue.
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
APPENDIX E, PAGE 4
E. User and Key Stakeholder Feedback - Weaknesses
Lack of full facility utilization. Several stakeholders indicated that
WestWorld facilities are overall underutilized. They explained that, due
to its large size, most events only use a fraction of the venue while the
remaining infrastructure sits empty. Alternatively, some stakeholders
discussed that when multiple events are held on the property
simultaneously, there have been challenges with loading, unloading,
staff support and navigation.
Food and beverage restrictions. Several stakeholders reported that
the food and beverage options at WestWorld are a weakness. They
noted a lack of flexibility to bring in outside vendors and said current
offerings do not align with their event audiences. They also remarked
that the current vendor is too expensive.
Revenue opportunity loss from outsourcing. A few stakeholders
remarked that WestWorld loses revenue by outsourcing amenities and
services that could be managed in-house, such as food and beverage,
parking, equipment rentals, sales and marketing. A few stakeholders
also reported that the priorities of a third-party vendor may clash with
the priorities of WestWorld as a city-run facility.
f
ll
J
i
1.
vs.
m
i
m
i
3m
''4
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
APPENDIX E, PAGE 5
E. User and Key Stakeholder Feedback - Opportunities for success
Interviewee and discussion group participants shared their visions of
what future success might look like for WestWorld, along with
opportunities to achieve that success.
Driving Economic Impact
Driving economic impact was a common theme among interviewees as
a key opportunity for WestWorld to continue to lean into.
Contributing to more "heads in beds." Most stakeholders indicated
that success for WestWorld means serving as a strong economic driver
for the City, its vendors and the Scottsdale community. Some described
success in terms of "heads in beds," with WestWorld attracting tourists
who stay overnight in Scottsdale hotels or other accommodations.
Stakeholders indicated that opportunities for achieving success include
developing a strategic plan focused on economic development and
building a sales team dedicated to booking events aligned with the plan
and strategic objectives.
Maximizing major multi-day events. Most stakeholders described
success in terms of event types held at WestWorld. Stakeholders
expressed hope that the venue would remain open to new potential
event types, such as music festivals or other multi-day events.
Stakeholders indicated hope that WestWorld would program highly
desirable and impactful events that could lead to economic growth.
Some stakeholders remarked that WestWorld needs a signature event
or series, likely equestrian-related, that could be recognized and
marketed nationally. Stakeholders also noted that programming should
reach beyond a local audience and align with the venue's priorities and
goals (once those are defined).
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
I want the facility to be busy and fully optimized. I want to... generate
revenue and economic impact wherever possible.
City staff
It’s about being an economic driver for the City with great events
and branding.
City leader
Your economic impact comes from people that come in from out of
town ... It's not just what they pay Westivorld. It’s what the city
brings in.
Community event organizer
We have a bed tax in the City of Scottsdale where that funding goes
into a tourism development fund... And I would love to see those
dollars stretched even more.
Community event organizer
WestWorld has the ability to attract major events. They could do a
huge music festival on the polo field... They already have a lot of the
things that go with the Music Festival concept.
Community event organizer
[WestWorld] needs more events that are recognized and well-known,
like signature events or something like that.
City staff
Why hasn't this community and the We.stWorld team developed
something like a rodeo series?
Community event organizer
APPENDIX E, PAGE 6
E. User and Key Stakeholder Feedback - Opportunities for success
Marketing/Communications
Stakeholders identified several areas of opportunity for improving
marketing and communications related to WestWorld.
Increased identity and brand recognition. Many stakeholders
indicated that success for WestWorld means developing a clear identity
and brand for the venue. With a clear direction in place, the venue can
better make decisions that serve the event organizers, community,
event attendees and the City. Some stakeholders suggested that
WestWorld's identity should be rooted in western culture as a nod to
Scottsdale's history and heritage. Some stakeholders added that
equestrian activities should remain part of its identity. Other
stakeholders specified that WestWorld's brand should appeal to a
luxury traveler. Stakeholders indicated that a clear brand gives
WestWorld an opportunity to build name recognition.
Program optimization. Some stakeholders indicated that success for
WestWorld means optimizing its event calendar to activate as much of
the venue as possible throughout the year.
Some stakeholders indicated that calendar optimization likely means
reviewing long-term contracts with event organizers to ensure date
availability and event type are still in the best interest of WestWorld's
programming strategy. Some stakeholders added that WestWorld
should look for event synergies, where an audience for one event could
carry over into a different event happening at the same time.
A couple of stakeholders added that staff across City-run venues should
improve communication with one another so that events that are not a
fit for WestWorld could potentially be placed at an alternative
City-operated venue.
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
Our destination marketing organization really promotes to the
luxury traveler... WestWorld is a way to enhance that experience for
[travelers], so [we should be] creating events there that do just that.
