Attachment F - PC Appeal - Z-157-24-3.pdf

CITY OF PHOENIX 
PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT 
FORM TO REQUEST PC to CC 
I HEREBY REQUEST THAT THE CC HOLD A PUBLIC HEARING ON: 
APPLICATION NO/ 
Z-157-24-3
LOCATION 
Approx. 1,080 feet
north of the
northeast corner of
the 1-17 Freeway
and thunderbird
Road
APPEALED FROM: 
PC 4/3/2025 
PC DATE 
TO PC/CC 
cc 5/7/2025 
HEARING 
CC DATE
REASON FOR REQUEST: 
See attached document. 
RECEIVED BY: 
Joshua Bednarek 
Tricia Gomes 
Racelle Escolar 
Sarah Stockham 
Adam Stranieri 
Stephanie Vasquez 
Heather Klotz 
Dalia Adams 
REVISED 10/16/2024 vcm 
Dom Amodio 
(SIGNATURE ON ORIGINAL IN FILE) 
opposition 
X 
applicant 
393 East Pam Lane 
Phoenix, AZ 85004 
STREET/ADDRESS/CITY/STATE/ZIP 
Dwight 0. Wetland 
602-550-4230
dwatland@walawaz.com
NAME I PHONE I EMAIL 
RECEIVED ON: 
Camryn Thompson 
Micah Alexander 
GIS 
4/10/2025 
Byron Easton (for PHO appeals only) 
Village Planner 
Applicant 
ATTACHMENT F

CITY OF pH 
OtNJX
City of Phoenix 
PLANNING ANO DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT 
APR 102025 
The CITY COUNCIL may approve the recommendation of the Planning CommissibW'Wwt1ĥ&VĦb]er 
The PLANNING COMMISSION agenda for April 3, 2025 is attached. 
hearing unless:
Department Pmem
1.
A REQUEST FOR A HEARING by the CITY COUNCIL is filed within seven (7) days. 
There is a $630.00 appeal fee for hearings requested by the applicant, due by 5:00 p.m. April 10, 2025.
Any member of the public may, within seven (7) days after the Planning Commission's action, request a 
hearing by the City Council on any application. If you wish to request a hearing, fill out and sign the form 
below and return it to the Planning and Development Department by 5:00 p.m., April 10, 2025.
2.
A WRITTEN PROTEST is filed, no later than seven (7) days after the Planning Commission's action, which 
requires a three-fourths vote. A written protest will require a three-fourths vote of the City Council to 
approve a zoning change when the owners of at least 20 percent of the property by area and number of 
lots, tracts, and condominium units within the zoning petition area have signed the petition. The zoning 
petition area includes both the area of the proposed amendment, and the area within 150 feet of the 
proposed amendment, including all rights-of-way. For condominium, townhouse and other types of 
ownership with common lands, authorized property owner signatures are required. Please see Planning 
and Development Department Staff for additional information prior to gathering signatures. 
To require a three-fourths vote of the City Council for approval, a written protest for applications on this 
agenda must be filed with the Planning and Development Department by 5:00 p.m. April 10, 2025.
The Planning and Development Department will verify ownership by protestors to determine whether or not 
a three-fourths vote will be required. 
3.
A CONTINUANCE is granted at the PLANNING COMMISSION. In the event of a continuance, there is an 
$830.00 fee due from the applicant within fourteen (14) days, by 5:00 p.m. April 17, 2025.
FORM TO REQUEST CITY COUNCIL HEARING 
I HEARBY REQUEST THAT THE CITY COUNCIL HOLD A PUBLIC HEARING: 
i3 ħ ( s? - Z-Lf-3 
N {? CoQ.iJĨfc..._ 
{- I 7 hZ.l.:BW? r T7r--k.R,v!J e:R/3 {IU) 
APPLICATION NO. 
LOCATION OF APPLICATION SITE 
/2fr?.1c.. 
3 I ce,z_.;-
/ 
'\-Z)[V\ AMGDi C) 
DATE APPEALED FROM 
--- [9"bPPOSITION 
PLANNER 
0 APPLICANT 
(PLANNER TAKING THE APPEAL) 
'
BY MY SIGNATURE BELOW, I ACKNOWLEDGE CITY cou::'£2 

  
vu.:i t eortt" 
E:), 
L-tj1c,.-rz_;;:.;0 ĩ 
"cl/ 
PRINTED NAME OF PERSON APPEALINĪG---
SIGNATURE--
393, l?A'0T Pr-::,ciYJ 
lbl(Jc 
-f/to /2e>1--;-
īREET ADDRESS 
DA
.
TE OF SIGNATURE 
\
_.1HD L'"N"r }a 
&'oo 1f.. 
(po1--sso Ĭ L../,. Z-':?:,o 
CITY, STATE & ZIP CODE 
TELEPHONE NO. 
ĭ u.J C:,_-/- ) Ct. 'rt Į Ce 
l.U ('..(. l "'1 1-(; q 5 ·. C O ) 
EMAIL ADDRESS 
REASON FOR REQUEST 
2)\2į A Li-t-e'D 
APPEALS MUST BE FILED IN PERSON AT 200 WEST WASHINGTON, 2ND FLOOR, ZONING COUNTER

