Extracted text (via pymupdf)
48059 characters
Board of Supervisors' Agenda 2014-2017: BRE ESA Portfolio LLC et al (TX2018-000189) Represented by Dickinson Wright PLLC; 2018-2023: GD KS Acquisition Company LS (TX2017-000029) Represented by Frazer, Ryan, Goldberg & Arnold LLP; Vestar LPTC LLC (TX2017-000030) Represented by Frazer, Ryan, Goldberg & Arnold LLP; Kohls Department Stores Inc (TX2017-000145) Represented by Frazer, Ryan, Goldberg & Arnold LLP; Kohls Department Stores Inc (TX2017-000146) Represented by Frazer, Ryan, Goldberg & Arnold LLP; BCB Group Investments - Tramonto Marketplace (TX2017-000147) Represented by Frazer, Ryan, Goldberg & Arnold LLP; Spirit Realty LLC (TX2018-000644) Represented by Frazer, Ryan, Goldberg & Arnold LLP; 2019-2023: Continental Suprise LLC, Maj Place HD LLC, et al (TX2018-000645) Represented by Frazer, Ryan, Goldberg & Arnold LLP; 2020-2023: Dillards Properties Inc et al (TX2019-001734) Represented by Mooney, Wright, Moore & Wilhoit, PLLC; 2021-2023: Kirst Philip P/Colleen TR (TX2020-000710) Represented by Frazer, Ryan, Goldberg & Arnold LLP; Somerville Mesa Limited Partnership (TX2020-000711) Represented by Frazer, Ryan, Goldberg & Arnold LLP; Inland Western Glendale LLC (TX2020-000713) Represented by Frazer, Ryan, Goldberg & Arnold LLP; 2022: Gaedeke Holdings LTD (TX2021-000456) Represented by Donald P. Roelke; 2023: Gaedeke Holdings LTD (TX2022-000432) Represented by Donald P. Roelke; Cotton Bethany LLC/303 Cotton LLC (TX2022-000446) Represented by Mooney, Wright, Moore & Wilhoit, PLLC; IA Avondale LLC (TX2020-000714) Represented by Frazer, Ryan, Goldberg & Arnold LLP; Crescent 2400 LLC (TX2022-000441) Represented by Quarles & Brady LLP; 2024: Northern Parkway Glendale Owner LLC and West Airport Eldridge Ltd (TX2023-000077) Represented by Mooney, Wright, Moore & Wilhoit, PLLC 2014 - 2017 Date: 11/14/2023 14 Parcels Prepared by: Parcel #s: See Attached Plaintiff: LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 15,146,379 28,376,621 43,523,000 See Parcel RECOMMENDED: 15,146,379 24,730,991 39,877,370 TASRs Chappell/Procaccini Tax Case: TX2018-000189 Tax Year: 2014 BRE ESA PORTFOLIO LLC et al *** C O V E R S H E E T *** _____________________________________________________________ TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Maricopa County 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 County Atty: O'CONNOR JACK Date: 10/05/2023 Parcel Allocation Page: 1 of 1 Tax Year: 2014 Plaintiff: BRE/ESA Portfolio LLC, et al Appraiser: Ned Chappell Tax Case: TX2018-000189 Attorney: Jack O'Connor Number of Parcels: 14 Date: 11/14/2023 14 Parcels Prepared by: Parcel #s: See Attached Plaintiff: LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 15,338,707 31,938,093 47,276,800 See Parcel RECOMMENDED: 15,338,707 27,979,553 43,318,260 TASRs Chappell/Procaccini Tax Case: TX2018-000189 Tax Year: 2015 BRE ESA PORTFOLIO LLC et al *** C O V E R S H E E T *** _____________________________________________________________ TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Maricopa County 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 County Atty: O'CONNOR JACK Date: 10/05/2023 Parcel Allocation Page: 1 of 1 Tax Year: 2015 Plaintiff: BRE/ESA Portfolio LLC, et al Appraiser: Ned Chappell Tax Case: TX2018-000189 Attorney: Jack O'Connor Number of Parcels: 14 Date: 11/14/2023 14 Parcels Prepared by: Parcel #s: See Attached Plaintiff: LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 15,665,400 38,392,700 54,058,100 See Parcel RECOMMENDED: 15,665,400 33,815,230 49,480,630 TASRs Chappell/Procaccini Tax Case: TX2018-000189 Tax Year: 2016 BRE ESA PORTFOLIO LLC et al *** C O V E R S H E E T *** _____________________________________________________________ TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Maricopa County 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 County Atty: O'CONNOR JACK Date: 10/05/2023 Parcel Allocation Page: 1 of 1 Tax Year: 2016 Plaintiff: BRE/ESA Portfolio LLC, et al Appraiser: Ned Chappell Tax Case: TX2018-000189 Attorney: Jack O'Connor Number of Parcels: 14 Date: 11/14/2023 14 Parcels Prepared by: Parcel #s: See Attached Plaintiff: LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 18,037,700 47,460,000 65,497,700 See Parcel RECOMMENDED: 18,037,700 41,896,730 59,934,430 TASRs Chappell/Procaccini Tax Case: TX2018-000189 Tax Year: 2017 BRE ESA PORTFOLIO LLC et al *** C O V E R S H E E T *** _____________________________________________________________ TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Maricopa County 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 County Atty: O'CONNOR JACK Date: 10/06/2023 Parcel Allocation Page: 1 of 1 Tax Year: 2017 Plaintiff: BRE/ESA Portfolio LLC, et al Appraiser: Ned Chappell Tax Case: TX2018-000189 Attorney: Jack O'Connor Number of Parcels: 14 2018 - 2023 Date: 11/16/2023 1 Parcel Prepared by: Parcel #: See Attached Plaintiff: LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 9,110,243 7,133,857 16,244,100 See Parcel RECOMMENDED: 9,110,243 5,509,447 14,619,690 TASRs Procaccini Tax Case: TX2017-000029 Tax Year: 2018 GD KS ACQUISITION COMPANY LLC *** C O V E R S H E E T *** _____________________________________________________________ TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Maricopa County 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 County Atty: JEFFREY MESSING Tax Case: TX2017-000029 Attorney: JEFFREY MESSING Number of Parcels: 1 Date: 10/16/2023 Parcel Allocation Page: 1 of 1 Tax Year: 2018 Plaintiff: GD KS ACQUISITION COMPANY LLC Appraiser: Tom Hoover Ü¿¬»æ ïïñïêñîðîí Date: 11/16/2023 1 Parcel Prepared by: Parcel #: See Attached Plaintiff: LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 9,110,243 7,133,857 16,244,100 See Parcel RECOMMENDED: 9,110,243 5,509,447 14,619,690 TASRs Procaccini Tax Case: TX2017-000029 Tax Year: 2019 GD KS ACQUISITION COMPANY LLC *** C O V E R S H E E T *** _____________________________________________________________ TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Maricopa County 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 County Atty: JEFFREY MESSING Date: 10/16/2023 Parcel Allocation Page: 1 of 1 Tax Year: 2019 Plaintiff: GD KS