City staff
I think really capitalizing on Scottsdale’s brand and the
Western culture.
City staff
Is it part of the park system? Should it be treated like a convention
center?... Everybody's got a different opinion .... And there’s not
really a cohesive plan as to how you build it out and how you
maintain it.
Community event organizer
I would love to see more collaboration with other events that are
going on within the valley... How do we make people from spring
training come out to WestWorld to see the events?
Community event organizer
There's not a lot more time and space at the facility. If there’s going to
be a pivot to another direction, then it’s going to come at the expense
of events that don't carry the same value as other events.
City staff
APPENDIX E, PAGE 7
E. User and Key Stakeholder Feedback - Opportunities for success
Promotional strategies that reach more metro Phoenix residents.
Some stakeholders indicated that success for WestWorld means having
a marketing strategy that better communicates events to the
community and beyond. Stakeholders provided suggestions for
achieving this strategy, including increased event signage such as an
electric billboard on the highway, developing marketing lists and
utilizing WestWorld's website and social media channels. Some
stakeholders said that marketing should further promote the value that
equestrian programming brings to WestWorld and the community.
Clear and desirable contracts. Some stakeholders described success in
terms of contract updates and restructured pricing models. Some
suggestions included offering a blended rate that does not itemize
individual fees, different peak and off-peak pricing, providing financial
incentives for new bookers and developing turnkey packages that make
booking simpler. One stakeholder commented that producers could use
a step-by-step guide for navigating the contracting and funding process
with WestWorld and the City of Scottsdale.
I think one of the opportunities for WestWorld is marketing. Once
they find out who they are, [it’s] getting that out there.
Community event organizer
Success would be that... you talk to someone on the East Coast [and]
they've heard of WestWorld.
City staff
[If] we want to attract people here in the off-season... finding ways to
be easier to do business with during that period would be a really
good opportunity for them.
Community event organizer
There’s potential from a prospective producers perspective that
they're being nickel and dimed [as] opposed to making sure you
capture all your fees and this is what the fee is.
City staff
The state of Texas helps fund incentives that are gifted to producers
of very large, very profitable shows. Having a fresh approach from
the City would help and then couple that with turnkey packages for
that Memorial Day to Labor Day window.
Event support staff
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
APPENDIX E, PAGE 8
E. User and Key Stakeholder Feedback - Opportunities for success
Management and Staffing
Improving various aspects of management and staffing was another
area of opportunity identified by stakeholders.
Instilling venue management culture. Some stakeholders indicated
that success for WestWorld entails having staff who are knowledgeable
about venue operations and can support event organizers to optimize
venue use. Stakeholders indicated that WestWorld staff should be
professional, accountable and able to provide high-quality customer
service.
Increased professional development opportunities. A couple of
stakeholders stated that opportunities to management and staffing
include fostering a culture of learning, providing professional
development opportunities and developing a succession plan.
Development of standard operating procedures. Several
stakeholders discussed success in terms of streamlined operations. They
discussed that opportunities to support this effort could include
creating standard operating procedures and rules for all event
organizers to follow, as well as having clear roles and responsibilities
outlined during the contracting process.
These events are turtwig over [and] you’ve only got a veiy limited
amount of time to get in and get out and you need to be working
well together.
City staff
That [WestWorld staff] know what's needed [for safety] ahead of
time and [then they] can pass that information along to producers
and to renters.
Event support staff
Strong understanding and strong support from the top is going to be
really valuable for WestWorld. I sense that [what] staff [are] really
looking for is direction so they know which direction to go in.
City staff
These are the rules for our venue across the board. If you want to
play here, then these are the rules that you have to play by.
City staff
They need to... bring on risk management [and] legal to help
establish more consistent rules to maximize [venue operations] and
efficiency.
City staff
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
APPENDIX E, PAGE 9
E. User and Key Stakeholder Feedback - Opportunities for success
Other Opportunities
Stakeholders mentioned other opportunities such as building
collaboration and trust, bringing services in house and ensuring that
facilities are well maintained and up-to-date.
Building collaboration and trust. A few stakeholders discussed success
in terms of how well all key stakeholders are listening to one another,
including WestWorld staff. City leadership, event organizers, event
support staff and community residents. Some stakeholders said that
building trust between these groups is important for developing a
unified direction for WestWorld and for making decisions about the
venue that support successful events for everyone.
Bringing services in house. A few stakeholders indicated that
WestWorld could be more successful if they managed more of their
amenities and services in-house, which they said would maximize
WestWorld's profit and contribute to a better experience. For example,
stakeholders indicated that by managing parking, food and beverage,
equipment rentals (i.e. barricades, temporary fencing, ramps) and
sales/marketing in-house, WestWorld could make more money from
those services and each event would not need to rent separately from a
third-party vendor.