Dwight Watland
From: 
Sent: 
To: 
Cc: 
Subject: 
AmicusDealtWith: 
Amicusld: 
AmicusStatus: 
AmicusFileName: 
AmicusFilelds: 
Robert and Justin 
Dwight Watland 
Thursday, April 10, 2025 11 :32 AM 
robert.kuhfuss@phoenix.gov; Kinkade, Justin 
Judy Mackin Qudy.mackin@gmail.com); Lynn Robbins; Roxanne Smith 
Home Depot - Thunderbird & 1-17 
Yes 
167185 
Saved 
Dwight O Watland PC - Home Depot 
810 
I have reviewed proposed Stipulations 5 and 6. The following are my thoughts to make both stipulations 
more attractive to the neighborhood, and be acceptable to Home Depot. 
Stipulation 5-
a -Stipulation 5 refers only to the area located adjacent to the drainage easement. That should 
be expanded to include the area adjacent to the East Wall of the parking lot. 
b-Justin, you had indicated that Home Depot would locate the taller equipment next to the East
Wall as that wall is higher. That seems appropriate to include in the Stipulation. 
b-Stipulation 5 should also include a requirement that no equipment should be stored or
displayed in a manner that extends above the adjacent wall. I understand that equipment may be stored 
or displayed while sitting on a trailer. Currently, all equipment, even if on a trailer, is lower than the East 
Wall. Therefore, this should be an acceptable stipulation. 
Stipulation 6-
a -A single sign will be lost in the plethora of sign age near the displayed and stored equipment. 
b-additional signage can be as follows:
Northeast corner of parking lot - "EXIT" -arrow pointing West 
In front of construction loading area - "EXIT" - arrow pointing North 
Along wall leading to frontage road - "EXIT" - arrow pointing North 
At the exterior door to rental area - "PLEASE USE FRONTAGE ROAD EXIT" 
At the frontage road exit - Monument signage with Home Depot sign and logo 
Identify as "RENTAL OFFICE" 
Placed near displayed equipment and trucks - "PLEASE EXIT TO NORTH" 
c -I don't know how specific signage requirement in a stipulation can be, However, a minimum 
of one sign is inadequate. 
Dwight O Watland 
Watland & Allen, pile 
1

393 East Palm Lane 
Phoenix AZ 85004 
602-252-0115
Fax - 602-252-7885
dwatland@walawaz.com
This email may contain confidential and privileged information. This email message is for the sole use of the intended 
recipient, or recipients. Any unauthorized review, use, disclosure or distribution is prohibited. If you are not the intended 
recipient, please contact the sender by reply email and destroy all copies of the original message. 
Federal tax regulations require us to notify you that any tax advice in this electronic message was not intended or written to be used, 
and cannot be used, for the purpose of avoiding penalties. 
2

City of Phoenix 
PLANNING & DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT 
APPLICATION TO AMEND ZONING ORDINANCE
APPLICATION NO: APZ-13-25 of Z-157-24-3 
PROPERTY LOCATION: Approximately 1,080 feet north of the northeast corner of the 1-17 Freeway
and Thunderbird Road 
PROPOSED USE: Commercial Uses
LEGAL DESCRIPTION: 
TO BE CHANGED: 
FROM: C-2 SP
TO: C-3
Ordinance#: 
CASE TYPE: General Rezoning
Ordinance Date: 
DSD#: 
CASE STATUS: Received 
GROSS ACREAGE: 2.38
VILLAGE: North Mountain
COUNCIL DISTRICT: 3
DA TE FILED: 04/10/2025
Contact Information 
Name 
Dwight 
Watland
Appellant
Address 
393 East Palm
Lane
Phone 
602-550-
4230
Fax
Email 
dwatland@walawaz.
com
An applicant may receive a clarification from the city of its interpretation or application of a statute, ordinance, 
code or authorized substantive policy statement. To request clarification or to obtain further information on the
application process and applicable review time frames, please call 602-262-7131 (option 6), email
zoning@phoenix.gov or visit our website at https://www.phoenix.gov/pdd/licensing-time-frames
I declare that all information submitted is true and correct to the best of my knowledge and belief. I
acknowledge that an 
• 
y application may be cause for changing its normal scheduling.
POST APPLICATION 
PM
MEETING DATE: 1/27/25
DATE:_/-_· þ/_f_c,ÿ(_2.{>_2.-_" _ _,.---_____ _
200 W. Washington St.. 2nd floor. Phoenix. AZ 85003 • 602-626-7131 
For more information or for a copy of this publication in an alternate format, contact Planning & Development at 
602-262-7811 voice or TTY use 7-1-1.