June 4 Meeting Minutes

City of Chandler — Regular Meeting (2024-07-09)

View PDF Meeting page

Extracted text (via pymupdf) 3829 characters
CITIZENS’ PANEL FOR REVIEW OF POLICE COMPLAINTS AND USE OF FORCE SPECIAL 
MEETING MINUTES 
 
June 4, 2024 
 
1. CALL TO ORDER/ROLL CALL 
Chairman Fagen called the meeting to order at approximately 7:01 PM 
 
Members in Attendance: 
Chairman Laurie Fagen 
Vice Chair Jason Diefenbacher 
Panel member Sam Enoch 
Panel member Gina Giammona 
Panel member Dawn Vukadinovich 
Panel member Flor Martinez 
Panel member Josh Whitaker 
Panel member Joseph Yang 
Panel member James Bogert 
 
Members Absent: 
Panel member Christopher Heo 
Panel member Carlos Lozano 
Panel member Allen Leibowitz 
 
Staff in Attendance: 
Cmdr. Daniel Shellum 
Lt. Michael Prendergast 
Det. Jeffrey Fox 
Sgt. Ronald Bromund 
Ean White, Assistant City Attorney 
Pamela Leon, Staff Liaison

2. SCHEDULED/UNSCHEDULED PUBLIC APPEARANCES/CALL TO PUBLIC 
a. None 
 
3. ACTION AGENDA 
a. Discuss current Citizens’ Panel for Review of Police Complaints and Use of 
Force Bylaws.  
 
The Chair requested the panel create a list of panel members when 
creating a Subpanel instead of the City Manager choosing which Panel 
members will be part of the Subpanel. There was discussion between the 
Panel members on what the verbiage should be regarding Subpanels and 
how members are chosen. The Panel ultimately agreed the Panel should 
create the list instead of the City Manager.  
 
Panel member Yang requested the Ordinance Number be corrected on 
the current Bylaws. Ordinance Number 3135 was amended and changed 
to Ordinance Number 4983.  
 
Panel member Yang requested the Bylaws change to include gender 
neutrality. Change Chairman to The Chair or Chairperson and remove 
him/his to their/them. 
 
Recommendation to Chief Chapman, the Panel requested The Bylaws 
include the following; “The Panel may make recommendations to the Chief 
of Police concerning training programs, revisions of policies or procedures, 
commendable actions, preventive or corrective measures except for 
employee discipline and community concerns regarding Police action and 
procedures”.  
 
Panel requested to remove the word “court” from Recording and Minutes. 
The staff liaison does record minutes, however; is not a court reporter.  
 
b. Discuss the Chandler City Code 2-23  
 
There was discussion between all Panel members on changing 23.2.4 
Powers and duties B; to allow Panel members to miss no more than two 
regular meetings per year instead of three (3) consecutive regular 
meetings.  
 
The Panel lastly discussed what the Panel reviews including all police 
shootings and police incidents when direct physical force by the Police

results in serious physical injury or death. The Panel discussed the Use of 
Force Quarterly summaries and requested to speak with Chief Chapman 
on their options. Panel members requested the Use of Force summaries 
include all police shootings and police incidents, as well as lethal and 
intermediate use of force as defined by department policy. The Chair 
notified the Panel Chief Chapman would be discussing their concerns and 
the July 9 regular meeting.  
 
 
4. BRIEFING ITEMS 
Briefing by Chair Fagen on the meeting with Chief Chapman and City         
Manager Josh Wright, called at the City Manager’s request on May 22,2024. 
City Manager contacted Chair Fagen to meet and discuss the Panel. City 
Manager, Josh Wright explained that the Panel was an early adopter for the 
City of Chandler Boards and Commissions. Explained the importance of 
transparency within the Department and Panel.  
5. ANNOUNCEMENTS 
 
 
6. CALENDAR/FUTURE AGENDA ITEMS 
 
Next meeting will be Tuesday, July 9, 2024.  
 
7. INFORMATION ITEMS 
 
8. ADJOURNMENT 
Panel member Whitaker moved to adjourn, seconded by Panel member 
Diefenbacher. The motion was approved by all Panel members present, 
and the meeting adjourned at approximately 8:49 p.m.