Ensuring facilities are well maintained and up-to-date. Many
stakeholders specified that success for WestWorld means addressing
priority facility upgrades, including venue safety, that contribute to
providing a high-quality event experience. Stakeholders specified that
upgrades should align with priorities of events being held at WestWorld,
which includes better drainage, parking, paving and shelter. A couple of
stakeholders added staff offices needed updating to better fit their
operational needs and boost morale.
The highest priority in my mind [is] that the community and the
elected officials and the management of WestWorld need to come
together and decide on the direction of WestWorld.
City staff
I think internally getting that team all working together well would
be a priority for me because I think it makes it easier to take
WestWorld to the next level.
City staff
If WestWorld invested in equipment, they would certainly make
revenue off it. They would be able to offer those elements, that all the
events need, to producers at a better price than we could get on the
regular market. They would keep more profit in-house and they could
also reduce costs to producers.
Community event organizer
Right now [WestWorld] outsources their sales and marketing.
There's been some conversations about maybe internalizing that and
cutting out those shared fees.
City staff
[If] we want to compete with these world-class facilities, we have to
put a significant amount of money into upgrading the facility.
City staff
Being able to use the site consistently in all weather... we've got to
deal better with [how the] water flows.
City staff
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
APPENDIX E, PAGE 10
E. User and Key Stakeholder Feedback - Barriers to success
Interviewee and discussion group participants described potential
threats or barriers to achieving success at WestWorld. When asked to
describe potential threats or barriers to success at WestWorld,
respondents shared the following concerns.
Government Restrictions
Government restrictions around the contract process, marketing and
other bureaucracy were identified as potential barriers to success.
Contract process. Some stakeholders indicated that the current
contracting process is a barrier to WestWorld's growth as a venue.
Some stakeholders said that existing long-term contracts prevent
WestWorld from booking new events that better utilize the facility or
potentially draw a better audience. Additionally, stakeholders said that
WestWorld's current pricing and fee structure makes booking events
challenging to navigate.
Bureaucracy. Some stakeholders indicated that government
bureaucracy is a barrier to success. Some stakeholders commented that
City leadership often does not have a strong understanding of
WestWorld as a venue, which leads to disagreements about its identity,
management model and adequate staffing levels. Stakeholders said that
these disagreements slow down funding for facility upgrades. Some
stakeholders remarked that the City of Scottsdale has more safety
restrictions than other cities, which adds to the expense of producing
events at WestWorld.
[There are] grandfathered-in clients with huge blocks of time
and long-term contracts.
WestWorld staff
I believe any deviation from [a] standard contract requires City
Council involvement... [a] corporate planner from Lexus is not going
to stand before City Council when they could just go to Dallas and
make [their event] happen.
Community event organizer
The staff [at WestWorld] will say that even though they 're part of the
City, sometimes they feel that the City doesn't really understand what
WestWorld is or what it does.
Community event organizer
[For] police and fire, [The City has] standards that are way above
other municipalities when it comes to the number of people they
think you need.
Event support staff
If the City sees the opportunity as WestWorld being a revenue
generating facility, then we have to make it easier for clients to access
[City]funds to make us competitive.
Community event organizer
Marketing restrictions. A few stakeholders indicated concern over
restrictions from the City on marketing events and providing event
incentives to organizers. Stakeholders said that these parameters
around sponsorship, funding and incentives can make event promotion
harder and less appealing to potential event organizers.
Scottsdale can’t pay to get these shows. [It’s] difficult to work with
because of the gift clause.
WestWorld staff
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
APPENDIX E, PAGE 11
E. User and Key Stakeholder Feedback - Barriers to success
Vision/Focus
Some stakeholders identified concerns with the focus of the strategic
plan being too broad, with others indicating concerns of the plan being
too narrow.
Narrow vision. Some stakeholders indicated that having too narrow of
a vision for WestWorld could be a barrier to the venue fully realizing its
potential. They remarked that being narrowly focused on the
programming that WestWorld has historically produced may not use the
facility to its greatest ability. Stakeholders added that the venue should
be getting creative and taking risks.
Broad vision. A few stakeholders indicated that if WestWorld focuses
too much on being a multipurpose facility, they run the chance of being
too broad. Some stakeholders indicated that if WestWorld tries to
create a venue that works for everyone, they may end up with a venue
that works for no one. One stakeholder explained that there are
inefficiencies when changing over some spaces for different types of
back-to-back events. They noted that some infrastructure can be easily
transformed for different events, while other infrastructure is best
utilized for a specific focus. A few stakeholders indicated that the City
should be selective of events at WestWorld to preserve its reputation.
I think we're also limited by the vision of the people that are
operating [WestWorld] today. I think they're hesitant to go down a
road where they're doing multiple things at multiple times.
Event support staff
If [there’s] a really good opportunity or a really good event that they
want to go after, taking a risk might make sense. I think the
weaknesses is the fear of prioritizing that.
