Public Comments as of 10-31-23

Chandler resident comments are highlighted in yellow (NOTE: Some respondents listed their city as "Chandler," but with an address outside the City limits.)
Serial 
number
Created
Name: First 
Name
Name: Last 
Name
Organization
Address: Address
Address: 
Address 2
Address: 
City/Town
Address: 
State/Province
Address: 
ZIP/Postal 
Code
Comments
1
10/25/2023 19:03
Dee
Bloom
10251 N 100th pl
scottsdale
Arizona
85258
Chandler   please do something to take animal cruelty out of your city and prosecute these people who are inhuman !!!  0please let me know what 
i can do to help  i have donated money to az humane society
2
10/25/2023 19:05
gregg
kuntz
7740 Gainey Ranch 48
scottsdale
Arizona
85258
Chandler   please do something to take animal cruelty out of your city and prosecute these people who are inhuman !!!  please let me know what i 
can do to help  i have donated money to az humane society
3
10/25/2023 20:27
Christine
Beatty
Helping any animal in need
3310 West Bell Road
146
Phoenix
Arizona
85053
Dear Chandler City Council,I write to express my profound anger and frustration with the lackadaisical  concerns regarding the definition of animal 
cruelty within the community. It is deeply disheartening to witness the unnecessary delay in protecting innocent animals from harm while the 
Chandler City Counsel ponders to define what is self-evident. There shouldnt be any need for a discussions about the definition of animal cruelty! 
The way this is being handled are indicative of a system that desperately needs reform and probably new council members. I have deep concerns 
about the leniency surrounding the punishment for animal cruelty within the community. The inadequate measures in place for dealing with 
animal abusers reflect poorly on the City of Chandler and sends a message that such behavior is tolerable. This is absolutely unacceptable. Animal 
cruelty is not only a grave moral issue but also an indicator of a broader societal problem. Those who abuse animals are often more likely to 
engage in violent acts towards humans, and their actions should not be taken lightly.It is imperative that you take swift and decisive action to 
protect our beloved pets and wildlife from harm. Defining animal cruelty should not be a protracted, bureaucratic process. Chandler City Counsel 
shouldnt be the ones who define what constitutes animal abuse. Its obvious you dont care and have no idea! The shelters are the ones that should 
be telling you how to defined animal abuse! They are the ones who volunteer their time and efforts and their own money to care for these abused, 
neglected and abandoned animals, the council doesnt.  I highly doubt that any council member has any knowledge, hands on experience or 
volunteered. You dont get the right to dictate how to define the obvious to everyone but you.  The council needs to act immediately to safeguard 
the lives and well-being of these innocent beings. The suffering experienced by these animals is a stark reminder that you have a responsibility to 
act urgently and stop sitting on your hands. The message you are sending is that its ok to abuse animals because when you do you dont have to 
worry because all you will get is a slap on the hand. The entire council should be utterly embarrassed and ashamed letting the abuse continue for 
so long.A strong example needs to be set in the community that animal cruelty will not be tolerated under any circumstances. It is my strong belief 
that animal cruelty should be a felony with no second chances or technicalities for the  abusers charges to be dismissed. Let them prove to the 
courts that they are responsible to own a animal.  I am also upset that animals deserve more than what currently qualifies as adequate care. It 
should be illegal to keep any animal outside their entire life, that qualifies as abuse. They dont deserve to be forced to stay outside and the only 
adequate thing that needs to be provided is some shade and water. It should be mandatory that any animal that is left outside for an extended 
period and not in a cooled residence should be deemed an abuser. And those convicted of such acts should face harsh penalties, including 
substantial fines, imprisonment, and never be allowed to own another animal. They should be treated like a sex offender and have to register 
themselves as an animal abuser. The cruel and unspeakable things that abusers are getting away with is because the legal system is pathetic. Just 
because they are animals doesnt mean they dont feel pain or love. They are helpless and if the council doesnt bring the hammer down you are just 
as culpable!  Making animal cruelty a felony, we not only send a clear message that our society values the welfare of animals, but we also deter 
potential abusers who may think twice before committing such heinous acts. This is not only a humane choice but a practical one for ensuring the 
f
d
ll b i
f h
i
I i
l
h Ch
dl
Ci
C
il
k
hi
i
i
d
h
i
l
d
d
di
4
10/25/2023 20:41
Cynthia
Robinson
17506 West Van Buren St.
85W
Goodyear
Arizona
85338
I am asking the court and judge in the current animal cruelty investigation and case against the fraudulent animal rescue and seizure of some 55 
dogs to bring the full weight of the law against the return of the 13 special needs dogs to April MacLaughlin. The AHS is providing vet care, expense 
and legal representation. The fact that the defendant could house this many animals in a residence not designed as a kennel and neglect their vet 
care for routine preventation should stand as evidence to her unqualified status as unfit to operate a rescue of even the lowest category. She 
knowingly deceived owners who acted in good faith and accepted funds intended for animal care.