ACQUISITION COMPANY LLC Appraiser: Tom Hoover Tax Case: TX2017-000029 Attorney: JEFFREY MESSING Number of Parcels: 1 Ü¿¬»æ ïïñïêñîðîí Date: 11/16/2023 1 Parcel Prepared by: Parcel #: See Attached Plaintiff: LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 9,984,700 8,027,600 18,012,300 See Parcel RECOMMENDED: 9,984,700 6,226,370 16,211,070 TASRs Procaccini Tax Case: TX2017-000029 Tax Year: 2020 GD KS ACQUISITION COMPANY LLC *** C O V E R S H E E T *** _____________________________________________________________ TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Maricopa County 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 County Atty: JEFFREY MESSING Date: 10/16/2023 Parcel Allocation Page: 1 of 1 Tax Year: 2020 Plaintiff: GD KS ACQUISITION COMPANY LLC Appraiser: Tom Hoover Tax Case: TX2017-000029 Attorney: JEFFREY MESSING Number of Parcels: 1 Ü¿¬»æ ïïñïêñîðîí Date: 11/16/2023 1 Parcel Prepared by: Parcel #: See Attached Plaintiff: LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 11,134,800 8,021,200 19,156,000 See Parcel RECOMMENDED: 11,134,800 6,105,600 17,240,400 TASRs Procaccini Tax Case: TX2017-000029 Tax Year: 2021 GD KS ACQUISITION COMPANY LLC *** C O V E R S H E E T *** _____________________________________________________________ TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Maricopa County 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 County Atty: JEFFREY MESSING Date: 10/16/2023 Parcel Allocation Page: 1 of 1 Tax Year: 2021 Plaintiff: GD KS ACQUISITION COMPANY LLC Appraiser: Tom Hoover Tax Case: TX2017-000029 Attorney: JEFFREY MESSING Number of Parcels: 1 Ü¿¬»æ ïïñïêñîðîí Date: 11/16/2023 1 Parcel Prepared by: Parcel #: See Attached Plaintiff: LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 11,134,800 8,138,500 19,273,300 See Parcel RECOMMENDED: 11,134,800 6,211,170 17,345,970 TASRs Procaccini Tax Case: TX2017-000029 Tax Year: 2022 GD KS ACQUISITION COMPANY LLC *** C O V E R S H E E T *** _____________________________________________________________ TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Maricopa County 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 County Atty: JEFFREY MESSING Date: 10/16/2023 Parcel Allocation Page: 1 of 1 Tax Year: 2022 Plaintiff: GD KS ACQUISITION COMPANY LLC Appraiser: Tom Hoover Tax Case: TX2017-000029 Attorney: JEFFREY MESSING Number of Parcels: 1 Ü¿¬»æ ïïñïêñîðîí Date: 11/16/2023 1 Parcel Prepared by: Parcel #: See Attached Plaintiff: LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 10,634,200 8,920,800 19,555,000 See Parcel RECOMMENDED: 10,634,200 6,965,300 17,599,500 TASRs Procaccini Tax Case: TX2017-000029 Tax Year: 2023 GD KS ACQUISITION COMPANY LLC *** C O V E R S H E E T *** _____________________________________________________________ TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Maricopa County 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 County Atty: JEFFREY MESSING Date: 10/16/2023 Parcel Allocation Page: 1 of 1 Tax Year: 2023 Plaintiff: GD KS ACQUISITION COMPANY LLC Appraiser: Tom Hoover Tax Case: TX2017-000029 Attorney: JEFFREY MESSING Number of Parcels: 1 Ü¿¬»æ ïïñïêñîðîí Date: 11/16/2023 1 Parcel Prepared by: Parcel #: See Attached Plaintiff: LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 3,140,900 6,260,200 9,401,100 See Parcel RECOMMENDED: 3,140,900 5,320,090 8,460,990 TASRs Procaccini Tax Case: TX2017-000030 Tax Year: 2018 VESTAR LPTC LLC *** C O V E R S H E E T *** _____________________________________________________________ TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Maricopa County 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 County Atty: JEFFREY MESSING Date: 10/16/2023 Parcel Allocation Page: 1 of 1 Tax Year: 2018 Plaintiff: VESTAR LPTC LLC Appraiser: Tom Hoover Tax Case: TX2017-000030 Attorney: JEFFREY MESSING Number of Parcels: 1 Ü¿¬»æ ïïñïêñîðîí Date: 11/16/2023 1 Parcel Prepared by: Parcel #: See Attached Plaintiff: LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 3,351,800 6,276,900 9,628,700 See Parcel RECOMMENDED: 3,351,800 5,314,030 8,665,830 TASRs Procaccini Tax Case: TX2017-000030 Tax Year: 2019 VESTAR LPTC LLC *** C O V E R S H E E T *** _____________________________________________________________ TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Maricopa County 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 County Atty: JEFFREY MESSING Date: 10/16/2023 Parcel Allocation Page: 1 of 1 Tax Year: 2019 Plaintiff: VESTAR LPTC LLC Appraiser: Tom Hoover Tax Case: TX2017-000030 Attorney: JEFFREY MESSING Number of Parcels: 1 Ü¿¬»æ ïïñïêñîðîí Date: 11/16/2023 1 Parcel Prepared by: Parcel #: See Attached Plaintiff: LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 4,357,400 6,449,900 10,807,300 See Parcel RECOMMENDED: 4,357,400 5,369,170 9,726,570 TASRs Procaccini Tax Case: TX2017-000030 Tax Year: 2020 VESTAR LPTC LLC *** C O V E R S H E E T *** _____________________________________________________________ TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Maricopa County 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 County Atty: JEFFREY MESSING Date: 10/16/2023 Parcel Allocation Page: 1 of 1 Tax Year: 2020 Plaintiff: VESTAR LPTC LLC Appraiser: Tom Hoover Tax Case: TX2017-000030 Attorney: JEFFREY MESSING Number of Parcels: 1 Ü¿¬»æ ïïñïêñîðîí Date: 11/16/2023 1 Parcel Prepared by: Parcel #: See Attached Plaintiff: LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 3,348,800 6,205,000 9,553,800 See Parcel RECOMMENDED: 3,348,800 5,249,620 8,598,420 TASRs Procaccini Tax Case: TX2017-000030 Tax Year: 2021 VESTAR LPTC LLC *** C O V E R S H E E T *** _____________________________________________________________ TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Maricopa County 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 County Atty: JEFFREY MESSING Date: 10/16/2023 Parcel Allocation Page: 1 of 1 Tax Year: 2021 Plaintiff: VESTAR LPTC LLC Appraiser: Tom Hoover Tax Case: TX2017-000030 Attorney: JEFFREY MESSING Number of Parcels: 1 Ü¿¬»æ ïïñïêñîðîí Date: 11/16/2023 1 Parcel Prepared by: Parcel #: See Attached Plaintiff: LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 3,384,900 6,171,700 9,556,600 See Parcel RECOMMENDED: 