Community event organizer
I think what could stand in the way [of success is] if we try to be
everything for everybody.
City staff
Are there some areas that maybe shouldn't have as much radical type
[of]flexibility, but keep [those] certain areas where it makes more
sense? Then you know [the]flexibilities you have.
City staff
If we aren't careful about what types of events that we're bringing in.
I think we can run the risk of ruining the reputation of WestWorld.
City staff
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
APPENDIX E, PAGE 12
E. User and Key Stakeholder Feedback - Barriers to success
Other Barriers
other potential barriers to success identified by stakeholders included
themes around lacking standard operating procedures, resident
complaints and potential issues surrounding the master plan.
Lack of standard operating procedures. Some stakeholders indicated
that having no standard operating procedures documented for event
organizers to follow is a barrier for WestWorld to operate as a premier
event space. One stakeholder referred to producing events at
WestWorld as "clumsy" and "unsophisticated" due to the lack
of protocol.
Resident complaints. Some stakeholders indicated that residents who
live near WestWorld could be a barrier to its success. Although the
venue was here before most of the residential areas were developed,
stakeholders said that there are often complaints about noise, lights
and the venue's aesthetic. Stakeholders indicated worry that as the
surrounding community grows, WestWorld's development could
continue to be a challenge.
Inadequate master plan. Some stakeholders shared concerns over the
WestWorld master plan, which focuses on prioritizing updates to
physical infrastructure.^ Some indicated that the plan is a barrier to
progress because the City is not collaborating with key stakeholders and
the plan is seemingly not prioritizing the most critical upgrades. Some
remarked that the plan is taking too long to create, making it more
susceptible to modifications when City leadership changes.
^ The WestWorld strategic plan is separate from the master plan, as it is focused
on strategy and operations.
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
[To] allow [producers] to just use the property as they wish, I think is
actually a threat because it turns into a jigsaw puzzle of trying to put
together safety plans and implement safety measures to meet each
individual producer's idea.
City staff
The area has built up around WestWorld. It used to be very remote.
The residents move in and then they don't like the fact that they
moved next to a noisy special event venue.
Community event organizer
We had issues when the tent had the flag on it. The folks up north
didn't like to see the flag so we changed out that tent and now we
have just a plain beige skin.
City staff
[The new masterplan] doesn't work for the equestrian community. It
doesn't work for the special event community .... [What’s] frustrating
is sometimes the City [will] involve events ... sometimes they don't.
Community event organizer
APPENDIX E, PAGE 13
E. User and Key Stakeholder Feedback - Preferences and priorities
Stakeholders reflected on their preferences and priorities for the
future of WestWorld.
Supporting Scottsdale Residents
Some interviewed stakeholders talked about the ways that WestWorld
could better support Scottsdale residents. They indicated that
WestWorld could bring residents more into the event planning process
and that WestWorld could better advertise their events to the
community as a potential audience. Some stakeholders talked about
finding a balance between programming for the community and for
tourists. A couple of stakeholders suggested that off-peak months at
WestWorld could have more community-focused programming like
summer camps, cultural events or free horseback riding lessons,
especially if they could be held indoors with air conditioning.
Some stakeholders did not share additional ideas to engage the
community, indicating that WestWorld is already serving their
community and that WestWorld's primary focus should be hosting
impactful events.
Supporting Local Businesses
Some interviewed stakeholders discussed ways that WestWorld could
better support local businesses. Some stakeholders indicated that
WestWorld could allow sponsorships that promote local businesses, and
others suggested that local businesses could be food vendors at the
venue. Some stakeholders added that WestWorld should focus on
hosting multi-day events because it supports local hotels, restaurants
and retail when venue patrons stay in town. Some stakeholders
indicated that WestWorld events are already serving local businesses.
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
Once WestWorld decides what it wants to be... you can then figure
out what the re.sidents of Scottsdale are interested in.... What would
give the community pride about this event?
City staff
Programming from a citizen perspective ... like free or reduced rate
horse riding lessons that [WestWorld] could partner on ... Some sort
of offering during their downtime that’s minimal impact on the
expenses of WestWorld.
City staff
I think WestWorld serves the residents of Scottsdale pretty well...
They’ve got it booked constantly ... They’re bringing tax dollars to
town. They’re bringing people to town that want to experience
Scottsdale. I don’t know how they can do that part a whole lot better.
Community event organizer
We try to get the local restaurants to come and be a part of the event,
which we do with a bunch of those [restaurants].
Community event organizer
[Are] there sponsorships that that year-round they could do to help
promote and offer local businesses during these major events?
City staff
[If] it's a larger event, where people are coming for multiple days,
you're going to benefit the loeal businesses. They're going to stay here
and [go to] restaurants and that's what our community thrives on.
