Attachment B - Outcome Measures

City of Phoenix — Public Safety and Justice Subcommittee (2024-10-23)

View PDF Meeting page

Extracted text (via pymupdf) 3905 characters
27th Avenue Outcome Measures 
Consensual 
Incidents
Non-Consensual 
Incidents
2018
1054
4402
2019
967
4939
2020
941
4678
2021
733
4662
Pre-intervention average 
924
4670
Outcome measure
652
4232
2022
1018
3957
2023
1685
3419
2024
649
1625
2023
-30%
-6%
Pre-CSP (2018-2021) 
32%
-30%
27th Ave. Police Incidents (Midtown)
Six-month trend analysis (January - June) 
Consenual Incidents
Non-Consenual 
Incidents
2018
261
2671
2019
286
2944
2020
311
3084
2021
375
3204
Pre-intervention average 
308
2976
Outcome Measure
210
2517
2022
258
2575
2023
321
2245
2024
125
1190
2023
-20%
7%
Pre-CSP (2018-2021) 
-17%
-17%
Six-month trend analysis (January - June)
27th Ave. Police Incidents (North)
ATTACHMENT B

June 2023
203 responses
June 2024
119 responses
Perception of Overall 
Safety 
(Responded somewhat 
safe or very safe)
34%
37%
Level of crime
(Responded crime 
decreased)  
8%
8%
Homeless encampments 
as an issue
(% of total identified as an 
issue)
84%
80%
Homeless encampments 
affecting safety
(% of total identified as an 
issue affecting safety)
63%
68%
Open drug use
(% of total identified as an 
issue)
70%
70%
Blight 
(% of total identified as an 
issue)
61%
53%
Graffiti 
(% of total identified as an 
issue)
55%
55%
Perceptions of Safety

19th Avenue Outcome Measures 
Consensual Incidents
Non-Consensual 
Incidents
2018
614
6864
2019
531
6627
2020
507
6661
2021
583
6194
Pre-CSP average 
559
6587
Outcome Measure
462
6023
2022
701
5928
2023
944
5872
2024
447
2873
2023
-4%
3%
Pre-CSP (2018-2021) 
55%
-11%
19th Ave. Police Incidents
Six-month trend analysis (January - June) 
June 2023
261 responses
June 2024
83 responses
Perception of Overall 
Safety 
(Responded somewhat 
safe or very safe)
40%
32%
Level of crime
(Responded crime 
decreased)  
6%
13%
Homeless encampments 
as an issue
(% of total identified as an 
issue)
80%
81%
Homeless encampments 
affecting safety
(% of total identified as an 
issue affecting safety)
61%
67%
Open drug use
(% of total identified as an 
issue)
70%
81%
Blight 
(% of total identified as an 
issue)
52%
58%
Graffiti 
(% of total identified as an 
issue)
54%
60%
Perceptions of Safety

Hatcher Road Outcome Measures 
Consensual 
Incidents
Non-Consensual 
Incidents
2018
92
272
2019
98
286
2020
45
292
2021
36
338
Pre-intervention average 
68
297
Outcome Measure
4
240
2022
39
341
2023
59
372
2024
26
130
2023
-24%
-33%
Pre-CSP (2018-2021) 
-42%
-9%
Hatcher Road Police Incidents
Six-month trend analysis (January - June)
June 2023
25 responses
June 2024
36 responses
Perception of Overall Safety 
(Responded somewhat safe 
or very safe)
28%
39%
Level of crime
(Responded crime decreased) 
8%
42%
Homeless encampments as 
an issue
(% of total identified as an 
issue)
84%
75%
Homeless encampments 
affecting safety
(% of total identified as an 
issue affecting safety)
76%
67%
Open drug use
(% of total identified as an 
issue)
80%
86%
Blight 
(% of total identified as an 
issue)
60%
69%
Graffiti 
(% of total identified as an 
issue)
56%
55%
Perceptions of Safety

Bell Road Outcome Measures 
Consensual Incidents
Non-Consensual Incidents
2018
180
1565
2019
197
1735
2020
276
1813
2021
331
2054
Pre-intervention average 
246
1792
Outcome Measure
105
1385
2022
232
1344
2023
113
1026
2024
70
524
2023
35%
14%
Pre-CSP (2018-2021) 
-40%
-39%
Bell Road Police Incidents
Six-month trend analysis (January - June)
June 2023
56 responses
June 2024
86 responses
Perception of Overall 
Safety 
(Responded somewhat 
safe or very safe)
25%
56%
Level of crime
(Responded crime 
decreased)  
9%
8%
Homeless encampments 
as an issue
(% of total identified as an 
issue)
86%
77%
Homeless encampments 
affecting safety
(% of total identified as an 
issue affecting safety)
71%
69%
Open drug use
(% of total identified as an 
issue)
80%
67%
Blight 
(% of total identified as an 
issue)
71%
56%
Graffiti 
(% of total identified as an 
issue)
64%
53%
Perceptions of Safety