3,384,900 5,216,040 8,600,940 TASRs Procaccini Tax Case: TX2017-000030 Tax Year: 2022 VESTAR LPTC LLC *** C O V E R S H E E T *** _____________________________________________________________ TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Maricopa County 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 County Atty: JEFFREY MESSING Date: 10/16/2023 Parcel Allocation Page: 1 of 1 Tax Year: 2022 Plaintiff: VESTAR LPTC LLC Appraiser: Tom Hoover Tax Case: TX2017-000030 Attorney: JEFFREY MESSING Number of Parcels: 1 Ü¿¬»æ ïïñïêñîðîí Date: 11/16/2023 1 Parcel Prepared by: Parcel #: See Attached Plaintiff: LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 3,440,200 6,540,700 9,980,900 See Parcel RECOMMENDED: 3,440,200 5,542,610 8,982,810 TASRs Procaccini Tax Case: TX2017-000030 Tax Year: 2023 VESTAR LPTC LLC *** C O V E R S H E E T *** _____________________________________________________________ TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Maricopa County 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 County Atty: JEFFREY MESSING Date: 10/16/2023 Parcel Allocation Page: 1 of 1 Tax Year: 2023 Plaintiff: VESTAR LPTC LLC Appraiser: Tom Hoover Tax Case: TX2017-000030 Attorney: JEFFREY MESSING Number of Parcels: 1 Ü¿¬»æ ïïñïêñîðîí Date: 11/17/2023 1 Parcel Prepared by: Parcel #: See Attached Plaintiff: LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 2,041,600 6,390,900 8,432,500 See Parcel RECOMMENDED: 2,041,600 5,547,650 7,589,250 TASRs Procaccini Tax Case: TX2017-000145 Tax Year: 2018 KOHLS DEPARTMENT STORES INC *** C O V E R S H E E T *** _____________________________________________________________ TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Maricopa County 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 County Atty: JEFFREY MESSING Tax Case: TX2017-000145 Attorney: JEFFREY MESSING Number of Parcels: 1 Date: 10/16/2023 Parcel Allocation Page: 1 of 1 Tax Year: 2018 Plaintiff: KOHLS DEPARTMENT STORES INC Appraiser: Tom Hoover Ü¿¬»æ ïïñïéñîðîí Date: 11/17/2023 1 Parcel Prepared by: Parcel #: See Attached Plaintiff: LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 1,803,500 6,425,500 8,229,000 See Parcel RECOMMENDED: 1,803,500 5,602,600 7,406,100 TASRs Procaccini Tax Case: TX2017-000145 Tax Year: 2019 KOHL'S DEPARTMENT STORES INC *** C O V E R S H E E T *** _____________________________________________________________ TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Maricopa County 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 County Atty: JEFFREY MESSING Date: 10/16/2023 Parcel Allocation Page: 1 of 1 Tax Year: 2019 Plaintiff: KOHLS DEPARTMENT STORES INC Appraiser: Tom Hoover Tax Case: TX2017-000145 Attorney: JEFFREY MESSING Number of Parcels: 1 Ü¿¬»æ ïïñïéñîðîí Date: 11/17/2023 1 Parcel Prepared by: Parcel #: See Attached Plaintiff: LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 1,726,600 6,617,000 8,343,600 See Parcel RECOMMENDED: 1,726,600 5,782,640 7,509,240 TASRs Procaccini Tax Case: TX2017-000145 Tax Year: 2020 KOHL'S DEPARTMENT STORES INC *** C O V E R S H E E T *** _____________________________________________________________ TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Maricopa County 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 County Atty: JEFFREY MESSING Date: 10/16/2023 Parcel Allocation Page: 1 of 1 Tax Year: 2020 Plaintiff: KOHLS DEPARTMENT STORES INC Appraiser: Tom Hoover Tax Case: TX2017-000145 Attorney: JEFFREY MESSING Number of Parcels: 1 Ü¿¬»æ ïïñïéñîðîí ÒñÝ Date: 11/17/2023 1 Parcel Prepared by: Parcel #: See Attached Plaintiff: LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 3,103,900 6,521,300 9,625,200 See Parcel RECOMMENDED: 3,103,900 4,453,860 7,557,760 TASRs Procaccini Tax Case: TX2017-000145 Tax Year: 2021 KOHLS DEPARTMENT STORES INC *** C O V E R S H E E T *** _____________________________________________________________ TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Maricopa County 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 County Atty: JEFFREY MESSING Date: 10/16/2023 Parcel Allocation Page: 1 of 1 Tax Year: 2021 Plaintiff: KOHLS DEPARTMENT STORES INC Appraiser: Tom Hoover Tax Case: TX2017-000145 Attorney: JEFFREY MESSING Number of Parcels: 1 Ü¿¬»æ ïïñïéñîðîí Date: 11/17/2023 1 Parcel Prepared by: Parcel #: See Attached Plaintiff: LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 3,103,900 6,601,200 9,705,100 See Parcel RECOMMENDED: 3,103,900 3,981,500 7,085,400 TASRs Procaccini Tax Case: TX2017-000145 Tax Year: 2022 KOHL'S DEPARTMENT STORES INC *** C O V E R S H E E T *** _____________________________________________________________ TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Maricopa County 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 County Atty: JEFFREY MESSING Date: 10/16/2023 Parcel Allocation Page: 1 of 1 Tax Year: 2022 Plaintiff: KOHLS DEPARTMENT STORES INC Appraiser: Tom Hoover Tax Case: TX2017-000145 Attorney: JEFFREY MESSING Number of Parcels: 1 Ü¿¬»æ ïïñïéñîðîí Date: 11/17/2023 1 Parcel Prepared by: Parcel #: See Attached Plaintiff: LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 3,182,700 7,193,900 10,376,600 See Parcel RECOMMENDED: 3,182,700 3,902,700 7,085,400 TASRs Procaccini Tax Case: TX2017-000145 Tax Year: 2023 KOHL'S DEPARTMENT STORES INC *** C O V E R S H E E T *** _____________________________________________________________ TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Maricopa County 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 County Atty: JEFFREY MESSING Date: 10/16/2023 Parcel Allocation Page: 1 of 1 Tax Year: 2023 Plaintiff: KOHLS DEPARTMENT STORES INC Appraiser: Tom Hoover Tax Case: TX2017-000145 Attorney: JEFFREY MESSING Number of Parcels: 1 Ü¿¬»æ ïïñïéñîðîí Date: 11/17/2023 1 Parcel Prepared by: Parcel #: See Attached Plaintiff: LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 2,936,519 6,204,081 9,140,600 See Parcel RECOMMENDED: 2,936,519 4,166,121 7,102,640 TASRs Procaccini Tax Case: TX2017-000146 Tax Year: 2018 KOHL'S DEPARTMENT STORES INC *** C O V E R S H E E T *** _____________________________________________________________ TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Maricopa County 