City staff
APPENDIX E, PAGE 14
E. User and Key Stakeholder Feedback - Preferences and priorities (survey responses)
Priorities Identified by City Staff
In the survey of City staff, when asked what audiences WestWorld
should focus on serving in the future, just over half of survey
respondents (56%) indicated that WestWorld should focus on
equestrian enthusiasts. Respondents also indicated that WestWorld
should focus on families (36%), national or international audiences
(32%) and the Scottsdale community (32%). Figure E-1 shows the range
of audiences selected by survey respondents.
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
E-1. Survey respondent audience priorities
60% -,56%
50%
36%
40%
32% 32%
28%
30%
20%
16% 16% 16%
20%
10%
4%
12% 12%
0%
/ / ■/ /
■r cT
^ „cP <9
/// /
/
Note:
N=25. Participants could select up to three responses.
Source:
Keen Independent Research.
APPENDIX E, PAGE 15
E. User and Key Stakeholder Feedback - Preferences and priorities (survey responses)
Values for the Future
When asked what values WestWorld should prioritize to guide its future
work, just over half of survey respondents (57%) indicated that
WestWorld should host a variety of programs and operate with
integrity (52%). Almost forty percent (39%) of respondents said that
WestWorld should focus on achieving a high standard of excellence
and professionalism. Figure E-2 shows the range of values selected by
survey respondents.
E-2. Survey respondent future values
Hosting a diverse variety of programs
Operating with integrity
Achieving a high standard of
excellence and professionalism
Maximizing activation of facilities
Cultivating robust national and
international audiences
Enhancing the quality of life
for local residents
High-quality customer service
Other
1
I 57%
52%
39%
35%
35%
35%
30%
4%
10%
20%
30%
40%
50%
60%
Note:
N=23. Participants could select up to three responses.
Source:
Keen Independent Research.
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
APPENDIX E, PAGE 16
E. User and Key Stakeholder Feedback - Preferences and priorities (survey responses)
Goals for the Future
When asked what goals WestWorld should prioritize, almost two-thirds
of survey respondents (63%) indicated that WestWorld should prioritize
enhancing economic development. Over half of respondents (54%) also
indicated that WestWorld should prioritize enhancing the quality of life
for Scottsdale residents. Just under half of respondents (46%) indicated
that WestWorld should prioritize making a profit. Figure E-3 shows all
responses that respondents believe WestWorld should prioritize.
Key Performance Indicators
Interview and discussion participants were asked about key
performance indicators for WestWorld. They indicated an interest
in tracking the following measures annually:
■
Revenue generated;
■
Net profit per event;
■
Percent of facility utilization throughout the year;
■
Total days programmed;
■
Total new events booked;
■
Total repeat bookings;
■
Total first-time attendees;
■
Total events spanning longer than three days;
■
Total hotel rooms booked; and
■
Length of visitor stay.
E-3. Survey respondent goals to prioritize
Enhancing economic development
Enhancing the quality of life for
Scottsdale residents
Making a profit
Meeting a predetermined budget
Other
46%
63%
54%
8%
8%
0%
10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70%
Note:
N=24. Participants could select up to two responses.
Source:
Keen Independent Research.
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
APPENDIX E, PAGE 17
E. User and Key Stakeholder Feedback - Survey demographics
Keen Independent examined the demographics of survey participants,
including their race and ethnicity, gender, age, affiliations with
WestWorld and other demographic identifiers.
Gender
Figure E-4 shows that nearly two-thirds of survey respondents
identified as female (63%) and one-fifth identified as male (21%) The
remaining respondents preferred not to answer (16%).
Race and Ethnicity
Figure E-5 shows the race and ethnicity of survey respondents. Among
those who reported their race and ethnicity, 14 identified as white and
four identified as Hispanic.
E-4. Gender of survey respondents
Prefer not to answer
(16%)
Male
(21%)
Female
(63%)
Note:
N=19. No respondents identified as non-binary.
Source:
Keen Independent Research.
E-5. Race and ethnicity of survey participants
Race and ethnicity
Response
White
14
Hispanic or Latino
4
Black or African American
1
Other
1
Asian
0
American Indian and/or Alaskan Native
0
Native Hawaiian and/or Pacific Islander
0
Prefer not to answer
3
“ ri
^ --- --- - -
-- -
Note:
N=19. Participants could select more than one answer.
Source:
Keen Independent Research.
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
APPENDIX E, PAGE 18
E. User and Key Stakeholder Feedback - Survey demographics
Age
Figure E-6 depicts the ages of individuals who completed the survey.
The survey captured a wide range of ages. Thirty percent of
respondents were either ages 25 to 34 or 55 to 64 and twenty percent
were ages 45 to 54.
Other Demographic Identifiers
Keen Independent invited survey respondents to share additional
demographic identifiers that may help the study team understand their
experiences or the experiences of other members of their household.