5
10/25/2023 22:38
Linda
Garden
2617 N Pleasant Dr
Chandler
Arizona
85225
Poison should not be allowed as a means of control, inflicts agonizing pain. Humane trapping only should be allowed. Hoarding of beings should be 
considered a felony. And future handling of beings are to be denied.
6
10/26/2023 6:18
SHERRY
BUCALO
1462 North 63rd Street
Mesa
Arizona
85205
Just the fact that Ms. McLaughlin stated she moved to Chandler simply because of the lax laws regarding animals is really all the input yo need. Do 
better Chandler!!!!
7
10/26/2023 7:27
Christiana
Garza
3115 e old southern ave
Chandler
Arizona
85040
There NEEDS to be a voice for those that cannot speak. we all saw the footage!!! there is nothing left to see!!!! its completely mind blowing that 
someone who committed such horrific acts of abuse, to become nationally known as the house of horrors, gets to conpletely walk free!!! even 
being able to take stolen property (the wheelchairs she is currently moving out of her garage, the same ones she took away from the disabled).  we 
need to do better. this city not only failed these poor dogs, but you also failed her mom. a wise note would also be to NOT interview the abused 
mother in front of her abuser. this was a welfare check that the mother pleaded to the library to do, and your officers COULDNT EVEN GO 
INSIDE!!! WE NEED CHANGE PLEASE HAVE A HEART. 
8
10/26/2023 7:52
FAITH
REICHEL
1537 HUMBOLDT ST
BELLINGHAM
Washington
98225
I'm chiming in here because I was born in Maricopa county, and I fiercely support the proposed revisions to the laws on animal welfare, abuse, and 
hoarding  for the upcoming calendar year. Please sign off on this Mayor Kevin Harte.
9
10/26/2023 7:55
Joellene
Blood
4421 S Granite Dr
Chandler
Arizona
85249
I believe that tgere should be stricter and clearer laws regarding animal abuse and hoarding in Chandler. As a dog and overall animal lover, I cannot 
fathom someone abusing these sweet souls, but as we have all seen, it happens. Without amendments t the current laws, there is too much room 
for ambiguity and uncertainty. Dogs are living beings and should not be subjected to hoarding or abuse at the hands of known abusers. 
10
10/26/2023 8:54
Katie
Miene
13324 E stoney vista dr
Chandler
Arizona
85249
The laws in Chandler in regard to animal rights and punishment for animal abuse, neglect and hoarding need to be reviewed and changed 
immediately The current case that is still unfolding shows there is such a large gap between where we are and where we should be in regards to 
protecting animals  People are free to abuse and hoard animals to the point of severe neglect  and death with little to no punishment  April 
Addison is a free woman after many dogs were euthanized because of her severe neglect  Many died in her home due to the severe neglect and 
hoarding Many are unaccounted for The laws need to change and become stricter so that Chandler is a safe place for all 
11
10/26/2023 9:35
kelly
stapleton
4505 Tagalong Trail, AZ, United States
Lake Montezuma
Arizona
86335
This situation brought a light to the abuse of animals and the funds that were meant for the treatment of the dogs.  It's not only abuse, but 
stealing.   Also the long delay in helping these animals from police and animal services was completely wrong.   You are not only needing better 
laws but also the desire to help the animals.  To get a warrent and see first hand what is going on, not listen to the abuser and just walk away.  It's 
time to take your jobs serious and care about the abuse the animal is suffering.
12
10/26/2023 10:25
Rochelle
Bailey
1460 W Camino Ct
Chandler
Arizona
85224
I'm relieved to see the updated language - it's much more comprehensive and more clearly spelled out. With that said, I do wonder why some of 
these violations aren't considered a felony in order to further deter individuals from inflicting suffering on animals. Chandler should have zero 
tolerance for neglect like we've seen with the Chandler 55. Thank you for giving this topic the time and attention it deserves.
13
10/26/2023 11:04
Alyssa
Alyssa Alvarez
444 n gila springs blvd
Chandler
Arizona
85226
Animal cruelty should def be taking more serious. Animals are sentinal creatures that have emotions and experience pain. The fact that cases are 
not taken seriously is obsurd! 
14
10/26/2023 12:45
Leslie
adams
1342 n bogle ave
Chandler
Arizona
85225
I agree to the changes and expect that the city of chandler enforces to the fullest extent against perpetrators.