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 County Atty: JEFFREY MESSING Date: 10/16/2023 Parcel Allocation Page: 1 of 1 Tax Year: 2018 Plaintiff: KOHLS DEPARTMENT STORES INC Appraiser: Tom Hoover Tax Case: TX2017-000146 Attorney: JEFFREY MESSING Number of Parcels: 1 Ü¿¬»æ ïïñïéñîðîí Date: 11/17/2023 1 Parcel Prepared by: Parcel #: See Attached Plaintiff: LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 2,936,519 6,204,081 9,140,600 See Parcel RECOMMENDED: 2,936,519 4,166,121 7,102,640 TASRs Procaccini Tax Case: TX2017-000146 Tax Year: 2019 KOHL'S DEPARTMENT STORES INC *** C O V E R S H E E T *** _____________________________________________________________ TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Maricopa County 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 County Atty: JEFFREY MESSING Date: 10/16/2023 Parcel Allocation Page: 1 of 1 Tax Year: 2019 Plaintiff: KOHLS DEPARTMENT STORES INC Appraiser: Tom Hoover Tax Case: TX2017-000146 Attorney: JEFFREY MESSING Number of Parcels: 1 Ü¿¬»æ ïïñïéñîðîí Date: 11/17/2023 1 Parcel Prepared by: Parcel #: See Attached Plaintiff: LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 4,351,000 7,656,500 12,007,500 See Parcel RECOMMENDED: 4,351,000 2,751,640 7,102,640 TASRs Procaccini Tax Case: TX2017-000146 Tax Year: 2020 KOHL'S DEPARTMENT STORES INC *** C O V E R S H E E T *** _____________________________________________________________ TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Maricopa County 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 County Atty: JEFFREY MESSING Date: 10/16/2023 Parcel Allocation Page: 1 of 1 Tax Year: 2020 Plaintiff: KOHLS DEPARTMENT STORES INC Appraiser: Tom Hoover Tax Case: TX2017-000146 Attorney: JEFFREY MESSING Number of Parcels: 1 Ü¿¬»æ ïïñïéñîðîí Date: 11/17/2023 1 Parcel Prepared by: Parcel #: See Attached Plaintiff: LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 4,041,900 7,655,400 11,697,300 See Parcel RECOMMENDED: 4,041,900 3,060,740 7,102,640 TASRs Procaccini Tax Case: TX2017-000146 Tax Year: 2021 KOHL'S DEPARTMENT STORES INC *** C O V E R S H E E T *** _____________________________________________________________ TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Maricopa County 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 County Atty: JEFFREY MESSING Date: 10/16/2023 Parcel Allocation Page: 1 of 1 Tax Year: 2021 Plaintiff: KOHLS DEPARTMENT STORES INC Appraiser: Tom Hoover Tax Case: TX2017-000146 Attorney: JEFFREY MESSING Number of Parcels: 1 Ü¿¬»æ ïïñïéñîðîí Date: 11/17/2023 1 Parcel Prepared by: Parcel #: See Attached Plaintiff: LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 4,041,900 7,771,100 11,813,000 See Parcel RECOMMENDED: 4,041,900 3,060,740 7,102,640 TASRs Procaccini Tax Case: TX2017-000146 Tax Year: 2022 KOHL'S DEPARTMENT STORES INC *** C O V E R S H E E T *** _____________________________________________________________ TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Maricopa County 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 County Atty: JEFFREY MESSING Date: 10/16/2023 Parcel Allocation Page: 1 of 1 Tax Year: 2022 Plaintiff: KOHLS DEPARTMENT STORES INC Appraiser: Tom Hoover Tax Case: TX2017-000146 Attorney: JEFFREY MESSING Number of Parcels: 1 Ü¿¬»æ ïïñïéñîðîí Date: 11/17/2023 1 Parcel Prepared by: Parcel #: See Attached Plaintiff: LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 3,187,800 8,604,200 11,792,000 See Parcel RECOMMENDED: 3,187,800 3,914,840 7,102,640 TASRs Procaccini Tax Case: TX2017-000146 Tax Year: 2023 KOHL'S DEPARTMENT STORES INC *** C O V E R S H E E T *** _____________________________________________________________ TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Maricopa County 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 County Atty: JEFFREY MESSING Date: 10/16/2023 Parcel Allocation Page: 1 of 1 Tax Year: 2023 Plaintiff: KOHLS DEPARTMENT STORES INC Appraiser: Tom Hoover Tax Case: TX2017-000146 Attorney: JEFFREY MESSING Number of Parcels: 1 Ü¿¬»æ ïïñïéñîðîí Date: 11/17/2023 1 Parcel Prepared by: Parcel #: See Attached Plaintiff: LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 1,806,000 5,840,100 7,646,100 See Parcel RECOMMENDED: 1,806,000 5,075,490 6,881,490 TASRs Procaccini Tax Case: TX2017-000147 Tax Year: 2018 BCB GROUP INVESTMENTS - TRAMONTO MARKETPLACE *** C O V E R S H E E T *** _____________________________________________________________ TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Maricopa County 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 County Atty: JEFFREY MESSING Date: 10/16/2023 Parcel Allocation Page: 1 of 1 Tax Year: 2018 Plaintiff: Appraiser: Tom Hoover BCB GROUP INVESTMENTS - TRAMONTO... Tax Case: TX2017-000147 Attorney: JEFFREY MESSING Number of Parcels: 1 Ü¿¬»æ ïïñïéñîðîí Date: 11/17/2023 1 Parcel Prepared by: Parcel #: See Attached Plaintiff: LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 1,617,400 5,865,800 7,483,200 See Parcel RECOMMENDED: 1,617,400 5,117,480 6,734,880 TASRs Procaccini Tax Case: TX2017-000147 Tax Year: 2019 BCB GROUP INVESTMENTS - TRAMONTO MARKETPLACE *** C O V E R S H E E T *** _____________________________________________________________ TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Maricopa County 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 County Atty: JEFFREY MESSING Date: 10/16/2023 Parcel Allocation Page: 1 of 1 Tax Year: 2019 Plaintiff: Appraiser: Tom Hoover BCB GROUP INVESTMENTS - TRAMONTO… Tax Case: TX2017-000147 Attorney: JEFFREY MESSING Number of Parcels: 1 Ü¿¬»æ ïïñïéñîðîí Date: 11/17/2023 1 Parcel Prepared by: Parcel #: See Attached Plaintiff: LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 1,654,000 6,028,400 7,682,400 See Parcel RECOMMENDED: 1,654,000 5,260,160 6,914,160 TASRs Procaccini Tax Case: TX2017-000147 Tax Year: 2020 BCB GROUP INVESTMENTS - TRAMONTO MARKETPLACE *** C O V E R S H E E T *** _____________________________________________________________ TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Maricopa County 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 County Atty: JEFFREY MESSING BCB GROUP INVESTMENTS - TRAMONTO... MA Date: 10/16/2023 Parcel Allocation Page: 1 of 1 Tax Year: 2020 Plaintiff: Appraiser: Tom Hoover Tax Case: TX2017-000147 Attorney: JEFFREY MESSING Number of Parcels: 1 Ü¿¬»æ ïïñïéñîðîí Date: 11/17/2023 1 Parcel Prepared by: Parcel #: See Attached Plaintiff: LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 2,326,700 6,268,000 8,594,700 See Parcel RECOMMENDED: 2,326,700 4,704,180 7,030,880 TASRs Procaccini Tax Case: TX2017-000147 Tax Year: 2021 BCB GROUP INVESTMENTS - TRAMONTO MARKETPLACE *** C O V E R S H E E T *** _____________________________________________________________ TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Maricopa County 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 County Atty: JEFFREY MESSING BCB GROUP INVESTMENTS - TRAMONTO… Date: 10/16/2023 Parcel Allocation Page: 1 of 1 Tax Year: 2021 Plaintiff: Appraiser: Tom Hoover Tax Case: TX2017-000147 Attorney: JEFFREY MESSING Number of Parcels: 1 Ü¿¬»æ ïïñïéñîðîí Date: 11/17/2023 1 Parcel Prepared by: Parcel #: See Attached Plaintiff: LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 2,326,700 6,278,200 8,604,900 See Parcel RECOMMENDED: 2,326,700 4,264,750 6,591,450 TASRs Procaccini Tax Case: TX2017-000147 Tax Year: 2022 BCB GROUP INVESTMENTS - TRAMONTO MARKETPLACE *** C O V E R S H E E T *** _____________________________________________________________ TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Maricopa County 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 County Atty: JEFFREY MESSING Date: 10/16/2023 Parcel Allocation Page: 1 of 1 Tax Year: 2022 Plaintiff: Appraiser: Tom Hoover BCB GROUP INVESTMENTS - TRAMONTO… Tax Case: TX2017-000147 Attorney: JEFFREY MESSING Number of Parcels: 1 Ü¿¬»æ ïïñïéñîðîí Date: 11/17/2023 1 Parcel Prepared by: Parcel #: See Attached Plaintiff: LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 1,913,400 6,833,000 8,746,400 See Parcel RECOMMENDED: 1,913,400 4,678,050 6,591,450 TASRs Procaccini Tax Case: TX2017-000147 Tax Year: 2023 BCB GROUP INVESTMENTS - TRAMONTO MARKETPLACE *** C O V E R S H E E T *** _____________________________________________________________ TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Maricopa County 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 County Atty: JEFFREY MESSING Date: 10/16/2023 Parcel Allocation Page: 1 of 1 Tax Year: 2023 Plaintiff: Appraiser: Tom Hoover BCB GROUP INVESTMENTS-TRAMONTO… Tax Case: TX2017-000147 Attorney: JEFFREY MESSING Number of Parcels: 1 Ü¿¬»æ ïïñïéñîðîí Date: 11/17/2023 1 Parcel Prepared by: Parcel #: See Attached Plaintiff: LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 2,039,100 5,356,500 7,395,600 See Parcel RECOMMENDED: 2,039,100 4,616,940 6,656,040 TASRs Procaccini Tax Case: TX2018-000644 Tax Year: 2018 SPIRIT REALTY LP *** C O V E R S H E E T *** _____________________________________________________________ TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Maricopa County 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 County Atty: JEFFREY MESSING Date: 10/16/2023 Parcel Allocation Page: 1 of 1 Tax Year: 2018 Plaintiff: SPIRIT REALTY LP Appraiser: Tom Hoover Tax Case: TX2018-000644 Attorney: JEFFREY MESSING Number of Parcels: 1 Ü¿¬»æ ïïñïéñîðîí Date: 11/17/2023 1 Parcel Prepared by: Parcel #: See Attached Plaintiff: LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 2,465,100 5,417,200 7,882,300 See Parcel RECOMMENDED: 2,465,100 4,628,970 7,094,070 TASRs Procaccini Tax Case: TX2018-000644 Tax Year: 2019 SPIRIT REALTY LP *** C O V E R S H E E T *** _____________________________________________________________ TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Maricopa County 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 County Atty: JEFFREY MESSING Date: 10/16/2023 Parcel Allocation Page: 1 of 1 Tax Year: 2019 Plaintiff: SPIRIT REALTY LP Appraiser: Tom Hoover Tax Case: TX2018-000644 Attorney: JEFFREY MESSING Number of Parcels: 1 Ü¿¬»æ ïïñïéñîðîí Date: 11/17/2023 1 Parcel Prepared by: Parcel #: See Attached Plaintiff: LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 2,893,500 5,470,300 8,363,800 See Parcel RECOMMENDED: 2,893,500 4,633,920 7,527,420 TASRs Procaccini Tax Case: TX2018-000644 Tax Year: 2020 SPIRIT REALTY LP *** C O V E R S H E E T *** _____________________________________________________________ TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Maricopa County 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 County Atty: JEFFREY MESSING Date: 10/16/2023 Parcel Allocation Page: 1 of 1 Tax Year: 2020 Plaintiff: SPIRIT REALTY LP Appraiser: Tom Hoover Tax Case: TX2018-000644 Attorney: JEFFREY MESSING Number of Parcels: 1 Ü¿¬»æ ïïñïéñîðîí Date: 11/17/2023 1 Parcel Prepared by: Parcel #: See Attached Plaintiff: LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 3,092,700 5,447,300 8,540,000 See Parcel RECOMMENDED: 3,092,700 4,593,300 7,686,000 TASRs Procaccini Tax Case: TX2018-000644 Tax Year: 2021 SPIRIT REALTY LP *** C O V E R S H E E T *** _____________________________________________________________ TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Maricopa County 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 County Atty: JEFFREY MESSING Date: 10/16/2023 Parcel Allocation Page: 1 of 1 Tax Year: 2021 Plaintiff: SPIRIT REALTY LP Appraiser: Tom Hoover Tax Case: TX2018-000644 Attorney: JEFFREY MESSING Number of Parcels: 1 Ü¿¬»æ ïïñïéñîðîí Date: 11/17/2023 1 Parcel Prepared by: Parcel #: See Attached Plaintiff: LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 3,092,700 5,341,000 8,433,700 See Parcel RECOMMENDED: 3,092,700 4,497,630 7,590,330 TASRs Procaccini Tax Case: TX2018-000644 Tax Year: 2022 SPIRIT REALTY LP *** C O V E R S H E E T *** _____________________________________________________________ TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Maricopa County 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 County Atty: JEFFREY MESSING Date: 10/16/2023 Parcel Allocation Page: 1 of 1 Tax Year: 2022 Plaintiff: SPIRIT REALTY LP Appraiser: Tom Hoover Tax Case: TX2018-000644 Attorney: JEFFREY MESSING Number of Parcels: 1 Ü¿¬»æ ïïñïéñîðîí Date: 11/17/2023 1 Parcel Prepared by: Parcel #: See Attached Plaintiff: LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 4,391,800 5,790,800 10,182,600 See Parcel RECOMMENDED: 