There were five respondents who shared additional identifiers and
11 respondents selected "no additional identifiers to share." Figure E-7
shows the demographic self-identification of respondents.
E-6. Age of survey respondents
Prefer not to answer (5%)
65 to 74 (5%)
18 to 24 (5%)
55 to 64
(30%)
25 to 34 (30%)
35 to 44 (5%)
45 to 54 (20%)
Note:
N=19. No respondents identified as under 18.
Source:
Keen Independent Research.
E-7. Demographic self-identification of survey participants and/or their
household members
Other demographic identifiers
Number of
responses
No additional identifiers to share
Veteran/military
Disability status
Bilingual/multilingual
LGBTQ+
Other
11
2
2
2
2
0
Note:
N=19. Participants could select more than one answer.
Source:
Keen Independent Research.
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
APPENDIX E, PAGE 19
E. User and Key Stakeholder Feedback - Survey demographics
Affiliation with WestWorld
Figure E-8 depicts survey respondents' affiliations with WestWorld.
Most respondents, a total of 25, were City of Scottsdale employees who
do not work at WestWorld. Five participants were WestWorld
employees and one participant identified as an exhibitor or performer
at a WestWorld event.
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
E-8. Survey participants reported affiliations with WestWorld
Affiliation with WestWorld
Number of
responses
City of Scottsdale employee
(not at WestWorld)
WestWorld employee
WestWorld event exhibitor or performer
WestWorld contractor or vendor
Other
No affiliation to WestWorld
Note:
N=31. Participants could select more than one answer.
Source:
Keen Independent Research.
25
5
1
0
1
1
APPENDIX E, PAGE 20
APPENDIX F. Benchmark Research — Introduction
Keen Independent conducted background research on three benchmark
venues to inform the strategic planning and goal setting process for
WestWorld.
Methodology
The study team worked with WestWorld staff to select benchmark
venues using criteria such as:
■
Location within a major metro area market;
■
Mix and size of equestrian arenas, expo halls and other
multi-purpose event spaces;
■
Availability of horse boarding and RV camping; and
■
Presence of major signature annual event(s).
Venue Selections
The study team selected the following venues as national benchmarks
for WestWorld:
■
Will Rogers Memorial Center (Fort Worth, TX);
■
National Western Center/National Western Complex
(Denver, CO); and
■
OC Fair and Event Center (Costa Mesa, CA).
Keen Independent interviewed venue representatives and conducted
additional background research to develop the venue profiles on the
following pages.
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
Key Takeaways
The following are key takeaways from this benchmark research:
■
All benchmarked venues utilize some form of event
management software;
■
Rental rates for event space, labor and equipment are
itemized at all benchmarked venues; and
■
Annual operations at benchmarked venues are subsidized
either by a major high-impact event or by government
funding, with one venue's operational deficit being primarily
covered by a Hotel Occupancy Tax.
F-1. Availability of horse boarding and RV camping at benchmarked venues
Horse
RV
Name
OC Fair and Events Center
Will Roger^Memorial Center
National Western Center/Complex
Location
Costa Mesa, CA
Fort Worth. TX
Denver, CO
boarding camping
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
Source:
Keen Independent Research.
APPENDIX F, PAGE 1
i
F. Benchmark Research — Will Rogers Memorial Center
Will Rogers Memorial Center (WRMC) is a 120-acre multi-purpose
facility in Fort Worth, Texas that hosts a variety of equestrian,
agricultural, entertainment, corporate, educational, social and sporting
events, including many international and high-impact shows.
Ownership and management structure. The City of Fort Worth owns
and operates the Will Rogers Memorial Center.
Venues. The Will Rogers Memorial Center includes:
■
Historic Will Rogers Coliseum (5,652 seats);
■
Will Rogers Auditorium (2,856 seats);
■
Amon G. Garter, Jr Exhibits Hall (94,000 square feet); and
■
Additional equestrian and livestock facilities with an
underground tunnel system.
Annual attendance. The venue hosts more than two million attendees
per year. ^
Annual budget. According to WRMC fiscal year 2024 financials, the
facility has about $16 million in annual expenses and about $10 million
in annual revenue. The deficit is primarily subsidized by Hotel
Occupancy Taxes (HOT).
Event load. WRMC holds about 200 events per year, with most of these
events being with repeat clients.
^ https://www.fortworth.com/will-rogers-memorial-center/
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
F-2. Will Rogers Memorial Center
....-.
to
<
a
i
BneT-T-/?
'i
n
*
7 7
i
Source:
City of Fort Worth.
F-3. Aerial view of Will Rogers Memorial Center
r.
Source: City of Fort Worth.
mm
a
APPENDIX F, PAGE 2
F. Benchmark Research — Will Rogers Memorial Center
Event management and booking system. According to a WRMC
venue representative interviewed by Keen Independent, the venue
utilizes Momentus for event booking and management.