15
10/26/2023 15:37
Kim
Henes
3823 West Park Avenue
Chandler
Arizona
85226
As a Chandler resident for 20 years I was absolutely appauled by the hoarding and animal abuse case that recently occurred in Chandler and that it 
took so long to rescue the animals from these horrific conditions. I am grateful that Chandler has stepped up to update their animal cruelty laws so 
animals can be removed quickly from abusive situations and not be held up by red tape due to the existing laws on the books. I would gladly sign a 
petition if needed. Thank you for addressing this quickly and for listening to the residents in our wonderful community and state. 
16
10/26/2023 17:58
Irene
Frampton
Self
26001 S Greencastle Dr
Chandler
Arizona
85248
If gound guilty, is mandatory restitution to all agenvies involed an option?
17
10/26/2023 19:24
Liz
Madrid
2452 E. Nathan Way
Chandler
Arizona
85225
I am very disappointed in how Chandler PD handle the Chandler55 case. They should've acted sooner in removing these poor disability dogs out of 
that psycho monster's house when it was first reported on September 8 but you guys waited 2-3 before raiding her home. There were enough 
evidence to go into her home. There are no strong laws in place for animal abuse so these sickos continue to hurt them. Enough is enough, these 
poor dogs have no voice. We are their voice! I see dog owners leaving their dogs outside in 100 plus degrees. They should not be labeled as 
property, they are part of our family. Why are you allowing this monster April Mclaughlin get away with abusing and killing these disabled dogs?! 
What is taking so long for this investigation, it is a clear case. She also abused her mother. Most officials I spoke to said Chandler PD mishandled 
this case. On behalf of all the rescues, I demand an answer as I am a tax payer for this city.
18
10/30/2023 7:46
Norma Langer
Norma Langer
24427 S Lakeway Circle SE
Chandler
Arizona
85248
Law enforcement must be educated about our animal cruelty laws.  Most are unaware and do not take citizens  concerns about animal welfare 
seriously.  Please take a look at what the city of Tempe has in place. 
19
10/30/2023 11:57
Tara
Salmieri
PlanActive Studio
3708 Pelican Lane
Orlando
Florida
32803
I'm a licensed and certified planner that provides consulting to local governments for over 23 years within the US. I have a word document that is 
easier to provide, if I could get an email address I can also send the document that way.tara@planactivestudio.com.  I included a few 
recommendations and considerations to the City's draft document. Here is a summary. 14-35 Definitions: Adequate medical care, add (D) BODY 
CONDITION SCORE UNDER 4 . Adequate Shelter, consider adding to the definition to include sufficient size to permit... ABLED ANDOR DISABLED, 
MOBILITY CHALLENGED ...animal to enter.     Add two new definitions:DISABLED ANIMAL SHALL MEAN ANY ANIMAL THAT IS BLIND, DEAF,   
NEUROLOGICAL ANDOR MOBILITY COMPROMISED. Then define MOBILITY COMPROMISED MEANS ANY ANIMAL THAT REQUIRES MOBILITY AIDES 
SUCH AS A HARNESS, WHEELCHAIR, SCOOTER, AND OTHER DEVICES THAT ASSIST WITH AN ANIMAL GAINING ACCESS TO SHELTER, FOOD, WATER, 
ADEQUATE VENTILATION AND PROTECTION FROM THE ELEMENTS. 14.36 Animal cruelty, consider adding this:.INTENTIONALLY, KNOWINGLY OR 
RECKLESSLY SUBJECTS ANY DISABLED ANDOR MOBILITY COMPROMISED ANIMAL FROM MOBILITY AIDS PROVIDING ACCESS TO WATER, FOOD AND 
ADEQUATE SHELTER. 14-37, animal hoarding, consider updatting 4 to this  4.FAILURE TO PROVIDE ACCESS TO SUITABLE WATER FOR DRINKING 
ANDOR NECESSARY FOOD THAT IS APPROPRIATE FOR THE SPECIES AND FIT FOR CONSUMPTION., Adding an additional circumstance.5.FAILURE TO 
PROVIDE SHELTER WHICH PROTECTS AN ANIMAL FROM EXPOSURE TO THE ELEMENTS, THAT PROVIDES FOR ADEQUATE VENTILATIONS INDOOR 
OR OUTDOOR. Updating 14-38, restraint number 5 to 5.DOES NOT PERMIT THE DOG ACCESS TO FOOD, WATER, SHADE, DRY GROUND, ADEQUATE 
VENTILATION OR SHELTER.        Thank you for considering the additions to the ordinance, I can provide a better copy, if requested as I do not have 
a way to send thisas an attachment. Tara Salmieri, AICP President PlanActive Studio
20
10/30/2023 21:29
Kathy OMeara
Kathy OMeara
3344 N sunaire
Mesa
Arizona
85215
You need tougher animal abuse laws. And elder abuse laws. Your current laws are a embarrassment   to Az. The tougher laws and punishment will 
hopefully deter people.