4,391,800 4,772,540 9,164,340 TASRs Procaccini Tax Case: TX2018-000644 Tax Year: 2023 SPIRIT REALTY LP *** C O V E R S H E E T *** _____________________________________________________________ TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Maricopa County 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 County Atty: JEFFREY MESSING Date: 10/16/2023 Parcel Allocation Page: 1 of 1 Tax Year: 2023 Plaintiff: SPIRIT REALTY LP Appraiser: Tom Hoover Tax Case: TX2018-000644 Attorney: JEFFREY MESSING Number of Parcels: 1 Ü¿¬»æ ïïñïéñîðîí 2019 - 2023 Date: 11/17/2023 1 Parcel Prepared by: Parcel #: See Attached Plaintiff: LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 1,973,400 6,974,900 8,948,300 See Parcel RECOMMENDED: 1,973,400 6,080,070 8,053,470 TASRs Procaccini Tax Case: TX2018-000645 Tax Year: 2019 CONTINENTAL SURPRISE LLC *** C O V E R S H E E T *** _____________________________________________________________ TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Maricopa County 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 County Atty: JEFFREY MESSING Date: 10/16/2023 Parcel Allocation Page: 1 of 1 Tax Year: 2019 Plaintiff: CONTINENTAL SURPRISE LLC Appraiser: Tom Hoover Tax Case: TX2018-000645 Attorney: JEFFREY MESSING Number of Parcels: 1 Ü¿¬»æ ïïñïéñîðîí Date: 11/17/2023 1 Parcel Prepared by: Parcel #: See Attached Plaintiff: LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 1,886,900 7,266,600 9,153,500 See Parcel RECOMMENDED: 1,886,900 6,351,250 8,238,150 TASRs Procaccini Tax Case: TX2018-000645 Tax Year: 2020 CONTINENTAL SURPRISE LLC *** C O V E R S H E E T *** _____________________________________________________________ TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Maricopa County 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 County Atty: JEFFREY MESSING Date: 10/16/2023 Parcel Allocation Page: 1 of 1 Tax Year: 2020 Plaintiff: CONTINENTAL SURPRISE LLC Appraiser: Tom Hoover Tax Case: TX2018-000645 Attorney: JEFFREY MESSING Number of Parcels: 1 Ü¿¬»æ ïïñïéñîðîí Date: 11/17/2023 1 Parcel Prepared by: Parcel #: See Attached Plaintiff: LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 3,140,800 7,261,200 10,402,000 See Parcel RECOMMENDED: 3,140,800 6,221,000 9,361,800 TASRs Procaccini Tax Case: TX2018-000645 Tax Year: 2021 CONTINENTAL SURPRISE LLC *** C O V E R S H E E T *** _____________________________________________________________ TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Maricopa County 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 County Atty: JEFFREY MESSING Date: 10/16/2023 Parcel Allocation Page: 1 of 1 Tax Year: 2021 Plaintiff: CONTINENTAL SURPRISE LLC Appraiser: Tom Hoover Tax Case: TX2018-000645 Attorney: JEFFREY MESSING Number of Parcels: 1 Ü¿¬»æ ïïñïéñîðîí Date: 11/17/2023 1 Parcel Prepared by: Parcel #: See Attached Plaintiff: LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 3,140,800 7,375,400 10,516,200 See Parcel RECOMMENDED: 3,140,800 6,323,780 9,464,580 TASRs Procaccini Tax Case: TX2018-000645 Tax Year: 2022 CONTINENTAL SURPRISE LLC *** C O V E R S H E E T *** _____________________________________________________________ TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Maricopa County 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 County Atty: JEFFREY MESSING Date: 10/16/2023 Parcel Allocation Page: 1 of 1 Tax Year: 2022 Plaintiff: CONTINENTAL SURPRISE LLC Appraiser: Tom Hoover Tax Case: TX2018-000645 Attorney: JEFFREY MESSING Number of Parcels: 1 Ü¿¬»æ ïïñïéñîðîí Date: 11/17/2023 1 Parcel Prepared by: Parcel #: See Attached Plaintiff: LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 5,860,600 8,064,400 13,925,000 See Parcel RECOMMENDED: 5,860,600 6,671,900 12,532,500 TASRs Procaccini Tax Case: TX2018-000645 Tax Year: 2023 CONTINENTAL SURPRISE LLC , MAJ PLACE HD LLC et al *** C O V E R S H E E T *** _____________________________________________________________ TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Maricopa County 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 County Atty: JEFFREY MESSING Tax Case: TX2018-000645 Attorney: JEFFREY MESSING Number of Parcels: 1 Date: 10/16/2023 Parcel Allocation Page: 1 of 1 Tax Year: 2023 Plaintiff: CONTINENTAL SURPRISE LLC et al Appraiser: Tom Hoover Ü¿¬»æ ïïñïéñîðîí 2020 - 2023 Date: 11/20/2023 1 Parcel Prepared by: Parcel #: See Attached Plaintiff: LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 3,425,900 12,458,900 15,884,800 See Parcel RECOMMENDED: 3,425,900 9,324,100 12,750,000 TASRs Procaccini Tax Case: TX2019-001734 Tax Year: 2020 DILLARDS PROPERTIES INC et al *** C O V E R S H E E T *** _____________________________________________________________ TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Maricopa County 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 County Atty: JEFFREY MESSING Tax Case: TX2019-001734 Attorney: JEFFREY MESSING Number of Parcels: 1 Date: 11/13/2023 Parcel Allocation Page: 1 of 1 Tax Year: 2020 Plaintiff: DILLARDS PROPERTIES INC et al Appraiser: Tom Hoover Ü¿¬»æ ïïñîðñîðîí Date: 11/20/2023 1 Parcel Prepared by: Parcel #: See Attached Plaintiff: LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 3,260,800 12,528,300 15,789,100 See Parcel RECOMMENDED: 3,260,800 8,751,700 12,012,500 TASRs Procaccini Tax Case: TX2019-001734 Tax Year: 2021 DILLARDS PROPERTIES INC et al *** C O V E R S H E E T *** _____________________________________________________________ TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Maricopa County 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 County Atty: JEFFREY MESSING Date: 11/13/2023 Parcel Allocation Page: 1 of 1 Tax Year: 2021 Plaintiff: DILLARDS PROPERTIES INC et al Appraiser: Tom Hoover Tax Case: TX2019-001734 Attorney: JEFFREY MESSING Number of Parcels: 1 Ü¿¬»æ ïïñîðñîðîí Date: 11/20/2023 1 Parcel Prepared by: Parcel #: See Attached Plaintiff: LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 3,009,600 11,381,600 14,391,200 See Parcel RECOMMENDED: 3,009,600 7,990,400 11,000,000 TASRs Procaccini Tax Case: TX2019-001734 Tax Year: 2022 DILLARDS PROPERTIES INC et al *** C O V E R S H E E T *** _____________________________________________________________ TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Maricopa County 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 County Atty: JEFFREY MESSING Date: 11/13/2023 Parcel Allocation Page: 1 of 1 Tax Year: 2022 Plaintiff: DILLARDS PROPERTIES INC et al Appraiser: Tom Hoover Tax Case: TX2019-001734 Attorney: JEFFREY MESSING Number of Parcels: 1 Ü¿¬»æ ïïñîðñîðîí Date: 11/20/2023 1 Parcel Prepared by: Parcel #: See Attached Plaintiff: LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 5,408,000 8,469,800 13,877,800 See Parcel RECOMMENDED: 5,408,000 5,592,000 11,000,000 TASRs Procaccini Tax Case: TX2019-001734 Tax Year: 2023 DILLARDS PROPERTIES INC et al *** C O V E R S H E E T *** _____________________________________________________________ TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Maricopa County 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 County Atty: JEFFREY MESSING Date: 11/13/2023 Parcel Allocation Page: 1 of 1 Tax Year: 2023 Plaintiff: DILLARDS PROPERTIES INC et al Appraiser: Tom Hoover Tax Case: TX2019-001734 Attorney: JEFFREY MESSING Number of Parcels: 1 Ü¿¬»æ ïïñîðñîðîí 2021 - 2023 Date: 11/20/2023 1 Parcel Prepared by: Parcel #: See Attached Plaintiff: LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 1,808,500 7,250,400 9,058,900 See Parcel RECOMMENDED: 1,808,500 6,344,510 8,153,010 TASRs Procaccini Tax Case: TX2020-000710 Tax Year: 2021 KIRST PHILIP P/COLLEEN TR *** C O V E R S H E E T *** _____________________________________________________________ TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Maricopa County 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 County Atty: JEFFREY MESSING Date: 10/16/2023 Parcel Allocation Page: 1 of 1 Tax Year: 2021 Plaintiff: KIRST PHILIP P/COLLEEN TR Appraiser: Tom Hoover Tax Case: TX2020-000710 Attorney: JEFFREY MESSING Number of Parcels: 1 Ü¿¬»æ ïïñîðñîðîí Date: 11/20/2023 1 Parcel Prepared by: Parcel #: See Attached Plaintiff: LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 1,808,500 7,355,500 9,164,000 See Parcel RECOMMENDED: 1,808,500 6,439,100 8,247,600 TASRs Procaccini Tax Case: TX2020-000710 Tax Year: 2022 KIRST PHILIP P/COLLEEN TR *** C O V E R S H E E T *** _____________________________________________________________ TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Maricopa County 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 County Atty: JEFFREY MESSING Date: 10/16/2023 Parcel Allocation Page: 1 of 1 Tax Year: 2022 Plaintiff: KIRST PHILIP P/COLLEEN TR Appraiser: Tom Hoover Tax Case: TX2020-000710 Attorney: JEFFREY MESSING Number of Parcels: 1 Ü¿¬»æ ïïñîðñîðîí ÒñÝ ÒñÝ ÒñÝ Date: 11/20/2023 1 Parcel Prepared by: Parcel #: See Attached Plaintiff: LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 3,159,500 8,045,400 11,204,900 See Parcel RECOMMENDED: 3,159,500 6,924,910 10,084,410 TASRs Procaccini Tax Case: TX2020-000710 Tax Year: 2023 KIRST PHILIP P/COLLEEN TR *** C O V E R S H E E T *** _____________________________________________________________ TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Maricopa County 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 County Atty: JEFFREY MESSING Date: 10/16/2023 Parcel Allocation Page: 1 of 1 Tax Year: 2023 Plaintiff: PHILIP P. KIRST & COLLEEN KIRST, TR Appraiser: Tom Hoover Tax Case: TX2020-000710 Attorney: JEFFREY MESSING Number of Parcels: 1 Ü¿¬»æ ïïñîðñîðîí Date: 11/20/2023 1 Parcel Prepared by: Parcel #: See Attached Plaintiff: LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 2,382,800 5,330,500 7,713,300 See Parcel RECOMMENDED: 2,382,800 4,559,170 6,941,970 TASRs Procaccini Tax Case: TX2020-000711 Tax Year: 2021 SOMERVILLE MESA LIMITED PARTNERSHIP *** C O V E R S H E E T *** _____________________________________________________________ TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Maricopa County 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 County Atty: JEFFREY MESSING Date: 10/16/2023 Parcel Allocation Page: 1 of 1 Tax Year: 2021 Plaintiff: SOMERVILLE MESA LIMITED PARTNERSHIP Appraiser: Tom Hoover Tax Case: TX2020-000711 Attorney: JEFFREY MESSING Number of Parcels: 1 Ü¿¬»æ ïïñîðñîðîí Date: 11/20/2023 1 Parcel Prepared by: Parcel #: See Attached Plaintiff: LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 2,382,800 5,197,000 7,579,800 See Parcel RECOMMENDED: 2,382,800 4,439,020 6,821,820 TASRs Procaccini Tax Case: TX2020-000711 Tax Year: 2022 SOMERVILLE MESA LIMITED PARTNERSHIP *** C O V E R S H E E T *** _____________________________________________________________ TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Maricopa County 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 County Atty: JEFFREY MESSING SOMERVILLE MESA LIMITED PARTNERSHIP Date: 10/16/2023 Parcel Allocation Page: 1 of 1 Tax Year: 2022 Plaintiff: Appraiser: Tom Hoover Tax Case: TX2020-000711 Attorney: JEFFREY MESSING Number of Parcels: 1 Ü¿¬»æ ïïñîðñîðîí Date: 11/20/2023 1 Parcel Prepared by: Parcel #: See Attached Plaintiff: LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 2,684,200 5,614,800 8,299,000 See Parcel RECOMMENDED: 2,684,200 4,784,900 7,469,100 TASRs Procaccini Tax Case: TX2020-000711 Tax Year: 2023 SOMERVILLE MESA LIMITED PARTNERSHIP *** C O V E R S H E E T *** _____________________________________________________________ TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Maricopa County 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 County Atty: JEFFREY MESSING Date: 10/16/2023 Parcel Allocation Page: 1 of 1 Tax Year: 2023 Plaintiff: SOMERVILLE MESA LIMITED Appraiser: Tom Hoover Tax Case: TX2020-000711 Attorney: JEFFREY MESSING Number of Parcels: 1 Ü¿¬»æ ïïñîðñîðîí ÍÑÓÛÎÊ×ÔÔÛ ÓÛÍß ÔÐ Date: 11/20/2023 1 Parcel Prepared by: Parcel #: See Attached Plaintiff: LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 2,612,300 5,374,700 7,987,000 See Parcel RECOMMENDED: 2,612,300 4,576,000 7,188,300 TASRs Procaccini Tax Case: TX2020-000713 Tax Year: 2021 INLAND WESTERN GLENDALE LLC *** C O V E R S H E E T *** _____________________________________________________________ TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Maricopa County 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 County Atty: JEFFREY MESSING Date: 10/16/2023 Parcel