Number of staff. The Culture and Tourism Fund, which includes
operations for WRMC and the Fort Worth Convention Center has 158
positions equating to about 147.60 full-time equivalent staff.
Strategic focus. As part of the City's Public Events Department, WRMC
aligns with the department's overall strategic direction. Department
strategic goals include:
■
Achieve an average Customer Experience Satisfaction score of
75 percent or better for the Public Events Department;
■
Increase Social Media presence across all platforms by
10 percent;
■
Keep the percentage of reliance on HOT for Public Events
Department operations under 30 percent;
■
Revise/Review/Improve at least four business processes per
fiscal year, per division WRMC, FWCC, ADMIN; and
■
100 percent of team members engaged in professional
development activity per fiscal year.
Rate structure. The space, equipment and labor rate structure for
WRMC is itemized and subject to City Council approval. The rate
structure is uniform and applies to ail events except the Fort Worth
Stock Show and Rodeo, which is the venue's oldest client and in a
public-private partnership with the City.
Incentives. According to the venue representative interviewed by Keen
Independent, WRMC does not offer incentives to bring high-value
events to the venue. However, its nonprofit partner. Visit Fort Worth,
could help with funding incentives to bring high-value events.
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
F-4. Equestrian facility at Will Rogers Memorial Center
i/
l::
I®
-m
Source:
Visit Fort Worth.
F-5. Historic Will Rogers Coliseum
.r. ----— r
--r-
Source:
Visit Fort Worth.
APPENDIX F, PAGE 3
F. Benchmark Research — National Western Center/National Western Complex
National Western Center is a 250-acre campus in Denver, Colorado that
is being constructed in partnership with the City and County of Denver,
the National Western Stock Show, CSU Spur, History Colorado and
Denver Museum of Nature and Science.
Ownership and management structure. The National Western Center
is owned by the City and County of Denver and operated by the
National Western Center Authority, a 501c6 nonprofit. The National
Western Center campus is adjacent to the National Western Complex,
which is owned and operated by the National Western Stock Show.
With the National Western Complex facilities aging and becoming too
small for the National Western Stock Show, the National Western Stock
Show provided funding for the National Western Complex. While still in
the planning stages, there is conversation around eventually replacing
the old National Western Complex facilities and being completely
converted into the National Western Center.
Venues. National Western Center currently includes the Stockyards
Event Center which comprises:
■
Wagner Equipment Co. Auction Arena (630 seats);
■
Stow L. Witwer Memorial Show Arena (17,500 square feet);
■
Cille and Ron Williams Yards (14-acre flexible hardscaped
space); and
■
Two outdoor plazas (one acre each).
Note that additional facilities at National Western Center are being
planned and under construction.
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
F-6. National Western Center campus map
I
n 9
smma
c
H BS it
Mm”
rw 1
r
\ national
V WESTERN^
*■>-- C .Nil .
MnK
SKP
CSU SPitB V10A
i
|i
" I iif HI...
1-10
I
manK
cfincn
i
THE EXCITEMENT IS BUILDING
CAMPUS MAP
TT J
Si;
/
KQCSiaiAl BBtOC
UYISTDCI CIlTfR
A
timi
A
S
p
i
m
OltCI
IKSnMB
M
-N
I miiu
m
sisuviBUEsaiofit
oj
r m ‘SSS.W-
'•S.'S
f
iMBin
USTMCr
i
NMIONAL WlSTttM
CINTBB CAMWS
OMNtUILDINOf
•UllOmOS COMING SOON
pvii CMift PAMAtK
MjiORB akbna, expc
U CSU SFUR CAMPUS
g MWSS UOACY lUILOINO
« MtXI04J$f SPAOS
n LOCATION OP tXISTINO NATIONAL
WISntN COMPLfX PACIUTtU
nmitl AIINA. EXPO HALL.
Source:
National Western Center.
APPENDIX F, PAGE 4
F. Benchmark Research — National Western Center/National Western Complex
Annual budget. With the National Western Center Authority and
National Western Stock Show being two separate entities, a concise
operating budget for the venue is not available. However, according to a
representative of the National Western Complex who was interviewed
by Keen Independent, the National Western Stock Show generates
significantly more revenue than the other events that take place there.
Event management and booking system. According to a National
Western Center venue representative, the venue utilizes Tripleseat for
event booking and management.
strategic focus. The mission of the National Western Center Authority
is to "convene the world at the National Western Center to lead, inspire,
create, educate and entertain in pursuit of global food solutions."
Rate structure. The space, equipment and labor rate structure for
National Western Center is itemized. The Authority offers discounts to
community and nonprofit organizations. This rate structure is uniform
for all events except the National Western Stock Show, which is a key
partner and funder for the National Western Center.
Incentives. According to the venue representative interviewed by
Keen Independent, National Western Center does not offer incentives
to bring high-value events to the venue.
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
F-7. Stockyards Event Center at National Western Center
T
9H
0
a
'■7
Source:
National Western Center rental brochure.
APPENDIX F, PAGE 5
F. Benchmark Research — OC Fair and Event Center
Positioned across 130 acres, OC Fair and Event Center is located in
Costa Mesa, California and home to the OC fair, which attracts more
than one million attendees annually.
Ownership and management structure. The OC Fair and Event Center
is owned and operated by the 32nd District Agricultural Association, an
institution of the state of California.
Venues. OC Fair and Event Center venues include:
■
Action Sports Arena (about 7,000 seats);
■
Pacific Amphitheater (about 8,500 seats); and
■
Seven exhibit halls and other additional meeting and
multipurpose areas (about 157,000 square feet).
Annual budget. The annual budget for the OC Fair and Event Center
separates financials for the State Fair from the rest of the venue's
annual operating expenses. When including the State Fair, the fiscal
year 2025 budget illustrated annual expenses of about $59 million and
$5 million in net revenue. Excluding the State Fair, annual operating
expenses were approximately $30 million with a deficit of about
$17 million.
Event management and booking system. According to an OC Fair and
Event Center representative contacted by Keen Independent, the venue
utilizes Momentus for event booking and management and for
generating contracts.
Strategic focus. The mission of the OC Fair and Event Center is to
"enhance equitable community access to agriculture, entertainment,
cultural and educational experiences."
Rate structure. The space, equipment and labor rate structure for
OC Fair and Event Center is itemized.
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
F-8. OC Fair and Event Center facilities
a
I
"•a-
f
■xS
T"
■r?
Source; OC Fair and Event Center.
APPENDIX F, PAGE 6
APPENDIX G. Implementation Tracking
Keen Independent has provided WestWorld staff with a multifaceted,
flexible tool for visualizing, coordinating, tracking and reporting
implementation of the strategic plan. Appendix G describes and
illustrates uses of the tool for tracking and reporting progress.
Figure G-1 depicts a sample dashboard view. Columns on the right allow
tracking and reporting on progress to date by stage and status, actual
metrics achieved and notes.
Provided drop-down options include:
■
NA/Not yet expected;
■
Not started;
■
Initiated;
■
In progress; and
■
Completed.
Provided drop-down menu options for status include:
■
NA/Not yet expected;
■
Progressing;
■
Delayed;
■
Stuck/blocked; and
■
Completed.
In Figure G-1, tracking fields are populated with mock-up data for
illustration purposes only.
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
APPENDIX 6, PAGE 1
APPENDIX G. Implementation Tracking
G-l. Sample dashboard view
Lead
start by Due by Example metrics/
__ febYt____ ttYc___ success indicators
Progress to date
Actual metrics/
stage_______ Status____progress to date
2. Strengthen and unify our organization
2-1.
a.
Improve consistency and standardization across
all business processes
Standardize policies and operational procedures to
erasure consistent practices across the organization
_____________
Policy and operational policy needs inventoried and prioritized. Then
General Manager M-26 Jun-28 100%of policyandoperationalprocedureprlorltiescompletedand
adopted.
Completed Completed
SOPs completed arxf ar<'>nt^
b. Provide training and communication to ensure aU
staff follow unified processes and expectations
General Manager Jul-27 Jun-29
100% of staff trained on unified processes. AU staff compliant with
processes
Initiated
Progressb \
TrainUig processes tmder
development
^ Improve the RV reservation system to enhance
usability and client experience*
improve communication throughout the customer
2-2. Journey, from sales to service delivery and follow
up
Track the number of instances in which RV staff were needed to st^ in
RVOfflcelead Apr-26 /^-27 andprovldecustomerasslstancewhenthesystemwasnotsuccesshjl Completed completed
at competing the reservation process
Customer Issued reduced by 10%
in 2027
Annual tracking in progress
If*
Iif'-
■-r
Strengthen communication workflows to ensure
a. timely, accurate information sharing among staff and
with clients
Director
Mar-26 Jun-27 Communication protocol adopted
Initiated
Prog,gi.‘ng
^
^
* >.aneelsde e > e'
F%\tl
.Je^-Aar touch bases with Police and
Fire at least two weeks before event
load in
^ Hold regular produclion meetings to align teams and
address operational needs in advance
Director
Mar-26 Jun-31
Develop a system to determine which events will require pre-event
production meetings and in-turn ensure that the meetings take place
inprogre s T g'>.iSriig
Production meetings taking place
before all Priority One events
KEEN INDEPENDENT RESEARCH — WESTWORLD OF SCOTTSDALE STRATEGIC PLAN
APPENDIX G, PAGE 2