Allocation Page: 1 of 1 Tax Year: 2021 Plaintiff: INLAND WESTERN GLENDALE LLC Appraiser: Tom Hoover Tax Case: TX2020-000713 Attorney: JEFFREY MESSING Number of Parcels: 1 Ü¿¬»æ ïïñîðñîðîí Date: 11/20/2023 1 Parcel Prepared by: Parcel #: See Attached Plaintiff: LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 2,612,300 5,269,100 7,881,400 See Parcel RECOMMENDED: 2,612,300 4,480,960 7,093,260 TASRs Procaccini Tax Case: TX2020-000713 Tax Year: 2022 INLAND WESTERN GLENDALE LLC *** C O V E R S H E E T *** _____________________________________________________________ TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Maricopa County 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 County Atty: JEFFREY MESSING Date: 10/16/2023 Parcel Allocation Page: 1 of 1 Tax Year: 2022 Plaintiff: INLAND WESTERN GLENDALE LLC Appraiser: Tom Hoover Tax Case: TX2020-000713 Attorney: JEFFREY MESSING Number of Parcels: 1 Ü¿¬»æ ïïñîðñîðîí Date: 11/20/2023 1 Parcel Prepared by: Parcel #: See Attached Plaintiff: LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 3,846,800 5,714,300 9,561,100 See Parcel RECOMMENDED: 3,846,800 4,758,190 8,604,990 TASRs Procaccini Tax Case: TX2020-000713 Tax Year: 2023 INLAND WESTERN GLENDALE LLC *** C O V E R S H E E T *** _____________________________________________________________ TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Maricopa County 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 County Atty: JEFFREY MESSING Date: 10/16/2023 Parcel Allocation Page: 1 of 1 Tax Year: 2023 Plaintiff: INLAND WESTERN GLENDALE LLC Appraiser: Tom Hoover Tax Case: TX2020-000713 Attorney: JEFFREY MESSING Number of Parcels: 1 Ü¿¬»æ ïïñîðñîðîí 2022 Date: 11/13/2023 1 Parcel Prepared by: Parcel #: See Attached Plaintiff: LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 3,863,564 42,811,436 46,675,000 See Parcel RECOMMENDED: 3,863,564 24,136,436 28,000,000 TASRs Chappell/Procaccini Tax Case: TX2021-000456 Tax Year: 2022 GAEDEKE HOLDINGS LTD *** C O V E R S H E E T *** _____________________________________________________________ TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Maricopa County 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 County Atty: MUTHIG KLAUS PETER Date: 09/19/2023 Parcel Allocation Page: 1 of 1 Tax Year: 2022 Plaintiff: GAEDEKE HOLDINGS LTD Appraiser: CHAPPELL NED Tax Case: TX2021-000456 Attorney: MUTHIG KLAUS PETER Number of Parcels: 1 Ü¿¬»æ ïïñïíñîðîí 2023 Date: 11/13/2023 1 Parcel Prepared by: Parcel #: See Attached Plaintiff: LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 3,863,564 42,811,436 46,675,000 See Parcel RECOMMENDED: 3,863,564 24,136,436 28,000,000 TASRs Chappell/Procaccini Tax Case: TX2022-000432 Tax Year: 2023 GAEDEKE HOLDINGS LTD *** C O V E R S H E E T *** _____________________________________________________________ TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Maricopa County 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 County Atty: MUTHIG KLAUS PETER Date: 10/23/2023 Parcel Allocation Page: 1 of 1 Tax Year: 2023 Plaintiff: GAEDEKE HOLDINGS LTD Appraiser: CHAPPELL NED Tax Case: TX2022-000432 Attorney: MUTHIG KLAUS PETER Number of Parcels: 1 Date: 11/08/2023 1 Parcel Prepared by: Parcel #: See Attached Plaintiff: LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 3,547,415 0 3,547,415 See Parcel RECOMMENDED: 56,800 0 56,800 TASRs Chappell/Procaccini Tax Case: TX2022-000446 Tax Year: 2023 COTTON BETHANY LLC/303 COTTON LLC *** C O V E R S H E E T *** _____________________________________________________________ TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Maricopa County 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 County Atty: PETER MUTHIG Current: Parcel Class PUC LPV Class 50103009N 2.R @15.0% 4110 N/C 56,800 N/C 56,800 B9 3,547,415 0 3,547,415 997,884 56,800 0 56,800 0034 3,547,415 0 3,547,415 997,884 Recommended: PUC Land Impr FCV LPV Land Impr FCV Rule Tax Case: TX2022-000446 Attorney: PETER MUTHIG Number of Parcels: 1 Date: 11/08/2023 Parcel Allocation Page: 1 of 1 Tax Year: 2023 Plaintiff: Appraiser: NED CHAPPELL COTTON BETHANY LLC/303 COTTON LLC Date: 11/20/2023 1 Parcel Prepared by: Parcel #: See Attached Plaintiff: LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 5,700,600 8,166,900 13,867,500 See Parcel RECOMMENDED: 5,700,600 6,059,400 11,760,000 TASRs Procaccini Tax Case: TX2020-000714 Tax Year: 2023 IA AVONDALE LLC *** C O V E R S H E E T *** _____________________________________________________________ TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Maricopa County 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 County Atty: JEFFREY MESSING Tax Case: TX2020-000714 Attorney: JEFFREY MESSING Number of Parcels: 1 Date: 10/17/2023 Parcel Allocation Page: 1 of 1 Tax Year: 2023 Plaintiff: IA AVONDALE LLC Appraiser: Tom Hoover Ü¿¬»æ ïïñîðñîðîí Ó·¨»¼ Date: 11/21/2023 1 Parcel Prepared by: Parcel #: See Attached Plaintiff: LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 3,056,300 13,058,800 16,115,100 See Parcel RECOMMENDED: 3,056,300 3,823,700 6,880,000 TASRs Hoover/Procaccini Tax Case: TX2022-000441 Tax Year: 2023 CRESCENT 2400 LLC *** C O V E R S H E E T *** _____________________________________________________________ TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Maricopa County 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 County Atty: MUTHIG KLAUS PETER Date: 09/14/2023 Parcel Allocation Page: 1 of 1 Tax Year: 2023 Plaintiff: CRESCENT 2400 LLC Appraiser: HOOVER TOM Tax Case: TX2022-000441 Attorney: MUTHIG KLAUS PETER Number of Parcels: 1 2024 Date: 11/02/2023 1 Parcel Prepared by: Parcel #: See Attached Plaintiff: LAND IMPS FCV RATIO CURRENT 3,714,800 764,626 4,479,426 See Parcel RECOMMENDED: 1,450,000 1,350,000 2,800,000 TASR HOOVER / PROCACCINI Tax Case: TX2023-000209 Tax Year: 2024 HPPC LLC *** C O V E R S H E E T *** _____________________________________________________________ TAX APPEAL SETTLEMENT RECOMMENDATION Maricopa County 301 West Jefferson Phoenix, AZ 85003 County Atty: PETER MUTHIG Date: 10/24/2023 Parcel Allocation Page: 1 of 1 Tax Year: 2024 Plaintiff: HPPC LLC Appraiser: TOM HOOVER Tax Case: TX2023-000209 Attorney: PETER MUTHIG Number of Parcels: 1 ïïñðîñîðîí